Rethinking motor learning and savings in adaptation paradigms: model-free memory for successful actions combines with internal models

Huang, Vincent S., Haith, Adrian, Mazzoni, Pietro, Krakauer, John W.·2011·Neuron

DOI 10.1016/j.neuron.2011.04.012

Cited by (470)

Items 201–300 of 470

Anodal motor cortex stimulation paired with movement repetition increases anterograde interference but not savings
Li‐Ann Leow, Geoff Hammond, Aymar de Rugy · 2014 · European Journal of Neuroscience
The capacity to learn new motor and perceptual calibrations develops concurrently in childhood
Cristina Rossi, Connie W. Chau, Kristan A. Leech, Matthew A. Statton, Anthony J. Gonzalez, Amy J. Bastian · 2019 · Scientific Reports
Reinforcement regulates timing variability in thalamus
Jing Wang, Eghbal A. Hosseini, Nicolas Meirhaeghe, Adam Akkad, Mehrdad Jazayeri · 2020 · eLife
Dissociable use-dependent processes for volitional goal-directed reaching
Jonathan Sanching Tsay, Hyosub E. Kim, Arohi Saxena, Darius E. Parvin, Timothy Verstynen, Richard B. Ivry · 2022 · Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences
Are fast/slow process in motor adaptation and forward/inverse internal model two sides of the same coin?
Fatemeh Yavari, Farzad Towhidkhah, Mohammad Ali Ahmadi‐Pajouh · 2013 · Medical Hypotheses
Reward-based motor adaptation can generalize across actions.
Katinka van der Kooij, Jeroen B. J. Smeets · 2018 · Journal of Experimental Psychology Learning Memory and Cognition
Mechanisms of responsibility assignment during redundant reaching movements
Alexandra Reichenbach, Angela de Lacy Costello, Peter Zatka-Haas, Jörn Diedrichsen · 2013 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Daily update of motor predictions by physical activity
Nicolas Gueugneau, Nicolas Schweighofer, Charalambos Papaxanthis · 2015 · Scientific Reports
Human decision making anticipates future performance in motor learning
Joshua B. Moskowitz, Daniel J. Gale, Jason P. Gallivan, Daniel M. Wolpert, John Randall Flanagan · 2020 · PLoS Computational Biology
Robust retention of individual sensorimotor skill after self-guided practice
Se‐Woong Park, Dagmar Sternad · 2015 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Similarities in error processing establish a link between saccade prediction at baseline and adaptation performance
Aaron L. Wong, Mark Shelhamer · 2014 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Independent voluntary correction and savings in locomotor learning
Kristan A. Leech, Ryan Thomas Roemmich · 2018 · Journal of Experimental Biology
Eye movements do not play an important role in the adaptation of hand tracking to a visuomotor rotation
Niels Gouirand, James Mathew, Eli Brenner, Frédéric Danion · 2019 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Consolidation through the looking‐glass: sleep‐dependent proactive interference on visuomotor adaptation in children
Charline M. Urbain, Emeline Houyoux, Geneviève Albouy, Philippe Peigneux · 2013 · Journal of Sleep Research
Rapid plasticity of motor corticospinal system with robotic reach training
Shailesh S. Kantak, Lauren M. Jones, P. Narayanan, Timothy N. Judkins, George Frederick Wittenberg · 2013 · Neuroscience
Adaptation Paths to Novel Motor Tasks Are Shaped by Prior Structure Learning
Dmitry Kobak, Carsten Mehring · 2012 · Journal of Neuroscience
Interference between competing motor memories developed through learning with different limbs
Neeraj Kumar, Adarsh Kumar, Bhoomika Sonane, Pratik K. Mutha · 2018 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Long-term retention and reconsolidation of a visuomotor memory
Rodrigo S. Maeda, Steven E. McGee, Daniel S. Marigold · 2018 · Neurobiology of Learning and Memory
Individualized feedback to change multiple gait deficits in chronic stroke
Kevin A. Day, Kendra M. Cherry‐Allen, Amy J. Bastian · 2019 · Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation
Domain-Specific Working Memory, But Not Dopamine-Related Genetic Variability, Shapes Reward-Based Motor Learning
Peter J. Holland, Olivier Codol, Elizabeth Oxley, Madison D. Taylor, Elizabeth Hamshere, Shadiq Joseph, Laura Huffer, Joseph M. Galea · 2019 · Journal of Neuroscience
Younger and Late Middle-Aged Adults Exhibit Different Patterns of Cognitive-Motor Interference During Locomotor Adaptation, With No Disruption of Savings
Cristina Rossi, Ryan Thomas Roemmich, Nicolas Schweighofer, Amy J. Bastian, Kristan A. Leech · 2021 · Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience
Implicit reward-based motor learning
Nina Marieke van Mastrigt, Jonathan Sanching Tsay, Tianhe Wang, Guy Avraham, Sabrina J. Abram, Katinka van der Kooij, Jeroen B. J. Smeets, Richard B. Ivry · 2023 · Experimental Brain Research
Differential effects of reward and punishment on reinforcement-based motor learning and generalization
Cong Yin, Biao Li, Tian Gao · 2023 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Lack of generalization between explicit and implicit visuomotor learning
Jinsung Wang, Shancheng Bao, Grant D. Tays · 2019 · PLoS ONE
In Experts, underlying processes that drive visuomotor adaptation are different than in Novices
Christian Leukel, Albert Gollhofer, Wolfgang Taube · 2015 · Frontiers in Human Neuroscience
Comparison of the Wide-Awake Approach and Conventional Approach in Extensor Indicis Proprius–to–Extensor Pollicis Longus Tendon Transfer for Chronic Extensor Pollicis Longus Rupture
Jung Jun Hong, Ho Jung Kang, Jong Ick Whang, Seung-Yong Sung, Sung-Hoon Kim, Sung-Chul Shin, Si-Nae Kim, Ji-Sup Kim · 2019 · Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery
Virtual Reality as a Context for Adaptation
Mathew P. Yarossi, Madhur Mangalam, Stephanie N. Naufel, Eugene Tunik · 2021 · Frontiers in Virtual Reality
Using robot-assisted stiffness perturbations to evoke aftereffects useful to post-stroke gait rehabilitation
Vaughn Chambers, Panagiotis Artemiadis · 2023 · Frontiers in Robotics and AI
Motor Memory Consolidation Deficits in Parkinson’s Disease: A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis
Jacopo Cristini, Zohra Parwanta, Bernat de las Heras, Almudena Medina‐Rincón, Caroline Paquette, Julien Doyon, Alain Dagher, Simon Steib, Marc Roig · 2023 · Journal of Parkinson s Disease
Motor Control and Learning Theories
Cristiano Alessandro, Niek Beckers, Peter Michael Goebel, Francisco Resquín, José González, Rieko Osu · 2015 · Biosystems & biorobotics
Financial incentives enhance adaptation to a sensorimotor transformation
Kathrin Gajda, Sandra Sülzenbrück, Herbert Heuer · 2016 · Experimental Brain Research
Null effects of levodopa on reward- and error-based motor adaptation, savings, and anterograde interference
Dimitrios J. Palidis, Heather E. McGregor, Andrew Vo, Penny A. MacDonald, Paul L. Gribble · 2021 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Enhancing Generalization of Visuomotor Adaptation by Inducing Use-dependent Learning
Yuming Lei, Shancheng Bao, Mónica A. Pérez, Jinsung Wang · 2017 · Neuroscience
Statistical determinants of visuomotor adaptation along different dimensions during naturalistic 3D reaches
Enrico Ferrea, J. Franke, Pierre Morel, Alexander Gail · 2022 · Scientific Reports
Neurophysiological Evidence of Sensory Prediction Errors Driving Speech Sensorimotor Adaptation
Kwang S. Kim, Leighton B. N. Hinkley, Kurtis Brent, Jessica L. Gaines, Alvince Le Arnz Pongos, Saloni Gupta, Corby L. Dale, Srikantan S. Nagarajan, John F. Houde · 2025 · Journal of Neuroscience
Conventional analysis of trial-by-trial adaptation is biased: Empirical and theoretical support using a Bayesian estimator
Daniel H. Blustein, Ahmed W. Shehata, Kevin B. Englehart, Jonathon W. Sensinger · 2018 · PLoS Computational Biology
Practice Structure and Locomotor Learning After Stroke
Erin E. Helm, Ryan Todd Pohlig, Devina S. Kumar, Darcy S. Reisman · 2019 · Neurology Report
Cerebellar contribution to sensorimotor adaptation deficits in humans with spinal cord injury
Yuming Lei, Mónica A. Pérez · 2021 · Scientific Reports
Perturbation schedule does not alter retention of a locomotor adaptation across days
Sara J. Hussain, Susanne M. Morton · 2014 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Changes in task parameters during walking prism adaptation influence the subsequent generalization pattern
M. Scott Alexander, Brent W. G. Flodin, Daniel S. Marigold · 2013 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Temporally stable adaptation is robust, incomplete and specific
Katinka van der Kooij, Krista E. Overvliet, Jeroen B. J. Smeets · 2016 · European Journal of Neuroscience
Error correction and spatial generalization in human grasp control
Evan Cesanek, Fulvio Domini A · 2017 · Neuropsychologia
Use of explicit processes during a visually guided locomotor learning task predicts 24-h retention after stroke
Margaret A. French, Susanne M. Morton, Darcy S. Reisman · 2020 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Exploring Temporospatial Gait Asymmetry, Dynamic Balance, and Locomotor Capacity After a 12-Week Split-Belt Treadmill Training in Adolescents with Unilateral Cerebral Palsy: A Randomized Clinical Study
Ragab Kamal Elnaggar, Ahmed Alhowimel, Mazyad Alotaibi, Mohamed S. Abdrabo, Mahmoud S. Elfakharany · 2023 · Physical & Occupational Therapy In Pediatrics
Acquisition of a precision walking skill and the impact of proprioceptive deficits in people with motor-incomplete spinal cord injury
Amanda E. Chisholm, Taha Qaiser, Alison M. M. Williams, Gevorg Eginyan, Tania Lam · 2019 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Learning the same motor task twice impairs its retention in a time- and dose-dependent manner
Raphaël Hamel, Lauranne Dallaire-Jean, É. De La Fontaine, Jean‐François Lepage, Pierre‐Michel Bernier · 2021 · Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences
Clustering analysis of movement kinematics in reinforcement learning
Ananda Sidarta, John Komar, David J. Ostry · 2021 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Modulation of motor learning by a paired associative stimulation protocol inducing LTD-like effects
Takuya Sasaki, Yuichiro Shirota, Satoshi Kodama, Naohiko Togashi, Yusuke Sugiyama, Shin‐ichi Tokushige, Satomi Inomata‐Terada, Yasuo Terao, Yoshikazu Ugawa, Tatsushi Toda et al. · 2018 · Brain stimulation
Basal ganglia contributions during the learning of a visuomotor rotation: Effect of dopamine, deep brain stimulation and reinforcement
Puneet Singh, Abhishek Lenka, Albert Stezin, Ketan Ramakant Jhunjhunwala, Pramod Kumar Pal, Ashitava Ghosal, Aditya Murthy · 2019 · European Journal of Neuroscience
Task Feedback Processing Differs Between Young and Older Adults in Visuomotor Rotation Learning Despite Similar Initial Adaptation and Savings
Eva‐Maria Reuter, Li‐Ann Leow, Timothy J. Carroll · 2020 · Neuroscience
Accelerating motor adaptation by virtual reality based modulation of error memories
Belén Rubio Ballester, Laura Serra Oliva, Armin Duff, Paul F. M. J. Verschure · 2015 · International Conference on Rehabilitation Robotics
Intermittent theta burst stimulation of the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex accelerates visuomotor adaptation with delayed feedback
Yanlong Song, Sarah E. Adams, Wynn Legon · 2020 · Cortex
Joint speed feedback improves myoelectric prosthesis adaptation after perturbed reaches in non amputees
Eric J. Earley, Reva E. Johnson, Jonathon W. Sensinger, Levi J. Hargrove · 2021 · Scientific Reports
Sensorimotor Learning in Response to Errors in Task Performance
Dhwani P. Sadaphal, Adarsh Kumar, Pratik K. Mutha · 2022 · eNeuro
Comparing Aftereffects after Split-Belt Treadmill Walking and Unilateral Stepping
KRISTIN V. HUYNH, CAROLINA H. SARMENTO, Ryan Thomas Roemmich, Elizabeth L. Stegemöller, Chris J. Hass · 2014 · Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise
The applicability of motor learning to neurorehabilitation
John W. Krakauer · 2020 · Oxford University Press eBooks
Neural oscillations reflect latent learning states underlying dual-context sensorimotor adaptation
Justin M. Fine, Dalton D. Moore, Marco Santello · 2017 · NeuroImage
Learning fast accurate movements requires intact frontostriatal circuits
Britne A. Shabbott · 2013 · Frontiers in Human Neuroscience
An implicit memory of errors limits human sensorimotor adaptation
Scott T. Albert, Jihoon Jang, Hannah Sheahan, Lonneke Teunissen, Koenraad Vandevoorde, Reza Shadmehr · 2019 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
Strength Training Biases Goal-Directed Aiming
Victor Selvarajah Selvanayagam, Stephan P. Riek, Aymar de Rugy, Timothy J. Carroll · 2016 · Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise
Trial-to-Trial Reoptimization of Motor Behavior Due to Changes in Task Demands Is Limited
Jean‐Jacques Orban de Xivry · 2013 · PLoS ONE
Vector and position coding in goal-directed movements
Marieke C. W. van der Graaff, Eli Brenner, Jeroen B. J. Smeets · 2016 · Experimental Brain Research
Variance in exposed perturbations impairs retention of visuomotor adaptation
Cesar Augusto Canaveral, Frédéric Danion, Félix Berrigan, Pierre‐Michel Bernier · 2017 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Error-related Persistence of Motor Activity in Resting-state Networks
Nicolò Francesco Bernardi, Floris T. van Vugt, Ricardo Ruy Valle-Mena, Shahabeddin Vahdat, David J. Ostry · 2018 · Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience
A generative learning model for saccade adaptation
Carlos R. Cassanello, Florian Ostendorf, Martin Rolfs · 2019 · PLoS Computational Biology
Force and electromyography responses during isometric force release of different rates and step-down magnitudes
Jeewon Choi, Wen Liang Yeoh, Ping Yeap Loh, Satoshi Muraki · 2019 · Human Movement Science
Motor learning in childhood reveals distinct mechanisms for memory retention and re-learning
Kristin E. Musselman, Ryan Thomas Roemmich, Ben Garrett, Amy J. Bastian · 2016 · Learning & Memory
Motor learning in real-world pool billiards
Shlomi Haar, Camille M. van Assel, A. Aldo Faisal · 2019 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
Implicit Adaptation Is Modulated by the Relevance of Feedback
Darius E. Parvin, Jonathan Sanching Tsay, Kristy V. Dang, Alissa R. Stover, Richard B. Ivry, J. Ryan Morehead · 2024 · Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience
Motor Learning: The Great Rate Debate
Adrian Mark Haith, John W. Krakauer · 2014 · Current Biology
Rat locomotor spinal circuits in vitro are activated by electrical stimulation with noisy waveforms sampled from human gait
Francesco Dose, Rachele Menosso, Giuliano Taccola · 2013 · Physiological Reports
Motor Experts Care about Consistency and Are Reluctant to Change Motor Outcome
Volker Kast, Christian Leukel · 2016 · PLoS ONE
Motion state-dependent motor learning based on explicit visual feedback is quickly recalled, but is less stable than adaptation to physical perturbations
Weiwei Zhou, Elizabeth A. Kruse, Rylee Brower, Ryan North, Wilsaan Mychal Joiner · 2022 · Journal of Neurophysiology
No Enhancement of 24-Hour Visuomotor Skill Retention by Post-Practice Caffeine Administration
Sara J. Hussain, Kelly J. Cole · 2015 · PLoS ONE
A Day Awake Attenuates Motor Learning-Induced Increases in Corticomotor Excitability
Toon T. de Beukelaar, Jago Van Soom, Reto Huber, Nicole Wenderoth · 2016 · Frontiers in Human Neuroscience
Neural Signatures of Reward and Sensory Prediction Error in Motor Learning
Dimitrios J. Palidis, Joshua G. A. Cashaback, Paul L. Gribble · 2018 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
Cortical preparatory activity during motor learning reflects visuomotor retention deficits after punishment feedback
Christopher M. Hill, D. Waddell, A. Del Arco · 2021 · Experimental Brain Research
Visuomotor errors drive step length and step time adaptation during ‘virtual’ split-belt walking: the effects of reinforcement feedback
Sumire D. Sato, Ashley Cui, Julia T. Choi · 2021 · Experimental Brain Research
The decay and consolidation of effector-independent motor memories
Shancheng Bao, Jinsung Wang, David L. Wright, John J. Buchanan, Yuming Lei · 2022 · Scientific Reports
This is a test: Oculomotor capture when the experiment keeps score
Brian A. Anderson, Lana Mrkonja · 2022 · Attention Perception & Psychophysics
Reinforcement Learning is Impaired in the Sub-acute Post-stroke Period
Meret Branscheidt, Alkis M. Hadjiosif, Manuel Alejandro Anaya, Jennifer L. Keller, Mario Widmer, Keith D. Runnalls, Andreas Rüdiger Luft, Amy J. Bastian, John W. Krakauer, Pablo A. Celnik · 2025 · Neurorehabilitation and neural repair
Generalization of unconstrained reaching with hand-weight changes
Xiang Yan, Qining Wang, Zhengchuan Lu, Ian H. Stevenson, Konrad Paul Kording, Kunlin Wei · 2012 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Improving the retention of motor skills after reward-based reinforcement by incorporating haptic guidance and error augmentation
Dylan P. Losey, Laura H. Blumenschein, Marcia K. O’Malley · 2016 · IEEE/RAS-EMBS International Conference on Biomedical Robotics and Biomechatronics (BioRob)
Recognition memory for human motor learning
Neeraj Kumar, Floris T. van Vugt, David J. Ostry · 2021 · Current Biology
Just Do It: Action-Dependent Learning Allows Sensory Prediction
Itai Novick, Eilon Vaadia · 2011 · PLoS ONE
Feedback control of recurrent circuits imposes dynamical constraints on learning
Harsha Gurnani, Weixuan Liu, Bingni W. Brunton · 2024 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
The role of training variability for model-based and model-free learning of an arbitrary visuomotor mapping
Carlos A. Velázquez-Vargas, Nathaniel D. Daw, Jordan A. Taylor · 2024 · PLoS Computational Biology
Effect of Extrinsic Reward on Motor Plasticity during Skill Learning
Goldy Yadav, Pierre Vassiliadis, Cécile Dubuc, Friedhelm Christoph Hummel, Gérard Derosière, Julie Duqué · 2025 · eNeuro
Interference Underlies Attenuation upon Relearning in Sensorimotor Adaptation
Guy Avraham, Richard B. Ivry · 2025 · eNeuro
Persistence of adaptation following visuomotor training
Shahryar Ebrahimi, David J. Ostry · 2022 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Physiological Mechanisms That Impact Exercise Adaptations for Individuals With Down Syndrome
Emily M. Post, William J. Kraemer · 2023 · The Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research
Technology-Assisted Rehabilitation of Writing Skills in Parkinson’s Disease: Visual Cueing versus Intelligent Feedback
Evelien Nackaerts, Alice Nieuwboer, Elisabetta Farella · 2017 · Parkinson s Disease
Repeated exposure to tripping like perturbations elicits more precise control and lower toe clearance of the swinging foot during steady walking
Tamon Miyake, Federica Aprigliano, Shigeki Sugano, Silvestro Micera, Vito Monaco · 2021 · Human Movement Science
Decreased Temporal Sensorimotor Adaptation Due to Perturbation-Induced Measurement Noise
Elisabeth B. Knelange, Joan López‐Moliner · 2019 · Frontiers in Human Neuroscience
Speed, precision and grip force analysis of human manual operations with and without direct visual input
Anil Ufuk Batmaz · 2018 · theses.fr (ABES)
Individual sensorimotor adaptation characteristics are independent across orofacial speech movements and limb reaching movements
Nick M. Kitchen, Kwang S. Kim, Prince Ziyi Wang, Robert J. M. Hermosillo, Ludo Max · 2022 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Reinforcement Learning during Locomotion
Jonathan M. Wood, Hyosub E. Kim, Susanne M. Morton · 2024 · eNeuro
A computational pipeline to find lobule-specific electric field distribution during non-invasive cerebellar stimulation
Zeynab Rezaee, Brandon M. Ruszala, Anirban Dutta · 2019 · International Conference on Rehabilitation Robotics
Memory decay and generalization following distinct motor learning mechanisms
Shancheng Bao, Yuming Lei · 2022 · Journal of Neurophysiology
Improvement in Hand Trajectory of Reaching Movements by Error-Augmentation
Sharon Israely, Gerry Leisman, Eli Carmeli · 2018 · Advances in experimental medicine and biology