Phenotypic Plasticity for Growth in the Common Snapping Turtle: Effects of Incubation Temperature, Clutch, and Their Interaction

Abstract

We examined a critical component of the Charnov-Bull hypothesis of temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD) by determining the reaction norms of hatchling growth to embryonic incubation temperature in the common snapping turtle, Chelydra serpentina Hormone manipulations of eggs produced females at male temperatures and vice versa, which thereby permitted same-sex comparisons of hatchling growth across a range of incubation temperatures. In this way, the normally confounded effects of incubation temperature and sex were dissociated experimentally. The resultant hatchlings, including controls and experimentals, exhibited normal gonadal structure and sex steroid profiles. The subsequent growth of hatchlings monitored for 6 mo was strongly affected by embryonic incubation temperature but not by sex As predicted, growth was enhanced at incubation temperatures that produced males. Clutch effects and interaction effects (clutch by incubation temperature) on growth were significant. In addition, there was a positive genetic covariance among incubation temperatures, but incubation temperature effects varied among clutches. The variation in growth plasticity among clutches was consistent with Charnov-Bull predictions. In this TSD species, incubation temperature is likely to have differential fitness effects on the sexes mediated via differences in growth.