A Proposed Material Passport Ontology to Enable Circularity for Industrialized Construction

The review found that other challenging areas of integration include the nature of data itself, with reports of data being recorded manually or in response to specific business and procurement models, and negative impacts of driving designers to select from limited databases.

“Other challenging areas of integration comprise the nature of data itself, with reports of data being recorded manually or in response to specific business and procurement models (Kedir et al., 2021), as well as the negative impacts of driving designers to select from limited databases (Honic et al., 2019a).”

Recent research has scoped opportunities for automated data collection for MPs, providing opportunity for dynamic data repositories for repurposed materials which can be 'mined' as part of urban-wide policies.

“Within this professional environment, recent research has scoped opportunities for automated data collection for MPs (Kedir, Bucher, & Hall, 2021), providing opportunity for dynamic data repositories for repurposed materials (Rose & Stegemann, 2019) which can be 'mined' as part of urban-wide policies (Honic et al., 2019c).”

The review identified nuance in the dataset: some authors favour the integration of data while others emphasise coexistence and interoperability across datasets similar to BIM federated architectures.

“Here we identify some nuance in the dataset, with some authors favouring the integration of data (Kedir et al., 2021;Kovacic & Honic, 2021;Panza et al., 2023) and others bringing attention to the coexistence (Buchholz & Lützkendorf, 2022) and interoperability (Çetin et al., 2023) across datasets similar to BIM federated architectures (Beach et al., 2017).”