Community Preferences for the Allocation of Solid Organs for Transplantation: A Systematic Review
The DOI matches its Crossref record; 42 of the 43 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Organs for transplantation are a scarce community resource but community preferences and how they are incorporated into allocation policies are unclear. This systematic review aimed to ascertain community preferences for organ allocation and the principles underpinning these preferences. METHODS: Medline, Embase, PsycINFO, EconLit, and gray literature databases were searched. Quantitative data were extracted, and a qualitative textual synthesis of the results and conclusions reported in each included study was performed. RESULTS: Fifteen studies involving more than 5563 respondents were included. Seven themes describing community preferences for organ allocation were identified: (1) maximum benefit, to achieve maximum health gain in recipient survival and quality of life; (2) social valuation, to base preferences on societal gain; (3) moral deservingness, to consider the "worthiness" of recipients based on their social standing and lifestyle decisions; (4) prejudice, to make a judgement based on personal ideologic viewpoints; (5) "fair innings," to provide an organ preferentially to the younger recipient giving opportunity for a "normal" life span and to those waiting for a first organ rather than a retransplant; (6) "first come, first served," to allocate the organ to recipients wait-listed the longest; and (7) medical urgency, to allocate based on illness severity and saving life. CONCLUSIONS: Community preferences for organ allocation hinge on a complex balance of efficiency, social valuation, morality, fairness, and equity principles. Being a community-held resource, effective ways to identify and incorporate community preferences into allocation algorithms for solid organ transplantation are warranted.
Overview
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
Claims other papers make about this one
Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?
In the citing paper
“the larger community has expressed preference to allocate this limited resource to younger patients first.(10)”
From Consensus document for the selection of lung transplant candidates: An update from the International Society for Heart and Lung Transplantation. (2021) · cites this paper as [10]
Citations
Cites
Lincoln, Y. S., Guba, E. G., & Pilotta, J. J. (1985) · International Journal of Intercultural Relations · doi:10.1016/0147-1767(85)90062-8 · Cited by 45,787
Tong, A., Sainsbury, P., & Craig, J. (2007) · International Journal for Quality in Health Care · doi:10.1093/intqhc/mzm042 · Cited by 42,509
Self-citationQualitative Research: Consensus methods for medical and health services research
Jones, J., & Hunter, D. (1995) · BMJ · doi:10.1136/bmj.311.7001.376 · Cited by 3,471 · cited 1×
“A consensus development approach in eliciting community preferences, such as the nominal group technique, may be used (46).”
MethodPrinciples for allocation of scarce medical interventions
Persad, G., Wertheimer, A., & Emanuel, E. J. (2009) · The Lancet · doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(09)60137-9 · Cited by 929 · cited 2×
“The authors recommend “a complete lives system,” which combined the principles of prioritizing younger people, considering prognosis, saving the most lives, and “promoting and rewarding social usefulness” (39) into a framework that is consistent with the widely held values of prioritizing those worst off, maximizing b…”
BackgroundResultIntergenerational Equity: An Exploration of the ‘Fair Innings’ Argument
Williams, A. (1997) · Health Economics · doi:10.1002/(sici)1099-1050(199703)6:2<117::aid-hec256>3.0.co;2-b · Cited by 804
McColl, E., Jacoby, A., Thomas, L., Soutter, J., Bamford, C., Steen, N., Thomas, R., Harvey, E., Garratt, A., & Bond, J. (2001) · Health Technology Assessment · doi:10.3310/hta5310 · Cited by 788 · cited 1×
“There are no empiric data on the relationship between quality of reporting and the quality of the methods in qualitative and questionnaire research (22, 23).”
BackgroundImpact of presumed consent for organ donation on donation rates: a systematic review
Rithalia, A., McDaid, C., Suekarran, S., Myers, L., & Sowden, A. (2009) · BMJ · doi:10.1136/bmj.a3162 · Cited by 340 · cited 4×
“We identified seven main themes underlying community preferences for organ allocation from our synthesis of the results and authors’ interpretations in each primary study: (1) maximum benefit, to achieve maximum health gain in terms of patient survival and quality of life; (2) social valuation, to base preferences on…”
BackgroundInfluentialAdministering, analysing, and reporting your questionnaire
Boynton, P. M. (2004) · BMJ · doi:10.1136/bmj.328.7452.1372 · Cited by 283
Assessing priorities for allocation of donor liver grafts: survey of public and clinicians
Neuberger, J., Adams, D., MacMaster, P., Maidment, A., & Speed, M. (1998) · BMJ · doi:10.1136/bmj.317.7152.172 · Cited by 261 · cited 5×
“Some studies have suggested that public perspectives regarding organ allocation are different to those of transplant health professionals (18, 19), and currently, there are few data on community preferences for deceased organ allocation.”
BackgroundInfluentialAxelrod, D. A., Guidinger, M. K., Finlayson, S., Schaubel, D. E., Goodman, D. C., Chobanian, M., & Merion, R. M. (2008) · JAMA · doi:10.1001/jama.2007.50 · Cited by 257 · cited 1×
“based on human leukocyte antigen typing, age, time on waiting list, clinical prognosis, life expectancy, and quality of life (10, 11).”
MethodRationing Failure: The Ethical Lessons of the Retransplantation of Scarce Vital Organs
Ubel, P. A. (1993) · JAMA · doi:10.1001/jama.270.20.2469 · Cited by 174
Public preferences for the allocation of donor liver grafts for transplantation
Ratcliffe, J. (2000) · Health Economics · doi:10.1002/(sici)1099-1050(200003)9:2<137::aid-hec489>3.0.co;2-1 · Cited by 155 · cited 5×
“Ratcliffe (27) Social conjoint analysis questionnaire survey, eight choices Liver United Kingdom 303/800 Prognosis”
BackgroundInfluentialDistributing scarce livers: The moral reasoning of the general public
Ubel, P. A., & Loewenstein, G. F. (1996) · Social Science & Medicine · doi:10.1016/0277-9536(95)00216-2 · Cited by 146 · cited 6×
“Characteristics of included studies Study references Study design Transplant Country n Criteria assessed or identified by authors Browning and Thomas (24) Questionnaire (ranking exercise of case scenario, 16 choices) Organ Australia 238 Waiting time Prognosis Age With/without dependents Chan et al. (25) Face to face,…”
BackgroundInfluentialCitizens at the centreDeliberative participation in healthcare decisions
Davies, C., Wetherell, M., & Barnett, E. (2006) · Policy Press eBooks · doi:10.1332/policypress/9781861348029.001.0001 · Cited by 107
Whose health service is it anyway? Community values in healthcare
MOONEY, G. H., & Blackwell, S. H. (2004) · The Medical Journal of Australia · doi:10.5694/j.1326-5377.2004.tb05804.x · Cited by 90
Allocation of transplantable organs: Do people want to punish patients for causing their illness?
Ubel, P. A., Jepson, C., Baron, J., Mohr, T., McMorrow, S., & Asch, D. A. (2001) · Liver Transplantation · doi:10.1053/jlts.2001.25361 · Cited by 80
Giving citizens a voice in healthcare policy in Canada
Maxwell, J., Rosell, S., & Forest, P.-G. (2003) · BMJ · doi:10.1136/bmj.326.7397.1031 · Cited by 80
Renal Transplantation in the United Kingdom for Patients From Ethnic Minorities
Rudge, C. J., Johnson, R., Fuggle, S. V., & Forsythe, J. L. R. (2007) · Transplantation · doi:10.1097/01.tp.0000259934.06233.ba · Cited by 72 · cited 1×
“However, allocation organizations recognize that selection based on these largely clinical criteria disadvantages certain patient groups: older patients, those with co morbidities and often patients from ethnic minorities (12).”
BackgroundThe Challenge of Doing What Is Right in Renal Transplantation: Balancing Equity and Utility
Courtney, A. E., & Maxwell, A. P. (2008) · Nephron Clinical Practice · doi:10.1159/000180121 · Cited by 59 · cited 1×
“There is still ongoing debate about how to maintain equity and achieve allocation outcomes that are acceptable to the medical community and wider society more generally (38).”
BackgroundThe efficacy and equity of retransplantation: an experimental survey of public attitudes
Ubel, P. A., & Loewenstein, G. F. (1995) · Health Policy · doi:10.1016/0168-8510(95)00714-4 · Cited by 58 · cited 4×
“We identified seven main themes underlying community preferences for organ allocation from our synthesis of the results and authors’ interpretations in each primary study: (1) maximum benefit, to achieve maximum health gain in terms of patient survival and quality of life; (2) social valuation, to base preferences on…”
BackgroundInfluentialPublic Perceptions of the Importance of Prognosis in Allocating Transplantable Livers to Children
Ubel, P. A., & Loewenstein, G. F. (1996) · Medical Decision Making · doi:10.1177/0272989x9601600307 · Cited by 57 · cited 5×
“ways that help those in greatest need such as patients with severe illness, rather than simply attempt to maximize overall utility” (34).”
BackgroundInfluentialCommunity values and preferences in transplantation organ allocation decisions
Browning, C. J., & Thomas, S. A. (2001) · Social Science & Medicine · doi:10.1016/s0277-9536(00)00187-8 · Cited by 48 · cited 4×
“Eight studies assessed preference for giving priority to patients who had spent a longer time on the waiting list (2, 18, 19, 24, 25, 27, 33, 35).”
BackgroundInfluentialUbel, P. A., Baron, J. A., & Asch, D. A. (1999) · Bioethics · doi:10.1111/1467-8519.00131 · Cited by 48
The ethics of organ allocation: The state of debate
Gutmann, T., & Land, W. G. (1997) · Transplantation Reviews · doi:10.1016/s0955-470x(97)80038-9 · Cited by 45 · cited 3×
“Seven themes describing community preferences for organ allocation were identified: (1) maximum benefit, to achieve maximum health gain in recipient survival and quality of life; (2) social valuation, to base preferences on societal gain; (3) moral deservingness, to consider the “worthiness” of recipients based on the…”
BackgroundUS public opinion concerning the procurement and distribution of donor organs.
Evans, R. W., & Manninen, D. L. (1988) · PubMed · Cited by 42
Dolan, P., & Shaw, R. (2003) · Health Policy · doi:10.1016/j.healthpol.2003.07.006 · Cited by 39 · cited 10×
“A 70-year-old has had his life he’s had the chance to live” (35).”
BackgroundInfluentialSelection criteria for recipients of scarce donor livers: a public opinion survey in Hong Kong.
Chan, H. M., Cheung, G., & Yip, A. K. W. (2006) · PubMed · Cited by 34
Evaluating Options for Utility-Based Kidney Allocation
Segev, D. L. (2009) · American Journal of Transplantation · doi:10.1111/j.1600-6143.2009.02667.x · Cited by 31
Wilmot, S., & Ratcliffe, J. (2002) · Health Expectations · doi:10.1046/j.1369-6513.2002.00176.x · Cited by 30 · cited 9×
“It was felt that greater life expectancy posttransplant, the greater the priority for transplantation” (18).”
BackgroundInfluentialNormative and prescriptive criteria: The efficacy of organ transplantation allocation protocols
Koch, T. (1996) · Metamedicine · doi:10.1007/bf00489742 · Cited by 29 · cited 4×
“Organ allocation decisions extend beyond clinical or economic judgment to entail a social and moral responsibility, which needs to be shared with the community (7, 11).”
BackgroundInfluentialStahl, J. E., Tramontano, A. C., Swan, J. S., & Cohen, B. J. (2008) · Journal of Medical Ethics · doi:10.1136/jme.2006.018291 · Cited by 27 · cited 3×
“Four studies examined preferences for primary transplant candidates versus retransplantation (2, 18, 25, 27), and seven studies examined age as an influencing factor in preferences for organ allocation (18, 19, 24, 25, 27, 30, 35).”
BackgroundPublic preferences for efficiency and racial equity in kidney transplant allocation decisions.
Ubel, P. A., DeKay, M. L., Baron, J., & Asch, D. A. (1996) · PubMed · Cited by 27
Citizens at the Centre: Deliberative Participation in Healthcare Decisions
Smith, E. (2007) · Journal of Interprofessional Care · doi:10.1080/13561820701455516 · Cited by 26
Developing a New Kidney Allocation Policy: The Rationale for Including Life Years from Transplant
Winters, M. D. (2009) · American Journal of Transplantation · doi:10.1111/j.1600-6143.2009.02712.x · Cited by 25
Developing principles for prudent health care allocation. The continuing Oregon experiment.
Crawshaw, R. S., Garland, M., Hines, B., & Anderson, B. (1990) · PubMed Central · Cited by 25
Moving Kidney Allocation Forward: The ASTS Perspective
Freeman, R. B., Matas, A. T., Henry, M. L., Segav, D. L., Kaufman, D. B., & Roberts, J. P. (2009) · American Journal of Transplantation · doi:10.1111/j.1600-6143.2009.02697.x · Cited by 24
Balancing Multiple and Conflicting Allocation Goals: A Logical Path Forward
Stock, P. G. (2009) · American Journal of Transplantation · doi:10.1111/j.1600-6143.2009.02715.x · Cited by 23
Cadaver kidneys: the rules of rationing
Guttmann, R. D. (1996) · The Lancet · doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(96)04010-x · Cited by 20 · cited 2×
“Organ allocation decisions extend beyond clinical or economic judgment to entail a social and moral responsibility, which needs to be shared with the community (7, 11).”
BackgroundMethodThe Kidney Allocation Score: Methodological Problems, Moral Concerns and Unintended Consequences
Hippen, B. E. (2009) · American Journal of Transplantation · doi:10.1111/j.1600-6143.2009.02594.x · Cited by 18
Spital, A. (2005) · Clinical Transplantation · doi:10.1111/j.1399-0012.2005.00336.x · Cited by 18 · cited 3×
“Spital (29) Telephone survey Organ United States 1014 Donor status of recipient”
BackgroundInfluentialCommunity consultation and engagement in health care reform
McBride, T., & Korczak, V. (2007) · Australian Health Review · doi:10.1071/ah070s13 · Cited by 15
Sears, S. F., Marhefka, S. L., Rodrigue, J. R., & Campbell, C. (2000) · Health Psychology · doi:10.1037/0278-6133.19.2.192 · Cited by 14 · cited 2×
“These included smoking (28, 31, 32), excessive alcohol drinking (18, 19, 25, 27, 32), crime (18), and drug use (19, 31, 35).”
Background
Research works printed but not linked: 1
- Leung, 2001, How to conduct a survey., Stud BMJ, 9, 143
Cited by
Leard, L. E., Holm, A. M., Valapour, M., Glanville, A. R., Attawar, S., Aversa, M., Campos, S. V., Christon, L. M., Cypel, M., Dellgren, G., et al. (2021) · The Journal of Heart and Lung Transplantation · doi:10.1016/j.healun.2021.07.005 · Cited by 821
Wong, G., Howard, K., Chapman, J. R., Chadban, S., Cross, N., Tong, A., Webster, A. C., & Craig, J. C. (2012) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0029591 · Cited by 222
Self-citationButler, C. R., Wong, S. P. Y., Wightman, A. G., & O’Hare, A. M. (2020) · JAMA Network Open · doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.27315 · Cited by 155
Perceptions of preparedness for the first medical clerkship: a systematic review and synthesis
Surmon, L., Bialocerkowski, A., & Hu, W. (2016) · BMC Medical Education · doi:10.1186/s12909-016-0615-3 · Cited by 125
Healthcare practitioners’ personal and professional values
Moyo, M., Goodyear‐Smith, F., Weller, J. M., Robb, G., & Shulruf, B. (2015) · Advances in Health Sciences Education · doi:10.1007/s10459-015-9626-9 · Cited by 133
“As we were interested in the values themselves rather than the quality of the study, we did not exclude studies on the basis of quality of research design nor reporting, if the studies were explicit on the value items they discussed or measured (Tong et al. 2010).”
Background
Metadata
- Authors
- Tong, A., Howard, K., Jan, S., Cass, A., Rose, J., Chadban, S., Allen, R. D., & Craig, J. C.
- Affiliations
- The University of Sydney (AU)
- Corresponding author
- Tong, Allison
- Venue
- Transplantation
- Published
- 2010-04-15
- Volume
- 89
- Issue
- 7
- Pages
- 796-805
- ISSN
- 0041-1337 (ISSN-L)
- OpenAlex
- W2050087718
- Semantic Scholar
- 084fedf28505a4b47b4bee5f0e7b7bd9c80c8a3b
- Cited by
- 92
- References
- 43
- Citations by year
- 2026: 4 · 2025: 7 · 2024: 2 · 2023: 12 · 2022: 3 · 2021: 8 · 2020: 5 · 2019: 2 · 2018: 2 · 2017: 7 · 2016: 5 · 2015: 10 · 2014: 5 · 2013: 5 · 2012: 8
- FWCI
- 0.88
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- closed
- Locations
- Transplantation (publishedVersion)
- PubMed (publishedVersion)
- Topics
- Health Sciences › Medicine › Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health › Organ Donation and Transplantation
- Health Sciences › Medicine › Surgery › Organ Transplantation Techniques and Outcomes
- Health Sciences › Medicine › Surgery › Transplantation: Methods and Outcomes
- Keywords
- organ allocation, solid organ transplantation, community preferences, public opinion, allocation principles, social valuation, fairness, equity, medical urgency, retransplantation, quality of life
- MeSH terms
- Algorithms, Community Health Services, Decision Making, Health Policy, Humans, Health Knowledge, Attitudes, Practice, Morals, Tissue and Organ Procurement, Prejudice, Prognosis, Public Opinion, Social Desirability, Social Values, Tissue Donors, Waiting Lists, Health Care Rationing, Organ Transplantation, Patient Selection, Decision Support Systems, Clinical
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.