CoChat

Gift Exchange

Open access
Mallard, Grégoire · 2019 · Cambridge University Press

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 176 of the 177 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; none of the 117 sources its claims cite is checked for support yet.

Abstract

Since Marcel Mauss published his foundational essay The Gift in 1925, many anthropologists and specialists of international relations have seen in the exchange of gifts, debts, loans, concessions or reparations the sources of international solidarity and international law. Still, Mauss's reflections were deeply tied to the context of interwar Europe and the French colonial expansion. Their normative dimension has been profoundly questioned after the age of decolonization. A century after Mauss, we may ask: what is the relevance of his ideas on gift exchanges and international solidarity? By tracing how Mauss's theoretical and normative ideas inspired prominent thinkers and government officials in France and Algeria, from Pierre Bourdieu to Mohammed Bedjaoui, Gregoire Mallard adds a building block to our comprehension of the role that anthropology, international law, and economics have played in shaping international economic governance from the age of European colonization to the latest European debt crisis. This title is also available as Open Access on Cambridge Core

Overview

CoChat Summary

TL;DR

Grégoire Mallard reconstructs Marcel Mauss's *The Gift* (1925) as a political intervention in interwar debates over German reparations and European financial solidarity, then traces how the model of gift exchange was deployed, contested, and eventually discarded across French colonial policy, Algerian decolonization, and the New International Economic Order. The book argues that the international and sovereign-debt dimensions of Maussian gift exchange were lost to later anthropology and economics, and that they remain relevant to contemporary Eurozone debates.

Key findings

  • Mauss wrote *The Gift* alongside more than forty editorials in *Le Populaire* (1920–1924) on German reparations; he advocated a moratorium and partial debt cancellation, arguing that gift exchange requires a temporal gap between gift and counter-gift ("Time is necessary to execute any counter-prestation: the idea of a 'term' is always implied"). The 1921 London Agreement restructured German debt from 200 to 132 billion gold marks; Germany ultimately paid only 22 billion of the 132 billion, with France bearing about 70 percent of interwar reconstruction costs.
  • Mauss's model was appropriated as a colonial ideology: his students (Germaine Tillion, Jacques Soustelle) used gift exchange and "integration" to argue for continued French-Algerian union, while Pierre Bourdieu and others attacked this as deceitful rhetoric masking acculturation and exploitation. The model was relocated from the international to the local level in anthropology.
  • Mohammed Bedjaoui and the NIEO "decolonized" the gift model, arguing for sovereign debt cancellation and global negotiations between North and South; this was dashed by neoliberalism and the collapse of Bretton Woods after Nixon let the dollar float in 1973.
  • Mauss's analysis made sense only within a system where states controlled exchange parities and currencies were indexed to gold; speculative market logics after 1973 made his state-level gift analysis "no longer make sense in any useful way."

Methods

Genealogical approach (Foucault) tracing the model of the gift across the "long twentieth century," combined with a neo-Bourdieuan historical sociology of intellectual fields (Charle, Bourdieu, Steinmetz) that situates actors at the intersection of metropolitan, colonial (Algerian and West African), and international fields. Sources include Mauss's archives at the Collège de France, the Archives Nationales (papers of Albert Thomas, Léon Blum, Jacques Soustelle), Mauss's unpublished manuscript *The Nation* (transcribed by Terrier and Fournier), and more than ten hours of recorded interviews with Mohammed Bedjaoui.

Limitations

The book does not state formal limitations. The text makes evident that the argument relies heavily on Francophone sources and a single national-intellectual lineage, which the author acknowledges by framing the study as complementing Anglophone histories (Liebersohn, Flandreau) and by noting that cross-pollination between traditions is only partially addressed. The author also concedes that some claims about Mauss's intentions are inferential, e.g., that Mauss "may not have been in agreement" with the MAUSS/Graeber reading, and that his reading of Germanic gift practices was criticized by Henri Hubert as politically motivated and empirically overstated.

Model-written summary of a shortened version of the paper’s full text (it is longer than we read). Check it against the paper before relying on it.

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1017/9781108570497

Cites

176 of 177 references verified0 citation errors · 1 not checkable

Statistics

Nothing to recompute.

Verification

Claims the paper makes

0 Valid · 19 Not valid · 117 Not checked · 217 Own results and interpretations

110 more claims

Create a free account to see all 353 claims and every source verdict.

See all claims — free account
  • Probably not a substantial claim. 167
  • It may state two separate claims as one. 144
  • The quote only partly states this claim. 17

Create a free account to see these claims.

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

Each contradiction between two passages listed here was confirmed by an independent check.

2 of 2

Citations

Cites

Research works printed but not linked: 184

  1. Weber, 1978, Economy and Society
  2. Varoufakis, 2017, Adults in the Room: My Battle with Europe’s Deep Establishment
  3. 1983, Official Records of the United Nations Conference on Succession of States in Respect of State Property, Archives and Debts, II
  4. Toussaint, 2017, Le système dette
  5. Topalov, 1999, Laboratoires du nouveau siècle: La nébuleuse réformatrice en France et ses réseaux (1880–1914)
  6. Tillion, 2015, Il était une fois l’ethnographie
  7. Tillion, 2009, Fragments de vie
  8. Tillion, 2005, Les ennemis complémentaires: Guerre d’Algérie
  9. Thénault, 2001, Une drôle de justice: les magistrats dans la guerre d’Algérie
  10. Soustelle, 1967, Les Quatre soleils
  11. Soustelle, 1962, L’espérance trahie
  12. Singaravélou, 2011, Professer l’Empire. Les “Sciences coloniales” en France sous la IIIe République
  13. Servet, 1999, Une économie sans argent, les systèmes d’échange local
  14. Sacriste, 2011, Germaine Tillion, Jacques Berque, Jean Servier et Pierre Bourdieu: des ethnologues dans la guerre d’indépendance algérienne
  15. Sack, 1927, Les effets des transformations des Etats sur leurs dettes publiques et autres obligations financières: traité juridique et financier
  16. Prélot, 1939, L’évolution politique du socialisme français, 1789–1934
  17. Peyrefitte, 1994, C’était De Gaulle
  18. Pénin, 1997, Charles Gide 1847–1932, p. L’esprit critique
  19. Orléan, 2011, Mon rapport au marxisme, Revue de la régulation, 10
  20. Nora, 1961, Les français d’Algérie
  21. Noiriel, 1988, Le creuset français, histoire de l’immigration XIXe–XXe siècle
  22. Mérat, 1927, L’évolution actuelle du régime financier des colonies: Etudes synthétique et analytique des principales modifications et de quelques applications du décret du 30 décembre 1912
  23. Mauss, 2016, The Gift, Expanded Edition
  24. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  25. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  26. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  27. Sahlins, 1974, Stone Age Economics
  28. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  29. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  30. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  31. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  32. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  33. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  34. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  35. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  36. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  37. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  38. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  39. Tillion, 1960, L’Afrique bascule vers l’avenir
  40. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques, 499
  41. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  42. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  43. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  44. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  45. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  46. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  47. Servet, 1980, Gratuité, dons, économie politique et économistes, Recherches et documents du Centre Thomas More, 26, 51
  48. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques, 201
  49. Soustelle, 1963, A New Road for France
  50. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  51. Mauss, Marcel 1925c. “Review essay of G. Schwalbe and A. Ploetz.” L’Année sociologique. July 1923–July 1924: 369–73.
  52. Burnett, 1965, Reparations at the Paris Peace Conference. From the Standpoint of the American Delegation
  53. Schuker, 1988, American “Reparations” to Germany, 1919–1933
  54. Bourgeois, 1919, Le Traité de paix de Versailles
  55. Thénault, 2012, Violence ordinaire dans l’Algérie coloniale. Camps, internements, assignations à résidence
  56. Augagneur, 2010, Erreurs et brutalités coloniales
  57. Bourdieu, 1994, Raisons pratiques. Sur la théorie de l’action
  58. Soustelle, 1957, Le drame algérien et la décadence française: Réponse à Raymond Aron
  59. Bourdieu, 1980, Le sens pratique
  60. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  61. Blévis, 2014, Histoire de l’Algérie à la période coloniale
  62. Blais, 2007, La solidarité: Histoire d’une idée
  63. Burrin, 1986, La dérive fasciste, Doriot, Déat, Bergery, 1933–1945
  64. Birnbaum, 1988, Un mythe politique: la “République juive” de Léon Blum à Pierre Mendès France
  65. Girard, 1961, Mensonges romantiques et vérité romanesque
  66. Sibeud, 2004, Marcel Mauss: Projet de présentation d’un bureau d’ethnologie, Revue d’histoire des sciences humaines, 10
  67. Bourdieu, 1990, Homo Academicus
  68. Bedjaoui, 1981, Thirteenth Report on Succession of States in Respect of Matters Other Than Treaties
  69. Soustelle, Jacques 1959b. “Press conference, April 7.” (Fonds Soustelle, 112AJ/23).
  70. Bedjaoui, 1974, Seventh Report on Succession of States in Respect of Matters Other Than Treaties
  71. Aron, 1963, Le grand débat: Initiation à la stratégie atomique
  72. Bedjaoui, 1970, Problèmes récents de succession d’Etats dans les Etats nouveaux, Recueil des cours de l’Académie de droit international, 130, 453
  73. Blum, 1972, L’œuvre, t.2
  74. Bedjaoui, 1958, Dotation Carnegie pour la paix internationale
  75. Lacouture, 2011, Le témoignage est un combat
  76. Bedjaoui, 1961, La Révolution algérienne et le droit
  77. Attali, 2016, C’était François Mitterrand
  78. Attali, 1982, La violence de la monnaie, 7
  79. Aron, 1957, La tragédie algérienne
  80. Malek, 1995, L’Algérie à Evian: Histoire des négociations secrètes, 1956–1962
  81. Sibeud, 2009, Une libre pensée impériale? Le Comité de protection et de défense des indigènes (1892–1914), 1900: Revue d’histoire intellectuelle, 27, 57
  82. Bedjaoui, 1970, Third Report on Succession of States in Respect of Matters Other Than Treaties
  83. Terrier, 2013, La Nation
  84. Bert, 2012, Marcel Mauss, Henri Hubert et la sociologie des religions: Penser et écrire à deux
  85. Bedjaoui, 1973, Sixth Report on Succession of States in Respect of Matters Other Than Treaties
  86. Barthélemy, 1917, La réparation des dommages de guerre
  87. Bourdieu, 2013, Manet, une révolution symbolique
  88. Thomas, 1919, La Coopération et les usines de Guerre
  89. Ligue française et ligue suisse pour la défense des indigènes dans le bassin conventionnel du Congo. 1910. Bulletin. (jan.–avril: 4). Paris: Archives Nationales (Fonds AT 94AP/329, Dossier N’Goko Sangha, 17–3).
  90. Challaye, 1906, Les deux Congo. Devant la Belgique et devant la France
  91. 1983, Official Records of the United Nations Conference on Succession of States in Respect of State Property, Archives and Debts, I
  92. Bourdieu, 1958, Sociologie de l’Algérie
  93. Bedjaoui, 1984, Droits et libertés à la fin du xxe siècle: influence des données économiques et technologiques. Etudes offertes à Claude-Albert Colliard, 45
  94. Bedjaoui, 1976, Eighth Report on Succession of States in Respect of Matters Other Than Treaties
  95. Bedjaoui, 1977, Ninth Report on Succession of States in Respect of Matters Other Than Treaties
  96. Marseille, 1984, Empire colonial et capitalisme français: Histoire d’un divorce
  97. Foucault, 2003, Society Must Be Defended: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1975–76
  98. Blum, 1972, L’œuvre, t.2
  99. Gide, 1958, Les Caves du Vatican
  100. Bedjaoui, 1969, Second Report on Succession of States in Respect of Matters Other Than Treaties
  101. Becker, 2003, Maurice Halbwachs. Un intellectuel en guerres mondiales, 1914–1945
  102. Mallard, Grégoire 2017. European Election Day: Synchronizing National Electoral Cycles and Improving Democracy in Europe. Report of the conference European Election Day. http://graduateinstitute.ch/files/live/sites/iheid/files/sites/hirschman-centre-on-democracy/docs/EEDay%20Report-05–10-17.pdf
  103. Loucheur, 1962, Carnets Secrets: 1908–1932
  104. Charle, 1980, Les hauts fonctionnaires en France au XIXe siècle
  105. Gide, 1931, Histoire économique et sociale de la guerre mondiale, 1
  106. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  107. Bouglé, 1924, Le solidarisme
  108. Oualid, 1928, Salaires, tarifs, conventions collectives et grèves: la politique du Ministère de l’Armement et du Ministère du Travail
  109. Aron, 1959, La société industrielle et la guerre
  110. Maurois, 1931, Lyautey
  111. Graeber, 2011, Debt: The First 5,000 Years
  112. Simiand, François 1925. “Review essay of J. M. Keynes.” L’Année sociologique. July 1923–July 1924: 778–9.
  113. Caillé, 1989, Critique de la raison utilitaire: manifeste du M.A.U.S.S
  114. Vauchez, 2014, Démocratiser l’Europe
  115. Becker, 1982, Art Worlds
  116. Weber, 2007, Le Populaire
  117. Heilbron, 1995, The Rise of Social Theory
  118. Hubert, 1932, Les Celtes et l’expansion celtique jusqu’à l’époque de La Tène
  119. Larnaude, 1918, Examen de la responsabilité pénale de l’Empereur Guillaume I
  120. Bedjaoui, 1972, Fifth Report on Succession of States in Respect of Matters Other Than Treaties
  121. Hennette, 2017, Pour un traité de democratization de l’Europe
  122. Colton, 1966, Léon Blum: Humanist in Politics
  123. Candar, 1994, Jaurès et les intellectuels
  124. Flory, 1968, La succession d’Etat en Afrique du Nord
  125. de L’estoile, 2007, Le goût des Autres. De l’Exposition coloniale aux Arts premiers
  126. Bouyahia, 2013, La polysémie du voile. Politiques et mobilisations postcoloniales
  127. Kojève, 2001, Colonialism from a European Perspective, Interpretation, 29
  128. Larnaude, 1917, La réparation des dommages de guerre
  129. Mitterrand, 1957, Présence française et abandon
  130. Bedjaoui, 1978, Pour un nouvel ordre économique international
  131. Vergès, 1968, De la stratégie judiciaire
  132. Durkheim, 1893, La division du travail social
  133. Girardet, 1972, L’idée coloniale en France: de 1871 à 1962
  134. Mauss, 1994, Œuvres 2, Représentations collectives et diversité des civilizations
  135. Halbwachs, 1925, Les cadres sociaux de la mémoire
  136. Attali, 1975, L’anti-économique
  137. Fournier, 1994, Marcel Mauss
  138. Gide, 1927, Voyage au Congo
  139. de Rougemont, 2010, Lazard Frères: Banquiers des Deux Mondes (1840–1939)
  140. Tarot, 1999, De Durkheim à Mauss, l’invention du symbolique, sociologie et science des religions
  141. Servet, 1984, Numismata: Etat et origines de la monnaie
  142. Cohn, 1996, Colonialism and Its Form of Knowledge: The British in India
  143. Cointepas, 2008, Arthur Fontaine, 1860–1931: Un réformateur, pacifiste et mécène au sommet de la Troisième République
  144. Guyer, 2016, The Gift, Expanded Edition
  145. Couturier, 2006, Le Gouverneur et son miroir: Marcel de Coppet (1881–1968)
  146. Bedjaoui, 1979, Eleventh Report on Succession of States in Respect of Matters Other Than Treaties
  147. Derrida, 1991, Donner le temps, t.1 la fausse monnaie
  148. Shaffer, Contractual Knowledge: One Hundred Years of Legal Experimentation in Global Markets, 289
  149. Dezalay, 1996, Dealing in Virtue: International Commercial Arbitration and the Construction of a Transnational Legal Order
  150. Berstein, 2006, Léon Blum
  151. Durkheim, 1991, L’Allemagne au-dessus de tout. La mentalité allemande et la guerre
  152. Durkheim, 1998, Lettres à Marcel Mauss
  153. Bedjaoui, 1971, Fourth Report on Succession of States in Respect of Matters Other Than Treaties
  154. Bedjaoui, 1978, Tenth Report on Succession of States in Respect of Matters Other Than Treaties, Yearbook of the International Law Commission, II
  155. Flory, 1961, Compte-Rendu de La révolution algérienne et le droit de Mohammed Bedjaoui, Annuaire français de droit international, 7
  156. Jèze, 1922, Cours de sciences des finances et de législation financière française
  157. Bedjaoui, 1968, First Report on Succession of States in Respect of Rights and Duties Resulting from Sources Other Than Treaties
  158. Foucault, 2010, The Birth of Biopolitics: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1978–79
  159. Freymond, 1951, Lénine et l’impérialisme
  160. Malye, 2012, François Mitterrand et la guerre d’Algérie
  161. Gide, 1958, Les faux monnayeurs
  162. Mallard, 2006, Quand l’expertise se heurte au pouvoir souverain: La nation américaine face à la prolifération nucléaire, 1945–1953, Sociologie du Travail, 48
  163. Girard, 1999, Je vois Satan tomber comme l’éclair
  164. Godbout, 2000, Le don, la dette et l’identité: Homo donator vs. Homo economicus
  165. Lagrange, 2010, Le déni des cultures
  166. Craig, 1963, The Diplomats 1919–1939
  167. Chaumont, 1970, Cours général de Droit international, Recueil des cours de l’Académie de droit international, 1, 335
  168. Hubert, 1952, Les Germains: Cours professé à l’école du Louvre en 1924–1925
  169. Hubert, 1899, Essai sur la nature et la function du sacrifice, L’Année sociologique, 2, 29
  170. Hubert, 1903, Esquisse d’une théorie générale de la magie, L’Année sociologique, 4, 1
  171. Journal Officiel. 1911. Débats parlementaires du 7 avril. Paris: Archives Nationales (Fonds AT 94AP/329, Dossier N’Goko Sangha, 17–3).
  172. Lachs, 1963, Report on Succession of States in Respect Other Than Treaties
  173. Fanon, 1961, Les damnés de la terre
  174. Lavau, 1989, Profession politiste, entretiens entre Georges Lavau, Florence Haegel, et Jean-Baptiste Legrave, Politix, 2
  175. Laville, 2007, L’économie solidaire: Une perspective internationale
  176. Lazard, 1990, Max Lazard, ses frères et Lyautey. Lettres (1894–1933)
  177. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques
  178. Lévi-Strauss, 1950, Sociologie et anthropologie, ix
  179. Malek, 1962, L’Algérie à Evian: Histoire des négociations secrètes, 1956–1962
  180. Manceron, 2003, Marianne et les colonies: Une introduction à l’histoire coloniale de la France
  181. Gide, 1932, La solidarité, Cours au collège de France 1927–8
  182. Bourdieu, 1964, Le déracinent
  183. Blum, 1972, L’œuvre, t.2
  184. Mauss, 1997, Ecrits politiques

Cited by

See all 62

Metadata

Authors
Mallard, G.
Affiliations
Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies (CH)
Corresponding author
Mallard, Grégoire
Venue
Cambridge University Press
Published
2019-03-14
OpenAlex
W4211026599
Cited by
49
References
164
Citations by year
2026: 5 · 2025: 10 · 2024: 10 · 2023: 1 · 2022: 6 · 2021: 12 · 2020: 3 · 2019: 2
FWCI
7.29
Type
book
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • Cambridge University Press eBooks (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc-nd)
  • Directory of Open access Books (OAPEN Foundation) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • OAPEN (The OAPEN Foundation) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc-nd)
Funders
Swiss National Science Foundation (10BP12_183395)
Topics
  • Social Sciences › Anthropology › Anthropological Studies and Insights
  • Social Sciences › Sociology and Political Science › Emile Durkheim and Sociology
  • Social Sciences › Arts and Humanities › History › Historical and Contemporary Political Dynamics
Keywords
Marcel Mauss, The Gift, gift exchange, international solidarity, international law, global economic governance, Pierre Bourdieu, French colonialism, decolonization, eurozone crisis

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-11-11, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).

A second model labelled each claim on 2026-11-11 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.