A Note on General Relativity, Energy Conservation, and Noether’s Theorems
The DOI matches its Crossref record; 25 of the 27 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
The subject of this note has been a small historical thread in the long and complex story of the status of energy conservation in General Relativity, concerning two related claims made by Klein and Hilbert: that the energy conservation law is an identity in generally covariant theories, and that this marks a contrast with other (earlier) theories. Both these claims were disputed by Einstein. We have seen how three theorems proved by Noether and Klein can be brought to bear on this disagreement, showing that:
Overview
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
Citations
Cites
Die Grundlage der allgemeinen Relativitätstheorie
Einstein, A. (1916) · Annalen der Physik · doi:10.1002/andp.19163540702 · Cited by 3,468
Gravitation: an Introduction to current research
Witten, L. (1962) · CERN Document Server (European Organization for Nuclear Research) · Cited by 2,004
Gravitation, an introduction to current research
Sewell, G. L. (1963) · Journal of the Franklin Institute · doi:10.1016/0016-0032(63)90691-4 · Cited by 1,942
The Foundation of the General Theory of Relativity (1916)
(2025) · The Essential Einstein: Scientific Writings · doi:10.2307/jj.27710910.18 · Cited by 1,692
The collected papers of Albert Einstein
Einstein, A., Stachel, J. J., Klein, M. J., Kox, A. J., Schulmann, R., Buchwald, D. K., Michel Janssen, B., Kennefick, D., Rowe, D. E., & Hirschmann, R. (1987) · Cited by 661
Collected Papers of Albert Einstein
Kraus, J. R. (2022) · The Charleston Advisor · doi:10.5260/chara.23.3.17 · Cited by 428
Symmetries in Physics: Philosophical Reflections
(2003) · Cambridge University Press eBooks · doi:10.1017/cbo9780511535369 · Cited by 296
Archive for History of Exact Sciences
(1960) · Nature · doi:10.1038/1881074b0 · Cited by 259
Conservation Laws in General Relativity
Goldberg, J. N. (1958) · Physical Review · doi:10.1103/physrev.111.315 · Cited by 251
Hilbert, D. (1935) · Dritter Band: Analysis · Grundlagen der Mathematik · Physik Verschiedenes · doi:10.1007/978-3-662-38452-7_18 · Cited by 196
Cited by
SYMMETRIES AND INVARIANCES IN CLASSICAL PHYSICS
Brading, K. A., & Castellani, E. (2007) · Elsevier eBooks · doi:10.1016/b978-044451560-5/50016-6 · Cited by 95
“67See Brading and Brown (2007). 68For a discussion of this in the case of general covariance, see Brading and Brown (2002).”
BackgroundInfluentialSelf-citationModified gravity: A unified approach
Böhmer, C. G., & Jensko, E. (2021) · Physical review. D/Physical review. D. · doi:10.1103/physrevd.104.024010 · Cited by 78
Pitts, J. B. (2010) · General Relativity and Gravitation · doi:10.1007/s10714-009-0874-y · Cited by 65
“Noether’s theorems do not care about the equivalence principle; they simply give results in any coordinate system [23].”
Background Independence in Classical and Quantum Gravity
Read, J. A. M. (2023) · doi:10.1093/oso/9780192889119.001.0001 · Cited by 86
Hilbert's ‘Foundations of Physics’: Gravitation and electromagnetism within the axiomatic method
Brading, K. A., & Ryckman, T. A. (2008) · Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics · doi:10.1016/j.shpsb.2007.08.002 · Cited by 72
Self-citationGravitational energy for GR and Poincaré gauge theories: A covariant Hamiltonian approach
Chen, C.-M., Nester, J. M., & Tung, R.-S. (2015) · International Journal of Modern Physics D · doi:10.1142/s0218271815300268 · Cited by 49
Curiel, E. (2014) · PhilSci-Archive (University of Pittsburgh) · Cited by 47
Noether's Theorems and Energy in General Relativity
De Haro, S. (2021) · arXiv · doi:10.48550/arxiv.2103.17160 · Cited by 44
Duerr, P. M. (2018) · Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics · doi:10.1016/j.shpsb.2018.07.002 · Cited by 47
Mesh and measure in early general relativity
Darrigol, O. (2015) · Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics · doi:10.1016/j.shpsb.2015.07.001 · Cited by 29
Duerr, P. M. (2019) · Synthese · doi:10.1007/s11229-019-02503-3 · Cited by 39
“What those circumstances exactly are, is a question of current dispute (closely related to the empirical significance of symmetries, see e.g. Kosso 2000; Brading and Brown 2004; Wallace and Greaves 2014; Teh 2015; Murgueitio Ramirez 2019).”
BackgroundInfluentialDoze mitos sobre a Teoria da Relatividade que precisamos superar
Nunes, R. C., & de Queirós, W. P. (2020) · Caderno Brasileiro de Ensino de Física · doi:10.5007/2175-7941.2020v37n2p531 · Cited by 21
Pitts, J. B. (2016) · Apollo (University of Cambridge) · Cited by 16
Gravitational Energy in Newtonian Gravity: A Response to Dewar and Weatherall
Duerr, P. M., & Read, J. A. M. (2019) · Foundations of Physics · doi:10.1007/s10701-019-00301-y · Cited by 21
“23 Historically too, this was Einstein’s route—avant la lettre (Brading [5]).”
BackgroundLompay, R. R., & Petrov, A. N. (2013) · Journal of Mathematical Physics · doi:10.1063/1.4810017 · Cited by 20
Gauging the Spacetime Metric—Looking Back and Forth a Century Later
Scholz, E. (2020) · Fundamental theories of physics · doi:10.1007/978-3-030-51197-5_2 · Cited by 19
The Field-Theoretic Approach in General Relativity and Other Metric Theories. A ReviewPreprint
Petrov, A. N., & Pitts, J. B. (2020) · arXiv (Cornell University) · doi:10.48550/arxiv.2004.10525 · Cited by 13
On metaphysically necessary laws from physics
Linnemann, N. (2020) · European Journal for Philosophy of Science · doi:10.1007/s13194-020-00281-1 · Cited by 11
“…then the following ρ relations are satisfied, one for every parameter on which the symmetry group depends: ∑ i ( ∂L ∂φi − ∂μ ∂L ∂(∂μφi) ) aki = ∑ i ∂ν { bνki ( ∂L ∂φi −∂μ ∂L ∂(∂μφi) )} (3) (Brading 2005, p. 131) The infinitesimal transformation δ0φi is given by δ0φi = ∑ k { aki (φi, ∂μφi, x)…”
Geometric Objects and Perspectivalism
Read, J. A. M. (2022) · Cambridge University Press eBooks · doi:10.1017/9781108665445.011 · Cited by 9
Penchev, V. D. (2023) · SSRN Electronic Journal · doi:10.2139/ssrn.4426040 · Cited by 19
“…2022; Duerr 2019; Maudlin, Okon, Sudarsky 2019; Hynecek 2018; Schäfer 2018; Wu 2016; Epp, McGrath, Mann 2013; Petrov, Lompay 2013; Yarman 2006; Brading 2005; Mensky 2004; Yoon 2004; 2001; Bondy 1990; Nissani, Leibowitz 1989; 1988; Kyrala 1981; Rylov 1963) consider conservation and…”
BackgroundInfluentialPitts, J. B. (2017) · Cambridge University Press eBooks · doi:10.1017/9781316535783.014 · Cited by 10
“Supposedly, change is missing in Hamiltonian General Relativity [Earman, 2002].”
BackgroundInfluentialOn Tensorial Concomitants and the Non-Existence of a Gravitational Stress-Energy TensorPreprint
Curiel, E. (2009) · PhilSci-Archive (University of Pittsburgh) · doi:10.48550/arxiv.0908.3322 · Cited by 8
“4See, e.g., Brading (2005).”
Energy is Conserved in General Relativity
Gibbs, P. (2013) · Cited by 3
Brading, K. A., & Ryckman, T. A. (2011) · Birkhäuser Boston eBooks · doi:10.1007/978-0-8176-4940-1_8 · Cited by 3
Self-citationConstraining Co-Varying Coupling Constants from Globular Cluster Age
Gupta, R. P. (2023) · Universe · doi:10.3390/universe9020070 · Cited by 2
“The long and complex story relating to the debate on energy conservation in general relativity among some of the most brilliant minds—Felix Klein, Emmy Noether, David Hilbert, Albert Einstein, and others—was narrated by Brading [82].”
Conservation of boundary term for gravitational action
Debnath, S., & Majumder, B. (2023) · Modern Physics Letters A · doi:10.1142/s0217732323500360 · Cited by 2
General Relativity, Mental Causation, and Energy Conservation
Pitts, J. B. (2022) · Erkenntnis · doi:10.1007/s10670-020-00284-7 · Cited by 1
“(This outcome charmingly satisfies one of Einstein’s desiderata (Brading, 2005; Pitts, 2016b).”
BackgroundWeyl׳s search for a difference between ‘physical’ and ‘mathematical’ automorphisms
Scholz, E. (2017) · Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics · doi:10.1016/j.shpsb.2017.04.003 · Cited by 8
“touched the problematics of the Noether theorems, without quoting Noether. For establishment, reception and philosophical discussion of the Noether theorems see (Kosmann-Schwarzbach 2011, Rowe 1999, Brading 2005, Sus 2016). 14 criterion for their physicality earlier (Hs. p. 16): the invariance of the laws of nature, w…”
Felix Klein's "Zu Hilberts erster Note über die Grundlagen der Physik": an English translationPreprint
Chen, C.-M., Nester, J. M., & Vogel, W. (2019) · arXiv (Cornell University) · doi:10.48550/arxiv.1912.12158 · Cited by 1
Chen, C.-M., Nester, J. M., & Vogel, W. (2019) · arXiv (Cornell University) · doi:10.48550/arxiv.1912.12161 · Cited by 1
LEO CORRY. David Hilbert and the Axiomatization of Physics (1898-1918)
Brading, K. A. (2007) · Philosophia Mathematica · doi:10.1093/philmat/nkm044
Self-citationKommentar zum vorangehenden Text Similarity and congruence
Weyl, H. (2016) · Springer eBooks · doi:10.1007/978-3-662-52711-5_3
Historical and Philosophical Insights about General Relativity and Space-time from Particle PhysicsPreprint
Pitts, J. B. (2019) · arXiv (Cornell University) · doi:10.48550/arxiv.1909.13642
“In particular, Einstein’s appeal to the principle of energy-momentum conservation (Einstein and Grossmann, 1996; Norton, 1989; Brading, 2005) contains the key ingredient that makes certain particle physicsstyle derivations of his equations successful (Pitts and Schieve, 2001), namely, that the gravitational field equa…”
BackgroundInfluentialChen, C.-M., Nester, J. M., & Vogel, W. (2020) · arXiv (Cornell University) · doi:10.48550/arxiv.2006.14743
Penchev, V. D. (2023) · SocArXiv (OSF Preprints) · doi:10.31235/osf.io/y2h68
Read, J. A. M. (2023) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780192889119.003.0005
Read, J. A. M. (2023) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780192889119.003.0006
Read, J. A. M. (2023) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780192889119.003.0002
Read, J. A. M. (2023) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780192889119.003.0001
(2023) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780192889119.002.0003
Classical Background Independence
Read, J. A. M. (2023) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780192889119.003.0003
Classical Theories of Spacetime
Read, J. A. M. (2023) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780192889119.003.0004
Al-Shammari, R. M. (2024) · SSRN Electronic Journal · doi:10.2139/ssrn.5016164
Characterization of wormhole spacetimes supported by a covariant action-dependent Lagrangian theory
Ayuso, I., & Lazkoz, R. (2024) · Physical review. D/Physical review. D. · doi:10.1103/physrevd.110.124056 · Cited by 2
“This issue traces back to the debate between Klein, Noether, Hilbert and Einstein concerning the mathematical relevance of the conservation of matter-energy [26], and was analyzed throughout the 20th century in the literature [27–31].”
BackgroundAbsolute representations and modern physics
Jacobs, C., & Read, J. A. M. (2025) · European Journal for Philosophy of Science · doi:10.1007/s13194-025-00645-5 · Cited by 1
“Another example, relevant to particle physics, is that of spinor fields (on which see [Pitts, 2012]).”
Metadata
- Authors
- Brading, K.
- Affiliations
- University of Notre Dame (US)
- Corresponding author
- Brading, Katherine
- ORCID
- Brading, Katherine
- Venue
- The Universe of General Relativity
- Publisher
- Birkhäuser Boston
- Published
- 2005
- Pages
- 125-135
- OpenAlex
- W1503812913
- Cited by
- 50
- References
- 27
- Citations by year
- 2026: 1 · 2025: 1 · 2024: 2 · 2023: 13 · 2022: 2 · 2021: 2 · 2020: 6 · 2019: 6 · 2018: 1 · 2017: 2 · 2016: 2 · 2015: 2 · 2014: 1 · 2013: 2
- FWCI
- 5.14
- Type
- book chapter
- Language
- en
- Open access
- closed
- Licence
- www.springer.com/tdm (tdm)
- Locations
- Birkhäuser Boston eBooks (publishedVersion)
- Topics
- Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Astronomy and Astrophysics › Relativity and Gravitational Theory
- Physical Sciences › Mathematics › Geometry and Topology › Advanced Differential Geometry Research
- Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Astronomy and Astrophysics › Cosmology and Gravitation Theories
- Keywords
- energy conservation (physics), general relativity, Noether's theorem, Klein, Hilbert, Albert Einstein, history of physics, energy-momentum tensor
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.