Between a Rock and a Hard Place: Resident Mothers and the Moral Dilemmas they Face During Custody Disputes
Open accessThe DOI matches its Crossref record; 3 of the 3 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
Recent scholarship has critiqued the tendency for separated mothers in custody disputes to be defined as hostile and alienating. Through the presentation of three case studies, drawn from an interview-based study with 21 women, we show how such pejorative constructions only arise when the conflicting gendered moral accountabilities of contemporary motherhood are overlooked. We found that mothers tend to believe that contact with non-resident fathers is generally in a child’s best interests. However, as a result of balancing complex moral obligations for the care of their children, they may raise questions about particular kinds of arrangements for contact with particular fathers. We argue, therefore, that family law practice will lead to better outcomes for children when professionals listen to the history of, and reasons for, mothers’ positions. To enable family law professionals to undertake this task, we offer an alternative interpretive framework for making sense of women’s stories. Should family law professionals make use of this framework, it is likely that they will understand that the positions mothers adopt are often the outcome of the difficult moral dilemmas they encounter in caring for their children, and that the reductive rubric of the ‘hostile mother’ needs to be treated with scepticism.
Overview
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
The self-check needs the paper’s full text.
Citations
Cites
(2008) · doi:10.1177/1077801208314833 · Cited by 125
Varcoe, C., & Irwin, L. G. (2004) · Qualitative Sociology · doi:10.1023/b:quas.0000015545.82803.90 · Cited by 83
Wuest, J., Ford-Gilboe, M., Merritt-Gray, M., & Lemire, S. (2006) · Health Care for Women International · doi:10.1080/07399330600770221 · Cited by 26
Research works printed but not linked: 59
- Arendell, Terry. 2000. Conceiving and investigating motherhood: The decade’s scholarship. Journal of Marriage and the Family 62: 1192–1207. · DOI · Paper page
- Bock, Jane D. 2000. Doing the right thing? Single mothers by choice and the struggle for legitimacy. Gender and Society 14: 62–86. · DOI · Paper page
- Boyd, Susan B. 2003. Child custody, law and women’s work. Don Mills, ON: Oxford University Press.
- Boyd, Susan B. 2004. Demonizing mothers: Father’s rights discourses in child custody law reform processes. Journal of Association for Research on Mothering 6: 52–74.
- Boyd, Susan B. 2006. Robbed of their families? Fathers’ rights discourse in Canadian parenting law reform processes. In Fathers’ rights activism and law reform in comparative perspective, ed. Richard Collier, and Sally Sheldon, 27–52. Oxford: Hart Publishing.
- Chesler, Phyllis. 1991. Mothers on trial: The custodial vulnerability of women. Feminism and Psychology 1: 409–425. · DOI · Paper page
- Collier, Richard. 2001. A hard time to be a father? Reassessing the relationship between law, policy and family (practices). Journal of Law and Society 28: 520–545. · DOI
- Collier, Richard. 2006. ‘The outlaw fathers fight back’: Fathers’ rights groups, Fathers 4 Justice and the politics of family law reform—reflections on the UK experience. In Fathers’ rights activism and law reform in comparative perspective, ed. Richard Collier, and Sally Sheldon, 53–78. Oxford: Hart Publishing.
- Douglas, Heather, and Tamara Walsh. 2010. Mothers, domestic violence, and child protection. Violence Against Women 16: 489–508. · DOI · Paper page
- Dowd, Nancy E. 2000. Redefining fatherhood. New York: New York University Press.
- Elizabeth, Vivienne. 2004. Viewing mothering, violence and sexuality through the lens of ethnicity: Mainstream media constructions of Tania Witika. In Sex and the body, ed. Annie Potts, Nicola Gavey, and Ann Wetherall, 51–70. Palmerston North: Dunmore.
- Elizabeth, Vivienne. 2010. Turning mothers into villains: Gaps and silences in media accounts of custody abductions. Feminist Media Studies 10: 50–67.
- Eriksson, Maria, and Marianne Hester. 2001. Violent men as good-enough fathers? Violence Against Women 7: 779–798. · DOI · Paper page
- Fineman, Martha A. 1988. Dominant discourse, professional language, and legal change in child custody decision making. Harvard Law Review 101: 727–774. · DOI
- Fraser, Nancy. 1989. Unruly practices: Power, discourse and gender in contemporary social theory. Cambridge: Polity Press.
- Gillies, Val. 2007. Marginalised mothers: Exploring working class experiences of parenting. Milton Park: Routledge.
- Glenn, Evelyn Nakano. 1994. Social constructions of mothering: A thematic overview. In Mothering: Ideology, experience and agency, ed. Evelyn Nakano Glenn, Grace Chang, and Linda R. Forcey, 1–29. New York: Routledge.
- Hays, Sharon. 1996. The cultural contradictions of motherhood. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
- Henderson, Angela C., Sandra M. Harmon, and Jeffrey Houser. 2010. A new state of surveillance? An application of Michel Foucault to modern motherhood. Surveillance and Society 7: 231–247. · doi:10.24908/ss.v7i3/4.4153
- Hester, Marianne. 2004. Future trends and developments. Violence Against Women 10: 1431–1448. · DOI
- Kaganas, Felicity, and Shelley Day Sclater. 2004. Contact disputes: Narrative constructions of ‘good’ parents. Feminist Legal Studies 12: 1–27. · DOI
- Kaspiew, Rae. 2007. Empirical insights into parental attitudes and children’s interests in Family Court litigation. Sydney Law Review 27: 131–162.
- Kopels, Sandra, and Marcie Chesnut Sheridan. 2002. Adding legal insult to injury: Battered women, their children and the failure to protect. Affilia 17: 9–29. · DOI
- Lacroix, Carol. 2006. Freedom, desire and power: Gender processes and presumptions of shared care and responsibility after parental separation. Women’s Studies International Forum 29: 184–196. · doi:10.1016/j.wsif.2006.03.004
- Laing, Karen. 2006. Doing the right thing: Cohabiting parents, separation and child contact. International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family 20: 169–180. · DOI
- Lawler, Steph. 1999. Children need but mothers only want: The power of ‘needs talk’ in the constitution of childhood. In Relating intimacies: Power and resistance, ed. Julie Seymour, and Paul Bagguley, 64–88. Hampshire: McMillan Press. · DOI
- MacLeod, Catriona, and Kevin Durrheim. 2002. Foucauldian feminism: The implications for governmentality. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 32: 41–60. · DOI
- Malson, Helen. 2000. Fictional(ising): Ontological assumptions and methodological productions of (‘anorexic’) subjectivities. In Lines of narrative: Psychosocial perspectives, ed. Molly Andres, Shelley Day Sclater, Corrine Squire, and Amal Treacher, 150–163. London: Routledge. · doi:10.4324/9780203471005_chapter_10
- May, Vanessa. 2003. Lone motherhood past and present: The life stories of Finnish lone mothers. NORA: Nordic Journal of Feminist and Gender Research 11: 27–39. · doi:10.1080/08038740307277
- May, Vanessa. 2004. Narrative identity and the re-conceptualization of lone motherhood. Narrative Identity 14: 169–189. · DOI
- May, Vanessa. 2005. Divorce in Finnish women’s life stories: Defining ‘moral’ behaviour. Women’s Studies International Forum 28: 473–483. · doi:10.1016/j.wsif.2005.09.003
- May, Vanessa. 2008. On being a ‘good’ mother: The moral presentation of self in written life stories. Sociology 42: 470–486. · DOI · Paper page
- Neale, Bren, and Carol Smart. 1997. Experiments in parenthood. Sociology 31: 201–219. · DOI
- Neustein, Amy, and Michael Lesher. 2005. From madness to mutiny: Why mothers are running from the Family Courts—and what can be done about it. Boston: Northeastern University Press.
- Peckover, Sue. 2002. Supporting and policing mothers: An analysis of the disciplinary practices of health visiting. Journal of Advanced Nursing 38: 369–377. · DOI
- Powell, Anastasia, and Suellen Murray. 2008. Children and domestic violence: Constructing a policy problem. Social and Legal Studies 17: 453–473. · DOI
- Rhoades, Helen. 2002. The ‘no contact mother’: Reconstructions of motherhood in the era of the ‘new father’. International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family 16: 71–94. · DOI · Paper page
- Ribbens McCarthy, Jane, Rosalind Edwards, and Val Gillies. 2000. Moral tales of the child and the adult: Narratives of contemporary family lives under changing circumstances. Sociology 34: 785–803. · DOI · Paper page
- Ribbens McCarthy, Jane, Rosalind Edwards, and Val Gillies. 2003. Making families: Moral tales of parenting and step-parenting. London: Sociology Press.
- Risley-Curtiss, Christina, and Kristin Heffernan. 2003. Gender biases in child welfare. Affilia 18: 395–410. · doi:10.1177/0886109903257629
- Sano, Yoshie, Leslie N. Richards, and Anisa M. Zvonkovic. 2008. Are mothers really ‘gatekeepers’ of children? Rural mothers’ perceptions of nonresident fathers’ involvement in low income families. Journal of Family Issues 29: 1701–1723. · DOI
- Sayer, Andrew. 2005. Class, moral worth and recognition. Sociology 39: 947–963. · DOI · Paper page
- Smart, Carol. 1989. Power and the politics of child custody. In Child custody and the politics of gender, ed. Carol Smart, and Selma Sevenhuijsen, 1–2. London: Routledge.
- Smart, Carol. 1991. The legal and moral ordering of child custody. Journal of Law and Society 18: 485–500. · DOI
- Smart, Carol. 1995. Law, crime and sexuality: Essays in feminism. London: Sage.
- Smart, Carol. 1996. Deconstructing motherhood. In Good enough mothering? Feminist perspectives on lone motherhood, ed. Elizabeth Silva, 37–57. London: Routledge.
- Smart, Carol. 1997. Wishful thinking and harmful tinkering? Sociological reflections on family policy. Journal of Social Policy 26: 301–321. · DOI
- Smart, Carol. 1999. The ‘new’ parenthood: Fathers and mothers after divorce. In The new family?, ed. Elizabeth Silva, and Carol Smart, 100–114. London: Sage.
- Smart, Carol. 2006. Preface. In Fathers’ rights activism and law reform in comparative perspective, ed. Richard Collier, and Sheldon Sally, 7–13. Oxford: Hart Publishing.
- Smart, Carol, and Bren Neale. 1999a. Family fragments? Cambridge: Polity Press.
- Smart, Carol, and Bren Neale. 1999b. “I hadn’t really thought about it”: New identities/new fatherhoods. In Relating intimacies: Power and resistance, ed. Julie Seymour, and Paul Bagguley, 118–141. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. · DOI
- Smyth, Bruce, Catherine Caruana, and Anna Ferro. 2004. Child-father contact after separation. Family Matters 67: 20–27.
- Terrance, Cheryl, Karyn Plumm, and Betsi Little. 2008. Maternal blame: Battered women and abused children. Violence Against Women 14: 870–885. · DOI
- Tolmie, Julia, Vivienne Elizabeth, and Nicola Gavey. 2009. Should father contact be prioritised over all other considerations when negotiating parenting arrangements after separation? Raising questions about current family law practices. New Zealand Law Review 4: 659–694.
- Tolmie, Julia, Vivienne Elizabeth, and Nicola Gavey. 2010. Is 50:50 shared care a desirable norm following family separation? Raising questions about current family law practices in New Zealand. New Zealand Universities Law Review 24: 136–166.
- Van Krieken, Robert. 2005. The ‘best interests of the child’ and parental separation: On the ‘civilising of parents’. Modern Law Review 68: 25–48. · DOI
- Wallbank, Julie. 1998. Castigating mothers: The judicial response to ‘wilful’ women in disputes over paternal contact in English law. Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law 20: 357–376. · DOI
- Wallbank, Julie. 2001. Challenging motherhood(s). Harlow: Pearson Education.
- Wallbank, Julie. 2007. Getting tough on mothers: Regulating contact and residence. Feminist Legal Studies 15: 189–222. · DOI
Cited by
Custody Stalking: A Mechanism of Coercively Controlling Mothers Following Separation
Elizabeth, V. (2017) · Feminist Legal Studies · doi:10.1007/s10691-017-9349-9 · Cited by 92
Self-citationDomestic Violence and the Paradox of Post-Separation Mothering
Holt, S. (2017) · British Journal of Social Work · doi:10.1093/bjsw/bcw162 · Cited by 54
“Implicit in the discourse on pre-separation mothering in an environment of domestic abuse is a criticism, often reflected in social work practice (Elizabeth et al., 2010), of her parenting or mothering for exposing her children to this abuse alongside a simultaneous stark absence of social work holding the abuser resp…”
BackgroundGalántai, J., Ligeti, A. S., & Wirth, J. (2019) · Journal of Family Violence · doi:10.1007/s10896-019-00066-y · Cited by 38
“The study’s findings reinforce that institutions may pay less attention to these abusive behaviours than they would necessitate in order for the mothers and children to be safe (Elizabeth et al. 2010, Saunders 2017, Heward-Belle 2017).”
BackgroundThe Gendered Dynamics of Power in Disputes Over the Postseparation Care of Children
Elizabeth, V., Gavey, N., & Tolmie, J. (2012) · Violence Against Women · doi:10.1177/1077801212452049 · Cited by 30
Self-citation‘It’s an invisible wound’: the disenfranchised grief of post-separation mothers who lose care time
Elizabeth, V. (2019) · Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law · doi:10.1080/09649069.2019.1554788 · Cited by 24
“…to financially provide for their children, mothers are morally obliged to facilitate the father-child relationship through sacrificing time with children and, if necessary, compelling children to have contact with their fathers (Elizabeth et al. 2010; Rathus 2010; Cain 2011; Elizabeth et al. 2012).”
BackgroundSelf-citation“Weaponizing” The Tort of Family Violence? Myths, Stereotypes, Lawyers’ Ethics and Access to Justice
Sowter, D., & Koshan, J. (2025) · Windsor Yearbook of Access to Justice · doi:10.22329/wyaj.v40.9559
Metadata
- Authors
- Elizabeth, V., Gavey, N., & Tolmie, J.
- Venue
- Feminist Legal Studies
- Published
- 2010-11-02
- Volume
- 18
- Issue
- 3
- Pages
- 253-274
- ISSN
- 0966-3622 (ISSN-L)
- 1572-8455
- OpenAlex
- W2079019942
- Cited by
- 37
- References
- 3
- FWCI
- 7.48
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- green
- Licence
- www.springer.com/tdm (tdm)
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.