CoChat
Sign Up
Cited by 24

Antibiotic resistance in urban stormwater: a review of the dissemination of resistance elements, their impact, and management opportunities

O'Malley, Kassidy, McDonald, Walter, McNamara, Patrick·2023·Environmental Science: Water Research & Technology
DOI 10.1039/d3ew00356f
Open this paper in CoChat — free account

Abstract

Traditional stormwater infrastructure facilitates the transport of antibiotic resistance genes while green stormwater infrastructure may capture the genes and promote horizontal gene transfer.

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Run the check — free, no account needed. It reads the open-access text and checks the sources it cites.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1039/d3ew00356f

Cites

5 of 5 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Run the check — free, no account needed. It reads the open-access text and checks the sources it cites.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Cites

Flagged first, then by citations

Research works printed but not linked: 144

  1. J. Davies, Where have all the antibiotics gone?, Can. J. Infect. Dis. Med. Microbiol., 2006, 17, 287-290.
  2. C. J. Murray, K. S. Ikuta, F. Sharara, L. Swetschinski, G. Robles Aguilar, A. Gray, C. Han, C. Bisignano, P. Rao, E. Wool, S. C. Johnson, A. J. Browne, M. G. Chipeta, F. Fell, S. Hackett, G. Haines-Woodhouse, B. H. Kashef Hamadani, E. A. P. Kumaran, B. McManigal, R. Agarwal, S. Akech, S. Albertson, J. Amuasi, J. Andrews, A. Aravkin, E. Ashley, F. Bailey, S. Baker, B. Basnyat, A. Bekker, R. Bender, A. Bethou, J. Bielicki, S. Boonkasidecha, J. Bukosia, C. Carvalheiro, C. Castañeda-Orjuela, V. Chansamouth, S. Chaurasia, S. Chiurchiù, F. Chowdhury, A. J. Cook, B. Cooper, T. R. Cressey, E. Criollo-Mora, M. Cunningham, S. Darboe, N. P. J. Day, M. De Luca, K. Dokova, A. Dramowski, S. J. Dunachie, T. Eckmanns, D. Eibach, A. Emami, N. Feasey, N. Fisher-Pearson, K. Forrest, D. Garrett, P. Gastmeier, A. Z. Giref, R. C. Greer, V. Gupta, S. Haller, A. Haselbeck, S. I. Hay, M. Holm, S. Hopkins, K. C. Iregbu, J. Jacobs, D. Jarovsky, F. Javanmardi, M. Khorana, N. Kissoon, E. Kobeissi, T. Kostyanev, F. Krapp, R. Krumkamp, A. Kumar, H. H. Kyu, C. Lim, D. Limmathurotsakul, M. J. Loftus, M. Lunn, J. Ma, N. Mturi, T. Munera-Huertas, P. Musicha, M. M. Mussi-Pinhata, T. Nakamura, R. Nanavati, S. Nangia, P. Newton, C. Ngoun, A. Novotney, D. Nwakanma, C. W. Obiero, A. Olivas-Martinez, P. Olliaro, E. Ooko, E. Ortiz-Brizuela, A. Y. Peleg, C. Perrone, N. Plakkal, A. Ponce-de-Leon, M. Raad, T. Ramdin, A. Riddell, T. Roberts, J. V. Robotham, A. Roca, K. E. Rudd, N. Russell, J. Schnall, J. A. G. Scott, M. Shivamallappa, J. Sifuentes- Osornio, N. Steenkeste, A. J. Stewardson, T. Stoeva, N. Tasak, A. Thaiprakong, G. Thwaites, C. Turner, P. Turner, H. R. van Doorn, S. Velaphi, A. Vongpradith, H. Vu, T. Walsh, S. Waner, T. Wangrangsimakul, T. Wozniak, P. Zheng, B. Sartorius, A. D. Lopez, A. Stergachis, C. Moore, C. Dolecek and M. Naghavi, Global burden of bacterial antimicrobial resistance in 2019: a systematic analysis, Lancet, 2022, 399(10325), 12-18.
  3. P. Dadgostar, Antimicrobial Resistance: Implications and Costs, Infect. Drug Resist., 2019, 12, 3903-3910.
  4. A. Chokshi, Z. Sifri, D. Cennimo and H. Horng, Global contributors to antibiotic resistance, J. Global Infect. Dis., 2019, 11, 36-42.
  5. G. Cox and G. D. Wright, Intrinsic antibiotic resistance: Mechanisms, origins, challenges and solutions, Int. J. Med. Microbiol., 2013, 303, 287-292.
  6. E. Peterson and P. Kaur, Antibiotic resistance mechanisms in bacteria: Relationships between resistance determinants of antibiotic producers, environmental bacteria, and clinical pathogens, Front. Microbiol., 2018, 9, 1-21.
  7. J. M. A. Blair, M. A. Webber, A. J. Baylay, D. O. Ogbolu and L. J. V. Piddock, Molecular mechanisms of antibiotic resistance, Nat. Rev. Microbiol., 2015, 13, 42-51.
  8. E. Goldman, Antibiotic abuse in animal agriculture: Exacerbating drug resistance in human pathogens, Hum. Ecol. Risk Assess., 2004, 10, 121-134.
  9. B. Spellberg, G. R. Hansen, A. Kar, C. D. Cordova, L. B. Price and J. R. Johnson, Antibiotic Resistance in Humans and Animals, NAM Perspect., 2016, DOI: 10.31478/201606d. · DOI
  10. W. Witte, Medical consequences of antibiotics use in agriculture, Science, 1998, 279, 996-997.
  11. M. Anwar, Q. Iqbal and F. Saleem, Improper disposal of unused antibiotics: an often overlooked driver of antimicrobial resistance, Expert Rev. Anti-infect. Ther., 2020, 18, 697-699.
  12. S. I. Polianciuc, A. E. Gurzău, B. Kiss, M. Georgia Ştefan and F. Loghin, Antibiotics in the environment: causes and consequences, Med. Pharm. Rep., 2020, 93, 231-240.
  13. D. G. J. Larsson, Antibiotics in the environment, Upsala J. Med. Sci., 2014, 119, 108-112.
  14. A. Yakimov, I. Bakhlanova and D. Baitin, Targeting evolution of antibiotic resistance by SOS response inhibition, Comput. Struct. Biotechnol. J., 2021, 19, 777-783.
  15. M. Zhuang, Y. Achmon, Y. Cao, X. Liang, L. Chen, H. Wang, B. A. Siame and K. Y. Leung, Distribution of antibiotic resistance genes in the environment, Environ. Pollut., 2021, 285, 117402.
  16. M. Imran, K. R. Das and M. M. Naik, Co-selection of multi- antibiotic resistance in bacterial pathogens in metal and Environmental Science: Water Research & Technology Critical review microplastic contaminated environments: An emerging health threat, Chemosphere, 2019, 215, 846-857.
  17. A. D. Wales and R. H. Davies, Co-selection of resistance to antibiotics, biocides and heavy metals, and its relevance to foodborne pathogens, Antibiotics, 2015, 4, 567-604.
  18. B. Berglund, Environmental dissemination of antibiotic resistance genes and correlation to anthropogenic contamination with antibiotics, Infect. Ecol. Epidemiol., 2015, 5, 28564.
  19. C. J. H. Von Wintersdorff, J. Penders and J. M. Van Niekerk, Dissemination of Antimicrobial Resistance in Microbial Ecosystems through Horizontal Gene Transfer, Front. Microbiol., 2016, 7, 1-10.
  20. S. B. Levy, Gene Transfer in the Environment, Gene Transfer in the Environment, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1989.
  21. C. M. Thomas and K. M. Nielsen, Mechanisms of, and barriers to, horizontal gene transfer between bacteria, Nat. Rev. Microbiol., 2005, 3, 711-721.
  22. A. Zarei-Baygi and A. L. Smith, Intracellular versus extracellular antibiotic resistance genes in the environment: Prevalence, horizontal transfer, and mitigation strategies, Bioresour. Technol., 2021, 319, 124181.
  23. S. Kunhikannan, C. J. Thomas, A. E. Franks, S. Mahadevaiah, S. Kumar and S. Petrovski, Environmental hotspots for antibiotic resistance genes, MicrobiologyOpen, 2021, 10(3), e1197.
  24. B. J. Koch, B. A. Hungate and L. B. Price, Food-animal production and the spread of antibiotic resistance: the role of ecology, Front. Ecol. Environ., 2017, 15, 309-318.
  25. E. A. Oniciuc, E. Likotrafiti, A. Alvarez-Molina, M. Prieto, J. A. Santos and A. Alvarez-Ordóñez, The present and future of whole genome sequencing (WGS) and whole metagenome sequencing (WMS) for surveillance of antimicrobial resistant microorganisms and antimicrobial resistance genes across the food chain, Genes, 2018, 9, 1-28.
  26. C. Baker-Austin, M. S. Wright, R. Stepanauskas and J. V. McArthur, Co-selection of antibiotic and metal resistance, Trends Microbiol., 2006, 14, 176-182.
  27. G. W. Sundin and C. L. Bender, Dissemination of the strA- strB streptomycin-resistance genes among commensal and pathogenic bacteria from humans, animals, and plants, Mol. Ecol., 1996, 5, 133-143.
  28. K. Pärnänen, A. Karkman, M. Tamminen, C. Lyra, J. Hultman, L. Paulin and M. Virta, Evaluating the mobility potential of antibiotic resistance genes in environmental resistomes without metagenomics, Sci. Rep., 2016, 6, 35790.
  29. S. R. Partridge, S. M. Kwong, N. Firth and S. O. Jensen, Mobile Genetic Elements Associated with Antimicrobial Resistance, Clin. Microbiol. Rev., 2018, 31(4), e00088-17.
  30. J. L. Martínez, T. M. Coque and F. Baquero, What is a resistance gene? Ranking risk in resistomes, Nat. Rev. Microbiol., 2015, 13, 116-123.
  31. D. J. Rankin, E. P. C. Rocha and S. P. Brown, What traits are carried on mobile genetic elements, and why?, Heredity, 2011, 106, 1-10.
  32. S. C. Jiang, K. Lim, X. Huang, D. McCarthy and A. J. Hamilton, Human and environmental health risks and benefits associated with use of urban stormwater, Wiley Interdiscip. Rev.: Water, 2015, 2, 683-699.
  33. L. Wang, J. Lyons, P. Kanehl and R. Bannerman, Impacts of urbanization on stream habitat and fish across multiple spatial scales, Environ. Manage., 2001, 28, 255-266.
  34. E. Eriksson, A. Baun, P. S. Mikkelsen and A. Ledin, Chemical hazard identification and assessment tool for evaluation of stormwater priority pollutants, Water Sci. Technol., 2005, 51, 47-55.
  35. M. Huber, A. Welker and B. Helmreich, Critical review of heavy metal pollution of traffic area runoff: Occurrence, influencing factors, and partitioning, Sci. Total Environ., 2016, 541, 895-919.
  36. W. Ahmed, K. Hamilton, S. Toze, S. Cook and D. Page, A review on microbial contaminants in stormwater runoff and outfalls: Potential health risks and mitigation strategies, Sci. Total Environ., 2019, 692, 1304-1321.
  37. S. J. Gaffield, R. L. Goo, L. A. Richards and R. J. Jackson, Public Health Effects of Inadequately Managed Stormwater Runoff, Am. J. Public Health, 2003, 93, 1527-1533.
  38. R. W. Haile, J. S. Witte, M. Gold, R. Cressey, C. McGee, R. C. Milikan, A. Glasser, N. Harawa, C. Ervin, P. Harmon, J. Harper, J. Dermand, J. Alamillo, K. Barrett, M. Nides and G. Wang, The Health Effects of Swimming in Ocean Water Contaminated by Storm Drain Runoff, Epidemiology, 1999, 10, 355-363.
  39. A. Almakki, E. Jumas-Bilak, H. Marchandin and P. Licznar- Fajardo, Antibiotic resistance in urban runoff, Sci. Total Environ., 2019, 667, 64-76.
  40. K. A. Hamilton, E. Garner, S. Joshi, W. Ahmed, N. Ashbolt, G. Medema and A. Pruden, Antimicrobial-resistant microorganisms and their genetic determinants in stormwater: A systematic review, Curr. Opin. Environ. Sci. Health, 2020, 16, 101-112.
  41. T. R. Burch, R. J. Newton, L. K. Kimbell, E. Lou LaMartina, K. O'Malley, S. M. Thomson, C. W. Marshall and P. J. McNamara, Targeting current and future threats: recent methodological trends in environmental antimicrobial Environmental Science: Water Research & Technology Critical review resistance research and their relationships to risk assessment, J. Environ. Sci., 2022, 8, 1787-1802.
  42. K. O'Malley, P. J. McNamara and W. M. McDonald, Seasonal and spatial patterns differ between intracellular and extracellular antibiotic resistance genes in urban stormwater runoff, Env. Sci. Adv., 2022, 1, 380-390.
  43. X. Zuo, P. Suo, Y. Li and Q. Xu, Diversity and distribution of antibiotic resistance genes associated with road sediments transported in urban stormwater runoff ☆, Environ. Pollut., 2022, 292, 118470.
  44. R. Liguori, S. H. Rommel, J. Bengtsson-Palme, B. Helmreich and C. Wurzbacher, Microbial retention and resistances in stormwater quality improvement devices treating road runoff, FEMS Microbiol. Ecol., 2021, 2, 1-13.
  45. A. M. S. Cardonha, R. H. S. F. Vieira, D. P. Rodrigues, A. Macrae, G. Peirano and G. N. D. Teophilo, Fecal pollution in water from storm sewers and adjacent seashores in Natal, Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil, Int. Microbiol., 2004, 7, 213-218.
  46. W. Ahmed, Q. Zhang, A. Lobos, J. Senkbeil, M. J. Sadowsky, V. J. Harwood, N. Saeidi, O. Marinoni and S. Ishii, Precipitation influences pathogenic bacteria and antibiotic resistance gene abundance in storm drain outfalls in coastal sub-tropical waters, Environ. Int., 2018, 116, 308-318.
  47. D. Baral, B. I. Dvorak, D. Admiraal, S. Jia, C. Zhang and X. Li, Tracking the Sources of Antibiotic Resistance Genes in an Urban Stream during Wet Weather using Shotgun Metagenomic Analyses, Environ. Sci. Technol., 2018, 52, 9033-9044.
  48. D. A. P. R. Dewi, B. Gotz and T. Thomas, Diversity and Genetic Basis for Carbapenem Resistance in a Coastal Marine Environment, Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 2020, 86(10), e02939-19.
  49. S. Lee, M. Suits, D. Wituszynski, R. Winston, J. Martin and J. Lee, Residential urban stormwater runoff: A comprehensive profile of microbiome and antibiotic resistance, Sci. Total Environ., 2020, 723, 138033.
  50. Z. R. Staley, J. Grabuski, E. Sverko and T. A. Edge, Comparison of microbial and chemical source tracking markers to identify fecal contamination sources in the Humber River (Toronto, Ontario, Canada) and associated storm water outfalls, Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 2016, 82, 6357-6366.
  51. M. Białasek and A. Miłobędzka, Revealing antimicrobial resistance in stormwater with MinION, Chemosphere, 2020, 258, DOI: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.127392. · DOI
  52. A. Eramo, H. D. Reyes and N. L. Fahrenfeld, Partitioning of antibiotic resistance genes and fecal indicators varies intra and inter-storm during combined sewer overflows, Front. Microbiol., 2017, 8, 1-13.
  53. S. L. McLellan, E. J. Hollis, M. M. Depas, M. Van Dyke, J. Harris and C. O. Scopel, Distribution and fate of Escherichia coli in Lake Michigan following contamination with urban stormwater and combined sewer overflows, J. Great Lakes Res., 2007, 33, 566-580.
  54. X. Pan, L. Chen, L. Zhang and J. Zuo, Characteristics of antibiotic resistance gene distribution in rainfall runoff and combined sewer overflow, Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res., 2022, 30, 30766-30778.
  55. N. L. R. Williams, N. Siboni, S. L. McLellan, J. Potts, P. Scanes, C. Johnson, M. James, V. McCann and J. R. Seymour, Rainfall leads to elevated levels of antibiotic resistance genes within seawater at an Australian beach, Environ. Pollut., 2022, 307, 119456.
  56. J. E. McLain, E. Cytryn, L. M. Durso and S. Young, Culture- based Methods for Detection of Antibiotic Resistance in Agroecosystems: Advantages, Challenges, and Gaps in Knowledge, J. Environ. Qual., 2016, 45, 432-440.
  57. S. Nayfach and K. S. Pollard, Toward Accurate and Quantitative Comparative Metagenomics, Cell, 2016, 166, 1103-1116.
  58. X. Yin, X. Chen, X. Jiang, Y. Yang, B. Li, M. H. Shum, T. T. Y. Lam, G. M. Leung, J. Rose, C. Sanchez-cid, T. M. Vogel, F. Walsh, T. U. Berendonk, J. Midega, C. Uchea, D. Frigon, G. D. Wright, S. Z. Ahammad, P. H. Nielsen, P. Hugenholtz, C. Bezuidenhout, R. C. Pica, N. J. Ashbolt, G. Corno, D. Fatta-kassinos, H. Bu, H. Schmitt, C. Cha, A. Pruden, K. Smalla, E. Cytryn, Y. Zhang, M. Yang, Y. Zhu, A. Dechesne, B. F. Smets, D. W. Graham, M. R. Gillings, W. H. Gaze, C. M. Manaia, M. C. M. Van Loosdrecht, P. J. J. Alvarez, M. J. Blaser, J. M. Tiedje, E. Topp and T. Zhang, Toward a Universal Unit for Quantification of Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Environmental Samples, Environ. Sci. Technol., 2023, 57, 9713-9721.
  59. P. Blanco, S. Hernando-Amado, J. A. Reales-Calderon, F. Corona, F. Lira, M. Alcalde-Rico, A. Bernardini, M. B. Sanchez and J. L. Martinez, Bacterial multidrug efflux pumps: Much more than antibiotic resistance determinants, Microorganisms, 2016, 4, 1-19.
  60. B. Youenou, S. Favre-Bonté, J. Bodilis, E. Brothier, A. Dubost, D. Muller and S. Nazaret, Comparative genomics of environmental and clinical Stenotrophomonas maltophilia strains with different antibiotic resistance profiles, Genome Biol. Evol., 2015, 7, 2484-2505.
  61. K. T. Konstantinidis and J. M. Tiedje, Trends between gene content and genome size in prokaryotic species with larger genomes, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A., 2004, 101, 3160-3165.
  62. M. R. Gillings, W. H. Gaze, A. Pruden, K. Smalla, J. M. Tiedje and Y. G. Zhu, Using the class 1 integron-integrase gene as a proxy for anthropogenic pollution, ISME J., 2015, 9, 1269-1279.
  63. Y. Zhang, A. Z. Gu, T. Cen, X. Li, M. He, D. Li and J. Chen, Sub-inhibitory concentrations of heavy metals facilitate the horizontal transfer of plasmid-mediated antibiotic resistance genes in water environment, Environ. Pollut., 2018, 237, 74-82.
  64. M. Nagler, H. Insam, G. Pietramellara and J. Ascher-Jenull, Extracellular DNA in natural environments: features, relevance and applications, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol., 2018, 102, 6343-6356.
  65. K. M. Nielsen, P. J. Johnsen, D. Bensasson and D. Daffonchio, Release and persistence of extracellular DNA in the environment, Environ. Biosaf. Res., 2007, 6, 37-53.
  66. D. Mao, Y. Luo, J. Mathieu, Q. Wang, L. Feng, Q. Mu, C. Feng and P. J. J. Alvarez, Persistence of extracellular DNA in river sediment facilitates antibiotic resistance gene propagation, Environ. Sci. Technol., 2014, 48, 71-78.
  67. G. Pietramellara, J. Ascher, F. Borgogni, M. T. Ceccherini, G. Guerri and P. Nannipieri, Extracellular DNA in soil and sediment: Fate and ecological relevance, Biol. Fertil. Soils, 2009, 45, 219-235.
  68. Y. Zhang, Z. Niu, Y. Zhang and K. Zhang, Occurrence of intracellular and extracellular antibiotic resistance genes in coastal areas of Bohai Bay (China) and the factors affecting them, Environ. Pollut., 2018, 236, 126-136.
  69. Y. Yang, H. Li, Y. Wei, Z. Chen, T. Chen, Y. Liang, J. Yin, D. Yang, Z. Yang, D. Shi, S. Zhou, H. Wang, J. Li and M. Jin, Comprehensive insights into profiles and bacterial sources of intracellular and extracellular antibiotic resistance genes in groundwater, Environ. Pollut., 2022, 307, 119541.
  70. C. Corinaldesi, R. Danovaro and A. Dell'Anno, Simultaneous recovery of extracellular and intracellular DNA suitable for molecular studies from marine sediments, Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 2005, 71, 46-50.
  71. M. A. Barnes, C. R. Turner, C. L. Jerde, M. A. Renshaw, W. L. Chadderton and D. M. Lodge, Environmental conditions influence eDNA persistence in aquatic systems, Environ. Sci. Technol., 2014, 48, 1819-1827.
  72. D. J. Levy-Booth, R. G. Campbell, R. H. Gulden, M. M. Hart, J. R. Powell, J. N. Klironomos, K. P. Pauls, C. J. Swanton, J. T. Trevors and K. E. Dunfield, Cycling of extracellular DNA in the soil environment, Soil Biol. Biochem., 2007, 39, 2977-2991.
  73. B. Zhu, Degradation of plasmid and plant DNA in water microcosms monitored by natural transformation and real- time polymerase chain reaction ( PCR ), Water Res., 2006, 40, 3231-3238.
  74. Y. Zhang, D. D. Snow, D. Parker, Z. Zhou and X. Li, Intracellular and Extracellular Antimicrobial Resistance Genes in the Sludge of Livestock Waste Management Structures, Environ. Sci. Technol., 2013, 47, 10206-10213.
  75. Z. Zhao, K. Zhang, N. Wu, W. Li, W. Xu, Y. Zhang and Z. Niu, Estuarine sediments are key hotspots of intracellular and extracellular antibiotic resistance genes: A high- throughput analysis in Haihe Estuary in China, Environ. Int., 2020, 135, 105385.
  76. Y. Zhang, Z. Niu, Y. Zhang and K. Zhang, Occurrence of intracellular and extracellular antibiotic resistance genes in coastal areas of Bohai Bay (China) and the factors affecting them, Environ. Pollut., 2018, 236, 126-136.
  77. T. He, L. Jin, J. Xie, S. Yue, P. Fu and X. Li, Intracellular and Extracellular Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Airborne PM2.5for Respiratory Exposure in Urban Areas, Environ. Sci. Technol. Lett., 2021, 8, 128-134.
  78. P. Dong, H. Wang, T. Fang, Y. Wang and Q. Ye, Assessment of extracellular antibiotic resistance genes (eARGs) in typical environmental samples and the transforming ability of eARG, Environ. Int., 2019, 125, 90-96.
  79. Y. Zhang, A. Li, T. Dai, F. Li, H. Xie, L. Chen and D. Wen, Cell-free DNA: A Neglected Source for Antibiotic Resistance Genes Spreading from WWTPs, Environ. Sci. Technol., 2018, 52, 248-257.
  80. M. Liu, A. Hata, H. Katayama and I. Kasuga, Consecutive ultrafiltration and silica adsorption for recovery of extracellular antibiotic resistance genes from an urban river, Environ. Pollut., 2020, 260, 114062.
  81. S. Zhang, S. Pang, P. F. Wang, C. Wang, N. Han, B. Liu, B. Han, Y. Li and K. Anim-Larbi, Antibiotic concentration and antibiotic-resistant bacteria in two shallow urban lakes after stormwater event, Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res., 2016, 23, 9984-9992.
  82. A. Chaudhary, I. Kauser and A. Ray, Taxon-Driven Functional Shifts Associated with Storm Flow in an Urban Stream Microbial Community, Appl. Environ. Sci., 2018, 3, e00194-18.
  83. A. K. Salmore, E. J. Hollis and S. L. McLellan, Delineation of a chemical and biological signature for stormwater pollution in an urban river, J. Water Health, 2006, 4, 247-262.
  84. S. Young, A. Juhl and G. D. O'Mullan, Antibiotic-resistant bacteria in the Hudson River Estuary linked to wet weather sewage contamination, J. Water Health, 2013, 11, 297-310.
  85. R. L. Carney, M. Labbate, N. Siboni, K. A. Tagg, S. M. Mitrovic and J. R. Seymour, Urban beaches are environmental hotspots for antibiotic resistance following rainfall, Water Res., 2019, 167, 115081.
  86. J. P. S. Sidhu, V. V. S. R. Gupta, C. Stange, J. Ho, N. Harris, K. Barry, D. Gonzalez, J. D. Van Nostrand, J. Zhou, D. Page, A. Tiehm and S. Toze, Prevalence of antibiotic resistance and virulence genes in the biofilms from an aquifer recharged with stormwater, Water Res., 2020, 185, 116269.
  87. A. Di Cesare, E. M. Eckert, M. Rogora and G. Corno, Rainfall increases the abundance of antibiotic resistance genes within a riverine microbial community, Environ. Pollut., 2017, 226, 473-478.
  88. E. Garner, J. S. Wallace, G. A. Argoty, C. Wilkinson, N. Fahrenfeld, L. S. Heath, L. Zhang, M. Arabi, D. S. Aga and A. Pruden, Metagenomic profiling of historic Colorado Environmental Science: Water Research & Technology Critical review Front Range flood impact on distribution of riverine antibiotic resistance genes, Sci. Rep., 2016, 6, 1-10.
  89. E. Garner, R. Benitez, E. von Wagoner, R. Sawyer, E. Schaberg, W. C. Hession, L. A. H. Krometis, B. D. Badgley and A. Pruden, Stormwater loadings of antibiotic resistance genes in an urban stream, Water Res., 2017, 123, 144-152.
  90. M. M. McConnell, L. T. Hansen, K. D. Neudorf, J. L. Hayward, R. C. Jamieson, C. K. Yost and A. Tong, Sources of Antibiotic Resistance Genes in a Rural River System, J. Environ. Qual., 2018, 47, 997-1005.
  91. M. Batrich, L. Maskeri, R. Schubert, B. Ho, M. Kohout, M. Abdeljaber, A. Abuhasna, M. Kholoki, P. Psihogios, T. Razzaq, S. Sawhney, S. Siddiqui, E. Xoubi, A. Cooper, T. Hatzopoulos and C. Putonti, Pseudomonas diversity within urban freshwaters, Front. Microbiol., 2019, 10, 1-13. 100
  92. L. Hou, J. Li, H. Wang, Q. Chen, J. Q. Su, M. Gad, W. Ahmed, C. P. Yu and A. Hu, Storm promotes the dissemination of antibiotic resistome in an urban lagoon through enhancing bio-interactions, Environ. Int., 2022, 168, 107457.
  93. C. Stange and A. Tiehm, Occurrence of antibiotic resistance genes and microbial source tracking markers in the water of a karst spring in Germany, Sci. Total Environ., 2020, 742, DOI: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.140529. 102 · DOI
  94. L. Hou, J. Li, H. Wang, Q. Chen, J. Q. Su, M. Gad, W. Ahmed, C. P. Yu and A. Hu, Storm promotes the dissemination of antibiotic resistome in an urban lagoon through enhancing bio-interactions, Environ. Int., 2022, 168, 107457. 103
  95. J. P. S. Sidhu, V. V. S. R. Gupta, C. Stange, J. Ho, N. Harris, K. Barry, D. Gonzalez, J. D. Van Nostrand, J. Zhou, D. Page, A. Tiehm and S. Toze, Prevalence of antibiotic resistance and virulence genes in the biofilms from an aquifer recharged with stormwater, Water Res., 2020, 185, 116269.
  96. A. Chaudhary, I. Kauser and A. Ray, Taxon-Driven Functional Shifts Associated with Storm Flow in an Urban Stream Microbial Community, Appl. Environ. Sci., 2018, 3, e00194-18. 105
  97. V. Venkataramanan, A. I. Packman, D. R. Peters, D. Lopez, D. J. Mccuskey, R. I. Mcdonald, W. M. Miller and S. L. Young, A systematic review of the human health and social well-being outcomes of green infrastructure for stormwater and flood management, J. Environ. Manage., 2019, 246, 868-880. 107
  98. J. Sage, E. Berthier and M. C. Gromaire, Stormwater Management Criteria for On-Site Pollution Control: A Comparative Assessment of International Practices, Environ. Manage., 2015, 56, 66-80. 108
  99. V. M. Jayasooriya, A. W. M. Ng, S. Muthukumaran and B. J. C. Perera, Green infrastructure practices for improvement of urban air quality, Urban For Urban Green, 2017, 21, 34-47. 109
  100. T. A. M. Pugh, A. R. MacKenzie, J. D. Whyatt and C. N. Hewitt, Effectiveness of green infrastructure for improvement of air quality in urban street canyons, Environ. Sci. Technol., 2012, 46, 7692-7699.
  101. K. V. Abhijith and P. Kumar, Field investigations for evaluating green infrastructure effects on air quality in open-road conditions, Atmos. Environ., 2019, 201, 132-147.
  102. M. E. Delorenzo, B. Thompson, E. Cooper, J. Moore and M. H. Fulton, A long-term monitoring study of chlorophyll, microbial contaminants, and pesticides in a coastal residential stormwater pond and its adjacent tidal creek, Environ. Monit. Assess., 2012, 184, 343-359.
  103. C. P. Muerdter, C. K. Wong and G. H. LeFevre, The Role of Vegetation in Bioretention for Stormwater Treatment in the Built Environment: Pollutant Removal , Hydrologic Function , and Ancillary Benefits, J. Environ. Sci., 2018, 4, 592-612.
  104. M. A. Gonzalez-Meler, L. A. Cotner, D. A. Massey, M. L. Zellner and E. S. Minor, The Environmental and Ecological Benefits of Green Infrastructure for Stormwater Runoff in Urban Areas, JSM Environ. Sci. Ecol., 2013, 1, 1007. 114
  105. G. LeFevre, K. Paus, P. Natarajan, J. Gulliver, P. Novak and R. Hozalski, Review of dissolved pollutants in urban storm water and their removal and fate in bioretention cells, J. Environ. Eng., 2015, 141, 04014050.
  106. X. Zuo, S. Zhang, F. Kong and Q. Xu, Application of electrochemical oxidation for the enhancement of antibiotic resistant bacteria removal in stormwater bioretention cells, Sci. Total Environ., 2023, 861, DOI: 10.1016/J.SCITOTENV.2022.160477. 116 · DOI
  107. X. Zuo, Q. Xu, Y. Li and K. Zhang, Antibiotic resistance genes removals in stormwater bioretention cells with three kinds of environmental conditions, J. Hazard. Mater., 2022, 429, 128336.
  108. M. B. Rugh, S. B. Grant, W. C. Hung, J. A. Jay, E. A. Parker, M. Feraud, D. Li, S. Avasarala, P. A. Holden, H. Liu, M. A. Rippy, L. C. V. De Werfhorst, T. Kefela, J. Peng, S. Shao, K. E. Graham, A. B. Boehm, S. Choi, S. K. Mohanty and Y. Cao, Highly variable removal of pathogens, antibiotic resistance genes, conventional fecal indicators and human-associated fecal source markers in a pilot-scale stormwater biofilter operated under realistic stormflow conditions, Water Res., 2022, 219, 118525. 118
  109. J. E. Grebel, S. K. Mohanty, A. A. Torkelson, A. B. Boehm, C. P. Higgins, R. M. Maxwell, K. L. Nelson and D. L. Sedlak, Engineered infiltration systems for urban stormwater reclamation, Environ. Eng. Sci., 2013, 30, 437-454.
  110. T. K. Stevik, K. Aa, G. Ausland and J. F. Hanssen, Retention and removal of pathogenic bacteria in wastewater percolating through porous media: A review, Water Res., 2004, 38, 1355-1367.
  111. A. B. Boehm, C. D. Bell, N. J. M. Fitzgerald, E. Gallo, C. P. Higgins, T. S. Hogue, R. G. Luthy, A. C. Portmann, B. A. Ulrich and J. M. Wolfand, Biochar-augmented biofilters to improve pollutant removal from stormwater-can they Environmental Science: Water Research & Technology Critical review improve receiving water quality?, J. Environ. Sci., 2020, 6, 1520-1537.
  112. B. K. Biswal, K. Vijayaraghavan, D. L. Tsen-Tieng and R. Balasubramanian, Biochar-based bioretention systems for removal of chemical and microbial pollutants from stormwater: A critical review, J. Hazard. Mater., 2022, 422, 126886.
  113. S. K. Mohanty, K. B. Cantrell, K. L. Nelson and A. B. Boehm, Efficacy of biochar to remove Escherichia coli from stormwater under steady and intermittent flow, Water Res., 2014, 61, 288-296.
  114. A. R. M. N. Afrooz and A. B. Boehm, Escherichia coli removal in biochar-modified biofilters: Effects of biofilm, PLoS One, 2016, 11, 1-17.
  115. A. R. M. N. Afrooz, A. K. Pitol, D. Kitt and A. B. Boehm, Role of microbial cell properties on bacterial pathogen and coliphage removal in biochar-modified stormwater biofilters, Environ. Sci.: Water Res. Technol., 2018, 4, 2160-2169.
  116. A. R. M. Nabiul Afrooz and A. B. Boehm, Effects of submerged zone, media aging, and antecedent dry period on the performance of biochar-amended biofilters in removing fecal indicators and nutrients from natural stormwater, Ecol. Eng., 2017, 102, 320-330.
  117. C. T. Vu and T. Wu, Engineered multifunctional sand for enhanced removal of stormwater runoff contaminants in fixed-bed column systems, Chemosphere, 2019, 224, 852-861. 127
  118. L. Zhang, E. A. Seagren, A. P. Davis and J. S. Karns, The Capture and Destruction of Escherichia coli from Simulated Urban Runoff Using Conventional Bioretention Media and Iron Oxide-coated Sand, Water Environ. Res., 2010, 82, 701-714. 128
  119. G. Prabhukumar, G. S. Bhupal and K. R. Pagilla, Laboratory Evaluation of Sorptive Filtration Media Mixtures for Targeted Pollutant Removals from Simulated Stormwater, Water Environ. Res., 2015, 87, 789-795.
  120. S. K. Mohanty, A. A. Torkelson, H. Dodd, K. L. Nelson and A. B. Boehm, Engineering solutions to improve the removal of fecal indicator bacteria by bioinfiltration systems during intermittent flow of stormwater, Environ. Sci. Technol., 2013, 47, 10791-10798.
  121. J. G. Lamori, J. Xue, A. T. Rachmadi, G. U. Lopez, M. Kitajima, C. P. Gerba, I. L. Pepper, J. P. Brooks and S. Sherchan, Removal of fecal indicator bacteria and antibiotic resistant genes in constructed wetlands, Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res., 2019, 26, 10188-10197.
  122. T. D. Hsu, W. J. Mitsch, J. F. Martin and J. Lee, Towards sustainable protection of public health : The role of an urban wetland as a frontline safeguard of pathogen and antibiotic resistance spread, Ecol. Eng., 2017, 108, 547-555. 132
  123. G. I. Chandrasena, T. Pham, E. G. Payne, A. Deletic and D. T. McCarthy, E. coli removal in laboratory scale stormwater biofilters: Influence of vegetation and submerged zone, J. Hydrol., 2014, 519, 814-822. 133
  124. C. P. Muerdter, C. K. Wong and G. H. LeFevre, Emerging investigator series: the role of vegetation in bioretention for stormwater treatment in the built environment: pollutant removal{,} hydrologic function{,} and ancillary benefits, Environ. Sci.: Water Res. Technol., 2018, 4, 592-612.
  125. W.-C. Hung, M. Rugh, M. Feraud, S. Avasarala, J. Kurylo, M. Gutierrez, K. Jimenez, N. Truong, P. A. Holden, S. B. Grant, H. Liu, R. F. Ambrose and J. A. Jay, Influence of soil characteristics and metal(loid)s on antibiotic resistance genes in green stormwater infrastructure in Southern California, J. Hazard. Mater., 2022, 424, 127469. 135
  126. E. Gullberg, S. Cao, O. G. Berg, C. Ilbäck, L. Sandegren, D. Hughes and D. I. Andersson, Selection of resistant bacteria at very low antibiotic concentrations, PLoS Pathog., 2011, 7, 1-9. 136
  127. M. Juhas, Horizontal gene transfer in human pathogens, Crit. Rev. Microbiol., 2015, 41, 101-108.
  128. A. J. Lopatkin, T. A. Sysoeva and L. You, Dissecting the effects of antibiotics on horizontal gene transfer: Analysis suggests a critical role of selection dynamics, BioEssays, 2016, 38, 1283. 138
  129. J. Bengtsson-Palme, E. Kristiansson and D. G. J. Larsson, Environmental factors influencing the development and spread of antibiotic resistance, FEMS Microbiol. Rev., 2018, 42, 68-80. 139
  130. C. Torres-Barceló, M. Kojadinovic, R. Moxon and R. C. Maclean, The SOS response increases bacterial fitness, but not evolvability, under a sublethal dose of antibiotic, Proc. R. Soc. B: Biol. Sci., 2015, 282, 20150885. 140
  131. C. Miller, L. E. Thomsen, C. Gaggero, R. Mosseri, H. Ingmer and S. N. Cohen, SOS response induction by β-lactams and bacterial defense against antibiotic lethality, Science, 2004, 305, 1629-1631. 141
  132. Z. Baharoglu and D. Mazel, Vibrio cholerae Triggers SOS and Mutagenesis in Response to a Wide Range of Antibiotics: a Route towards Multiresistance, Antimicrob. Agents Chemother., 2011, 55, 2438. 142
  133. D. Hughes and D. I. Andersson, Selection of resistance at lethal and non-lethal antibiotic concentrations, Curr. Opin. Microbiol., 2012, 15, 555-560.
  134. R. I. Aminov and R. I. Mackie, Evolution and ecology of antibiotic resistance genes, FEMS Microbiol. Lett., 2007, 271, 147-161.
  135. R. Zhao, J. Feng, J. Liu, W. Fu, X. Li and B. Li, Deciphering of microbial community and antibiotic resistance genes in Environmental Science: Water Research & Technology Critical review activated sludge reactors under high selective pressure of different antibiotics, Water Res., 2019, 151, 388-402.
  136. H. Wu, D. Shi, D. Yang, J. Yin, Z. Yang, J. Li, W. Yang and M. Jin, Putative environmental levels of levofloxacin facilitate the dissemination of antibiotic-resistant Escherichia coli via plasmid-mediated transformability, Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf., 2020, 195, 110461. 148
  137. Y. Qingxiang, W. Qiang and Z. Kaiyue, Effects of Antibiotics and Metal Ions Exposure on the Natural Transformation Frequency of an Antibiotic Resistant Plasmid, Fresenius Environ. Bull., 2017, 26, 5732-5736. 149
  138. Y. Zhang, A. Z. Gu, M. He, D. Li and J. Chen, Subinhibitory Concentrations of Disinfectants Promote the Horizontal Transfer of Multidrug Resistance Genes within and across Genera, Environ. Sci. Technol., 2017, 51, 570-580. 150
  139. D. Li, S. Zeng, M. He and A. Z. Gu, Water Disinfection Byproducts Induce Antibiotic Resistance-Role of Environmental Pollutants in Resistance Phenomena, Environ. Sci. Technol., 2016, 50, 3193-3201. 151
  140. J. Lu, Y. Wang, S. Zhang, P. Bond, Z. Yuan and J. Guo, Triclosan at environmental concentrations can enhance the spread of extracellular antibiotic resistance genes through transformation, Sci. Total Environ., 2020, 713, 136621. 152
  141. Y. Han, Z. C. Zhou, L. Zhu, Y. Y. Wei, W. Q. Feng, L. Xu, Y. Liu, Z. J. Lin, X. Y. Shuai, Z. J. Zhang and H. Chen, The impact and mechanism of quaternary ammonium compounds on the transmission of antibiotic resistance genes, Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res., 2019, 26, 28352-28360.
  142. R. I. Aminov and C. Knapp, Horizontal gene exchange in environmental microbiota, Front. Microbiol., 2011, 2, 1-19. 154
  143. Y. Kohyama and S. Suzuki, Conjugative Gene Transfer between Nourished and Starved Cells of Photobacterium damselae ssp. damselae and Escherichia coli, Microbes Environ., 2019, 34, 388-392. 155
  144. J. Moralez, K. Szenkiel, K. Hamilton, A. Pruden and A. J. Lopatkin, Quantitative analysis of horizontal gene transfer in complex systems, Curr. Opin. Microbiol., 2021, 62, 103-109. Environmental Science: Water Research & Technology Critical

Cited by

Sorted by citations

Authors
O'Malley, K., McDonald, W., & McNamara, P.
Affiliations
Department of Civil, Construction and Environmental Engineering, Marquette University, 1637 W Wisconsin Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53233, USA
ORCID
Venue
Environmental Science: Water Research & Technology
Publisher
Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC)
Published
2023
Volume
9
Issue
9
Pages
2188-2212
ISSN
  • 2053-1400
  • 2053-1419
DOI
10.1039/d3ew00356f
Cited by
24
References
5
Language
en
Licence
creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/ (vor, 214 d)
Funders
National Science Foundation (2041851)

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review