Energy-based Generative Adversarial Network

“We impose the following restrictions on EBGAN models: (i)-using learning rate 0.001 and Adam (Kingma & Ba, 2014) for both G and D ; (ii)- nLayerD represents the total number of layers combining Enc and Dec .”

“Finally, we trained EBGANs to generate high-resolution images on ImageNet (Russakovsky et al., 2015).”

“For training both EBGANs and GANs for the grid search, we use the following setting: • Batch normalization (Ioffe & Szegedy, 2015) is applied after each weight layer, except for the generator output layer and the discriminator input layer (Radford et al., 2015).”

“Generative Adversarial Networks (GAN) (Goodfellow et al., 2014) have led to significant improvements in image generation (Denton et al., 2015; Radford et al., 2015; Im et al., 2016; Salimans et al., 2016), video prediction (Mathieu et al., 2015) and a number of other domains.”

“(2010) and Rifai et al. (2011). In quest for better techniques for stabilizing GAN training, several papers was presented with helpful techniques in Salimans et al.”

“Generative Adversarial Networks (GAN) (Goodfellow et al., 2014) have led to significant improvements in image generation (Denton et al., 2015; Radford et al., 2015; Im et al., 2016; Salimans et al., 2016), video prediction (Mathieu et al., 2015) and a number of other domains.”

“We also trained a network to generate images of size 256 × 256 , on a dog-breed subset of ImageNet, using the wordNet IDs provided by Vinyals et al. (2016).”

“By adding regularizers, several techniques were addressed to resolve such problem (Vincent et al., 2010; Rifai et al., 2011; Ng; MarcAurelio Ranzato & Chopra, 2007; Kavukcuoglu et al., 2010).”

“To access the capacity of generating 64× 64 RGB images on the basis of using deep convolutional models, we have trained EBGANs on the LSUN bedroom dataset (Yu et al., 2015) and the large scale face dataset CelebA under alignment (Liu et al.”

“, 2014) have led to significant improvements in image generation (Denton et al., 2015; Radford et al., 2015; Im et al., 2016; Salimans et al., 2016), video prediction (Mathieu et al., 2015) and a number of other domains. The basic idea of GAN is to simultaneously train a discriminator and a generator. The discriminato…”

“Other researchers propose EBGANs[32] to explain GANs from energy, or BEGANs[33] to control the equilibrium between diversity and quality etc.”

“Taking into account that our proposed GAN architecture is based on a variation of the energy-based GAN [10] and to further make a direct comparison with the latter work, we decided to use the precision/recall curves measure to evaluate the performance of the proposed model used in our study.”

“The work in [20] listed several methods for better training of GAN, and [21] explained the principles of GAN in terms of energy.”

“Image-to-image translation problems are often formulated as a per-pixel classification or regression [13,20,25,38,42].”

“There are also numerous follow-up works proposed to enhance the image generation performance and training stability of GAN, in terms of new architectures [45, 12, 40, 41], objective functions [60, 3, 38] and training procedure [9, 48, 24, 29].”

“The methods of [24, 40, 2, 3] generated random face images with noise signal as input.”

“In the context of EMs [58], the energy function is realized through the discriminator D , and the corresponding objective functions for the discriminator and generator are defined as: where x is a real data sample, z is a noise vector, G ( z ) is the generated sample, E ( · ) is the energy assigned…”

“Another related method in unsupervised learning is generative adversarial networks (GANs) [16]–[18], which utilize a discriminator model to classify output images into ‘real’ or ‘fake’ and utilize a generator model to produce ‘fake’ images which the discriminator model cannot distinguish from…”

“Energy-Based GANs (EBGANs) [44] made contributions based on its theoretical foundation.”

“In addition, there are many GAN variants aimed at the training procedure to achieve fast and stable convergence, such as the least square GAN [64], Loss-sensitive GAN [65], Energy-Based GAN (EBGAN) [66], Boundary Equilibrium GAN (BEGAN) [67], etc.”

“Meanwhile, there are frameworks that characterizes distribution learning from other perspectives, for instance, statistical inference [54, 108], graphical models and rewards [130, 12], energy functions [134] and biological neurons [88].”

“In addition, studies such as LAPGAN [44], PGGAN [45], StyleGAN [12], EBGAN [46], SAGAN [47], and BigGAN [48] that have improved the structure of the models.”

“This is similar in spirit to energy-based GAN [13].”

“In this paper, we propose the Dual Inverse Network Optimisation (DINO) framework1 which is based on energy-based GANs (Zhao et al., 2017) and consists of two networks that perform translation in opposite directions as shown in Figure 1.”

“A lot of work has been proposed to stabilize the training and improve the image quality [14–19].”

“EBGAN [20] improved GAN from the perspective of energy model, which gives GAN a definition of an energy model that is different from other models in defining loss functions by distance metrics, training the GAN model with a broader structure and a wider variety of loss function types.”

“…which leads to non-convergence (Jacobian regularization-JARE) CIFAR10 [52], CelebA [58], ImageNet [56] Stable training and convergence EBGAN [13] Generator & Discriminator as energy functions, assign low energy for realistic samples ImageNet [56], LSUN [53] High rate of convergence and…”

“ted[5,14].Competitiveresultshavebeenprovidedbyseveral practices that stabilize the training [7]. These methods include different strategies,suchasusingdifferentcostfunctionstothegeneratorordiscriminator[4,15,18,32,29]anddecreasingthelearningratethroughtheiterations[20]. GANtrainingthatinvolvesmultiplegeneratorsand/ordis…”

“Various approaches have been introduced to address/reduce this problem [31,36] including the ensemble of GANs [37].”

“This issue is also The first four blocks of images are taken from [34], the fifth is taken from [36], and the last block contains the images generated using our method.”

“It is shown that the training procedure of a GAN resembles that of a deep EBM with variational inference [2, 3, 4, 15].”

“es different distances between distributions adopted by existing generative adversarial algorithms, and show many of them are discontinuous, such as Jensen-Shannon divergence [17] and Total Variation [76], except for Wasserstein distance. The discontinuity makes the gradient descent infeasible for training. Consequent…”

“Since then, They have been proposed continuously, such as InfoGANs [27], Energy-based GANs [28], WGANs [29], Progressive GANs [30], and SN-GANs [31].”

“Various improvements [29]–[32] have been proposed for more stable and easy training of GANs, and their applications are far beyond image generation.”

“A well-known weakness of GANs is training instability; however, this has been improved in recent work [1, 2, 4, 6, 9, 14, 15, 22, 24, 27, 29, 34, 39, 46, 48].”

“CVAE-GAN [3], EBAGN [21], and some others [9] extended the concept of feature matching of IGAN to pairwise feature matching and some other different feature matching concepts.”

“Popular generative modeling techniques include generative adversarial networks (GAN) (Goodfellow et al. 2014; Zhao, Mathieu, and LeCun 2016; Arjovsky, Chintala, and Bottou 2017), variational autoencoders (VAE) (Kingma and Welling 2013; Kingma, Salimans, and Welling 2016), and autoregres-sion (Van…”

“Inspired by the recent GANs [12]-[14] success in image generation, our model is divided into two parts–generator model (G) and discriminator model (D).”

“Energy-based Models [26,7,43,4,29,5,11,8,16,41,9] are probabilistic frameworks designed to represent complex distributions.”

“A lot of contemporary GANs [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18] that implement IPMs to evaluate their loss functions provide much better training stability than the F -divergence GANs.”

“For diversity, some works [8,9,11,48] have utilized a diversity loss derived from a repelling regularizer [50], guaranteeing dissimilarities between selected keyframes.”

“Both OT-GAN [28] and EBGAN [29] introduce the energy function to improve training stability.”

“For the energy-based model, we compared the proposed method with EBM [8] and NCSN [32].”

“The second category is combined with other networks, including energy-based GAN, BEGAN, DFM, VAE-GAN, MRGAN, α-GAN [37–42], etc.”

“Similar to EBGAN (Zhao et al., 2017), we assume E and R have infinite capacity.”

“Recently, generative adversarial networks (GAN) [16, 17] has achieved good results in image generation.”

“There are multiple variations such as WGAN [16], EBGAN [17], BEGAN [18], VAR+GAN [19] and VAC+GAN [20], which have evolved from the original GAN by adjusting the loss function and/or the network architecture.”

“lation [12, 13, 14] and speech enhancement [15].”

“While the original GAN model has a binary classification discriminator that distinguishes fake samples from real ones, the recent models construct more informative discriminator costs such as an autoen-coder cost that assign lower cost to real samples and higher cost to fake ones [3, 6, 7].”

“The framework has been analyzed from various viewpoints, based on its Energy function, Class probability estimation, Divergence Minimisation, Ratio Matching and Moment Matching [37]-[40].”

“Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) [12], [13] have achieved impressive results in image generation [12], [14], image editing [13], and representation learning [15].”

“Several recent studies propose constraints and improvements to the framework to improve training stability and synthesis results [15], [22]–[25].”

“Other works offered regularisation techniques which were built around the base architecture of [5] to try and stabilise training by altering its training scheme or adding components around it [7,14,15].”

“Recent generation works have explored the tasks of generating novel images [5, 6, 3, 24, 33, 26, 37, 1, 9, 39, 2, 11] and future video frames [29, 25, 17, 38, 35, 10, 15, 30, 4, 32], but this work is the first to explore the generation of cinemagraphs from a single image, which include the features of both images (sta…”

“Lately, a wide range of GAN type architectures, which offer novel objec-tive functions by changing the structure of discriminator [23, 27, 35], have been proposed.”

“Zhao et al.(61) considered the discriminator as an energy function and interpreted the function as a combination of low energies near the data manifold regions and high energies from other regions.”

“The Energy-Based GAN (EBGAN) [Zhao et al., 2016] uses a reconstruction loss as an energy function that assigns low energies to the regions near the data manifold and higher energies to others.”

“CVAE-GAN [4], EBAGN [23], and some others [11] extended the concept of feature matching of IGAN to pairwise feature matching and some other different feature matching concepts.”

“But fortunately, in image processing area, generative adversarial networks (GANs) have been widely used to capture features of an image(Goodfellow et al., 2014; Goodfellow, 2016; Denton et al., 2015; Chen et al., 2016; Zhao et al., 2016; Nowozin et al., 2016).”

“Generative AI (GAI) employs various AI algorithms creatively, enhancing the value and diversity of generated data [20], [21], and promoting the rapid development of large-scale and multi-modal applications [22], [23].”

“The energy-based model aims to learn an energy surface in which the data samples consistent with the model have low energies while those classed as outliers are given high energies (LeCun et al. 2006; Zhao, Mathieu, and LeCun 2017).”

“The other category is adversarial EBMs (Zhai et al., 2016; Geng et al., 2021; Kumar et al., 2019; Zhao et al., 2017), which introduce a ’generator’ to form a minimax game be-tween the energy function and the introduced generator.”

“…adversarial training mainly to aid with the reconstruction-based anomaly score and autoen-coder performance, there are many works based on GANs and adversarial training that explicitly use the discriminator output to complement or entirely substitute the reconstruction error [47], [48], [49], [50].”

“In [18], a similar idea was empirically explored.”

“First, modifying the architecture of the discriminator to improve the discriminator’s ability [47–49].”

“Recently, deep learning Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) have achieved impressive results in multiple areas in computer vision, such as image generation 7 and image translation.”

“colored grayscale images using cGANs [26].”

“Some studies tried to enable GAN to learn a more accurate distribution during training process by using improved adversarial learning objectives ( e.g. LSGAN [22], energy-based GAN [23] and WGAN [24] ) .”

“…different GAN training concepts have been proposed in recent years, employing multistage generation or topology growing [21,54,59], improved training objectives like energy-based cost functions [60], least-square loss [34], or Wasserstein distance [3], and combinations with autoencoders [11,41].”

“GANs have been used in a wide variety of applications such as image generation [4, 57], representation learning [42], image manipulation [24], object detection [29], and video applications [8, 33, 44].”

“Zhao et al. (2016) introduce Energy-based GAN (EBGAN) using an autoencoder.”

“Bu problemin üstesinden gelmek için yeni kayıp fonksiyonları [5], [6], yeni düzenlileştirme teknikleri [7], [8] ve yeni ağ mimarileri [4], [9], [10] önerilmiştir.”

“More recently, Energy Based GANs [36] (EBGANs) were proposed as a class of GANs that aim to model a discriminator D(x) as an energy function.”

“We adopt a convolutional auto-encoder as a discriminator and a decoder as a generator, as done in [7].”

“energy-based GAN (EBGAN) (80), metric learning-based GAN (MLGAN) (81), and deep convolutional GAN (DCGAN) (82) have been proposed and generated compelling results.”

“The insight of the Autoencoder GANS (AE-GANs) is that D can be expanded from a single-dimensional criterion— the scalar class probability—to a multidimensional criterion by constructing it as an autoencoder (Zhao, Mathieu, and LeCun 2016).”

“Originally, the GAN model was designed to do image generation [9, 4, 26].”

“This kind of adver­ sarial training achieves a win-win situation when the generator and the discriminator reach a Nash Equilibrium (Zhao et al., 2016; Arora et al., 2017; Guimaraes et al., 2017).”

“One of the common issues in CNN models is when the training is complete no additional information is acquired by the system [22].”

“…among the empirical measures ˆ ν ¯ x , ˆ μ p x , ˆ ν ¯ x , and ˆ μ q x is defined as This new ME divergence combines both the differentiable MOT metric and energy divergence with an unbiased estimator [45], resulting in a highly discriminative divergence function with stable and unbiased gradients.”

“There are several GAN models which focus modifying their loss functions like Energy based GAN [19] used Lyapunov functions for discriminator stability, Least-Square GAN [20] uses least square based loss function for addressing the vanishing gradient problem, Wasserstein GAN [21] uses Earth Mover…”

“EBMs in particular have experienced a surging interest in recent years due to their high generalisation capabilities in regression [13], classification [14] and generative problems [15].”

“For H ( p G ) , we adopt the pull away (PT) method proposed in [27], [30] to measure its value, and the formula is defined as The discriminator takes the representations of benign user data and the generated fake fraud data as input, and tries to distinguish them.”

“In addition, autoencoders have naturally been employed in the Energy-Based Model (EBM) [85] aiming to learn an energy map in which the low energy is attributed to the data manifold [85].”

“These values prevent clustering of generated images and reflect the real image manifold.[15] At the time of abstracting the input image information, discriminators of CycleGAN functionally correspond to autoencoder of EBGAN.”

“The GAN has gained world-wide success in representation learning, image editing,(34) and image generation.(26,35) There are two major modules in the GAN, the generator and the discriminator.”