Assessing predictions of violence: Being accurate about accuracy.

Abstract

The prediction of violence occupies a prominent and controversial place in public mental health practice. Productive debate about the validity of violence predictions has been hampered by the use of methods for quantifying accuracy that do not control for base rates or biases in favor of certain outcomes. This article describes these problems and shows how receiver-operating characteristic analysis can be used to solve them. The article also reanalyzes 58 data sets from 44 published studies of violence prediction. Taken together, these data strongly suggest that mental health professionals' violence predictions are substantially more accurate than chance. Short-term (1-7 day) clinical predictions seem no more accurate than long-term (> 1 year) predictions. Past behavior alone appears to be a better long-term predictor of future behavior than clinical judgments and may also be a better indicator than cross-validated actuarial techniques.

Cited by (20)

1. The suicidal behaviors questionnaire-revised (SBQ-R): validation with clinical and nonclinical samples
   Osman, Augustine, Bagge, Courtney L., Gutierrez, Peter M., Konick, Lisa C., Kopper, Beverly A., Barrios, Francisco X. · 2001 · Assessment
2. Comparing effect sizes in follow-up studies: ROC Area, Cohen's d, and r.
   Rice, Marnie E., Harris, Grant T. · 2005 · Law and Human Behavior
3. Improving risk assessments for sex offenders: A comparison of three actuarial scales.
   Hanson, R. Karl, Thornton, David · 2000 · Law and Human Behavior
4. Twelve-Month Prevalence of and Risk Factors for Suicide Attempts in the World Health Organization World Mental Health Surveys
   Borges, Guilherme, Nock, Matthew K., Haro Abad, Josep M., Hwang, Irving, Sampson, Nancy A., Alonso, Jordi, Andrade, Laura Helena, Angermeyer, Matthias C., Beautrais, Annette, Bromet, Evelyn et al. · 2010 · The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry
5. Studying the clinician: judgment research and psychological assessment
   1999 · Choice Reviews Online

See all 796