A Simple Formula for Obtaining Markedly Improved Mutation Rate Estimates

Abstract

In previous work by M. E. Jones and colleagues, it was shown that mutation rate estimates can be improved and corresponding confidence intervals tightened by following a very easy modification of the standard fluctuation assay: cultures are grown to a larger-than-usual final density, and mutants are screened for in only a fraction of the culture. Surprisingly, this very promising development has received limited attention, perhaps because there has been no efficient way to generate the predicted mutant distribution to obtain non-moment-based estimates of the mutation rate. Here, the improved fluctuation assay discovered by Jones and colleagues is made amenable to quantile-based, likelihood, and other Bayesian methods by a simple recursion formula that efficiently generates the entire mutant distribution after growth and dilution. This formula makes possible a further protocol improvement: grow cultures as large as is experimentally possible and severely dilute before plating to obtain easily countable numbers of mutants. A preliminary look at likelihood surfaces suggests that this easy protocol adjustment gives markedly improved mutation rate estimates and confidence intervals.