Student or educator? Sign up with your school email and get 6 months of Pro free.
CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 271 of the 271 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

The multiscale wisdom of the body: collective intelligence as a tractable interface for next-generation biomedicine

Open access
Levin, Michael · 2025 · BioEssays

Abstract

The dominant paradigm in biomedicine focuses on genetically‐specified components of cells and their biochemical dynamics, emphasizing bottom‐up emergence of complexity. Here, I explore the biomedical implications of a complementary emerging field: diverse intelligence. Using tools from behavioral science and multiscale neuroscience, we can study development, regenerative repair, and cancer suppression as behaviors of a collective intelligence of cells navigating the spaces of possible morphologies and transcriptional and physiological states. A focus on the competencies of living material—from molecular to organismal scales—reveals a new landscape for interventions. Such top‐down approaches take advantage of the memories and homeodynamic goal‐seeking behavior of cells and tissues, offering the same massive advantages in biomedicine and bioengineering that reprogrammable hardware has provided information technologies. The bioelectric networks that bind individual cells toward large‐scale anatomical goals are an especially tractable interface to organ‐level plasticity, and tools to modulate them already exist. This suggests a research program to understand and tame the software of life for therapeutic gain by understanding the many examples of basal cognition that operate throughout living bodies.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1002/bies.202400196

Cites

271 of 271 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

FIGURE 1 Living substrate on the spectrum of persuadability. (A) Systems fall on a “spectrum of persuadability,” which defines the kind of tools to which their prediction and control are amenable. Here are shown just four representative regions on that spectrum. Simple systems are only tractable to physical rewiring: changes of the hardware, which means that the engineer must understand every element and all of their emergent system‐level interactions. Homeostatic circuits enable simple goal states, and can be manipulated via the tools of cybernetics and control theory: rewriting their setpoints and letting the system achieve them. What is needed for these kinds of systems is knowledge of where and how the setpoints are stored and interpreted. More complex systems can learn, enabling the tools of behavioral science (e.g., behavior‐shaping) to achieve outcomes that are too complicated to be implemented directly. In these systems, the learning interface provides an abstraction layer that hides the underlying detail (which is managed by the learning algorithm), enabling the effective training of such systems without knowledge of the mechanisms under the hood. The far right end of the spectrum belongs to advanced symbol manipulating systems with complex meta‐cognitive circuits that can change their own goals, choose novel problems to solve, and otherwise exert their own self‐modifying agency to various degrees. Overall, moving rightward across the spectrum, the amount of micromanagement needed (or even possible) falls, moving from bottom‐up to top‐down control strategies, and the ability to depend on the system for autonomous problem‐solving rises. Crucially, what also rises is the importance of taking the perspective of the system itself (what does it know, what are its memories, and how does it make decisions) in order to have good predictive and control capabilities, while the need to understand every molecular component falls. Image courtesy of Jeremy Guay of Peregrine Creative previously published in [18]. (B) Crucially, the position of any given system (e.g., single cells) on this spectrum is not a philosophical question but an empirical one, settled only by making hypotheses and determining what level of control they afford. Here is shown an example [23, 24] in which the standard approaches of behavioral science (in this case, associative learning) are applied to what seem initially to surely be low‐agency, mechanical systems: gene‐regulatory networks (B’). They are deterministic, small networks of molecules that up‐ and down‐regulate each other's activity, and are currently addressed in biomedicine and synbio research exclusively via hardware rewiring, for example, gene therapy and promoter editing. But taking seriously the idea that unexpected proto‐cognitive capacities (not merely complexity) can be emergent in simple systems enables an empirical test in which such networks are exposed to patterns of stimuli one would use to train an animal, revealing several kinds of learning (which does not require changes to the hardware) including Pavlovian conditioning. Image courtesy of Jeremy Guay of Peregrine Creative, previously published in [24].
FIGURE 1 Living substrate on the spectrum of persuadability. (A) Systems fall on a “spectrum of persuadability,” which defines the kind of tools to which their prediction and control are amenable. Here are shown just four representative regions on that spectrum. Simple systems are only tractable to physical rewiring: changes of the hardware, which means that the engineer must understand every element and all of their emergent system‐level interactions. Homeostatic circuits enable simple goal states, and can be manipulated via the tools of cybernetics and control theory: rewriting their setpoints and letting the system achieve them. What is needed for these kinds of systems is knowledge of where and how the setpoints are stored and interpreted. More complex systems can learn, enabling the tools of behavioral science (e.g., behavior‐shaping) to achieve outcomes that are too complicated to be implemented directly. In these systems, the learning interface provides an abstraction layer that hides the underlying detail (which is managed by the learning algorithm), enabling the effective training of such systems without knowledge of the mechanisms under the hood. The far right end of the spectrum belongs to advanced symbol manipulating systems with complex meta‐cognitive circuits that can change their own goals, choose novel problems to solve, and otherwise exert their own self‐modifying agency to various degrees. Overall, moving rightward across the spectrum, the amount of micromanagement needed (or even possible) falls, moving from bottom‐up to top‐down control strategies, and the ability to depend on the system for autonomous problem‐solving rises. Crucially, what also rises is the importance of taking the perspective of the system itself (what does it know, what are its memories, and how does it make decisions) in order to have good predictive and control capabilities, while the need to understand every molecular component falls. Image courtesy of Jeremy Guay of Peregrine Creative previously published in [18]. (B) Crucially, the position of any given system (e.g., single cells) on this spectrum is not a philosophical question but an empirical one, settled only by making hypotheses and determining what level of control they afford. Here is shown an example [23, 24] in which the standard approaches of behavioral science (in this case, associative learning) are applied to what seem initially to surely be low‐agency, mechanical systems: gene‐regulatory networks (B’). They are deterministic, small networks of molecules that up‐ and down‐regulate each other's activity, and are currently addressed in biomedicine and synbio research exclusively via hardware rewiring, for example, gene therapy and promoter editing. But taking seriously the idea that unexpected proto‐cognitive capacities (not merely complexity) can be emergent in simple systems enables an empirical test in which such networks are exposed to patterns of stimuli one would use to train an animal, revealing several kinds of learning (which does not require changes to the hardware) including Pavlovian conditioning. Image courtesy of Jeremy Guay of Peregrine Creative, previously published in [24].CC BY · PubMed Central
FIGURE 2 Unconventional intelligence. (A) Cognitive capacity lies on a spectrum [89] which spans from passive matter through diverse forms of active behavior with different degrees of causal linkage to past and future events. As one moves up the ladder, systems acquire more autonomy and require more consideration of their past and their internal model of the world (i.e., seeing the world from the system's perspective) to effectively control them. Image modified after [89]. (B) Anatomical outcomes are a combination of two fundamental processes. The more conventional and most often emphasized is feed‐forward (open‐loop) emergence of complexity: gene‐regulatory networks (GRNs) produce proteins which interact according to the laws of physics and eventually result in complex outcomes. However, a critically important and less often emphasized component is the ability of the system to activate effectors at the level of transcription and physiology to continuously reduce the error relative to the creature's target morphology. Image previously published in [90]. (C) An example of this anatomical homeostasis is seen in salamander limb regeneration, where an amputation anywhere along the axis causes cells to rapidly proliferate and undergo morphogenesis, stopping when (and only when) a “correct salamander limb” is complete. This closed‐loop process, which is context‐sensitive and most effectively described as a homeostatic loop with a specific setpoint, is fundamentally different than just emergence because it aims at a well‐defined, yet complex, goal state and specifically implies questions such as the mechanism of storage of the target morphology information and the degree of competency the system would have to reach its goal in the face of various different kinds of perturbations away from that setpoint. Image courtesy of Jeremy Guay of Peregrine Creative, previously published in [14]. (D) One powerful formalism for modeling the ability of systems to return to their setpoints, especially at higher levels along the hierarchy in (A), is through the concept of navigation of problem spaces. In this case, the anatomical morphospace is the latent space of possible shapes that can be built [91, 92]. For example, planarian species have different head shapes. Each specific head shape represents an attractor in morphospace, and cell collectives navigate the space to get to their correct species‐specific region if deviated by damage or undergoing embryogenesis. However, as with many kinds of autonomous navigational systems, the same hardware can occupy different attractors, and a genetically wild‐type planarian fragment can grow heads appropriate to different species of planaria [93, 94]. Image courtesy of Alexis Pietak, previously published in [94].
FIGURE 2 Unconventional intelligence. (A) Cognitive capacity lies on a spectrum [89] which spans from passive matter through diverse forms of active behavior with different degrees of causal linkage to past and future events. As one moves up the ladder, systems acquire more autonomy and require more consideration of their past and their internal model of the world (i.e., seeing the world from the system's perspective) to effectively control them. Image modified after [89]. (B) Anatomical outcomes are a combination of two fundamental processes. The more conventional and most often emphasized is feed‐forward (open‐loop) emergence of complexity: gene‐regulatory networks (GRNs) produce proteins which interact according to the laws of physics and eventually result in complex outcomes. However, a critically important and less often emphasized component is the ability of the system to activate effectors at the level of transcription and physiology to continuously reduce the error relative to the creature's target morphology. Image previously published in [90]. (C) An example of this anatomical homeostasis is seen in salamander limb regeneration, where an amputation anywhere along the axis causes cells to rapidly proliferate and undergo morphogenesis, stopping when (and only when) a “correct salamander limb” is complete. This closed‐loop process, which is context‐sensitive and most effectively described as a homeostatic loop with a specific setpoint, is fundamentally different than just emergence because it aims at a well‐defined, yet complex, goal state and specifically implies questions such as the mechanism of storage of the target morphology information and the degree of competency the system would have to reach its goal in the face of various different kinds of perturbations away from that setpoint. Image courtesy of Jeremy Guay of Peregrine Creative, previously published in [14]. (D) One powerful formalism for modeling the ability of systems to return to their setpoints, especially at higher levels along the hierarchy in (A), is through the concept of navigation of problem spaces. In this case, the anatomical morphospace is the latent space of possible shapes that can be built [91, 92]. For example, planarian species have different head shapes. Each specific head shape represents an attractor in morphospace, and cell collectives navigate the space to get to their correct species‐specific region if deviated by damage or undergoing embryogenesis. However, as with many kinds of autonomous navigational systems, the same hardware can occupy different attractors, and a genetically wild‐type planarian fragment can grow heads appropriate to different species of planaria [93, 94]. Image courtesy of Alexis Pietak, previously published in [94].CC BY · PubMed Central
FIGURE 3 Developmental bioelectricity: fundamental mechanisms. (A) Neurons form networks that can perform computations and guide behavior in 3D space because context‐sensitive ion channels enable each cell to set and modify a resting potential (voltage gradient across the membrane) which it may communicate to neighbors if the (also context‐sensitive) electric synapses—gap junctions—are sufficiently open. This enables the project of “neural decoding” (A’) in which the physiological conditions are read out and decoded to read out the memories, preferences, and other aspects of the internal cognitive states of the being implemented by the neural network. (B) This machinery is evolutionarily ancient, with all body cells having ion channels and most having gap junction connections to a tissue network. Thus, the parallel task is cracking the bioelectric code to decode the proto‐cognitive content of the cellular collective intelligence, which uses precisely the same bioelectric and neurotransmitter mechanisms to navigate through anatomical space and solve problems (deal with injury and other perturbations). (C) Tools have now been developed to read and write the bioelectric state of non‐neural tissues, using molecular‐genetics, pharmacology, and light (optogenetics) to open and close ion channels and gap junctions, thus regulating the topology of connections in the network and the specific bioelectrical patterns encoded in it at any specific time. All images courtesy of Jeremy Guay of Peregrine Creative; A,B previously published in [90]; C previously published in [15].
FIGURE 3 Developmental bioelectricity: fundamental mechanisms. (A) Neurons form networks that can perform computations and guide behavior in 3D space because context‐sensitive ion channels enable each cell to set and modify a resting potential (voltage gradient across the membrane) which it may communicate to neighbors if the (also context‐sensitive) electric synapses—gap junctions—are sufficiently open. This enables the project of “neural decoding” (A’) in which the physiological conditions are read out and decoded to read out the memories, preferences, and other aspects of the internal cognitive states of the being implemented by the neural network. (B) This machinery is evolutionarily ancient, with all body cells having ion channels and most having gap junction connections to a tissue network. Thus, the parallel task is cracking the bioelectric code to decode the proto‐cognitive content of the cellular collective intelligence, which uses precisely the same bioelectric and neurotransmitter mechanisms to navigate through anatomical space and solve problems (deal with injury and other perturbations). (C) Tools have now been developed to read and write the bioelectric state of non‐neural tissues, using molecular‐genetics, pharmacology, and light (optogenetics) to open and close ion channels and gap junctions, thus regulating the topology of connections in the network and the specific bioelectrical patterns encoded in it at any specific time. All images courtesy of Jeremy Guay of Peregrine Creative; A,B previously published in [90]; C previously published in [15].CC BY · PubMed Central
FIGURE 4 Anatomical outcomes enabled by reading and writing bioelectric prepatterns. Voltage‐sensitive fluorescent dye can be used to non‐invasively reveal the bioelectric patterns during morphogenesis. (A) Frog embryo cells during early development (image courtesy of Dany S. Adams). (B) The “electric face” prepattern which reveals the location of the eyes, mouth, and other structures that determine the locations of the gene expression domains that regionalize the craniofacial ectoderm and ultimately determine the position and size of the organs (previously published in [118]). (C) These patterns are functionally instructive, which is revealed by experiments such as injecting mRNA encoding potassium channels to induce a voltage spot resembling the eye field (left spot in B) in ectopic locations. This induces eyes to be formed (red arrow, C′) in ectopic locations such as in the gut. These eyes have the normal structure of internal components as seen in histological section and immunostaining (C″). Image in C taken from Xenbase [121]. Images in C′,C″ previously published in [120]. (D) Remarkably, when only a small number of cells are injected (blue beta‐galactosidase stain reveals the cells misexpressing the K+ channel protein), the task of making a lens in an ectopic location is still completed because these cells autonomously recruit neighbors (brown tissue) to complete the task for which the original cells’ numbers are insufficient. Image previously published in [18]. (E) A froglet soaked in voltage‐sensitive fluorescent dye reveals a depolarization signal (green stain above the dashed white line) in the un‐touched, contralateral leg (right arrow) which indicates whether, and where, the left leg was amputated (blue arrow). Yellow arrow indicates the spinal cord. Image previously published in [122].
FIGURE 4 Anatomical outcomes enabled by reading and writing bioelectric prepatterns. Voltage‐sensitive fluorescent dye can be used to non‐invasively reveal the bioelectric patterns during morphogenesis. (A) Frog embryo cells during early development (image courtesy of Dany S. Adams). (B) The “electric face” prepattern which reveals the location of the eyes, mouth, and other structures that determine the locations of the gene expression domains that regionalize the craniofacial ectoderm and ultimately determine the position and size of the organs (previously published in [118]). (C) These patterns are functionally instructive, which is revealed by experiments such as injecting mRNA encoding potassium channels to induce a voltage spot resembling the eye field (left spot in B) in ectopic locations. This induces eyes to be formed (red arrow, C′) in ectopic locations such as in the gut. These eyes have the normal structure of internal components as seen in histological section and immunostaining (C″). Image in C taken from Xenbase [121]. Images in C′,C″ previously published in [120]. (D) Remarkably, when only a small number of cells are injected (blue beta‐galactosidase stain reveals the cells misexpressing the K+ channel protein), the task of making a lens in an ectopic location is still completed because these cells autonomously recruit neighbors (brown tissue) to complete the task for which the original cells’ numbers are insufficient. Image previously published in [18]. (E) A froglet soaked in voltage‐sensitive fluorescent dye reveals a depolarization signal (green stain above the dashed white line) in the un‐touched, contralateral leg (right arrow) which indicates whether, and where, the left leg was amputated (blue arrow). Yellow arrow indicates the spinal cord. Image previously published in [122].CC BY · PubMed Central
FIGURE 5 A context‐sensitive bioelectric intervention for birth defects. (A) The neurectoderm in early frog embryos bears a specific bioelectric pattern (quantified in A’) prior to forming the brain [124]. (B) That pattern is required for normal brain development, because equalizing the resting potential across the midline by bringing all the cells to the same high value (red) or the same low value (green), using chloride (GlyR) or potassium (Kv1.5) channel misexpression, results in severe brain defects: it is the difference between the cells at the left and right edge of the nascent brain field that is crucial—not a specific voltage number but a pattern. This pattern is disrupted by numerous teratogenic influences [125, 126, 127], including nicotine, alcohol, and mutation of the Notch gene. (C) The normal bilateral pattern of forebrain, midbrain, and hindbrain is severely disrupted after Notch mutation (C’): the forebrain is gone and the midbrain and hindbrain are reduced to fluid‐filled bubbles. These complex anatomical structures can be restored by reinforcing the bioelectric prepattern; this can be done, for example, by homogenously up‐regulating HCN2 channel activity, because this channel will sharpen the “bell curve” pattern by only hyperpolarizing the cells in the correct middle region, which are somewhat but not entirely depolarized as a result of the Notch mutation (C”). Images previously published in [124].
FIGURE 5 A context‐sensitive bioelectric intervention for birth defects. (A) The neurectoderm in early frog embryos bears a specific bioelectric pattern (quantified in A’) prior to forming the brain [124]. (B) That pattern is required for normal brain development, because equalizing the resting potential across the midline by bringing all the cells to the same high value (red) or the same low value (green), using chloride (GlyR) or potassium (Kv1.5) channel misexpression, results in severe brain defects: it is the difference between the cells at the left and right edge of the nascent brain field that is crucial—not a specific voltage number but a pattern. This pattern is disrupted by numerous teratogenic influences [125, 126, 127], including nicotine, alcohol, and mutation of the Notch gene. (C) The normal bilateral pattern of forebrain, midbrain, and hindbrain is severely disrupted after Notch mutation (C’): the forebrain is gone and the midbrain and hindbrain are reduced to fluid‐filled bubbles. These complex anatomical structures can be restored by reinforcing the bioelectric prepattern; this can be done, for example, by homogenously up‐regulating HCN2 channel activity, because this channel will sharpen the “bell curve” pattern by only hyperpolarizing the cells in the correct middle region, which are somewhat but not entirely depolarized as a result of the Notch mutation (C”). Images previously published in [124].CC BY · PubMed Central
FIGURE 6 The future of biomedicine. (A) Biomedical interventions can be grouped into two major categories. The bottom‐up ones seek to directly manage hardware though surgery, transplantation, modification/creation of transcriptional circuits, and drugs that force specific pathway states. The top‐down approach, which is only now emerging in allopathic medicine, consists of attempts to signal to, communicate with, and change the internal memory content of the living material. Ways to control the agential material of the body include: shaping the behavior of pathways, cells, and tissues through training signals (rewards and punishments), deployment of interventions which are themselves not low‐agency drugs or materials but biobots or smart implants with goal‐directed loops and capacity to control cellular decision‐making, and modalities (drugs, light, etc.) which modify the course of complex morphogenesis by serving as triggers (for example for organ‐building cascades) or other ways to impact their navigation in morphospace. A subset of these morphoceuticals are electroceuticals, which use the bioelectric interface to communicate goal state information to tissues via ion channel and gap junctional modulation. Image previously published in [183]. (B) The capability of cellular collectives is not obvious from the default morphology, nor are “developmental constraints” (which may be more constraints in our thinking than in the traversal of the option space by a given system). The same cellular hardware can be pushed into novel configurations by specific prompts, which evolution exploits this routinely, using developmental modules, triggers, and setpoint‐signals [56, 184, 185, 186]. This is how biological systems control their own parts, but this strategy has not gone un‐noticed by parasites that exploit the competencies of their target material. The normal leaf architecture (B) becomes something completely different (B’)—a patterned gall—when prompted by a non‐human bioengineer: an insect parasite that hacks the competencies of the leaf cells. Interestingly, the sophistication of the galls produced matches the overall complexity level of the parasite—on a spectrum from virus to nematode to insect, the most advanced prompter is able to induce the most complex galls [187]; this bodes well for human bioengineers, if we can commit to the task of improving our bioprompting abilities. (C) Anthrobots are motile, self‐assembling constructs created from human tracheal epithelial cells [188]. Not only do the cells from adult patients form a totally new, functional shape but they also reveal interesting and unpredictable capabilities (E’), such as gathering into a super‐bot cluster (green) and healing injuries in cultured human iPSC‐derived neurons (red). White arrow points to the healed portion under the bots. Images previously published in [188]. (D) Future progress can be envisaged where AI‐augmented algorithms can intervene anywhere on the continuum of the body, from high‐level mental constructs in the brain to control structures within the collective intelligence of body cells. Such an AI can act as a translator of bioelectric and other information, mimicking the effects seen in “mind‐body medicine” where information crosses levels from the human personality's cognitive intent to the downstream changes of biochemical states. Image by Jeremy Guay of Peregrine Creative.
FIGURE 6 The future of biomedicine. (A) Biomedical interventions can be grouped into two major categories. The bottom‐up ones seek to directly manage hardware though surgery, transplantation, modification/creation of transcriptional circuits, and drugs that force specific pathway states. The top‐down approach, which is only now emerging in allopathic medicine, consists of attempts to signal to, communicate with, and change the internal memory content of the living material. Ways to control the agential material of the body include: shaping the behavior of pathways, cells, and tissues through training signals (rewards and punishments), deployment of interventions which are themselves not low‐agency drugs or materials but biobots or smart implants with goal‐directed loops and capacity to control cellular decision‐making, and modalities (drugs, light, etc.) which modify the course of complex morphogenesis by serving as triggers (for example for organ‐building cascades) or other ways to impact their navigation in morphospace. A subset of these morphoceuticals are electroceuticals, which use the bioelectric interface to communicate goal state information to tissues via ion channel and gap junctional modulation. Image previously published in [183]. (B) The capability of cellular collectives is not obvious from the default morphology, nor are “developmental constraints” (which may be more constraints in our thinking than in the traversal of the option space by a given system). The same cellular hardware can be pushed into novel configurations by specific prompts, which evolution exploits this routinely, using developmental modules, triggers, and setpoint‐signals [56, 184, 185, 186]. This is how biological systems control their own parts, but this strategy has not gone un‐noticed by parasites that exploit the competencies of their target material. The normal leaf architecture (B) becomes something completely different (B’)—a patterned gall—when prompted by a non‐human bioengineer: an insect parasite that hacks the competencies of the leaf cells. Interestingly, the sophistication of the galls produced matches the overall complexity level of the parasite—on a spectrum from virus to nematode to insect, the most advanced prompter is able to induce the most complex galls [187]; this bodes well for human bioengineers, if we can commit to the task of improving our bioprompting abilities. (C) Anthrobots are motile, self‐assembling constructs created from human tracheal epithelial cells [188]. Not only do the cells from adult patients form a totally new, functional shape but they also reveal interesting and unpredictable capabilities (E’), such as gathering into a super‐bot cluster (green) and healing injuries in cultured human iPSC‐derived neurons (red). White arrow points to the healed portion under the bots. Images previously published in [188]. (D) Future progress can be envisaged where AI‐augmented algorithms can intervene anywhere on the continuum of the body, from high‐level mental constructs in the brain to control structures within the collective intelligence of body cells. Such an AI can act as a translator of bioelectric and other information, mimicking the effects seen in “mind‐body medicine” where information crosses levels from the human personality's cognitive intent to the downstream changes of biochemical states. Image by Jeremy Guay of Peregrine Creative.CC BY · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Show all 271 references

Research works printed but not linked: 11

  1. Hinton G. E., 1987, How Learning Can Guide Evolution, Complex System, 1, 495
  2. Slijper E. J., 1942, Biologic Anatomical Investigations on the Bipedal Gait and Upright Posture in Mammals—With Special Reference to a Little Goat Born Without Forelegs II, Proceedings of the Koninklijke Nederlandse Akademie Van Wetenschappen, 45, 407
  3. Statland J. M., 1993, GeneReviews(R)
  4. Newman S. A., 2017, Evolutionary Developmental Biology: A Reference Guide, 1
  5. 10.7554/eLife.92683.4 · doi:10.7554/elife.92683.4
  6. Maturana H. R., 1980, Autopoiesis and Cognition the Realization of the Living. Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science
  7. Noble D., 2017, Dance to the Tune of Life: Biological Relativity Cambridge
  8. Ho M.‐W., 1988, Evolutionary Processes and Metaphors Chichester
  9. Goodwin B. C., 1994, How the Leopard Changed Its Spots: The Evolution of Complexity New York
  10. Goodwin B. C., 1977, Cognitive Biology, Communication and Cognition, 10, 87
  11. Rosen R., 1985, Anticipatory Systems: Philosophical, Mathematical, and Methodological Foundations

Cited by

See all 34

Metadata

Authors
Levin, M.
Affiliations
Tufts University (US)
Corresponding author
Levin, Michael
Venue
BioEssays
Publisher
Wiley
Published
2024-12-02
Volume
47
Issue
3
Pages
e202400196-e202400196
ISSN
  • 0265-9247 (ISSN-L)
  • 1521-1878
OpenAlex
W4404978008
Cited by
34
References
271
Citations by year
2026: 17 · 2025: 17
FWCI
1.38
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • BioEssays (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
Funders
  • Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation
  • Schmidt Futures
  • Templeton World Charity Foundation
Topics
  • Life Sciences › Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology › Molecular Biology › Planarian Biology and Electrostimulation
  • Health Sciences › Medicine › Complementary and alternative medicine › Biofield Effects and Biophysics
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Statistical and Nonlinear Physics › Complex Systems and Dynamics
Keywords
collective intelligence, cell behavior, bottom-up emergence, top-down control, homeodynamics, tumor suppression, basal cognition, transcriptional states, bioengineering
MeSH terms
Animals, Humans, Intelligence, Biomedical Research, Bioengineering

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: The multiscale wisdom of the body: collective intelligence as a tractable interface for next-generation biomedicine. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1002/bies.202400196
The paper
Levin, M. (2025). The multiscale wisdom of the body: collective intelligence as a tractable interface for next-generation biomedicine. BioEssays. https://doi.org/10.1002/bies.202400196

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.