CoChat

Have a Korean Lineage and Transmit a Chinese One Too: Lineage Practices in Seon Buddhism

Ahn, Juhn Y. · 2020 · Journal of Chan Buddhism

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 21 of the 21 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Abstract

Abstract Today, Korean dharma lineages all trace themselves back to Seosan Hyujeong 西山休靜 (1520–1604). Although some claim that Hyujeong’s own lineage should be traced back to Taego Bou 太古普愚 (1301–1382), others claim that it should be traced back to Naong Hyegeun 懶翁慧勤 (1320–1376) instead. The present article will demonstrate that both claims are flawed. They fail to take an important fact into account: the assumptions that guided lineage practices in the fourteenth century were no longer guiding lineage practices in the seventeenth century, which is when both claims were first made. Attempts to trace Hyujeong’s lineage to either Taego or Naong mistakenly accept the veracity of seventeenth-century lineage claims and assumptions. In pre-seventeenth century Korea Seon masters who received dharma transmission in China officially recognized not only their Chinese Chan lineage but also their Korean Seon lineage(s). As shown in this article, there was nothing wrong with having two or more dharma lineages in Korea. Hyegeun is a good example. He claimed to have inherited two different dharma lineages and may have even had a third. Hyegeun’s lineage began to lose favor, this article argues, because it did not accord with the new assumptions that began to guide lineage practices in seventeenth-century Korea.

Overview

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1163/25897179-12340001

Cites

21 of 21 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Recomputing p-values needs the paper’s full text.

Verification

Claims the paper makes

This paper’s full text isn’t openly available, so its claims and self-check weren’t run. The registry and citation checks still apply.

Citations

Cites

Show all 21 references

Research works printed but not linked: 21

  1. Seoyeok Junghwa Haedong buljo weollyu 西域中華海東佛祖源流 [Origin and Spread of the Buddhas and Patriarchs of India, China, and Korea]. By Chae Yeong 采永 (fl. 18th C.), 1764. References made to the hand-copied edition (1914) currently housed in the East Asia Library at the University of California Berkeley.
  2. Ahn, Juhn Y. ‘The Origins of the Public Chan or Sŏn Monastery in Korea: The Monk Tamjin and his Impact on Sŏn Buddhism.’ Unpublished paper presented at ‘Creating the World Chan/Sŏn/Zen’ Conference, University of Arizona.
  3. Bak Hae-dang 박해당. ‘Jogyejong beoptongseol e daehan bipanjeok geomto’ 曹溪宗 法統說에 대한 비판적 검토 [A Critical Examination of the Jogye Order’s Dharma Lineage Theory]. Cheorhak sasang 哲學思想 11 (2000): 51–74.
  4. Bak Yun-jin 朴胤珍. ‘Silla-mal Goryeo-cho eui “bulbeop tongnyuseol” ’ 신라말 고려초의 “佛法東流說” [The “Flow of the Teachings of the Buddha to the East” Theory during the Late Silla and Early Goryeo Period]. Hanguk chungsesa yeon-gu 한국중세사연구 21 (2006): 221–253.
  5. Bak Yun-jin 朴胤珍. ‘Silla-mal Goryeo-cho goseungbi e boineun jongbeopjeok pyohyeon gwa gyebo insik’ 新羅末 高麗初 高僧碑에 보이는 종법적 표현과 계보 인식 [Patrilineal Expressions and Genealogical Thinking in the Steles for Eminent Monks from the Late Silla and Early Goryeo Period]. Sahak yeon-gu 사학연구 109 (2013): 1–40.
  6. Choe Byeong-heon 崔柄憲. ‘Joseon sidae Bulgyo beoptongseol eui munje’ 朝鮮時代佛教法統說의問題 [Problems with Theories about the Dharma Lineage of Joseon Period Buddhism]. Hanguksaron 한국사론 19 (1988): 281–293.
  7. Duan Yuming 段玉明. ‘ “Zhikong heshang chanyao lu” yanjiu’ <<指空和尚禪要錄>> 研究 [A Study of the Record of Seon Essentials by the Venerable Jigong]. Zongjiaoxue yanjiu 宗教學研究 2 (2007): 61–68.
  8. Gim Yeong-mi 김영미. ‘Namal Ryeocho seonsadeul eui gyebo insik’ 나말려초 선사 (禪師) 들의 계보인식 [Lineage Consciousness among Seon Masters of the Late Silla and Early Goryeo Period]. Yeoksa wa hyeonsil 56 (2005): 52–80.
  9. Gim Yeong-su 金映遂. ‘Ogyo yangjong e daehaya’ 五教兩宗에 대하야 [On the Five Doctrinal Schools and Two Seon Orders]. Jindan hakbo 8 (1937): 74–101.
  10. Gim Yeong-tae 김영태. ‘Huiyangsanpa eui seongnip gwa keu beopgye e daehayeo’ 희양산선파 (曦陽山禪派) 의 성립과 그 법계에 대하여 [On the Lineage and Formation of the Huiyang-san School], Hanguk Bulgyohak 4 (1979): 11–38.
  11. Gim Yeong-tae 김영태. ‘Joseon Seonga eui beoptonggo – Seosan gatong eui gyumyeong’ 朝鮮禪家의 法統考 – 西山家統의 究明 [Thoughts on the Dharma Lineage of the Korean Seon Tradition: A Study of Seosan’s Lineage]. Bulgyo hakbo 佛教學報 22 (1985): 11–44.
  12. Go Ik-jin 高翊晉. ‘Byeoksong Jieom eui sin jaryo wa beoptong munje’ 碧松智嚴의 新資料와 法統問題 [New Sources on Byeoksong Jieom and the Question of Dharma Lineage]. Bulgyo hakbo 佛教學報 22 (1985): 203–212.
  13. Jo Beom-hwan. ‘Silla hadae Weon-gam seonsa Hyeonuk eui Namjong Seon suyong kwa hwaldong’ 新羅下代 圓鑑禪師 玄昱의 南宗禪 受容과 活動 [Reception and Activities of the Southern School Seon of Seon Master Weon-gam Hyeonuk of the Late Silla Period]. Dongbuga munhwa yeon-gu 동북아문제연구 14 (2008): 5–28.
  14. Nam Dongsin. ‘Yeomal Seoncho-gi Naong hyeonchang undong’ 여말선초기 현창운동 [The Late Goryeo and Early Joseon Movement to Apotheosize Naong]. Hanguksa yeongu 한국사연구 139 (2007): 161–2003.
  15. Seongcheol 性徹. Hanguk Bulgyo ui beommaek, jeungbopan 韓國佛教의 法脈 증보판 [The Dharma Lineage of Korean Buddhism, Expanded Edition]. Gyeongnam Hapcheon-gun: Janggyeonggak 藏經閣, 1990.
  16. Son Seong-pil. ‘17-segi jeonban goseungbi geollip gwa Joseon Bulgyogye’ 17 세기 전반 高僧碑 건립과 조선 불교계 [The Erection of Eminent Monk Steles in the Early 17th Century and Joseon Buddhism]. Hanguksa yeongu 한국사연구 156 (2012): 145–190.
  17. Son Seong-pil. ‘17-segi Buhyu-gye seungdo eui bi geollip gwa munpa jeongcheseong eui hyeongseong’ 17 세기 浮休系 僧徒의 碑 건립과 門派 정체성의 형성 [Stele Erection in the 17th Century by Buhhyu-line Monks and the Formation of Sectarian Identity]. Joseon sidae sahakbo 조선시대사학보 83 (2017): 129–171.
  18. Uhlmann, Patrick R., trans. Anthology of Stele Inscriptions of Eminent Korean Buddhist Monks, Collected Works of Korean Buddhism 12, edited by John Jorgensen. Seoul: Compilation Committee of Korean Buddhist Through, Jogye Order of Korean Buddhism, 2012.
  19. Yeom Jung-seop 염중섭. ‘Jigong eui gagye jujang e daehan geomto – Goryeo eseo Jigong eui seonggong yoin eul jungsimeuro’ 指空의 家系주장에 대한 검토 – 고려에서 지공의 성공요인을 중심으로 [A Review of the Genealogical Claims of Jigong: Focusing on the Factors of Jigong’s Success in Goryeo]. Jindan hakbo 震檀學報 120 (2014): 31–53.
  20. Yeom Jung-seop 염중섭. ‘Naong eui buchim gwa gwallyeondoen Jigong eui yeonghyang: Jigong e daehan insik eui byeonhwa reul jungsimeuro’ 나옹懶翁의 부침浮沈과 관련된 지공指空의 영향 – 지공指空에 대한 인식의 변화를 중심으로 [The Influence of Jigong on the Rise and Fall of Naong: Focusing on the Changing Attitudes Toward Jigong]. Gukhak yeongu 국학연구 24 (2014): 93–127.
  21. Yeom Jung-seop 염중섭. ‘Hwanam Honsu eui sabeop jeonghwang gwa beopgye e daehan insik byeonhwa I – Naong e daehan sabeop gwan’gye reul jungsimeuro’ 환암혼수幻菴混修의 사법嗣法 정황과 법계法系에 대한 인식변화 I – 나옹懶翁에 대한 사법 관계를 중심으로 [The Circumstances of Hwanam Honsu’s Dharma Succession and the Transformation of Lineage Consciousness I: Focusing on Naong’s Dharma Successors]. Gukhak yeongu 국학연구 33 (2017): 301–340.

Metadata

Authors
Ahn, J. Y.
Affiliations
University of Michigan (US)
Corresponding author
Ahn, Juhn Y.
Venue
Journal of Chan Buddhism
Published
2020-12-22
Volume
1
Issue
1-2
Pages
178-209
ISSN
  • 2589-7160 (ISSN-L)
  • 2589-7179
OpenAlex
W3116305872
Cited by
0
References
16
FWCI
0.00
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
closed
Locations
Journal of Chan Buddhism (publishedVersion)
Topics
  • Social Sciences › Arts and Humanities › Religious studies › Indian and Buddhist Studies
  • Social Sciences › Arts and Humanities › History › Chinese history and philosophy
  • Social Sciences › Arts and Humanities › Philosophy › Study and Philosophy of Religion
Keywords
Seon Buddhism, dharma transmission

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Have a Korean Lineage and Transmit a Chinese One Too: Lineage Practices in Seon Buddhism. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1163/25897179-12340001
The paper
Ahn, J. Y. (2020). Have a Korean Lineage and Transmit a Chinese One Too: Lineage Practices in Seon Buddhism. Journal of Chan Buddhism. https://doi.org/10.1163/25897179-12340001

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.