Measuring Collapse and Correction in Homogeneous-Panel LLM Debate

May combine two claims.

A post-hoc audit of all 91 model-row pairs found the screen reorders 26 pairs relative to initial accuracy, and observed conditional collapse follows the screen in 13 and initial accuracy in 12 (one tie).

“A post-hoc audit of all 91 model-row pairs bounds this use: the screen reorders 26 pairs relative to initial accuracy, and observed conditional collapse follows the screen in 13 and initial accuracy in 12 (one tie; Section G.1).”

May combine two claims.

Low-α_tot families occupy the low-collapse ranks, while high-α_tot open-model families carry most collapse risk; Meta is the visible upper-tail inversion.

“Low-α tot families occupy the low-collapse ranks, while high-α tot open-model families carry most collapse risk; Meta is the visible upper-tail inversion.”

May combine two claims.

Under equal collapse/correction weights, a leave-one-model-out probe-gated freeze prevents 29 collapses but discards 108 corrections, for a net utility of -79.

“a leave-one-model-out probe-gated freeze prevents 29 collapses but loses 108 corrections under equal weights”

• Also stated in: § 2.15%). · plain

  “under equal collapse/correction weights, a leave-one-model-out probe-gated freeze prevents 29 collapses but discards 108 corrections, for a net utility of -79.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

Realized-cohort model-row partials remain positive after residualizing on initial accuracy (ρ = +0.658, p = 0.014) and initial accuracy plus raw revision (ρ = +0.667, p = 0.018).

“Realized-cohort model-row partials remain positive after residualizing on initial accuracy (ρ=+0.658,p=0.014) and initial accuracy plus raw revision (ρ=+0.667,p=0.018)”

The quote only partly states this claim.

Simple Round 1 replay gates show the same sign as the LOMO freeze.

“Simple Round 1 replay gates show the same sign”

May combine two claims.

Capability pressure, measured as 1-initial-majority accuracy, is a close free comparator (ρ = +0.821 at the family level), leaving a modest marginal rank gain for α_tot of about Δρ = 0.07.

“Capability pressure, measured as 1-initial-majority accuracy, is a close free comparator (ρ=+0.821at the family level), leaving a modest marginal rank gain for α tot of about ∆ρ=0.07”

May combine two claims.

The family-level rank partial after initial-majority accuracy remains positive but is no longer confirmatory (ρ = +0.767, exact two-sided p = 0.0877).

“The family-level rank partial after initial-majority accuracy remains positive but is no longer confirmatory (ρ=+0.767,exact two-sided p=0.0877).”

May combine two claims.

Probe ablations support the intended argument/social channel separation, but the effect is uneven, with Qwen-3 rows near zero.

“Probe ablations support the intended argument/social channel separation, but the effect is uneven, with Qwen-3 rows near zero.”

May combine two claims.

The probe reverses the capability-pressure order (α_tot = 0.774 vs. 0.607), matching the observed conditional-collapse ordering (8.46% vs. 5.11%).

“The probe reverses this order (α tot =0.774 vs. 0.607), matching the observed conditional-collapse ordering (8.46% vs. 5.11%).”

May combine two claims.

The combined collapse predictor changed by at most 0.004 AUC when very_strong was removed and by at most 0.005 AUC when only non-social probes were used.

“The combined predictor used in the main text (mean probe flip rate + difficulty + initial disagreement) changed by at most 0.004 AUC when very_strong was removed and by at most 0.005 AUC when only non-social probes were used.”

May combine two claims.

Removing the very_strong probe preserved the model-level S/A ordering exactly (Spearman ρ=1.00 across four models), with largest absolute shift in mean S/A only 0.024.

“Removing very_strong preserved the model-level S/A ordering exactly (Spearman ρ = 1.00 across the four models), with the largest absolute shift in mean S/A only 0.024.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

Alphabetic tie-breaking is used in 298/3,240 primary initial/final majority reductions (9.20%), with 272/1,620 rows having at least one primary initial/final tie.

“Alphabetic tie-breaking is used in 298/3,240 primary initial/final majority reductions (9.20%), with 272/1,620 rows having at least one primary initial/final tie.”

May combine two claims.

Recomputing S/A on a single shared 200-question pool leaves the model-level rank ordering of S/A unchanged (Spearman ρ=0.95 between per-model and shared-pool rankings on the four overlap models), with largest absolute shift in S/A 0.04.

“The model-level rank ordering of S/A is unchanged (Spearman ρ = 0.95 between the per-model and shared-pool rankings on the four overlap models), and the largest absolute shift in S/A is 0.04.”

May combine two claims.

Anti-argument and anti-social system prompts elicit measurably different flip distributions in all 16/16 tested models, with grand mean Cohen's d = 0.53 and 12/16 paired tests surviving Holm-Bonferroni correction.

“Anti-argument and anti-social system prompts elicit measurably different flip distributions in all 16/16 tested models, with grand mean Cohen's d=0.53 and 12/16 paired tests surviving Holm-Bonferroni correction”

May combine two claims.

In eleven reasoning-mode rows, collapses and corrections both persist.

“In eleven reasoning-mode rows, collapses and corrections both persist”

May combine two claims.

In the Mistral row, four questions lack a valid initial majority; excluding them changes the signed net from +1 to -1.

“In the Mistral row, four questions lack a valid initial majority; excluding them changes the signed net from +1 to -1”

May combine two claims.

In the raw-log subset, removing the very_strong probe preserves the model-level S/A ordering exactly (Spearman ρ = 1.00 over four models) and changes matched collapse-prediction AUC by at most 0.004.

“In the raw-log subset, removing that very_strong probe preserves the model-level S/A ordering exactly (Spearman ρ=1.00 over four models) and changes matched collapse-prediction AUC by at most 0.004”

May combine two claims.

Private revision has a negative point difference in all eleven reasoning-mode rows (intervals below zero in seven).

“private revision has a negative point difference in all eleven (intervals below zero in seven; Table 8).”

May combine two claims.

Private revision reduces wrong-answer collapses but leaves more ties.

“it reduces wrong-answer collapses but leaves more ties”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing), S4 (based). May combine two claims.

Initial-majority accuracy is a close comparator; after Round 0 sampling, disagreement is the stronger runtime diagnostic.

“Initial-majority accuracy is a close comparator; after Round 0 sampling, disagreement is the stronger runtime diagnostic.”

May combine two claims.

The strict parser labels both initial and final majorities for 966/1,620 checked-in trace rows; among those strict-labeled rows, four-cell transition membership changes in 51 rows (5.28%), with 20 collapse-label and 29 correction-label changes.

“The strict parser labels both initial and final majorities for 966/1,620 checked-in trace rows; among those strict-labeled rows, four-cell transition membership changes in 51 rows (5.28%), with 20 collapse-label and 29 correction-label changes.”

May combine two claims.

Attrition and manifest-discipline exclusions reduced the matched post-A6 cohort to N = 14, and six of those rows are related Qwen variants.

“attrition and manifest-discipline exclusions reduced the matched post-A6 cohort to N =14, and six of those rows are related Qwen variants.”

May combine two claims.

Anti-argument prompts elicit more revision than anti-social prompts, with the ordering holding in 16/16 tested models.

“Anti-argument prompts elicit more revision than anti-social prompts.The ordering holds in 16/16 tested models”

• Also stated in: § B.6 Full 16-Model Channel Manipulation Results · plain

  “Anti-argument FR > Anti-social FR in 16/16 models”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

The tie rule fires in 298/3,240 initial/final majority reductions (9.20%), and removing the last-valid-letter fallback changes 51/966 strict-labeled transition cells.

“in the open trace subset, it fires in 298/3,240 initial/final majority reductions (9.20%), and removing the last-valid-letter fallback changes 51/966 strict-labeled transition cells.”

May combine two claims.

DeepSeek V4 Flash gains despite nonzero collapse because corrections dominate.

“while DeepSeek V4 Flash gains despite nonzero collapse because corrections dominate”

May combine two claims.

Qwen3-4B (d = 0.092) and Qwen3-8B (d = 0.057) are near-zero separability cases.

“Qwen3-4B (d=0.092) and Qwen3-8B (d=0.057) are near-zero separability cases.”

May combine two claims.

The current model-row Spearman is ρ = +0.8295, and coding new-lane None post-answers as flips gives ρ = +0.8119.

“the current model-row Spearman is ρ=+0.8295,and coding new-lane None post-answers as flips gives ρ=+0.8119.”

May combine two claims.

At the per-question level, after initial answers are observed, disagreement is the stronger runtime diagnostic, while probe FR and S/A do not act as row-level collapse detectors.

“At the per-question level, the screen boundary is sharper: after initial answers are observed, disagreement is the stronger runtime diagnostic, while probe FR and S/A do not act as row-level collapse detectors”

May combine two claims.

All three freeze-style gates prevent some collapses but lose more corrections; even the closest Round 1 gate is 56 prevented versus 69 lost.

“All three freeze-style gates prevent some collapses but lose more corrections; even the closest Round 1 gate is 56 prevented versus 69 lost.”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: The freeze-style gates evaluated are representative of intervention policies for debate.

May combine two claims.

α tot remains associated with C cond under simple rank residualizations: controlling capability-pressure proxy gives ρ=+0.658 (p=0.014); controlling raw debate-revision proxy alone gives ρ=+0.780 (p=0.0017); controlling capability pressure plus raw debate-revision proxy gives ρ=+0.667 (p=0.018).

“α tot remains associated with C cond under simple rank residualizations: controlling the capability-pressure proxy gives ρ=+0.658(p=0.014);controlling raw debate-revision proxy alone gives ρ=+0.780(p=0.0017);controlling capability pressure plus the raw debate-revision proxy gives ρ=+0.667(p=0.018).”

May combine two claims.

Mistral Small 4 has 20/120 conditional collapses and 21/78 corrections, producing only +1 net debate under equal collapse/correction weights.

“Mistral Small 4 has 20/120 conditional collapses and 21/78 corrections, producing only +1 net debate under equal collapse/correction weights.”

May combine two claims.

The observed Round 1 lift is ∆R1=+0.099 with debate-index percentile 95% CI [+0.080, +0.118]; the residual full-trajectory lift is ∆full=+0.077 with 95% CI [+0.064, +0.092].

“The observed Round 1 lift is ∆ R1 =+0.099 with debate-index percentile 95% CI [+0.080, +0.118]; the residual full-trajectory lift is ∆ full =+0.077with 95% CI [+0.064, +0.092].”

May combine two claims.

If appended as a post-hoc N=15 model-row stress test, the Spearman association remains ρ=+0.822; averaging it into the Qwen family leaves the G=7 family association unchanged at +0.893, and treating it as a separate stress family gives G=8 ρ=+0.857.

“If appended as a post-hoc N =15 model-row stress test, the Spearman association remains ρ=+0.822;averaging it into the Qwen family leaves the G=7 family association unchanged at +0.893, and treating it as a separate stress family gives G=8 ρ=+0.857.”

May combine two claims.

Phi remains a high-collapse row (C cond=10.24%), while Anthropic/OpenAI/Google/DeepSeek occupy the lower-collapse ranks.

“Phi remains a high-collapse row (C cond =10.24%), while Anthropic/OpenAI/Google/DeepSeek occupy the lower-collapse ranks.”

May combine two claims.

Mistral Small 4 has the highest holdout probe rate (α tot=0.3772), 7/140 R4 collapses (5.00%), and 13/60 R4 corrections (21.67%).

“Mistral Small 4 is the main new-family stress row: it has the highest holdout probe rate (α tot =0.3772), 7/140 R4 collapses (5.00%), and 13/60 R4 corrections (21.67%).”

May combine two claims.

Dropping each Qwen variant in turn leaves the model-row Spearman in [+0.809, +0.875] over the remaining N=13 rows; worst cases are dropping Qwen3-4B or Qwen3-8B (ρ=+0.809).

“Dropping each Qwen variant in turn leaves the model-row Spearman in [+0.809, +0.875] over the remaining N =13 rows; the worst cases are dropping Qwen3-4B or Qwen3-8B (ρ=+0.809).”

May combine two claims.

The cascade is dominantly a Round 1 phenomenon (58.9% onset) but not exclusively.

“The cascade is dominantly a Round 1 phenomenon (58.9% onset) but not exclusively”

May combine two claims.

Leave-one-model-out predictive R2 on a rank-linear fit is R2 LOMO=0.26 for total α and 0.12 for α adv.

“(2) Leave-one-model-out predictive R 2 on a rank-linear fit: R 2 LOMO =0.26 for total α and 0.12 for α adv .”

May combine two claims.

The two 80% misses are Meta (observed below the interval) and Qwen (observed above it); Qwen is the only 95% miss, with the held-out fit underpredicting the upper tail.

“The two 80% misses are Meta (observed below the interval) and Qwen (observed above it); Qwen is the only 95% miss, with the held-out fit underpredicting the upper tail.”

May combine two claims.

Per-model α and α adv values drop uniformly by ∆α ∈ [-0.073, -0.022] but their rank order across models is preserved.

“the per-model α and α adv values drop uniformly by ∆α ∈ [-0.073, -0.022] but their rank order across models is preserved.”

May combine two claims.

The clipped EIV-propagated predictive intervals cover 5/7 families at 80% and 7/7 at 95%; Meta and Qwen remain the two 80% misses, while Qwen is now included only at the upper edge of the 95% interval.

“The clipped EIV-propagated predictive intervals cover 5/7 families at 80% and 7/7 at 95%; Meta and Qwen remain the two 80% misses, while Qwen is now included only at the upper edge of the 95% interval.”

May combine two claims.

GPQA contributes the only collapse (1/31=3.2%) and all three corrections; TruthfulQA has 0/42 collapses and no corrections.

“GPQA contributes the only collapse (1/31=3.2%)and all three corrections; TruthfulQA has 0/42 collapses and no corrections.”

May combine two claims.

Pooled out-of-fold AUC is 0.669 for the pre-debate baseline, 0.768 for Round 1 trajectory, and 0.846 for the full trajectory.

“Pooled out-of-fold AUC is 0.669 for the pre-debate baseline, 0.768 for Round 1 trajectory, and 0.846 for the full trajectory.”

May combine two claims.

Llama 3.3 70B and DeepSeek V4 Flash both have measurable collapses, but standard debate is net positive because corrections are larger (+7 and +37 debates, respectively).

“Llama 3.3 70B and DeepSeek V4 Flash add a useful contrast: both have measurable collapses, but standard debate is net positive because corrections are larger (+7 and +37 debates, respectively).”

May combine two claims.

α adv remains directionally positive after initial accuracy but is weaker and non-confirmatory (ρ=+0.52, raw p=0.148), while α cor points negative.

“It does not: α adv remains directionally positive after initial accuracy but is weaker and non-confirmatory (ρ=+0.52,raw p=0.148), while α cor points negative.”

May combine two claims.

With model-constant predictors and N=9 models grouped into 6 families, the GEE coefficients on α adv and initial accuracy are individually statistically indistinguishable from zero (cluster-robust |z|≤0.5); the predictors are near-collinear (Spearman between α adv and initial accuracy: -0.58).

“With model-constant predictors and N =9 models grouped into 6 families, the GEE coefficients on α adv and initial accuracy are individually statistically indistinguishable from zero (cluster-robust |z|≤0.5); the predictors are near-collinear (Spearman between α adv and initial accuracy: -0.58).”

May combine two claims.

The family-level partial Spearman remains positive, ρ α|init acc=+0.767, with exact two-sided p=0.0877.

“The family-level partial remains positive, ρ α|init acc =+0.767, but the small denominator is visible: enumerating all 7! assignments of family-level C cond while holding family α tot and initial accuracy fixed gives exact two-sided p=0.0877.”

May combine two claims.

Expanding the same Gemini lane to the full 198-question GPQA Diamond split preserves the boundary interpretation: collapse remains sparse (2/147=1.4%), while corrections remain nonzero (9/51=17.6%).

“Expanding the same Gemini lane to the full 198-question GPQA Diamond split preserves the boundary interpretation: collapse remains sparse (2/147=1.4%),while corrections remain nonzero (9/51=17.6%).”

May combine two claims.

The permutation null for total α gives observed Spearman ρ=+0.78 with 2-sided permutation p<0.02; for α adv, ρ=+0.62 gives p≈0.09.

“(1) Permutation null (10,000 random shuffles of C cond ): the observed Spearman ρ=+0.78 for total α has 2-sided permutation p<0.02; for α adv , ρ=+0.62 gives p≈0.09.”

May combine two claims.

GPT-5.4-mini has an S/A ratio of +0.048, near zero, consistent with argument-dominated revision.

“GPT-5.4-mini was selected as a preregistered held-out sanity check because its S/A ratio (+0.048) is near zero, consistent with argument-dominated revision.”

May combine two claims.

On ARC-Challenge, both Haiku and GPT-4o-mini show dramatically lower flip rates (Haiku: 0.512→0.179, d=-1.13; GPT: 0.458→0.161, d=-1.07) and near-zero collapse (Haiku: 0.5%, GPT: 0.0%).

“On ARC-Challenge [4] (an easier benchmark), both Haiku and GPT-4o-mini show dramatically lower flip rates (Haiku: 0.512 → 0.179, d = -1.13;GPT: 0.458 → 0.161, d = -1.07)and near-zero collapse (Haiku: 0.5%, GPT: 0.0%).”

• cites [4]Not matched

  Couldn’t be matched to a paper in Crossref, so it can’t be checked.

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: ARC-Challenge is an easier benchmark.

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

Round 1 majority-change rate is even higher on this slice (ρ=+0.986).

“Round 1 majority-change rate is even higher on this slice (ρ=+0.986),as expected for a runtime trajectory score.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

The six near-complete additional OpenRouter alpha-channel lanes all preserve AA>AS.

“The six near-complete additional lanes all preserve AA>AS.”

May combine two claims.

Gemini 3-flash (S/A=-0.08) provides a second low-S/A 200-debate sanity row, with low collapse at 0.5% and a correction-to-collapse ratio of 2.0.

“Gemini 3-flash (S/A = -0.08)provides a second low-S/A 200-debate sanity row, with low collapse at 0.5% and a correction-to-collapse ratio of 2.0.”

May combine two claims.

The realized N=14 rerun gives point Spearman +0.8295 and median latent rank correlation +0.8022, with 95% interval [+0.7099, +0.8725] and Pr(r>0)=1.000 over 20,000 bootstrap draws.

“The realized N =14 rerun gives point Spearman +0.8295 and median latent rank correlation +0.8022, with 95% interval [+0.7099, +0.8725] and Pr(r>0)=1.000over 20,000 bootstrap draws (seed 20260427).”

• Also stated in: § C.7 Specification Curve and Errors-in-Variables · plain

  “The realized N =14 rerun gives point Spearman +0.8295 and median latent rank correlation +0.8022, 95% interval [+0.7099, +0.8725], Pr(r>0)=1.000.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

Clipping the displayed intervals to the admissible [0,100]% range leaves both coverage counts unchanged.

“Clipping the displayed intervals to the admissible [0, 100]% range leaves both coverage counts unchanged.”

May combine two claims.

The held-out-family predictive check gives predicted-vs-observed Spearman +0.821 (p=0.023), 80% prediction intervals cover 5/7 families, 95% intervals cover 6/7, and mean absolute rank error 0.857.

“The diagnostic supports a ranking interpretation but not a calibrated forecast: predictedvs.-observedSpearman is +0.821 (p=0.023),80% prediction intervals cover 5/7 families, 95% intervals cover 6/7, and the mean absolute rank error is 0.857.”

May combine two claims.

Across all three day pairs, the 20 shared question-level mean-α values have Spearman 1.000, mean absolute delta 0.0000, max absolute delta 0.0000, and zero initial-answer majority changes.

“Across all three day pairs, the 20 shared question-level mean-α values have Spearman 1.000, mean absolute delta 0.0000, max absolute delta 0.0000, and zero initial-answer majority changes.”

May combine two claims.

Leave-one-family-out on the family-mean table has worst case ρ=+0.8286; dropping any of Anthropic, DeepSeek, Google, or OpenAI gives +0.829; dropping Meta gives +1.000; dropping Phi or Qwen gives +0.943.

“Leave-one-familyout on the family-mean table has worst case ρ=+0.8286:dropping any of Anthropic, DeepSeek, Google, or OpenAI gives +0.829 because those rows occupy the low-collapse rank cluster; dropping Meta gives +1.000; dropping Phi or Qwen gives +0.943.”

May combine two claims.

OpenAI models show the strongest channel manipulation effects (mean d=0.82) with prominent channel substitution.

“OpenAI models show the strongest channel manipulation effects (mean d = 0.82) with prominent channel substitution.”

May combine two claims.

Dropping both Meta and Qwen leaves the remaining five families strictly monotone, ρ=+1.000 (exact two-sided p=0.0167 over 5! permutations).

“Dropping both Meta (the visible upper-tail inversion) and Qwen (the multi-row upper-tail family) leaves the remaining five families strictly monotone, ρ=+1.000(exact two-sided p=0.0167 over 5! permutations).”

May combine two claims.

Both mean and median family aggregation over the seven retained families give ρ=+0.8929; exact permutation over all 7! family-label assignments gives two-sided p=0.0123.

“Both mean and median aggregation over the seven retained families give ρ=+0.8929;exact permutation over all 7! family-label assignments gives two-sided p=0.0123.”

May combine two claims.

Within every day of the three-day Gemini Flash-Lite panel there are zero initial-answer instabilities, mean/max within-question α range 0.0000/0.0000, and 4.38% probe post-answer parse-None rate.

“Within every day there are zero initial-answer instabilities, mean/max within-question α range 0.0000/0.0000,and 4.38% probe post-answer parse-None rate.”

May combine two claims.

The high-accuracy Google/xAI lanes have very low observed R4 collapse (zero or one collapse among 145-167 initially-correct pluralities), while still producing nonzero corrections.

“The highaccuracy Google/xAI lanes have very low observed R4 collapse (zero or one collapse among 145-167 initially-correct pluralities), while still producing nonzero corrections.”

May combine two claims.

Across 100 debates in the Gemini 3.1 Flash-Lite 50+50 check, initial-majority accuracy is 73.0% and final-majority accuracy is 75.0%; there is only 1 collapse (1/73=1.4% conditional collapse) and 3 corrections.

“The Gemini 3.1 Flash-Lite 50+50 check is not a powered transfer test: across 100 debates, initial-majority accuracy is 73.0% and final-majority accuracy is 75.0%;there is only 1 collapse (1/73=1.4% conditional collapse) and 3 corrections.”

May combine two claims.

Qwen3-32B has probe α tot=0.6767 over 1,800 alpha rows, matched to 200 debated questions; in those debates initial-majority accuracy improves from 36.5% to 52.0%, with 8/73 at-risk initial-correct majorities collapsing (10.96%) and 39/127 initially-wrong majorities corrected (30.71%).

“The paired slice is complete: probe α tot =0.6767 over 1,800 alpha rows (200 questions × 3 conditions × 3 agents), matched to the same 200 debated questions with no duplicate question rows.In those debates, initial-majority accuracy improves from 36.5% to 52.0%, with 8/73 at-risk initial-correct majorities collapsing (10.96%) and 39/127 initially-wrong majorities corrected (30.71%).”

May combine two claims.

All 27 specification-curve cells return ρ>0 on the N=9 cohort with median +0.62.

“All 27 cells return ρ>0 on the N =9 cohort with median +0.62”

May combine two claims.

Alternative taxonomies preserve the positive association: splitting Qwen into 3/3.5/3.6 generations gives ρ=+0.883 over 9 groups; merging Phi and Gemma into a small-dense group gives ρ=+0.929 over 7 groups; applying both gives ρ=+0.933 over 9 groups.

“Alternative taxonomies preserve the positive association: splitting Qwen into 3 / 3.5 / 3.6 generations gives ρ=+0.883 over 9 groups; merging Phi and Gemma into a small-dense group gives ρ=+0.929 over 7 groups; applying both choices gives ρ=+0.933 over 9 groups.”

May combine two claims.

On GPT-4o-mini, where collapse is already rare (2.0%), all four candidates (Standard, Shielded, ACC, DRS) sit within ±1.5pp of each other and none robustly beats Standard.

“On GPT-4o-mini, where collapse is already rare (2.0%), all four candidates (Standard, Shielded, ACC, DRS) sit within ±1.5pp of each other and none robustly beats Standard.”

May combine two claims.

On Phi-4-mini, DisagreementGate is 55.7/2.6, DRS is 58.3/7.3, and ACC is 59.9/4.7.

“On Phi-4-mini, DisagreementGate is 55.7/2.6,DRS is 58.3/7.3, and ACC is 59.9/4.7.”

May combine two claims.

Private revision reduces wrong-answer collapses in every setting, with intervals below zero in eleven, but raises correct-to-tied transitions in all twelve, and corrections decrease in every setting.

“It reduces wrong-answer collapses in every setting, with intervals below zero in eleven, but raises correct-to-tied transitions in all twelve, and corrections decrease in every setting.”

May combine two claims.

Round 1 is not sufficient: 18.6% of collapses first appear in Round 2 and 22.5% in Round 3, while some debates later correct a Round 1 wrong majority.

“Most importantly for policy, Round 1 is not sufficient: 18.6% of collapses first appear in Round 2 and 22.5% in Round 3, while some debates later correct a Round 1 wrong majority.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

F3 floor of -0.02, McNemar discordant counts 0/1 (p=1.0), Spearman perm.p=0.78 for Qwen3.5-9B.

“F3 floor of -0.02, McNemar discordant counts 0/1 (p=1.0),Spearman perm.p=0.78.”

May combine two claims.

As a weaker same-trace sanity check on the available 1,255 replay cohort, DisagreementGate is also net-negative: 63 collapses prevented, 104 corrections lost, net -41 (-3.27pp).

“As a weaker same-trace sanity check on the available 1,255 replay cohort, DisagreementGate is also net-negative: 63 collapses prevented, 104 corrections lost, net -41 (-3.27pp).”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: The 1,255-trace replay cohort is representative of the 6,525-debate LOMO cohort for the DisagreementGate sanity check.

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

The observed collapse rate is 7.98%.

“Posterior predictive check: observed collapse rate 7.98%, replicate mean matches; PPC one-sided p=0.5426.”

May combine two claims.

Qwen3.6-27B-FP8 clears the F3-floor gate despite its full-ladder Spearman being underpowered (perm.p=0.247).

“Notably Qwen3.6-27B-FP8clears the F3-floor gate despite its full-ladder Spearman being underpowered (perm.p=0.247)”

May combine two claims.

On Haiku (200 development questions), DisagreementGate yields 73.0% accuracy / 7.0% collapse and DRS yields 74.5%/5.0%, both worse than ACC's 78.0%/1.5%.

“On Haiku (200 development questions), DisagreementGate yields 73.0% accuracy / 7.0% collapse and DRS yields 74.5%/5.0%,both worse than ACC's 78.0%/1.5%.”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim. May combine two claims.

3,145 debates across 4 OSS models with per-round trace data: Phi-4-mini, Qwen3-4B, Llama-3.1-8B, Qwen3-8B.

“3,145 debates across 4 OSS models with per-round trace data: Phi-4-mini, Qwen3-4B, Llama-3.1-8B,Qwen3-8B.”

May combine two claims.

Under expected tie scoring the differences lie between -1.62 and +0.38 points and seven intervals remain below zero.

“Under expected tie scoring the differences lie between -1.62 and +0.38 points and seven intervals remain below zero, so much of the binary loss comes from counting ties as wrong.”

May combine two claims.

The F3-floor magnitudes are statistically separable from zero on both usable models: Qwen3.5-4B at +20 pp (McNemar p=0.003) and Qwen3.6-27B-FP8 at +10 pp (McNemar p=0.031).

“The F3-floor magnitudes are statistically separable from zero on both usable models: Qwen3.5-4B at +20 pp (McNemar p=0.003) and Qwen3.6-27B-FP8 at +10 pp (McNemar p=0.031).”

May combine two claims.

Collapse onset remains early: R1 accounts for 40/75 collapses (53.3%), followed by R2:10, R3:11, and R4:14.

“Collapse onset remains early: R1 accounts for 40/75 collapses (53.3%), followed by R2: 10, R3: 11, and R4: 14.”

May combine two claims.

A prompt control on Qwen3-8B and Granite-4.1-8B (two runs per arm) loses 2.48 and 2.43 binary accuracy points relative to a contemporaneous peer arm, and both differences remain significant after Holm correction over four planned contrasts, but it does not reliably reduce total collapse.

“A prompt control on Qwen3-8B and Granite-4.1-8B(two runs per arm) replaces the debate framing with a neutral self-review prompt.It still loses 2.48 and 2.43 binary accuracy points relative to a contemporaneous peer arm, and both differences remain significant after Holm correction over four planned contrasts, but it does not reliably reduce total collapse.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

αtot = 0.6767 for Qwen3-32B holdout.

“αtot | 0.6767”

May combine two claims.

On the seven-source primary cohort (1,255 usable debates), always freezing prevents 94 collapses but loses 124 corrections (-2.39pp).

“On the seven-source primary cohort (1,255 usable debates), always freezing prevents 94 collapses but loses 124 corrections (-2.39pp).”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

Qwen3-32B local-vLLM holdout has 1,800 alpha rows over 200 questions with complete 3×3 design.

“Alpha rows / questions | 1,800 / 200 | complete 3×3 design”

May combine two claims.

On 1,200 debates in the post-A6 replication, 662 have an initially correct majority, 75 collapse (11.3% conditional), and 144 correct an initially wrong majority; final accuracy is 60.9%.

“On 1,200 debates, 662 have an initially correct majority, 75 collapse (11.3% conditional), and 144 correct an initially wrong majority; final accuracy is 60.9%.”

May combine two claims.

Qwen3.5-9B's p k trajectory across k=0,...,8 is {0.04, 0.06, 0.08, 0.02, 0.02, 0.04, 0.04, 0.06, 0.02}, flat at low magnitude with no graded response to ladder rung.

“Q3.5-9B's p k trajectory across k=0, . . ., 8 is {0.04, 0.06, 0.08, 0.02, 0.02, 0.04, 0.04, 0.06, 0.02}, flat at low magnitude with no graded response to ladder rung.”

May combine two claims.

In a smaller reviewer-requested zero-retune transfer check on Qwen3-4B (50 development questions, 300 held-out test questions), ACC is also null (p = 0.743 for accuracy, p = 1.000 for collapse).

“In a smaller reviewer-requested zero-retune transfer check on Qwen3-4B (50 development questions, 300 held-out test questions), ACC is also null (p = 0.743 for accuracy, p = 1.000 for collapse).”

May combine two claims.

Harness-detected anti-monotonicity in 1/3 pilot models, statistically indistinguishable from null (Spearman perm.p=0.78, McNemar discordant n=1).

“harness-detected anti-monotonicity in 1/3 pilot models, statistically indistinguishable from null (Spearman perm.p=0.78,McNemar discordant n=1)”

May combine two claims.

Pooled with legacy/partial traces, R1 remains the largest localized onset bucket (40/77 collapses overall, with 15 R4 and one unlocalized).

“Pooled with legacy/partial traces, R1 remains the largest localized onset bucket (40/77 collapses overall, with 15 R4 and one unlocalized).”

May combine two claims.

In the 2×2 debate experiment (N = 100 questions per cell), the independence prompt does not reduce collapse for either Haiku (McNemar p = 0.593) or GPT-4o-mini (p = 1.000).

“In the 2×2 debate experiment (N = 100 questions per cell), the independence prompt does not reduce collapse for either Haiku (McNemar p = 0.593) or GPT-4o-mini (p = 1.000).”

The quote only partly states this claim.

In the sealed pre-A6 N=9 rank-correlation cross-check, probe α_tot has Spearman ρ = +0.78 (95% CI [+0.25, +0.95], p=0.013) with conditional collapse.

“Probe αtot (8-probe total) ⋆ | +0.78 | [+0.25, +0.95] | 0.013 | n/a”

May combine two claims.

On the original 800-question test, Phi-4-mini showed a modest positive trend (+1.25pp accuracy, -1.12pp collapse relative to Standard), but neither paired McNemar test was significant (p = 0.485 for accuracy, p = 0.336 for collapse).

“On the original 800-question test, Phi-4-mini showed a modest positive trend (+1.25pp accuracy, -1.12pp collapse relative to Standard), but neither paired McNemar test was significant (p = 0.485 for accuracy, p = 0.336 for collapse).”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

The intercept is -4.254 with 95% interval [-5.46, -2.96].

“Intercept -4.254 [-5.46, -2.96].”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

251 collapses (7.98%); 1,509 unique questions.

“251 collapses (7.98%); 1,509 unique questions.”

May combine two claims.

The intuitive R1-majority-changed rule gates 23.2% of debates and is still net-negative: 56 collapses prevented, 69 corrections lost, -1.04pp accuracy change.

“The intuitive R1-majority-changed rule gates 23.2% of debates and is still net-negative: 56 collapses prevented, 69 corrections lost, -1.04pp accuracy change.”

May combine two claims.

The positive trend did not replicate: ACC reduces accuracy by 1.93pp and increases collapse by 0.40pp (p = 0.106 for accuracy, p = 0.656 for collapse).

“The positive trend did not replicate: ACC reduces accuracy by 1.93pp and increases collapse by 0.40pp (p = 0.106 for accuracy, p = 0.656 for collapse).”

May combine two claims.

They prevent only 2 collapses while losing 31 corrections in held-out replay.

“preventing only 2 collapses while losing 31 corrections in held-out replay”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: The aggregate Table 37 ledger is sufficient to evaluate the probe-gated freeze policy without the row-level decision matrix.

May combine two claims.

On Haiku, neither Shielded nor ACC beats Standard debate (p = 0.188 for accuracy, p = 1.000 for collapse).

“On Haiku, neither Shielded nor ACC beats Standard debate (p = 0.188 for accuracy, p = 1.000 for collapse).”

May combine two claims.

Observed collapse follows the screen in 13 pairs, initial accuracy in 12, and neither in one tie.

“Observed collapse follows the screen in 13 pairs, initial accuracy in 12, and neither in one tie.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

The temperature field is missing from the saved probe records of several later rows.

“The temperature field is missing from the saved probe records of several later rows.”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: The missing temperature field in saved probe records does not invalidate the screen results.

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

The Gemini-3.1-Pro row has about 11% missing answers in both probe revisions and debate answers.

“The Gemini-3.1-Prorow has about 11% missing answers in both probe revisions and debate answers.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

Excluding the four leaves 20/120 collapses and 19/74 corrections, so the signed net changes from +1 to -1.

“Excluding the four leaves 20/120 collapses and 19/74 corrections, so the signed net changes from +1 to -1.”

May combine two claims.

Dropping each Qwen row in turn keeps the model-row correlation between 0.809 and 0.875 and leaves the family estimate at ρ = 0.893.

“Dropping each Qwen row in turn keeps the model-row correlation between 0.809 and 0.875 and leaves the family estimate at ρ = 0.893.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

Dropping the Tencent row gives ρ = 0.948 (exact p = 0.00013) and a partial ρ = 0.931 (p = 0.000265).

“dropping it gives ρ = 0.948 (exact p = 0.00013) and a partial ρ = 0.931 (p = 0.000265)”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

Three mixed-model panels answer the same 200 MMLU-Pro questions and produce both transition directions.

“Three mixed-model panels answer the same 200 MMLU-Pro questions and produce both transition directions.”

May combine two claims.

In 20 to 28 of 200 initial states no answer has a unique plurality, so the results depend on the aggregation rule: treating such states as undecided and wrong changes the three nets from +14, +6 and 0 to +22, +8 and +7.

“In 20 to 28 of 200 initial states no answer has a unique plurality, so the results depend on the aggregation rule: treating such states as undecided and wrong changes the three nets from +14, +6 and 0 to +22, +8 and +7.”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: The alphabetic tie rule is an appropriate way to resolve initial states without a unique plurality.

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

The two arms sampled their initial answers independently, so only the 162 questions whose initial-majority labels match are paired; on them, peer-only and self-only correct outcomes are 3 and 3 (exact McNemar p = 1.0).

“The two arms sampled their initial answers independently, so only the 162 questions whose initial-majority labels match are paired; on them, peer-only and self-only correct outcomes are 3 and 3 (exact McNemar p = 1.0).”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

A GLM-4.6 row with provider reasoning disabled shows hidden turnover: accuracy moves from 76.0% to 75.5% while the ledger records 6/152 collapses and 5/48 corrections.

“A GLM-4.6 row with provider reasoning disabled shows hidden turnover: accuracy moves from 76.0% to 75.5% while the ledger records 6/152 collapses and 5/48 corrections.”

May combine two claims.

Ten unadjusted tests have p < 0.05 (screen 4, initial accuracy 6); after Holm correction over the 26 tests, eight remain (screen 2, initial accuracy 6), mostly within the Qwen family.

“Ten unadjusted tests have p < 0.05 (screen 4, initial accuracy 6); after Holm correction over the 26 tests, eight remain (screen 2, initial accuracy 6), mostly within the Qwen family.”

May combine two claims.

In the Mistral Small 4 row of Table 30, four of the 198 questions have no valid initial majority and are counted as initially wrong; two of them end correct.

“In the Mistral Small 4 row of Table 30, four of the 198 questions have no valid initial majority and are counted as initially wrong; two of them end correct.”

May combine two claims.

The motivating Llama-3.1-8B/Qwen3-4B reordering has unadjusted p = 0.0033 but does not survive correction.

“The motivating Llama-3.1-8B/Qwen3-4Breordering has unadjusted p = 0.0033 but does not survive correction.”

May combine two claims.

Early disagreement can precede both harmful cascades and useful recovery.

“where early disagreement can precede both harmful cascades and useful recovery.”

May combine two claims.

In multi-agent LLM debate, the same discussion can rescue an initially wrong majority or destroy an initially correct one.

“The same discussion that can correct an initially wrong majority can also collapse an initially correct majority into a wrong consensus, without an external adversary, tool output, or new evidence.”

May combine two claims.

The screen is a distinct secondary signal for prioritizing trace collection, not a better selector.

“The screen is therefore a distinct secondary signal for prioritizing trace collection, not a better selector.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

The study's scope is narrow: homogeneous same-model, closed-book MCQ debate.

“Scope is narrow: homogeneous same-model, closed-book MCQ debate.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

The April 19 pre-registration locked an N = 18 model-row Spearman extension as the confirmatory analysis.

“The April 19 pre-registration locked an N =18 model-row Spearman extension as the confirmatory analysis.”

May combine two claims.

All MCQ answer extraction, collapse/correction labels, and onset labels are rule-based, with no LLM-judge fallback.

“There is no LLM-judge fallback: all MCQ answer extraction, collapse/correction labels, and onset labels are rule-based.”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: The rule-based parser and alphabetic tie-breaking produce transition labels accurate enough for the headline collapse/correction counts.

Classified as probably not a substantial claim. May combine two claims.

The screen is protocol-bound triage, not a capability-free property, per-question oracle, or controller.

“The screen is protocol-bound triage, not a capability-free property, per-question oracle, or controller.”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim.

The ledger keeps comparison auditable when user-stated utility weights change which controller is selected.

“The ledger keeps that comparison auditable when user-stated utility weights change which controller is selected.”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim.

Round 3 being larger than Round 2 is not a contradiction because onset is the first correct-to-wrong majority switch.

“Round 3 being larger than Round 2 is not a contradiction: onset is the first correct-to-wrong majority switch”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim.

The family-level analysis avoids treating correlated variants as independent.

“This family-level analysis avoids treating correlated variants as independent.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

For the same model, the selection procedure is deterministic given the random probe seed.

“for the same model, the procedure is deterministic given the random probe seed.”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim.

These results bound, rather than settle, the comparison with compute-matched solo reasoning.

“These results bound, rather than settle, the comparison with compute-matched solo reasoning.”

May combine two claims.

The S/A bootstrap intervals support the selection-sensitivity statement: full-pool S/A estimates stay within the bootstrap ranges, so the high-FR restriction sharpens measurement without changing the qualitative pool-check conclusion.

“These intervals support the selection-sensitivity statement in Section B.1: full-pool S/A estimates stay within the bootstrap ranges, so the high-FR restriction sharpens measurement without changing the qualitative pool-check conclusion.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

The primary cohort does not isolate reasoning mode or effort, and one of its rows (DeepSeek V4 Flash) ran with provider reasoning enabled.

“The primary cohort does not isolate reasoning mode or effort, and one of its rows (DeepSeek V4 Flash) ran with provider reasoning enabled.”

May combine two claims.

MMLU-Pro is primary; ARC, TruthfulQA, GPQA, and OpenRouter/Gemini rows do not establish benchmark transfer or cover heterogeneous judge-debater systems, tool use, retrieval, free-form generation, rubric-or judge-scored answers, or agent workflows that gather evidence over longer contexts rather than static choices.

“MMLU-Pro is primary; ARC, TruthfulQA, GPQA, and OpenRouter/Gemini rows do not establish benchmark transfer or cover heterogeneous judge-debater systems, tool use, retrieval, free-form generation, rubric-or judge-scored answers, or agent workflows that gather evidence over longer contexts rather than static choices.”

May combine two claims.

When every initial and final majority is defined, corrections minus collapses divided by n equals final-minus-initial majority accuracy, so the ledger decomposes accuracy rather than replacing it.

“When every initial and final majority is defined, corrections minus collapses divided by n equals final-minus-initial majority accuracy, so the ledger decomposes accuracy rather than replacing it.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

Mixed-model panels and GSM8K rows added after review are feasibility checks, not transfer evidence.

“Mixed-model panels and GSM8K rows added after review are feasibility checks, not transfer evidence”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim. May combine two claims.

Because the cohort contains related variants, the family-aggregated Spearman exact test is primary, with the N = 14 model-row statistic as sensitivity.

“Because the cohort contains related variants, the familyaggregated Spearman exact test is primary, with the N =14 model-row statistic as sensitivity.”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim.

The family-aggregated exact test is a design-aware non-independence correction for the realized cohort.

“We therefore report the family-aggregated exact test as a design-aware non-independence correction for the realized cohort”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

Each S/A bootstrap interval resamples question-level S/A estimates within a model; it is a within-row measurement interval, not a cross-model hypothesis test.

“Each interval resamples question-level S/A estimates within a model; it is therefore a within-row measurement interval, not a cross-model hypothesis test.”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim.

This is a realized-cohort correction to the inferential unit, not a claim that the originally targeted N = 18 model-row primary was completed unchanged.

“This is a realized-cohort correction to the inferential unit, not a claim that the originally targeted N =18 model-row primary was completed unchanged.”

May combine two claims.

The adjusted evidence supports triage and cost allocation, not a capability-adjusted predictor.

“The adjusted evidence supports triage and cost allocation, not a capability-adjusted predictor.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

The work uses only public benchmark questions; no human-subjects data, personally identifying information, or crowd-worker labels were collected, so IRB review was not required.

“The work uses only public benchmark questions; no human-subjects data, personally identifying information, or crowd-worker labels were collected, so IRB review was not required.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

Qwen3-32B is valid in the sealed pre-A6 vintage; its exclusion applies only to the later post-A6 cohort, where the archived lane used the wrong question pool.

“Qwen3-32B is valid in this sealed vintage; its exclusion applies only to the later post-A6 cohort, where the archived lane used the wrong question pool.”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim.

No item is selected, dropped, or reweighted using its debate transition label.

“Selected items may later be debated as part of the model-row audit, but no item is selected, dropped, or reweighted using its debate transition label.”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim.

The paper does not claim a strict N = 14 one-agent validation without recovering per-agent raw rows for sealed lanes.

“so we do not claim a strict N =14 one-agent validation without recovering per-agent raw rows for sealed lanes.”

May combine two claims.

The selection is computed entirely on probe behavior, never on debate outcomes, so it is outcome-blind with respect to the targets reported in Table 16.

“The selection is computed entirely on probe behavior, never on debate outcomes (collapse, correction, or any downstream label), so it is outcome-blind with respect to the targets reported in Table 16.”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim.

The α_tot is the pre-specified rank measurement.

“Total α tot pools the two and is the pre-specified rank measurement (Table 23).”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

Exact per-debate Round 1 and strict matched-τ DisagreementGate matrices remain gated, so those results are diagnostic rather than primary and provider reruns may drift.

“Exact per-debate Round 1 and strict matched-τ DisagreementGate matrices remain gated, so those results are diagnostic rather than primary and provider reruns may drift.”

May combine two claims.

The high unlabeled rate is concentrated in long Qwen traces, so the audit does not replace gated full-trace validation; it bounds fallback sensitivity where strict parsing still yields labels.

“The high unlabeled rate is concentrated in long Qwen traces, so this audit does not replace gated full-trace validation; it bounds fallback sensitivity where strict parsing still yields labels”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

Held-out-family diagnostics test rank discipline, not calibrated forecasting.

“Held-out-family diagnostics test rank discipline, not calibrated forecasting.”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim.

The LOMO probe-gated freeze classifier, threshold τ, and freeze mode are tuned on held-in models and then evaluated frozen on the held-out model.

“the classifier, τ , and the freeze mode are tuned on held-in models and then evaluated frozen on the held-out model.”

May combine two claims.

Channel separability varies with both model family and instruction-tuning approach.

“suggesting that channel separability varies with both model family and instruction-tuning approach.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

Five robustness checks were pre-registered before the cohort-extension data-collection round.

“We pre-registered five robustness checks (see §6 of the supplementary pre-registration document) before the cohort-extension data-collection round”

May combine two claims.

The held-out-family predictive check supports a ranking interpretation but not a calibrated forecast.

“The diagnostic supports a ranking interpretation but not a calibrated forecast: predictedvs.-observedSpearman is +0.821 (p=0.023),80% prediction intervals cover 5/7 families, 95% intervals cover 6/7, and the mean absolute rank error is 0.857.”

May combine two claims.

These results confirm the preregistered prediction and illustrate healthy debate dynamics in this low-S/A held-out setting.

“These results confirm the preregistered prediction and illustrate healthy debate dynamics in this low-S/A held-out setting: rapid early convergence, productive revisions concentrated in early rounds, and collapses confined to rare late-round cascades.”

May combine two claims.

The family aggregation is not a proof of benchmark-general robustness, but it bounds the realized-family imbalance directly.

“The family aggregation is therefore not a proof of benchmark-general robustness, but it bounds the realized-family imbalance directly.”

May combine two claims.

High revisability can produce measurable collapses and many productive corrections in the same scaffold, so mitigation must preserve corrections rather than freezing revision wholesale.

“Unlike the small Mistral slice above, this run is net accuracy-positive; it therefore reinforces the control lesson rather than weakening it: high revisability can produce measurable collapses and many productive corrections in the same scaffold, so mitigation must preserve corrections rather than freezing revision wholesale.”

May combine two claims.

The social-pressure flip-rate proxy is not treated as an independent social mechanism score; the narrower social-over-solo lift is the cleaner conformity contrast, and it is not predictive.

“We therefore do not treat it as an independent social mechanism score; the narrower social-over-solo lift is the cleaner conformity contrast, and it is not predictive.”

May combine two claims.

A collapse-only metric would penalize debate without accounting for corrections, while final accuracy alone would hide which harmful transitions occurred.

“This reinforces the signed-utility lesson rather than the model-rank lesson: a collapse-only metric would penalize debate without accounting for corrections, while final accuracy alone would hide which harmful transitions occurred.”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim. May combine two claims.

Revision can create both harmful collapses and useful corrections, so interventions should be judged on both transitions.

“This is not a powered independent validation of monotone ranking, but it reinforces the control lesson: revision can create both harmful collapses and useful corrections, so interventions should be judged on both transitions.”

May combine two claims.

These runtime diagnostics are not replacements for the selection-time screen: they are measured only after initial or Round 1 answers have been sampled, cover only three families in the current raw-trace slice, and leave the trace-only partial ρ α|init-disagree=+0.196 underpowered (p=0.752).

“These are important runtime diagnostics, but not replacements for the selection-time screen: they are measured only after initial or Round 1 answers have been sampled, cover only three families in the current raw-trace slice, and leave the trace-only partial ρ α|init-disagree =+0.196 underpowered (p=0.752).”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

The clustered delta-AUC recomputation is unavailable in the open tier.

“The audit record therefore marks the clustered delta-AUC recomputation as unavailable in the open tier rather than recomputing a different estimand from newer trace files.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

The EIV-propagated calculation should be read as a Jeffreys conditional-collapse propagation, not a fully calibrated forecasting model.

“This keeps α tot fixed and therefore should be read as a Jeffreys conditional-collapse propagation, not a fully calibrated forecasting model.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

The family-level partial is used as a capability-pressure sensitivity, not as a separate confirmatory test.

“We therefore use this as a capability-pressure sensitivity, not as a separate confirmatory test.”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim. May combine two claims.

α tot is kept as the pragmatic triage measurement and α adv/α cor are treated as a descriptive decomposition rather than a standalone leaderboard.

“We therefore keep α tot as the pragmatic triage measurement and treat α adv /α cor as a descriptive decomposition rather than a standalone leaderboard.”

May combine two claims.

The small panel supports same-snapshot stability for one closed API lane; it is not an input to the family-level association and does not bound future provider-side snapshot changes.

“This small panel supports same-snapshot stability for one closed API lane; it is not an input to the family-level association and does not bound future provider-side snapshot changes.”

May combine two claims.

The reduction is consistent with a general anchoring effect rather than selectively targeting one channel.

“consistent with a general anchoring effect rather than selectively targeting one channel”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing), S4 (based).

The oracle detect-revert row is an upper bound.

“the oracle detect-revert row is an upper bound”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

Convergence: all R=1.00, no divergences after non-centered reparameterization, ESS bulk ≥1,013.

“Convergence: all R=1.00, no divergences after non-centered reparameterization, ESS bulk ≥1,013.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing), S4 (based). May combine two claims.

Strict quality control requires at most 2% missing answers, truncations, and unclosed reasoning blocks; rows marked † pass only an amended criterion that separates explicit abstentions from unparsed complete responses.

“Strict quality control requires at most 2% missing answers, truncations, and unclosed reasoning blocks; rows marked † pass only an amended criterion that separates explicit abstentions from unparsed complete responses.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

The G=7 association is the primary analysis, and GPQA rows are post-hoc stress checks.

“The G=7 association is the primary analysis, and GPQA rows are post-hoc stress checks.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

Adding the observed Round 1 majority state to pre-debate features can only improve an ideal Bayes score if Round 1 carries information about the final collapse label.

“Adding the observed Round 1 majority state to pre-debate features can only improve an ideal Bayes score if Round 1 carries information about the final collapse label.”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim.

The two Phi-4-mini tests use disjoint question sets.

“the two Phi-4-mini tests use disjoint question sets”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim.

Converting that information into a deployable policy that wins under frozen evaluation remains the open problem.

“converting that information into a deployable policy that wins under frozen evaluation remains the open problem”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing). May combine two claims.

In a toy three-agent MCQ panel conditioned on the initial majority being correct, if each agent independently abandons the correct answer with probability α_adv, then the probability of a wrong Round 1 majority is bounded above by 3α_adv^2 - 2α_adv^3, monotone in α_adv on [0,1].

“In a toy three-agent MCQ panel, condition on the initial majority being correct and suppose each agent independently abandons the correct answer with probability α adv .A wrong Round 1 majority then requires at least two agents to abandon the correct answer and coordinate on a wrong option, so a loose upper envelope is Pr(M (1) ̸ =C) ≤ 3α 2 adv -2α 3 adv , monotone in α adv on [0, 1].”

• AssumptionThe authors state this as an assumption: In the toy three-agent MCQ panel, each agent independently abandons the correct answer with probability α_adv.

Classified as probably not a substantial claim.

We treat R1 as a diagnostic substrate, not a standalone deployable gate.

“We therefore treat R1 as a diagnostic substrate, not a standalone deployable gate.”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: The aggregate Table 37 ledger is sufficient to evaluate the probe-gated freeze policy without the row-level decision matrix.

Classified as probably not a substantial claim. May combine two claims.

ACC is selected on pooled development data, then evaluated without retuning.

“ACC is selected on pooled development data, then evaluated without retuning”

Classified as probably not a substantial claim.

The floor metric isolates the refusal-rate shift on the affected rungs without staking the claim on rank-monotone behavior across all 9 rungs.

“the floor metric isolates the refusal-rate shift on the affected rungs without staking the claim on rank-monotone behavior across all 9 rungs”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing), S4 (based).

The wrong-answer coincidence factor is not uniform because a plausible but wrong argument can steer multiple agents to the same distractor.

“The wrong-answer coincidence factor is not uniform because a plausible but wrong argument can steer multiple agents to the same distractor.”

Probably not a substantial claim: may not pass S3 (load-bearing).

The posterior predictive check one-sided p-value is 0.5426.

“Posterior predictive check: observed collapse rate 7.98%, replicate mean matches; PPC one-sided p=0.5426.”

May combine two claims.