The evolution of antisocial punishment in optional public goods games

Rand, David G., Nowak, Martin A.·2011·Nature Communications
DOI 10.1038/ncomms1442

Cited by (351)

Items 201–300 of 351

  1. Retaliation and the role for punishment in the evolution of cooperation
    Irenaeus Wolff · 2012 · Journal of Theoretical Biology
  2. Antisocial peer exclusion does not eliminate the effectiveness of prosocial peer exclusion in structured populations
    Shulan Li, Chunpeng Du, Xingxu Li, Chen Shen, Лей Ши · 2023 · Journal of Theoretical Biology
  3. Threshold-based punishment mechanism in evolutionary public goods games on random hypergraphs
    Jiliang Zhang, Yuhang Wang, Yinzuo Zhou, Yi‐Cheng Zhang, Fanyuan Meng · 2025 · Chaos Solitons & Fractals
  4. Quantifying the impact of noise on macroscopic organization of cooperation in spatial games
    Faqi Du, Feng Fu · 2013 · Chaos Solitons & Fractals
  5. BMI is not related to altruism, fairness, trust or reciprocity: Experimental evidence from the field and the lab
    Pablo Brañas‐Garza, Antonio M. Espín, Balint Lenkei · 2016 · Physiology & Behavior
  6. The public goods game with shared punishment cost in well-mixed and structured populations
    Xianjia Wang, Shaojie Lv · 2019 · Journal of Theoretical Biology
  7. The rise and fall of donation behavior through reputation
    Xianjia Wang, Rui Ding, Jinhua Zhao, Wenman Chen · 2021 · Chaos Solitons & Fractals
  8. Risk Taking Begets Risk Taking: Evidence from Casino Openings and Investor Portfolios
    Chi Liao · 2015 · Financial Review
  9. Civic Capital in Two Cultures: The Nature of Cooperation in Romania and USA
    Tore Ellingsen, Benedikt Herrmann, Martin A. Nowak, David Gertler Rand, Corina E. Tarnita · 2012 · SSRN Electronic Journal
  10. The cost of noise: Stochastic punishment falls short of sustaining cooperation in social dilemma experiments
    Salahshour, Mohammad, Oberhauser, Vincent, Smerlak, Matteo · 2022 · PLOS ONE
  11. Exit options sustain altruistic punishment and decrease the second-order free-riders, but it is not a panacea
    Chen Shen, Zhao Song, Лей Ши, Jun Tanimoto, Zhen Wang · 2024 · Science China Information Sciences
  12. Co-evolutionary dynamics of attack and defence in cybersecurity
    Adeela Bashir, Zia Ush Shamszaman, Zhao Song, The Anh Han · 2026 · Knowledge-Based Systems
  13. Impact of keeping silence on spatial reciprocity in spatial games
    Xu‐Wen Wang, Zhen Wang, Sen Nie, Luo-Luo Jiang, Bing-Hong Wang · 2014 · Applied Mathematics and Computation
  14. Collective punishment promotes resource conservation if it is not enforced
    Karolina Safarzyńska · 2020 · Forest Policy and Economics
  15. More cooperation compensates for lower self-esteem in social dilemmas
    Qingzhou Sun, Haozhi Guo, Xiaofen Yu, Jing Zhang, Xue Liu, Cheng‐Ming Jiang, Yongfang Liu · 2021 · Personality and Individual Differences
  16. Network adaption based on environment feedback promotes cooperation in co-evolutionary games
    Yüjie Guo, Liming Zhang, Haihong Li, Qionglin Dai, Junzhong Yang · 2023 · Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its Applications
  17. Evolution of cooperation on interdependent networks: The impact of asymmetric punishment
    Tian Guo, Chunpeng Du, Лей Ши · 2023 · Applied Mathematics and Computation
  18. Violating Social Norms when Choosing Friends: How Rule-Breakers Affect Social Networks
    Karlo Hock, Nina H. Fefferman · 2011 · PLoS ONE
  19. The Singaporean model in public goods dilemmas with benevolent leaders and bribery
    Yinhai Fang, Matjaž Perc, Haiyan Xu · 2020 · Journal of Theoretical Biology
  20. Cooperation evolves by the payoff-difference-based probabilistic reward
    Tetsushi Ohdaira · 2021 · The European Physical Journal B
  21. WHEN HAWKS GIVE RISE TO DOVES: THE EVOLUTION AND TRANSITION OF ENFORCEMENT STRATEGIES
    Omar Tonsi Eldakar, Andrew C. Gallup, William W. Driscoll · 2012 · Evolution
  22. Public goods with high-powered punishment: high cooperation and low efficiency
    Terence C. Burnham · 2014 · Journal of Bioeconomics
  23. The evolutionary prisoner’s dilemma game in continuous signed networks
    Guangyu Li, Haifeng Du, Xiaochen He · 2024 · Chaos Solitons & Fractals
  24. Ethics, Prosperity, and Society: Moral Evaluation Using Virtue Ethics and Utilitarianism
    Aditya Hegde, Vibhav Agarwal, Shrisha Rao · 2020 · International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence
  25. The demand for punishment to promote cooperation among like-minded people
    Christoph Bühren, Astrid Dannenberg · 2021 · European Economic Review
  26. Evolutionary Dynamics of Gig Economy Labor Strategies under Technology, Policy and Market Influence
    Kevin Hu, Feng Fu · 2021 · Games
  27. Preferential selection and expected payoff drive cooperation in spatial voluntary public goods game
    Kai Xie, Xingwen Liu, Hao Chen, Jun Yang · 2022 · Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its Applications
  28. Socially Networked Citizen Science and the Crowd-Sourcing of Pro-Environmental Collective Actions
    Janis L. Dickinson, Rhiannon L. Crain · 2014 · Lecture notes in social networks
  29. Three-strategy N -person snowdrift game incorporating loners
    Meng Xu, Dafang Zheng, Chongxin Xu, P. M. Hui · 2016 · Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its Applications
  30. Voluntary play increases cooperation in the presence of punishment: A lab in the field experiment
    Francesca Pancotto, Simone Righi, Károly Takács · 2020 · Theory and Decision
  31. A social monitoring mechanism for third-party judges promotes cooperation in evolutionary games
    Qianxi Yang, Yanlong Yang · 2024 · Applied Mathematics and Computation
  32. Costly punishment sustains indirect reciprocity under low defection detectability
    Yohsuke Murase · 2025 · Journal of Theoretical Biology
  33. Optional participation only provides a narrow scope for sustaining cooperation
    Khadija Khatun, Chen Shen, Jun Tanimoto · 2025 · Physical review. E
  34. Picking strategies in games of cooperation
    Julian Andrés García, Arne Traulsen · 2025 · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
  35. Residents’ Willingness to Pay for Forest Ecosystem Services Based on Forest Ownership Classification in South Korea
    Young-Gyun Son, Yohan Lee, Jang‐Hwan Jo · 2024 · Forests
  36. Understanding post disaster prosociality: Comparing post earthquake cooperation and fairness in two Italian regions
    Francesca Pancotto, Francesca Giardini, Simone Righi · 2024 · International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction
  37. The Impact of Cognitive Load on Cooperation and Antisocial Punishment: Insights from a Public Goods Game Experiment
    Yanru Zhao, Zhuoran Li, Jin Shan, Xiaomeng Zhang · 2024 · Behavioral Sciences
  38. Stability of pairwise social dilemma games: Destructive agents, constructive agents, and their joint effects
    Khadija Khatun, Chen Shen, Лей Ши, Jun Tanimoto · 2024 · Physical review. E
  39. Parametric Excitation and Evolutionary Dynamics
    Rocio E. Ruelas, David Gertler Rand, Richard H. Rand · 2013 · Journal of Applied Mechanics
  40. Exploring an Effective Incentive System on a Groupware
    Fujio Toriumi, H. Yamamoto, Isamu Okada · 2016 · Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation
  41. Complexity of Behavioural Strategies and Cooperation in the Optional Public Goods Game
    Shirsendu Podder, Simone Righi · 2023 · Dynamic Games and Applications
  42. Reducing global inequality increases local cooperation: a simple model of group selection with a global externality
    Karolina Safarzynska, P. Smaldino · 2023 · Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Biological Sciences
  43. Social selection of game organizers promotes cooperation in spatial public goods games
    Yongkui Liu, Xiaojie Chen, Zhang Li, Fei Tao, Long Wang · 2013 · Europhysics Letters (EPL)
  44. Understanding and Addressing Cultural Variation in Costly Antisocial Punishment
    Joanna Joy Bryson, James Mitchell, Simon T. Powers, Karolina Sylwester · 2014 · Springer eBooks
  45. Cooperative emergence induced by asymmetric punishment and strategy persistence mechanisms in multilayer networks
    Yuping Li, Wensheng Jia, Luping Liu · 2025 · Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation
  46. Effects of dynamic probabilistic punishment with environmental threshold on cooperation in spatial public goods games
    Chanchan Li, Guanghui Yang, Wensheng Jia · 2025 · Chaos Solitons & Fractals
  47. Tax thresholds yield multiple optimal cooperation levels in the spatial public goods game
    Xiaogang Li, Wei Wang, Yongjuan Ma, Xingyu An, Ting Wang, Лей Ши · 2023 · Chaos An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science
  48. Cooperation, domination: Twin functions of third‐party punishment
    Jordan Wylie, Ana P. Gantman · 2024 · Social and Personality Psychology Compass
  49. Egoistic punishment outcompetes altruistic punishment in the spatial public goods game
    Juan Li, Yi Liu, Zhen Wang, Haoxiang Xia · 2021 · Scientific Reports
  50. Speculative defectors as unexpected insulators of super cooperators in structured populations
    Zehua Si, Zhixue He, Chen Shen, Jun Tanimoto · 2023 · Chaos Solitons & Fractals
  51. Evolving cooperation in spatial population with punishment by using PSO algorithm
    Xiaoyang Wang, Lei Zhang, Xiaorong Du, Yunlin Sun · 2016 · Natural Computing
  52. Changes in political party systems arising from conflict and transfer among political parties
    Junpyo Park · 2018 · Chaos An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science
  53. Cooperator-driven and defector-driven punishments: How do they influence cooperation?
    Peng-Bi Cui, Zhi-Xi Wu, Tao Zhou, Xiaojie Chen · 2019 · Physical review. E
  54. Cooperation in spatial public good games depends on the locality effects of game, adaptation, and punishment
    Isamu Okada, Hitoshi Yamamoto, Eizo Akiyama, Fujio Toriumi · 2021 · Scientific Reports
  55. Consensus towards Partially Cooperative Strategies in Self-Regulated Evolutionary Games on Networks
    Dario Madeo, Chiara Mocenni · 2021 · Games
  56. A motivational perspective on punishment in social dilemmas
    Stefan Pfattheicher, Johannes Keller · 2017 · European Review of Social Psychology
  57. Investigating the impact of environmental feedback on the optional prisoner’s dilemma for insights into cyclic dominance and evolution of cooperation
    Md. Fahimur Rahman Shuvo, K. M. Ariful Kabir · 2024 · Royal Society Open Science
  58. Non-participant externalities reshape the evolution of altruistic punishment
    Zhao Song, Chen Shen, Valerio Capraro, The Anh Han · 2026 · Journal of The Royal Society Interface
  59. Resolving social dilemmas with minimal reward transfer
    Richard Willis, Yali Du, Joel Z. Leibo, G. Flucke · 2024 · Autonomous Agents and Multi-Agent Systems
  60. Complex Systems of Mindful Entities: On Intention Recognition and Commitment
    Luı́s Moniz Pereira, The Anh Han, Francisco C. Santos · 2013 · Studies in applied philosophy, epistemology and rational ethics
  61. Strategic use of payoff information in k-hop evolutionary Best-shot networked public goods game
    Xing Jin, Yuchen Tao, Jingrui Wang, Chao Wang, Yongheng Wang, Zhouyang Zhang, Zhen Wang · 2023 · Applied Mathematics and Computation
  62. Deterrence or signal? The function of third-party intervention
    Yuchen GUO, Yanbin LIU, Yuan Hang Cheng · 2023 · Advances in Psychological Science
  63. The influence of the heterogeneities of social institutions and individuals’ tendency to establish social institutions on cooperation
    Yao Zhang, Qing-Yi Hao, Jia-Li Qian, Chao-Yun Wu, Yan Bi · 2024 · Chaos Solitons & Fractals
  64. Moral Preferences Co-Evolve With Cooperation in Networked Populations
    Hui Wei, Xiandong Pu, Jianlei Zhang, Chunyan Zhang, Ming Cao · 2024 · IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation
  65. The effects of repeated induction of emotions on cooperation and punishment
    Jinkwon Lee, Sujin Min · 2021 · Economic Inquiry
  66. How punishment and memory mechanism affect cooperative emergence in prisoner’s dilemma game
    Jie Lu, Peipei Zhang, Dandan Li · 2021 · International Journal of Modern Physics C
  67. Promotion, Disintegration and Remediation of group cooperation under heterogeneous distribution system based on peer rating
    Jianwei Wang, Fengyuan Yu, Jialu He, Wei Chen, Wenshu Xu, Wenhui Dai, Yuexin Ming · 2023 · Chaos Solitons & Fractals
  68. Impact of shill intervention on the evolution of cooperation
    Changhao Sun, Haibin Duan · 2015 · Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its Applications
  69. Democracy matters: a psychological perspective on the beneficial impact of democratic punishment systems in social dilemmas
    Rebekka Kesberg, Stefan Pfattheicher · 2019 · Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
  70. The second-order probabilistic pool punishment proportional to the payoff difference can solve the punishment problem of previous studies
    Tetsushi Ohdaira · 2025 · Chaos Solitons & Fractals
  71. THE EFFECT OF SOCIAL PREFERENCES ON THE EVOLUTION OF COOPERATION IN PUBLIC GOOD GAMES
    Marco A. Janssen, Miles K. Manning, Oyita Udiani · 2014 · Advances in Complex Systems
  72. Cognitive Ability and Cooperation: Evidence from the Public Goods Experiments
    Su Zhang, Wei Gao, Binbin Fan · 2015 · RePEc: Research Papers in Economics
  73. The Evolution of Cooperation in a Mobile Population on Random Networks: Network Topology Matters Only for Low-Degree Networks
    Igor V. Erovenko, Mark Broom · 2024 · Dynamic Games and Applications
  74. Spatial modes of cooperation based on bounded rationality
    Qiuhui Pan, Lingxiao Wang, Rongrong Shi, Huan Wang, Mingfeng He · 2014 · Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its Applications
  75. Exposure to superfluous information reduces cooperation and increases antisocial punishment in reputation-based interactions
    Miguel dos Santos, Victoria A. Braithwaite, Claus Wedekind · 2014 · Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution
  76. Intelligent social bots uncover the link between user preference and diversity of news consumption
    Min, Yong, Tingjun Jiang, Jin Cheng, Qu Li, Xiaogang Jin · 2019 · arXiv (Cornell University)
  77. Spatial public goods game on hypergraphs with particle swarm intelligence
    Shun De Gao, Liming Zhang, Qionglin Dai, Haihong Li, Claudio Juan Tessone, Junzhong Yang · 2025 · Chaos Solitons & Fractals
  78. Simple exit encouragement does not always enhance cooperation
    Tian Guo, Xinyu Wang, Zhao Song, Zichuan Mi, Chen Shen · 2025 · Chaos Solitons & Fractals
  79. Effects of an update mechanism based on combinatorial memory and high-reputation learning objects on the evolution of cooperation
    Qianxi Yang, Yanlong Yang · 2025 · Applied Mathematics and Computation
  80. Study of the Evolution of Cooperation Based on an Alternative Notion of Punishment “Sanction with Jealousy”
    Tetsushi Ohdaira · 2016 · Journal of Information Processing
  81. Payoff control in game theory
    龙 王, 芳 陈, 星如 陈 · 2022 · Scientia Sinica Informationis
  82. Experimental insights on antisocial behavior: two meta-analyses
    Alexandros Karakostas, Emily Nhu Tran, Daniel John Zizzo · 2025 · Experimental Economics
  83. Robust Against Whom?
    Nick Cowen · 2018 · Emerald Group Publishing Limited eBooks
  84. Traffic Police Punishment Mechanism Promotes Cooperation in Snowdrift Game on Lattice
    Jinjing Zu, Wei Xiang, Qin Kang, Hang Yang, Hancheng Wang · 2022 · Journal of Shanghai Jiaotong University (Science)
  85. Modified particle swarm strategies in spatial public goods games
    Shun De Gao, Wei Zhang, Liming Zhang, Xiangyi Li, Yi‐Cheng Zhang, Qionglin Dai · 2025 · Chaos Solitons & Fractals
  86. Particle swarm intelligence promotes cooperation by adapting interaction radii in co-evolutionary games
    Yue Tian, Shun De Gao, Haihong Li, Qionglin Dai, Junzhong Yang · 2024 · Applied Mathematics and Computation
  87. The social benefits of “anti-social” punishment
    Alain Schläpfer · 2025 · Evolution and Human Behavior
  88. Evolutionary dynamics of cooperation in optional public goods games with loners' punishment
    Rui Ding, Xian‐Jia Wang, Ji Quan, Shuting Ma, Jinhua Zhao · 2025 · Chaos An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science
  89. Rewards and punishments help humans overcome biases against cooperation partners assumed to be machines
    Kinga Makovi, Jean‐François Bonnefon, Mayada Oudah, Anahit Sargsyan, Talal Rahwan · 2025 · iScience
  90. Towards a unified theory of reciprocity
    Alejandro Rosas · 2012 · Behavioral and Brain Sciences
  91. The effects of dark tetrad and hexaco traits on laboratory-induced malice behaviors
    Luna Radević, Bojana M. Dinić · 2022 · Current Psychology
  92. Authority or Autonomy? Exploring Interactions between Central and Peer Punishments in Risk-Resistant Scenarios
    Jun Qian, Xiao Sun, Tongda Zhang, Yueting Chai · 2022 · Entropy
  93. Punishment catalyzes the evolution of cooperation
    Arend Hintze, Christoph Adami · 2012 · arXiv (Cornell University)
  94. Correction: The Structure of Mutations and the Evolution of Cooperation
    Julian Andrés García, Arne Traulsen · 2012 · PLoS ONE
  95. Understanding Norm Change: An Evolutionary Game-Theoretic Approach (Extended Version)
    Soham De, Dana S. Nau, Michele Joy Gelfand · 2017 · arXiv (Cornell University)
  96. Decoupling altruistic punishment: immune punishers learn to not cooperate, but still punish hypocritically.
    Maxwell N. Burton-Chellew, Claire Guérin · 2021
  97. Correction: Strict or Graduated Punishment? Effect of Punishment Strictness on the Evolution of Cooperation in Continuous Public Goods Games
    Hajime Shimao, Mayuko Nakamaru · 2014 · PLoS ONE
  98. Public Goods with Punishment & Payment for Relative Rank
    Terence C. Burnham · 2015 · SSRN Electronic Journal
  99. Calculated Punishment
    Fa-Dong Chen, G. Nave, Lei Wang · 2024 · Journal of Business Ethics
  100. Evolution of Coordination Through Institutional Incentives: An Evolutionary Game Theory Approach
    Ndidi Bianca Ogbo, Zhao Song, The Anh Han · 2025 · International Conference on Distributed Artificial Intelligence (DAI)