Batch effect removal methods for microarray gene expression data integration: a survey

Lazar, C., Meganck, S., Taminau, J., Steenhoff, D., Coletta, A., Molter, C., Weiss-Solis, D. Y., Duque, R. +2 more·2013·Briefings in Bioinformatics
DOI 10.1093/bib/bbs037

Cited by (334)

Items 201–300 of 334

  1. Gene co-expression modules integrated with immunoscore predicts survival of non-small cell lung cancer
    Xuetao Li, Jia‐Tao Zhang, Hong‐Hong Yan, Jian Su, Mei-Ling Cheng, Qihui Sun, Wen‐Zhao Zhong, Yi-Long Lung Cancer Wu, Xu‐Chao Zhang, Jun Hou · 2020 · Cancer Treatment and Research Communications
  2. A qualitative transcriptional signature for predicting the biochemical recurrence risk of prostate cancer patients after radical prostatectomy
    Xiang Li, Haiyan Huang, Jiahui Zhang, Fengle Jiang, Yating Guo, Yidan Shi, Zheng Guo, Lu Ao · 2020 · The Prostate
  3. Deciphering common temporal transcriptional response during powdery mildew disease in plants using meta-analysis
    Avinash Sethi, Murali Mohan Sharaff, Ranabir Sahu · 2021 · Plant Gene
  4. MAGE: An Open-Source Tool for Meta-Analysis of Gene Expression Studies
    Ioannis Tamposis, Γεώργιος Μανιός, Theodosia Charitou, Konstantina E. Vennou, Panagiota I. Kontou, Pantelis G. Bagos · 2022 · Biology
  5. Methodology to identify a gene expression signature by merging microarray datasets
    Olga Fajarda, João Rafael Almeida, Sara Duarte-Pereira, Raquel Monteiro Silva, José Luís Oliveira · 2023 · Computers in Biology and Medicine
  6. Development and Validation of a 15-gene Expression Signature with Superior Prognostic Ability in Stage II Colorectal Cancer
    Matjaž Rokavec, Elif Özcan, Jens H. L. Neumann, Heiko Hermeking · 2023 · Cancer Research Communications
  7. A 41-Gene Pair Signature for Predicting the Pathological Response of Locally Advanced Rectal Cancer to Neoadjuvant Chemoradiation
    Zhengfa Xue, Shuxin Yang, Yun Luo, Hao Cai, Ming He, Youping Ding, Lei Lei, Wei Peng, Guini Hong, You Guo · 2021 · Frontiers in Medicine
  8. msmsEDA & msmsTests: Label-Free Differential Expression by Spectral Counts
    Josep Gregori, Álex Sánchez‐Pla, Josep Villanueva · 2021 · Methods in molecular biology
  9. Discriminating cancer-related and cancer-unrelated chemoradiation-response genes for locally advanced rectal cancers
    You Guo, Jun Cheng, Lu Ao, Xiangyü Li, Qingzhou Guan, Juan Zhang, Haidan Yan, Hao Cai, Qiao Gao, Weizhong Jiang et al. · 2016 · Scientific Reports
  10. Long non-coding RNA transcriptome of uncharacterized samples can be accurately imputed using protein-coding genes
    Aritro Nath, Paul Geeleher, R. Stephanie Huang · 2018 · Briefings in Bioinformatics
  11. The significance of molecular heterogeneity in breast cancer batch correction and dataset integration
    Nicholas Moir, Dominic Pearce, Simon P. Langdon, T. Ian Simpson · 2025 · Breast Cancer Research
  12. Causal network analysis of omics data using prior knowledge databases
    G. Е. Svinin, Enrico Glaab · 2025 · Briefings in Bioinformatics
  13. Integrative approaches for data analysis in systems biology: Current advances
    Alina Frolova, Maria Obolenska · 2016 · IEEE International Young Scientists Forum on Applied Physics and Engineering (YSF)
  14. COVID-19 Biomarkers Recognition & Classification Using Intelligent Systems
    Javier Bajo-Morales, Juan Carlos Prieto-Prieto, Luis Javier Herrera, Ignacio Rojas, Daniel Castillo-Secilla · 2022 · Current Bioinformatics
  15. Circulating Metabolomic and Lipidomic Signatures Identify a Type 2 Diabetes Risk Profile in Low-Birth-Weight Men with Non-Alcoholic Fatty Liver Disease
    Line Ohrt Elingaard-Larsen, Sofie Olund Villumsen, Louise Justesen, Anne Cathrine B. Thuesen, Min Gyu Kim, Mina Ali, Else Rubæk Danielsen, Cristina Legido‐Quigley, Gerrit van Hall, Torben F. Hansen et al. · 2023 · Nutrients
  16. Analysis Considerations for Utilizing RNA-Seq to Characterize the Brain Transcriptome
    CHRISTINA L. ZHENG, Sunita Kawane, Daniel Bottomly, Beth Wilmot · 2014 · International review of neurobiology
  17. Comparison of location-scale and matrix factorization batch effect removal methods on gene expression datasets
    Emilie Renard, Pierre-Antoine Absil · 2017 · IEEE International Conference on Bioinformatics and Biomedicine (BIBM)
  18. Hierarchical clustering of DNA k-mer counts in RNA-seq fastq files reveals batch effects
    Wolfgang Kaisers, Holger R. Schwender, Heiner Schaal · 2014 · arXiv (Cornell University)
  19. Identification of key genes affecting intramuscular fat deposition in pigs using machine learning models
    Yumei Shi, Xini Wang, Shaokang Chen, Yanhui Zhao, Yan Wang, Xihui Sheng, Xiaolong Qi, Lei Zhou, Yu Feng, Jianfeng Liu et al. · 2025 · Frontiers in Genetics
  20. Composite quantile regression approach to batch effect correction in microbiome data
    Ji Won Park, Taesung Park · 2025 · Frontiers in Microbiology
  21. Systematic comparison of differential expression networks in MTB mono-, HIV mono- and MTB/HIV co-infections for drug repurposing
    Yao Jiang, Jiaxuan Zhang, Rong Liu · 2022 · PLoS Computational Biology
  22. Integration of estimated regional gene expression with neuroimaging and clinical phenotypes at biobank scale
    Nhung Hoang, Neda Sardaripour, Grace D. Ramey, Kurt Schilling, Emily Liao, Yi-Ting Chen, Jee Hyun Park, Xavier Bledsoe, Bennett A. Landman, Eric R. Gamazon et al. · 2024 · PLoS Biology
  23. Identification of shared important genes associated with ferroptosis across different etiologies of acute lung injury
    Jing Li, Yuan‐Han Yang, Zhengjun Cui · 2025 · Scientific Reports
  24. A Cancer-Specific Qualitative Method for Estimating the Proportion of Tumor-Infiltrating Immune Cells
    Huiting Xiao, Jiashuai Zhang, Kai Wang, Kai Song, Hailong Zheng, Jing Yang, Keru Li, Rongqiang Yuan, Wenyuan Zhao, Yang Hui · 2021 · Frontiers in Immunology
  25. Predicting COVID-19 Severity Integrating RNA-Seq Data Using Machine Learning Techniques
    Javier Bajo-Morales, Daniel Castillo-Secilla, Luis Javier Herrera, Octavio Caba, Jose Carlos Prados, Ignacio Rojas · 2022 · Current Bioinformatics
  26. Reliability of microarray analysis for studying periodontitis: low consistency in 2 periodontitis cohort data sets from different platforms and an integrative meta-analysis
    Yoon-Seon Jeon, Manu Shivakumar, Dokyoon Kim, Chang‐Sung Kim, Jung‐Seok Lee · 2020 · Journal of Periodontal & Implant Science
  27. Mining Protein Expression Databases Using Network Meta-Analysis
    Christine Winter, Klaus Jung · 2021 · Methods in molecular biology
  28. AMDBNorm: an approach based on distribution adjustment to eliminate batch effects of gene expression data
    Xu Zhang, Zhiqiang Ye, Jing Chen, Feng Qiao · 2021 · Briefings in Bioinformatics
  29. An interpretable semi-supervised classifier using two different strategies for amended self-labeling
    Isel Grau, Sengupta, Dipankar, Maria M. Garcia Lorenzo, Ann Nowé · 2020 · arXiv (Cornell University)
  30. Be Like Water: Robustness to Extraneous Variables Via Adaptive Feature Normalization
    Aakash Kaku, Sreyas Mohan, Avinash Parnandi, Heidi M. Schambra, Carlos Fernandez‐Granda · 2020 · arXiv (Cornell University)
  31. Merging versus Ensembling in Multi-Study Prediction: Theoretical Insight from Random Effects
    Zoe Guan, Giovanni Parmigiani, Prasad Patil · 2019 · arXiv (Cornell University)
  32. A comparative analysis of CXCR4 gene expression from published datasets and cell surface protein levels in breast and prostate cancer models
    Veli Kaan Aydın, Yasemin Adalı, Aylin Köseler · 2025 · Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications
  33. Exploring Gene Expression Patterns in Alzheimer’s Disease Using a Human Microarray Data Meta-Analysis
    Eleni Dermitzaki, Vasileios L. Zogopoulos, Apostolos Malatras, Vasiliki Georgopoulou, Petrina-Marina Aslanoglou, Adamantia Teta, Maria Rea Kalligianni, Christos Karoussiotis, Vassiliki A. Iconomidou, Ioannis Sotiropoulos et al. · 2026 · Biology
  34. BatMan: Mitigating Batch Effects Via Stratification for Survival Outcome Prediction
    Ai Ni, Mengling Liu, Li‐Xuan Qin · 2023 · JCO Clinical Cancer Informatics
  35. Decoding the regulatory network of microRNAs, lncRNAs, and transcription factors in relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis: A case-control in silico study
    Maria Lui, Simone D’Angiolini, Emanuela Mazzon, Marco Calabrò · 2025 · Heliyon
  36. Row versus column correlations: avoiding the ecological fallacy in RNA/protein expression studies
    Jonathon J. O’Brien, Harsha P. Gunawardena, Bahjat F. Qaqish · 2017 · Briefings in Bioinformatics
  37. Biostatistics and Bioinformatics in Clinical Trials
    Donald A. Berry, Kevin R. Coombes · 2014 · Elsevier eBooks
  38. Study of Meta-analysis Strategies for Network Inference Using Information-Theoretic Approaches
    Ngoc C. Pham, Benjamin Haibe‐Kains, Pau Bellot, Gianluca Bontempi, Patrick E. Meyer · 2016 · International Workshop on Database and Expert Systems Applications (DEXA)
  39. Study of Meta-analysis strategies for network inference using information-theoretic approaches
    Ngoc C. Pham, Benjamin Haibe‐Kains, Pau Bellot, Gianluca Bontempi, Patrick E. Meyer · 2017 · BioData Mining
  40. Detecting and Correcting Batch Effects in High-Throughput Genomic Experiments
    Sarah E. Reese · 2013 · VCU Scholars Compass (Virginia Commonwealth University)
  41. Aligning Sets of Temporal Signals with Riemannian Geometry and Koopman Operator
    Ohad Rahamim, Ronen Talmon · 2021 · IEEE International Conference on Acoustics Speech and Signal Processing
  42. Heterogeneous Gene Expression Cross-Evaluation of Robust Biomarkers Using Machine Learning Techniques Applied to Lung Cancer
    Javier Bajo-Morales, Juan Manuel Gálvez, Juan Carlos Prieto-Prieto, Luis Javier Herrera, Ignacio Rojas, Daniel Castillo-Secilla · 2021 · Current Bioinformatics
  43. Biostatistics and Bioinformatics in Clinical Trials
    Brian Paul Hobbs, Donald A. Berry, Kevin R. Coombes · 2020 · Elsevier eBooks
  44. Comparing alternative pipelines for cross-platform microarray gene expression data integration with RNA-seq data in breast cancer
    Alina Frolova, Vladyslav Bondarenko, Maria Obolenska · 2016 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  45. Select-ProtoNet: Learning to Select for Few-Shot Disease Subtype Prediction
    Ziyi Yang, Jun Shu, Yong Qi Liang, Deyu Meng, Zongben Xu · 2020 · arXiv (Cornell University)
  46. Modelling single-stress omics integration with HIVE enables the identification of responding signatures to multifactorial stress combinations in plants
    Giulia Calia, Sophia Marguerit, Ana Paula Zotta Mota, Manon Vidal, Hannes Schuler, Ana Cristina Miranda Brasileiro, Patrí­cia Messenberg Guimarães, Silvia Bottini · 2024 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  47. Prioritization of differentially expressed genes through integrating public expression data
    W. Xu, Sen Li, Zhenzuo Zhang, Jieyun Hu, Y. Zhao · 2019 · Animal Genetics
  48. Rank Matrix Approach for Endometriosis: Integrating Data and Constructing Diagnostic Models
    Ranze Xie, Deqing Hong, Jiaqi Yuan, Peng Xu, Wenbin Liu, Zheng Ye · 2024 · Current Bioinformatics
  49. Model-free latent confounder-adjusted feature selection with FDR control
    Jian Ru Xiao, Shaoting Li, Jun Chen, Wensheng Zhu · 2024 · Computational Statistics & Data Analysis
  50. Development and validation of a predictive model for adherent perirenal fat based on CT radiomics and deep learning
    Xiaobo Ding, Hongcheng Liu, Xu Li, Dayong Jin, Mingshuang Lu, Suyan Tian, Mingyang Li, Li Liu, Huimao Zhang, Erick M. Remer et al. · 2025 · World Journal of Urology
  51. Computational Identification of Differentially Expressed Genes in Prostate Cancer Using Integrated Public Datasets
    V. K. Aydin · 2026 · Russian Journal of Genetics
  52. Quantitative benchmarking of batch effects correction methods for single-cell metabolomics
    Fengzhu Wu, Xuena Hao, Anqi Chen, Luhong Wen · 2026 · Microchemical Journal
  53. Cancer After Metastasis: The Second Transformation
    Ying Xu, Juan Cui, David Puett · 2014 · Springer eBooks
  54. Multi-platform microarray integration research
    Ronghui Wu, Lei Lu · 2017 · AIP conference proceedings
  55. DynSig: Modelling Dynamic Signaling Alterations along Gene Pathways for Identifying Differential Pathways
    Ming Shi, Yanwen Chong, Weiming Shen, Xin-Ping Xie, Hongqiang Wang · 2018 · Genes
  56. Computational identification of key genes and regulatory miRNAs responsible for differential regulation of host-pathogen response during early and late blight diseases in tomato
    Shivalika Pathania, Manoj Kumar · 2022 · Plant Stress
  57. Plant Metabolomics: The Great Potential of Plant Metabolomics in Big Data Biology
    Miyako Kusano, Atsushi Fukushima · 2022 · CABI eBooks
  58. Comparative Study of Transcriptome Profile and Immune-related Genes Network Associated with Intestinal Epithelial Tissue based on Microarray Data in Poultry with Coccidiosis
    Reza Seyed Sharifi, Reza Khalkhali-Evrigh, Nemat Hedayat · 2022 · Research on Animal Production
  59. Comparison of gene expression profiles in healthy individuals and people with lung cancer using the meta-analysis method
    Dongyun Huang, Chen Zhen, Guan Wang, Wenjing Xu · 2023 · Cellular and Molecular Biology
  60. Utilizing Neurons to Interrogate Cancer: Integrative Analysis of Cancer Omics Data With Deep Learning Models
    Raid Halawani, Michael Büchert, Yi‐Ping Phoebe Chen · 2024 · IEEE Reviews in Biomedical Engineering
  61. СONSECUTIVE INTEGRATION OF AVAILABLE MICROARRAY DATA FOR ANALYSIS OF DIFFERENTIAL GENE EXPRESSION IN HUMAN PLACENTA
    Oleksandr Lykhenko · 2021 · Biotechnologia Acta
  62. Comprehensive Workflow for Integrative Transcriptomics Meta-Analysis
    Ali Nehme, Frédéric Mazurier, Kazem Zibara · 2018 · Elsevier eBooks
  63. Blind normalization of public high-throughput databases
    Sebastian Ohse, Melanie Boerries, Hauke S. Busch · 2019 · PeerJ Computer Science
  64. A New Approach to Batch Effect Removal Based on Distribution Matching in Latent Space
    Huaqing Li, Haluk Dogan, Juan Cui · 2019 · IEEE International Conference on Bioinformatics and Biomedicine (BIBM)
  65. Deep learning identifies erroneous microarray-based, gene-level conclusions in literature
    Yanan Qin, Daiyao Yi, Xianghao Chen, Yuanfang Guan · 2021 · NAR Genomics and Bioinformatics
  66. Deep learning based multi-batch calibration for classification in various omics
    Qian Wang, Jingyang Niu, Wei Hong Xu, Dongming Wei, Kun Qian · 2021 · Research Square
  67. Deep Learning Uncovers Distinct Behaviour of Rice Network to Pathogens Response
    Ravi Kumar, Abhishek Khatri, Vishal Acharya · 2022 · SSRN Electronic Journal
  68. A Benchmark of Pre-processing Effect on Single Cell RNA Sequencing Integration Methods
    Ali Anaissi, Seid Miad Zandavi, Basem Suleiman, Widad Alyassine, Ali Braytee, Fatemeh Vafaee · 2022 · Research Square
  69. The ratio of interacting miRNAs’ expressions is a robust biomarker for disease classification in multi-center data
    Yonghao Zhang, Cuidie Ma, Rui Ding, Han Chen, Lida Xu, Changyuan Yu · 2023 · medRxiv
  70. Detecting Dysregulated Processes and Pathways
    Daniel Stöckel, Hans‐Peter Lenhof · 2014 · Wiley eBooks
  71. An Improved Ratio-Based (IRB) Batch Effects Removal Algorithm for Cancer Data in a Co-Analysis Framework
    Shuchu Ham, Hong Qin, Dantong Yu · 2014 · IEEE International Conference on Bioinformatics and Bioengineering (BIBE)
  72. Systems biology of lung diseases: a multi-perspective view from host and pathogen
    Shuyi Ma · 2015 · Illinois Digital Environment for Access to Learning and Scholarship (University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign)
  73. Screening for the optimal gene and functional gene sets related to breast cancer using differential co-expression and differential expression analysis
    Lei Wang, Hong Ma, Lixia Zhu, Liping Ma, Lanting Cao, Hui Wei, Jumei Xu · 2016 · Cancer Biomarkers
  74. Analyzing and Benchmarking Genomic Preprocessing and Batch Effect Removal Methods in Big Data Infrastructure
    Quentin De Clerck · 2014
  75. Single-gene prognostic signatures for advanced stage serous ovarian cancer based on 1257 patient samples
    Fan Zhang, Kai Ge Yang, Kui Deng, Yuanyuan Zhang, Weiwei Zhao, Huan Xu, Zhiwei Rong, Kang Li · 2018 · Molecular Omics
  76. A computational approach to study the transcriptional response of enterocytes exposed to luminal factors
    Prashanna Balaji Venkatasubramanian · 2018
  77. A Reliable Method to Remove Batch Effects Maintaining Group Differences in Lymphoma Methylation Case Study
    Giulia Pontali, Luciano Cascione, Alberto J. Arribas, Andrea Rinaldi, Francesco Bertoni, Rosalba Giugno · 2019 · Lecture notes in computer science
  78. Integration Strategies of Cross-Platform Microarray Data Sets in Multiclass Classification Problem
    Sebastian Student, Alicja Płuciennik, Krzysztof Łakomiec, Agata Wilk, Wojciech Bensz, Krzysztof Fujarewicz · 2019 · Lecture notes in computer science
  79. Integrative Data Analysis of Microarray and RNA-seq
    Qi Wang · 2018 · NDSU Repository (North Dakota State University)
  80. Precision Sub-phenotyping of Histologically Stable Kidney Transplants by a Composite Molecular and Cellular Instability Score
    Dmitry Rychkov, S. Sur, Marina Sirota, Minnie Sarwal · 2019 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  81. Analysis of variance when both input and output sets are high-dimensional
    Gustavo de los Campos, Torsten Pook, Agustín González-Reymúndez, Henner Simianer, George I. Mias, Ana Ines Vazquez · 2020 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  82. Resolving the molecular complexity of brain tumors through machine learning approaches for precision medicine
    Edwin Sandanaraj · 2019
  83. Using Gene-level to Generalize Transcript-level Classification Performance on Multiple Colorectal Cancer Microarray Studies
    Hendrick Gao-Min Lim, Yuan-Chii Gladys Lee · 2020 · International Conference on Bioscience, Biochemistry and Bioinformatics (ICBBB)
  84. Statistical and Machine Learning Methods for Clinical Risk Prediction
    Zoe Guan · 2020 · Digital Access to Scholarship at Harvard (DASH) (Harvard University)
  85. Conceptualizing experimental controls using the potential outcomes framework
    Kristen B. Hunter, Kristen Koenig, Marie‐Abèle Bind · 2021 · arXiv (Cornell University)
  86. Distortion Discovery: A Framework to Model, Spot and Explain Tumor Heterogeneity and Mitigate its Negative Impact on Cancer Risk Assessment
    Dalia Elmansy · 2021 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  87. COVID-19 Biomarkers Detection Using ‘KnowSeq’ R Package
    Javier Bajo-Morales, Daniel Castillo-Secilla, Luis Javier Herrera, Ignacio Rojas · 2021 · Lecture notes in computer science
  88. A Novel Unfolded Protein Response (UPR) Related 6 Genes Signature for Prognosis of Human Gastric Cancer
    XuYang Jia, Runzhi Huang, Shuyuan Xian, Yu Song, Hao Pan, Donglei Zhou · 2020
  89. Gene Expression Analysis of Innate Immune Compromised Mice Reveals Secondary Target Genes in Response to Intracortical Microelectrode Implantation
    Sydney Song, Hillary W. Bedell, Brianna Regan, Evon S. Ereifej, Ricky Chan, Jeffrey R. Capadona · 2021 · SSRN Electronic Journal
  90. Peer Review #3 of "A reproducible approach to high-throughput biological data acquisition and integration (v0.1)"
    2015 · PeerJ
  91. Peer Review #3 of "A reproducible approach to high-throughput biological data acquisition and integration (v0.2)"
    2015 · PeerJ
  92. Peer Review #1 of "A reproducible approach to high-throughput biological data acquisition and integration (v0.1)"
    2015 · PeerJ
  93. Peer Review #2 of "A reproducible approach to high-throughput biological data acquisition and integration (v0.1)"
    2015 · PeerJ
  94. Peer Review #1 of "A reproducible approach to high-throughput biological data acquisition and integration (v0.2)"
    2015 · PeerJ
  95. Establishing a resource for genetic, epidemiological, and biomarker studies: The important role of twin registers
    Veronika V. Odintsova, Gonneke A. H. M. Willemsen, Conor V. Dolan, Jouke‐Jan Hottenga, Nicholas G. Martin, P. Eline Slagboom, Juan Ramón Ordoñana, Dorret Irene Boomsma · 2022 · Elsevier eBooks
  96. RankDMG: a differentially methylated gene analysis method for three special scenarios
    Qi Fan, Zheng LinYong, Haifeng Chen, Jun He, Fenglong Yang, Xiaopei Shen, Haidan Yan · 2023 · Research Square
  97. Data from Development and Validation of a 15-gene Expression Signature with Superior Prognostic Ability in Stage II Colorectal Cancer
    Matjaž Rokavec, Elif Özcan, Jens H. L. Neumann, Heiko Hermeking · 2023
  98. bapred: Batch Effect Removal and Addon Normalization (in Phenotype Prediction using Gene Data)
    Roman Hornung, David Causeur · 2015
  99. Bioinformatics for Multi-Omics Data Integration
    Rajveer Singh Shekhawat, Pragya Kashyap, Asish Kumar Swain, Vedikaa Dhiman, Jyoti Sharma, Abhishek Kumar, Pankaj Yadav · 2024 · Elsevier eBooks
  100. Benefits and challenges of OMICS data integration at the pathway level
    Nicolas M. Borisov, Maxim Sorokin · 2024 · Elsevier eBooks