Mathematical problem solving by analogy.

Abstract

We report the results of 2 experiments and a verbal protocol study examining the component processes of solving mathematical word problems by analogy. College students first studied a problem and its solution, which provided a potential source for analogical transfer. Then they attempted to solve several analogous problems. For some problems, subjects received one of a variety of hints designed to reduce or eliminate the difficulty of some of the major processes hypothesized to be involved in analogical transfer. Our studies yielded 4 major findings. First, the process of mapping the features of the source and target problems and the process of adapting the source solution procedure for use in solving the target problem were clearly distinguished: (a) Successful mapping was found to be insufficient for successful transfer and (b) adaptation was found to be a major source of transfer difficulty. Second, we obtained direct evidence that schema induction is a natural consequence of analogical transfer. The schema was found to co-exist with the problems from which it was induced, and both the schema and the individual problems facilitated later transfer. Third, for our multiple-solution problems, the relation between analogical transfer and solution accuracy was mediated by the degree of time pressure exerted for the test problems. Finally, mathematical expertise was a significant predictor of analogical transfer, but general analogical reasoning ability was not. The implications of the results for models of analogical transfer and for instruction were considered.

Cites (5)

1. Perception in chess
   Chase, William G., Simon, Herbert A. · 1973 · Cognitive Psychology
2. Schema induction and analogical transfer
   Gick, Mary L., Holyoak, Keith J. · 1983 · Cognitive Psychology
3. Analogical problem solving
   Gick, Mary L., Holyoak, Keith J. · 1980 · Cognitive Psychology
4. Chunking in recall of symbolic drawings
   Egan, Dennis E., Schwartz, Barry J. · 1979 · Memory & Cognition
5. The role of analogy in transfer between similar problem states
   Reed, Stephen K., Ernst, George W., Banerji, Ranan · 1974 · Cognitive Psychology

Show all 5 references

Cited by (11)

1. Discipline‐Based Education Research: Understanding and Improving Learning in Undergraduate Science and Engineering
   Singer, Susan, Smith, Karl A. · 2013 · Journal of Engineering Education
2. The nature of feedback: How different types of peer feedback affect writing performance
   Nelson, Melissa M., Schunn, Christian D. · 2009 · Instructional Science
3. A symbolic-connectionist theory of relational inference and generalization.
   Hummel, John E., Holyoak, Keith J. · 2003 · Psychological Review
4. Children's mathematical development: Research and practical applications.
   Geary, David C. · 1994
5. Analogy and Relational Reasoning
   Holyoak, Keith J. · 2012 · The Oxford Handbook of Thinking and Reasoning

See all 413