Chapter 6: Supervised and Unsupervised: Approaches to Machine Learning for Textual Entities

Abstract

Applications that feed text into machine learning algorithms have existed for more than a decade. But it took multiple developments to make machine learning an exciting methodological approach to questions grounded in the humanities. The latest developments in handwritten text recognition (HTR) show the capabilities of supervised deep learning. However, the success of the technology comes with a price: It generates a set of methods that are complicated to grasp in theory and difficult to train algorithms in, algorithms that are not comprehensible to humans at all. By focusing on the two most frequently used approaches in machine learning (unsupervised and supervised), this paper lays out ways to critically use machine learning algorithms in the humanities. At the same time, we argue that these approaches help us to understand the epistemological assumptions of our disciplines and our methods. Topic modeling used on large corpora of text leads to new insights into what topics occur, as well as the tendencies of a corpus. The approach uses unsupervised machine learning, through which a set of algorithms identify what words appear together frequently and so might indicate a topic. Topic modeling puts scholars at the end of the process, where they must still interpret the output of the algorithms. In deciphering handwriting, supervised deep learning approaches have led to astonishing results, but also to new problems induced by the algorithm. The algorithm tries to adapt to the d…