Positive site selection bias in meta-analyses comparing natural regeneration to active forest restoration
Open accessThe DOI matches its Crossref record; 32 of the 32 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
Selection bias calls into question whether natural regeneration is really more successful than active tropical forest restoration.
Overview
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Figures
Verification
Claims the paper makes
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Claims other papers make about this one
Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?
The check wasn’t confident either way, so it gives no verdict — never disputed.
In the citing paper
“by having limited (14) and at times negative (9) effects on native biodiversity”
From The biodiversity and ecosystem service contributions and trade-offs of forest restoration approaches (2022) · cites this paper as [14]
Experimental — accuracy not yet measured
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
The self-check needs the paper’s full text.
Citations
Cites
Restoration of Degraded Tropical Forest Landscapes
Lamb, D., Erskine, P. D., & Parrotta, J. A. (2005) · Science · doi:10.1126/science.1111773 · Cited by 1,444
When and where to actively restore ecosystems?
Holl, K. D., & Aide, T. M. (2011) · Forest Ecology and Management · doi:10.1016/j.foreco.2010.07.004 · Cited by 919 · cited 2×
“For restoration practitioners seeking evidence-based management strategies, a take-home message from the empirical literature is that it is often worthwhile to observe natural forest recovery for a year or two to assess if natural regeneration will accomplish management objectives before deciding whether some form of…”
BackgroundAbandoned Pastures in Eastern Amazonia. I. Patterns of Plant Succession
Uhl, C., Buschbacher, R., & Serrao, E. A. S. (1988) · The Journal of Ecology · doi:10.2307/2260566 · Cited by 818
Crouzeilles, R., Ferreira, M. S., Chazdon, R. L., Lindenmayer, D. B., Sansevero, J. B. B., Monteiro, L., Iribarrem, A., Latawiec, A. E., & Strassburg, B. B. N. (2017) · Science Advances · doi:10.1126/sciadv.1701345 · Cited by 705
Arroyo-Rodríguez, V., Melo, F. P. L., Martínez-Ramos, M., Bongers, F., Chazdon, R. L., Meave, J. A., Norden, N., Santos, B. A., Leal, I. R., & Tabarelli, M. (2017) · Biological Reviews · doi:10.1111/brv.12231 · Cited by 688
Aide, T. M., Zimmerman, J. K., Pascarella, J. B., Rivera, L., & Marcano‐Vega, H. (2000) · Restoration Ecology · doi:10.1046/j.1526-100x.2000.80048.x · Cited by 574 · cited 1×
“A few of these factors include soil quality (20, 21), fire (22), presence of seed-dispersing animals (23), competition from exotic grasses (24), and herbivory (25).”
BackgroundMeli, P., Holl, K. D., Rey Benayas, J. M., Jones, H. P., Jones, P. C., Montoya, D., & Moreno Mateos, D. (2017) · PLOS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0171368 · Cited by 455
Letcher, S. G., & Chazdon, R. L. (2009) · Biotropica · doi:10.1111/j.1744-7429.2009.00517.x · Cited by 366
BIOMASS, CARBON, AND NUTRIENT DYNAMICS OF SECONDARY FORESTS IN A HUMID TROPICAL REGION OF MÉXICO
Hughes, R. F., Kauffman, J. B., & Jaramillo, V. J. (1999) · Ecology · doi:10.1890/0012-9658(1999)080[1892:bcando]2.0.co;2 · Cited by 314
Total carbon stocks in a tropical forest landscape of the Porce region, Colombia
Sierra, C. A., del Valle, J. I., Orrego, S. A., Moreno, F. H., Harmon, M. E., Zapata, M., Colorado, G. J., Herrera, M. A., Lara, W., Restrepo, D. E., et al. (2007) · Forest Ecology and Management · doi:10.1016/j.foreco.2007.03.026 · Cited by 239
Research works printed but not linked: 1
- United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity Decision adopted by the conference of the parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity at its eleventh meeting. XI/16. Ecosystem restoration (United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity 2012).
Cited by
The biodiversity and ecosystem service contributions and trade-offs of forest restoration approaches
Hua, F., Bruijnzeel, L. A., Meli, P., Martin, P. A., Zhang, J., Nakagawa, S., Miao, X., Wang, W., McEvoy, C., Peña-Arancibia, J. L., et al. (2022) · Science · doi:10.1126/science.abl4649 · Cited by 831
“Third, although we used paired data and accounted for the rigor of site matching in our analyses (18), we cannot rule out the potential influence of preexisting site differences incurred by land-use history (13) and species turnover across space (betadiversity) (48), both of which are often difficult to ascertain.”
BackgroundMethodInfluentialMapping carbon accumulation potential from global natural forest regrowth
Cook-Patton, S. C., Leavitt, S. M., Gibbs, D., Harris, N. L., Lister, K., Anderson-Teixeira, K. J., Briggs, R. D., Chazdon, R. L., Crowther, T. W., Ellis, P. W., et al. (2020) · Nature · doi:10.1038/s41586-020-2686-x · Cited by 619
The intervention continuum in restoration ecology: rethinking the active–passive dichotomy
Chazdon, R. L., Falk, D. A., Banin, L. F., Wagner, M., J. Wilson, S., Grabowski, R. C., & Suding, K. N. (2024) · Restoration Ecology · doi:10.1111/rec.13535 · Cited by 204
“The literature on passive recovery tends to compare outcomes of active interventions with natural regeneration, rather than emphasize how the two approaches can be complementary (e.g. Crouzeilles et al. 2017; Reid et al. 2018; Holl & Brancalion 2020).”
Forest Landscape Restoration—What Generates Failure and Success?
Höhl, M., Ahimbisibwe, V., Stanturf, J. A., Elsasser, P., Kleine, M., & Bolte, A. (2020) · Forests · doi:10.3390/f11090938 · Cited by 189
Restoration of ecosystem services in tropical forests: A global meta-analysis
Shimamoto, C. Y., Padial, A. A., da Rosa, C. M., & Marques, M. C. M. (2018) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0208523 · Cited by 188
Restoring forests: regeneration and ecosystem function for the future
Löf, M., Madsen, P., Metslaid, M., Witzell, J., & Jacobs, D. F. (2019) · New Forests · doi:10.1007/s11056-019-09713-0 · Cited by 186
Carbon sequestration in riparian forests: A global synthesis and meta‐analysis
Dybala, K. E., Matzek, V., Gardali, T., & Seavy, N. E. (2019) · Global Change Biology · doi:10.1111/gcb.14475 · Cited by 170
Linking bacterial life strategies with soil organic matter accrual by karst vegetation restoration
Hu, P., Zhang, W., Kuzyakov, Y. V., Xiao, L., Xiao, D., Xu, L., Chen, H., Zhao, J., & Wang, K. (2022) · Soil Biology and Biochemistry · doi:10.1016/j.soilbio.2022.108925 · Cited by 166
Implementing forest landscape restoration under the Bonn Challenge: a systematic approach
Stanturf, J. A., Kleine, M., Mansourian, S., Parrotta, J., Madsen, P., Kant, P., Burns, J., & Bolte, A. (2019) · Annals of Forest Science · doi:10.1007/s13595-019-0833-z · Cited by 164
“…or bottom-up planning and priority setting (Cordell et al. 2017; Evans et al. 2018), potential of passive versus active restoration (Crouzeilles et al. 2017; Reid et al. 2018), and perceived need for exclusion of non-native species in favor of native species (Davis et al. 2011; Thomas et al. 2014).”
BackgroundThe Ecology of Tropical East Asia
Corlett, R. T. (2019) · doi:10.1093/oso/9780198817017.001.0001 · Cited by 164
Atkinson, J., Brudvig, L. A., Mallen‐Cooper, M., Nakagawa, S., Moles, A. T., & Bonser, S. P. (2022) · Ecology Letters · doi:10.1111/ele.14025 · Cited by 163
Herbivory limits success of vegetation restoration globally
Xu, C., Silliman, B. R., Chen, J., Li, X., Thomsen, M. S., Zhang, Q., Lee, J., Lefcheck, J. S., Daleo, P., Hughes, B. B., et al. (2023) · Science · doi:10.1126/science.add2814 · Cited by 155
An overview of forest loss and restoration in the Brazilian Amazon
da Cruz, D. C., Beñayas, J. M. R., Ferreira, G. C., Santos, S. R., & Schwartz, G. (2020) · New Forests · doi:10.1007/s11056-020-09777-3 · Cited by 155
“Active” and “passive” ecological restoration strategies in meta‐analysis
Atkinson, J., & Bonser, S. P. (2020) · Restoration Ecology · doi:10.1111/rec.13229 · Cited by 147
“Reid et al. (2018) note an inherent flaw that describes why a conceptual shift is necessary: when comparing a tree plantation in a degraded pasture (active restoration) with regeneration in a 10-year-old secondary forest (passive restoration) they note that the plantation has the opportunity to…”
BackgroundInfluentialRural land abandonment is too ephemeral to provide major benefits for biodiversity and climate
Crawford, C. L., Yin, H., Radeloff, V. C., & Wilcove, D. S. (2022) · Science Advances · doi:10.1126/sciadv.abm8999 · Cited by 146
“Furthermore, these estimates may be overly optimistic, due to positive site selection bias (46), especially if the area around fast-recovering sites retained relatively high forest cover [76% on average in (26)].”
BackgroundBrodie, E. G., Knapp, E. E., Brooks, W. R., Drury, S. A., & Ritchie, M. W. (2024) · Fire Ecology · doi:10.1186/s42408-023-00241-z · Cited by 138
Future restoration should enhance ecological complexity and emergent properties at multiple scales
Bullock, J. M., Fuentes‐Montemayor, E., McCarthy, B., Park, K. J., Hails, R. S., Woodcock, B. A., Watts, K., Corstanje, R., & Harris, J. (2021) · Ecography · doi:10.1111/ecog.05780 · Cited by 130
Cost-effectiveness of natural forest regeneration and plantations for climate mitigation
Busch, J., Bukoski, J. J., Cook‐Patton, S. C., Griscom, B. W., Kaczan, D. J., Potts, M. D., Yi, Y., & Vincent, J. R. (2024) · Nature Climate Change · doi:10.1038/s41558-024-02068-1 · Cited by 120
Cruz‐Alonso, V., Ruiz‐Benito, P., Villar‐Salvador, P., & Beñayas, J. M. R. (2019) · Journal of Applied Ecology · doi:10.1111/1365-2664.13340 · Cited by 117
Prediction and uncertainty in restoration science
Brudvig, L. A., & Catano, C. P. (2021) · Restoration Ecology · doi:10.1111/rec.13380 · Cited by 110
“It is important that these efforts include projects with varying degrees of success, as the literature may bias against failed restoration efforts (Reid et al. 2018).”
Moving biodiversity from an afterthought to a key outcome of forest restoration
Brancalion, P. H. S., Hua, F., Joyce, F. H., Antonelli, A., & Holl, K. D. (2025) · Nature Reviews Biodiversity · doi:10.1038/s44358-025-00032-1 · Cited by 97
Banin, L. F., Raine, E. H., Rowland, L. M., Chazdon, R. L., Smith, S. W., Rahman, N. E., Butler, A. B., Philipson, C. D., Applegate, G., Axelsson, E. P., et al. (2022) · Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rstb.2021.0090 · Cited by 96
Hu, P., Zhang, W., Chen, H., Li, D., Zhao, Y., Zhao, J., Xiao, J., Wu, F., He, X., Luo, Y., et al. (2021) · The Science of The Total Environment · doi:10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.145298 · Cited by 79
Fifteen essential science advances needed for effective restoration of the world's forest landscapes
Marshall, A. R., Waite, C. E., Pfeifer, M., Banin, L. F., Rakotonarivo, O. S., Chomba, S., Herbohn, J., Gilmour, D. A., Brown, M., & Chazdon, R. L. (2022) · Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rstb.2021.0065 · Cited by 74
Biodiversity responses to restoration across the Brazilian Atlantic Forest
Romanelli, J. P., Meli, P., Santos, J. P. B., Jacob, I. N., Souza, L. R., Rodrigues, A. V., Trevisan, D. P., Huang, C., de Almeida, D. R. A., Silva, L. G. M., et al. (2022) · The Science of The Total Environment · doi:10.1016/j.scitotenv.2022.153403 · Cited by 70
“Furthermore, active restoration initiatives are generally not exposed to the same environmental fi lters as passive restoration (Reid et al., 2018), and the process of passive restoration can be highly variable (Gilman et al., 2016; Holl and Zahawi, 2014).”
InfluentialGarcía, J. M. D., López‐Barrera, F., Pineda, E., Toledo‐Aceves, T., & Andresen, E. (2020) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0242020 · Cited by 66
“To avoid confounding factors, comparisons need to be made in sites where both restoration strategies have been implemented at the same time in the same landscape [7].”
BackgroundResultFrugivores enhance potential carbon recovery in fragmented landscapes
Bello, C., Crowther, T. W., Ramos, D. L., Morán‐López, T., Pizo, M. A., & Dent, D. H. (2024) · Nature Climate Change · doi:10.1038/s41558-024-01989-1 · Cited by 65
“An open question in forest restoration ecology is in which areas animals can contribute strongly to trigger natural restoration and which areas require active restoration 22,24,34 .”
González‐Varo, J. P., Albrecht, J., Arroyo, J., Bueno, R., Burgos, T., Escribano‐Ávila, G., Farwig, N., García, D., Illera, J. C., Jordano, P., et al. (2023) · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · doi:10.1073/pnas.2302440120 · Cited by 63
“Finally, our study provides useful knowledge for the restoration of unmanaged agricultural lands, revealing a high potential for passive forest restoration of fleshy - fruited plants in matrices with isolated trees and at short distances from forest edges ( 300 m) (48).”
Villa, P. M., Martins, S. V., Rodrigues, A. C., Safar, N. V. H., Bonilla, M. A. C., & Ali, A. (2019) · Ecological Engineering · doi:10.1016/j.ecoleng.2019.05.015 · Cited by 62
Tian, D., Xiang, Y., Seabloom, E. W., Wang, J., Jia, X., Li, T., Li, Z., Yang, J., Guo, H., & Niu, S. (2023) · Communications Earth & Environment · doi:10.1038/s43247-023-00737-1 · Cited by 60
Trends in active restoration of tropical dry forest: Methods, metrics, and outcomes
Dimson, M., & Gillespie, T. W. (2020) · Forest Ecology and Management · doi:10.1016/j.foreco.2020.118150 · Cited by 59
Drivers and benefits of natural regeneration in tropical forests
Chazdon, R. L., Blüthgen, N., Brancalion, P. H. S., Heinrich, V., & Bongers, F. (2025) · Nature Reviews Biodiversity · doi:10.1038/s44358-025-00043-y · Cited by 55
“In addition, current carbon accumulation estimates from tropical forest regeneration are potentially overestimated owing to a positive bias in selecting study sites 221 and in accurately assessing forest age based on satellite imagery.”
The cost of restoring carbon stocks in Brazil's Atlantic Forest
Brancalion, P. H. S., Guillemot, J., César, R. G., Andrade, H. S., Mendes, A., Sorrini, T. B., Píccolo, M. D. C., Peluci, M. C., Moreno, V. D. S., Colletta, G. D., et al. (2020) · Land Degradation and Development · doi:10.1002/ldr.3764 · Cited by 54
“Although not appropriate for objectively comparing these restoration approaches per se and isolating uncontrolled factors (Reid et al., 2018), our study design depicts the cost-effectiveness of restoration approaches currently being implemented in agricultural landscapes of Brazil's Atlantic Forest…”
BackgroundInfluentialThe past and future of ecosystem restoration in China
Li, B. V., Wu, S., Hua, F., & Mi, X. (2024) · Current Biology · doi:10.1016/j.cub.2024.03.057 · Cited by 52
Direct seeded and colonizing species guarantee successful early restoration of South Amazon forests
Rodrigues, S. B., Freitas, M. G., Campos‐Filho, E. M., do Carmo, G. H. P., da Veiga, J. M., Junqueira, R. G. P., & Vieira, D. L. M. (2019) · Forest Ecology and Management · doi:10.1016/j.foreco.2019.117559 · Cited by 51
Crouzeilles, R., Barros, F. S. M., Molin, P. G., Ferreira, M. S., Junqueira, A. B., Chazdon, R. L., Lindenmayer, D. B., Tymus, J. R. C., Strassburg, B. B. N., & Brancalion, P. H. S. (2019) · Journal of Applied Ecology · doi:10.1111/1365-2664.13501 · Cited by 50
Brazil’s forest restoration, biomass and carbon stocks: A critical review of the knowledge gaps
Gardon, F. R., dos Santos, R. F., & Rodrigues, R. R. (2020) · Forest Ecology and Management · doi:10.1016/j.foreco.2020.117972 · Cited by 50
Pérez-Cárdenas, N., Mora, F., Arreola-Villa, F., Arroyo‐Rodríguez, V., Balvanera, P., Flores-Casas, R., Navarrete-Pacheco, A., & Ortega-Huerta, M. A. (2020) · Forest Ecology and Management · doi:10.1016/j.foreco.2020.118818 · Cited by 47
Landscape-scale forest cover drives the predictability of forest regeneration across the Neotropics
Arroyo‐Rodríguez, V., Rito, K. F., Gutiérrez, M. F., Navia, I. C., Mora, F., Arreola-Villa, F., Balvanera, P., Bongers, F., Castellanos‐Castro, C., Catharino, E. L. M., et al. (2023) · Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rspb.2022.2203 · Cited by 47
“The lack of research on secondary succession in highly degraded tropical landscapes has been noted in previous studies [5,68] and highlights the urgent need to fill this gap to attain a better understanding of the effect of landscape-scale disturbance on successional trajectories [69].”
BackgroundRequena‐Mullor, J. M., Maguire, K. C., Shinneman, D. J., & Caughlin, T. T. (2019) · Global Change Biology · doi:10.1111/gcb.14728 · Cited by 47
“, 2017), while leaving relatively intact landscapes to recover without intervention, resulting in bias when active restoration is compared to natural regeneration (Reid et al., 2018).”
BackgroundEscobar, S., Newell, F. L., Endara, M., Guevara, J. E., Landim, A. R., Neuschulz, E. L., Hausmann, R., Müller, J. C., Pedersen, K., Schleuning, M., et al. (2025) · Ecosphere · doi:10.1002/ecs2.70157 · Cited by 46
Enhanced but highly variable biodiversity outcomes from coastal restoration: A global synthesis
Sievers, M., Connolly, R. M., Finlayson, K. A., Kitchingman, M. E., Ostrowski, A., Pearson, R. M., Turschwell, M. P., Adame, M. F., Bugnot, A. B., Ditria, E. M., et al. (2024) · One Earth · doi:10.1016/j.oneear.2024.02.013 · Cited by 44
Simler‐Williamson, A. B., & Germino, M. J. (2022) · Nature Communications · doi:10.1038/s41467-022-31102-z · Cited by 44
Rules of thumb for predicting tropical forest recovery
Holl, K. D., Reid, J. L., Oviedo‐Brenes, F., Kulikowski, A. J., & Zahawi, R. A. (2018) · Applied Vegetation Science · doi:10.1111/avsc.12394 · Cited by 43
Self-citationCrouzeilles, R., Maurenza, D., Prieto, P. V., Barros, F. S. M., Jakovac, C. C., Ferreira, M. S., Chazdon, R. L., Lindenmayer, D. B., Brancalion, P. H. S., Ceccon, E., et al. (2020) · Conservation Letters · doi:10.1111/conl.12768 · Cited by 43
Toledo‐Aceves, T., Trujillo-Miranda, A. L., & López‐Barrera, F. (2021) · Forest Ecology and Management · doi:10.1016/j.foreco.2021.119050 · Cited by 43
Williams‐Linera, G., Bonilla‐Moheno, M., López‐Barrera, F., & Tolome, J. (2021) · Forest Ecology and Management · doi:10.1016/j.foreco.2021.119260 · Cited by 42
Insects remove more seeds than mammals in first‐year prairie restorations
Linabury, M. C., Turley, N. E., & Brudvig, L. A. (2019) · Restoration Ecology · doi:10.1111/rec.13004 · Cited by 41
“Unfortunately, restoration outcomes can be highly variable, and we typically lack an understanding of how and why this variation results (Pywell et al. 2002; Walker et al. 2004; Brudvig et al. 2017; Jones et al. 2018; Reid et al. 2018).”
BackgroundGullett, P. R., Leslie, C., Mason, R., Ratcliffe, P., Sargent, I., Beck, A., Cameron, T. C., Cowie, N., Hetherington, D., MacDonell, T., et al. (2023) · Journal of Applied Ecology · doi:10.1111/1365-2664.14501 · Cited by 40
“Several authors have highlighted the merits of a spectrum of approaches to achieve woodland expansion (e.g. Reid et al., 2018), including ground preparation to aid regeneration from natural seed rain (Wijedasa et al., 2019), and ‘assisted re-generation’ (Chazdon et al., 2020), whereby small pockets…”
BackgroundPothong, T., Elliott, S., Chairuangsri, S., Chanthorn, W., Shannon, D. P., & Wangpakapattanawong, P. (2021) · New Forests · doi:10.1007/s11056-021-09844-3 · Cited by 39
Integrating functional traits into trophic rewilding science
Atkinson, J., Gallagher, R. V., Czyżewski, S., Kerr, M. R., Trepel, J., Buitenwerf, R., & Svenning, J. (2024) · Journal of Ecology · doi:10.1111/1365-2745.14307 · Cited by 39
“While passive restoration approaches may offer landscape-scale and cost-effective restoration of many degraded areas (Huang et al., 2019; Prach & del Moral, 2015 ), these are most effective in less degraded ecosystems (Reid et al., 2018 ).”
BackgroundDemographic costs and benefits of natural regeneration during tropical forest restoration
Caughlin, T. T., de la Peña‐Domene, M., & Martínez‐Garza, C. (2018) · Ecology Letters · doi:10.1111/ele.13165 · Cited by 37
García, J. M. D., López‐Barrera, F., Toledo‐Aceves, T., Andresen, E., & Pineda, E. (2020) · Biological Conservation · doi:10.1016/j.biocon.2019.108400 · Cited by 36
Gong, H., Song, W., Wang, J., Wang, X., Ji, Y., Zhang, X., & Gao, J. (2023) · Journal of Integrative Plant Biology · doi:10.1111/jipb.13545 · Cited by 36
The effectiveness of using targeted grazing for vegetation management: a meta‐analysis
Marchetto, K. M., Wolf, T. M., & Larkin, D. J. (2021) · Restoration Ecology · doi:10.1111/rec.13422 · Cited by 35
“One explanation for this may be site selection bias (Reid et al. 2018).”
BackgroundThe recovery of functional diversity with restoration
O’Brien, S. A., Dehling, D. M., & Tylianakis, J. M. (2021) · Ecology · doi:10.1002/ecy.3618 · Cited by 35
Kobayashi, Y., Seidl, R., Rammer, W., Suzuki, K., & Mori, A. (2022) · Restoration Ecology · doi:10.1111/rec.13681 · Cited by 35
“Such a more nuanced perspective can help to overcome the sometimes overly simplistic discussion of planting versus natural regeneration for restoration (Reid et al. 2018).”
BackgroundBrudvig, L. A., Turley, N. E., Bartel, S. L., Bell‐Dereske, L. P., Breland, S., Damschen, E. I., Evans, S. E., Gibbs, J., Hahn, P. G., Isaacs, R., et al. (2021) · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · doi:10.1073/pnas.2020935118 · Cited by 34
“We randomly applied restoration treatments to half of the plots in our study, thereby avoiding site selection issues, which can bias restoration studies (34).”
MethodCheng, S. H., Costedoat, S., Sterling, E. J., Chamberlain, C., Jagadish, A., Lichtenthal, P., Nowakowski, A. J., Taylor, A., Tinsman, J. C., Canty, S. W. J., et al. (2022) · Environmental Evidence · doi:10.1186/s13750-022-00268-w · Cited by 33
“…that some interventions have been effective in enhancing carbon sequestration, but require attention to improving the evidence base, notably by more rigorously disentan-gling the net impact of specific restoration interventions from confounding factors and site location bias (see e.g. [22–24]).”
BackgroundIntegrating forest restoration into land-use planning at large spatial scales
Hua, F., Liu, M., & Wang, Z. (2024) · Current Biology · doi:10.1016/j.cub.2024.02.034 · Cited by 32
Reliability of evidence‐review methods in restoration ecology
Romanelli, J. P., Meli, P., Naves, R. P., Alves, M. C., & Rodrigues, R. R. (2020) · Conservation Biology · doi:10.1111/cobi.13661 · Cited by 31
Broughton, R. K., Bullock, J. M., George, C., Gerard, F., Maziarz, M., Payne, W., Scholefield, P. A., Wade, D., & Pywell, R. F. (2022) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0277545 · Cited by 31
“However, published studies are reported to be biased towards those showing successful colonisation of woodland, with relatively few examples of the trajectory of passive rewilding on sites that are considered to have less favourable characteristics [18, 19].”
BackgroundAssisted restoration interventions drive functional recovery of tropical wet forest tree communities
Werden, L. K., Zarges, S., Holl, K. D., Oliver, C. L., Oviedo‐Brenes, F., Rosales, J. A., & Zahawi, R. A. (2022) · Frontiers in Forests and Global Change · doi:10.3389/ffgc.2022.935011 · Cited by 30
“However, there is a paucity of paired comparisons between natural and assisted recovery techniques in the same system, and most studies to date have been biased because more resource-intensive management interventions are often needed, and therefore implemented, at the most degraded sites (Reid et al., 2018).”
BackgroundSelf-citationThe underestimated role of understory vegetation dynamics for forest ecosystem resilience: a review
Haritika, & Negi, A. K. (2025) · Plant Ecology · doi:10.1007/s11258-025-01529-7 · Cited by 29
“(Lof et al., 2019; Crouzeilles et al. 2017; Meli et al., 2017; Reid et al. 2018).”
Bosshard, E., Jansen, M., Löfqvist, S., & Kettle, C. J. (2021) · Frontiers in Forests and Global Change · doi:10.3389/ffgc.2020.589982 · Cited by 29
“, 2018), while active restoration typically is initiated within highly deforested landscapes (Reid et al., 2018).”
BackgroundHishe, H., Giday, K., Fremout, T., Negussie, A., Aerts, R., & Muys, B. (2021) · Restoration Ecology · doi:10.1111/rec.13471 · Cited by 29
“However, such a positive inclination to passive restoration is criticized for bias due to positive site selection (Reid et al. 2018).”
BackgroundRestoration interventions mediate tropical tree recruitment dynamics over time
Kulikowski, A. J., Zahawi, R. A., Werden, L. K., Zhu, K., & Holl, K. D. (2022) · Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rstb.2021.0077 · Cited by 29
Self-citationStaples, T. L., Mayfield, M. M., England, J. R., & Dwyer, J. M. (2019) · Restoration Ecology · doi:10.1111/rec.13077 · Cited by 29
“Natural regrowth stands were only surveyed if they had persisted from land abandonment to time of survey, which is a positive site bias (Reid et al. 2018).”
BackgroundBauld, J. T., Guy, M., Hughes, S., Forster, J., & Watts, K. (2023) · Restoration Ecology · doi:10.1111/rec.14004 · Cited by 28
“However, Reid et al. (2018) identi fi ed a degree of selection bias in the comparison of natural processes (colonization and regeneration) with tree planting.”
BackgroundResultInfluentialPotential native timber production in tropical forest restoration plantations
Krainovic, P. M., de Resende, A. F., Amazonas, N. T., de Almeida, C. T., de Almeida, D. R. A., Silva, C. C., de Andrade, H. S. F., Rodrigues, R. R., & Brancalion, P. H. S. (2023) · Perspectives in Ecology and Conservation · doi:10.1016/j.pecon.2023.10.002 · Cited by 27
da Cruz, D. C., Beñayas, J. M. R., Ferreira, G. C., & Ribeiro, S. S. (2020) · Forests · doi:10.3390/f11050527 · Cited by 28
“[73] who found a positive site selection bias in meta-analyses comparing natural regeneration to active forest restoration (i.”
BackgroundThe power of data synthesis to shape the future of the restoration community and capacity
Ladouceur, E. R., & Shackelford, N. (2020) · Restoration Ecology · doi:10.1111/rec.13251 · Cited by 25
“To move forward, a global perspective of the current status of restoration project successes and failures (Reid et al. 2018), through the accumulation of data (Cooke et al. 2019), could be a powerful, complementary approach to local-scale projects and experiments.”
BackgroundYe, Y., Zhang, R., Tian, D., Wang, J., Yu, G., & Niu, S. (2025) · Global Change Biology · doi:10.1111/gcb.70255 · Cited by 24
“In contrast, natural regeneration offers a more sustainable and cost-effective strategy (Reid et al. 2018), providing substantial and lasting benefits for soil carbon enhancement.”
Ram, M., Caughlin, T. T., & Roopsind, A. (2021) · Restoration Ecology · doi:10.1111/rec.13400 · Cited by 23
“The differences between actively restored and degraded sites in our study are likely due to project managers’ expertise in choosing sites for active restoration (e.g. Reid et al. 2018).”
BackgroundBorda‐Niño, M., Ceccon, E., Meli, P., Hernández-Muciño, D., Mas, J., & Brancalion, P. H. S. (2021) · Perspectives in Ecology and Conservation · doi:10.1016/j.pecon.2021.04.001 · Cited by 23
“It is necessary understand where forest is regenerating in agricultural landscape and what are the drivers of their development and persistence (Brancalion et al., 2016b; Reid et al., 2018).”
BackgroundForest Biodiversity Conservation and Restoration
Raj, A., Jhariya, M. K., Banerjee, A., Kittur, B. H., Bargali, S. S., Bargali, K., & Nema, S. (2023) · Wiley eBooks · doi:10.1002/9781119879954.ch10 · Cited by 22
Schimetka, L. R., Ruggiero, P. G. C., Carvalho, R. L., Behagel, J. H., Metzger, J. P., Nascimento, N., Chaves, R. B., Brancalion, P. H. S., Rodrigues, R. R., & Krainovic, P. M. (2024) · Restoration Ecology · doi:10.1111/rec.14161 · Cited by 22
“Generally, the choice between active and passive restoration approaches depends on the respective site conditions and management objectives (Reid et al. 2018).”
BackgroundZhu, K., Ran, Y., Ma, M., Li, W., Mir, Y., Ran, J.-J., Wu, S., & Huang, P. (2021) · Soil and Tillage Research · doi:10.1016/j.still.2021.105263 · Cited by 22
Crookes, D. J., & Blignaut, J. N. (2019) · Heliyon · doi:10.1016/j.heliyon.2019.e01765 · Cited by 22
“The studies vary both in terms of temporal and spatial distribution as well as restoration method to avoid site selection bias (Reid et al., 2018).”
BackgroundTrujillo-Miranda, A. L., Toledo‐Aceves, T., López‐Barrera, F., & Günter, S. (2020) · New Forests · doi:10.1007/s11056-020-09787-1 · Cited by 21
Zeng, X., & Fischer, G. A. (2020) · Forest Ecology and Management · doi:10.1016/j.foreco.2020.118819 · Cited by 21
The evolution and frontier development of land ecological restoration research
Xing, Y., Cai-quan, B., Long-wu, L., Zi-cong, Z., Song, W., & Yan, Z. (2020) · 自然资源学报 · doi:10.31497/zrzyxb.20200105 · Cited by 21
What's hot and what's not – Identifying publication trends in insect ecology
Andrew, N. R., Evans, M. J., Svejcar, L. N., Prendegast, K., Mata, L., Gibb, H., Stone, M. J., & Barton, P. S. (2021) · Austral Ecology · doi:10.1111/aec.13052 · Cited by 21
Wu, J., Gong, J., Sun, F., Zhou, S., Kausar, T., Li, T., Cui, L., Xu, Z. H., Degen, A. A., Kuzyakov, Y. V., et al. (2025) · Earth s Future · doi:10.1029/2025ef006021 · Cited by 20
“At present, it is unclear as to which restoration strategy maximizes C sequestration in alpine grasslands (Reid et al., 2018), as there are few comparisons between passive and active restoration studies (Crouzeilles et al., 2017; Tian et al., 2023).”
Bioeconomic opportunities in restored tropical forests
Krainovic, P. M., Romanelli, J. P., de Resende, A. F., Simões, L. H. P., Boeni, A. F., Souza, L. R., Toledo, C. A. P., Souza, V. C., Guillemot, J., Brouwer, R. G., et al. (2025) · AMBIO · doi:10.1007/s13280-025-02234-5 · Cited by 19
Roder, L. R., Guerrini, I. A., Sivisaca, D. C. L., Yaguana, C., de Moraes, F. G., da Silva, J. P., Fonseca, R. C. B., Umbelino, M. T., James, J. N., Capra, G. F., et al. (2022) · Journal of Environmental Management · doi:10.1016/j.jenvman.2022.116521 · Cited by 18
Massante, J. C., de Castro, A. F., Sarmento, P. S. D. M., da Silva, G. M., Caldeira, C. F., Ramos, S. J., & Gastauer, M. (2023) · Ecological Engineering · doi:10.1016/j.ecoleng.2023.107039 · Cited by 17
Grand challenges in ecosystem restoration
Waring, B. G. (2024) · Frontiers in Environmental Science · doi:10.3389/fenvs.2023.1353829 · Cited by 15
Advances in forest restoration management and technology
Stanturf, J. A., Dumroese, R. K., Elliott, S., Ivetić, V., Khokthong, W., Kleine, M., Lang, M., Löf, M., Madsen, P., Prescott, C. E., et al. (2024) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/9780197683958.003.0011 · Cited by 15
Wu, Y., Zhang, R., MacDougall, A. S., Tian, D., Wang, J., & Niu, S. (2025) · Global Ecology and Biogeography · doi:10.1111/geb.70063 · Cited by 15
Brouwer, R. G., Peña‐Claros, M., Bongers, F., Poorter, L., Guillemot, J., de Almeida, D. R. A., de Almeida, C. T., de Resende, A. F., Simões, L. H. P., Ivanauskas, N. M., et al. (2025) · Biological Conservation · doi:10.1016/j.biocon.2025.111269 · Cited by 14
Wan, L., Liu, G., Fu, B., Hu, Y., & Su, X. (2025) · Journal of Applied Ecology · doi:10.1111/1365-2664.70221 · Cited by 14
Predicting landscape‐scale biodiversity recovery by natural tropical forest regrowth
Prieto, P. V., Bukoski, J. J., Barros, F. S. M., Beyer, H. L., Iribarrem, Á., Brancalion, P. H. S., Chazdon, R. L., Lindenmayer, D. B., Strassburg, B. B. N., Guariguata, M. R., et al. (2021) · Conservation Biology · doi:10.1111/cobi.13842 · Cited by 14
“Another limitation of our study is a potential bias toward positive site selection in studies of natural forest regrowth; most studies reported only those cases in which natural forest regrowth succeeded in reestablishing a forest community (Reid et al., 2018).”
BackgroundSimler‐Williamson, A. B., Applestein, C. V., & Germino, M. J. (2022) · Conservation Science and Practice · doi:10.1111/csp2.12737 · Cited by 14
“…(given their environmental context) are particularly important considering that restoration treatments may be disproportionately applied to more stressful or degraded sites, compared to the full climatic range of sagebrush steppe ecosystems (Reid et al., 2018; Simler-Williamson & Germino, 2022).”
BackgroundGarcía, J. M. D., López‐Barrera, F., Toledo‐Aceves, T., Andresen, E., Moreno, C. E., & Pineda, E. (2022) · Ecological Engineering · doi:10.1016/j.ecoleng.2022.106806 · Cited by 13
Cost‐effectiveness of management strategies in a nucleation experiment in a tropical dry forest
Toro, L., Torres-Romero, F. J., Salinas, S. M., Muñoz, A. A., Galatowitsch, S. M., Secchi, S., & Powers, J. S. (2024) · Restoration Ecology · doi:10.1111/rec.14094 · Cited by 13
“Their effectiveness in most tropical areas is still uncertain because most passive restoration projects tend to be established in areas where secondary succession is ongoing, and usually rapidly (Reid et al. 2018).”
BackgroundLing, P., Aguilar‐Amuchastegui, N., Baldwin-Cantello, W., Rayden, T., Gordon, J., Dainton, S., Bagwill, A., & Pacheco, P. (2023) · Environmental Research Letters · doi:10.1088/1748-9326/accfaf · Cited by 12
Tang, F., Quan, W., Li, C., Huang, X., Wu, X., Yang, Q., Pan, Y., Xu, T., Qian, C., & Gu, Y. (2019) · International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health · doi:10.3390/ijerph16111919 · Cited by 12
Smart allocation of restoration funds over space and time
Shoo, L. P., Catterall, C. P., Beyer, H. L., Cockbain, P., Duncan, M., Robson, T., Roche, D., Taylor, H., White, Z., & Wilson, K. A. (2021) · Ecological Applications · doi:10.1002/eap.2448 · Cited by 13
Constantz, B., Stella, J. C., & Holl, K. D. (2025) · Ecological Applications · doi:10.1002/eap.70043 · Cited by 11
Metadata
- Authors
- Reid, J. L., Fagan, M. E., & Zahawi, R. A.
- Affiliations
- Missouri Botanical Garden (US)
- University of Maryland, Baltimore County (US)
- University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa (US)
- Corresponding author
- Reid, J. Leighton
- Venue
- Science Advances
- Published
- 2018-05-04
- Volume
- 4
- Issue
- 5
- Pages
- eaas9143-eaas9143
- ISSN
- 2375-2548 (ISSN-L)
- PMC
- PMC5955619
- OpenAlex
- W2804830460
- Cited by
- 178
- References
- 31
- Citations by year
- 2026: 15 · 2025: 21 · 2024: 24 · 2023: 19 · 2022: 24 · 2021: 24 · 2020: 20 · 2019: 25 · 2018: 6
- FWCI
- 1.65
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- gold
- doi.org
- Licence
- cc-by-nc
- Locations
- Science Advances (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- Europe PMC (PubMed Central) (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- PubMed (publishedVersion)
- ANU Open Research (Australian National University) (acceptedVersion)
- Maryland Shared Open Access Repository (USMAI Consortium) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- Digital Repository at the University of Maryland (University of Maryland College Park)
- Topics
- Life Sciences › Agricultural and Biological Sciences › Forestry › Seedling growth and survival studies
- Physical Sciences › Environmental Science › Nature and Landscape Conservation › Ecology and Vegetation Dynamics Studies
- Physical Sciences › Environmental Science › Global and Planetary Change › Conservation, Biodiversity, and Resource Management
- Keywords
- natural regeneration, tree planting, tropical forest recovery, secondary forest, meta-analysis bias
- MeSH terms
- Conservation of Natural Resources, Humans, Tropical Climate, Selection Bias, Ecosystem, Forests
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.
