Student or educator? Sign up with your school email and get 6 months of Pro free.
CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 88 of the 90 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

In situ covalent reinforcement of a benzene-1,3,5-tricarboxamide supramolecular polymer enables biomimetic, tough, and fibrous hydrogels and bioinks

Open access
Hafeez, Shahzad, Decarli, Monize Caiado, Aldana, Agustina, Ebrahimi, Mahsa, Ruiter, Floor A.A., Duimel, Hans, van Blitterswijk, Clemens, Pitet, Louis M., Moroni, Lorenzo, Baker, Matthew B. · 2023 · Advanced Materials

Abstract

Synthetic hydrogels often lack the load‐bearing capacity and mechanical properties of native biopolymers found in tissue, such as cartilage. In natural tissues, toughness is often imparted via the combination of fibrous noncovalent self‐assembly with key covalent bond formation. This controlled combination of supramolecular and covalent interactions remains difficult to engineer, yet can provide a clear strategy for advanced biomaterials. Here, a synthetic supramolecular/covalent strategy is investigated for creating a tough hydrogel that embodies the hierarchical fibrous architecture of the extracellular matrix (ECM). A benzene‐1,3,5‐tricarboxamide (BTA) hydrogelator is developed with synthetically addressable norbornene handles that self‐assembles to form a and viscoelastic hydrogel. Inspired by collagen's covalent cross‐linking of fibrils, the mechanical properties are reinforced by covalent intra‐ and interfiber cross‐links. At over 90% water, the hydrogels withstand up to 550% tensile strain, 90% compressive strain, and dissipated energy with recoverable hysteresis. The hydrogels are shear‐thinning, can be 3D bioprinted with good shape fidelity, and can be toughened via covalent cross‐linking. These materials enable the bioprinting of human mesenchymal stromal cell (hMSC) spheroids and subsequent differentiation into chondrogenic tissue. Collectively, these findings highlight the power of covalent reinforcement of supramolecular fibers, offering a strategy for the bottom‐up design of dynamic, yet tough, hydrogels and bioinks.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1002/adma.202301242

Cites

88 of 88 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

Figure 1 Molecular structures of NB BTA and cross-linkers employed in the study. a) Chemical structure of norbornene functionalized NB BTA macromonomer. Cartoon representation of NB BTA macromonomer and proposed stacking of NB BTA macromonomer (middle) to form a fiber (right). Blue chains represent 20K PEG. b) Thiol cross-linkers utilized for cross-linking supramolecular assemblies. c) Reaction scheme for thiol-ene chemistry of norbornene and thiol. d) Cartoon of supramolecularly self-assembled fiber cross-linked using short dithiol cross-linker. e) Intra- and interfiber crosslinking at molecular level. 20K PEG chains were not shown in (d) and (e) to clearly demonstrate cross-linking of the supramolecular fiber. f) Schematic of the supramolecular hydrogel network (left), after cross-linking with a short 2-arm thiol cross-linker (middle left), 4-arm thiol cross-linker (middle right), and MMP sensitive 2-arm thiol cross-linker (right). The green border on a supramolecular fiber represents the norbornene.
Figure 1 Molecular structures of NB BTA and cross-linkers employed in the study. a) Chemical structure of norbornene functionalized NB BTA macromonomer. Cartoon representation of NB BTA macromonomer and proposed stacking of NB BTA macromonomer (middle) to form a fiber (right). Blue chains represent 20K PEG. b) Thiol cross-linkers utilized for cross-linking supramolecular assemblies. c) Reaction scheme for thiol-ene chemistry of norbornene and thiol. d) Cartoon of supramolecularly self-assembled fiber cross-linked using short dithiol cross-linker. e) Intra- and interfiber crosslinking at molecular level. 20K PEG chains were not shown in (d) and (e) to clearly demonstrate cross-linking of the supramolecular fiber. f) Schematic of the supramolecular hydrogel network (left), after cross-linking with a short 2-arm thiol cross-linker (middle left), 4-arm thiol cross-linker (middle right), and MMP sensitive 2-arm thiol cross-linker (right). The green border on a supramolecular fiber represents the norbornene.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 2 Self-assembly studies. a) Nile red fluorescence as a function of NB BTA concentration in water. b) Nanofibres of NB BTA at 10 mg mL -1 as observed via cryo-TEM. c) Supramolecular fibers in dilute solutions at 5 mg mL -1 aged for 30 d showed nanofiber bundles with a diameter around 5 nm. d) Nile red fluorescence for cross-linked versus non-crosslinked (supramolecular) NB BTA solutions at 5 mg mL -1 . e) the supramolecular structure is still observed by cryo-TEM after exposure to UV light (365 nm at ≈ 1 mW cm -2 ) for cross-linking. f) A dissolved supramolecular hydrogel (to 5 mg mL -1 ) also showed bundles of fibrils around 10-15 nm in diameter.
Figure 2 Self-assembly studies. a) Nile red fluorescence as a function of NB BTA concentration in water. b) Nanofibres of NB BTA at 10 mg mL -1 as observed via cryo-TEM. c) Supramolecular fibers in dilute solutions at 5 mg mL -1 aged for 30 d showed nanofiber bundles with a diameter around 5 nm. d) Nile red fluorescence for cross-linked versus non-crosslinked (supramolecular) NB BTA solutions at 5 mg mL -1 . e) the supramolecular structure is still observed by cryo-TEM after exposure to UV light (365 nm at ≈ 1 mW cm -2 ) for cross-linking. f) A dissolved supramolecular hydrogel (to 5 mg mL -1 ) also showed bundles of fibrils around 10-15 nm in diameter.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 3 Cross-linking of the supramolecular hydrogel leads to strong, tough, and stretchable hydrogels. a,g) Optical image of NB BTA hydrogel at 5% w/v before (a) and after (b) cross-linking. c-h) Optical images of supramolecular and cross-linked hydrogel under extreme compression (c vs d), cutting of the hydrogel using a spatula (e vs f), and cutting using a scalpel (g vs h). il) Stretching of extruded supramolecular (i and k) and crosslinked filament (j and l). The supramolecular filament broke while the cross-linked filament can be stretched to 4.5 × (450% strain) of its original length. m-o) The supramolecular hydrogel (50 mg mL -1 ) showed anisotropic fibril morphology via cryo-SEM at low (m) and high (n) magnification, and the hydrogel aged for 30 d (o) showed aligned bundle of fibers.
Figure 3 Cross-linking of the supramolecular hydrogel leads to strong, tough, and stretchable hydrogels. a,g) Optical image of NB BTA hydrogel at 5% w/v before (a) and after (b) cross-linking. c-h) Optical images of supramolecular and cross-linked hydrogel under extreme compression (c vs d), cutting of the hydrogel using a spatula (e vs f), and cutting using a scalpel (g vs h). il) Stretching of extruded supramolecular (i and k) and crosslinked filament (j and l). The supramolecular filament broke while the cross-linked filament can be stretched to 4.5 × (450% strain) of its original length. m-o) The supramolecular hydrogel (50 mg mL -1 ) showed anisotropic fibril morphology via cryo-SEM at low (m) and high (n) magnification, and the hydrogel aged for 30 d (o) showed aligned bundle of fibers.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 4 Mechanical properties of hydrogels before and after cross-linking. a) Supramolecular hydrogel storage moduli ( G ′ , filled symbols) and loss moduli ( G ′′ , open symbols) as a function of angular frequency at 2.5%, 5%, and 10% w/v NB BTA. b) Evolution of ( G ′ , filled symbols) and loss moduli ( G ′′ , open symbols) over time for cross-linking of the supramolecular hydrogel when exposed to a UV-light source. c) Storage moduli ( G ′ , filled symbols) and loss moduli ( G ′′ , open symbols) as a function of the angular frequency of the cross-linked hydrogels. d,e) Storage moduli as a function of the angular frequency of uncross-linked and cross-linked hydrogels using different mole equivalents of short dithiol cross-linker (d) and using 2arm versus 4arm cross-linkers (e). f) Diffusion coefficients of supramolecular and cross-linked hydrogels using short dithiol and PEG2K cross-linker remain similar before and after cross-linking.
Figure 4 Mechanical properties of hydrogels before and after cross-linking. a) Supramolecular hydrogel storage moduli ( G ′ , filled symbols) and loss moduli ( G ′′ , open symbols) as a function of angular frequency at 2.5%, 5%, and 10% w/v NB BTA. b) Evolution of ( G ′ , filled symbols) and loss moduli ( G ′′ , open symbols) over time for cross-linking of the supramolecular hydrogel when exposed to a UV-light source. c) Storage moduli ( G ′ , filled symbols) and loss moduli ( G ′′ , open symbols) as a function of the angular frequency of the cross-linked hydrogels. d,e) Storage moduli as a function of the angular frequency of uncross-linked and cross-linked hydrogels using different mole equivalents of short dithiol cross-linker (d) and using 2arm versus 4arm cross-linkers (e). f) Diffusion coefficients of supramolecular and cross-linked hydrogels using short dithiol and PEG2K cross-linker remain similar before and after cross-linking.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 5 Mechanical properties of hydrogels before and after cross-linking. a-c) Stress-strain curves of the cross-linked hydrogels during a tensile test (a), and optical images of the short (b) and PEG 5K (c) hydrogels during the test. d,e) Elastic moduli (d) and strain energies (e) calculated from the compression tests. f) Compression stress-strain curves of the cross-linked hydrogels until 90% strain loaded at 1 mm min -1 . g) Compression stressstrain curves for ramped cyclic loading of the 10% (w/v, 1:1 NB/thiol) cross-linked hydrogel of varying strain loaded at 1 mm min -1 and released at 0.2 mm min -1 . The same sample was reloaded immediately for the next cycle without any waiting time. h) Strain energy, relaxation energy, and hysteresis energy calculated for each cycle in the graph (g). Of note, three values from the triplicate 80% strain are shown in order to show the lack of fatigue in these cycles. i,j) Proposed mechanisms for energy dissipation during high strain loading include rearrangement of the network via mechanisms like BTA unstacking in BTA fibers (i) and BTA fiber sliding (j).
Figure 5 Mechanical properties of hydrogels before and after cross-linking. a-c) Stress-strain curves of the cross-linked hydrogels during a tensile test (a), and optical images of the short (b) and PEG 5K (c) hydrogels during the test. d,e) Elastic moduli (d) and strain energies (e) calculated from the compression tests. f) Compression stress-strain curves of the cross-linked hydrogels until 90% strain loaded at 1 mm min -1 . g) Compression stressstrain curves for ramped cyclic loading of the 10% (w/v, 1:1 NB/thiol) cross-linked hydrogel of varying strain loaded at 1 mm min -1 and released at 0.2 mm min -1 . The same sample was reloaded immediately for the next cycle without any waiting time. h) Strain energy, relaxation energy, and hysteresis energy calculated for each cycle in the graph (g). Of note, three values from the triplicate 80% strain are shown in order to show the lack of fatigue in these cycles. i,j) Proposed mechanisms for energy dissipation during high strain loading include rearrangement of the network via mechanisms like BTA unstacking in BTA fibers (i) and BTA fiber sliding (j).CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 6 Self-healing, shear-thinning, injectability, and 3D printability of the NB BTA hydrogel. a) A self-healing visual test showed the self-healing behavior of hydrogels after 24 h in a closed environment. b) Decrease in viscosity with increasing shear rate showed shear-thinning behavior of the hydrogels. c) Extruding of supramolecular hydrogel (5% w/v) into a continuous uniform fiber with 1 equivalent of a short thiol cross-linker and 2 × 10 -3 m LAP photoinitiator. The extruded fiber was cross-linked using 365 nm UV-light. d) The cross-linked fiber was observed to be strong and stretchable. e,f) Cryo-SEM images of non-crosslinked (e) and cross-linked (f) hydrogels after extruding through a 22 gauge syringe showed fibril morphology before and after cross-linking. g-i) The supramolecular hydrogel extruded into a single filament (g), hexagonal (h), and hollow tube structures (i). j,k) Hollow (j) and solid (k) meniscus cartilage models were 3D printed using the supramolecular hydrogel. l) Schematic of the 3D printing of a cartilage model using the extrusion printer. m,n) The meniscus cartilage model printed with 5% hydrogel, then cross-linked after printing each layer. o,p) A cartilage model printed with 5% hydrogel with inks with different equivalents of thiol cross-linker. The green ink (top part in o and bottom part in p) has a 1:1 ratio of NB to thiol and the clear ink (bottom part in o and top part in p) has a 1:0.5 ratio of NB to thiol. q) The meniscus cartilage model recovery before (left) and after (right) 60 kg of weight exerted three times.
Figure 6 Self-healing, shear-thinning, injectability, and 3D printability of the NB BTA hydrogel. a) A self-healing visual test showed the self-healing behavior of hydrogels after 24 h in a closed environment. b) Decrease in viscosity with increasing shear rate showed shear-thinning behavior of the hydrogels. c) Extruding of supramolecular hydrogel (5% w/v) into a continuous uniform fiber with 1 equivalent of a short thiol cross-linker and 2 × 10 -3 m LAP photoinitiator. The extruded fiber was cross-linked using 365 nm UV-light. d) The cross-linked fiber was observed to be strong and stretchable. e,f) Cryo-SEM images of non-crosslinked (e) and cross-linked (f) hydrogels after extruding through a 22 gauge syringe showed fibril morphology before and after cross-linking. g-i) The supramolecular hydrogel extruded into a single filament (g), hexagonal (h), and hollow tube structures (i). j,k) Hollow (j) and solid (k) meniscus cartilage models were 3D printed using the supramolecular hydrogel. l) Schematic of the 3D printing of a cartilage model using the extrusion printer. m,n) The meniscus cartilage model printed with 5% hydrogel, then cross-linked after printing each layer. o,p) A cartilage model printed with 5% hydrogel with inks with different equivalents of thiol cross-linker. The green ink (top part in o and bottom part in p) has a 1:1 ratio of NB to thiol and the clear ink (bottom part in o and top part in p) has a 1:0.5 ratio of NB to thiol. q) The meniscus cartilage model recovery before (left) and after (right) 60 kg of weight exerted three times.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 7 Cell viability after injectability and in 3D bioprinted hydrogels. a) Schematics representing the bulk hydrogel and injectability method employed for cell viability in (b)-(e). b,c) Live-dead images of ATDC5 chondrocytes in the supramolecular and cross-linked hydrogel after 2 h. The green color represents live cells and the red color represents dead cells. d,e) Live-dead images of ATDC5 chondrocytes after injection through 22 gauge after 2 h of injection. f) schematics representing 3D bioprinting of chondrocytes and hMSC spheroids employed in (g)-(j) and (l)-(r), respectively. g) Visual image of the NB BTA hydrogel bioprinted cartilage construct. A cartilage model was printed using 22 gauge and with ATDC5s encapsulated. h-j) Live-dead images of cartilage model from day 0 until day 11. k) hMSC spheroids retain spherical morphology after mixing in NB BTA hydrogel. l-n) hMSC spheroid image after 1 d in culture (l), macroscopic hydrogel (cross-linked using short dithiol) picture (m), and spheroid picture (n) after 28 d in culture under chondrogenic differentiation conditions. o-r) Immunostaining for collagen II after 1 day (o) and 28 days (p) and immunostaining for collagen I after 1 day (q) and 28 days (r) of culture in bioprinted NB BTA hydrogel under chondrogenic differentiation conditions.
Figure 7 Cell viability after injectability and in 3D bioprinted hydrogels. a) Schematics representing the bulk hydrogel and injectability method employed for cell viability in (b)-(e). b,c) Live-dead images of ATDC5 chondrocytes in the supramolecular and cross-linked hydrogel after 2 h. The green color represents live cells and the red color represents dead cells. d,e) Live-dead images of ATDC5 chondrocytes after injection through 22 gauge after 2 h of injection. f) schematics representing 3D bioprinting of chondrocytes and hMSC spheroids employed in (g)-(j) and (l)-(r), respectively. g) Visual image of the NB BTA hydrogel bioprinted cartilage construct. A cartilage model was printed using 22 gauge and with ATDC5s encapsulated. h-j) Live-dead images of cartilage model from day 0 until day 11. k) hMSC spheroids retain spherical morphology after mixing in NB BTA hydrogel. l-n) hMSC spheroid image after 1 d in culture (l), macroscopic hydrogel (cross-linked using short dithiol) picture (m), and spheroid picture (n) after 28 d in culture under chondrogenic differentiation conditions. o-r) Immunostaining for collagen II after 1 day (o) and 28 days (p) and immunostaining for collagen I after 1 day (q) and 28 days (r) of culture in bioprinted NB BTA hydrogel under chondrogenic differentiation conditions.CC-BY · From the PDF

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Show all 90 references

Cited by

See all 48

Metadata

Authors
Hafeez, S., Decarli, M. C., Aldana, A., Ebrahimi, M., Ruiter, F. A. A., Duimel, H., van Blitterswijk, C., Pitet, L. M., Moroni, L., & Baker, M. B.
Affiliations
  • Maastricht University (NL)
  • Department of Complex Tissue Regeneration MERLN Institute for Technology‐Inspired Regenerative Medicine Maastricht University P.O. Box 616 Maastricht 6200 MD The Netherlands
  • Hasselt University (BE)
  • Maastricht MultiModal Molecular Imaging Institute P.O. Box 616 Maastricht 6200 MD The Netherlands
Corresponding author
Baker, Matthew B.
Venue
Advanced Materials
Publisher
Wiley
Published
2023-07-30
Volume
35
Issue
35
Pages
e2301242-e2301242
ISSN
  • 0935-9648 (ISSN-L)
  • 1521-4095
OpenAlex
W4382344837
Cited by
48
References
90
Citations by year
2026: 10 · 2025: 22 · 2024: 15 · 2023: 1
FWCI
3.07
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • Advanced Materials (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • Research Publications (Maastricht University) (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • Document Server@UHasselt (UHasselt) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
Funders
  • European Commission (101028471, 953169, HORIZON2020)
  • Fonds Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek (G080020N)
  • Nederlandse Organisatie voor Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek (731.016.202)
  • Vlaamse regering
  • H2020 European Research Council (694801)
Topics
  • Physical Sciences › Materials Science › Biomaterials › Supramolecular Self-Assembly in Materials
  • Physical Sciences › Materials Science › Biomaterials › Hydrogels: synthesis, properties, applications
  • Physical Sciences › Engineering › Biomedical Engineering › 3D Printing in Biomedical Research
Keywords
benzene-1,3,5-tricarboxamide, supramolecular hydrogels, covalent cross-linking, norbornene, hydrogel toughening, fibrous hydrogels, biomimetic hydrogels, bioinks, 3D bioprinting, mesenchymal stem cells, chondrogenic differentiation, extracellular matrix, viscoelasticity, shear thinning, cartilage tissue engineering
MeSH terms
Benzamides, Extracellular Matrix, Humans, Polymers, Hydrogels, Tissue Engineering, Biomimetics, Bioprinting, Printing, Three-Dimensional

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: In situ covalent reinforcement of a benzene-1,3,5-tricarboxamide supramolecular polymer enables biomimetic, tough, and fibrous hydrogels and bioinks. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1002/adma.202301242
The paper
Hafeez, S., Decarli, M. C., Aldana, A., Ebrahimi, M., Ruiter, F. A. A., Duimel, H., van Blitterswijk, C., Pitet, L. M., Moroni, L., & Baker, M. B. (2023). In situ covalent reinforcement of a benzene-1,3,5-tricarboxamide supramolecular polymer enables biomimetic, tough, and fibrous hydrogels and bioinks. Advanced Materials. https://doi.org/10.1002/adma.202301242

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.