A multi-disciplinary perspective on emergent and future innovations in peer review
Open accessThe DOI matches its Crossref record; 240 of the 240 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
Peer review of research articles is a core part of our scholarly communication system. In spite of its importance, the status and purpose of peer review is often contested. What is its role in our modern digital research and communications infrastructure? Does it perform to the high standards with which it is generally regarded? Studies of peer review have shown that it is prone to bias and abuse in numerous dimensions, frequently unreliable, and can fail to detect even fraudulent research. With the advent of Web technologies, we are now witnessing a phase of innovation and experimentation in our approaches to peer review. These developments prompted us to examine emerging models of peer review from a range of disciplines and venues, and to ask how they might address some of the issues with our current systems of peer review. We examine the functionality of a range of social Web platforms, and compare these with the traits underlying a viable peer review system: quality control, quantified performance metrics as engagement incentives, and certification and reputation. Ideally, any new systems will demonstrate that they out-perform current models while avoiding as many of the biases of existing systems as possible. We conclude that there is considerable scope for new peer review initiatives to be developed, each with their own potential issues and advantages. We also propose a novel hybrid platform model that, at least partially, resolves many of the technical and social issues associated with peer review, and can potentially disrupt the entire scholarly communication system. Success for any such development relies on reaching a critical threshold of research community engagement with both the process and the platform, and therefore cannot be achieved without a significant change of incentives in research environments.
Overview
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
The self-check needs the paper’s full text.
Citations
Cites
Items 201–240 of 240
O’Toole, M. (1991) · Nature · doi:10.1038/352560a0 · Cited by 24
When nonreliability of reviews indicates solid science
Eckberg, D. L. (1991) · Behavioral and Brain Sciences · doi:10.1017/s0140525x00065791 · Cited by 24
Naomi, F. (2017) · Scientometrics · doi:10.1007/s11192-017-2414-y · Cited by 23
Natural selection of academic papers
Perakakis, P., Taylor, M., Mazza, M., & Trachana, V. (2010) · Scientometrics · doi:10.1007/s11192-010-0253-1 · Cited by 22
Extending ArXiv.org to Achieve Open Peer Review and Publishing
Boldt, A. (2010) · Journal of Scholarly Publishing · doi:10.3138/jsp.42.2.238 · Cited by 22
Digital Badges: Signposts and Claims of Achievement
Rughinis, R. V., & Matei, Ș. (2013) · Communications in computer and information science · doi:10.1007/978-3-642-39476-8_18 · Cited by 20
Dynamic Publication Formats and Collaborative Authoring
Heller, L., The, R., & Bartling, S. H. (2013) · Springer eBooks · doi:10.1007/978-3-319-00026-8_13 · Cited by 20
Through a glass darkly: The present and the future of editorial peer review
Grivell, L. A. (2006) · EMBO Reports · doi:10.1038/sj.embor.7400718 · Cited by 20
Peerage of Science: will it work?
Hettyey, A., Griggio, M., Mann, M., Raveh, S., Schaedelin, F. C., Thonhauser, K. E., Thoß, M., van Dongen, W. F. D., White, J., Zala, S. M., et al. (2012) · Trends in Ecology & Evolution · doi:10.1016/j.tree.2012.01.005 · Cited by 20
Single versus Double Blind Reviewing at WSDM 2017Preprint
Tomkins, A., Zhang, M., & Heavlin, W. D. (2017) · arXiv (Cornell University) · doi:10.48550/arxiv.1702.00502 · Cited by 18
Peer review and journal modelsPreprint
Dall'Aglio, P. (2006) · arXiv (Cornell University) · doi:10.48550/arxiv.physics/0608307 · Cited by 17
Wikipedia for academic publishing: advantages and challenges
Xiao, L., & Askin, N. (2012) · Online Information Review · doi:10.1108/14684521211241396 · Cited by 17
Understanding and supporting anonymity policies in peer review
Nobarany, S., & Booth, K. S. (2016) · Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology · doi:10.1002/asi.23711 · Cited by 17
Pisani, E., & Botchway, S. (2017) · Wellcome Open Research · doi:10.12688/wellcomeopenres.12259.1 · Cited by 17
Priority, Rivalry, and Peer Review
Riggs, J. E. (1995) · Journal of Child Neurology · doi:10.1177/088307389501000325 · Cited by 15
Mhurchú, A. N., McLeod, L., Collins, S., & Siles‐Brügge, G. (2016) · Political Studies Review · doi:10.1177/1478929916658918 · Cited by 15
EPISCIENCES – An overlay publication platform
Berthaud, C., Capelli, L., Gustedt, J., Kirchner, C., Loiseau, K., Magron, A., Medves, M., Monteil, A., Rivrieux, G., & Romary, L. (2014) · Information Services & Use · doi:10.3233/isu-140749 · Cited by 14
Morrison, J. (2006) · Medical Education · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2929.2006.02573.x · Cited by 14
Kuehn, B. M. (2017) · eLife · doi:10.7554/elife.32014 · Cited by 14
Rodgers, P. (2017) · eLife · doi:10.7554/elife.32011 · Cited by 14
Should Biomedical Publishing Be “Opened Up”? Toward a Values-Based Peer-Review Process
Lipworth, W. L., Kerridge, I., Carter, S. M., & Little, M. (2011) · Journal of Bioethical Inquiry · doi:10.1007/s11673-011-9312-4 · Cited by 13
Data exchange standards to support and acknowledge peer‐review activity
Paglione, L., & Lawrence, R. N. (2015) · Learned Publishing · doi:10.1087/20150411 · Cited by 13
GROWTH OF COLLECTIVE INTELLIGENCE BY LINKING KNOWLEDGE WORKERS THROUGH SOCIAL MEDIA
Kubátová, J. (2012) · DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) · Cited by 11
Putman, T., Burgstaller-Muehlbacher, S., Waagmeester, A., Wu, C., Su, A. I., & Good, B. M. (2016) · Database · doi:10.1093/database/baw028 · Cited by 11
A brief survey on peer review in scholarly communication
Nicholson, J. M., & Alperín, J. P. (2016) · The Winnower · Cited by 11
A prospective study on an innovative online forum for peer reviewing of surgical science
Almquist, M., von Allmen, R. S., Carradice, D., Oosterling, S. J., McFarlane, K., & Wijnhoven, B. P. L. (2017) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0179031 · Cited by 11
Misconduct and Journal Peer Review
Rennie, D. (2003) · DigitalGeorgetown (Georgetown University Library) · Cited by 10
RUBRIQ: tools, services, and software to improve peer review
STEMMLE, L., & COLLIER, K. (2013) · Learned Publishing · doi:10.1087/20130406 · Cited by 9
New Toolkits on the Block: Peer Review Alternatives in Scholarly Communication
Schmidt, B., & Edit, G. (2017) · IOS Press eBooks · doi:10.3233/978-1-61499-769-6-62 · Cited by 9
Tennant, B. J. P. (2017) · Editorial Office News · doi:10.18243/eon/2017.10.8.1 · Cited by 9
Blockchain For Science And Knowledge Creation
Bartling, S. H., & Fecher, B. (2016) · Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research) · doi:10.5281/zenodo.60223 · Cited by 9
Web of Science owner buys up booming peer-review platform
Noorden, R. V. (2017) · Nature · doi:10.1038/nature.2017.22094 · Cited by 8
Exploring Citations for Conflict of Interest Detection in Peer-review System
Khan, M. A. (2012) · Computer Information Systems and Industrial Management Applications · Cited by 8
Does the Internet Deserve Everybody?
Elkhatib, Y., Gareth Tyson, A., & Sathiaseelan, A. (2015) · doi:10.1145/2793013.2793018 · Cited by 5
Self-citationPeer-review in the Internet agePreprint
Sobkowicz, P. (2008) · arXiv (Cornell University) · doi:10.48550/arxiv.0810.0486 · Cited by 4
On the Status and Future of Peer Review in Software EngineeringPreprint
Prechelt, L., Graziotin, D., & Méndez, D. (2017) · arXiv (Cornell University) · Cited by 4
Self-citationCan editors protect peer review from bad reviewers?Preprint
D’Andrea, R., & O’Dwyer, J. P. (2017) · doi:10.7287/peerj.preprints.3005v1 · Cited by 2
Peer Review #1 of "Software citation principles (v0.2)"
(2016) · PeerJ Computer Science · doi:10.7287/peerj-cs.86v0.2/reviews/1 · Cited by 2
Peer Review #1 of "Software citation principles (v0.1)"
(2016) · PeerJ Computer Science · doi:10.7287/peerj-cs.86v0.1/reviews/1 · Cited by 2
Peer Review #2 of "Software citation principles (v0.1)"
(2016) · PeerJ Computer Science · doi:10.7287/peerj-cs.86v0.1/reviews/2 · Cited by 2
Research works printed but not linked: 53
- D Adam, 2010, Climate scientists hit out at ‘sloppy’ melting glaciers error., The Guardian.
- 2017, arXiv monthly submission rates
- M Baldwin, 2017b, What it was like to be peer reviewed in the 1860s., Phys Today., 10.1063/PT.5.9098 · doi:10.1063/pt.5.9098
- N Belojevic, 2014, Peer review personas, J Electron Publishing., 17, 10.3998/3336451.0017.304 · doi:10.3998/3336451.0017.304
- R Bernstein, 2015, Updated: Sexist peer review elicits furious twitter response, PLOS apology., Science., 10.1126/science.aab2568 · doi:10.1126/science.aab2568
- B Brembs, 2015, The cost of the rejection-resubmission cycle., The Winnower., 10.15200/winn.142497.72083 · doi:10.15200/winn.142497.72083
- B Carlisle, 2014, Proof of prespecified endpoints in medical research with the bitcoin blockchain., The Grey Literature.
- D Crotty, 2009, How meaningful are user ratings? (this article = 4.5 stars!)., The Scholarly Kitchen.
- P Davis, 2017, Wither portable peer review., The Scholarly Kitchen.
- V Dhillon, 2016, From bench to bedside: Enabling reproducible commercial science via blockchain., Bitcoin Magazine.
- M Eisen, 2011, Peer review is f***ed up – let’s fix it
- T Farley, 2011, Hypothes.is reaches funding goal., James Randi Educational Foundation Swift Blog.
- K Fitzpatrick, 2011a, Peer review, judgment, and reading., Profession., 196-201, 10.1632/prof.2011.2011.1.196 · doi:10.1632/prof.2011.2011.1.196
- P Frishauf, 2009, Reputation systems: a new vision for publishing and peer review., J Particip Med., 1, e13a
- A Fyfe, 2015, Journals, learned societies and money: Philosophical Transactions, ca. 1750–1900., Notes Rec R Soc Lond., 69, 277-299, 10.1098/rsnr.2015.0032 · doi:10.1098/rsnr.2015.0032
- M Gashler, 2008, GPeerReview - a tool for making digital-signatures using data mining., KDnuggets.
- E Gibney, 2016, Toolbox: Low-cost journals piggyback on arXiv., Nature., 530, 117-118, 10.1038/530117a · doi:10.1038/530117a
- K Graf, 2014, Fetisch peer review., Archivalia.
- S Greaves, 2006, Overview: Nature’s peer review trial., Nature., 10.1038/nature05535 · doi:10.1038/nature05535
- S Gupta, 2016, How has publishing changed in the last twenty years?, Notes and Records: the Royal Society Journal of the History of Science., 70, 391-392, 10.1098/rsnr.2016.0035 · doi:10.1098/rsnr.2016.0035
- D Harley, 2010, Affordable and open textbooks: An exploratory study of faculty attitudes., Calif J Politics Policy., 2, 10.5070/P2D60T · doi:10.5070/p2d60t
- J Hukkinen, 2017, Peer review has its shortcomings, but AI is a risky fix., Wired.
- E Katsh, 2015, What we know and need to know about online dispute resolution., SCL Rev., 67, 329
- A Kosner, 2012, GitHub is the next big social network, powered by what you do, not who you know., Forbes.
- D Lee, 2015, The new Reddit journal of science., IMM-press Magazine.
- D Luzi, 2000, Trends and evolution in the development of grey literature: a review., International Journal on Grey Literature., 1, 106-117, 10.1108/14666180010345537 · doi:10.1108/14666180010345537
- P Maharg, 2007, Black box, pandora’s box or virtual toolbox? an experiment in a journal’s transparent peer review on the web., International Review of Law Computers & Technology., 21, 109-128, 10.1080/13600860701492104 · doi:10.1080/13600860701492104
- A Manten, 1980, Development of european scientific journal publishing before 1850., Development of science publishing in Europe., 1-22
- M Marra, 2017, Arxiv-based commenting resources by and for astrophysicists and physicists: An initial survey., Expanding Perspectives on Open Science: Communities, Cultures and Diversity in Concepts and Practices., 100-117, 10.3233/978-1-61499-769-6-100 · doi:10.3233/978-1-61499-769-6-100
- N McCormack, 2009, Peer review and legal publishing: What law librarians need to know about open, single-blind, and double-blind reviewing., Law Libr J., 101, 59
- G McKiernan, 2003, Alternative peer review: Quality management for 21st century scholarship.
- N Moxham, 2016, A pre-history of ‘peer review’: refereeing and editorial selection at the royal society., Hist J.
- A Mulligan, 2008, Quality, certification and peer review., Inf Serv Use., 28, 197-214, 10.3233/ISU-2008-0582 · doi:10.3233/isu-2008-0582
- T Murphy, 2014, Perceptions of the UK’s research excellence framework 2014: a media analysis., Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management., 36, 603-615, 10.1080/1360080X.2014.957890 · DOI
- 2010, Response required., Nature., 468, 867, 10.1038/468867a · doi:10.1038/468867a
- S Owens, 2014, The world’s largest 2-way dialogue between scientists and the public., Sci Am.
- A Pallavi Sudhir, 2015, PhysicsOverflow: A postgraduate-level physics Q&A site and open peer review system., Asia Pac Phys Newslett., 4, 53-55, 10.1142/S2251158X15000193 · doi:10.1142/s2251158x15000193
- J Perkel, 2015, Annotating the scholarly web., Nature., 528, 153-4, 10.1038/528153a · doi:10.1038/528153a
- S Pinfield, 2016, Mega-journals: the future, a stepping stone to it or a leap into the abyss?, Times Higher Education.
- A Plume, 2014, Publish or perish? The rise of the fractional author., Research Trends., 38
- G Pullum, 1984, Stalking the perfect journal., Natural language & linguistic theory., 2, 261-267
- 2016, Analysis of 7 million Amazon reviews: customers who receive free or discounted item much more likely to write positive review
- M Rodriguez, 2006, The convergence of digital libraries and the peer-review process., J Inform Sci., 32, 149-159, 10.1177/0165551506062327 · DOI
- N Ross, 2016, Onboarding at rOpenSci: A year in reviews., rOpenSci Blog.
- Q Schiermeier, 2017, 'You never said my peer review was confidential' - scientist challenges publisher., Nature., 541, 446, 10.1038/nature.2017.21342 · doi:10.1038/nature.2017.21342
- S Shuttleworth, 2016, Science periodicals in the nineteenth and twenty-first centuries., Notes Rec R Soc J Hist Sci., 70, 297-304, 10.1098/rsnr.2016.0026 · doi:10.1098/rsnr.2016.0026
- D Singh Chawla, 2016, Here’s why more than 50,000 psychology studies are about to have PubPeer entries., Retraction Watch.
- D Stanton, 2007, Report of the MLA task force on evaluating scholarship for tenure and promotion., Profession., 9-71, 10.1632/prof.2007.2007.1.9 · doi:10.1632/prof.2007.2007.1.9
- K Torpey, 2015, Astroblocks puts proofs of scientific discoveries on the bitcoin blockchain., Inside Bitcoins.
- T Vines, 2015a, Molecular Ecology’s best reviewers 2015., The Molecular Ecologist.
- T Vines, 2015b, The core inefficiency of peer review and a potential solution., Limnology and Oceanography Bulletin., 24, 36-38, 10.1002/lob.10022 · doi:10.1002/lob.10022
- M Weicher, 2008, Peer review and secrecy in the “information age”., Proc Am Soc Inform Sci Tech., 45, 1-12, 10.1002/meet.2008.14504503155 · DOI
- N Zamiska, 2006, Nature cancels public reviews of scientific papers., Wall Str J.
Cited by
What is open peer review? A systematic review
Ross-Hellauer, T. (2017) · F1000Research · doi:10.12688/f1000research.11369.2 · Cited by 449
Self-citationThe limitations to our understanding of peer review
Tennant, J. P., & Ross-Hellauer, T. (2020) · Research Integrity and Peer Review · doi:10.1186/s41073-020-00092-1 · Cited by 384
Self-citationThe evaluation of scholarship in academic promotion and tenure processes: Past, present, and future
Schimanski, L. A., & Alperin, J. P. (2018) · F1000Research · doi:10.12688/f1000research.16493.1 · Cited by 342
Checco, A., Bracciale, L., Loreti, P., Pinfield, S., & Bianchi, G. (2021) · Humanities and Social Sciences Communications · doi:10.1057/s41599-020-00703-8 · Cited by 286
“A wide range of alternative peer review processes, systems and online solutions (from Reddit-like voting systems to block-chain models) are explored by Tennant et al. (2017).”
BackgroundThe effect of publishing peer review reports on referee behavior in five scholarly journals
Bravo, G., Grimaldo, F., López-Iñesta, E., Mehmani, B., & Squazzoni, F. (2019) · Nature Communications · doi:10.1038/s41467-018-08250-2 · Cited by 273
Metadata
- Authors
- Tennant, J. P., Dugan, J. M., Graziotin, D., Jacques, D. C., Waldner, F., Mietchen, D., Elkhatib, Y., B. Collister, L., Pikas, C. K., Crick, T., Masuzzo, P., Caravaggi, A., Berg, D. R., Niemeyer, K. E., Ross-Hellauer, T., Mannheimer, S., Rigling, L., Katz, D. S., Greshake Tzovaras, B., Pacheco-Mendoza, J., Fatima, N., Poblet, M., Isaakidis, M., Irawan, D. E., Renaut, S., Madan, C. R., Matthias, L., Nørgaard Kjær, J., O'Donnell, D. P., Neylon, C., Kearns, S., Selvaraju, M., & Colomb, J.
- Venue
- F1000Research
- Publisher
- F1000 Research Ltd
- Published
- 2017-07-20
- Volume
- 6
- Pages
- 1151
- ISSN
- 2046-1402 (ISSN-L)
- OpenAlex
- W4245802241
- Cited by
- 289
- References
- 240
- FWCI
- 126.94
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Update notices
- Open access
- gold
- Funders
- Horizon 2020 (643410, H2020-EINFRA-2014-1)
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.