Publication bias in reports of animal stroke studies leads to major overstatement of efficacy

Sena, Emily S., van der Worp, H. Bart, Bath, Philip M. W., Howells, David W., Macleod, Malcolm R.·2010·PLoS Biology
DOI 10.1371/journal.pbio.1000344

Cited by (598)

Items 401–500 of 598

  1. Therapeutic effects and potential mechanisms of astragaloside IV on pulmonary fibrosis: a systematic review and meta-analysis of preclinical studies
    Shujuan Zhang, Yan Xue, Xing Zhang, Feng Chen, Yalan Li, Wei Zhang · 2025 · Frontiers in Pharmacology
  2. Fingolimod as a Potential Cerebroprotectant Results From the Stroke Preclinical Assessment Network
    Lígia Simões Braga Boisserand, Alison L. Herman, Basavaraju G. Sanganahalli, Jelena M. Mihailovic, Hannah E. Beatty, Conor W. Johnson, Sebastián Díaz-Pérez, Jonathan Howard DeLong, Sofia E. Velazquez, Jaime Grutzendler et al. · 2025 · Stroke
  3. Advancements in Ischemic Stroke Management: Transition from Traditional to Nanotechnological Approaches
    Mohammad Adil, Umme Jiba, Afshan Khan, M. Shahrukh, Nazeer Hasan, F. J. Ahmad · 2024 · Journal of Drug Delivery Science and Technology
  4. Hypothermia in Traumatic Brain Injury – A Literature Review
    Liming Qiu · 2011 · Journal of the Intensive Care Society
  5. Methodological standards, quality of reporting and regulatory compliance in animal research on amyotrophic lateral sclerosis: a systematic review
    Joana Guilherme-Fernandes, Nuno Henrique Franco, Andrew J. Grierson, Jan Hultgren, Andrew J. Furley, I. Anna S. Olsson · 2019 · BMJ Open Science
  6. In-air EIS sensor for in situ and real-time monitoring of in vitro epithelial cells under air-exposure
    Seungbeom Noh, Hanseup Kim · 2020 · Lab on a Chip
  7. Bias in animal studies of estrogen effects on cardiovascular disease: A systematic review and meta‐analysis
    Christopher Friis Berntsen, Pernille Rootwelt, Anders Erik Astrup Dahm · 2021 · Research and Practice in Thrombosis and Haemostasis
  8. Why There Is No Obligation to Participate in Clinical Research
    Mark A. Yarborough · 2017 · The Journal of Law Medicine & Ethics
  9. Reproducibility in Biomedical Research
    Kevin Mullane, Michael J. Curtis, Michael J. Williams · 2017 · Elsevier eBooks
  10. The Therapeutic Potential of the Stem Cell Secretome for Spinal Cord Repair: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
    Catriona J. Cunningham, Marc Vives Enrich, Molly M Pickford, William MacIntosh-Smith, Wenlong L. Huang · 2020 · OBM Neurobiology
  11. Theme Editorial: Controlled Human Infection Models: Exploring the landscape in India
    Vijayaprasad Gopichandran, Gagandeep Kang · 2018 · Indian Journal of Medical Ethics
  12. A methodological review with meta-epidemiological analysis of preclinical systematic reviews with meta-analyses
    Noémie Simon‐Tillaux, Anne-Laure Gerard, Deivanes Rajendrabose, Florence Tubach, Agnès Dechartres · 2022 · Scientific Reports
  13. Preclinical Evidence of Curcuma longa Linn. as a Functional Food in the Management of Metabolic Syndrome: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Rodent Studies
    Samuel Abiodun Kehinde, Zahid Naeem Qaisrani, Rinrada Pattanayaiying, Wai Phyo Lin, Bo Bo Lay, Khin Yadanar Phyo, Myat Mon San, Nurulhusna Awaeloh, Sasithon Aunsorn, Ran Kitkangplu et al. · 2025 · Biomedicines
  14. Mensch – Tier – Gott
    Internationale Vereinigung für Moraltheologie und Sozialethik 2019 Brixen, Martin M. Lintner, Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft · 2021 · Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft mbH & Co. KG eBooks
  15. Organoid Technologies for SARS-CoV-2 Research
    Khiry Sutton, Timothy S. Leach, Vikram Surendran, Phillip W. Clapp, Sean V. Murphy · 2022 · Current Stem Cell Reports
  16. Near infrared spectroscopy detection of hemispheric cerebral ischemia following middle cerebral artery occlusion in rats
    Ardy Wong, Mohammad Iqbal H. Bhuiyan, Jeffrey Rothman, Kelly L. Drew, Kambiz Pourrezaei, Dandan Sun, Zeinab Barati · 2022 · Neurochemistry International
  17. Preclinical Animal Models of Cancer: Applications and Limitations
    Girish D. Sharma, Yuvraj Goyal, Simran Bhatia · 2023 · Handbook of Animal Models and its Uses in Cancer Research
  18. Twenty years after: Do animal trials inform clinical resuscitation research?
    Penny S. Reynolds · 2011 · Resuscitation
  19. Animal experimental research design in critical care
    Justin S. Merkow, Janine M. Hoerauf, Angela F. D. Moss, Jason C. Brainard, Lena M. Mayes, Ana Fernandez-Bustamante, Susan K. Mikulich‐Gilbertson, Karsten Bartels · 2018 · BMC Medical Research Methodology
  20. Animal Models
    Philipp Mergenthaler, Andreas Meisel · 2015 · Elsevier eBooks
  21. Animal models: value and translational potency
    Philipp Mergenthaler, Andreas Meisel · 2021 · Elsevier eBooks
  22. How to End Selective Reporting in Animal Research
    Gerben ter Riet, L.M. Bouter · 2016 · Methods and principles in medicinal chemistry
  23. Lost in Translation - - the challenges with the use of animal models in translational research
    Attila A. Seyhan · 2019
  24. Dissecting the pro-neurogenic effects of monoaminergic medications used to treat depression: a systematic review and meta-analysis
    Juliana Aparecida Bolzan, Tamires Martins, Karolina Domingues, Alexandre Surget, Catherine Belzung, Cilene Lino de Oliveira · 2025 · Journal of Psychopharmacology
  25. Assessing post-stroke cognition in pre-clinical models: Lessons and recommendations from a multi-center study
    Gaia Brezzo, Kristy A. Zera, Dana Straus, Jennifer E. Goertz, Sanna H. Loppi, R. Crumpacker, Jennifer Beischel Frye, Danielle A. Becktel, María Isabel Cuartero, Alicia García‐Culebras et al. · 2025 · Journal of Cerebral Blood Flow & Metabolism
  26. Transient Middle Cerebral Artery Occlusion in Rats as a Nonclinical Model of Ischemic Stroke: A Systematic Review
    Priscila Mendes, Joana Pinto, Carole Mateus, Inês Guerra, Vanessa Mateus · 2026 · Current Issues in Molecular Biology
  27. Nanoparticles for Thrombolytic Therapy in Ischemic Stroke: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Preclinical Studies
    Jesús Prego-Domínguez, Fernando Laso-García, Nuria Palomar-Alonso, María Pérez‐Mato, Esteban López‐Arias, Antonio Dopico‐López, Pablo Hervella, María Gutiérrez‐Fernández, María Alonso de Leciñana, Ester Polo et al. · 2025 · Pharmaceutics
  28. Plasma galectin-3 concentrations in patients with primary aldosteronism
    T.N.A. van den Berg, Wouter C. Meijers, A. Rogier T. Donders, Antonius Eduard van Herwaarden, Gerard A. P. J. M. Rongen, Rudolf A. de Boer, Jaap Deinum, Niels Peter Riksen · 2017 · Journal of Hypertension
  29. Postmarketing withdrawal of human medicinal products because of adverse reactions in animals: a systematic review and analysis
    Igho Onakpoya, Carl J. Heneghan, Jeffrey K Aronson · 2017 · Pharmacoepidemiology and Drug Safety
  30. Animal Models and the Search for Drug Treatments for Traumatic Brain Injury
    Pandora Pound · 2020 · Advances in neuroethics
  31. Pharmacologic Reduction of Angiographic Vasospasm in Experimental Subarachnoid Hemorrhage: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
    Malcolm Robert Macleod · 2012 · Journal of Cerebral Blood Flow & Metabolism
  32. X-WAS, Traditional Epidemiology, and Policy Action
    John P. A. Ioannidis, Robert E. Tarone, Joseph K. McLaughlin · 2011 · Epidemiology
  33. Systematic review and meta-analysis of pre-clinical research: the need for reporting guidelines.
    Nathalie Percie du Sert · 2011 · PubMed
  34. How to Avoid Bumping into the Translational Roadblock
    Malcolm Robert Macleod · 2010 · Neuromethods
  35. Controlled human infection models for vaccine development: Zika virus debate
    Vijayaprasad Gopichandran · 2017 · Indian Journal of Medical Ethics
  36. Animal studies paint misleading picture
    Janelle Weaver · 2010 · Nature
  37. Role of JNK3 signaling in acute ischemic stroke cerebroprotection: A systematic review
    Federica Ferrari, Federico Mazzacane, Beatrice Del Bello, Anna Maria Cavallini, Domenico Raimondo, Tiziana Borsello · 2025 · Biomedicine & Pharmacotherapy
  38. Animal researchers’ views on the publication of negative results and subsequent policy adoptions
    Carlos Óscar S. Sorzano, Daniel George Hamilton, Eva Méndez · 2024 · Laboratory Animals
  39. Connecting the dots in neuroscience research: The future of evidence synthesis
    Kaitlyn Hair, María Arroyo-Araujo, Sofija Vojvodić, Maria Economou, Charis Wong, Francesca Tinsdeall, Sean Smith, Torsten Rackoll, Emily S. Sena, Sarah McCann · 2024 · Experimental Neurology
  40. Targeting Nerve Fiber Outgrowth Inhibition After Experimental Spinal Cord Injury: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Chondroitinase ABC
    A. Khanteymoori, Clayton Peterson, Roza Atamny, M. Hohenhaus, J. Beck, D. Howells, Jan M. Schwab, Ralf Watzlawick · 2025 · Neurorehabilitation and Neural Repair
  41. Cardiac stem cell treatment in myocardial infarction: protocol for a systematic review and meta‐analysis of preclinical studies
    Peter-Paul M. Zwetsloot, Sanne J. Jansen of Lorkeers, Anna M. D. Végh, Gerardus P. J. van Hout, Gillian L. Currie, Marie‐José Goumans, Steven A. J. Chamuleau, Joost P. G. Sluijter · 2015 · Evidence-based Preclinical Medicine
  42. Evaluation of an Internal Research Funding Program in a School of Veterinary Medicine
    David G. Baker, Michael T. Kearney · 2011 · Journal of Veterinary Medical Education
  43. A Discussion of the Role of Complex Evolved Systems in the Development of Invasive Cardiovascular Interventions as Illustrated by the Blalock- Taussig Shunt and Intra-Arterial Stents
    Ray Greek · 2014 · Biological Systems Open Access
  44. Our time is now - how companion animal veterinarians can transform biomedical science.
    R. Mellanby · 2015 · Journal of Small Animal Practice
  45. Neglecting the null: the pitfalls of underreporting negative results in preclinical research
    William Foster, Samantha Putos · 2014 · University of Ottawa Journal of Medicine
  46. Pre-clinical disease models in drug toxicity evaluation
    Martyn L. Foster · 2017 · Current Opinion in Toxicology
  47. Evaluation of spin in the abstracts of systematic reviews and meta-analyses focused on treatments of alcohol use disorder
    Cole Verble, Marysa Cloeter, Ryan Ottwell, Wade Arthur, Micah L. Hartwell, Branden Carr, Kelly E. Dunn, Jana Baker, Drew Wright, Meghan Sealey et al. · 2021 · The American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse
  48. A compact guide to the systematic review and meta-analysis of the literature in neuroscience
    Juliana Aparecida Bolzan, Cilene Lino de Oliveira · 2022 · Journal for Reproducibility in Neuroscience
  49. Arguments Against Using Nonhuman Primates in Research
    Jarrod Bailey · 2023 · Springer eBooks
  50. Between therapy effect and false-positive result in animal experimentation
    Paweł Sosnowski, Piotr Sass, Anna Stanisławska‐Sachadyn, Michał Krzemiński, Paweł Sachadyn · 2023 · Biomedicine & Pharmacotherapy
  51. Accelerating addiction research via Open Science and Team Science
    Jonas Dora, Marilyn L. Piccirillo, Katherine T. Foster, Kevin Michael King · 2023 · The Psychology of learning and motivation/The psychology of learning and motivation
  52. Future of Regulatory Safety Assessment
    Gerd Bode, Petra Starck-Lantova, Peter-Juergen Kramer · 2023 · Springer eBooks
  53. Muscarinic receptor agonists and positive allosteric modulators in animal models of psychosis: protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis
    Spyridon Siafis, Nobuyuki Nomura, Johannes Schneider‐Thoma, Irene Bighelli, Alexandra Bannach‐Brown, Fiona Ramage, Francesca Tinsdeall, Ioannis Mantas, Sameer Jauhar, Sridhar Natesan et al. · 2024 · F1000Research
  54. Web-based survey among animal researchers on publication practices and incentives for increasing publication rates
    Susanne Deutsch, Miriam Heider, Silke Glage, André Bleich, Rene Hany Tolba, Daniel Strech, Susanne Wieschowski · 2021 · PLoS ONE
  55. Experimental Planning and Execution
    Kevin Mullane, Michael J. Curtis, Michael J. Williams · 2017 · Elsevier eBooks
  56. An Open Source Technology Platform to Manufacture Hydrogel-Based 3D Culture Models in an Automated and Standardized Fashion
    Sebastian Eggert, Melanie Kahl, Ross Kent, Lukas Gaats, Nathalie Bock, Christoph Meinert, Dietmar Werner Hutmacher · 2022 · Journal of Visualized Experiments
  57. Dissemination of Research Results
    Tamarinde Laura Haven, Daniel Strech · 2023 · Collaborative bioethics
  58. The dilemma of neuroprotection trials in times of successful endovascular recanalization
    Antje Schmidt‐Pogoda, Johannes Kaesmacher, Nadine Bonberg, Nils Werring, Jan‐Kolja Strecker, Mailin Hannah Marie Koecke, Carolin Beuker, Jan Gralla, Raphael Meier, Heinz Wiendl et al. · 2024 · Frontiers in Neurology
  59. A meta-analysis of animal studies evaluating the effect of hydrogen sulfide on ischemic stroke: is the preclinical evidence sufficient to move forward?
    Selda Emre Aydıngöz, Arıyan Teimoori, Halit Güner Orhan, Elif Demirtaş, Nargız Zeynalova · 2024 · Naunyn-Schmiedeberg s Archives of Pharmacology
  60. Preclinical pancreatic cancer mouse models for treatment with small molecule inhibitors: a systematic review and meta-analysis
    Sophia Villwock, Yalda Mirzaei, Edgar Dahl, Julia Steitz · 2025 · Scientific Reports
  61. Systematic review and meta-analysis of cognitive assessments used to detect deficits in the bilateral carotid artery stenosis model for vascular cognitive impairment
    Matthew Padgett, Nela Fucelova, Johannes Boltze, Timothy J. England, Tuuli M Hietamies, Karen J. Horsburgh, Terence J. Quinn, Emily S. Sena, Lorraine M. Work, Marietta Zille et al. · 2026 · Journal of Cerebral Blood Flow & Metabolism
  62. Extracellular Vesicles in Osteoarthritis: From Pathogenic Mediators to Engineered Therapeutics in a Precision Medicine Roadmap
    Duc‐Hiep Bach, Văn Giang Bùi, T U O N G Nguyen · 2026 · Journal of Extracellular Biology
  63. La experimentación animal y el progreso de la medicina
    Joan M.V. Pons, Gaietà Permanyer-Miralda, Jordi Camı́, Joan Rodés · 2014 · Medicina Clínica
  64. Red blood cell transfusion in animal models of acute brain injuries: a systematic review protocol
    M. Laflamme, Hourmazd Haghbayan, Manoj Mathew Lalu, Ryan Zarychanski, François Lauzier, Amélie Boutin, Malcolm Robert Macleod, Dean A. Fergusson, Lynne Moore, Olivier Costerousse et al. · 2021 · Systematic Reviews
  65. Preregistration in Animal Research
    Céline Heinl, Gilbert Schönfelder, Bettina Bert · 2022 · Springer eBooks
  66. Meta-analysis of preclinical measures of efficacy in immune checkpoint blockade therapies and comparison to clinical efficacy estimates
    Juan Miguel Tenorio-Pedraza, Jörg Lippert, Rolf Burghaus, Christian Scheerans · 2023 · Translational Medicine Communications
  67. The hazards of chasing subgroups in neutral stroke trials
    Philip M. Bath, George Howard, Werner Hacke · 2025 · Neurological Research and Practice
  68. A three-stage strategy for conducting an experimental investigation: A recommendation to improve the reproducibility of reported conclusions
    Simon T. Bate, S. Clare Stanford, Lee Page · 2025 · Journal of Psychopharmacology
  69. Una referencia valiosa para el uso responsable de los animales en la investigación científica: el documento guía “Principios rectores internacionales para la investigación biomédica con animales CIOMS-ICLAS”
    Marcela Rebuelto · 2022 · Revista de Bioética y Derecho
  70. Anti‐inflammatory compounds to reduce infarct size in large‐animal models of myocardial infarction: A meta‐analysis
    Gerardus P. J. van Hout, Sanne J. Jansen of Lorkeers, Kimberley Elaine Wever, Emily S. Sena, Wouter W. van Solinge, Pieter A. Doevendans, Gerard Pasterkamp, Steven A. J. Chamuleau, Imo E. Hoefer · 2014 · Evidence-based Preclinical Medicine
  71. The need for registration of preclinical studies
    Sanja Pavlica · 2013 · Medical Writing
  72. Clinical Trial Design in Prevention and Treatment of Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome
    Gerard F. Curley, Daniel Francis McAuley · 2014 · Clinics in Chest Medicine
  73. From Mice to Men: Translation from Bench to Bedside
    Marianne I. Martić-Kehl, Pius August Schubiger · 2016 · John Wiley & Sons, Inc. eBooks
  74. Should we be publishing more null results?
    2014 · Journal of Wildlife Management
  75. Clinical Translation in Central Nervous System Diseases: Ethical and Social Challenges
    Jonathan Kimmelman, Spencer Phillips Hey · 2014 · Springer eBooks
  76. The 3Rs and Good Scientific Practice
    With Catarina Vieira de Castro · 2017 · Cambridge University Press eBooks
  77. Validating Methods that Promote Reduction and Refinement in Laboratory Animal Science
    MICHAEL D. WALKER · 2016 · The Atrium (University of Guelph)
  78. Understanding in vivo modelling of depression
    Alexandra Bannach‐Brown · 2019 · ERA
  79. Discovery reliability
    A. Hånell · 2019 · Journal of Cerebral Blood Flow and Metabolism
  80. Researchers‘ perspectives on preregistration in animal research
    Cristina Priboi, Boris Mayer, Evie Vergauwe, Bernice S. Elger, Hanno Würbel · 2025 · bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
  81. Preclinical systematic review of CCR5 antagonists as cerebroprotective and stroke recovery enhancing agents
    Ayni Sharif, Matthew Strider Jeffers, Dean A. Fergusson, Raj Bapuji, Stuart Gordon Nicholls, John Humphrey, Warren Johnston, Ed Mitchell, Mary-Ann Speirs, Laura Stronghill et al. · 2025 · eLife
  82. Benzotriazole in Cancer: A Systematic Review on Preclinical Evidence and Structure–Activity Relationship
    Gabriel Mardale, Alexandra Prodea, Andreea Mara Munteanu, Mihaela Jorgovan, Sabina Mardale, Victor Cristian Dumitrascu, Codruţa Şoica · 2025 · Pharmaceuticals
  83. Restoring comparative expertise to improve translation of animal models
    K. C. Kent Lloyd · 2026 · Disease Models & Mechanisms
  84. Ethics in Translational Gene Transfer Research
    Insoo Hyun, Jonathan Kimmelman · 2013 · Elsevier eBooks
  85. Endpoints in animal pain models
    Andrew S.C. Rice · 2012 · Scandinavian Journal of Pain
  86. Prof Benchie and Dr Athena—A modern tragedy…
    Malcolm Robert Macleod · 2015 · Evidence-based Preclinical Medicine
  87. Year in review 2013: Critical Care- respirology
    Gerard F. Curley, Arthur S. Slutsky · 2014 · Critical Care
  88. Systematic Review and Meta-analysis: Important Tools in Understanding Drug Development for Stroke
    S. McCann, E. Sena, G. Currie, M. Macleod, D. Howells · 2017 · Springer series in translational stroke research
  89. Mouse Models of Chronic Intestinal Inflammation: Characterization and Use in Pharmacological Intervention Studies
    Cynthia Reinoso Webb, Matthew B. Grisham · 2017 · Springer eBooks
  90. Potenziale und Grenzen des EBM-Paradigmas in den Gesundheitswissenschaften
    Martin Langanke, Stefan Kirschke · 2017 · Springer eBooks
  91. Software for designing rigorous and replicable preclinical research: The Experimental Design Accelerator
    David H. Malin, Scott A. Hetherington, Duyen M. Nghiem, Christopher Peyton Ward, Nicholas Kelling, Jonathan J. Izygon, L. Jean Harrison‐Walker, Joseph R. Campbell, Ryan Hughes, William R. Buras · 2019 · Journal of Neuroscience Research
  92. No clear trends in expatriation of non-human primate research from Switzerland between 2004 and 2017
    Filipe Maximiano Sousa, John Andrew Berezowski, Simon R. Rüegg · 2021 · Schweizer Archiv für Tierheilkunde
  93. Future of Regulatory Safety Assessments
    Gerd Bode, Petra Starck-Lantova · 2020 · Springer eBooks
  94. Publication Bias
    R. Barker Bausell · 2021
  95. Preclinical Animal Models of Cancer: Applications and Limitations
    Girish D. Sharma, Yuvraj Goyal, Simran Bhatia · 2022 · Handbook of Animal Models and its Uses in Cancer Research
  96. The Quality of Reporting Raises Questions on the Experimental Validity of Animal Studies Conducted in India and Sri Lanka: Preliminary Analysis of a Systematic Survey
    Vijay Pal Singh, Ayushi Jain, Shubhra Agrawal Gupta, Manudharshy Vijayakumar, Kunal Pratap, Deepanshu Maheshwari, Tharanga Thoradeniya · 2020 · Alternatives to Laboratory Animals
  97. Incidence of post-traumatic epilepsy following paediatric traumatic brain injury: protocol for systematic review and meta-analysis
    Frederick P. Mariajoseph, Sarah S. J. Rewell, Terence John O'Brien, Bridgette D. Semple, Ana Antonic‐Baker · 2021 · BMJ Open
  98. Effects of anti-inflammatory treatments on stroke outcome in animal models
    Ivo ACW Tiebosch · 2012 · Utrecht University Repository (Utrecht University)
  99. The Solution to Science's Replication Crisis
    B. Knuteson · 2016 · SSRN Electronic Journal
  100. Researcher Conduct Determines Data Reliability
    Mark N. Wass, Larry Ray, Martin Michaelis · 2018 · Preprints.org