Finding application errors and security flaws using PQL: a program query language

Abstract

A number of effective error detection tools have been built in recent years to check if a program conforms to certain design rules. An important class of design rules deals with sequences of events asso-ciated with a set of related objects. This paper presents a language called PQL (Program Query Language) that allows programmers to express such questions easily in an application-specific context. A query looks like a code excerpt corresponding to the shortest amount of code that would violate a design rule. Details of the tar-get application's precise implementation are abstracted away. The programmer may also specify actions to perform when a match is found, such as recording relevant information or even correcting an erroneous execution on the fly.We have developed both static and dynamic techniques to find solutions to PQL queries. Our static analyzer finds all potential matches conservatively using a context-sensitive, flow-insensitive, inclusion-based pointer alias analysis. Static results are also use-ful in reducing the number of instrumentation points for dynamic analysis. Our dynamic analyzer instruments the source program to catch all violations precisely as the program runs and to optionally perform user-specified actions.We have implemented the techniques described in this paper and found 206 errors in 6 large real-world open-source Java applica-tions containing a total of nearly 60,000 classes. These errors are important security flaws, resource leaks, and violations of consis-tency invariants. The combination of static and dynamic analysis proves effective at addressing a wide range of debugging and pro-gram comprehension queries. We have found that dynamic analysis is especially suitable for preventing errors such as security vulner-abilities at runtime.