Seed Size and Phylogeny in Six Temperate Floras: Constraints, Niche Conservatism, and Adaptation

Abstract

Seed size is correlated with a number of other plant attributes, and such correlations are commonly interpreted as adaptations to different life histories. However, seed size is also strongly related to species phylogeny. In the current comparative literature, correlations between trait variation and taxonomic membership are often interpreted as evidence for phylogenetic constraints, and such phylogenetic explanations of variation are presented as alternatives to adaptive explanations. However, phylogenetic patterns of trait variation should not be discussed exclusively in terms of constraints. Neither should phylogenetic and adaptive explanations for variation be automatically presented as alternatives. Another explanation for similarity among related taxa is phylogenetic niche conservatism (PNC). This process is well known to exist-indeed, it is an inevitable consequence of evolution by natural selection-and is explicitly adaptive. Under PNC, radiation within a lineage is shaped by phylogeny, by the env...