Patients’ experiences of assessment and detention under mental health legislation: systematic review and qualitative meta-synthesis

Akther, Syeda Ferhana, Molyneaux, Emma, Stuart, Ruth, Johnson, Sonia, Simpson, Alan, Oram, Sian·2019·BJPsych Open
DOI 10.1192/bjo.2019.19

Cited by (199)

Items 101–199 of 199

  1. A suitable manner? Seven key elements of a dialogical approach to the Mental Health Act Assessment
    Tom Cant, Rob Manchester · 2025 · BJPsych Advances
  2. Exploring pathways to compulsory detention and ways to prevent repeat compulsory detentions in England; clinician perspectives
    Ariana Kular, Mary Birken, Lisa Wood, Jordan Parkinson, Theresa Bacarese-Hamilton, Louise Blakley, Chloë Hutchings-Hay, Patrick Nyikavaranda, Dilshard Alam, Raphael Emeka Ogbolu et al. · 2025 · PLOS mental health.
  3. Truly Listening to Accounts of Mental Health Act Assessments: Reflections on my Practice
    Louise Blakley · 2023 · The British Journal of Social Work
  4. Area-level factors associated with variation in involuntary psychiatric hospitalisation across England: a cross-sectional, ecological study
    Matilda Minchin, Colette Christiansen, Lucy C. Maconick, Sonia Johnson · 2024 · Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology
  5. Misdiagnosed, mismanaged, mistreated: personality disorders and the Mental Health Act
    Ruslan Zinchenko, Hosam Elhamoui · 2025 · BJPsych Bulletin
  6. Experiences of reintegration, relapse, and readmission: a qualitative study among patients with alcohol use disorder in Uganda
    Hillary Mugabo Mukula, Morris Ndeezi, Harriet Opondo, Samuel Ouma, Khamisi Musanje · 2025 · Frontiers in Public Health
  7. Catastrophic Health Expenditure in Mental Health as Coercion in Post–Suicide Attempt Care: A Population-Based Study in Latin America
    Felipe Agudelo‐Hernández, Laura Fernanda Murillo-Alzate · 2026 · International Journal of Social Psychiatry
  8. ‘ Finally, I feel listened to ’: hearing the voices of those with mental health challenges – using WRAP to formulate an advance healthcare directive
    Michael John Norton · 2026 · Irish Journal of Psychological Medicine
  9. Involuntary Psychiatric Holds in Acute Care Settings: Implications for Emergency Department Capacity and Care — A Narrative Review
    A F Brown, Cole Ettingoff, Joshua J. Davis, Heather Henderson · 2025 · Journal of Emergency Medicine
  10. A crisis-focused cognitive behavioural informed approach to formulating experiences of psychosis in acute mental health inpatient settings
    Lisa Wood, Anthony P. Morrison, Claire Williams, Barbara Lay, Sonia Johnson · 2025 · Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy
  11. Legislative differences in compulsory mental health care for children and adolescents across European countries
    Tjaša Vranetič, Konsta Hakala, Jörg Michael Fegert, Maja Drobnič Radobuljac, Riittakerttu Kaltiala‐Heino, Robert R. J. M. Vermeiren, Astrid Moell · 2026 · European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
  12. Patient experiences of coercion in mental healthcare: systematic review and metasummary of qualitative studies from 1991 to 2025
    Olav Nyttingnes, Tonje Lossius Husum, Solveig Helene Høymork Kjus, Tiina Överlund, Jorun Rugkåsa · 2026 · BJPsych Open
  13. Unpacking assisted admissions under the Mental Health Care Act 17 of 2002
    Kalpesh Narsi · 2022 · South African Family Practice
  14. Can using the Cochrane RCT classifier in EPPI‐Reviewer help speed up study selection in qualitative evidence syntheses? A retrospective evaluation
    Heather Melanie R. Ames, Christine Hillestad Hestevik, Patricia Sofia Jacobsen Jardim, Martin Smådal Larsen, Lars Jørun Langøien, Hans Bugge Bergsund, Tiril Cecilie Borge · 2025 · Cochrane Evidence Synthesis and Methods
  15. The impact of the duration of untreated psychosis on the risk of involuntary hospitalization during the first psychotic episode
    V. А. Chinarev, Елена Викторовна Малинина · 2025 · Medical Herald of the South of Russia
  16. Ethnic disparity in mental health legislation at the point of inpatient entry: pilot review in detained adolescents with developmental disorders
    Deborah J. Morris, Elanor Lucy Webb, Lowri Foster-Davies, Paul M. Wallang, David Gibbs, Peter D. McAllister, Farshad Shaddel · 2021 · Journal of Forensic Practice
  17. Vice and Psychiatric Diagnosis
    John Z. Sadler · 2024
  18. BJPsych Open: celebrating 10 years of publishing excellence: a decade in review
    Kenneth R. Kaufman · 2025 · BJPsych Open
  19. In B.C., Alberta and around the world, forcing drug users into treatment is a violent policy
    Tyson Singh Kelsall, Lyana Patrick, Alya Govorchin · 2023
  20. Putting the Hope Back In: Making the Case for Solution Focused Practice in AMHP Interventions
    Nick Perry, Kelly Alexander, Jill Hemmington · 2026 · Journal of solution-focused brief therapy
  21. “Backed into a Corner”: Lived experiences of receiving and providing involuntary psychiatric treatment under British Columbia’s Mental Health Act
    Snow, Mary Elizabeth, Salmon, Amy, Banjo, Jenyo, Morrow, Marina, Varcoe, Colleen · 2026 · PLOS One
  22. Preventing prejudice by preserving the spirit of mental health legislation during the COVID-19 national emergency
    Calina Ouliaris, Linda Sheahan, Duncan George · 2020 · Australasian Psychiatry
  23. Being recovery-oriented and reducing the use of restrictive interventions in mental health care
    Lisa Mary Brophy, Justine R. Fletcher, Bridget Elizabeth Hamilton · 2020 · Routledge eBooks
  24. Effects of temporary psychiatric holds on length of stay and readmission risk among persons admitted for psychotic disorders
    Tyler A. Durns, Patrick O'Connell, Anna Shvartsur, Jessica S. Grey, Brent Michael Kious · 2021 · International Journal of Law and Psychiatry
  25. What does safety in acute mental health units mean for consumers
    Natalie Ann Cutler · 2021 · Research Online (University of Wollongong)
  26. Capacity and Consent in the Criminal and Civil Contexts
    Ailbhe O’Loughlin · 2021 · Cambridge University Press eBooks
  27. Civil Proceedings
    Jennifer M. Brown, Miranda A. H. Horvath · 2021 · Cambridge University Press eBooks
  28. MEDICINE OF BORDERLINE CONDITIONS AS AN INNOVATIVE DIRECTION FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF PREVENTIVE MEDICINE: review
    Vоlоdymyr Korobchanskyі, Vladyslava V. Sarkis-Ivanova, Igor Rechkiman, Оксана Володимирівна Веремієнко, Olga Gerasymenko · 2022 · Inter Collegas
  29. Factors associated with involuntary hospitalization
    Emilija Novaković, Ivana Stašević-Karličić, Mirjana Stojanović-Tasić, T. Novaković, Jovana Milošević, Vladan Đorđević · 2021 · Praxis medica
  30. First-tier Tribunal (Mental Health) hearings: protecting the therapeutic relationship
    Helen Rees · 2023 · Mental Health Practice
  31. Exploring the Experiences of Black Men Through the Decision-Making Process in Secure Settings: A Qualitative Study
    Chanae Mayers, Kim Gordon · 2023 · Journal of Black Psychology
  32. Deepening the analysis of the vice/mental disorder relationship
    John Z. Sadler · 2024 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  33. Vice and mental illness—an ancient-to-modern iconography
    John Z. Sadler · 2024 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  34. Introductions literal and metaphorical
    John Z. Sadler · 2024 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  35. The public interest context of the VMDR
    John Z. Sadler · 2024 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  36. Conceptual paradoxes in vice and mental disorder
    John Z. Sadler · 2024 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  37. Forty theses: Conclusions, implications, and prescriptions
    John Z. Sadler · 2024 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  38. Copyright Page
    2024 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  39. The legal and criminal justice context of the VMDR
    John Z. Sadler · 2024 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  40. Building a moral-medical psychiatry
    John Z. Sadler · 2024 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  41. Preface and acknowledgments
    2024 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  42. Vice and the DSMs—the problems
    John Z. Sadler · 2024 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  43. Activity and Positive Engagement within a PICU
    Rebecca Davies, Robert Rathouse, Wendy Sherwood · 2024 · Cambridge University Press eBooks
  44. Improving reasonable adjustments for people with learning disabilities in mental health tribunals
    Indermeet Sawhney, Neeraj Prabhakaran, Asif Zia, Chetan P. Shah · 2024 · Learning Disability Practice
  45. Anorexia Nervosa: The Making of the First Eating Disorder
    Alison M. Fixsen · 2024 · The politics of mental health and illness
  46. The Experience of Coercion and Violence: Service User, Professional and Informal Caregiver Perspectives
    Sabine Hahn, Melina Hasler, Sabine Rühle Andersson, Yvonne D. B. Bonner, Dirk Richter · 2024 · Springer eBooks
  47. “Presenting psychosis”: how is it triggered on a ward and interpreted by psychiatry and other health professionals?
    Benjamin Thomas Gray, Matthew Sisto, Renee Conley, India Sisto · 2025 · Mental Health and Social Inclusion
  48. Multidisciplinarity in Psychiatry
    Robert B. Dudas, Elizabeth Fistein, Toby Williamson · 2025 · Cambridge University Press eBooks
  49. Within the Walls: Experiences of Admission to Psychiatric Hospital in Ireland Prior to 2001
    Clare Graham, Anthony Webster, Suzanne Guérin, Keith Gaynor · 2025 · International Journal of Mental Health Nursing
  50. Attitudes and ethical beliefs of Russian psychiatrists towards the use of coercive treatment practices
    Andrew Stickley, Roman A. Koposov, Johan Isaksson, Tomiki Sumiyoshi, Oleg A. Ponomarev, Vladislav V. Ruchkin · 2025 · International Journal of Law and Psychiatry
  51. The contribution of BJPsych Open to the growing relevance of legal epidemiology
    Steve R Kisely, Ben Beaglehole · 2025 · BJPsych Open
  52. Decision of compulsory psychiatric hospitalization in patients referred to emergency departments for a first forensic expertise: Impact of the pre-existing care network
    Oussama Bikrani, Matthieu Hein, Axel Dossa, Benjamin Wacquier, Camille Point · 2025 · L Encéphale
  53. Mealtime practices in the treatment of restrictive eating disorders: an ethnographic study of Norwegian youth psychiatric units
    Tone Jørgensen, Trine Brinkmann, Ann-Karina Henriksen, Esben Olesen · 2025 · SSM - Mental Health
  54. Validity and reliability of the Japanese version of the admission experience survey in individuals with mental illness
    Mayui Nara, Asami Matsunaga, Yuuki Yamada, Chiyo Fujii, Maki Taniguchi · 2025 · International Journal of Law and Psychiatry
  55. Violencias psiquiátricas y activismo en salud mental: un estudio cualitativo
    Juan Brea Iglesias, Andrés Arias Astray, David Alonso González · 2025 · Prisma social
  56. Additional file 3 of A crisis planning and monitoring intervention to reduce compulsory hospital readmissions (FINCH study): protocol for a randomised controlled feasibility study
    Sonia Johnson, Mary Birken, Patrick Nyikavaranda, Ariana Kular, Rafael Gafoor, Jordan Parkinson, Chloë Hutchings-Hay, Gant, Thomas, Jazmin Molai, Rivera, Jessica et al. · 2024 · Figshare
  57. Additional file 2 of A crisis planning and monitoring intervention to reduce compulsory hospital readmissions (FINCH study): protocol for a randomised controlled feasibility study
    Sonia Johnson, Mary Birken, Patrick Nyikavaranda, Ariana Kular, Rafael Gafoor, Jordan Parkinson, Chloë Hutchings-Hay, Thomas Gant, Jazmin Molai, Rivera, Jessica et al. · 2024 · Figshare
  58. Additional file 2 of A systematic review of people’s lived experiences of inpatient treatment for anorexia nervosa: living in a “bubble”
    Rebekah M. Rankin, Janet Conti, Lucie Michelle Ramjan, Hay, Phillipa · 2023 · Figshare
  59. Additional file 1 of A systematic review of people’s lived experiences of inpatient treatment for anorexia nervosa: living in a “bubble”
    Rebekah M. Rankin, Janet Conti, Lucie Michelle Ramjan, Hay, Phillipa · 2023 · Figshare
  60. Additional file 1 of A crisis planning and monitoring intervention to reduce compulsory hospital readmissions (FINCH study): protocol for a randomised controlled feasibility study
    Sonia Johnson, Mary Birken, Patrick Nyikavaranda, Ariana Kular, Rafael Gafoor, Jordan Parkinson, Chloë Hutchings-Hay, Thomas Gant, Jazmin Molai, Rivera, Jessica et al. · 2024 · Figshare
  61. Additional file 3 of A systematic review of people’s lived experiences of inpatient treatment for anorexia nervosa: living in a “bubble”
    Rebekah M. Rankin, Janet Conti, Lucie Michelle Ramjan, Hay, Phillipa · 2023 · Figshare
  62. Additional file 1 of Study protocol for an adaptive, multi-arm, multi-stage (MAMS) randomised controlled trial of brief remotely delivered psychosocial interventions for people with serious mental health problems who have experienced a recent suicidal crisis: Remote Approaches to Psychosocial Intervention Delivery (RAPID)
    Melissa Pyle, Lucy Loftus, Richard Emsley, Daniel H. Freeman, Steven Gillard, Andrew Ian Gumley, Justyna Sierpatowska, Lisa Wood, O’Connor, Rory C., Paul N Pfeiffer et al. · 2024 · Figshare
  63. Additional file 4 of A crisis planning and monitoring intervention to reduce compulsory hospital readmissions (FINCH study): protocol for a randomised controlled feasibility study
    Sonia Johnson, Mary Birken, Patrick Nyikavaranda, Ariana Kular, Rafael Gafoor, Jordan Parkinson, Chloë Hutchings-Hay, Gant, Thomas, Jazmin Molai, Rivera, Jessica et al. · 2024 · Figshare
  64. Feasibility testing and preliminary trial of a crisis planning and monitoring intervention to reduce compulsory readmissions: the FINCH Study
    Sonia Johnson, M. Birken, R. Gafoor, P. Nyikavaranda, A. Kular, J. Parkinson, K. Fraser, J. Hardy, M. Holden, L. Mitchell et al. · 2025 · BMC Medicine
  65. “Hospital or Prison! Not Both” Perspectives and Experiences of Forensic Psychiatric Patients on Hospitals in Türkiye
    Hakan Karaağaç, Didem Kaçar Adam, Tuğba Kara · 2026 · Journal of Forensic Psychology Research and Practice
  66. Managing Boundaries in a Borderland—Experiences of Independent Support Persons in Compulsory Psychiatric Care and Forensic Psychiatric Care
    Britt‐Marie Lindgren, Jenni Lahti Nilsson, Sebastian Gabrielsson, Jenny Molin · 2026 · Issues in Mental Health Nursing
  67. Coerción, trauma, y recuperación: un análisis crítico de los servicios de hospitalización en salud mental
    Hansel Duque, Stacia Alsabrook, Yuly Suárez Colorado, Jairo Gallo-Acosta, Edith T. Aristizábal Díaz-Granados · 2025 · Duazary
  68. Patient dignity in mental health care: from inherent worth to standing
    Caner Turan, Oliver Sensen · 2026 · Academia Mental Health and Well-Being
  69. Involuntary Hospitalization for Treatment: Triangulation of Perspectives of Patients, Relatives, and Professionals
    Sara Kærn Linstow, Katrine Schepelern Johansen, Mads Gram Henriksen, Julie Nordgaard, Annick Urfer-Parnas · 2026 · Psychopathology
  70. A service evaluation of restraint, seclusion and escalation in inpatient mental health care: a retrospective observational study in England
    Ndukwe Walter Ugwuocha, Oladayo O Bifarin, Chengeto Shoko, Simon Nielson, Alexander Challinor, Deborah Morgan, Andrew Jones, Nutmeg Hallett, Dan W. Joyce · 2026 · Research Square
  71. Understanding involuntary psychiatric hospitalisation: a thematic analysis and the Arc of Experience model
    Vasiliki Aliki Nikopoulou, Vasiliki Holeva, Ioannis Diakogiannis, Ioannis Nimatoudis, Eleni Parlapani · 2026 · Psychiatry Psychology and Law
  72. Psychosoziale Unterstützung ohne Zwang: Konsequenzen, Dilemmata und mögliche Auswege
    Dirk Richter · 2023 · Psychiatrie Verlag eBooks
  73. Danksagung
    Dirk Richter · 2023 · Psychiatrie Verlag eBooks
  74. Epilog
    Dirk Richter · 2023 · Psychiatrie Verlag eBooks
  75. Psychosoziale Probleme anders betrachten: das Spektrenmodell
    Dirk Richter · 2023 · Psychiatrie Verlag eBooks
  76. Einleitung: Menschenrechte und Zwang in der psychiatrischen Versorgung – Konzepte, Daten und Begrifflichkeiten
    Dirk Richter · 2023 · Psychiatrie Verlag eBooks
  77. Die Legitimation von psychiatrischen Maßnahmen gegen den Willen einer Person
    Dirk Richter · 2023 · Psychiatrie Verlag eBooks
  78. Recent clinical practice guidelines on schizophrenia remain largely silent on the role of coercion in psychiatric care
    Steve R Kisely, Lisa Mary Brophy, Tessa‐May Zirnsak, Sharon Lawn, Chris Maylea, Christopher J. Ryan · 2026 · Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry
  79. “My Body Was Never Mine”: An Arts-Based Phenomenological Analysis of Queer and Trans Adolescent Involuntary Psychiatric Hospitalization Experiences
    Megan Doyle · 2025 · Digital Commons - DU (University of Denver)
  80. Revised long version (KEZ-R) and short form (KEZ-S) of the Cologne Questionnaire on Attitudes towards Coercive Measures in in-patient mental healthcare
    Mario Schmitz-Buhl, Immanuel Baar, Euphrosyne Gouzoulis‐Mayfrank · 2026 · BJPsych Open
  81. De‐Escalation in United Kingdom Inpatient Mental Health Care: A Structured Critical Narrative Synthesis of People, Capability and Context
    Ndukwe Walter Ugwuocha, Simon Neilson, Alexander Challinor, Chengeto Shoko, Deborah Oyine Aluh, Oladayo O Bifarin · 2026 · International Journal of Mental Health Nursing
  82. Uptake and useability of a digital solution to assessing behaviours of concern in the emergency department: A multi-methods study
    Belinda Munroe, Kate Anne Curtis, Sarah Kourouche, Rachel Morland, Anna O’Hare, Emily Pfeffer, Samuel Jones, Kylie Harper, Timothy Wand · 2026 · Australasian Emergency Care
  83. Kafka on the Ward: The Kafkaesque Experience of Involuntary Psychiatric Admission
    Gustavo França · 2026 · Research Square
  84. The role of patient-reported outcomes at the interface between medicine and psychiatry: a systematic review of domains, measures, and longitudinal change in adult patients hospitalized for first-episode psychosis
    Pierluigi Catapano, Marika Menicucci, Anna Stifano, Giovanni Vasca, Valeria Del Vecchio, Francesco Perris, Salvatore Cipolla, Andrea Fiorillo, Gaia Sampogna · 2026 · International Review of Psychiatry
  85. Mind and Brain
    Joe Gough · 2026 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  86. After Mind
    Joe Gough · 2026
  87. Psychology
    Joe Gough · 2026 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  88. Mind and Law
    Joe Gough · 2026 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  89. Introduction: Conceptual Breakage
    Joe Gough · 2026 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  90. The Growth of Sciences
    Joe Gough · 2026 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  91. Psychiatry
    Joe Gough · 2026 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  92. Theory of Mind
    Joe Gough · 2026 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  93. Conclusion
    Joe Gough · 2026 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  94. Descartes and Aristotelianism
    Joe Gough · 2026 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  95. Cognitive Science
    Joe Gough · 2026 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  96. Human Beings and Their Make-Up
    Joe Gough · 2026 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  97. Mind in Philosophy
    Joe Gough · 2026 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  98. Intuitive Dualism and Human Specialness
    Joe Gough · 2026 · Oxford University Press eBooks
  99. Experience-based co-design of interventions to improve care quality and reduce detention under the Mental Health Act
    Roisin Mooney, Doreen Joseph, Rose McCabe, Karen Newbigging, Paul McCrone, Raghu Raghavan, Frank Keating, Nusrat Husain, Kamaldeep Singh Bhui · 2026 · BMJ Mental Health