CoChat

Formation and radiative forcing of contrail cirrus

Open access
Kärcher, Bernd · 2018 · Nature Communications

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 153 of the 153 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Abstract

Aircraft-produced contrail cirrus clouds contribute to anthropogenic climate change. Observational data sets and modelling approaches have become available that clarify formation pathways close to the source aircraft and lead to estimates of the global distribution of their microphysical and optical properties. While contrail cirrus enhance the impact of natural clouds on climate, uncertainties remain regarding their properties and lifecycle. Progress in representing aircraft emissions, contrail cirrus and natural cirrus in global climate models together with tighter constraints on the sensitivity of the climate system will help judge efficiencies of and trade-offs between mitigation options.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1038/s41467-018-04068-0

Cites

153 of 153 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

Fig. 1 Aviation radiative forcing components. a Aviation as a percentage of total global radiative forcing (RF) due to human activities in the year 2011 relative to pre-industrial times, 2.29 (1.13–3.33) W m−2 (ref. 7). b Forcing components within the aviation fraction, of which aircraft-induced clouds (AIC) account for more than half. AIC and carbon dioxide (CO2) estimates represent 2011 emission levels10; the latter contribution has been obtained by extrapolating the year 2005 value11 using the corresponding increase in scheduled air traffic distance (Table 7.SM.2 in ref. 10). RF estimates for all aviation components together for the same year and emission levels superseding 2005 values are not available13. Aircraft emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx) cause positive and negative RF contributions, values here calculated based on refs. 107,139. Small direct RF contributions from aircraft water vapour140 and particle emissions14 together nearly cancel out and are therefore not shown. No scientific consensus has been reached regarding the sign of RF due to modification of natural clouds by particle emissions. Therefore, the RF caused by those ‘indirect’ effects is not considered here, but may be of opposite sign and as large as that of AIC. c Breakdown of AIC radiative forcing into contrail cirrus and persistent contrails based on ref.10
Fig. 1 Aviation radiative forcing components. a Aviation as a percentage of total global radiative forcing (RF) due to human activities in the year 2011 relative to pre-industrial times, 2.29 (1.13–3.33) W m−2 (ref. 7). b Forcing components within the aviation fraction, of which aircraft-induced clouds (AIC) account for more than half. AIC and carbon dioxide (CO2) estimates represent 2011 emission levels10; the latter contribution has been obtained by extrapolating the year 2005 value11 using the corresponding increase in scheduled air traffic distance (Table 7.SM.2 in ref. 10). RF estimates for all aviation components together for the same year and emission levels superseding 2005 values are not available13. Aircraft emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx) cause positive and negative RF contributions, values here calculated based on refs. 107,139. Small direct RF contributions from aircraft water vapour140 and particle emissions14 together nearly cancel out and are therefore not shown. No scientific consensus has been reached regarding the sign of RF due to modification of natural clouds by particle emissions. Therefore, the RF caused by those ‘indirect’ effects is not considered here, but may be of opposite sign and as large as that of AIC. c Breakdown of AIC radiative forcing into contrail cirrus and persistent contrails based on ref.10CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 2 Processes influencing the contrail formation stage. Exhaust plumes produced by combusting fuel–air mixtures at high temperature and pressure within turbofan jet engines contain gaseous and particulate matter. Particles types present in the freely expanding and cooling plumes (jet regime) comprise emitted soot particles and aqueous aerosol particles formed in the exhaust (Box 1) along with entrained ambient aerosol particles. When turbulent mixing (arrows) and the associated cooling produces plume supersaturation over liquid water (sw > 0), copious plume particles turn into water droplets (grey) that freeze and grow rapidly by uptake of water vapour forming a visible contrail. This happens when the ambient temperature, T, falls below the formation threshold, Θ. In soot-rich exhaust, most droplets contain soot inclusions. Droxtals, frozen water droplets with faceted surfaces, and hexagonal prisms and columns likely developing from them may provide a realistic representation of small ice crystals in fresh contrails, but no direct observational evidence for their shapes is available. Plumes from multiple aircraft engines merge with two wing tip vortices, forming an inhomogeneous wake. The further evolution of ice crystals depends largely on fluid-dynamical processes (vortex regime). The downward motion of the vortex pair warms the air causing ice crystal sublimation in the lower part of the wake. A small contrail fraction is released from the jets remaining at flight level and enhanced by detrainment of air from the lower wake. Ice crystals present in the upper wake continue to grow by uptake of entrained ice-supersaturated (si > 0) ambient water vapour. Few minutes past emission, the organised flow pattern collapses and mixes with ambient air (dissipation regime). Ice crystal images adapted from ref. 141 with permission from The Optical Society of America (OSA)
Fig. 2 Processes influencing the contrail formation stage. Exhaust plumes produced by combusting fuel–air mixtures at high temperature and pressure within turbofan jet engines contain gaseous and particulate matter. Particles types present in the freely expanding and cooling plumes (jet regime) comprise emitted soot particles and aqueous aerosol particles formed in the exhaust (Box 1) along with entrained ambient aerosol particles. When turbulent mixing (arrows) and the associated cooling produces plume supersaturation over liquid water (sw > 0), copious plume particles turn into water droplets (grey) that freeze and grow rapidly by uptake of water vapour forming a visible contrail. This happens when the ambient temperature, T, falls below the formation threshold, Θ. In soot-rich exhaust, most droplets contain soot inclusions. Droxtals, frozen water droplets with faceted surfaces, and hexagonal prisms and columns likely developing from them may provide a realistic representation of small ice crystals in fresh contrails, but no direct observational evidence for their shapes is available. Plumes from multiple aircraft engines merge with two wing tip vortices, forming an inhomogeneous wake. The further evolution of ice crystals depends largely on fluid-dynamical processes (vortex regime). The downward motion of the vortex pair warms the air causing ice crystal sublimation in the lower part of the wake. A small contrail fraction is released from the jets remaining at flight level and enhanced by detrainment of air from the lower wake. Ice crystals present in the upper wake continue to grow by uptake of entrained ice-supersaturated (si > 0) ambient water vapour. Few minutes past emission, the organised flow pattern collapses and mixes with ambient air (dissipation regime). Ice crystal images adapted from ref. 141 with permission from The Optical Society of America (OSA)CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 3 Nucleation of ice crystals in jet aircraft exhaust plumes. Ice crystal number emission index (per kilogram of fuel burnt) in the jet regime as a function of the number emission index of emitted soot particles simulated by a parcel model37. Two results are shown for an ambient temperature, T, close to a contrail formation threshold temperature, Θ ≈ 225 K, frequently found in extratropical cruise conditions, and a rather low temperature 12 K below this value. At intermediate ambient temperatures, nucleated ice crystal numbers increase due to enhanced water activation of either soot or ultrafine aqueous plume particles (Box 1). An approximate range of current in-flight soot emission indices is indicated (hatched area). In soot-rich exhaust, the number of soot particles that can be water-activated and freeze increases with decreasing ambient temperature that in turn increases plume cooling rates and levels of plume supersaturation over liquid water. As T approaches Θ in soot-poor exhaust, ambient aerosol particles mixed into exhaust plumes are the only source of contrail ice crystals, as increasingly fewer plume particles can be activated owing to diminishing plume supersaturation; the number concentrations of ambient particles are much lower in contrails than current soot emission levels. The plume cooling rate determines the time of water activation of entrained ambient particles, hence, the number of ice crystals derived from them. In soot-poor exhaust, ultrafine aqueous plume particles are formed in large numbers in the fresh exhaust, if the fuel contains sufficient amounts of condensable vapours besides water vapour. Those small particles are predicted to contribute significantly to ice crystal formation at low ambient temperatures well below average values at cruise levels (T ≈ 218 K in the extratropics and T ≈ 228 K in the tropics). If the formation of ultrafine particles cannot be avoided, ice crystal numbers are lowest in an intermediate range of soot emissions, 1013–1014 (kg-fuel)−1
Fig. 3 Nucleation of ice crystals in jet aircraft exhaust plumes. Ice crystal number emission index (per kilogram of fuel burnt) in the jet regime as a function of the number emission index of emitted soot particles simulated by a parcel model37. Two results are shown for an ambient temperature, T, close to a contrail formation threshold temperature, Θ ≈ 225 K, frequently found in extratropical cruise conditions, and a rather low temperature 12 K below this value. At intermediate ambient temperatures, nucleated ice crystal numbers increase due to enhanced water activation of either soot or ultrafine aqueous plume particles (Box 1). An approximate range of current in-flight soot emission indices is indicated (hatched area). In soot-rich exhaust, the number of soot particles that can be water-activated and freeze increases with decreasing ambient temperature that in turn increases plume cooling rates and levels of plume supersaturation over liquid water. As T approaches Θ in soot-poor exhaust, ambient aerosol particles mixed into exhaust plumes are the only source of contrail ice crystals, as increasingly fewer plume particles can be activated owing to diminishing plume supersaturation; the number concentrations of ambient particles are much lower in contrails than current soot emission levels. The plume cooling rate determines the time of water activation of entrained ambient particles, hence, the number of ice crystals derived from them. In soot-poor exhaust, ultrafine aqueous plume particles are formed in large numbers in the fresh exhaust, if the fuel contains sufficient amounts of condensable vapours besides water vapour. Those small particles are predicted to contribute significantly to ice crystal formation at low ambient temperatures well below average values at cruise levels (T ≈ 218 K in the extratropics and T ≈ 228 K in the tropics). If the formation of ultrafine particles cannot be avoided, ice crystal numbers are lowest in an intermediate range of soot emissions, 1013–1014 (kg-fuel)−1CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 4 Sublimation-induced ice crystal losses in aircraft wakes. Dependence of the fraction of ice crystals escaping complete sublimation during the vortex regime versus nucleated ice crystal number emission index taken from LES simulations for a large aircraft at cruise and low (0.1), medium (0.2) and high (0.3) ambient ice supersaturation (Table A2 Block 4 in ref. 43). The magnitude of sublimation losses depends on aircraft engine thrust settings affecting soot particle numbers as well as on aircraft weight affecting the vertical depth of the wake; ambient conditions including ice supersaturation, air temperature and its vertical gradient and turbulence levels; and level of plume ice supersaturation and number, mean size and spread of the contrail ice crystal size distribution in the late jet regime. Substantial losses have been attributed to the Kelvin effect31, marking an increase in supersaturation over the surfaces of small particles relative to ambient values. Although this increase is very small (0.001–0.1) for µm-sized ice crystals, it becomes important in aircraft wake vortices for high ice crystal number concentrations causing rapid sublimation rates42
Fig. 4 Sublimation-induced ice crystal losses in aircraft wakes. Dependence of the fraction of ice crystals escaping complete sublimation during the vortex regime versus nucleated ice crystal number emission index taken from LES simulations for a large aircraft at cruise and low (0.1), medium (0.2) and high (0.3) ambient ice supersaturation (Table A2 Block 4 in ref. 43). The magnitude of sublimation losses depends on aircraft engine thrust settings affecting soot particle numbers as well as on aircraft weight affecting the vertical depth of the wake; ambient conditions including ice supersaturation, air temperature and its vertical gradient and turbulence levels; and level of plume ice supersaturation and number, mean size and spread of the contrail ice crystal size distribution in the late jet regime. Substantial losses have been attributed to the Kelvin effect31, marking an increase in supersaturation over the surfaces of small particles relative to ambient values. Although this increase is very small (0.001–0.1) for µm-sized ice crystals, it becomes important in aircraft wake vortices for high ice crystal number concentrations causing rapid sublimation rates42CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 5 Factors affecting the development of aircraft-induced clouds. Areal cloud coverage increases due to vertical shear of horizontal wind components. Turbulent mixing (entrainment) forces ice crystal concentrations to decrease (dilute) over time. Ice crystal sizes increase by uptake (deposition) of water vapour from ice-supersaturated layers. Sustained deposition growth causes ice crystal shapes (habits) to deviate from initial isometry. The shapes of ice crystals, which are only poorly known and illustrated as droxtals, hexagonal prisms and columns, bullet rosettes and aggregates, affect their size-dependent growth and fall rates and optical properties. Ice crystals with maximum dimensions >30 µm settle (sediment) due to gravity with fall speeds >100 m h−1 and sublimate in warmer or drier air, while smaller crystals remain around the flight levels due to negligible fall speeds as long as some supersaturation can be maintained depending on the meteorological situation. The efficiency of sedimentation depends on the depositional growth rate, i.e., on ice supersaturation, the rate of cooling of air, and on ice crystal size, habit and number concentration. Sedimentation increases the vertical extent of AIC, which, in turn, enhances the rate of spreading and therefore coverage in a sheared flow. Sustained warming and drying due to large-scale subsidence dissolves AIC entirely. Ice crystal images adapted from ref. 141 with permission from The OSA
Fig. 5 Factors affecting the development of aircraft-induced clouds. Areal cloud coverage increases due to vertical shear of horizontal wind components. Turbulent mixing (entrainment) forces ice crystal concentrations to decrease (dilute) over time. Ice crystal sizes increase by uptake (deposition) of water vapour from ice-supersaturated layers. Sustained deposition growth causes ice crystal shapes (habits) to deviate from initial isometry. The shapes of ice crystals, which are only poorly known and illustrated as droxtals, hexagonal prisms and columns, bullet rosettes and aggregates, affect their size-dependent growth and fall rates and optical properties. Ice crystals with maximum dimensions >30 µm settle (sediment) due to gravity with fall speeds >100 m h−1 and sublimate in warmer or drier air, while smaller crystals remain around the flight levels due to negligible fall speeds as long as some supersaturation can be maintained depending on the meteorological situation. The efficiency of sedimentation depends on the depositional growth rate, i.e., on ice supersaturation, the rate of cooling of air, and on ice crystal size, habit and number concentration. Sedimentation increases the vertical extent of AIC, which, in turn, enhances the rate of spreading and therefore coverage in a sheared flow. Sustained warming and drying due to large-scale subsidence dissolves AIC entirely. Ice crystal images adapted from ref. 141 with permission from The OSACC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 6 Variability in contrail optical depth. Probability distributions (PDF) of contrail optical depth, OD, and (top) the cumulative distribution (a) simulated by an idealised contrail model. The model PDF (b) was obtained (i) by solving an equation governing the evolution of the ice crystal size distribution accounting for mixing-induced dilution, shear-induced spreading, sedimentation and growth by vapour uptake and (ii) by imposing on this solution variability in meteorological factors described by probability distributions (inset) of air temperature, T, ice supersaturation (accounting for unresolved vertical air motion variability), si, vertical shear of horizontal winds, σ, and thickness of ice supersaturated layers, Δz, all constrained by atmospheric observations and numerical weather analyses. Simulation results65 are compared with satellite observations56 of contrails over the eastern North Pacific in the year 2001. According to the model analysis66, the measurements detected only 39% of all contrails over the whole OD range, 49% are subvisible (OD < 0.02) and 11% are not optically thin (OD > 0.3). By comparing simulated and observed PDF, detection efficiencies, ε, were inferred: 11.5% for data in the range 0< OD ≤ 0.05; 49% for 0.05 < OD ≤ 0.1; 94.5% for 0.1 < OD ≤ 0.2; and 100% for OD > 0.2, partly overlapping with values derived with other methods and in other conditions59. After adjusting the model PDF for inefficient detection using these efficiencies (horizontal arrow), it replicates the observed cumulant (stepped curve). Overall, applying the detection efficiency curve is consistent with a single cut-off OD value of 0.04, the upper limit OD value of the hatched area marking undetected (and partly invisible) contrails. The mean OD of all simulated contrails is 0.15, translating into 0.29 when corrected for non-detectable contrails. The corrected OD is roughly in line with the observed mean value, 0.24, that overestimates the model mean value of all contrails by ≈63%
Fig. 6 Variability in contrail optical depth. Probability distributions (PDF) of contrail optical depth, OD, and (top) the cumulative distribution (a) simulated by an idealised contrail model. The model PDF (b) was obtained (i) by solving an equation governing the evolution of the ice crystal size distribution accounting for mixing-induced dilution, shear-induced spreading, sedimentation and growth by vapour uptake and (ii) by imposing on this solution variability in meteorological factors described by probability distributions (inset) of air temperature, T, ice supersaturation (accounting for unresolved vertical air motion variability), si, vertical shear of horizontal winds, σ, and thickness of ice supersaturated layers, Δz, all constrained by atmospheric observations and numerical weather analyses. Simulation results65 are compared with satellite observations56 of contrails over the eastern North Pacific in the year 2001. According to the model analysis66, the measurements detected only 39% of all contrails over the whole OD range, 49% are subvisible (OD < 0.02) and 11% are not optically thin (OD > 0.3). By comparing simulated and observed PDF, detection efficiencies, ε, were inferred: 11.5% for data in the range 0< OD ≤ 0.05; 49% for 0.05 < OD ≤ 0.1; 94.5% for 0.1 < OD ≤ 0.2; and 100% for OD > 0.2, partly overlapping with values derived with other methods and in other conditions59. After adjusting the model PDF for inefficient detection using these efficiencies (horizontal arrow), it replicates the observed cumulant (stepped curve). Overall, applying the detection efficiency curve is consistent with a single cut-off OD value of 0.04, the upper limit OD value of the hatched area marking undetected (and partly invisible) contrails. The mean OD of all simulated contrails is 0.15, translating into 0.29 when corrected for non-detectable contrails. The corrected OD is roughly in line with the observed mean value, 0.24, that overestimates the model mean value of all contrails by ≈63%CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 7 Global annual mean radiative forcing due to aircraft-induced clouds. RF due to a persistent contrails alone and b together with contrail cirrus from selected studies and assessments sorted by publication date since 1999. Purely observational global estimates derive from extrapolating local aircraft and regional satellite data. Pure model estimates are based on or rely upon global model simulations. Uncertainty ranges evaluated across several methodologies are taken from comprehensive assessments. IPCC 1999 assessed persistent contrail RF to be 20 (5–60) mW m−2 for air traffic in the year 1992 (ref. 4), followed by two studies summarising knowledge in the subsequent decade11,73. A narrower range, 8–20 mW m−2, was provided for the year 2000 after correcting older estimates that include off-line radiative transfer simulations with prescribed contrail coverage and mean optical depth for undetectable contrails67. Taken together, subsequent climate model simulations and extrapolation from in situ and satellite observations yielded 3–16 mW m−2 for air traffic in 2002–2006 (refs. 63,69,71,142). Relying in part on extrapolation and scaling data from earlier years, the IPCC most recently assessed contrail RF to be 10 (5–30) mW m−2 (ref. 10) for 2011. Refs. 4,11,73 provided possible RF ranges due to AIC. Ref. 6 estimated for the first time global AIC RF to be 38 mW m−2 for air traffic in the year 2002 using a climate model that tracks AIC explicitly; an improved model version70 estimated 56 mW m−2 for 2006. AIC RF values 50 mW m−2 and 60 mW m−2 were predicted for 2006 based on an off-line model that tracks contrail segments forming along flight tracks in combination with weather forecast and climate host models52,88. In a climate model that regards contrails as a source term for natural clouds, ref. 69 reported a global AIC RF of 13 mW m−2 for the same reference year. The IPCC best estimate of global net RF due to AIC for air traffic in the year 2011—associated with low confidence—is 50 mW m−2 (ref. 10), corresponding to more than half of the total aviation RF, with a 90% uncertainty range, 20–150 mW m−2. This most recent best estimate does not include indirect effects of aircraft particle emissions on natural clouds
Fig. 7 Global annual mean radiative forcing due to aircraft-induced clouds. RF due to a persistent contrails alone and b together with contrail cirrus from selected studies and assessments sorted by publication date since 1999. Purely observational global estimates derive from extrapolating local aircraft and regional satellite data. Pure model estimates are based on or rely upon global model simulations. Uncertainty ranges evaluated across several methodologies are taken from comprehensive assessments. IPCC 1999 assessed persistent contrail RF to be 20 (5–60) mW m−2 for air traffic in the year 1992 (ref. 4), followed by two studies summarising knowledge in the subsequent decade11,73. A narrower range, 8–20 mW m−2, was provided for the year 2000 after correcting older estimates that include off-line radiative transfer simulations with prescribed contrail coverage and mean optical depth for undetectable contrails67. Taken together, subsequent climate model simulations and extrapolation from in situ and satellite observations yielded 3–16 mW m−2 for air traffic in 2002–2006 (refs. 63,69,71,142). Relying in part on extrapolation and scaling data from earlier years, the IPCC most recently assessed contrail RF to be 10 (5–30) mW m−2 (ref. 10) for 2011. Refs. 4,11,73 provided possible RF ranges due to AIC. Ref. 6 estimated for the first time global AIC RF to be 38 mW m−2 for air traffic in the year 2002 using a climate model that tracks AIC explicitly; an improved model version70 estimated 56 mW m−2 for 2006. AIC RF values 50 mW m−2 and 60 mW m−2 were predicted for 2006 based on an off-line model that tracks contrail segments forming along flight tracks in combination with weather forecast and climate host models52,88. In a climate model that regards contrails as a source term for natural clouds, ref. 69 reported a global AIC RF of 13 mW m−2 for the same reference year. The IPCC best estimate of global net RF due to AIC for air traffic in the year 2011—associated with low confidence—is 50 mW m−2 (ref. 10), corresponding to more than half of the total aviation RF, with a 90% uncertainty range, 20–150 mW m−2. This most recent best estimate does not include indirect effects of aircraft particle emissions on natural cloudsCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 8 Options to mitigate the climate effect of aircraft-induced clouds. Options are categorised into short-term and long-term solutions. Long-term options are further distinguished as drop-in (easily replaceable) and non-drop-in approaches. Mitigation options may also be categorised according to their influence in the two stages of AIC evolution. Most options, including technological options addressing alterations of aircraft engine architecture and airframe/engine integration, affect the formation stage (red) by reducing or modifying particle emissions or affecting nucleation and sublimation of contrail ice crystals in aircraft exhaust plumes and wakes. Only two options affect the spreading stage (blue), requiring sound predictive capability of ice supersaturated areas (air traffic management, ATM) or producing short-lived contrails in the dry lower stratosphere (supersonic flight) with negligible radiative impact
Fig. 8 Options to mitigate the climate effect of aircraft-induced clouds. Options are categorised into short-term and long-term solutions. Long-term options are further distinguished as drop-in (easily replaceable) and non-drop-in approaches. Mitigation options may also be categorised according to their influence in the two stages of AIC evolution. Most options, including technological options addressing alterations of aircraft engine architecture and airframe/engine integration, affect the formation stage (red) by reducing or modifying particle emissions or affecting nucleation and sublimation of contrail ice crystals in aircraft exhaust plumes and wakes. Only two options affect the spreading stage (blue), requiring sound predictive capability of ice supersaturated areas (air traffic management, ATM) or producing short-lived contrails in the dry lower stratosphere (supersonic flight) with negligible radiative impactCC BY · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

1 more claim about this paper

Create a free account to see every claim other papers make about this one.

See all claims — free account

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Show all 153 references

Research works printed but not linked: 2

  1. National Research Council. Radiative Forcing of Climate Change —Expanding the Concept and Addressing Uncertainties 207pp (The National Academies Press, Washington, D.C., 2005). ISBN 0-309-09506-9.
  2. Baughum, S. L., Danilin, M. Y., Miloshevich, L. M. & Heymsfield, A. J. Properties of ice-supersaturated layers based on radiosonde data analysis. In Proceedings of the TAC-2, June 22—25, 169–173 (2009).

Cited by

See all 521

Metadata

Authors
Kärcher, B.
Affiliations
Deutsches Zentrum für Luft- und Raumfahrt e. V. (DLR) (DE)
Corresponding author
Kärcher, Bernd
Venue
Nature Communications
Published
2018-05-08
Volume
9
Issue
1
Pages
1824-1824
ISSN
2041-1723 (ISSN-L)
OpenAlex
W2800510884
Cited by
377
References
150
Citations by year
2026: 43 · 2025: 81 · 2024: 62 · 2023: 54 · 2022: 47 · 2021: 37 · 2020: 32 · 2019: 15 · 2018: 6
FWCI
2.55
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Licence
Locations
  • Nature Communications (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • Europe PMC (PubMed Central) (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • elib (German Aerospace Center) (acceptedVersion)
  • RePEc: Research Papers in Economics (submittedVersion)
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion, cc-by-sa)
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion)
Topics
  • Physical Sciences › Environmental Science › Global and Planetary Change › Atmospheric aerosols and clouds
  • Physical Sciences › Engineering › Aerospace Engineering › Advanced Aircraft Design and Technologies
  • Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Atmospheric Science › Atmospheric Ozone and Climate
Keywords
contrail cirrus, radiative forcing, aviation emissions, cloud formation, cirrus clouds, climate change, cloud microphysical properties, cloud optical properties, global climate models

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Formation and radiative forcing of contrail cirrus. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1038/s41467-018-04068-0
The paper
Kärcher, B. (2018). Formation and radiative forcing of contrail cirrus. Nature Communications. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-04068-0

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.