CoChat

LEAD FIGURINES FROM THE SANCTUARY OF ARTEMIS ORTHIA AT SPARTA IN THE ART GALLERY OF GREATER VICTORIA (CANADA): PROBLEMS OF TYPOLOGY AND COLLECTIONS HISTORY

Open access
Braun, Graham C., Engstrom, Jacob M. · 2022 · The Annual of the British School at Athens

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 67 of the 95 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 2 of the 115 sources its claims cite were checked for support.

Abstract

This paper presents the collections history and typological characteristics of a small collection of Laconian lead figurines from the sanctuary of Artemis Orthia currently held in the Art Gallery of Greater Victoria, British Columbia, Canada. The collection, which first belonged to Ramsay Traquair, serves as a case study for the applicability of the traditional lead figurine typology to decontextualised artefacts, demonstrating its limitations for assigning precise and accurate dates based on style without the benefit of stratigraphic and contextual evidence. The paper further attests to the value of comprehensively analysing small museum and gallery collections in order to gain more individualised understandings of the figurines within the large Laconian corpus than could be afforded upon excavation. Thus, this study helps to elucidate some of the limitations to the means by which we interpret Laconian material culture as well as to nuance our understanding of Laconian lead figurines by demonstrating the varied capability of the typology and published comparanda in dating and stylistic description.

Overview

CoChat Summary

TL;DR

This article reconstructs the collections history and typology of 62 Laconian lead figurines from the sanctuary of Artemis Orthia, now in the Art Gallery of Greater Victoria, tracing them to Ramsay Traquair and the 1906 British School at Athens excavations. It argues that Wace’s traditional lead figurine typology cannot reliably assign precise dates to decontextualised figurines on stylistic grounds, except in a few distinctive cases.

Key findings

  • The AGGV received 62 Laconian lead figurines in a 1965 donation from Mrs H.V. Bartholomew; a note dated 10 May 1910 from Ramsay Traquair to his sister Hilda Napier, mother of the donor, confirms their origin in the 1906 BSA excavations at the sanctuary of Artemis Orthia, limiting findspots to the conical riverbank deposit, Trench A and/or Trench B.
  • The traditional typology is ineffective for precise stylistic dating without stratigraphic context: only a few figurines can be confidently assigned precise phases (e.g. 11, 18, 38), while entire classes, especially spike wreaths, can only be assigned broad ranges. Spike wreaths are assigned Lead II–VI (c. 620–250 BCE); ball wreaths (n = 3) cannot be dated more precisely; the pomegranate wreath (52) and ring (7) are attributed to Lead I–II.
  • Among the 12 female figurines, possible attributions span Lead I–VI, though most find closest comparanda in Lead I–IV; 11 is assigned Lead I–II, likely Lead II, and 38 is assigned c. 650–500 BCE. Among 11 male figurines (10 warriors and a flautist), 18 is assigned Lead I–II and the flautist 32 is assigned Lead I–II. Among six animal figurines, the winged horse 35 is assigned Lead I–II and the deer 49 is favoured as later Lead V or VI; five miscellaneous figurines are unassignable to specific dates.
  • Contrary to Wace’s suggestion, thickness does not hold firm as a reliable independent criterion for determining relative date on an individual basis within the Traquair Collection; the study finds no demonstrable correlation between thickness and likely date as determined from closest stylistic comparanda.

Methods

  • Case study of the 62 lead figurines in the AGGV, with a supplementary catalogue providing standardised measurements of length, width and thickness, descriptions and comparanda for all figurines.
  • Figurines are grouped into five broad groups—wreaths and ring, female figurines, male figurines, animals, and miscellaneous—and compared against the published Laconian lead figurine corpus.
  • Chronological attribution employs Wace’s lead phases and Hodkinson’s dating of those phases (Table 1), while collections history is reconstructed from the Traquair note, an aged paper label, AGGV donation records and BSA archival material.

Limitations

  • Stated: the collection lacks stratigraphic context, so phase and date attributions depend on typology and published comparanda; the traditional typology is often insufficient for precise dates, wreaths are chronically under-published and stylistically conservative, and no large-scale, well-stratified, published assemblage excavated under modern methodology exists to support a critical re-analysis of Wace’s typology.
  • Stated: absolute chronology for the Geometric and Archaic phases at Artemis Orthia remains uncertain and partly speculative; Wace’s typology has not received comprehensive updating on the stratigraphic and contextual bases on which it was founded.
  • Evident from the text: the sample is small (62 figurines), no shared moulds are represented within the collection itself, many figurines are incomplete or fragmentary, and even identifiable matching moulds can still yield wide date ranges, as with figurine 38.

Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1017/s0068245421000150

Cites

67 of 95 references verified0 citation errors · 28 not checkable

Statistics

Nothing to recompute.

Figures

Fig.  . Plan of the sanctuary of Artemis Orthia following the  excavation season. Trench A, Trench B and test pits excavated during the  season are labelled as such. (After Dawkins  - , pl.  ; AO , pl. III; British School at Athens Archive, Sparta Excavation Records, Sparta  a; reproduced with the permission of the British School at Athens.)
Fig.  . Plan of the sanctuary of Artemis Orthia following the  excavation season. Trench A, Trench B and test pits excavated during the  season are labelled as such. (After Dawkins  - , pl.  ; AO , pl. III; British School at Athens Archive, Sparta Excavation Records, Sparta  a; reproduced with the permission of the British School at Athens.)CC-BY · From the PDF
Fig.  . Wreaths and ring. (Photo by authors.)
Fig.  . Wreaths and ring. (Photo by authors.)CC-BY · From the PDF
Fig.  . Catalogue no.  : female figurine carrying a votive offering. (Photo by authors.)
Fig.  . Catalogue no.  : female figurine carrying a votive offering. (Photo by authors.)CC-BY · From the PDF
Fig.  . Catalogue no.  : female figurine with headdress and lozenge-patterned dress. (Photo by authors.)
Fig.  . Catalogue no.  : female figurine with headdress and lozenge-patterned dress. (Photo by authors.)CC-BY · From the PDF
Fig.  . Catalogue no.  : flautist. (Photo by authors.)
Fig.  . Catalogue no.  : flautist. (Photo by authors.)CC-BY · From the PDF

Verification

Claims the paper makes

0 Valid · 9 Not valid · 77 Not checked · 129 Own results and interpretations

74 more claims

Create a free account to see all 215 claims and every source verdict.

See all claims — free account
  • It may state two separate claims as one. 80
  • Probably not a substantial claim. 78
  • The quote only partly states this claim. 3

Create a free account to see these claims.

Citations

Cites

Show all 95 references

Research works printed but not linked: 94

  1. Kourouniotis, 1910, Τὸ ἐν Βάσσαις ἀρχαιότερον ἱερὸν τοῦ Ἀπόλλωνος, ArchEph, 271
  2. 18. Calligas, P.G. . 'From the Amyklaion', in J.M. Sanders (ed.), ΦΙΛΟΛΑΚΩΝ: Lakonian Studies in Honour of Hector Catling (London), -.
  3. 128. Spelman, H. . 'Alcman  PMGF and Horace C. .', ZPE , -.
  4. 4. Angelopoulos, K. and Konstantinidis, D. . "Το κοίτασμα ψευδαργύρου -αργύρου -μολύβδου των Μολάων Λακωνίας", Bulletin of the Geological Society of Greece , -.
  5. 141. Traquair, R. . The Old Silver of Quebec (Toronto).
  6. 5. Antonaccio, C.M. . 'Dedications and the character of cult', in R. Hägg and B. Alroth (eds), Greek Sacrificial Ritual, Olympian and Chthonian: Proceedings of the Sixth International Seminar on Ancient Greek Cult, Organized by the Department of Classical Archaeology and Ancient History, Göteborg University, - April  (Stockholm), -.
  7. 43. Dickins, G. -b. 'Laconia: II. Excavations at Sparta, . . Topographical conclusions', BSA , -.
  8. 47. Dickins, G. . 'The art of Sparta', BurlMag , -.
  9. 154. Wasowicz, A. and Zdrojewska, W. . Monuments en plomb d'Olbia pontique au musée national de Varsovie (Monumenta Antiqua Orae Septentrionalis Ponti Euxini Reperta Locisque Externis Deposita ; Torun ´).
  10. 155. LEAD FIGURINES FROM THE SANCTUARY OF ARTEMIS ORTHIA AT SPARTA  https://doi.org/10.1017/S0068245421000150 Published online by Cambridge University Press
  11. 87. Lorimer, H.L. . Homer and the Monuments (London).
  12. 89. Luongo, F. . 'Cui bono? Perché tornare a riflettere sulle fasi arcaiche del santuario di Artemis Orthia a Sparta?' ASAtene , -.
  13. 64. Hill, R.G. (ed.) . 'Traquair, Ramsay', in Biographical Dictionary of Architects in Canada - (available online <http:// dictionaryofarchitectsincanada.org/node/> accessed July ).
  14. 94. Macmillan, G.A. . 'The British School at Athens - survey of Sparta', The Times,  February, .
  15. 99. Megaw, A.H.S. -. 'Archaeology in Greece, - ', AR , -.
  16. 131. Stibbe, C.M. . Lakonische Vasenmaler des sechsten Jahrhunderts v. Chr. Supplement (Mainz am Rhein).
  17. 13. Boss, M. . Lakonische Votivgaben aus Blei (Würzburg).
  18. 106. GRAHAM C. BRAUN AND JACOB M. ENGSTROM  https://doi.org/10.1017/S0068245421000150 Published online by Cambridge University Press
  19. 92. Luongo, F. . 'Il santuario di Artemis Orthia a Sparta: nuove considerazioni sulle Traqu di frequentazione più antiche dell'area sacra', in A. Pontrandolfo and M. Scafuro (eds), Dialoghi sull'Archeologia della Magna Grecia e del Mediterraneo. Atti del I. Convegno Internazionale di Studi, Paestum, - settembre  (Paestum), -.
  20. 32. Davies, M. (ed.) . Poetarum Melicorum Graecorum Fragmenta, Volumen I: Alcman, Stesichorus, Ibycus (Oxford).
  21. 107. Nafissi, M. . 'Distribution and trade', in C.M. Stibbe, Laconian Mixing Bowls: A History of the Krater Lakonikos from the Seventh to the Fifth Century B.C. Laconian Black-Glazed Pottery, part  (Allard Pierson Series -Scripta Minora ; Amsterdam), -.
  22. 114. Pipili, M. . Laconian Iconography of the Sixth Century BC (Oxford University Committee for Archaeology Monograph ; Oxford).
  23. 30. Cook, J.M. and Nicholls, R.V. . 'Laconia: Kalývia Sokhás. Sparta', BSA , -.
  24. 6. Baumer, L.E. . Kult im Kleinen. Ländliche Heiligtümer spätarchaischer bis hellenistischer Zeit. Attika-Arkadien-Argolis-Kynouria (Rahden).
  25. 57. Fragkopoulou, F. . 'Spartan sanctuaries and Lakonian identity between  and  BC' (unpublished PhD thesis, King's College London).
  26. 63. Hedgcock, F.T., Moreau, A., Marshall, H. and Kennedy, G. . 'Nondestructive physical examination of corroded lead', in J.S. Olin and M.J. Blackman (eds), Proceedings of the  th International Archaeometry Symposium, Smithsonian Institution, - May  (Washington, DC), -.
  27. Romaios, 1911, Ἔρευναι ἐν Κυνουρίᾳ, Prakt, 253
  28. 140. Traquair, R. . 'Frankish architecture in Greece', Royal Institute of British Architects Journal , - and -.
  29. Bonias, 1998, Ένα αγροτικό ιερό στις Αιγιές Λακωνίας
  30. 1905–6, Annual meeting of the subscribers, BSA, 12, 481
  31. 134. Tillyard, H.J.W. -. 'Laconia: I. Inscriptions from the Artemisium', BSA , -.
  32. 157. Waywell, G.B., Wilkes, J.J., Bailey, D.M. and Sanders, G. D.R. . 'Excavations at Sparta: the Roman stoa, -. Preliminary report, part ', BSA , -.
  33. Zavvou, 1997a, Ανώγεια. Θέση Μολύβι, ArchDelt, 52, 196
  34. 42. Dickins, G. -a. 'Laconia: II. Excavations at Sparta, . . The theatre', BSA , -.
  35. Cartledge, 2001, Spartan Reflections
  36. 152. Wace, A.J.B, Thompson, M.S. and Droop, J.P. -. 'Laconia: I. Excavations at Sparta, . . The Menelaion', BSA , -.
  37. 118. Prost, F. . 'Laconian art', in A. Powell (ed.), A Companion to Sparta, vol.  (Hoboken), -.
  38. 25. Cavanagh, W., Crouwel, J., Catling, R.W.V. and Shipley, G. . Continuity and Change in a Greek Rural Landscape: The Laconia Survey, vol. : Methodology and Interpretation (BSA Supp. Vol. ; London).
  39. Droop, 1929, The Laconian pottery, AO, 52
  40. 21. Catling, H.W. -. 'Excavations at the Menelaion, Sparta, -', AR , -.
  41. 115. Pipili, M. . 'Archaic Laconian vase-painting: some iconographic considerations', in W.G. Cavanagh and S.E.C Walker (eds), Sparta in Laconia: The Archaeology of a City and its Countryside (BSA Studies Vol. ; London), -.
  42. 59. Gallou, C. . Death in Mycenaean Laconia: A Silent Place (Oxford).
  43. 103. Murray, I. (ed.) . 'Ramsay Traquair: the architectural heritage of Quebec', Digital Exhibitions & Collections from the McGill University Library (available online at <cac.mcgill.ca/ traquair> accessed July ).
  44. 66. Hodkinson, S. b. 'Patterns of bronze dedications at Spartan sanctuaries, c. - BC: towards a quantified database of material and religious investment', in W.G. Cavanagh and S.E.C. Walker (eds), Sparta in Laconia: The Archaeology of a City and its Countryside (BSA Studies Vol. ; London), -.
  45. Tsountas, 1892, Ἐκ τοῦ Ἀμυκλαίου, ArchEph, 1
  46. 123. Sanders, J.M. . 'The early Lakonian Dioskouroi reliefs', in J.M. Sanders (ed.), ΦΙΛΟΛΑΚΩΝ: Lakonian Studies in Honour of Hector Catling (London), -.
  47. 76. Kennell, N.M. . Spartans: A New History (Malden, MA).
  48. 74. Kastriotes, P. . "Τὸ Μενελάϊον", Prakt, -.
  49. 146. Wace, A.J.B. -. 'Laconia: I. Excavations at Sparta, . . The Menelaion: the lead figurines', BSA , -.
  50. 142. Traquair, R. . The Old Architecture of Quebec: A Study of the Buildings Erected in New France from the Earliest Explorers to the Middle of the Nineteenth Century (Toronto).
  51. 84. Léger, R.M. . Artemis and Her Cult (Oxford).
  52. Wace, 1929, Lead figurines, AO, 249
  53. 58. Fyfe, T. . Review of van Millingen , JHS , -.
  54. 1906–7, List of directors, honorary students, students and associates, BSA, 13, 472
  55. Dawkins, 1929b, The terracotta figurines, AO, 145
  56. 72. Jurriaans-Helle, G. . 'Spartaans, loodzwaar, én charmant', Vereniging van Vrienden, Allard Pierson Museum Amsterdam, Mededelingenblad , -.
  57. 108. Nafissi, M. . La nascita del kosmos: studi sulla storia e la società di Sparta (Naples).
  58. 121. Ross, L. . Archäologische aufsätze, vol.  (Leipzig).
  59. 97. Matthews, T.H. . 'Obituary: Ramsay Traquair', Journal of the Royal Architectural Institute of Canada , .
  60. 116. Pipili, M. . 'Samos, the Artemis sanctuary. The Laconian pottery', JdI , -.
  61. 145. Wace, A.J.B. -. 'Laconia: I. Excavations at Sparta, . . The city wall', BSA , -.
  62. 160. Woodward, A.M. and Hobling, M.B. /-/. 'Excavations at Sparta, -. . The acropolis', BSA , -.
  63. Dawkins, 1929a, The history of the sanctuary, AO, 1
  64. 52. Dugas, C. and Laurent, R. . 'Essai sur les vases de style cyrénéen', RA , -.
  65. Kiskyras, 1988, Ὁ ὀρυκτὸς πλοῦτος τῆς Μάνης καὶ γενικώτερα τῆς Λακωνίας, Lakonikai Spoudai, 9, 117
  66. 102. Murray, I. (ed.) . Ramsay Traquair and His Successors: A Guide to the Archive (Montreal).
  67. 24. Cavanagh, W., Crouwel, J., Catling, R.W.V. and Shipley, G. . Continuity and Change in a Greek Rural Landscape: The Laconia Survey, vol. : Archaeological Data (BSA Supp. Vol. ; London).
  68. 50. Droop, J.P. . 'The Laconian pottery', in AO, -. DSA= 'Ramsay Traquair', in Dictionary of Scottish Architects,  (available online <www. scottisharchitects.org.uk/architect_full.php?id=> accessed July ).
  69. 110. Nobbs, P.E. . 'Ramsay Traquair, Hon. M.A., F.R. I.B.A', Journal of the Royal Architectural Institute of Canada , -.
  70. 126. Smith, T.J. . 'Dances, drinks and dedications: the Archaic komos in Laconia', in W.G. Cavanagh and S.E.C. Walker (eds), Sparta in Laconia: The Archaeology of a City and its Countryside (BSA Studies Vol. ; London), -.
  71. 86. Lloyd, J. forthcoming. '"No figures warranted absolutely accurate": the final phases of the lead votives at the sanctuary of Orthia', in M. Pagkalos and A. Scarpato (eds), The Hellenistic Peloponnese: New Perspectives (London).
  72. 95. Marangou, E.-L.I. . Lakonische Elfenbein-und Beinschnitzereien (Tübingen).
  73. 96. Mason, H. . 'The literary reception of Sparta in France', in A. Powell (ed.), A Companion to Sparta, vol.  (Hoboken), -.
  74. 156. Waywell, G.B. and Wilkes, J.J. . 'Excavations at Sparta: the Roman stoa, -. Part ', BSA , -.
  75. Hedgcock, 1986, Proceedings of the 24th International Archaeometry Symposium, Smithsonian Institution, 14–18 May 1984, 243
  76. 23. Catling, H.W. . 'The work of the British School at Athens at Sparta and Laconia', in W.G. Cavanagh and S.E.C. Walker (eds), Sparta in Laconia: The Archaeology of a City and its Countryside (BSA Studies Vol. ; London), -.
  77. 129. Stibbe, C.M. . Lakonische Vasenmaler des sechsten Jahrhunderts v. Chr.,  vols (Amsterdam).
  78. 60. Gassowska, B. . 'Wota ołowiane z sanktuariów spartan ´skich w Muzeum Narodowym w Warszawie', Rocznik Muzeum Narodowego w Warszawie , -.
  79. 109. Nafissi, M. . 'La stele di Damonon (IG V ,  = Moretti, IAG ), gli Hekatombaia (Strabo ,,) e il sistema festive della Laconia d'epoca classica', in La cultura a Sparta in età classica. Atti del seminario di studi, Università statale di Milano, - maggio  (Aristonothos ; Trento), -.
  80. 12. Bosher, J.F. . Imperial Vancouver Island: Who Was Who, - (Bloomington, IN).
  81. 73. Kakissis, A.G. . 'The Byzantine Research Fund archive: encounters of arts and crafts architects in Byzantium', in M. Llewellyn Smith, P.M. Kitromilides and E. Calligas (eds), Scholars, Travels, Archives: Greek History and Culture through the British School at Athens (BSA Studies Vol. ; London), -.
  82. 91. Luongo, F. . 'The Artemis Orthia's notebooks revised: new informations from old excavation?', ASAtene , -.
  83. 38. Dawkins, R.M. c. 'Carvings in soft limestone', in AO, -.
  84. 39. Dawkins, R.M. d. 'Objects in carved ivory and bone', in AO, -.
  85. Forster, 1906–7, Laconia: II. Topography, BSA, 13, 219
  86. 85. Lloyd, J. . 'The Spartan lead votives: new data from archival and scientific analysis', in C. Tarditi and R. Sassu (eds), Offerte in metallo nei santuari greci. Doni votive, rituali, smaltimento. Atti del seminario internazionale online,  ottobre  (Thiasos ; Rome), -.
  87. Kourinou, 2000, Σπάρτη. Συμβολὴ στὴ μνημειακὴ τοπογραφία της
  88. 71. Jensen, S.R. . 'Reception of Sparta in North America: eighteenth to twenty-first centuries', in A. Powell (ed.), A Companion to Sparta, vol.  (Hoboken), -.
  89. Dickins, 1929, The masks, AO, 163
  90. Phaklaris, 1990, Αρχαία Κυνουρία. Ανθρώπινη δραστηριότητα καὶ περιβάλλον
  91. Woodward, 1929, Inscriptions, AO, 285
  92. 132. Stos-Gale, Z.A. and Gale, N.H. . 'The Minoan thalassocracy and the Aegean metal trade', in R. Hägg and N. Marinatos (eds), The Minoan Thalassocracy: Myth and Reality (Stockholm), -.
  93. 158. Waywell, G.B., Wilkes, J.J., Bland, R., Sidell, E.J., Wilkinson, K.N and Chandler, G.M. . 'Excavations at Sparta: the Roman stoa, -. Part ', BSA , -.
  94. Zavvou, 1997b, Μουσείο Σπάρτης, ArchDelt, 52, 207

Cited by

See all 5

Metadata

Authors
Braun, G. C., & Engstrom, J. M.
Affiliations
  • University of British Columbia (CA)
  • University of Cincinnati (US)
Corresponding author
Engstrom, Jacob M.
Venue
The Annual of the British School at Athens
Published
2022-04-18
Volume
117
Pages
195-228
ISSN
  • 0068-2454 (ISSN-L)
  • 2045-2403
OpenAlex
W4223956362
Cited by
5
References
89
Citations by year
2026: 1 · 2025: 1 · 2024: 1 · 2023: 2
FWCI
5.51
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
The Annual of the British School at Athens (publishedVersion, cc-by)
Funders
  • Smithsonian Institution
  • McGill University
  • University of Victoria
  • British School at Athens
  • University of Cambridge
  • King's College London
Topics
  • Social Sciences › Arts and Humanities › Archeology (arts and humanities) › Ancient Mediterranean Archaeology and History
  • Social Sciences › Arts and Humanities › Classics › Classical Antiquity Studies
  • Social Sciences › Arts and Humanities › Archeology (arts and humanities) › Ancient and Medieval Archaeology Studies
Keywords
Sparta, figurine typology, stylistic analysis, history of museum collections

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.

A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-02, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).

A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-02 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).

Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol).

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: LEAD FIGURINES FROM THE SANCTUARY OF ARTEMIS ORTHIA AT SPARTA IN THE ART GALLERY OF GREATER VICTORIA (CANADA): PROBLEMS OF TYPOLOGY AND COLLECTIONS HISTORY. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1017/s0068245421000150
The paper
Braun, G. C., & Engstrom, J. M. (2022). LEAD FIGURINES FROM THE SANCTUARY OF ARTEMIS ORTHIA AT SPARTA IN THE ART GALLERY OF GREATER VICTORIA (CANADA): PROBLEMS OF TYPOLOGY AND COLLECTIONS HISTORY. The Annual of the British School at Athens. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0068245421000150

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.