Visual search for orientation among heterogeneous distractors: experimental results and implications for signal-detection theory models of search.

Abstract

Three experiments tested a signal-detection theory (SDT) model of visual search (e.g., as described in J. Palmer, C. T. Ames, & D. T. Lindsey, 1993). In Experiment 1, participants searched for a 0 degrees line among distractors at (a) 30 degrees; (b) 1/3 at 30 degrees, 2/3 at 50 degrees; (c) 1/3 at 30 degrees, 50 degrees, and 70 degrees; and (d) 1/3 at 30 degrees, 2/3 at 70 degrees. The SDT model predicts improved performance in the more heterogeneous conditions, as some distractors are more discriminable from the target. In contrast, in Experiment 1 human performance degraded in the more heterogeneous conditions (c and d). In Experiment 2, sparser displays improved the performance of the SDT model. In Experiment 3, search for theta degrees among homogeneous theta + 20 degrees distractors was compared with search for theta degrees among theta+/-20 degrees distractors. Performance in the latter condition was often worse, relative to performance in the homogeneous condition, than predicted by the SDT model; however, this depended greatly on the identity of the target.

Cites (24)

1. The Psychophysics Toolbox
   David H. Brainard · 1997 · Spatial Vision
2. Untitled work
   1966 · Medical Entomology and Zoology
3. Visual search and stimulus similarity.
   John Duncan, Glyn W. Humphreys · 1989 · Psychological Review
4. Guided Search 2.0 A revised model of visual search
   Jeremy M. Wolfe · 1994 · Psychonomic Bulletin & Review
5. Statistics of Directional Data.
   D. V. Gokhale, K. V. Mardia · 1973 · Biometrics
6. Attention and Performance Viii
   Raymond S. Nickerson · 2014 · Psychology Press eBooks
7. Statistics of Directional Data
   1972 · Elsevier eBooks
8. The psychophysics of visual search
   John C. Palmer, Preeti Verghese, Misha Pavel C · 2000 · Vision Research
9. Pixel independence: measuring spatial interactions on a CRT display
   Denis G. Pelli · 1997 · Spatial Vision
10. Set-size effects in visual search: The effect of attention is independent of the stimulus for simple tasks
    John C. Palmer · 1994 · Vision Research
11. Measuring the effect of attention on simple visual search.
    John C. Palmer, Cynthia T. Ames, Delwin T. Lindsey · 1993 · Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & Performance
12. The role of categorization in visual search for orientation.
    Jeremy M. Wolfe, Stacia R. Friedman‐Hill, Marion I. Stewart, Kathleen M. O’Connell · 1992 · Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & Performance
13. The role of features in preattentive vision: Comparison of orientation, motion and color cues
    Hans‐Christoph Nothdurft · 1993 · Vision Research
14. A signal detection model predicts the effects of set size on visual search accuracy for feature, conjunction, triple conjunction, and disjunction displays
    Miguel P. Eckstein, James P. Thomas, John C. Palmer, Steven S. Shimozaki · 2000 · Perception & Psychophysics
15. Texture segmentation and pop-out from orientation contrast
    Hans‐Christoph Nothdurft · 1991 · Vision Research
16. A simple saliency model predicts a number of motion popout phenomena
    Ruth E. Rosenholtz · 1999 · Vision Research
17. Feature analysis and the role of similarity in preattentive vision
    Hans‐Christoph Nothdurft · 1992 · Perception & Psychophysics
18. Decision and Estimation Theory
    James L. Melsa, D. L. Cohn, George M. Siouris · 1981 · IEEE Transactions on Systems Man and Cybernetics
19. Visual Search for a Tilted Target: Tests of Spatial Uncertainty Models
    Michael J. Morgan, Roger M Ward, Éric Castet · 1998 · The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology Section A
20. Stimulus discriminability in visual search
    Preeti Verghese, Ken Nakayama · 1994 · Vision Research
21. The information capacity of visual attention
    Preeti Verghese, Denis G. Pelli · 1992 · Vision Research
22. Imperfect, Unlimited-Capacity, Parallel Search Yields Large Set-Size Effects
    John C. Palmer, Jennifer McLean · 1995
23. Are direction and speed coded independently by the visual system? Evidence from visual search
    Peter McLeod, Zoltan Paul Dienes, Jon Driver · 1992 · Spatial Vision
24. Letter Localization, Not Discrimination, Is Constrained by Attention.
    Patrick J. Bennett, Paul D. Jaye · 1995 · Canadian Journal of Experimental Psychology/Revue canadienne de psychologie expérimentale

Cited by (68)

1. Saliency, attention, and visual search: An information theoretic approach
   Neil D. B. Bruce, John K. Tsotsos · 2009 · Journal of Vision
2. Measuring visual clutter
   Ruth E. Rosenholtz, Yuanzhen Li, Lisa Nakano · 2007 · Journal of Vision
3. A detection theory account of change detection
   Patrick Wilken, Wei Ji Ma · 2004 · Journal of Vision
4. Guided Search 4.0
   Jeremy M. Wolfe · 2007 · Oxford University Press eBooks
5. Visual search: A retrospective
   Miguel P. Eckstein · 2011 · Journal of Vision
6. A summary statistic representation in peripheral vision explains visual search
   Ruth E. Rosenholtz, Jun Huang, Alvin Raj, Benjamin Balas, L. Ilie · 2012 · Journal of Vision
7. Feature congestion
   Ruth E. Rosenholtz, Yuanzhen Li, J. S. ephen Mansfield, Zhenlan Jin · 2005 · CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
8. Behavior and neural basis of near-optimal visual search
   Wei Ji Ma, Vidhya Navalpakkam, Jeffrey M. Beck, Ronald van den Berg, Alexandre Pouget · 2011 · Nature Neuroscience
9. Do predictions of visual perception aid design?
   Ruth E. Rosenholtz, Amal Kumar Dorai, Rosalind Freeman · 2011 · ACM Transactions on Applied Perception
10. Building ensemble representations: How the shape of preceding distractor distributions affects visual search
    Андрей Анатольевич Четвериков, Gianluca Campana, Arni Kjalar Kristjansson · 2016 · Cognition
11. Cutting through the clutter: Searching for targets in evolving complex scenes
    Mark B. Neider, Gregory J. Zelinsky · 2011 · Journal of Vision
12. Visual Clutter Causes High-Magnitude Errors
    S. Baldassi, N. Megna, D. Burr · 2006 · PLoS Biology
13. Optimal feature integration in visual search
    Benjamin Thomas Vincent, Roland Baddeley, T. Troscianko, Iain Donald Gilchrist · 2009 · Journal of Vision
14. Parallel averaging of size is possible but range-limited: A reply to Marchant, Simons, and De Fockert
    Igor Utochkin, Natalia A. Tiurina · 2013 · Acta Psychologica
15. Optimal observer model of single-fixation oddity search predicts a shallow set-size function
    Wade Schoonveld, Steve Shimozaki, Miguel P. Eckstein · 2007 · Journal of Vision
16. Does precision decrease with set size?
    Helga Mazyar, Ronald van den Berg, W. J. Ma · 2012 · Journal of Vision
17. The effect of background color on asymmetries in color search
    Ruth E. Rosenholtz, Allen L. Nagy, Nicole R. Bell · 2004 · Journal of Vision
18. No capacity limit in attentional tracking: Evidence for probabilistic inference under a resource constraint
    W. J. Ma, W. Huang · 2009 · Journal of Vision
19. Rapid learning of visual ensembles
    Андрей Анатольевич Четвериков, Gianluca Campana, Arni Kjalar Kristjansson · 2017 · Journal of Vision
20. Probabilistic Computations for Attention, Eye Movements, and Search
    Miguel P. Eckstein · 2017 · Annual Review of Vision Science
21. A population response model of ensemble perception.
    Igor Utochkin, Jeunghwan Choi, Sang Chul Chong · 2023 · Psychological Review
22. The Pervasiveness of Ensemble Perception
    Jennifer Elise Corbett, Igor Utochkin, Shaul Hochstein · 2023 · Cambridge University Press eBooks
23. The roles of distractor noise and target certainty in search: A signal detection model
    Nayantara Santhi, Adam Reeves · 2004 · Vision Research
24. Comparing set summary statistics and outlier pop out in vision
    Shaul Hochstein, Marina Pavlovskaya, Yoram S. Bonneh, Nachum Soroker · 2018 · Journal of Vision
25. A target contrast signal theory of parallel processing in goal-directed search
    Alejandro Lleras, Zhiyuan Wang, Gavin Jun Peng Ng, Kirk Ballew, Zoe Xu, Simona Buetti · 2020 · Attention Perception & Psychophysics
26. Information-limited parallel processing in difficult heterogeneous covert visual search.
    Barbara Anne Dosher, Songmei Han, Zhong‐Lin Lu · 2010 · Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & Performance
27. Independence is elusive: Set size effects on encoding precision in visual search
    Helga Mazyar, Ronald van den Berg, Robert L Seilheimer, W. J. Ma · 2013 · Journal of Vision
28. Learning features in a complex and changing environment: A distribution-based framework for visual attention and vision in general
    Андрей Анатольевич Четвериков, Gianluca Campana, Arni Kjalar Kristjansson · 2017 · Progress in brain research
29. An explicit investigation of the roles that feature distributions play in rapid visual categorization
    Hee Yeon Im, Natalia A. Tiurina, Igor Utochkin · 2020 · Attention Perception & Psychophysics
30. Similarity and heterogeneity effects in visual search are mediated by “segmentability”.
    Igor Utochkin, Maria Yurevich · 2016 · Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & Performance
31. Classic Visual Search Effects in an Additional Singleton Task: An Open Dataset
    Kirsten C. S. Adam, Titiksha Patel, Nicole Rangan, John T. Serences · 2021 · Journal of Cognition
32. Requiem for the max rule?
    Wei Ji Ma, Shan Shen, Gintare Karolina Dziugaite, Ronald van den Berg · 2015 · Vision Research
33. Age-related interference from irrelevant distracters in visual feature search among heterogeneous distracters
    Edward C. Merrill, Frances A. Conners · 2013 · Journal of Experimental Child Psychology
34. Continuous to discrete: Ensemble-based segmentation in the perception of multiple feature conjunctions
    Igor Utochkin, Vladislav A. Khvostov, Yulia M. Stakina · 2018 · Cognition
35. Effects of target and distractor heterogeneity on search for a color target
    Allen L. Nagy, Kelly E. Neriani, Travis L. Young · 2005 · Vision Research
36. Structural and contextual priors affect visual search in children with and without autism
    Van de Cruys, Sander, Lemmens, Lisa, Sapey‐Triomphe, Laurie‐Anne, Chetverikov, Andrey, Noens, Ilse, Wagemans, Johan · 2021 · Autism Research
37. Encoding perceptual ensembles during visual search in peripheral vision
    Ömer Dağlar Tanrıkulu, Андрей Анатольевич Четвериков, Arni Kjalar Kristjansson · 2020 · Journal of Vision
38. Representing Variability
    Андрей Анатольевич Четвериков, Arni Kjalar Kristjansson · 2024 · Cambridge University Press eBooks
39. Explaining the effects of distractor statistics in visual search
    Joshua Michael Calder-Travis, Wei Ji Ma · 2020 · Journal of Vision
40. Temporal integration of feature probability distributions
    Sabrina Hansmann-Roth, Sóley Þorsteinsdóttir, Joy J. Geng, Arni Kjalar Kristjansson · 2022 · Psychological Research
41. Psychophysical evaluation of individual low-level feature influences on visual attention
    David Berga, Xosé R. Fdez-Vidal, Xavier Otazu, Víctor Leborán, Xosé M. Pardo · 2018 · Vision Research
42. Evidence from partially valid cueing that words are processed serially
    Miranda Johnson, John C. Palmer, Cathleen M. Moore, Geoffrey M. Boynton · 2022 · Psychonomic Bulletin & Review
43. Current Progress With a Model of Visual Search
    Jeremy M. Wolfe · 2006
44. Speed versus accuracy in visual search: Optimal performance and neural architecture
    Bo Chen, Pietro Perona · 2015 · Journal of Vision
45. Do People Take Stimulus Correlations into Account in Visual Search?
    Manisha Bhardwaj, Ronald van den Berg, Wei Ji Ma, Krešimir Josić́ · 2016 · PLoS ONE
46. Coherent plaids are preattentively more than the sum of their parts
    J.-H. Nam, Joshua A. Solomon, Michael J. Morgan, Charles E. Wright, C. Chubb · 2009 · Attention Perception & Psychophysics
47. The Evolution of Psychological and Behavioral Consequences of Self-Isolation During Lockdown: A Longitudinal Study Across United Kingdom and Italy
    Zaninotto, Francesca, Bossi, Francesco, Terry, Philip, Riccaboni, Massimo, Galli, Giulia · 2022 · Frontiers in Psychiatry
48. Uniform versus random orientation in fading and filling-in
    Catherine Hindi Attar, Kai Hamburger, Ruth E. Rosenholtz, Herbert Götzl, Lothar Spillmann A · 2007 · Vision Research
49. No previews are good news: Using preview search to probe categorical grouping for orientation
    John P. Hodsoll, Glyn W. Humphreys · 2007 · Vision Research
50. Visual Decisions in the Presence of Measurement and Stimulus Correlations
    Manisha Bhardwaj, Samuel R. Carroll, Wei Ji Ma, Krešimir Josić́ · 2015 · Neural Computation
51. The psychophysics of visual search with heterogeneous distractors
    Andra Mihali, Wei Ji Ma · 2020 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
52. Reduced visual attention in heterogeneous textures is reflected in occipital alpha and theta band activity
    Tobias Feldmann‐Wüstefeld, Makoto Miyakoshi, Marco A. Petilli, Anna Schubö, Scott Makeig · 2017 · PLoS ONE
53. Categorical grouping is not required for guided conjunction search
    Igor Utochkin, Vladislav A. Khvostov, Jeremy M. Wolfe · 2020 · Journal of Vision
54. Set-size effects in change detection depend on failures of retrieval and/or comparison and not on perception, encoding or storage
    James C. Moreland, John C. Palmer, Geoffrey M. Boynton · 2020 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
55. Explaining the effects of distractor statistics in visual search
    Joshua Michael Calder-Travis, Wei Ji Ma · 2020 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
56. LAG-1: A dynamic, integrative model of learning, attention, and gaze
    Jordan Barnes, Mark R. Blair, R. Calen Walshe, Paul F. Tupper · 2022 · PLoS ONE
57. What limits search for conjunctions of simple visual features?
    Endel Põder, Maciej Kosilo · 2019 · Journal of Vision
58. A signal-detection account of item-based and ensemble-based visual change detection: A reply to Harrison, McMaster, and Bays
    Daniil Azarov, Daniil Grigorev, Igor Utochkin · 2024 · Journal of Vision
59. Divided attention effects in visual search are caused by objects not by space
    Cathleen M. Moore, James Pai, John C. Palmer · 2022 · Journal of Vision
60. Stimulus Heterogeneity in a Task-Irrelevant Dimension Affects Selective Attention
    Cheol Hwan Kim, Suk Won Han · 2023 · Behavioral Sciences
61. Visual search and real-image similarity: An empirical assessment through the lens of deep learning
    Marco A. Petilli, Francesca Rodio, Fritz Günther, Marco Marelli · 2024 · Psychonomic Bulletin & Review
62. Real-Time Statistical Saliency Using High Throughput Circuit Design and Its Applications in Psychophysical Study
    David A Blau · 2007 · DSpace@MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology)
63. Observer detection and discrimination performance as a function of clutter: a signal detection approach
    Archana Bora, Tarun Aggarwal, Vasudevan Lakshminarayanan · 2011 · Journal of Modern Optics
64. Investigation of potential industrial uses for tools assessing saliency and clutter of design features
    Tanya S. Goldhaber · 2010 · DSpace@MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology)
65. Ensemble-Based Segmentation in the Perception of Multiple Feature Conjunctions
    Igor Utochkin, Vladislav A. Khvostov, Yulia M. Stakina · 2017 · SSRN Electronic Journal
66. A major role for retrieval and/or comparison in the set-size effects of change detection
    James C. Moreland, John C. Palmer, Geoffrey M. Boynton · 2021 · Journal of Vision
67. The influence of category representativeness on the low prevalence effect in visual search
    Ryan Edward O'Donnell, Brad Wyble · 2022 · Psychonomic Bulletin & Review
68. Agent based intelligent decluttering enhancements
    Stacy Lovell Pfautz, Nathan Schurr, Gabe Ganberg, David T. Bauer, Paul Scerri · 2011

Related (10)

1. The psychophysics of visual search with heterogeneous distractors: effects ofset size, task, temporal order and stimulus spacing
   Andra Mihali, Wei Ji Ma · 2019 · Journal of Vision
2. Predicting visual search performance by quantifying stimuli similarities
   Tamar Avraham, Yaffa Yeshurun, Michael Lindenbaum · 2008 · Journal of Vision
3. The roles of distractor noise and target certainty in search: A signal detection model
   Nayantara Santhi, Adam Reeves · 2004 · Vision Research
4. The psychophysics of visual search with heterogeneous distractors
   Andra Mihali, Wei Ji Ma · 2020 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
5. Bayesian theory of visual search
   J. Beck, W. J. Ma, V. Navalpakkam · 2010 · Journal of Vision
6. Distractor–distractor interactions in visual search for oriented targets explain the increased difficulty observed in nonlinearly separable conditions.
   Zoe Xu, Alejandro Lleras, Yujie Shao, Simona Buetti · 2021 · Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & Performance
7. Distractor heterogeneity as the cause of the linear separability effect
   Zoe Xu, Alejandro Lleras, John E. Hummel, Simona Buetti · 2022 · Journal of Vision
8. Evaluating the ability of visual search models suggested for computer-vision to predict human performance
   Yaffa Yeshurun, Tamar Avraham, Michael Lindenbaum · 2010 · Journal of Vision
9. The effect of distractor statistics in visual search
   Joshua Michael Calder-Travis, Wei Ji Ma · 2019 · Journal of Vision
10. GSDT: An integrative model of visual search.
    Wolf Schwarz, Jeff O. Miller · 2016 · Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & Performance