Do humans have two systems to track beliefs and belief-like states
The DOI matches its Crossref record; 211 of the 214 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
The lack of consensus on how to characterize humans' capacity for belief reasoning has been brought into sharp focus by recent research. Children fail critical tests of belief reasoning before 3 to 4 years of age (H. Wellman, D. Cross, & J. Watson, 2001; H. Wimmer & J. Perner, 1983), yet infants apparently pass false-belief tasks at 13 or 15 months (K. H. Onishi & R. Baillargeon, 2005; L. Surian, S. Caldi, & D. Sperber, 2007). Nonhuman animals also fail critical tests of belief reasoning but can show very complex social behavior (e.g., J. Call & M. Tomasello, 2005). Fluent social interaction in adult humans implies efficient processing of beliefs, yet direct tests suggest that belief reasoning is cognitively demanding, even for adults (e.g., I. A. Apperly, D. Samson, & G. W. Humphreys, 2009). The authors interpret these findings by drawing an analogy with the domain of number cognition, where similarly contrasting results have been observed. They propose that the success of infants and nonhuman animals on some belief reasoning tasks may be best explained by a cognitively efficient but inflexible capacity for tracking belief-like states. In humans, this capacity persists in parallel with a later-developing, more flexible but more cognitively demanding theory-of-mind abilities.
Overview
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
Claims other papers make about this one
Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?
In the citing paper
“Contrary to this assumption, pragmatic reasoning, such as the derivation of implicatures, reasoning about an interlocutor and general Theory of Mind, is typically believed to bear a cognitive cost and be effortful and slow [61,82].”
From The role of pragmatic mechanisms in referential communication and categorization: An emergent communication model (2026) · cites this paper as [82]
Citations
Cites
Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. B
Press, H. (1886) · Cited by 10,080
Does the autistic child have a “theory of mind” ?
Baron-Cohen, S., Leslie, A. M., & Frith, U. (1985) · Cognition · doi:10.1016/0010-0277(85)90022-8 · Cited by 8,599
(2013) · Handbooks of Sociology and Social Research · doi:10.1007/978-94-007-6772-0 · Cited by 7,486
Relevance: Communication and Cognition
Sperber, D., & Wilson, D. (1986) · Cited by 6,708
Wimmer, H. (1983) · Cognition · doi:10.1016/0010-0277(83)90004-5 · Cited by 6,305
Statistical learning by 8-month-old infants
Saffran, J. R., Aslin, R. N., & Newport, E. L. (1996) · Science · doi:10.1126/science.274.5294.1926 · Cited by 5,659
Language, Thought, and Other Biological Categories: New Foundations for Realism
Millikan, R. G. (1984) · doi:10.7551/mitpress/4124.001.0001 · Cited by 4,758
Fodor, J. A. (1975) · Medical Entomology and Zoology · Cited by 4,588
(1989) · Cited by 4,498
Meta-Analysis of Theory-of-Mind Development: The Truth about False Belief
Wellman, H. M., Cross, D., & Watson, J. (2001) · Child Development · doi:10.1111/1467-8624.00304 · Cited by 4,476
Cited by
Items 701–800 of 999
Language Comprehension, Inference, and Alternatives
Skordos, D., & Barner, D. (2019) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198791768.013.1 · Cited by 4
Being Pluralist About Understanding Others: Contexts and Communicative Practices
Gallagher, S., & Fiebich, A. (2019) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780198794400.003.0004 · Cited by 9
Knowledge, Belief, and the Asymmetry Thesis
Wikforss, Å. M. (2019) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780198794400.003.0003 · Cited by 6
Challenging the Two-systems Model of Mindreading
Jacob, P. (2019) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780198794400.003.0005 · Cited by 12
Law, Folk Psychology and Cognitive Science
Kurek, Ł. (2021) · Cambridge University Press eBooks · doi:10.1017/9781108623056.004 · Cited by 9
Li, X., Yuan, M., Xu, P., & Wu, W. (2021) · Psychology Research and Behavior Management · doi:10.2147/prbm.s333824 · Cited by 4
Theory of mind tested by implicit false belief: a simple and full‐fledged mental state attribution
Egawa, J., Kawasaki, K., Hayashi, T., Akikawa, R., Someya, T., & Hasegawa, I. (2021) · FEBS Journal · doi:10.1111/febs.16322 · Cited by 5
Reading Patterns, Engagement Style and Theory of Mind
Das, A., & Moosath, H. (2022) · Psychological Studies · doi:10.1007/s12646-021-00635-6 · Cited by 6
Brooks, P. J., & Parshina, O. (2019) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198791768.013.5 · Cited by 6
Mindreading in Adults: Cognitive Basis, Motivation, and Individual Differences
Apperly, I. A., & Wang, J. J. (2021) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780198843290.003.0005 · Cited by 9
Self-citationOn the Origins of Mind: A Comparative Perspective
Durdevic, K., & Call, J. (2022) · Annual Review of Developmental Psychology · doi:10.1146/annurev-devpsych-050620-125215 · Cited by 8
Going Dennettian about Gricean communication
Planer, R. J. (2023) · Philosophical Psychology · doi:10.1080/09515089.2023.2204887 · Cited by 8
On the importance of infant carrying for social learning and the development of social cognition
Bánovský, J. (2023) · Philosophical Psychology · doi:10.1080/09515089.2023.2217211 · Cited by 4
Seeing Together: Joint Attention in Attic Tragedy
Duncan, A. C. (2023) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780192888938.003.0010 · Cited by 6
Budelmann, F. (2023) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780192888938.003.0001 · Cited by 4
Tay, C., Ng, R., Ye, N. N., & Ding, X. P. (2024) · Journal of Experimental Child Psychology · doi:10.1016/j.jecp.2024.105863 · Cited by 4
Theory of mind and Verstehen (understanding) methodology
Kumazaki, T. (2016) · History of Psychiatry · doi:10.1177/0957154x16650791 · Cited by 5
The dot perspective task revisited: Evidence for directional effects.
O’Grady, C., Scott‐Phillips, T., Lavelle, J. S., & Smith, K. (2017) · Cognitive Science · Cited by 4
Wahrnehmung von Personen und soziale Kognition
Schweinberger, S. R., & Schneider, D. (2014) · Psychologische Rundschau · doi:10.1026/0033-3042/a000225 · Cited by 5
Putting unicepts to work: a teleosemantic perspective on the infant mindreading puzzle
Michael, J. (2015) · Synthese · doi:10.1007/s11229-015-0850-x · Cited by 5
Tonhauser, J. (2019) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198791768.013.30 · Cited by 6
Enquiries Concerning the Minds of Others
Parrott, M. (2019) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780198794400.003.0001 · Cited by 4
Mazon, C., Fage, C., Consel, C., Amestoy, A., Hesling, I., Bouvard, M. P., Etchegoyhen, K., & Sauzeon, H. (2019) · Brain Sciences · doi:10.3390/brainsci9120334 · Cited by 8
Young Children’s Meta-Ignorance
Bartz, D. T. (2017) · Digital Access to Scholarship at Harvard (DASH) (Harvard University) · Cited by 10
Flexible cultural learning through action coordinationPreprint
Charbonneau, M., Curioni, A., McEllin, L. S., & Strachan, J. W. A. (2022) · PsyArXiv (OSF Preprints) · doi:10.31234/osf.io/ahrgs · Cited by 5
Thinking Through Things: Extended Cognition as a Consolatory Fiction in Greek Tragedy
Noel, A.-S. (2023) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780192888938.003.0007 · Cited by 6
Melzel, S., Altvater‐Mackensen, N., Ganglmayer, K., Müller, F., Steinmassl, K., Hauf, P., & Paulus, M. (2024) · Journal of Experimental Child Psychology · doi:10.1016/j.jecp.2024.106064 · Cited by 4
The vividness of visualisations and autistic trait expression are not strongly associated
Bouyer, L. N., Pellicano, E., Saurels, B. W., Schwarzkopf, D. S., & Arnold, D. H. (2025) · Consciousness and Cognition · doi:10.1016/j.concog.2025.103821 · Cited by 3
Heise, M. J., & Bowman, L. C. (2025) · Child Development · doi:10.1111/cdev.14263 · Cited by 4
Creating a shared representational space
Oláh, K., Elekes, F., & Király, I. (2025) · Acta Psychologica · doi:10.1016/j.actpsy.2025.106137 · Cited by 7
Pomareda, C., Devine, R. T., & Apperly, I. A. (2024) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0305270 · Cited by 4
Self-citationImplicit False Beliefs: The State of Art
Lebedeva, E. I., & Ilina, E. A. (2024) · Journal of Modern Foreign Psychology · doi:10.17759/jmfp.2024130204 · Cited by 3
Neuropsychology of social cognition: culture, display rules, and emotional expressivity
Nestor, P. G., & Woodhull, A.-A. (2024) · Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology · doi:10.1080/13803395.2024.2428728 · Cited by 6
It's Only Human: The Evolution of Distinctively Human Cognition
Schulz, A. W. (2025) · doi:10.1093/9780197800188.001.0001 · Cited by 3
Navigating space and the developing mind
Németh, A. R., Stojić, S., & Nádasdy, Z. (2025) · Frontiers in Psychology · doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1521487 · Cited by 5
The evolutionary foundations of common ground
Armstrong, J. (2025) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/9780191967566.003.0005 · Cited by 3
Social evaluation of skill and competence in primates
O’Hearn, W. J., Hirel, M., Keupp, S., & Fischer, J. (2025) · Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews · doi:10.1016/j.neubiorev.2025.106346 · Cited by 4
Wang, Z., & Wang, L.-M. (2021) · International Journal of Behavioral Development · doi:10.1177/0165025420988594 · Cited by 4
Hannes Rakoczy, B., & Proft, M. (2022) · Frontiers in Psychology · doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2022.988754 · Cited by 3
Rubio, F., Neira, C., Villacura-Herrera, C., & Castillo, R. D. (2022) · Psykhe (Santiago) · doi:10.7764/psykhe.2021.36317 · Cited by 6
Rydz, E., Gut, A., Pietryga, A., & Wróblewski, Z. (2023) · Religions · doi:10.3390/rel14060694 · Cited by 4
A new rationalist account of the development of false-belief understanding
Antilici, F. (2023) · Philosophical Studies · doi:10.1007/s11098-023-01986-8 · Cited by 3
Growth From Uncertainty: Understanding the Replication ‘Crisis’ in Infant Cognition
Lavelle, J. S. (2023) · Philosophy of Science · doi:10.1017/psa.2023.157 · Cited by 5
Navarro, E., & Rossi, E. (2024) · Journal of Psycholinguistic Research · doi:10.1007/s10936-024-10105-5 · Cited by 5
Zhou, S., Yang, H., Ye, M., Ding, N., & Liu, T. (2024) · Communication Research · doi:10.1177/00936502241302569 · Cited by 5
Biocultural evolution, narratives, and emerging cultures of sustainability
Glynn, P. D., Cockerill, K., HELGESON, J. F., Newman, G., Glynn, S. A., & White, P. (2025) · Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change · doi:10.1007/s11027-025-10200-5 · Cited by 6
The co-evolution of pragmatics and grammatical complexity
Wittenberg, E., & Jackendoff, R. S. (2025) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/9780191967566.003.0011 · Cited by 3
The neural underpinnings of allocentric thinking in a novel signaling task
Zhen, S., Chowdhury, A., & Yu, R. (2021) · NeuroImage · doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2021.117808 · Cited by 3
Holtgraves, T. (2019) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198791768.013.32 · Cited by 4
Face perception and mind misreading
Smortchkova, J. (2022) · Topoi · doi:10.1007/s11245-022-09823-z · Cited by 4
Understanding the Immediacy of Other Minds
Gangopadhyay, N., & Pichler, A. (2016) · European Journal of Philosophy · doi:10.1111/ejop.12196 · Cited by 3
Spontaneous false belief attribution develops earlier in less inhibited children
Białek, A., & Białecka‐Pikul, M. (2018) · Cognitive Development · doi:10.1016/j.cogdev.2018.06.003 · Cited by 3
Theory of Mind and referring expressions after Traumatic Brain Injury
Balaban, N., Biran, M., & Sacher, Y. (2019) · Aphasiology · doi:10.1080/02687038.2019.1637812 · Cited by 3
He, X., Yang, Y., Wang, L., & Yin, J. (2021) · Psychonomic Bulletin & Review · doi:10.3758/s13423-020-01857-x · Cited by 3
The Cognitive Basis of Social Interaction Across the Lifespan: An Introduction
Ferguson, H. J. (2021) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780198843290.003.0001 · Cited by 6
Grigoroglou, M., & Papafragou, A. (2019) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198791768.013.18 · Cited by 3
Neuroscience Contributions to Childhood Theory of Mind Development
Bowman, L. C., & Wellman, H. M. (2013) · Emerald Group Publishing Limited eBooks · doi:10.1108/978-1-62396-513-620251014 · Cited by 25
Raisa, Z. H., Karuppali, S., Bhat, J. S., & Bajaj, G. (2019) · Indian Journal of Psychiatry · doi:10.4103/psychiatry.indianjpsychiatry_115_18 · Cited by 5
Pouscoulous, N., & Dulcinati, G. (2019) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198791768.013.19 · Cited by 3
Boccadoro, S., Cracco, E., Hudson, A. R., Bardi, L., Nijhof, A. D., Wiersema, J. R., Braß, M., & Mueller, S. C. (2019) · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory) · doi:10.1101/560953 · Cited by 3
Haman, M. (2019) · Psychology of Language and Communication · doi:10.2478/plc-2019-0006 · Cited by 3
Perspective taking in a novel signaling task: effects of world knowledge and contextual constraintPreprint
Sulik, J., & Lupyan, G. (2018) · PsyArXiv (OSF Preprints) · doi:10.31234/osf.io/ftz94 · Cited by 4
Moral development: conflicts and compromisesPreprint
Buon, M., & Habib, M. (2016) · PsyArXiv (OSF Preprints) · doi:10.31234/osf.io/nznt6 · Cited by 4
Franchin, L. (2019) · Springer eBooks · doi:10.1007/978-3-319-98390-5_3-1 · Cited by 3
Mindreading and Social Cognition
Lavelle, J. S. (2022) · Cambridge University Press eBooks · doi:10.1017/9781108946766 · Cited by 24
Seeing Through Other Eyes: How Language Experience and Cognitive Abilities Shape Theory of Mind
Pathare, M., Navarro, E., & Conway, A. R. A. (2025) · Behavioral Sciences · doi:10.3390/bs15060755 · Cited by 4
Level-1-visual perspective taking for human and robot avatars
Blech, C., Lembcke, H., Bouquet, C. A., & Liepelt, R. (2025) · Psychological Research · doi:10.1007/s00426-025-02188-z · Cited by 2
Lorenzo, G., Meliá, S., Lorenzo-Lledó, ., Gadzhimusieva, D., & Cerdán-Chacón, A. (2025) · Interactive Technology and Smart Education · doi:10.1108/itse-04-2025-0081 · Cited by 6
Against a normative view of folk psychology
Wilkinson, M. R. (2014) · Frontiers in Psychology · doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2014.00598 · Cited by 3
Joint action without robust theory of mind
Story, D. (2019) · Synthese · doi:10.1007/s11229-019-02386-4 · Cited by 3
Spontaneous theory of mind in adults with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder
Hayashi, W., Arai, G., Uno, H., Saga, N., Ikuse, D., Takashio, O., & Iwanami, A. (2020) · Psychiatry Research · doi:10.1016/j.psychres.2020.113025 · Cited by 4
Ganglmayer, K., Haupt, M., Finke, K., & Paulus, M. (2021) · Cognitive Processing · doi:10.1007/s10339-021-01015-8 · Cited by 3
The Cognitive Basis of Mindreading
Apperly, I. A. (2021) · Springer eBooks · doi:10.1007/978-3-030-51890-5_18 · Cited by 2
Self-citationThe Cognitive Study of Religious Activity: Beyond Religion and Belief
Boyer, P. (2022) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780190693350.013.3 · Cited by 2
Rohde, H. (2019) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198791768.013.21 · Cited by 2
Rong, Y. I. N. (2022) · Advances in Psychological Science · doi:10.3724/sp.j.1042.2022.02540 · Cited by 2
Are Mentalizing Systems Necessary? An Alternative Through Self–other Distinction
Watanabe, M. (2022) · Review of Philosophy and Psychology · doi:10.1007/s13164-022-00656-8 · Cited by 3
Spontaneous perspective-taking and its relation to schizotypy
Gardner, M. R., & Buchanan, T. (2023) · Cognitive Neuropsychiatry · doi:10.1080/13546805.2023.2189575 · Cited by 3
Schein, S. L. (2023) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oso/9780192888938.003.0011 · Cited by 2
Herold, M., Kovács, G. X., Herold, R., Pótó, Z., Fekete, J., Varga, E., Hajnal, A. S., Csulak, T., Pethő, B., Hebling, D., et al. (2024) · Journal of Psychiatric Research · doi:10.1016/j.jpsychires.2024.01.022 · Cited by 3
Nestor, P. G., & Woodhull, A.-A. (2024) · Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology · doi:10.1080/13803395.2024.2348212 · Cited by 3
The priority of intentional action: From developmental to conceptual priority
Levy, Y. (2024) · The Philosophical Quarterly · doi:10.1093/pq/pqae023 · Cited by 3
Verbal Perceptual Prompts Facilitate Children’s Sensitivity to False Beliefs
Huang, Q., & Liu, X. (2024) · Journal of Intelligence · doi:10.3390/jintelligence12080073 · Cited by 2
Lu, H., Niu, J., Wang, J., Liu, M., & Xu, M. (2024) · Frontiers in Psychiatry · doi:10.3389/fpsyt.2024.1449995 · Cited by 3
Acting for Reasons: In defence of Common-sense Psychology
Borg, E. (2024) · doi:10.1093/9780198929031.001.0001 · Cited by 4
Improving ToM Capabilities of LLMs in Applied Domains
Galitsky, B. A. (2026) · Springer eBooks · doi:10.1007/978-3-032-16524-4_4 · Cited by 3
McDonough, K. L., Parrotta, E., Enwereuzor, C. U., & Bach, P. (2025) · Cognition · doi:10.1016/j.cognition.2025.106112 · Cited by 3
Ghosn, F., Perea, M., Lizarán, M., Labusch, M., Moreno-Giménez, A., Sahuquillo-Leal, R., Almansa, B., Buesa, J., Campos, L., Pérez, J. A., et al. (2025) · Autism · doi:10.1177/13623613251323493 · Cited by 3
Seymour, R. A., Rippon, G., Gooding‐Williams, G., Wang, H., & Kessler, K. (2025) · European Journal of Neuroscience · doi:10.1111/ejn.70109 · Cited by 3
Gricean communication, natural language, and human evolution
Harris, D. W. (2025) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/9780191967566.003.0004 · Cited by 5
de Ruiter, J. P. (2019) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198791768.013.7 · Cited by 4
Ferguson, H. J. (2019) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198791768.013.9 · Cited by 2
Spotorno, N., & Noveck, I. A. (2019) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198791768.013.16 · Cited by 2
Tabares, Á. S. G. (2022) · Principia an international journal of epistemology · doi:10.5007/1808-1711.2022.e78054 · Cited by 2
Methodological principles of research of social communication processes
Холод, О. (2023) · Social Communications Theory and Practice · doi:10.51423/2524-0471-2023-15-1-1 · Cited by 5
From Parsing Actions to Understanding Intentions
Byrne, R. W. (2011) · Biosemiotics/Biosemiotics. Bookseries · doi:10.1007/978-94-007-2336-8_8 · Cited by 2
The game is afoot: A response to three insightful commentaries
Wu, W., Sheppard, E., & Mitchell, P. (2016) · British Journal of Psychology · doi:10.1111/bjop.12168 · Cited by 2
Opportunities and challenges for current developmental neuroscience
Steinbeis, N., & Margulies, D. S. (2016) · Theory & Psychology · doi:10.1177/0959354316662158 · Cited by 2
Live theatre as exception and test case for experiencing negative emotions in art
Goldstein, T. R. (2017) · Behavioral and Brain Sciences · doi:10.1017/s0140525x17001704 · Cited by 2
Introspection, mindreading, and the transparency of belief
Peters, U. (2018) · European Journal of Philosophy · doi:10.1111/ejop.12318 · Cited by 2
Metadata
- Authors
- Apperly, I. A., & Butterfill, S. A.
- Affiliations
- University of Birmingham (GB)
- University of Warwick (GB)
- Venue
- Psychological Review
- Published
- 2009
- Volume
- 116
- Issue
- 4
- Pages
- 953-970
- ISSN
- 0033-295X (ISSN-L)
- 1939-1471
- OpenAlex
- W2100694823
- Cited by
- 1,261
- References
- 214
- Citations by year
- 2026: 58 · 2025: 82 · 2024: 126 · 2023: 102 · 2022: 93 · 2021: 93 · 2020: 63 · 2019: 107 · 2018: 84 · 2017: 83 · 2016: 77 · 2015: 75 · 2014: 61 · 2013: 66 · 2012: 36
- FWCI
- 54.20
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- closed
- Locations
- Psychological Review (publishedVersion)
- PubMed (publishedVersion)
- University of Birmingham Research Portal (University of Birmingham) (submittedVersion)
- Topics
- Social Sciences › Psychology › Developmental and Educational Psychology › Child and Animal Learning Development
- Social Sciences › Psychology › Social Psychology › Social Robot Interaction and HRI
- Social Sciences › Arts and Humanities › Philosophy › Philosophy and Theoretical Science
- Keywords
- belief reasoning, theory of mind, false belief tasks, cognitive development, numerical cognition, cognitive flexibility, cognitive efficiency, infants, non-human animals, social cognition
- MeSH terms
- Adult, Animals, Child, Child, Preschool, Culture, Defense Mechanisms, Humans, Infant, Judgment, Problem Solving, Self Concept, Social Behavior, Socialization, Personal Construct Theory
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.