Rethinking motor learning and savings in adaptation paradigms: model-free memory for successful actions combines with internal models

Huang, Vincent S., Haith, Adrian, Mazzoni, Pietro, Krakauer, John W.·2011·Neuron
DOI 10.1016/j.neuron.2011.04.012

Cited by (470)

Items 301–400 of 470

  1. Timing-Dependent Priming Effects of Anodal tDCS on Two-Hand Coordination
    Atefeh Azarpaikan, Hamid Reza Taheri, Mehdi Sohrabi, Reza Boostani, Majid Ghoshoni · 2019 · Journal of Psychophysiology
  2. Gait symmetric adaptation: Comparing effects of implicit visual distortion versus split-belt treadmill on aftereffects of adapted step length symmetry
    Pranathi Chunduru, Seung-Jae Kim, Hyunglae Lee · 2019 · Human Movement Science
  3. Generalization of visuomotor adaptation depends on the spatial characteristic of visual workspace
    Lei Wang, Jochen Müsseler · 2012 · Experimental Brain Research
  4. Consolidation of use-dependent motor memories induced by passive movement training
    Grant D. Tays, Shancheng Bao, Mousa Javidialsaadi, Jinsung Wang · 2020 · Neuroscience Letters
  5. Human motor learning is robust to control-dependent noise
    Bo Pang, Leilei Cui, Zhong‐Ping Jiang · 2022 · Biological Cybernetics
  6. Reward actively engages both implicit and explicit components in dual force field adaptation
    Marion Forano, David W. Franklin · 2024 · Journal of Neurophysiology
  7. Cognitive computational model reveals repetition bias in a sequential decision-making task
    Eric Legler, Darío Cuevas Rivera, Sarah Schwöbel, Ben Wagner, Stefan J. Kiebel · 2025 · Communications Psychology
  8. Boost your brain: a simple 100% normobaric oxygen treatment improves human motor learning processes
    Zheng Wang, Guillaume Spielmann, Neil Michael Johannsen, Frank L. Greenway, Brian A. Irving, Marc Dalecki · 2023 · Frontiers in Neuroscience
  9. Sensory prediction error drives subconscious motor learning outside of the laboratory
    Scott T. Albert, Emily M. Blaum, Daniel H. Blustein · 2023 · Journal of Neurophysiology
  10. Interacting Learning Processes during Skill Acquisition: Learning to control with gradually changing system dynamics
    Nicolas Ludolph, Martin A. Giese, Winfried Ilg · 2017 · Scientific Reports
  11. Quantifying feedforward control: a linear scaling model for fingertip forces and object weight
    Ying Lu, Seda Bilaloglu, Viswanath Aluru, Preeti Raghavan · 2015 · Journal of Neurophysiology
  12. The Neuropsychology of Movement and Movement Disorders: Neuroanatomical and Cognitive Considerations
    Kathleen Y. Haaland, Richard P. Dum, Pratik K. Mutha, Peter L. Strick, Alexander I. Tröster · 2017 · Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society
  13. The nature of savings associated with a visuomotor adaptation task that involves one arm or both arms
    Reshma James, Shancheng Bao, Arthur D’Amato, Jinsung Wang · 2021 · Human Movement Science
  14. Can moving in a redundant workspace accelerate motor adaptation?
    Jahangir Esfandiari, Seyedsina Razavizadeh, Max‐Philipp Stenner · 2022 · Journal of Neurophysiology
  15. Acoustic stimulation increases implicit adaptation in sensorimotor adaptation
    Li‐Ann Leow, James R. Tresilian, Aya Uchida, Dirk Koester, Tamara Spingler, Stephan P. Riek, Welber Marinovic · 2021 · European Journal of Neuroscience
  16. Home-Based Rehabilitation: Enabling Frequent and Effective Training
    Kyle B. Reed, Ismet Handz̆ić, Samuel McAmis · 2014 · Trends in augmentation of human performance
  17. Can we improve slow learning in cerebellar patients?
    Thomas Hulst, A. Mamlins, Maarten A. Frens, Dae‐In Chang, Sophia L. Goericke, Dagmar Timmann, Opher Donchin · 2020 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  18. Increased error-correction leads to both higher levels of variability and adaptation
    Elisabeth B. Knelange, Joan López‐Moliner · 2020 · PLoS ONE
  19. Adaptive coupling influences generalization of sensorimotor learning
    Mohsen Sadeghi, James N. Ingram, Daniel M. Wolpert · 2018 · PLoS ONE
  20. Wrist speed feedback improves elbow compensation and reaching accuracy for myoelectric transradial prosthesis users in hybrid virtual reaching task
    Eric J. Earley, Reva E. Johnson, Jonathon W. Sensinger, Levi J. Hargrove · 2023 · Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation
  21. Learning to shape virtual patient locomotor patterns: internal representations adapt to exploit interactive dynamics
    Christopher J. Hasson, Sarah E. Goodman · 2018 · Journal of Neurophysiology
  22. The relationship between habits and motor skills in humans
    Yue Du, John W. Krakauer, Adrian Mark Haith · 2021
  23. A software tool for at-home measurement of sensorimotor adaptation
    Jihoon Jang, Reza Shadmehr, Scott T. Albert · 2023 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  24. Revisiting the explicit-implicit additivity assumption in visuomotor adaptation
    Y P Chen, Jordan A. Taylor · 2026 · Journal of Neurophysiology
  25. Parallel learning processes of a visuomotor adaptation task in a changing environment
    Juan J. Mariman, Pablo Ignacio Burgos, Pedro Maldonado · 2018 · European Journal of Neuroscience
  26. Dorsomedial frontal cortex damage impairs error-based, but not reinforcement-based motor learning in humans
    Dimitrios J. Palidis, Lesley K. Fellows · 2023 · Cerebral Cortex
  27. Oculomotor behavior can be adjusted on the basis of artificial feedback signals indicating externally caused errors
    Frauke Heins, Markus Lappe · 2024 · PLoS ONE
  28. Cognitive attribution of the source of an error in object-lifting results in differences in motor generalization
    Kelene A. Fercho, Lee A. Baugh · 2016 · Experimental Brain Research
  29. It Pays to Prepare: Human Motor Preparation Depends on the Relative Value of Potential Response Options
    Eva‐Maria Reuter, Welber Marinovic, Jesse J. Beikoff, Timothy J. Carroll · 2018 · Neuroscience
  30. Perceptual Adaptation to Continuous Versus Intermittent Exposure to Spatial Distortions
    Iona R. McLean, Tyler S. Manning, Emily A. Cooper · 2022 · Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science
  31. Transcranial Direct-Current Stimulation Does Not Affect Implicit Sensorimotor Adaptation: A Randomized Sham-Controlled Trial
    Huijun Wang, Kunlin Wei · 2022 · Brain Sciences
  32. Changes in Resting State Functional Connectivity Associated with Dynamic Adaptation of Wrist Movements
    Andria J. Farrens, Shahabeddin Vahdat, Fabrizio Sergi · 2023 · Journal of Neuroscience
  33. Cortically Evoked Movement in Humans Reflects History of Prior Executions, Not Plan for Upcoming Movement
    Abdelbaset Suleiman, Deborah Solomonow‐Avnon, Firas Mawase · 2023 · Journal of Neuroscience
  34. Online Visual Feedback during Error-Free Channel Trials Leads to Active Unlearning of Movement Dynamics: Evidence for Adaptation to Trajectory Prediction Errors
    Ángel Lago-Rodríguez, R. Chris Miall · 2016 · Frontiers in Human Neuroscience
  35. Motor System
    Janine Reis, George Prichard, Brita Fritsch · 2014 · Elsevier eBooks
  36. Movement Neuroscience Foundations of Neurorehabilitation
    Robert L. Sainburg, Pratik K. Mutha · 2016 · Springer eBooks
  37. Motor learning decline with age is related to differences in the explicit memory system
    Noham Wolpe, James N. Ingram, Kamen A. Tsvetanov, Richard N. Henson, Rogier Kievit, Daniel M. Wolpert, James Benedict Rowe · 2018 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  38. Cognitive load suppresses explicit learning while sparing implicit learning in visuomotor adaptation
    Xiaoyue Zhang, Tianyang Zhang, Kunlin Wei · 2025 · Journal of Neurophysiology
  39. Effects of Sanda Sports Training on Cognitive–Motor Control Based on EEG and Heart Rate Sensors: A Coupled ERP and HRV Analysis
    Ziwen Ning, Jiayi Zhao, Chuanyin Jiang, Haojie Li, Haidong Jiang, Tianfen Zhou · 2025 · Sensors
  40. Implicit Sensorimotor Adaptation Proceeds in Absence of Movement Execution
    Constance Pawlowsky, François Thénault, Pierre‐Michel Bernier · 2023 · eNeuro
  41. Gait Symmetric Adaptation and Aftereffect Through Concurrent Split-Belt Treadmill Walking and Explicit Visual Feedback Distortion
    Seung-Jae Kim, Omik M. Save, Emily Tanner, Arianna Marquez, Hyunglae Lee · 2024 · IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering
  42. Continuous Auditory Feedback Promotes Fine Motor Skill Learning in Mice
    Dongsheng Xiao, Matilde Balbi · 2025 · eNeuro
  43. Metronome-guided training accelerates the adaptation to an aerobic training pace in swimming
    Marco Fassone, Luca Puce, Monica Biggio, Laura Avanzino, Marco Bove, Ambra Bisio · 2025 · Frontiers in Sports and Active Living
  44. Improving short-term retention after robotic training by leveraging fixed-gain controllers
    Dylan P. Losey, Laura H. Blumenschein, Janelle P. Clark, Marcia K. O’Malley · 2019 · Journal of Rehabilitation and Assistive Technologies Engineering
  45. Multiple functions of cerebello-thalamic neurons in learning and offline consolidation of a motor skill in mice
    Andrés Pablo Varani, Caroline Mailhes‐Hamon, Romain W Sala, Marie Sarraudy, Sarah E.E. Fouda, Jimena Laura Frontera, Clément Léna, Daniela Popa · 2026 · eLife
  46. Evidence of sensory error threshold in triggering locomotor adaptations in humans
    Emily Herrick, Sergiy Yakovenko · 2025 · PLoS ONE
  47. Upper Limb Impairment
    Preeti Raghavan · 2018 · Elsevier eBooks
  48. Memories of motor adaptation do not necessarily decay with behavioral unlearning
    Chenyu Yan, Yilin Chen, Ziyin Lu, Zhi Li · 2019 · Experimental Brain Research
  49. Beyond the mean reaction time: Trial-by-trial reaction time reveals the distraction effect on perceptual-motor sequence learning
    Yue Du, Jane E. Clark · 2020 · Cognition
  50. Robotic Technology for Spinal Cord Injury: Upper Extremity
    Berna Celik · 2015 · Türkiye Fiziksel Tıp ve Rehabilitasyon Dergisi
  51. Model-free robust optimal feedback mechanisms of biological motor control
    Tao Bian, Zhong‐Ping Jiang · 2016 · World Congress on Intelligent Control and Automation
  52. Motorisches Lernen
    Mathias Hegele, Sandra Sülzenbrück · 2016 · Springer eBooks
  53. Dual contributions of cerebellar-thalamic networks to learning and offline consolidation of a complex motor task
    Andrés Pablo Varani, Romain W Sala, Caroline Mailhes‐Hamon, Jimena Laura Frontera, Clément Léna, Daniela Popa · 2020 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  54. Altered Dynamics of Cortical Beta-Oscillations during Motor Learning in Cerebellar Ataxia
    Jana Klimpke, Dorothea Henkel, Hans‐Jochen Heinze, Max‐Philipp Stenner · 2020 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  55. Multiple functions of cerebello-thalamic neurons in learning and offline consolidation of a motor skill in mice
    Andrés Pablo Varani, Caroline Mailhes‐Hamon, Romain W Sala, Marie Sarraudy, Sarah E.E. Fouda, Jimena Laura Frontera, Clément Léna, Daniela Popa · 2024 · eLife
  56. Distributed representations of temporally accumulated reward prediction errors in the mouse cortex
    Hiroshi Makino, Ahmad Marwazi Mohd Suhaimi · 2025 · Science Advances
  57. Habits and dopamine
    Jesus Bertran‐Gonzalez, Bernard W. Balleine · 2025 · Handbook of behavioral neuroscience
  58. Using tools as cues for motor adaptation in virtual reality
    Andrew Michael King, Jacob J. Boulrice, Shanaathanan Modchalingam, Laura Mikula, Bernard Marius ’t Hart, Denise Y P Henriques · 2026 · Journal of Neurophysiology
  59. M1 a‐ tDCS does not acutely enhance motor skill acquisition of a dexterous, timing‐based videogame task in adults
    Brandon O. Blake, Walter P. Burton, Emelia E. Duchow, Quinn McCallion, Brach Poston, Zachary A. Riley · 2026 · Physiological Reports
  60. Use‐dependent directional bias does not transfer to the untrained limb during bimanual contractions
    Welber Marinovic, Melinda Homan, Timothy J. Carroll · 2017 · European Journal of Neuroscience
  61. Lateralization of acquisition and consolidation in direction but not amplitude of a motor skill task
    Jisung Yuk, Robert L. Sainburg · 2024 · Experimental Brain Research
  62. Variant Target Effects on Motor Learning With M1 Anodal tDCS
    Joselyn Perez, Quinn McCallion, Brach Poston, Zachary A. Riley · 2025 · Brain and Behavior
  63. Generalization of adaptation to a complex visuo-motor transformation across the workspace
    Herbert Heuer, Sandra Sülzenbrück · 2012 · Behavioural Brain Research
  64. Reward gain model describes cortical use-dependent plasticity
    Firas Mawase, Nicholas F. Wymbs, Shintaro Uehara, Pablo A. Celnik · 2016 · Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC)
  65. Repetitive training of contralateral limb through reconsolidation strengthens motor skills
    Tomoya Gyoda, Kazuto Ishida, Tatsunori Watanabe, Ippei Nojima · 2021 · Neuroscience Letters
  66. Evidence for an efferent-based prediction contributing to implicit motor adaptation
    Annika Szarka, Hyosub E. Kim, John Timothy Inglis, Romeo Chua · 2025 · PLoS ONE
  67. Nos1+ neurons are critical for motor learning and post-stroke motor recovery
    Yu‐Hui Lin, Xiu-Mei Xu, Long Lin, Xian-Hui Deng, Wei Chen, Mingyu Chen, Ya-Lan Hou, Fan Gao, Chang-Jing Zhang, Hai‐Yin Wu et al. · 2025 · Cell Reports
  68. Spatial realignment in sensorimotor adaptation: Taking the efficiency into account.
    Lei Wang, Miya K. Rand, Jochen Müsseler · 2013 · Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & Performance
  69. Direction-Specific Iterative Tuning of Motor Commands With Local Generalization During Randomized Reaching Practice Across Movement Directions
    Pritesh N. Parmar, James L. Patton · 2021 · Frontiers in Neurorobotics
  70. Indirect feedback hinders explicit sensorimotor adaptation
    Y P Chen, Sabrina J. Abram, Richard B. Ivry, Jonathan Sanching Tsay · 2025 · Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences
  71. Modeling Expected Reaching Error and Behaviors for Motor Adaptation
    Eric J. Earley, Levi J. Hargrove · 2019 · Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC)
  72. Sensory prediction errors, not performance errors, update memories in visuomotor adaptation
    Kangwoo Lee, Youngmin Oh, Jun Izawa, Nicolas Schweighofer · 2018 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  73. The Impact of Mechanical Feedback on Correcting Errors in Overhead Volleyball Serve Performance
    Manaf Majid Hassan, Hameed Hammad Khalaf, Omar Ahmed Mosleh, Waleed Khalid Hammadi, Shakir Mahmood Abdullah · 2024 · Annals of Applied Sport Science
  74. Multiple Functions of Cerebello-Thalamic Neurons in Learning and Offline Consolidation of a Motor Skill in mice
    Andrés Pablo Varani, Caroline Mailhes‐Hamon, Romain W Sala, Sarah E.E. Fouda, Jimena Laura Frontera, Clément Léna, Daniela Popa · 2024 · eLife
  75. Speed and Accuracy of Movement During Visuomotor Adaptation Are Still Developing in School‐Age Children
    Alexander J. Cook, Deborah Eileen Giaschi, Hee Yeon Im · 2026 · Infant and Child Development
  76. Continuous Control of Diverse Skills in Quadruped Robots Without Complete Expert Datasets
    Jiaxin Tu, Xiaoyi Wei, Yueqi Zhang, Taixian Hou, Xiaofei Gao, Zhiyan Dong, Peng Zhai, Lihua Zhang · 2025 · Proceedings - IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation/Proceedings
  77. Advancing Stroke Recovery Through Operant Conditioning of Corticomuscular Coherence
    Jasper I. Mark, David A. Cunningham, Jessica M. Cassidy · 2025 · Restorative Neurology and Neuroscience
  78. Sensorimotor Learning of Dexterous Manipulation
    Qiushi Fu, Marco Santello · 2018 · Elsevier eBooks
  79. Generalization of visuomotor adaptation associated with use-dependent learning across different movement workspaces and limb postures
    Shancheng Bao, Yuming Lei, Kevin G. Keenan, Jinsung Wang · 2022 · Human Movement Science
  80. The Influence of Age on the Intermanual Transfer and Retention of Implicit Visuomotor Adaptation
    Sajida Khanafer, Heidi Sveistrup, Erin Krista Cressman · 2022 · Journal of Motor Behavior
  81. Movement Neuroscience Foundations of Neurorehabilitation
    Robert L. Sainburg, Pratik K. Mutha · 2022 · Springer eBooks
  82. Slower rates of prism adaptation but intact aftereffects in patients with early to mid-stage Parkinson's disease
    Alex Swainson, Kathryn M. Woodward, Marciana Ionela Boca, Michal Rolinski, Philip Collard, Nadia L. Cerminara, Richard Apps, Alan L. Whone, Iain Donald Gilchrist · 2023 · Neuropsychologia
  83. Savings in visuomotor learning are associated with connectivity changes within a cerebello-thalamo-cortical network encoding movement errors
    Lucas Struber, Laurent Lamalle, Pierre-Alain Barraud, Aurélien Courvoisier, Rafael Laboissière, Takayuki Ito, Vincent Nougier, David J. Ostry, Fabien Cignetti · 2025 · Brain Structure and Function
  84. Triggering motor adaptations at the pelvis using the RGR trainer
    Antoine Dewarrat, Giacomo Severini, Paolo Bonato, Maciej Dariusz Pietrusinski, Dinos Mavroidis · 2014 · IEEE Annual Northeast Bioengineering Conference (NEBEC)
  85. Analysis of Q-learning on ANNs for robot control using live video feed
    Nihal Murali, Kunal Gupta, Surekha Bhanot · 2017 · IEEE International Conference on Signal and Image Processing Applications (ICSIPA)
  86. Two different motor learning mechanisms contribute to learning reaching movements in a rotated visual environment
    Virginia W. Chu, Terence D. Sanger · 2014 · F1000Research
  87. Perceiving transformed movements when using tools
    Christine Sutter, Sandra Sülzenbrück · 2012 · Experimental Brain Research
  88. Mechanisms of motor learning and brain plasticity post stroke
    Erin E. Helm · 2024 · Library, Museums and Press - UDSpace (University of Delaware)
  89. Understanding the physiological role of the cerebellum and motor cortex on human motor learning
    Danny Adrian Spampinato · 2017
  90. To Overwrite or to Recall? Individual Differences in Motor Adaptation
    Young-Min Oh, Nicolas Schweighofer · 2018 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  91. Null effects of levodopa on reward- and error-based motor adaptation, savings, and anterograde interference
    Dimitrios J. Palidis, Heather R. McGregor, Andrew Vo, Penny A. MacDonald, Paul L. Gribble · 2020 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  92. A novel approach to the empirical characterization of learning in biological systems
    Yarden Cohen, Predrag Cvitanović, Sara A. Solla · 2021 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  93. To Examine the Effects of Exercise & Instructional Based Interventions on Executive Functioning, Motor Learning & Emotional Intelligence Abilities Among Older Adults
    Lavanya Rajeshkumar · 2021
  94. System identification reveals multiple interacting states in visuomotor adaptation
    Priscilla Balestrucci, Marc O. Ernst · 2022 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  95. Neural population variance explains adaptation differences during learning
    Hannah M. Stealey, Yi Zhao, Hung‐Yun Lu, Enrique Contreras-Hernandez, Yin-Jui Chang, Philippe N. Tobler, Jarrod A. Lewis‐Peacock, Samantha R. Santacruz · 2024 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  96. Editorial: Reinforcement feedback in motor learning: neural underpinnings of skill refinement
    Christopher M. Hill, Vincent Koppelmans, Mario Ubaldo Manto · 2025 · Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience
  97. Road width effects on feedback control in human steering behavior
    Jo-Yu Liu, James R. H. Cooke, Luc P. J. Selen, W. Pieter Medendorp · 2025
  98. Instrumental-Motor Transfer: The Relative Value of Competing Movement Goals Modulates Implicit Motor Learning
    Naser Al-Fawakhiri, Vikram S. Chib, Samuel D. McDougle · 2026 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  99. Motor Memories for Expectation and Uncertainty in the Environment
    Alkis M. Hadjiosif · 2015 · Digital Access to Scholarship at Harvard (DASH) (Harvard University)
  100. Motor learning during reaching movements : model acquisition and recalibration
    SJ Telgen · 2015 · UCL Discovery (University College London)