CoChat

A Total-Evidence Approach to Dating with Fossils, Applied to the Early Radiation of the Hymenoptera

Open access

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 80 of the 86 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Abstract

Phylogenies are usually dated by calibrating interior nodes against the fossil record. This relies on indirect methods that, in the worst case, misrepresent the fossil information. Here, we contrast such node dating with an approach that includes fossils along with the extant taxa in a Bayesian total-evidence analysis. As a test case, we focus on the early radiation of the Hymenoptera, mostly documented by poorly preserved impression fossils that are difficult to place phylogenetically. Specifically, we compare node dating using nine calibration points derived from the fossil record with total-evidence dating based on 343 morphological characters scored for 45 fossil (4--20 complete) and 68 extant taxa. In both cases we use molecular data from seven markers (∼5 kb) for the extant taxa. Because it is difficult to model speciation, extinction, sampling, and fossil preservation realistically, we develop a simple uniform prior for clock trees with fossils, and we use relaxed clock models to accommodate rate variation across the tree. Despite considerable uncertainty in the placement of most fossils, we find that they contribute significantly to the estimation of divergence times in the total-evidence analysis. In particular, the posterior distributions on divergence times are less sensitive to prior assumptions and tend to be more precise than in node dating. The total-evidence analysis also shows that four of the seven Hymenoptera calibration points used in node dating are likely to be based on erroneous or doubtful assumptions about the fossil placement. With respect to the early radiation of Hymenoptera, our results suggest that the crown group dates back to the Carboniferous, ∼309 Ma (95% interval: 291--347 Ma), and diversified into major extant lineages much earlier than previously thought, well before the Triassic. [Bayesian inference; fossil dating; morphological evolution; relaxed clock; statistical phylogenetics.].

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1093/sysbio/sys058

Cites

80 of 80 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

Figure 1. Flow-chart showing the main analyses conducted in this study. See Materials and Methods section for details, explanations, and justifications for the different steps.
Figure 1. Flow-chart showing the main analyses conducted in this study. See Materials and Methods section for details, explanations, and justifications for the different steps.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 2. Finding suitable prior parameters for relaxed-clock models. a) Relationship between branch lengths estimated under a strict-clock and under a nonclock model. The outlier corresponds to the branch leading to Xyelidae. b) Increase in variance (squared deviation from the expectation) of nonclock branch lengths over time. The slope of the regression line was used directly to center the prior for the variance increase parameter of the IGR model, and via simulations for the TK02 (Thorne–Kishino 2002) anc CPP models. c) Outcome of the simulations under the CPP model showing success of different combinations of the variance of the rate multiplier and the rate of the Poisson process to approximate the observed variance in branch lengths. Colors (in the online version of this figure) represent the relative deviation from the observed variance. The results were used to choose appropriate priors. d) The rate ratios observed in random pairs of branches tend to be higher than the ratios between parent and offspring pairs, demonstrating slight but significant rate autocorrelation in the data set (P=0.0055; Kolmogorov–Smirnov test of equality of distributions). The bars on the random pairs represent SDs obtained from 1000 replicates of random pair sets of the same size as the parent–offspring pair set.
Figure 2. Finding suitable prior parameters for relaxed-clock models. a) Relationship between branch lengths estimated under a strict-clock and under a nonclock model. The outlier corresponds to the branch leading to Xyelidae. b) Increase in variance (squared deviation from the expectation) of nonclock branch lengths over time. The slope of the regression line was used directly to center the prior for the variance increase parameter of the IGR model, and via simulations for the TK02 (Thorne–Kishino 2002) anc CPP models. c) Outcome of the simulations under the CPP model showing success of different combinations of the variance of the rate multiplier and the rate of the Poisson process to approximate the observed variance in branch lengths. Colors (in the online version of this figure) represent the relative deviation from the observed variance. The results were used to choose appropriate priors. d) The rate ratios observed in random pairs of branches tend to be higher than the ratios between parent and offspring pairs, demonstrating slight but significant rate autocorrelation in the data set (P=0.0055; Kolmogorov–Smirnov test of equality of distributions). The bars on the random pairs represent SDs obtained from 1000 replicates of random pair sets of the same size as the parent–offspring pair set.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 3. Phylogeny of extant Hymenoptera and outgroups retrieved under a nonclock model. Branch colors indicate the families of symphytans (the basal grade of Hymenoptera) included in the analysis. Capital letters followed by a star show the nine calibration points used in the calibrated analyses (Table 2). Values above nodes indicate Bayesian posterior probabilities.
Figure 3. Phylogeny of extant Hymenoptera and outgroups retrieved under a nonclock model. Branch colors indicate the families of symphytans (the basal grade of Hymenoptera) included in the analysis. Capital letters followed by a star show the nine calibration points used in the calibrated analyses (Table 2). Values above nodes indicate Bayesian posterior probabilities.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 4. Extensive simulations were used to validate the MCMC algorithms. Here we show a simple example: retrieval of the uniform clock tree prior for a tree with four extant taxa a and c) and a tree with two extant taxa and two extinct taxa b and d). The age of the tree root was fixed to 1.0 in both cases, and the age of the fossils to 0.5. Both tree probabilities a and c) and branch length distributions b and d; only part shown in d) closely match analytically derived values. The results shown are for the strict-clock model; similar results were obtained under all relaxed-clock models.
Figure 4. Extensive simulations were used to validate the MCMC algorithms. Here we show a simple example: retrieval of the uniform clock tree prior for a tree with four extant taxa a and c) and a tree with two extant taxa and two extinct taxa b and d). The age of the tree root was fixed to 1.0 in both cases, and the age of the fossils to 0.5. Both tree probabilities a and c) and branch length distributions b and d; only part shown in d) closely match analytically derived values. The results shown are for the strict-clock model; similar results were obtained under all relaxed-clock models.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 5. Clock model and rooting assumption had a large effect on tree topology. When a clock was not assumed, the morphological a), molecular (not shown), and combined morphological and molecular b) trees were virtually congruent and agreed well with previous studies. c) Under the strict-clock model, however, the topology changed dramatically. d) Enforcing Holometabola to be monophyletic did not change hymenopteran relationships in the strict-clock analysis. e) The relaxed-clock models (here IGR) also produced apparent topological artifacts close to the root of the tree. f) When aided by a rooting constraint (Holometabola monophyletic), however, the relaxed-clock models (here IGR) retrieved the expected topology. The widths of clades are proportional to their representation in our data set, not to their true diversity. Only extant taxa were included in the analyses shown here.
Figure 5. Clock model and rooting assumption had a large effect on tree topology. When a clock was not assumed, the morphological a), molecular (not shown), and combined morphological and molecular b) trees were virtually congruent and agreed well with previous studies. c) Under the strict-clock model, however, the topology changed dramatically. d) Enforcing Holometabola to be monophyletic did not change hymenopteran relationships in the strict-clock analysis. e) The relaxed-clock models (here IGR) also produced apparent topological artifacts close to the root of the tree. f) When aided by a rooting constraint (Holometabola monophyletic), however, the relaxed-clock models (here IGR) retrieved the expected topology. The widths of clades are proportional to their representation in our data set, not to their true diversity. Only extant taxa were included in the analyses shown here.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 6. Different relaxed-clock models result in different relative divergence time estimates (uncalibrated trees). a) Tree with branches colored according to their substitution rate as estimated under the IGR relaxed-clock model. The letters denote the branches examined in plots c–f, respectively. b) As previous, but under the CPP relaxed-clock model. c–f) Length of the four branches indicated in Figure 5a as estimated under different clock and nonclock models. For the relaxed-clock models, we plotted both the time length (in expected substitutions per site at the base rate of the clock) and the corresponding effective branch length, which equals the time length times the rate estimated for that branch (see labels in Fig. 5d). Note that effective branch lengths tend to be very similar to nonclock branch lengths, while time length distributions vary more across relaxed-clock models and tend to be less precise.
Figure 6. Different relaxed-clock models result in different relative divergence time estimates (uncalibrated trees). a) Tree with branches colored according to their substitution rate as estimated under the IGR relaxed-clock model. The letters denote the branches examined in plots c–f, respectively. b) As previous, but under the CPP relaxed-clock model. c–f) Length of the four branches indicated in Figure 5a as estimated under different clock and nonclock models. For the relaxed-clock models, we plotted both the time length (in expected substitutions per site at the base rate of the clock) and the corresponding effective branch length, which equals the time length times the rate estimated for that branch (see labels in Fig. 5d). Note that effective branch lengths tend to be very similar to nonclock branch lengths, while time length distributions vary more across relaxed-clock models and tend to be less precise.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 7. Majority-rule consensus tree from a total-evidence analysis including all fossils (IGR model). The tree is poorly resolved, which reflects the uncertainty in fossil placement. The underlying consensus tree of extant taxa is virtually identical to trees obtained in analyses without fossils (see Figs. 7 and 8). Grey-scale boxes indicate the percentage of morphological characters that were coded for each taxon, showing the incompleteness of the fossils. Values above branches represent PPs.
Figure 7. Majority-rule consensus tree from a total-evidence analysis including all fossils (IGR model). The tree is poorly resolved, which reflects the uncertainty in fossil placement. The underlying consensus tree of extant taxa is virtually identical to trees obtained in analyses without fossils (see Figs. 7 and 8). Grey-scale boxes indicate the percentage of morphological characters that were coded for each taxon, showing the incompleteness of the fossils. Values above branches represent PPs.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 8. The uncertainty in phylogenetic placement varied considerably across fossils. We show the PPs of four example fossils attaching to specific branches on the majority rule consensus tree of the extant taxa (IGR model). (a) Mesoxyela mesozoica Rasnitsyn, 1965 (140 Ma). (b) Sogutia liassica Rasnitsyn, 1977 (190 Ma). (c) Aulisca odontura Rasnitsyn, 1968 (161 Ma). (d) Leptephialtities caudatus Rasnitsyn, 1975 (161 Ma). Results were similar under the CPP and TK02 models.
Figure 8. The uncertainty in phylogenetic placement varied considerably across fossils. We show the PPs of four example fossils attaching to specific branches on the majority rule consensus tree of the extant taxa (IGR model). (a) Mesoxyela mesozoica Rasnitsyn, 1965 (140 Ma). (b) Sogutia liassica Rasnitsyn, 1977 (190 Ma). (c) Aulisca odontura Rasnitsyn, 1968 (161 Ma). (d) Leptephialtities caudatus Rasnitsyn, 1975 (161 Ma). Results were similar under the CPP and TK02 models.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 9. Comparison of node age estimates obtained using total-evidence dating (red in the online version, light gray in the print version) node dating (blue in the online version, dark gray in the print version) under the IGR model. The bars represent the 95% posterior credibility (highest posterior density) intervals for the age of each node, and are plotted on top of the extant consensus tree resulting from the total-evidence analysis. Two nodes in the Apocrita clade (lower part of tree) were differently resolved in the node-dating analysis, and the blue bars are therefore missing for these. Arrows indicate the direction and extent to which the median node age shifted from the total-evidence analysis to the node-calibration analysis.
Figure 9. Comparison of node age estimates obtained using total-evidence dating (red in the online version, light gray in the print version) node dating (blue in the online version, dark gray in the print version) under the IGR model. The bars represent the 95% posterior credibility (highest posterior density) intervals for the age of each node, and are plotted on top of the extant consensus tree resulting from the total-evidence analysis. Two nodes in the Apocrita clade (lower part of tree) were differently resolved in the node-dating analysis, and the blue bars are therefore missing for these. Arrows indicate the direction and extent to which the median node age shifted from the total-evidence analysis to the node-calibration analysis.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 10. Posteriors obtained under node dating and total-evidence dating are compared across three different priors on tree age for eight nodes (a–h; cf. Table 2). The nodes correspond to the most recent common ancestor of the extant forms of the specified taxa. For the intermediate prior on tree age, we used an offset-exponential distribution with a minimum of 315 Ma (oldest neopteran fossil) and a mean of 396 Ma (oldest insect fossil). For the more and less restrictive prior, we shifted the mean to half and twice the distance to the minimum (355 Ma and 477 Ma), respectively. Note that the total-evidence posteriors are less sensitive to prior assumptions than node-dating posteriors. They also tend to be more precise; if not, the total-evidence analysis indicated that the calibration points were based on erroneous or doubtful assumptions about fossil placement, causing posteriors to be artificially truncated (c; probably also e and f).
Figure 10. Posteriors obtained under node dating and total-evidence dating are compared across three different priors on tree age for eight nodes (a–h; cf. Table 2). The nodes correspond to the most recent common ancestor of the extant forms of the specified taxa. For the intermediate prior on tree age, we used an offset-exponential distribution with a minimum of 315 Ma (oldest neopteran fossil) and a mean of 396 Ma (oldest insect fossil). For the more and less restrictive prior, we shifted the mean to half and twice the distance to the minimum (355 Ma and 477 Ma), respectively. Note that the total-evidence posteriors are less sensitive to prior assumptions than node-dating posteriors. They also tend to be more precise; if not, the total-evidence analysis indicated that the calibration points were based on erroneous or doubtful assumptions about fossil placement, causing posteriors to be artificially truncated (c; probably also e and f).CC BY-NC · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Show all 80 references

Research works printed but not linked: 10

  1. Hennig, 1981, Insect phylogeny.
  2. Rasnitsyn, 1964, New Triassic Hymenoptera of the Middle Asia (in Russian), Paleontol. Zh., 1, 88
  3. Rasnitsyn, 1969, Origin and evolution of Lower Hymenoptera (in Russian), T. Paleontol. Inst. Acad. Sci. USSR., 123, 1
  4. Rasnitsyn, 1975, Hymenoptera Apocrita of Mesozoic (in Russian), T. Paleontol. Inst. Acad. Sci. USSR., 147, 1
  5. Rasnitsyn, 1980, Origin and evolution of Hymenoptera (in Russian), T. Paleontol. Inst. Acad. Sci. USSR., 174, 1
  6. Rasnitsyn, 1983, Hymenopterous insects in Jurassic of the Eastern Siberia (in Russian), Bull. Moscow Soc. Nat. Biol. Sect., 58, 85
  7. Rasnitsyn, 2002, History of insects., 10.1007/0-306-47577-4 · DOI · Paper page
  8. Rasnitsyn, 2004, Important new fossil insects from Carrizo Arroyo and the Permo-Carboniferous faunal boundary, 215
  9. Zhang, 1985, New data on the Mesozoic fossil insects from Laiyang in Shandong, Geol. Shandong., 1, 23
  10. Zuckerkandl, 1962, Molecular disease, evolution and genetic heterogeneity, 189

Cited by

Items 401–500 of 922

Metadata

Authors
Ronquist, F., Klopfstein, S., Vilhelmsen, L., Schulmeister, S., Murray, D. L., & Rasnitsyn, A. P.
Affiliations
  • Swedish Museum of Natural History (SE)
  • Natural History Museum of Denmark (DK)
  • Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München (DE)
  • Duke University (US)
  • Russian Academy of Sciences (RU)
Corresponding author
Ronquist, Fredrik
Venue
Systematic Biology
Published
2012-07-26
Volume
61
Issue
6
Pages
973-999
ISSN
  • 1063-5157 (ISSN-L)
  • 1076-836X
OpenAlex
W2159597448
Cited by
930
References
86
Citations by year
2026: 50 · 2025: 43 · 2024: 56 · 2023: 54 · 2022: 63 · 2021: 81 · 2020: 91 · 2019: 90 · 2018: 65 · 2017: 56 · 2016: 80 · 2015: 78 · 2014: 82 · 2013: 33 · 2012: 7
FWCI
65.46
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • Systematic Biology (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
  • Europe PMC (PubMed Central) (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • Research at the University of Copenhagen (University of Copenhagen) (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
Funders
  • National Science Foundation (0337220)
  • Schweizerischer Nationalfonds zur Förderung der Wissenschaftlichen Forschung (130173)
  • Vetenskapsrådet (2008-05629)
Topics
  • Life Sciences › Agricultural and Biological Sciences › Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics › Hymenoptera taxonomy and phylogeny
  • Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Paleontology › Evolution and Paleontology Studies
  • Life Sciences › Agricultural and Biological Sciences › Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics › Fossil Insects in Amber
Keywords
Hymenoptera, divergence time estimation, total-evidence dating, fossil calibration, node dating, morphological characters, relaxed clock, Carboniferous
MeSH terms
Animals, Fossils, Hymenoptera, Models, Genetic, Phylogeny, Statistics as Topic, Time Factors, Models, Statistical, Genetic Speciation

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.