CoChat

Compaction and Segregation of DNA in Escherichia coli

Open access
Woldringh, Conrad Louis · 2024 · Life

Preprint — published as 10.3390/life14060660

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 1 of the 1 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Abstract

Theoretical and experimental approaches have been applied to study the polymer physics under-lying compaction of DNA in the bacterial nucleoid. Knowledge of the compaction mechanism is necessary to obtain a mechanistic understanding of the process of segregation of replicating chromosome arms (replichores) during the cell cycle. In the first part of this review light microscope observations are discussed that have demonstrated that the nucleoid has a lower refractive index and thus a lower density than the cytoplasm. A polymer-physical explanation for this phenomenon was given by the theory of Theo Odijk pro-posed in 1998. By assuming a phase separation between nucleoid and cytoplasm and by imposing equality of osmotic pressure and chemical potential between the two phases, a minimal energy situation is obtained in which soluble proteins are depleted from the nucleoid, thus explaining its lower density. The theory is compared with recent views for DNA compaction that are based on mere exclusion of polyribosomes from the nucleoid or on the transcriptional activity of the cell. These new views raise the question of whether they can still explain the lower refractive index or density of the nucleoid. In the second part of this review the question is discussed how DNA segregation occurs in Esche-richia coli, in the absence of the so-called active ParABS system, present in the majority of bacteria. How is entanglement prevented of nascent chromosome arms, generated at the origin in the pa-rental network of the E. coli nucleoid? The observations of the groups of Sherratt and Hansen in 2006, that the four nascent chromosome arms synthesized in the initial replication bubble, segre-gate to opposite halves of the sister nucleoids implies that extensive intermingling of daughter strands does not occur. Based on the hypothesis that leading and lagging replichores synthesized in the replication bubble, fold into micro-domains that do not intermingle, a passive "four-excluding-arms model" for segregation is proposed. This model implies that the key for seg-regation already lies in the structure of the replication bubble at the very start of DNA replication; it explains the different patterns of chromosome arms as well as the segregation distances between replicated loci as experimentally observed.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.20944/preprints202404.0089.v1

Cites

1 of 1 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

Figure 9 Measurement of positions of origins (green circles) and fluorescently labeled foci (red and blue stars), as observed in the constructs of Flemming Hansen in slow-growing E. coli cells with a doubling time of 150 min at 32°. The diagrams below the cells show the presumed replication status of the chromosome. The percentages indicate the major patterns observed; see tables in [66]. (a) Newborn cells with unreplicated DNA. (b) Cells with duplicated origins (4 spots) showing 2 patterns. (c) Cells with an almost replicated chromosome (6 spots) showing the most common pattern (34%) that, upon division, leads to the pattern (L-O-R) in newborn cells, as shown in (a).
Figure 9 Measurement of positions of origins (green circles) and fluorescently labeled foci (red and blue stars), as observed in the constructs of Flemming Hansen in slow-growing E. coli cells with a doubling time of 150 min at 32°. The diagrams below the cells show the presumed replication status of the chromosome. The percentages indicate the major patterns observed; see tables in [66]. (a) Newborn cells with unreplicated DNA. (b) Cells with duplicated origins (4 spots) showing 2 patterns. (c) Cells with an almost replicated chromosome (6 spots) showing the most common pattern (34%) that, upon division, leads to the pattern (L-O-R) in newborn cells, as shown in (a).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 10 The four-excluding-arms model: daughter strand exclusion in the initial replication bubble (orisome). (a) Schematic drawing of the initial stage, 30 s after the firing of the origin (green circles). Leading and lagging strands of ~10 µm synthesized by the two Pol III replicases of each replisome (red and blue triangles. See Appendix C). The nascent leading and lagging arms are proposed to exclude each other (remain de-mixed) because of physical differences (random coil versus supercoiled segments) and physiological differences (transcription of different genes). (b) Initial stage of the replication bubble 30 s after initiation: the 2 leading chromosome arms (#2 and #3) will immediately become supercoiled and fold into a blob (diameter of 140 nm; see Table A3). The 2 lagging arms (#1 and #4) will adopt a random coil conformation until the Okazaki fragments (about 20 fragments) are ligated. Due to the tethering of the two replisomes to the parental DNA they are replicating, the enlarging blobs push the origins apart (double arrow) (see also description of Figure 4 in [8]). (c) A 2D projection of the developing microdomains: after 5 min, nascent chromosome arms of 100 µm of DNA are synthesized and enlarged into microdomains with a diameter of 310 µm. The inset shows a 3D representation. Red and blue circles represent nascent microdomains of left and right replichores; black cross represents the terminus (compare with Figure 8a). Further enlargement of the microdomains by DNA synthesis will force these domains to rearrange their positions in the narrow tube of the nucleoid (see Figure 11(b1) and Table A3 in Appendix C).
Figure 10 The four-excluding-arms model: daughter strand exclusion in the initial replication bubble (orisome). (a) Schematic drawing of the initial stage, 30 s after the firing of the origin (green circles). Leading and lagging strands of ~10 µm synthesized by the two Pol III replicases of each replisome (red and blue triangles. See Appendix C). The nascent leading and lagging arms are proposed to exclude each other (remain de-mixed) because of physical differences (random coil versus supercoiled segments) and physiological differences (transcription of different genes). (b) Initial stage of the replication bubble 30 s after initiation: the 2 leading chromosome arms (#2 and #3) will immediately become supercoiled and fold into a blob (diameter of 140 nm; see Table A3). The 2 lagging arms (#1 and #4) will adopt a random coil conformation until the Okazaki fragments (about 20 fragments) are ligated. Due to the tethering of the two replisomes to the parental DNA they are replicating, the enlarging blobs push the origins apart (double arrow) (see also description of Figure 4 in [8]). (c) A 2D projection of the developing microdomains: after 5 min, nascent chromosome arms of 100 µm of DNA are synthesized and enlarged into microdomains with a diameter of 310 µm. The inset shows a 3D representation. Red and blue circles represent nascent microdomains of left and right replichores; black cross represents the terminus (compare with Figure 8a). Further enlargement of the microdomains by DNA synthesis will force these domains to rearrange their positions in the narrow tube of the nucleoid (see Figure 11(b1) and Table A3 in Appendix C).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 11 Schematic representation of the development of 4 excluding microdomains in the transversal arrangement of E. coli B/r during slow growth (Td = 150 min) and longitudinal arrangement after shift-up to fast growth (modification of Figure 2 in [91]). (a) The 4 initial microdomains, as depicted in Figure 10b,c, are drawn as a tetrahedron of 4 spheres (not to scale) connected to each other by the origin (green circle) and the feeding threads emanating from the replisomes replicating the parental DNA (light colored regions). In this 4-spot cell (cf. Figure 8b), the pattern is L-O-O-R. (b1) At the end of replication, the 4 spherical domains, enlarged through continued DNA synthesis, rearranged themselves in the long axis of the narrow nucleoid as indicated by the dashed arrows. They end up in a transversal arrangement. Because both leading arms of the two replichores move faster than the lagging arms, the asymmetric ordering pattern L-O-R L-O-R is obtained. (b2) An alternative arrangement can be obtained because of a faster expansion of both the leading and the lagging arms of the red replichore (caused by pausing of the blue replisome), resulting in the symmetric pattern L-O-R R-O-L (see [69]). (c) Nutritional shift-up from a doubling time of 150 min to fast growth (Td = 24 min). After 60 min, the average cell is wider and contains 4 origins after reinitiation. Because the microdomains do not have to rearrange in the wider cell, the origins remain at the tip of the nucleoid in a longitudinal arrangement. (d) After 90 min, the average cell contains 2 nucleoids with a total of 8 origins (for the construction of the DNA replication cycle during shift-up, see the cell cycle simulation program in [92]). Cell sizes reflect the measurements of E. coli B/r cells by Woldringh et al. [93]. See also Youngren et al. [76] for the longitudinal arrangement of the E. coli nucleoid in fast-growing cells.
Figure 11 Schematic representation of the development of 4 excluding microdomains in the transversal arrangement of E. coli B/r during slow growth (Td = 150 min) and longitudinal arrangement after shift-up to fast growth (modification of Figure 2 in [91]). (a) The 4 initial microdomains, as depicted in Figure 10b,c, are drawn as a tetrahedron of 4 spheres (not to scale) connected to each other by the origin (green circle) and the feeding threads emanating from the replisomes replicating the parental DNA (light colored regions). In this 4-spot cell (cf. Figure 8b), the pattern is L-O-O-R. (b1) At the end of replication, the 4 spherical domains, enlarged through continued DNA synthesis, rearranged themselves in the long axis of the narrow nucleoid as indicated by the dashed arrows. They end up in a transversal arrangement. Because both leading arms of the two replichores move faster than the lagging arms, the asymmetric ordering pattern L-O-R L-O-R is obtained. (b2) An alternative arrangement can be obtained because of a faster expansion of both the leading and the lagging arms of the red replichore (caused by pausing of the blue replisome), resulting in the symmetric pattern L-O-R R-O-L (see [69]). (c) Nutritional shift-up from a doubling time of 150 min to fast growth (Td = 24 min). After 60 min, the average cell is wider and contains 4 origins after reinitiation. Because the microdomains do not have to rearrange in the wider cell, the origins remain at the tip of the nucleoid in a longitudinal arrangement. (d) After 90 min, the average cell contains 2 nucleoids with a total of 8 origins (for the construction of the DNA replication cycle during shift-up, see the cell cycle simulation program in [92]). Cell sizes reflect the measurements of E. coli B/r cells by Woldringh et al. [93]. See also Youngren et al. [76] for the longitudinal arrangement of the E. coli nucleoid in fast-growing cells.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure A1 Enlargement and rearrangement of nascent domains in the four-excluding-arms model. (a) Schematic representation of the 4 nascent excluding arms (cf. Figure 8a in main text). (b) For the volumes of the domains, see Table A3. Sizes (yellow contour) of the E. coli B/r cells are not to scale. The replication period is assumed to be C = 40 min. (b1) After initiation of DNA replication, the 4 excluding arms in the replication bubble are assumed to form a tetrahedron within the parental nucleoid. (b2) After 5 min of replication, the enlarged tetrahedron exceeds the diameter of the parental nucleoid, forcing the domains to rearrange in the long axis. (b3) After 20 min of replication, the rearranged domains have formed the most common ordering pattern, L-R-L-R, in the elongating nucleoid (see Table 3 in the main text). (b4) After 40 min of replication, the chromosome is assumed to have fully replicated. The two replichore domains of each daughter arm now occupy opposite halves in the developing daughter nucleoids, as observed in [13,14]. The double red arrow indicates the distance over which a replicated locus on the left replichore has segregated. Compare to segregation distances shown for a different strain (E. coli K-12) in Figure A2a. (b5) Schematic representation of a cell at division, in which the daughter nucleoids have moved apart through continued cell elongation before cell division.
Figure A1 Enlargement and rearrangement of nascent domains in the four-excluding-arms model. (a) Schematic representation of the 4 nascent excluding arms (cf. Figure 8a in main text). (b) For the volumes of the domains, see Table A3. Sizes (yellow contour) of the E. coli B/r cells are not to scale. The replication period is assumed to be C = 40 min. (b1) After initiation of DNA replication, the 4 excluding arms in the replication bubble are assumed to form a tetrahedron within the parental nucleoid. (b2) After 5 min of replication, the enlarged tetrahedron exceeds the diameter of the parental nucleoid, forcing the domains to rearrange in the long axis. (b3) After 20 min of replication, the rearranged domains have formed the most common ordering pattern, L-R-L-R, in the elongating nucleoid (see Table 3 in the main text). (b4) After 40 min of replication, the chromosome is assumed to have fully replicated. The two replichore domains of each daughter arm now occupy opposite halves in the developing daughter nucleoids, as observed in [13,14]. The double red arrow indicates the distance over which a replicated locus on the left replichore has segregated. Compare to segregation distances shown for a different strain (E. coli K-12) in Figure A2a. (b5) Schematic representation of a cell at division, in which the daughter nucleoids have moved apart through continued cell elongation before cell division.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure A2 Graphical overview of the average distances between spot pairs (L-L, O-O, R-R) measured in growing and non-growing rifampicin-inhibited cells of E. coli K-12 (MG1655), as documented in Table 3 in [66]. The lengths of cells and segregation distances (colored double arrows) are drawn to scale. The numbers next to the double arrows indicate distances in µm, averaged over the first 5 constructs in Table 3 in [66]. Because the nucleoids were not visualized by staining, their sizes are not known and are drawn schematically. (a) In growing cells, showing the L-R-L-R ordering pattern of chromosome arms, replicated loci of the L-O-R pattern segregate over similar distances maintaining the L-O-R-L-O-R pattern (see Figure 9 in the main text). The red and blue triangles indicate hypothetical replisomes that have slightly moved apart. (b) In cells showing the LRRL or RLLR ordering pattern, the hypothetical replisomes stay in the cell center, and the L-L and R-R distances are either larger or smaller than the segregation distance between the origins (green O-O). (c,d) In rifampicin-treated cells, the loci segregate during run-off DNA synthesis similar to control cells (cf. a,b). Smaller cells have an elongated nucleoid that contains double the amount of DNA due to run-off DNA synthesis (indicated by the darker shade; see Figure 3 in [66]). Such nucleoids will not divide. Cell lengths and segregation distances are smaller than in growing cells (a,b).
Figure A2 Graphical overview of the average distances between spot pairs (L-L, O-O, R-R) measured in growing and non-growing rifampicin-inhibited cells of E. coli K-12 (MG1655), as documented in Table 3 in [66]. The lengths of cells and segregation distances (colored double arrows) are drawn to scale. The numbers next to the double arrows indicate distances in µm, averaged over the first 5 constructs in Table 3 in [66]. Because the nucleoids were not visualized by staining, their sizes are not known and are drawn schematically. (a) In growing cells, showing the L-R-L-R ordering pattern of chromosome arms, replicated loci of the L-O-R pattern segregate over similar distances maintaining the L-O-R-L-O-R pattern (see Figure 9 in the main text). The red and blue triangles indicate hypothetical replisomes that have slightly moved apart. (b) In cells showing the LRRL or RLLR ordering pattern, the hypothetical replisomes stay in the cell center, and the L-L and R-R distances are either larger or smaller than the segregation distance between the origins (green O-O). (c,d) In rifampicin-treated cells, the loci segregate during run-off DNA synthesis similar to control cells (cf. a,b). Smaller cells have an elongated nucleoid that contains double the amount of DNA due to run-off DNA synthesis (indicated by the darker shade; see Figure 3 in [66]). Such nucleoids will not divide. Cell lengths and segregation distances are smaller than in growing cells (a,b).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 1 Visualization of bacterial nucleoid in live E. coli cells from three laboratories, applying the immersion of cells in medium with a high refractive index. The nucleoids become visible when the refractive indices of the cytoplasm and immersion medium are almost equal in the range of n = 1.38–1.39. (a) Mason and Powelson [1] used 20% gelatin for the immersion medium and a phase-contrast microscope that showed dark areas in the cells, comparable to the nuclei of stained preparations (negative phase contrast). Here, the image contrast is inverted. The images represent the Figures 4, 7, 9 and 12 in [1] ©1956 American Society for Microbiology. Modified with permission. The age of cells in minutes is indicated in upper left corner. Black arrows indicate the growth and division of a single nucleoid. Magnification bar = 2 µm. (b) Cutout from [22]. Note the increase in refractive index of the medium in panels H (n = 1.37), I (n = 1.38) and J (n = 1.39), achieved with increased concentrations of bovine serum albumin (BSA) and reduced concentrations of salt in the medium to maintain constant osmolality. Panel J shows “phase reversal”: the light intensity of the nucleoid is higher than that of the surrounding medium. Magnification bar = 1 µm. (c) Still from a movie by Hironori Niki [24] of rapidly growing E. coli cells immersed in gelatin, obtained with permission from Niki (Microbial Physiology Laboratory, Department of Gene Function and Phenomics, National Institute of Genetics, Shizuoka, Japan). Magnification bar = 1 µm.
Figure 1 Visualization of bacterial nucleoid in live E. coli cells from three laboratories, applying the immersion of cells in medium with a high refractive index. The nucleoids become visible when the refractive indices of the cytoplasm and immersion medium are almost equal in the range of n = 1.38–1.39. (a) Mason and Powelson [1] used 20% gelatin for the immersion medium and a phase-contrast microscope that showed dark areas in the cells, comparable to the nuclei of stained preparations (negative phase contrast). Here, the image contrast is inverted. The images represent the Figures 4, 7, 9 and 12 in [1] ©1956 American Society for Microbiology. Modified with permission. The age of cells in minutes is indicated in upper left corner. Black arrows indicate the growth and division of a single nucleoid. Magnification bar = 2 µm. (b) Cutout from [22]. Note the increase in refractive index of the medium in panels H (n = 1.37), I (n = 1.38) and J (n = 1.39), achieved with increased concentrations of bovine serum albumin (BSA) and reduced concentrations of salt in the medium to maintain constant osmolality. Panel J shows “phase reversal”: the light intensity of the nucleoid is higher than that of the surrounding medium. Magnification bar = 1 µm. (c) Still from a movie by Hironori Niki [24] of rapidly growing E. coli cells immersed in gelatin, obtained with permission from Niki (Microbial Physiology Laboratory, Department of Gene Function and Phenomics, National Institute of Genetics, Shizuoka, Japan). Magnification bar = 1 µm.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 2 Cutout of Figure 2a,b in Oh et al. [27]. E. coli cells were grown in tryptic soy broth in the absence of antibiotics. The doubling time at 25 °C was 56 min. (a) A three-section view of the reconstructed refractive index (RI) distribution of E. coli cells grown for 240 min without antibiotics. The color map shows the RI values. (b) A 3D rendered image of the growing cells in (a) obtained with Tomocube software. The double red arrow shows a cell with 2 nucleoids with a lower RI value than cytoplasmic regions. Scale bar = 3 µm. Permission obtained from Yongkeun Park (Department of Physics, Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology, Daejeon, Republic of Korea).
Figure 2 Cutout of Figure 2a,b in Oh et al. [27]. E. coli cells were grown in tryptic soy broth in the absence of antibiotics. The doubling time at 25 °C was 56 min. (a) A three-section view of the reconstructed refractive index (RI) distribution of E. coli cells grown for 240 min without antibiotics. The color map shows the RI values. (b) A 3D rendered image of the growing cells in (a) obtained with Tomocube software. The double red arrow shows a cell with 2 nucleoids with a lower RI value than cytoplasmic regions. Scale bar = 3 µm. Permission obtained from Yongkeun Park (Department of Physics, Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology, Daejeon, Republic of Korea).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 3 Immersive refractometry of an E. coli B/r cell growing in alanine medium with a doubling time of 150 min. (a) Thin arrows represent light along the optical axis. For real cell dimensions, see Figure A2 in [28]: cell diameter dcell = 0.5 µm; thickness of the cytoplasmic layer surrounding the nucleoid d1 = 0.145 µm; diameter of the nucleoid d2 = 0.21 µm. In the left and right panels, the cell is immersed in 17.5 and 24% BSA, with refractive index (n1) values of 1.342 and 1.370, respectively. (b) The bold line indicates the refractive index integrated along the optical axis for different cell positions: cytoplasm (n2), cell center (cytoplasmic layer plus nucleoid, n4), and nucleoid (dashed arrow, n3). (c) The calculated relative light intensity of the phase-contrast image is indicated as in Figure 5 in [32]. The background intensity is assumed to be equal (horizontal dashed line). Note that the difference in the relative light intensity (ΔI) of the nucleoid-containing part (n4) increases in the medium with a higher refractive index, and the disturbing halo around the cell decreases, improving the visibility of the nucleoid.
Figure 3 Immersive refractometry of an E. coli B/r cell growing in alanine medium with a doubling time of 150 min. (a) Thin arrows represent light along the optical axis. For real cell dimensions, see Figure A2 in [28]: cell diameter dcell = 0.5 µm; thickness of the cytoplasmic layer surrounding the nucleoid d1 = 0.145 µm; diameter of the nucleoid d2 = 0.21 µm. In the left and right panels, the cell is immersed in 17.5 and 24% BSA, with refractive index (n1) values of 1.342 and 1.370, respectively. (b) The bold line indicates the refractive index integrated along the optical axis for different cell positions: cytoplasm (n2), cell center (cytoplasmic layer plus nucleoid, n4), and nucleoid (dashed arrow, n3). (c) The calculated relative light intensity of the phase-contrast image is indicated as in Figure 5 in [32]. The background intensity is assumed to be equal (horizontal dashed line). Note that the difference in the relative light intensity (ΔI) of the nucleoid-containing part (n4) increases in the medium with a higher refractive index, and the disturbing halo around the cell decreases, improving the visibility of the nucleoid.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 4 Graphical summary of Odijk’s free-energy approach; also, see Appendix A. (a) Topology of the linear double helix with diameter deff = 2 nm: solvent molecules (black circles) collide with a linear DNA strand with 1 kBT of energy, the amount of energy per thermal fluctuation. The continuous collisions cause the DNA to resemble a wormlike chain. Nevertheless, sections of the chain somewhat less than the persistence length P (about 45 nm, giving a Kuhn length of 90 nm) are essentially rodlike. Two points on the DNA contour separated by a distance much greater than P are uncorrelated (see Figure 3a and Equation (1) in [35]. (b) The DNA double helix is depicted as a branched supercoil. See Appendix A for the calculation of the excluded volume of two colliding superhelical Kuhn segments. (c) Electrostatic cross-interactions between soluble proteins (blue circles with radius a = 2.3 nm) with the DNA double helix, which has depletion radius E = 4.7 nm (dashed green tube). See Appendix A for the calculation of the cross-interaction volume of a protein and the DNA. (d) Minimalization of the total free energy is obtained by assuming a phase separation between the cytoplasm and the nucleoid and imposing equal osmotic pressure (π) and chemical potential (μ) in the two coexisting phases (with indices c and n for cytoplasm and nucleoid).
Figure 4 Graphical summary of Odijk’s free-energy approach; also, see Appendix A. (a) Topology of the linear double helix with diameter deff = 2 nm: solvent molecules (black circles) collide with a linear DNA strand with 1 kBT of energy, the amount of energy per thermal fluctuation. The continuous collisions cause the DNA to resemble a wormlike chain. Nevertheless, sections of the chain somewhat less than the persistence length P (about 45 nm, giving a Kuhn length of 90 nm) are essentially rodlike. Two points on the DNA contour separated by a distance much greater than P are uncorrelated (see Figure 3a and Equation (1) in [35]. (b) The DNA double helix is depicted as a branched supercoil. See Appendix A for the calculation of the excluded volume of two colliding superhelical Kuhn segments. (c) Electrostatic cross-interactions between soluble proteins (blue circles with radius a = 2.3 nm) with the DNA double helix, which has depletion radius E = 4.7 nm (dashed green tube). See Appendix A for the calculation of the cross-interaction volume of a protein and the DNA. (d) Minimalization of the total free energy is obtained by assuming a phase separation between the cytoplasm and the nucleoid and imposing equal osmotic pressure (π) and chemical potential (μ) in the two coexisting phases (with indices c and n for cytoplasm and nucleoid).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 5 Measurement of nucleoid volume in a population of living E. coli B/rH266 cells grown in alanine medium (doubling time 150 min), stained in growth medium with DAPI [40]. Cells and nucleoids were analyzed with ImageJ plugin (Coli-Inspector-04o+NucVol.ojj) at 3 thresholds. The program finds the cell contour in the phase-contrast image (green line in panels) and extends it with 8 pixels (yellow contour). The area of a nucleoid in the fluorescence channel, including its neighborhood, is temporarily smoothed before its min and max values are detected. Then, in the fluorescence images (right panels), an intensity threshold of, for example, threshold = min + 0.4 × (max – min), is applied to define the nucleoid contour using the 3 threshold values indicated (magenta contour). The contour is converted to a “best-fitting rod” in order to measure length and diameter and calculate nucleoid volume. Here, the three values for the average nucleoid volume are given. For the nucleoid volumes of newborn cells, see Table 1, last row. The results of the calculations using the 0.5 threshold best correspond to measurements by eye and hand.
Figure 5 Measurement of nucleoid volume in a population of living E. coli B/rH266 cells grown in alanine medium (doubling time 150 min), stained in growth medium with DAPI [40]. Cells and nucleoids were analyzed with ImageJ plugin (Coli-Inspector-04o+NucVol.ojj) at 3 thresholds. The program finds the cell contour in the phase-contrast image (green line in panels) and extends it with 8 pixels (yellow contour). The area of a nucleoid in the fluorescence channel, including its neighborhood, is temporarily smoothed before its min and max values are detected. Then, in the fluorescence images (right panels), an intensity threshold of, for example, threshold = min + 0.4 × (max – min), is applied to define the nucleoid contour using the 3 threshold values indicated (magenta contour). The contour is converted to a “best-fitting rod” in order to measure length and diameter and calculate nucleoid volume. Here, the three values for the average nucleoid volume are given. For the nucleoid volumes of newborn cells, see Table 1, last row. The results of the calculations using the 0.5 threshold best correspond to measurements by eye and hand.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 6 Schematic qualitative representation of a nucleoid compaction curve comparable to Figure 2a in [6]. The solid red line shows the nucleoid volume relative to cell volume as a function of the number of crowders (polyribosomes or proteins). nc indicates either polyribosomes or proteins, and nC0 is the corresponding number under normal physiological conditions. The dashed green and blue lines represent the relative crowder concentrations within the nucleoid for polyribosomes and soluble proteins, respectively. Cell (a) is a model cell (fixed volume of 0.7 µm3) in a non-equilibrium situation with a fully dispersed nucleoid and a homogeneous crowder mixture of small proteins and large polyribosomes. From left to right, an increased relative polyribosome concentration shows immediate phase separation (see inset of Figure 2a in [6]) and a full exclusion of polyribosomes from the nucleoid (dashed green line). A slow compaction of nucleoid volume (solid red line) is obtained upon increasing the polyribosome concentration. Cell (b) shows the equilibrium situation at physiological concentrations of polyribosomes and soluble proteins. Nucleoid volume decreased to half the cell volume (Vnuc = 0.35 µm3), while soluble proteins still occurred at ~95% within the nucleoid volume (dashed blue line). Cell (b) was also used for comparison in Figure 7a. Cell (c) shows that upon a further increase in crowder concentration (e.g., by osmotic shock), the soluble proteins become depleted from the nucleoid and nucleoid volume rapidly decreases.
Figure 6 Schematic qualitative representation of a nucleoid compaction curve comparable to Figure 2a in [6]. The solid red line shows the nucleoid volume relative to cell volume as a function of the number of crowders (polyribosomes or proteins). nc indicates either polyribosomes or proteins, and nC0 is the corresponding number under normal physiological conditions. The dashed green and blue lines represent the relative crowder concentrations within the nucleoid for polyribosomes and soluble proteins, respectively. Cell (a) is a model cell (fixed volume of 0.7 µm3) in a non-equilibrium situation with a fully dispersed nucleoid and a homogeneous crowder mixture of small proteins and large polyribosomes. From left to right, an increased relative polyribosome concentration shows immediate phase separation (see inset of Figure 2a in [6]) and a full exclusion of polyribosomes from the nucleoid (dashed green line). A slow compaction of nucleoid volume (solid red line) is obtained upon increasing the polyribosome concentration. Cell (b) shows the equilibrium situation at physiological concentrations of polyribosomes and soluble proteins. Nucleoid volume decreased to half the cell volume (Vnuc = 0.35 µm3), while soluble proteins still occurred at ~95% within the nucleoid volume (dashed blue line). Cell (b) was also used for comparison in Figure 7a. Cell (c) shows that upon a further increase in crowder concentration (e.g., by osmotic shock), the soluble proteins become depleted from the nucleoid and nucleoid volume rapidly decreases.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 7 Schematic representations (not to scale) of (a) an average E. coli K-12 cell from [6] and (b) an average E. coli B/rH266 cell [40] (see Table 1 and Figure 5b). The cell in (a) is the same as cell (b) in Figure 6. The cell in (b) is from the same population as the cell in Figure 5. For both cells, it is assumed that polyribosomes are excluded from the nucleoid, whereas soluble proteins can diffuse throughout the cytoplasm and nucleoid and are thus not depleted from the nucleoid, as proposed by Odijk [5]. For the calculated reduction of the RI of the nucleoid relative to the cytoplasm, see Appendix B, Table A2, note (12). For the measured dimensions of the cells in (a), see [6], and for the cells in (b), see Table 1, note (7).
Figure 7 Schematic representations (not to scale) of (a) an average E. coli K-12 cell from [6] and (b) an average E. coli B/rH266 cell [40] (see Table 1 and Figure 5b). The cell in (a) is the same as cell (b) in Figure 6. The cell in (b) is from the same population as the cell in Figure 5. For both cells, it is assumed that polyribosomes are excluded from the nucleoid, whereas soluble proteins can diffuse throughout the cytoplasm and nucleoid and are thus not depleted from the nucleoid, as proposed by Odijk [5]. For the calculated reduction of the RI of the nucleoid relative to the cytoplasm, see Appendix B, Table A2, note (12). For the measured dimensions of the cells in (a), see [6], and for the cells in (b), see Table 1, note (7).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 8 Schematic representation of the circular chromosome and localization of replichores in the nucleoid. (a) Left and right chromosome arms (replichores) with replicated origins (green circles) in the replication bubble. During the replication or C-period [72], the arms are replicated by the two replisomes (red and blue triangles), each synthesizing a leading strand and a lagging strand with Okazaki fragments (short triangles). Several fluorescently labeled loci (red and blue stars) are indicated, showing the position of the loci in the growing cells from Flemming Hansen (see below). The two daughter chromosomes (dashed arrows) end up in the prospective daughter cells with their replichores in two opposite halves of the nucleoid. The origin localizes at mid-cell between the left and right replichores that are connected by the terminus (black cross). (b) Position in a slow-growing E. coli cell (cf. Figure 5), with the two chromosome arms in the transversal arrangement. Initiation of DNA replication at mid-cell forms a replication bubble, resulting in a replichore pattern indicated as Left-ori-ori-Right (L-O-O-R). The terminus occurs in a stretched connection between replichores and migrates after duplication and cell division from the new pole to the cell center. (c) For comparison, a longitudinal arrangement of chromosome arms (cf. Caulobacter [17] or Agrobacterium [18]). The replication bubble is positioned at the cell pole; the terminus is at the other tip of the nucleoid [17].
Figure 8 Schematic representation of the circular chromosome and localization of replichores in the nucleoid. (a) Left and right chromosome arms (replichores) with replicated origins (green circles) in the replication bubble. During the replication or C-period [72], the arms are replicated by the two replisomes (red and blue triangles), each synthesizing a leading strand and a lagging strand with Okazaki fragments (short triangles). Several fluorescently labeled loci (red and blue stars) are indicated, showing the position of the loci in the growing cells from Flemming Hansen (see below). The two daughter chromosomes (dashed arrows) end up in the prospective daughter cells with their replichores in two opposite halves of the nucleoid. The origin localizes at mid-cell between the left and right replichores that are connected by the terminus (black cross). (b) Position in a slow-growing E. coli cell (cf. Figure 5), with the two chromosome arms in the transversal arrangement. Initiation of DNA replication at mid-cell forms a replication bubble, resulting in a replichore pattern indicated as Left-ori-ori-Right (L-O-O-R). The terminus occurs in a stretched connection between replichores and migrates after duplication and cell division from the new pole to the cell center. (c) For comparison, a longitudinal arrangement of chromosome arms (cf. Caulobacter [17] or Agrobacterium [18]). The replication bubble is positioned at the cell pole; the terminus is at the other tip of the nucleoid [17].CC BY · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Metadata

Authors
Woldringh, C. L.
Affiliations
University of Amsterdam (NL)
Corresponding author
Woldringh, Conrad Louis
Venue
Life
Publisher
MDPI AG
Published
2024-04-01
Volume
14
Issue
6
Pages
660-660
ISSN
2075-1729 (ISSN-L)
OpenAlex
W4398203063
Cited by
8
References
1
Citations by year
2026: 4 · 2025: 2 · 2024: 2
FWCI
2.12
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • Life (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • Preprints.org (acceptedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion, cc-by-sa)
Topics
  • Life Sciences › Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology › Genetics › Bacterial Genetics and Biotechnology
  • Life Sciences › Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology › Molecular Biology › Genomics and Chromatin Dynamics
  • Life Sciences › Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology › Molecular Biology › DNA and Nucleic Acid Chemistry
Keywords
DNA condensation, bacterial nucleoid, Escherichia coli, DNA segregation, chromosome arms, refractive index, phase separation, osmotic pressure, protein exclusion, ParABS system, microdomains

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Compaction and Segregation of DNA in Escherichia coli. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.20944/preprints202404.0089.v1
The paper
Woldringh, C. L. (2024). Compaction and Segregation of DNA in Escherichia coli. Life. https://doi.org/10.20944/preprints202404.0089.v1

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.