Photon Counting Probabilities in Quantum Optics

Abstract

We reconsider various approaches to the quantum theory of photodetection from the point of view of the quantum theory of measurement, and show that important differences between them depend upon the manner in which they take into account the modification of the field distribution produced by the presence of the detector. We show that the Mandel photon counting formula may lead to unphysical results, such as negative probabilities, in some situations just because this modification is not incorporated into the model. We also show that the recently developed quantum theory of continuous measurements provides a completely satisfactory framework for discussing photon counting experiments. As an illustration, an exact derivation of the photon statistics of a single-mode free field is presented, and some of the results are shown to be identical to those derived earlier by Mollow and others. We also indicate how our approach can be extended to discuss the photon statistics of fields in interaction with sources and reservoirs.