What Do Polemics Do? Religion, Citizenship, and Secularism in South Indian Islam
The DOI matches its Crossref record; 43 of the 44 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; none of the 89 sources its claims cite is checked for support yet.
Abstract
This article is conceived as an intervention in primarily two domains of academic research—religious polemics and secularism. How and why do religious polemics become the subject of reflective discourses that raise questions about their objectives and necessity? What religious purpose do they serve? Are they indispensable to piety? What are their social consequences? Such “problematizations” also advance various responses to polemics: What kind of solutions are proffered? How can we make sense of the simultaneity of mutually exclusive, and sometimes contradictory, responses? I argue that the discourse about polemics is necessitated by the condition of secularism, or the sovereign power of the modern nation-state that seeks to configure what religion is or ought to be, prescribe its proper content, and disperse and ratify subjectivities, ethical norms, and everyday practices. Understanding contemporary religious polemics requires that attention be paid to how the sensibilities, dispositions, and affects that characterize the thinking aloud about polemics are aligned to state projects to regulate religion. Drawing on ethnographic research and media content, this article engages with these broad issues by studying how Muslims in the southwestern
Overview
CoChat Summary
TL;DR
Menon argues that contemporary Malayalee Muslim debates about intra-Islamic polemics in Kerala are shaped by secularism—the modern nation-state’s power to define and regulate religion—and by Muslims’ precarious citizenship as a religious minority. The article shows critics and defenders alike treat polemics as acts that differentiate or undifferentiate religion, politics, community, and public/private, while also pointing to alternative imaginaries beyond secular modernity.
Key findings
- In Kerala, intra-Islamic polemics take three forms—*samvadam*/*vadaprathivadam* (disputation), *mukhamukham* (open forum), and *khandanam* (monologic rebuttal)—and center on Sunni–Mujahid disputes such as *tawassul*, women praying in mosques, *raka‘ah* in *tarawih*, and Arabic vs. Malayalam *khutba*; the first recorded intra-Islamic polemical event occurred in 1925 in Kozhikode. Kerala Muslims account for 26.6 percent of Kerala’s 33 million population, the fourth highest percentage among Indian states.
- Critics, including the documentary *Ivide Tholkunathe Islam* and Sunni *alim* Muhammad Qasimi, argue polemics replace *da‘wa* and *nasiha*, destroy *manam* and *abhimanam*, blur friend/enemy and public/private boundaries, enable enemies such as Hindu nationalism, and risk an apocalyptic end like Muslim Spain; Qasimi says King Ferdinand slaughtered 30 lakh [300,000] Muslims.
- Defenders, including Majeed Saqafi, Abdurahman Ahsani, Abdullah Kondotty, and Mujeeb Rahmani, argue polemics are a religious duty, create transparency, separate truth from falsehood and religion from politics, and craft *iman*; Rahmani says Muslims are “eunuchs” in faith and cites census projections that by 2050 or 2070 Muslims will “stand first” in India, which the article calls a wild exaggeration.
- Comparing contemporary discourse with Abu al-Hasan al-Ash‘ari (d. 936 CE), who treated *munazara* as a moral duty but ethically deficient when aimed at conquest, Menon argues polemics are now framed as a choice to continue or discontinue, tied to secular governance and the politics of Muslim minority citizenship.
Methods
- Ethnographic research and media content: fieldwork in Kerala across two trips in 2010 and 2012—lasting a year and four months, respectively—plus annual returns since 2007; attendance at public polemical events in Kannur, Kozhikode, and Malappuram; audiovisual recordings; interviews with polemicists, organizers, and audience members; all Malayalam data translated by the author; all names changed.
- Analysis guided by two questions—what Muslims say intra-Islamic polemics do, and what subjectivities polemics and discourses about them enable—treating polemics as speech acts with performative power, and drawing on genre/intertextuality and secularism/secularization literature.
Limitations
- Stated by the author: the article does not reveal an essential transhistorical meaning of polemics, does not engage their theological content, does not compare polemics with critique or prove critique/rationality are not alien to Islam, does not advance a new definition of polemics, does not make claims about secularization or argue Muslims are secularizing Islam, and does not tease out secularity from political secularism or advance a general social project of secularization.
- Evident from the text: the study is qualitative and interview/media-based, with no systematic survey or quantitative sample; it relies on translated and anonymized media and interview material; and its focus on selected Sunni–Mujahid critics and defenders in Kerala limits generalization to all Malayalee Muslims or other regions.
Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
0 Valid · 5 Not valid · 93 Not checked · 165 Own results and interpretations
The paper states this without a source or data behind it here, so there is nothing to check it against. The quote shows it is in the paper.
In the paper
“Contemporary re fl ections about polemics, whether to endorse or reject them (which are mutually exclusive positions in Kerala), see them as much more than a religious duty incumbent upon Muslims.”
plain- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: unclear — It is unclear why the paper says it holds.
The paper states this without a source or data behind it here, so there is nothing to check it against. The quote shows it is in the paper.
In the paper
“Malayalee (speakers of Malayalam) Muslims defend or reject polemics by re fl ecting about their goals, their mode of conduct (particularly their argumentative and competitive nature), their necessity or otherwise, and their impact on the everyday lives of their coreligionists.”
plain- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: unclear — It is unclear why the paper says it holds.
In the paper
“The documentary makers identi fi ed themselves only as ' Nasih-UlUmma [advisers of the community], '”
What the sources say
- Not matchedcites [54]
Couldn’t be matched to a paper in Crossref, so it can’t be checked.
plainSingle case- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: unclear — It is unclear whether the paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Not matched
A result the paper reports from its own data — it cites no other source for it, so there is none to check. The quote shows it is in the paper.
In the paper
“One strand is related to a sense of the imminent end ( antyam ) of the Muslim community: interestingly, both the documentary and Qasimi communicated this idea by way of an analogy with the experience of Muslim Spain (Al-Andalus).”
plainstates an association- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: unclear — It is unclear whether the paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
A result the paper states — it cites no source for it, so there is none to check. The quote shows it is in the paper.
In the paper
“Qasimi is branded as a pawn in the hands of IUML politicians.”
plain- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
56 more claims
Create a free account to see all 263 claims and every source verdict.
- Probably not a substantial claim. 161
- It may state two separate claims as one. 102
- The quote only partly states this claim. 1
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
Each contradiction between two passages listed here was confirmed by an independent check.
Rated minor: it would not touch a result — a value no result rests on, a p-value that stays on the same side of the significance level, or a conflict that is clerical, resolved elsewhere in the paper, or outside its own findings.
In the paper
§ AGAINST POLEMICS · p. 13
“King Ferdinand slaughtered 30 lakh”
§ AGAINST POLEMICS · p. 13
“[300,000] Muslims.”
Rated minor: it would not touch a result — a value no result rests on, a p-value that stays on the same side of the significance level, or a conflict that is clerical, resolved elsewhere in the paper, or outside its own findings.
In the paper
§ AGAINST POLEMICS · p. 21
“no Muslim survived alive or was converted to Catholicism, claimed Qasimi.”
§ AGAINST POLEMICS · p. 13
“The rest were forcibly converted.”
Citations
Cites
(2017) · The SHAFR Guide Online · doi:10.1163/2468-1733_shafr_sim210040063 · Cited by 8,972
(2003) · Cited by 3,033
Conscripts of Modernity: The Tragedy of Colonial Enlightenment
Scott, D. (2004) · Duke University Press eBooks · doi:10.1215/9780822386186 · Cited by 1,256
Genre, Intertextuality, and Social Power
Briggs, C. L., & Bauman, R. (1992) · Journal of Linguistic Anthropology · doi:10.1525/jlin.1992.2.2.131 · Cited by 1,167
The Saffron Wave: Democracy and Hindu Nationalism in Modern India
Hansen, T. B. (1999) · Princeton University Press eBooks · doi:10.1515/9781400823055 · Cited by 1,069
The Graves of TarimGenealogy and Mobility across the Indian Ocean
Ho, E. (2006) · University of California Press eBooks · doi:10.1525/california/9780520244535.001.0001 · Cited by 842
The Anthropology of the State in the Age of Globalization: Close Encounters of the Deceptive Kind
Trouillot, M. (2001) · Current Anthropology · doi:10.1086/318437 · Cited by 749
Fluid Signs: Being a Person the Tamil Way
Daniel, E. V. (1984) · University of California Press eBooks · doi:10.1525/9780520342149 · Cited by 723
Aretxaga, B. (2003) · Annual Review of Anthropology · doi:10.1146/annurev.anthro.32.061002.093341 · Cited by 596
Religious Difference in a Secular Age: A Minority Report
Mahmood, S. (2016) · Princeton University Press eBooks · doi:10.1515/9781400873531 · Cited by 467
Refashioning Futures: Criticism after Postcoloniality
Scott, D. (1999) · Project Muse (Johns Hopkins University) · doi:10.1515/9781400823062 · Cited by 450
Questioning Secularism: Islam, Sovereignty, and the Rule of Law in Modern Egypt
Agrama, H. A. (2012) · University of Chicago Press eBooks · doi:10.7208/chicago/9780226010700.001.0001 · Cited by 432
Muslims through Discourse: Religion and Ritual in Gayo Society
Bowen, J. R. (1993) · Princeton University Press eBooks · doi:10.1515/9780691221588 · Cited by 372
The Republic Unsettled: Muslim French and the Contradictions of Secularism
Fernando, M. L. (2014) · Duke University Press eBooks · doi:10.1215/9780822376286 · Cited by 299
Living Islam: Muslim Religious Experience in Pakistan's North-West Frontier
Marsden, M. (2005) · Cambridge University Press eBooks · doi:10.1017/cbo9780511489549 · Cited by 239
Secularism in Antebellum America
Modern, J. L. (2011) · University of Chicago Press eBooks · doi:10.7208/chicago/9780226533254.001.0001 · Cited by 236
Debating Difference: Group Rights and Liberal Democracy in India
Bajpai, R. (2011) · doi:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198067504.001.0001 · Cited by 214
Muslim Writers on Judaism and the Hebrew Bible: From Ibn Rabban to Ibn Hazm
Adang, C. (1996) · BRILL eBooks · doi:10.1163/9789004451216 · Cited by 199
Thinking About Tradition, Religion, and Politics in Egypt Today
Asad, T. (2015) · Critical Inquiry · doi:10.1086/683002 · Cited by 172
HIRSCHKIND, C. (2011) · Cultural Anthropology · doi:10.1111/j.1548-1360.2011.01116.x · Cited by 169
Pandey, G. (1999) · Comparative Studies in Society and History · doi:10.1017/s0010417599003072 · Cited by 168
Pious Practice and Secular Constraints: Women in the Islamic Revival in Europe
Jouili, J. S. (2020) · Stanford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1515/9780804794893 · Cited by 135
Only paradoxes to offer: french feminists and the rights of man
Doy, G. (1998) · Women s History Review · doi:10.1080/09612029500200328 · Cited by 134
Devotional Islam and Politics in British India: Ahmad Riza Khan Barelwi and His Movement, 1870-1920
Kozlowski, G. C., & Sanyal, U. (1999) · Journal of the American Oriental Society · doi:10.2307/604866 · Cited by 126
Indian secularism: a social and intellectual history, 1890-1950
(2009) · Choice Reviews Online · doi:10.5860/choice.47-1020 · Cited by 115
Islamism and Democracy in India
Ahmad, I. (2009) · Princeton University Press eBooks · doi:10.2307/j.ctv4w3ss4 · Cited by 102
Ahmad, I. (2017) · University of North Carolina Press eBooks · doi:10.5149/northcarolina/9781469635095.001.0001 · Cited by 86
Trade, Conversion and the Growth of the Islamic Community of Kerala, South India
Dale, S. F. (1990) · Studia Islamica · doi:10.2307/1595642 · Cited by 78
Tambar, K. (2020) · Stanford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1515/9780804791182 · Cited by 77
Ahmed Deedat and the Form of Islamic Evangelism
Larkin, B. (2008) · Social Text · doi:10.1215/01642472-2008-006 · Cited by 76
Inventing polemic: religion, print, and literary culture in early modern England
Lander, J. M., & Considine, J. (2005) · Renaissance and Reformation · doi:10.33137/rr.v41i4.9062 · Cited by 75
Dhulipala, V. (2014) · Cambridge University Press · doi:10.1017/cbo9781107280380 · Cited by 74
The Acoustics of Muslim Striving: Loudspeaker Use in Ritual Practice in Pakistan
Khan, N. (2011) · Comparative Studies in Society and History · doi:10.1017/s0010417511000259 · Cited by 73
Miller, L. B. (1985) · University Microfilms International eBooks · Cited by 51
Medieval heresy : An anthropological view
Asad, T. (1986) · Social History · doi:10.1080/03071028608567662 · Cited by 44
Imagining communities–differently
Arunima, G. (2006) · The Indian Economic & Social History Review · doi:10.1177/001946460504300103 · Cited by 34
Islamism and Social Reform in Kerala, South India
Osella, F., & Osella, C. (2013) · Cambridge University Press eBooks · doi:10.1017/cbo9781139382786.007 · Cited by 27
Menon, N. R. (2014) · Modern Asian Studies · doi:10.1017/s0026749x14000109 · Cited by 23
Self-citationDidier, B. J. (2004) · The Journal of Asian Studies · doi:10.1017/s0021911804000063 · Cited by 19
Menon, D. M. (2015) · History and Theory · doi:10.1111/hith.10779 · Cited by 13
The Contemporary Afterlife of Moorish Spain
Hirschkind, C. (2016) · Routledge eBooks · doi:10.4324/9781315589930-18 · Cited by 8
Devika, J. (2018) · Modern Asian Studies · doi:10.1017/s0026749x16000548 · Cited by 7
Andalusi musical origins at the Moroccan-Algerian frontier: Beyond charter myth
Glasser, J. (2015) · American Ethnologist · doi:10.1111/amet.12166 · Cited by 2
Research works printed but not linked: 64
- Research, respectively-though I have been studying intra-Islamic polemics in Kerala since 2007 and have returned to the state every year since then (for at least a month). A "non-Muslim
- Austin John L., 1971, How to Do Things with Words (Oxford: Oxford University Press
- Krauss Samuel, 1996, William Horbury, 1
- Stoker Valerie, 2016, Hindu Sectarianism, and the Sixteenth-Century Vijayanagara Court
- Szpiech Ryan, 2012, Conversion and Narrative: Reading and Religious Authority in Medieval Polemic (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press
- Berzon Todd S., 2016, Heresiology and the Limits of Knowledge in Late Antiquity (Berkeley: University of California Press
- Dascal Marcelo, 2004, Religious Polemics in Context, ed. T. L. Hettema and A. Van Der Kooij
- Abulafia Anna Sapir, 1998, Christians and Jews in Dispute: Disputational Literature and the Rise of Anti-Judaism in the West (1000-1150) (Aldershot: Ashgate Varorium
- Cuffel Alexandra, 2007, Gendering Disgust in Medieval Religious Polemic (Notre Dame
- Nederman Cary J., 2000, Worlds of Difference: European Discourses of Toleration, c. 1100-c. 1550 (Philadelphia: Pennsylvania State University Press
- Suerbaum Almut, 2015, Polemic: Language as Violence in Medieval and Early Modern Discourse (Farnham: Ashgate
- Crewe Compare Jonathan, 2004, Polemic: Critical and Uncritical, ed. Jane Gallop
- Foucault Michel, 1997, The Politics of Truth, ed. Sylvère Lotringer and Lysa Hochroth
- Fischer Michel, 1990, Debating Muslims: Cultural Dialogue in Postmodernity and Tradition (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press
- Jones Kenneth W., 1992, Religious Controversy in British India: Dialogues in South Asian Languages (Albany: State University of New York Press
- Powell Avril Ann, 1993, Muslims and Missionaries in Pre-Mutiny India (Surrey: Curzon
- Tareen Sherali, 2012, Islamic Studies, 51, 49
- Asad Talal, 1993, Genealogies of Religion: Discipline and Reasons of Power in Christianity and Islam (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press
- Dale, 1996, Muslim Politics
- Bhargava Rajeev, 2006, The Future of Secularism, ed. T. N. Srinivasan
- Nandy Ashis, 1998, Rajeev Bhargava
- Iqtidar Humeira, 2011, Permanent Black
- Muhammadkannu Haji M., Smaranakal
- The, Sunni
- SaqafiMadavoor Alikutty, 2010, Samvadangal (Kozhikode: Capital International Books
- Eranadan K. V. K., 1979, Kuttichira Sunni Mujahid Vadaprathivada Samgraham (Pulikkal: Irshadiya Publications
- Bauman Richard, 2004, Blackwell, 4
- November 30, 2013, 5: 24
- December 30, 2013, 12: 23
- September 19, 2011, 2: 13
- November 30, 2013, 5: 18
- Qasimi, actual
- Dusenbery Verne A., 1990, Divine Passions: The Social Construction of Emotion in India, ed. Owen M. Lynch
- Chakrabarty Dipesh, 2002, Permanent Black, 73
- Chatterjee Partha, 1993, The Nation and Its Fragments: Colonial and Postcolonial Histories (Princeton
- Anidjar Gil, 2002, Philosophy, Literature in Arab Jewish Letters
- Menon Dilip, 2010, Sugata Bose and Kris Manjapra
- For, medina
- Kresse Kai, 2008, Islam and Cosmopolitanism in the Western Indian Ocean (New York: Columbia University Press
- Ansari M. T., 2016, Routledge, 73
- Thursby Gene R., 1975, Hindu-Muslim Relations in British India: A Study of Controversy, Conflict and Communal Movements in Northern India 1923-1928 (Leiden: Brill
- Roberts Michael, 1990, Mirrors of Violence: Communities, Riots and Survivors in South Asia, ed. Veena Das
- Foucault Michel, 1978, History of Sexuality, Volume I: An Introduction (New York: Pantheon
- Cook David, 2002, Studies in Muslim Apocalyptic (Princeton
- Bull Malcolm, 1999, Verso, 79
- Cook David, 2005, Contemporary Muslim Apocalyptic Literature (Syracuse
- June 10, 2010.
- 2015, AP Sunnikal Prabodhanarangam Vazhimattumbol
- June 24, 2010.
- January 30, 2016, 0: 22
- Messick Brinkley, 1996, The Calligraphic State: Textual Domination and History in a Muslim Society (Berkeley: University of California Press
- Izutsu Toshihiko, 2006, The Concept of Belief in Islamic Theology (Kuala Lumpur: Islamic Book Trust
- Ahamed Anwar, 2012, Ivide Tholkunathe Islam
- Pandey Gyanendra, 1990, The Construction of Communalism in Colonial North India (New Delhi: Oxford University Press
- Ahmed Ihjas, 2012, Ivide Tholkunathe Islam
- Freitag Sandra, 1989, Collective Action and Community: Public Arenas and the Emergence of Communalism in North India (Berkeley: University of California Press
- This, however, imply that the Indian public sphere is a neutral space, instead it is "necessarily (not just contingently) articulated by power
- Agrama Hussein, 2015, Politics of Religious Freedom, ed. Winnifred Fallers Sullivan, Elizabeth Shakman Hurd, Saba Mahmood, and Peter G. Danchin
- Asad Talal, 1986, The Idea of an Anthropology of Islam (Washington
- Stroumsa Sarah, 1999, Abu Bakr Al-Razi and Their Impact on Islamic Thought
- November 30, 2013, 41: 34
- Amir-Moazami Shirin, 2003, Muslim Networks and Transnational Communities in and across Europe, ed. Stefano Allevi and Jorgen Nielsen
- Starrett Gregory, 1998, Politics and Religious Transformation in Egypt (Berkeley: University of California Press
- Jayal Neeraja Gopal, 2013, Permanent Black, 6
Cited by
Islamic Traditionalism in a Globalizing World: Sunni Muslim identity in Kerala, South India
Visakh, M. S., Santhosh, R., & ROSHAN, C. K. M. (2021) · Modern Asian Studies · doi:10.1017/s0026749x20000347 · Cited by 17
Neither global nor local: Reorienting the study of Islam in South Asia
Kiliyamannil, T. J. (2023) · Asian journal of social science · doi:10.1016/j.ajss.2023.07.002 · Cited by 17
Ummah Imaginations in Plural Kerala: Being International in the Traditional Way
Fathah, M. A. (2021) · ULUMUNA · doi:10.20414/ujis.v25i2.456 · Cited by 3
Constructing Authenticity in Discourse(s)
Thadathil, H. (2020) · Asian journal of social science · doi:10.1163/15685314-04805007 · Cited by 1
Metadata
- Authors
- Menon, N. R.
- Affiliations
- University of Göttingen (DE)
- Corresponding author
- Menon, Nandagopal R.
- ORCID
- Menon, Nandagopal R.
- Venue
- History of Religions
- Publisher
- University of Chicago Press
- Published
- 2018-11
- Volume
- 58
- Issue
- 2
- Pages
- 128-164
- ISSN
- 0018-2710 (ISSN-L)
- 1545-6935
- OpenAlex
- W2901857360
- Cited by
- 5
- References
- 44
- Citations by year
- 2023: 1 · 2021: 2 · 2020: 2
- FWCI
- 3.23
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- closed
- Locations
- History of Religions (publishedVersion)
- Topics
- Social Sciences › Political Science and International Relations › Islamic Studies and History
- Social Sciences › Sociology and Political Science › Religion and Society Interactions
- Social Sciences › Arts and Humanities › History › South Asian Studies and Diaspora
- Keywords
- polemics, religious controversy, citizenship, secularism, Christian-Muslim relations, religious identity
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-21, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).
A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-21 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.