A case study of binary outcome data extraction across three systematic reviews of hip arthroplasty: errors and differences of selection
Open accessThe DOI matches its Crossref record; 25 of the 26 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Data extraction is a key stage in systematic review, yet it is the subject of little research. The aim of the present research was to use a small case study to highlight some important issues affecting this fundamental process. METHODS: The authors undertook an analysis of differences in the binary event data extracted and analysed by three systematic reviews on the same topic: a comparison of total hip arthroplasty and hemiarthroplasty. The following binary event data were extracted for three key outcomes, common to all three reviews, from those trials common to all three reviews: Dislocation rates, 1-year mortality, and revision rates. Differences between the data extracted by the three reviews were categorised as either errors or an issue of data selection. Meta-analysis was performed to assess whether these differences led to differences in summary estimates of effect. RESULTS: Across the three outcomes, differences in selection accounted for between 8% and 42% of the data differences between reviews, and errors accounted for between 8% and 17%. No rationale was given in any of these former cases for the choice of event data being reported. These differences did lead to small differences in meta-analysed relative risks between the two treatments in the three reviews, but none was significant. CONCLUSIONS: Systematic reviewers should use double-data extraction to minimise error and also make every effort to clarify or explain their choice of data, within the scope of their publication. Reviewers frequently exercise selection when faced with a choice of alternative but potentially equally appropriate data for an outcome. However, this selection is rarely made clear by review authors. Systematic review was developed as a method specifically to be both reproducible and transparent. This case study suggests that neither objective is always being achieved.
Overview
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Claims other papers make about this one
Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?
The cited source doesn’t support the claim as written.
In the citing paper
“The rate of data extraction errors ranged between 8% and 42% (depending on outcome and review).”
From Frequency of data extraction errors and methods to increase data extraction quality: a methodological review (2017) · cites this paper as [16]
Checked by a reasoning model — may be wrong.
Experimental — accuracy not yet measuredThe source backs part of the claim, not all of it — or backs it for a different population, condition or comparison.
In the citing paper
“Differences in pooled effect estimates were small (difference of relative risk, range: 0.01–0.05).”
From Frequency of data extraction errors and methods to increase data extraction quality: a methodological review (2017) · cites this paper as [16]
Experimental — accuracy not yet measuredThe source backs part of the claim, not all of it — or backs it for a different population, condition or comparison.
In the citing paper
“There is a high prevalence of extraction errors [ 8 , 13 , 15 , 16 ].”
From Frequency of data extraction errors and methods to increase data extraction quality: a methodological review (2017) · cites this paper as [16]
Experimental — accuracy not yet measuredThe source backs part of the claim, not all of it — or backs it for a different population, condition or comparison.
In the citing paper
“This might cause relevant bias in effect estimates [ 8 , 15 – 17 ].”
From Frequency of data extraction errors and methods to increase data extraction quality: a methodological review (2017) · cites this paper as [16]
Experimental — accuracy not yet measuredThe source backs part of the claim, not all of it — or backs it for a different population, condition or comparison.
In the citing paper
“However, we addressed this by performing randomized and blinded adjudication, adopting best practices seen in radiology, ophthalmology, and clinical trials 28-31 .”
From Automation of Systematic Reviews with Large Language Models (2025) · cites this paper as [28]
Experimental — accuracy not yet measured
2 more claims about this paper
Create a free account to see every claim other papers make about this one.
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
The self-check needs the paper’s full text.
Citations
Cites
Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses
Higgins, J. P. T., Thompson, S. G., Deeks, J. J., & Altman, D. G. (2003) · BMJ · doi:10.1136/bmj.327.7414.557 · Cited by 63,139 · cited 2×
“Examples of this include the BMJ review’s inclusion of revisions and exclusions as deaths, without imputation for these missing data [14], and excessive extrapolation (6-month data as 1 year data) (see Table 3 and [10]).”
BackgroundGRADE guidelines: 4. Rating the quality of evidence—study limitations (risk of bias)
Guyatt, G. H., Oxman, A. D., Vist, G., Kunz, R., Brozek, J., Alonso-Coello, P., Montori, V., Akl, E. A., Djulbegovic, B., & Falck-Ytter, Y. (2011) · Journal of Clinical Epidemiology · doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2010.07.017 · Cited by 2,798 · cited 1×
“[15] We feel that an appeal for similar clarity is required for the data extraction process.”
BackgroundSystematic Reviews in Health Care : Meta-Analysis in Context
Egger, M., Smith, G. D., & Altman, D. G. (2000) · Cited by 2,401
Systematic Reviews in Health Care: Meta‐Analysis in Context
(2001) · doi:10.1002/9780470693926 · Cited by 1,693
Post-randomisation exclusions: the intention to treat principle and excluding patients from analysis
Fergusson, D., Aaron, S. D., Guyatt, G., & Hébert, P. (2002) · BMJ · doi:10.1136/bmj.325.7365.652 · Cited by 708 · cited 2×
“[13] If these are included, then explicit best and worst case analyses perhaps should have been performed, with imputations explained [14]”
BackgroundSingle data extraction generated more errors than double data extraction in systematic reviews
Buscemi, N., Hartling, L., Vandermeer, B., Tjosvold, L., & Klassen, T. P. (2006) · Journal of Clinical Epidemiology · doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2005.11.010 · Cited by 464 · cited 7×
“Errors have been defined in various ways in these studies, principally as inaccuracies, omissions, inadequacies and incomplete data [1,2].”
BackgroundInfluentialBAKER, R. P., SQUIRES, B., GARGAN, M. F., & BANNISTER, G. C. (2006) · The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery-American Volume · doi:10.2106/00004623-200612000-00004 · Cited by 440 · cited 2×
“They appear to occur principally due to human error, although double data extraction should minimise the chance of such bias or random ted in the 3 reviews (RR, 95% CI), p value error [16].”
BackgroundKEATING, J. F., GRANT, A., MASSON, M., SCOTT, N. W., & FORBES, J. F. (2006) · The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery-American Volume · doi:10.2106/00004623-200602000-00001 · Cited by 423 · cited 1×
“Both the BMJ and Cochrane reviews reported using this approach, and the number of errors was indeed relatively small, usually no more than 8% of the data for any of the three outcomes assessed.”
MethodArthroplasties (with and without bone cement) for proximal femoral fractures in adults
Parker, M. J., Gurusamy, K. S., & Azegami, S. (2010) · Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews · doi:10.1002/14651858.cd001706.pub4 · Cited by 391
Ravikumar, K. J., & Marsh, G. (2000) · Injury · doi:10.1016/s0020-1383(00)00125-x · Cited by 380 · cited 1×
“The incidence of errors appears to be low based on this small case study sample.”
Background
Research works printed but not linked: 3
- Liang LZ: Meta analysis of total hip arthroplasty versus hemiarthroplasty for displaced femoral neck fractures in elderly patients. J Clin Rehab Tissue Eng Res. 2010, 14: 3991-3995.
- Carroll C, Scope A, Kaltenthaler E, Stevenson M: Re: Extraction and analysis errors and queries: Author Response. Br Med J. 2010, 340: c2332-10.1136/bmj.c2332. · DOI · Paper page
- Higgins J, Green S: Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011]. 2011, The Cochrane Collaboration, Available from http://www.cochrane-handbook.org
Cited by
Mathes, T., Klaßen, P., & Pieper, D. (2017) · BMC Medical Research Methodology · doi:10.1186/s12874-017-0431-4 · Cited by 240
“Carroll 2013 [16] 8 (3) Selection (outcome 1) 17% (review 1 vs.”
BackgroundResultInfluentialAutomation of Systematic Reviews with Large Language Models
Cao, C., Arora, R., Cento, P., Budak, A., Manta, K., Farahani, E., Cecere, M., Selemon, A., Sang, J., Gong, L. X., et al. (2025) · medRxiv · doi:10.1101/2025.06.13.25329541 · Cited by 33
Reproducibility and replicability of systematic reviews
Shokraneh, F. (2019) · World Journal of Meta-Analysis · doi:10.13105/wjma.v7.i3.66 · Cited by 29
Yet another problem with systematic reviews: a living review update
Uttley, L., Weng, Y., & Falzon, L. (2024) · Journal of Clinical Epidemiology · doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111608 · Cited by 27
Lu, C., Wu, S., Ke, L., Liu, F., Shang, W., Deng, X., Huang, Y., Zhang, Q., Cui, X., Mentis, A. A., et al. (2022) · Frontiers in Pharmacology · doi:10.3389/fphar.2022.901875 · Cited by 22
Metadata
- Authors
- Carroll, C., Scope, A., & Kaltenthaler, E.
- Affiliations
- University of Sheffield (GB)
- Corresponding author
- Carroll, Christopher
- Venue
- BMC Research Notes
- Published
- 2013-12
- Volume
- 6
- Issue
- 1
- Pages
- 539-539
- ISSN
- 1756-0500 (ISSN-L)
- PMC
- PMC3878552
- OpenAlex
- W1980640998
- Cited by
- 18
- References
- 26
- Citations by year
- 2026: 3 · 2025: 2 · 2024: 2 · 2023: 1 · 2022: 1 · 2021: 3 · 2019: 3 · 2018: 1 · 2017: 2
- FWCI
- 0.00
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- gold
- doi.org
- Licence
- cc-by
- creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0 (tdm)
- Locations
- BMC Research Notes (publishedVersion, cc-by)
- PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
- PubMed (publishedVersion)
- White Rose Research Online (University of Leeds, The University of Sheffield, University of York) (acceptedVersion)
- Topics
- Social Sciences › Decision Sciences › Statistics, Probability and Uncertainty › Meta-analysis and systematic reviews
- Social Sciences › Sociology and Political Science › Delphi Technique in Research
- Physical Sciences › Mathematics › Statistics and Probability › Statistical Methods in Epidemiology
- Keywords
- data extraction errors, total hip arthroplasty, hemiarthroplasty, dislocation rate, revision rate, one-year mortality
- MeSH terms
- Data Collection, Humans, Research Design, Meta-Analysis as Topic, Publication Bias, Arthroplasty, Replacement, Hip
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
How to cite
Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.
- This page
- CoChat. (2026). Citation check: A case study of binary outcome data extraction across three systematic reviews of hip arthroplasty: errors and differences of selection. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1186/1756-0500-6-539
- The paper
- Carroll, C., Scope, A., & Kaltenthaler, E. (2013). A case study of binary outcome data extraction across three systematic reviews of hip arthroplasty: errors and differences of selection. BMC Research Notes. https://doi.org/10.1186/1756-0500-6-539
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.