The stability of cosmological scaling solutions

On the positive-potential branch s=+1, when λ2>3γm there is a scaling solution; for dust or radiation γm≥1, μk>0 and μΣ,μs<0, so shear and spin-torsion are damped but curvature grows, and the scaling solution is a saddle in the full six-dimensional phase space.

“For dust or radiation (γ m ≥ 1) one has µ k > 0 and µ Σ , µ s < 0. Shear and spin-torsion are damped, but curvature grows.In the full six-dimensional phase space the scaling solution is a saddle: it is stable in (x, y, Σ, Ω s ) but unstable in the curvature direction [26].”

Near the scaling saddle, curvature is a growing mode with μk = 3γm - 2 > 0 for γm ≥ 1, but once the ekpyrotic field dominates it is strongly suppressed.

“Near the scaling saddle, curvature is a growing mode with µ k = 3γ m -2 > 0 for γ m ≥ 1 [26], but once the ekpyrotic field dominates it is strongly suppressed.”

For λ2>3γm, the scalar tracks the fluid with wφ=wm and Ωφ=3γm/λ2; this scaling point is stable in the (x,y) sector but, once curvature is included, the curvature direction is unstable for γm≥1, so in the full six-dimensional space it is a saddle.

“For λ 2 > 3γ m , the scalar tracks the fluid with w φ = w m and Ω φ = 3γ m /λ 2 [23,24].This point is stable in the (x, y) sector but, once curvature is included, the curvature direction is unstable for γ m ≥ 1 (the GR result of [26]).In the full six-dimensional space the scaling point is a saddle.”

Billyard et al. showed that the CLW scaling solution is stable to shear in expanding GR backgrounds, while in contracting GR backgrounds a canonical scalar is generically unstable to anisotropy (the shear instability), which motivates ekpyrotic phases with wφ≫1.

“Billyard et al. showed that the CLW scaling solution is stable to shear in expanding GR backgrounds [26], while in contracting GR backgrounds a canonical scalar is generically unstable to anisotropy (the shear instability), which motivates ekpyrotic phases with w φ ≫ 1 [27].”