Bond Dissociation Energies and Radical Stabilization Energies Associated with Substituted Methyl Radicals

Abstract

Bond dissociation energies (BDEs) and radical stabilization energies (RSEs) associated with a series of 22 monosubstituted methyl radicals ( • CH 2 X) have been determined at a variety of levels including, CBS-RAD, G3(MP2)-RAD, RMP2, UB3-LYP and RB3-LYP. In addition, W1‘ values were obtained for a subset of 13 of the radicals. The W1‘ BDEs and RSEs are generally close to experimental values and lead to the suggestion that a small number of the experimental estimates warrant reexamination. Of the other methods, CBS-RAD and G3(MP2)-RAD produce good BDEs. A cancellation of errors leads to reasonable RSEs being produced from all the methods examined. CBS-RAD, W1‘ and G3(MP2)-RAD perform best, while UB3-LYP performs worst. The substituents (X) examined include lone-pair-donors (X = NH 2, OH, OCH 3, F, PH 2, SH, Cl, Br and OCOCH 3 ), π-acceptors (X = BH 2, CH CH 2, C⋮CH, C 6 H 5, CHO, COOH, COOCH 3, CN and NO 2 ) and hyperconjugating groups (CH 3, CH 2 CH 3, CF 3 and CF 2 CF 3 ). All substituents other than CF 3 and CF 2 CF 3 result in radical stabilization, with the vinyl (CH CH 2 ), ethynyl (C⋮CH) and phenyl (C 6 H 5 ) groups predicted to give the largest stabilizations of the π-acceptor substituents examined and the NH 2 group calculated to provide the greatest stabilization of the lone-pair-donor groups. The substituents investigated in this work stabilize methyl radical centers in three general ways that delocalize the odd electron: π-acceptor groups (unsaturated substituents) delocalize the unpaired electron into the π-system of the substituent, lone-pair-donor groups (heteroatomic substituents) bring about stabilization through a three-electron interaction between a lone pair on the substituent and the unpaired electron at the radical center, while alkyl groups stabilize radicals via a hyperconjugative mechanism. Polyfluoroalkyl substituents are predicted to slightly destabilize a methyl radical center by inductively withdrawing electron density from the electron-deficient radical center.