Advancements in Ligand-Based Virtual Screening through the Synergistic Integration of Graph Neural Networks and Expert-Crafted Descriptors

Abstract

The fusion of traditional chemical descriptors with Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) offers a compelling strategy for enhancing ligand-based virtual screening methodologies. A comprehensive evaluation revealed that the benefits derived from this integrative strategy vary significantly among different GNNs. Specifically, while GCN and SchNet demonstrate pronounced improvements by incorporating descriptors, SphereNet exhibits only marginal enhancement. Intriguingly, despite SphereNet's modest gain, all three models-GCN, SchNet, and SphereNet-achieve comparable performance levels when leveraging this combination strategy. This observation underscores a pivotal insight: sophisticated GNN architectures may be substituted with simpler counterparts without sacrificing efficacy, provided that they are augmented with descriptors. Furthermore, our analysis reveals a set of expert-crafted descriptors' robustness in scaffold-split scenarios, frequently outperforming the combined GNN-descriptor models. Given the critical importance of scaffold splitting in accurately mimicking real-world drug discovery contexts, this finding accentuates an imperative for GNN researchers to innovate models that can adeptly navigate and predict within such frameworks. Our work not only validates the potential of integrating descriptors with GNNs in advancing ligand-based virtual screening but also illuminates pathways for future enhancements in model development and application. Our implementation can be found at https://github.com/meilerlab/gnn-descriptor.