CoChat
Sign Up
PreprintCited by 425Black Holes and Theoretical PhysicsNoncommutative and Quantum Gravity TheoriesQuantum Electrodynamics and Casimir Effect

The DOI matches its DataCite record.

An Apologia for Firewalls

Open access
Almheiri, Ahmed, Marolf, Donald, Polchinski, Joseph, Stanford, Douglas, Sully, James·2013·arXiv
DOI 10.48550/arxiv.1304.6483arXiv 1304.6483
Open this paper in CoChat — free accountOpen PDF

Abstract

We address proposed alternatives to the black hole firewall. We show that embedding the interior Hilbert space of an old black hole into the Hilbert space of the early radiation is inconsistent, as is embedding the semi-classical interior of an AdS black hole into any dual CFT Hilbert space. We develop the use of large AdS black holes as a system to sharpen the firewall argument. We also reiterate arguments that unitary non-local theories can avoid firewalls only if the non-localities are suitably dramatic.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Run the check — free, no account needed. It reads the open-access text and checks the sources it cites.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

DataCite · 10.48550/arxiv.1304.6483

Cites

Statistics

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Run the check — free, no account needed. It reads the open-access text and checks the sources it cites.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

  • It is impossible to fix the information problem by adding small corrections to the Hawking process by slightly modifying the Hamiltonian or state of the quantum fields near the horizon.

    “In particular, it is impossible to fix the problem by adding small corrections to the Hawking process by slightly modifying the Hamiltonian or state of the quantum fields near the horizon [62-64].”

    From The entropy of Hawking radiation (2021) · cites this paper as [64]

    The Introduction (p. 3) says that Hawking-mode propagation cannot remain close to effective-field-theory predictions while preserving the paper’s other assumptions, and §3 (p. 11) explains why an added process to reduce entanglement is difficult to implement. These passages support the objection to small corrections, but they do not establish the claim’s unqualified impossibility for every slight modification of the near-horizon Hamiltonian or field state. (LLM, conf=0.82)

    Experimental — accuracy not yet measured

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

No references could be resolved yet.

Research works printed but not linked: 73

  1. [1][1] A. Almheiri, D. Marolf, J. Polchinski and J. Sully, 'Black Holes: Complementarity or Firewalls?,' JHEP 1302 , 062 (2013) [arXiv:1207.3123 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  2. [2][2] D. N. Page, 'Average entropy of a subsystem,' Phys. Rev. Lett. 71 , 1291 (1993) [grqc/9305007]; D. N. Page, 'Black hole information,' hep-th/9305040. - · arXiv
  3. [4][4] S. D. Mathur, 'The Information paradox: A Pedagogical introduction,' Class. Quant. Grav. 26 , 224001 (2009) [arXiv:0909.1038 [hep-th]]; - · arXiv
  4. [5][5] S. B. Giddings, 'Models for unitary black hole disintegration,' Phys. Rev. D 85 , 044038 (2012) [arXiv:1108.2015 [hep-th]]; - · arXiv
  5. [6][6] S. B. Giddings, 'Black holes, quantum information, and unitary evolution,' Phys. Rev. D 85 , 124063 (2012) [arXiv:1201.1037 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  6. [7][7] P. Hayden and J. Preskill, 'Black holes as mirrors: Quantum information in random subsystems,' JHEP 0709 , 120 (2007) [arXiv:0708.4025 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  7. [8][8] S. B. Giddings and W. M. Nelson, 'Quantum emission from two-dimensional black holes,' Phys. Rev. D 46 , 2486 (1992) [hep-th/9204072]. - · arXiv
  8. [11][11] E. Verlinde and H. Verlinde, 'Black Hole Entanglement and Quantum Error Correction,' arXiv:1211.6913 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  9. [12][12] R. D. Sorkin, 'The statistical mechanics of black hole thermodynamics,' gr-qc/9705006. - · arXiv
  10. [13][13] S. L. Braunstein, 'Black hole entropy as entropy of entanglement, or it's curtains for the equivalence principle,' [arXiv:0907.1190v1 [quant-ph]]. - · arXiv
  11. [14][14] S. B. Giddings, and Y. Shi, 'Quantum information transfer and models for black hole mechanics,' arXiv:1205.4732 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  12. [15][15] L. Susskind, L. Thorlacius and J. Uglum, 'The Stretched horizon and black hole complementarity,' Phys. Rev. D 48 , 3743 (1993) [hep-th/9306069]. - · arXiv
  13. [17][17] A. R. Brown, 'Tensile Strength and the Mining of Black Holes,' arXiv:1207.3342 [gr-qc]. - · arXiv
  14. [23][23] M. Srednicki, 'Entropy and area,' Phys. Rev. Lett. 71 , 666 (1993) [hep-th/9303048]. - · arXiv
  15. [24][24] T. Jacobson, 'Introduction to quantum fields in curved space-time and the Hawking effect' in Lectures on quantum gravity ed. by eds. A. Gomberoff and D. Marolf (Springer, 2005). [gr-qc/0308048]. - · arXiv
  16. [25][25] S. B. Giddings, 'Black hole information, unitarity, and nonlocality,' Phys. Rev. D 74 , 106005 (2006) [hep-th/0605196]. - · arXiv
  17. [26][26] Y. Sekino and L. Susskind, 'Fast Scramblers,' JHEP 0810 , 065 (2008) [arXiv:0808.2096 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  18. [27][27] S. D. Mathur, 'Tunneling into fuzzball states,' Gen. Rel. Grav. 42 , 113 (2010) [arXiv:0805.3716 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  19. [28][28] C. R. Stephens, G. 't Hooft and B. F. Whiting, 'Black hole evaporation without information loss,' Class. Quant. Grav. 11 , 621 (1994) [gr-qc/9310006]. - · arXiv
  20. [30][30] L. Susskind and L. Thorlacius, 'Gedanken experiments involving black holes,' Phys. Rev. D 49 , 966 (1994) [hep-th/9308100]. - · arXiv
  21. [31][31] S. B. Giddings, 'Nonviolent nonlocality,' arXiv:1211.7070 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  22. [32][32] S. B. Giddings, 'Nonviolent information transfer from black holes: a field theory parameterization,' arXiv:1302.2613 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  23. [35][35] Y. Nomura, J. Varela and S. J. Weinberg, 'Black Holes, Information, and Hilbert Space for Quantum Gravity,' arXiv:1210.6348 [hep-th]; - · arXiv
  24. [36][36] S. D. H. Hsu, 'Macroscopic superpositions and black hole unitarity,' arXiv:1302.0451 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  25. [37][37] D. Harlow and P. Hayden, 'Quantum Computation vs. Firewalls,' arXiv:1301.4504 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  26. [38][38] R. Bousso, 'Complementarity Is Not Enough,' arXiv:1207.5192 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  27. [40][40] Y. Nomura, J. Varela and S. J. Weinberg, 'Complementarity Endures: No Firewall for an Infalling Observer,' arXiv:1207.6626 [hep-th]; - · arXiv
  28. [41][41] K. Papadodimas and S. Raju, 'An Infalling Observer in AdS/CFT,' arXiv:1211.6767 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  29. [42][42] Y. Nomura and J. Varela, 'A Note on (No) Firewalls: The Entropy Argument,' arXiv:1211.7033 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  30. [43][43] L. Susskind, 'Black Hole Complementarity and the Harlow-Hayden Conjecture,' arXiv:1301.4505 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  31. [45][45] A. Kapustin, 'Is there life beyond Quantum Mechanics?,' arXiv:1303.6917 [quant-ph]. - · arXiv
  32. [46][46] D. Kabat, G. Lifschytz, D. A. Lowe, 'Constructing local bulk observables in interacting AdS/CFT,' Phys. Rev. D83 , 106009 (2011). [arXiv:1102.2910 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  33. [47][47] I. Heemskerk, D. Marolf, J. Polchinski and J. Sully, 'Bulk and Transhorizon Measurements in AdS/CFT,' JHEP 1210 , 165 (2012) [arXiv:1201.3664 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  34. [48][48] A. Hamilton, D. N. Kabat, G. Lifschytz and D. A. Lowe, 'Local bulk operators in AdS/CFT: A Holographic description of the black hole interior,' Phys. Rev. D 75 , 106001 (2007) [Erratum-ibid. D 75 , 129902 (2007)] [hep-th/0612053]. - · arXiv
  35. [49][49] R. Bousso, B. Freivogel, S. Leichenauer, V. Rosenhaus and C. Zukowski, 'Null Geodesics, Local CFT Operators and AdS/CFT for Subregions,' arXiv:1209.4641 [hepth]. - · arXiv
  36. [50][50] T. Banks and W. Fischler, 'Holographic Space-Time Does Not Predict Firewalls,' arXiv:1208.4757 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  37. [51][51] L. Susskind, 'Singularities, Firewalls, and Complementarity,' arXiv:1208.3445 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  38. [52][52] S. G. Avery, B. D. Chowdhury, and A. Puhm, 'Unitarity and fuzzball complementarity: 'Alice fuzzes but may not even know it!',' arXiv:1210.6996 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  39. [54][54] S. Hossenfelder, 'Comment on the black hole firewall,' arXiv:1210.5317 [gr-qc]. - · arXiv
  40. [55][55] T. Jacobson, 'Boundary unitarity without firewalls,' arXiv:1212.6944 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  41. [56][56] E. Witten, 'Multitrace operators, boundary conditions, and AdS / CFT correspondence,' hep-th/0112258. - · arXiv
  42. [57][57] M. Berkooz, A. Sever and A. Shomer, ''Double trace' deformations, boundary conditions and space-time singularities,' JHEP 0205 , 034 (2002) [hep-th/0112264]. - · arXiv
  43. [58][58] S. S. Gubser and I. R. Klebanov, 'A Universal result on central charges in the presence of double trace deformations,' Nucl. Phys. B 656 , 23 (2003) [hep-th/0212138]. - · arXiv
  44. [59][59] E. Witten, 'SL(2,Z) action on three-dimensional conformal field theories with Abelian symmetry,' In *Shifman, M. (ed.) et al.: From fields to strings, vol. 2* 1173-1200 [hepth/0307041]. - J. V. Rocha, 'Evaporation of large black holes in AdS: Coupling to the evaporon,' -
  45. [60][60] JHEP 0808 , 075 (2008) [arXiv:0804.0055 [hep-th]]; J. V. Rocha, 'Evaporation of large black holes in AdS: Greybody factor and decay rate,' JHEP 0908 , 027 (2009) [arXiv:0905.4373 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  46. [61][61] G. Compere and D. Marolf, 'Setting the boundary free in AdS/CFT,' Class. Quant. Grav. 25 , 195014 (2008) [arXiv:0805.1902 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  47. [62][62] O. Domenech, M. Montull, A. Pomarol, A. Salvio and P. J. Silva, 'Emergent Gauge Fields in Holographic Superconductors,' JHEP 1008 , 033 (2010) [arXiv:1005.1776 [hepth]]. - · arXiv
  48. [63][63] T. Faulkner and J. Polchinski, 'Semi-Holographic Fermi Liquids,' JHEP 1106 , 012 (2011) [arXiv:1001.5049 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  49. [64][64] T. Andrade and D. Marolf, 'AdS/CFT beyond the unitarity bound,' JHEP 1201 , 049 (2012) [arXiv:1105.6337 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  50. [65][65] O. Aharony, O. Bergman, D. L. Jafferis and J. Maldacena, 'N=6 superconformal ChernSimons-matter theories, M2-branes and their gravity duals,' JHEP 0810 , 091 (2008) [arXiv:0806.1218 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  51. [66][66] T. Hertog and S. Hollands, 'Stability in designer gravity,' Class. Quant. Grav. 22 , 5323 (2005) [hep-th/0508181]; - A. J. Amsel and D. Marolf, 'Energy Bounds in Designer Gravity,' Phys. Rev. D 74 , 064006 (2006) [Erratum-ibid. D 75 , 029901 (2007)] [hep-th/0605101]; A. J. Amsel, T. Hertog, S. Hollands and D. Marolf, 'A Tale of two superpotentials: Stability and instability in designer gravity,' Phys. Rev. D 75 , 084008 (2007) [Erratumibid. D 77 , 049903 (2008)] [hep-th/0701038]; T. Faulkner, G. T. Horowitz and M. M. Roberts, 'New stability results for Einstein scalar gravity,' Class. Quant. Grav. 27 , 205007 (2010) [arXiv:1006.2387 [hep-th]]; A. J. Amsel and M. M. Roberts, 'Stability in Einstein-Scalar Gravity with a Logarithmic Branch,' Phys. Rev. D 85 , 106011 (2012) [arXiv:1112.3964 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  52. [67][67] S. G. Avery, and B. D. Chowdhury, 'Firewalls in AdS/CFT,' arXiv:1302.5428 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  53. [69][69] M. Hanada, Y. Hyakutake, J. Nishimura and S. Takeuchi, 'Higher derivative corrections to black hole thermodynamics from supersymmetric matrix quantum mechanics,' Phys. Rev. Lett. 102 , 191602 (2009) [arXiv:0811.3102 [hep-th]]; M. Hanada, 'Monte Carlo approach to the string/M-theory,' PoS LATTICE 2012 , 019 (2012) [arXiv:1212.2814 [hep-lat]]. - · arXiv
  54. [70][70] R. Gambini and J. Pullin, arXiv:1302.5265 [gr-qc]. - · arXiv
  55. [71][71] D. Marolf, 'Black Holes, AdS, and CFTs,' Gen. Rel. Grav. 41 , 903 (2009) [arXiv:0810.4886 [gr-qc]]. - · arXiv
  56. [72][72] D. Marolf and A. C. Wall, 'Eternal Black Holes and Superselection in AdS/CFT,' Class. Quant. Grav. 30 , 025001 (2013) [arXiv:1210.3590 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  57. [73][73] S. S. Gubser, I. R. Klebanov and A. M. Polyakov, 'Gauge theory correlators from non-critical string theory,' Phys. Lett. B 428 , 105 (1998) [arXiv:hep-th/9802109]. - · arXiv
  58. [74][74] E. Witten, 'Anti-de Sitter space and holography,' Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2 , 253 (1998) [arXiv:hep-th/9802150]. - · arXiv
  59. [75][75] A. Ori, 'Firewall or smooth horizon?,' arXiv:1208.6480 [gr-qc]. - · arXiv
  60. [76][76] A. Ashtekar and M. Bojowald, 'Black hole evaporation: A Paradigm,' Class. Quant. Grav. 22 , 3349 (2005) [gr-qc/0504029]. - · arXiv
  61. [77][77] W. Kim, B. -H. Lee and D. -H. Yeom, 'Black hole complementarity and firewall in two dimensions,' JHEP 1305 , 060 (2013) [arXiv:1301.5138 [gr-qc]]. - · arXiv
  62. [79][79] A. Strominger, 'Five Problems in Quantum Gravity,' Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 192193 , 119 (2009) [arXiv:0906.1313 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  63. [80][80] B. Freivogel and L. Susskind, 'A Framework for the landscape,' Phys. Rev. D 70 , 126007 (2004) [hep-th/0408133]; R. Bousso and L. Susskind, 'The Multiverse Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics,' Phys. Rev. D 85 , 045007 (2012) [arXiv:1105.3796 [hep-th]]; I. Heemskerk, D. Marolf, J. Polchinski and J. Sully, 'Bulk and Transhorizon Measurements in AdS/CFT,' JHEP 1210 , 165 (2012) [arXiv:1201.3664 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  64. [81][81] J. Polchinski, unpublished; L. Susskind, 'The Transfer of Entanglement: The Case for Firewalls,' arXiv:1210.2098 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  65. [82][82] B. Freivogel, V. E. Hubeny, A. Maloney, R. C. Myers, M. Rangamani and S. Shenker, 'Inflation in AdS/CFT,' JHEP 0603 , 007 (2006) [hep-th/0510046]. - · arXiv
  66. [83][83] M. Gary and S. B. Giddings, 'The Flat space S-matrix from the AdS/CFT correspondence?,' Phys. Rev. D 80 , 046008 (2009) [arXiv:0904.3544 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  67. [84][84] J. Maldacena and L. Susskind, 'Cool horizons for entangled black holes,' arXiv:1306.0533 [hep-th]. - · arXiv
  68. [85][85] G. Chapline, E. Hohlfeld, R. B. Laughlin and D. I. Santiago, 'Quantum phase transitions and the breakdown of classical general relativity,' Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 18 , 3587 (2003) [gr-qc/0012094]. - · arXiv
  69. [86][86] P. O. Mazur and E. Mottola, 'Gravitational condensate stars: An alternative to black holes,' gr-qc/0109035. - · arXiv
  70. [88][88] A. Davidson, 'Holographic Shell Model: Stack Data Structure inside Black Holes,' arXiv:1108.2650 [gr-qc]. - · arXiv
  71. [89][89] A. Giveon and N. Itzhaki, 'String Theory Versus Black Hole Complementarity,' JHEP 1212 , 094 (2012) [arXiv:1208.3930 [hep-th]]. - · arXiv
  72. [90][90] S. B. Giddings, 'Black holes and massive remnants,' Phys. Rev. D 46 , 1347 (1992) [hep-th/9203059]. - · arXiv
  73. [91][91] S. D. Mathur and D. Turton, 'Comments on black holes I: The possibility of complementarity,' arXiv:1208.2005 [hep-th]. · arXiv

Cited by

Sorted by citations

Metadata

Authors
Almheiri, A., Marolf, D., Polchinski, J., Stanford, D., & Sully, J.
Affiliations
University of California, Santa Barbara (US)
Corresponding author
Polchinski, Joseph
ORCID
Venue
arXiv
Publisher
arXiv
Published
2013
Volume
2013
Issue
9
ISSN
1029-8479 (ISSN-L)
DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1304.6483
arXiv
1304.6483
OpenAlex
W2142493599
Cited by
425
References
0
Citations by year
2026: 11 · 2025: 22 · 2024: 24 · 2023: 16 · 2022: 29 · 2021: 32 · 2020: 36 · 2019: 45 · 2018: 30 · 2017: 38 · 2016: 38 · 2015: 42 · 2014: 56 · 2013: 6
FWCI
21.60
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Licence
arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Locations
  • Journal of High Energy Physics (publishedVersion)
  • arXiv (Cornell University) (submittedVersion)
  • arXiv (Cornell University)
Topics
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Nuclear and High Energy Physics › Black Holes and Theoretical Physics
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Nuclear and High Energy Physics › Noncommutative and Quantum Gravity Theories
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Atomic and Molecular Physics, and Optics › Quantum Electrodynamics and Casimir Effect
Keywords
black hole firewalls, black hole complementarity, AdS/CFT correspondence, AdS black holes, Hilbert space embedding, unitarity, black hole interior

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review