CoChat

Autonomic Integration in Nested Protocell Communities

Open access
Yin, Zhuping, Gao, Ning, Xu, Can, Li, Mei, Mann, Stephen · 2023 · Journal of the American Chemical Society

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 60 of the 60 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Abstract

The self-driven organization of model protocells into higher-order nested cytomimetic systems with coordinated structural and functional relationships offers a step toward the autonomic implementation of artificial multicellularity. Here, we describe an endosymbiotic-like pathway in which proteinosomes are captured within membranized alginate/silk fibroin coacervate vesicles by guest-mediated reconfiguration of the host protocells. We demonstrate that interchange of coacervate vesicle and droplet morphologies through proteinosome-mediated urease/glucose oxidase activity produces discrete nested communities capable of integrated catalytic activity and selective disintegration. The self-driving capacity is modulated by an internalized fuel-driven process using starch hydrolases sequestered within the host coacervate phase, and structural stabilization of the integrated protocell populations can be achieved by on-site enzyme-mediated matrix reinforcement involving dipeptide supramolecular assembly or tyramine-alginate covalent cross-linking. Our work highlights a semi-autonomous mechanism for constructing symbiotic cell-like nested communities and provides opportunities for the development of reconfigurable cytomimetic materials with structural, functional, and organizational complexity.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1021/jacs.3c02816

Cites

60 of 60 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

Figure 1 Self-driven capture of proteinosomes in reconfigurable coacervate vesicles. (a) Urease (red triangles)/GOx (gray dots)-containing proteinosomes (P, blue rings) are incorporated into alginate/CSF coacervate vesicles (CV, dark green rings) by endogenously controlled enzyme-mediated reconfiguration via a two-step pH-oscillation process involving membrane-less coacervate droplets (CD, green circles) intermediates. A CV and P non-interacting binary population at pH 4 is transformed into an interacting CD + P community at pH 7 by urea/urease activity, and results in spontaneous proteinosome capture and formation of proteinosome-in-coacervate droplets (P@CD) at pH 9. P@CD is reconfigured into proteinosome-in-coacervate vesicles (P@CV) at pH 4 by GOx/glucose-mediated self-membranization. (b–e) LSCM images showing a non-interacting binary population of coacervate vesicles (FITC-CSF, green fluorescence) and proteinosomes (Dylight 405, blue fluorescence) with encapsulated GOx, urease, and RITC-gelatin (red fluorescence) at pH 6 (b), interactive binary population of proteinosomes (purple) and coacervate droplets (green) at pH 7.5 (c), a single coacervate droplet with captured proteinosomes at pH 9 (d), and an individual proteinosome-in-coacervate vesicle at pH 6 (e); scale bars, 20 μm. (f) FACS 2D dot plots of forward light scattered area (FSC-A) versus side light scattered area (SSC-A) for single populations of CV, CD and P, a non-interacting CV + P binary population, and populations of P@CD and P@CV. Total number of particles recorded in each experiment: n = 20,000. Variance values; σ2 = 0.24, 0.65, and 1.23 for CV, P@CD, and P@CV, respectively. (g) Fuel-driven reconfiguration of P@CD into P@CV by enzyme-mediated cascade processing. P@CD is prepared at pH 9 with sequestered starch hydrolases (purple hexagons) and captured GOx-containing proteinosomes (gray dots in blue rings). Addition of soluble starch induces the endogenous production of glucose, GOx-mediated acidification, and membranization. (h) LSCM images of hydrolase/GOx-containing P@CD before (left) and 10.5 h after addition of starch at concentrations of 30 or 60 mM showing the formation of P@CV. No reconfiguration is observed when starch (60 mM) is added in the absence of the starch hydrolases (right image). Amylase (40 IU/mL); amyloglucosidase (20 IU/mL); proteinosomes (Dylight 405, blue fluorescence); alginate/RITC-CSF coacervate (red fluorescence). Scale bars, 20 μm.
Figure 1 Self-driven capture of proteinosomes in reconfigurable coacervate vesicles. (a) Urease (red triangles)/GOx (gray dots)-containing proteinosomes (P, blue rings) are incorporated into alginate/CSF coacervate vesicles (CV, dark green rings) by endogenously controlled enzyme-mediated reconfiguration via a two-step pH-oscillation process involving membrane-less coacervate droplets (CD, green circles) intermediates. A CV and P non-interacting binary population at pH 4 is transformed into an interacting CD + P community at pH 7 by urea/urease activity, and results in spontaneous proteinosome capture and formation of proteinosome-in-coacervate droplets (P@CD) at pH 9. P@CD is reconfigured into proteinosome-in-coacervate vesicles (P@CV) at pH 4 by GOx/glucose-mediated self-membranization. (b–e) LSCM images showing a non-interacting binary population of coacervate vesicles (FITC-CSF, green fluorescence) and proteinosomes (Dylight 405, blue fluorescence) with encapsulated GOx, urease, and RITC-gelatin (red fluorescence) at pH 6 (b), interactive binary population of proteinosomes (purple) and coacervate droplets (green) at pH 7.5 (c), a single coacervate droplet with captured proteinosomes at pH 9 (d), and an individual proteinosome-in-coacervate vesicle at pH 6 (e); scale bars, 20 μm. (f) FACS 2D dot plots of forward light scattered area (FSC-A) versus side light scattered area (SSC-A) for single populations of CV, CD and P, a non-interacting CV + P binary population, and populations of P@CD and P@CV. Total number of particles recorded in each experiment: n = 20,000. Variance values; σ2 = 0.24, 0.65, and 1.23 for CV, P@CD, and P@CV, respectively. (g) Fuel-driven reconfiguration of P@CD into P@CV by enzyme-mediated cascade processing. P@CD is prepared at pH 9 with sequestered starch hydrolases (purple hexagons) and captured GOx-containing proteinosomes (gray dots in blue rings). Addition of soluble starch induces the endogenous production of glucose, GOx-mediated acidification, and membranization. (h) LSCM images of hydrolase/GOx-containing P@CD before (left) and 10.5 h after addition of starch at concentrations of 30 or 60 mM showing the formation of P@CV. No reconfiguration is observed when starch (60 mM) is added in the absence of the starch hydrolases (right image). Amylase (40 IU/mL); amyloglucosidase (20 IU/mL); proteinosomes (Dylight 405, blue fluorescence); alginate/RITC-CSF coacervate (red fluorescence). Scale bars, 20 μm.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 2 Matrix reinforcement in the proteinosome-in-coacervate vesicles. (a) Guest-mediated peptide assembly mechanism in alginate/CSF scaffolds. A proteinosome-in-coacervate droplet (P@CD) consisting of a membrane-less coacervate phase (light orange circle) and captured urease/GOx-containing proteinosomes (red triangles/gray dots/blue rings) is reconfigured in the presence of glucose and dipeptide Fmoc-AA-OH into a structurally reinforced multi-chambered proteinosome-in-coacervate vesicle (P@CV, dark orange). Membranization and peptide assembly (black symbols) occur simultaneously as the pH is decreased from 9 to 4 by GOx-mediated acidification. (b, c) LSCM images of a single GOx-containing P@CD (b) and P@CV (c) prepared in the presence of Fmoc-AA-OH at pH values of 9 or 4, respectively. The P@CV is structurally reinforced by peptide nanofilaments after the addition of glucose. Fluorescent labels: proteinosomes (Dylight 405, blue fluorescence); coacervate (RITC-CSF, red fluorescence). Scale bars, 20 μm. (d) FRAP profiles (gray values) for P@CD (I, black squares, pH 9, no glucose; II, gray circles, pH 9, no glucose, Fmoc-AA-OH (0.75 mg/mL)); non-reinforced P@CV (III, red squares, pH 4, 20 mM glucose; IV, blue squares, pH 4, 60 mM glucose), and reinforced P@CV (V, orange circles, pH 4, 20 mM glucose, Fmoc-AA-OH (0.75 mg/mL); VI, light purple circles, pH 4, 60 mM glucose, Fmoc-AA-OH (0.75 mg/mL)). The photo-bleaching regime is shaded in green. (e) Host-mediated cross-linking mechanism in alginate-Tyr/CSF scaffolds. Reconfiguration of P@CD at pH 9 into matrix-reinforced multi-chambered P@CV at pH 4 occurs by GOx/HRP-mediated oxidative cross-linking of alginate-Tyr using in situ hydrogen peroxide production after addition of glucose. Increasing the pH back to 9 by urea/urease activity does not reconfigure the reinforced P@CV. Labels as in (a) except for HRP (pink triangles) and alginate-Tyr (black symbols). (f, g) LSCM images of a single P@CV after alginate-Tyr cross-linking recorded at pH 4 (left) and 9 (right). Staining as in (b) and (c). Scale bars, 20 μm. (h–j) Time series of LSCM images showing P@CV at pH 4 with no matrix reinforcement (h), reinforcement with peptide nanofilaments (i), or reinforcement by covalent cross-linking (j) in the presence of sodium chloride. Only the reinforced P@CV are salt-tolerant. Staining as in (b) and (c). Scale bars, 20 μm. (k) Time-dependent LSCM images of a Fmoc-AA-OH-reinforced P@CV containing acid-tolerant lipase before (t0) and after addition of calcein-AM and sodium chloride. Lipase hydrolase activity is maintained under high ionic strength, producing a calcein (green fluorescence) output. Scale bars are 20 μm. (l) Corresponding changes in calcein fluorescence intensity (gray value) recorded within peptide-reinforced lipase-containing protocells (+Fmoc, P@CV, dark green dots) under high ionic strength. Leakage of calcein into the surrounding solution (+Fmoc, Environment, light green squares) is negligible over the initial 30 min period.
Figure 2 Matrix reinforcement in the proteinosome-in-coacervate vesicles. (a) Guest-mediated peptide assembly mechanism in alginate/CSF scaffolds. A proteinosome-in-coacervate droplet (P@CD) consisting of a membrane-less coacervate phase (light orange circle) and captured urease/GOx-containing proteinosomes (red triangles/gray dots/blue rings) is reconfigured in the presence of glucose and dipeptide Fmoc-AA-OH into a structurally reinforced multi-chambered proteinosome-in-coacervate vesicle (P@CV, dark orange). Membranization and peptide assembly (black symbols) occur simultaneously as the pH is decreased from 9 to 4 by GOx-mediated acidification. (b, c) LSCM images of a single GOx-containing P@CD (b) and P@CV (c) prepared in the presence of Fmoc-AA-OH at pH values of 9 or 4, respectively. The P@CV is structurally reinforced by peptide nanofilaments after the addition of glucose. Fluorescent labels: proteinosomes (Dylight 405, blue fluorescence); coacervate (RITC-CSF, red fluorescence). Scale bars, 20 μm. (d) FRAP profiles (gray values) for P@CD (I, black squares, pH 9, no glucose; II, gray circles, pH 9, no glucose, Fmoc-AA-OH (0.75 mg/mL)); non-reinforced P@CV (III, red squares, pH 4, 20 mM glucose; IV, blue squares, pH 4, 60 mM glucose), and reinforced P@CV (V, orange circles, pH 4, 20 mM glucose, Fmoc-AA-OH (0.75 mg/mL); VI, light purple circles, pH 4, 60 mM glucose, Fmoc-AA-OH (0.75 mg/mL)). The photo-bleaching regime is shaded in green. (e) Host-mediated cross-linking mechanism in alginate-Tyr/CSF scaffolds. Reconfiguration of P@CD at pH 9 into matrix-reinforced multi-chambered P@CV at pH 4 occurs by GOx/HRP-mediated oxidative cross-linking of alginate-Tyr using in situ hydrogen peroxide production after addition of glucose. Increasing the pH back to 9 by urea/urease activity does not reconfigure the reinforced P@CV. Labels as in (a) except for HRP (pink triangles) and alginate-Tyr (black symbols). (f, g) LSCM images of a single P@CV after alginate-Tyr cross-linking recorded at pH 4 (left) and 9 (right). Staining as in (b) and (c). Scale bars, 20 μm. (h–j) Time series of LSCM images showing P@CV at pH 4 with no matrix reinforcement (h), reinforcement with peptide nanofilaments (i), or reinforcement by covalent cross-linking (j) in the presence of sodium chloride. Only the reinforced P@CV are salt-tolerant. Staining as in (b) and (c). Scale bars, 20 μm. (k) Time-dependent LSCM images of a Fmoc-AA-OH-reinforced P@CV containing acid-tolerant lipase before (t0) and after addition of calcein-AM and sodium chloride. Lipase hydrolase activity is maintained under high ionic strength, producing a calcein (green fluorescence) output. Scale bars are 20 μm. (l) Corresponding changes in calcein fluorescence intensity (gray value) recorded within peptide-reinforced lipase-containing protocells (+Fmoc, P@CV, dark green dots) under high ionic strength. Leakage of calcein into the surrounding solution (+Fmoc, Environment, light green squares) is negligible over the initial 30 min period.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 3 Catalytic reactivity in co-trapped protocell populations. (a) Urease (red triangles)/GOx (gray dots)-containing proteinosomes (P1, blue rings) and HRP (pink triangles)-containing proteinosomes (P2, red rings) are co-captured within alginate/CSF coacervate vesicles (CV, gray ring) by endogenously controlled enzyme-mediated reconfiguration via a fuel-driven two-step pH-oscillation process involving membrane-less host/guest coacervate droplets (P1/P2@CD, gray circle) intermediates loaded with starch hydrolases (purple hexagons). Co-production of hydrogen peroxide acts as a diffusive signal to drive oPD peroxidation in the captured HRP-containing proteinosomes, leading to a green fluorescence output (2,3-DAP) in the host/guest coacervate vesicles (P1/P2@CV, green circle). (b) LSCM image of a single P1/P2@CD showing co-located P1 and P2 guest protocells. Fluorescent labels: coacervate droplets (FITC-CSF, green); proteinosomes, P1 (Dylight 405, blue), P2, (RITC, red). Scale bars, 20 μm. (c, d) Time-dependent changes in pH ((c), membranization) and absorbance at 495 nm ((d), 2,3-DAP production, arbitrary units). Plots for P1/P2@CV after the addition of starch and oPD (black squares) show decrease in pH and increase in absorbance. Plots for P1@CV (red circles) show a similar decrease in pH (c) but a negligible change in absorbance (d). Plots for P2@CV (blue triangles) show negligible changes in pH and absorbance. (e) Time-sequence of fluorescence images of a single P1/P2@CV before (t0) and after (t0 = 0.5, 1, and 2 h) the addition of glucose. Production of 2,3-DAP via an inter-proteinosome GOx/HRP cascade reaction gives rise to green fluorescence in the unlabeled coacervate matrix. Blue and red labels as shown in (b). Scale bars, 20 μm. (f) Time-dependent changes in green fluorescence (2,3-DAP, gray value) recorded on individual coacervate vesicles containing captured GOx- and HRP-loaded proteinosomes after the addition of oPD and glucose in the presence of starch and starch hydrolases (red triangles), without starch but with starch hydrolases (green circles), or with starch but without starch hydrolases (blue triangles).
Figure 3 Catalytic reactivity in co-trapped protocell populations. (a) Urease (red triangles)/GOx (gray dots)-containing proteinosomes (P1, blue rings) and HRP (pink triangles)-containing proteinosomes (P2, red rings) are co-captured within alginate/CSF coacervate vesicles (CV, gray ring) by endogenously controlled enzyme-mediated reconfiguration via a fuel-driven two-step pH-oscillation process involving membrane-less host/guest coacervate droplets (P1/P2@CD, gray circle) intermediates loaded with starch hydrolases (purple hexagons). Co-production of hydrogen peroxide acts as a diffusive signal to drive oPD peroxidation in the captured HRP-containing proteinosomes, leading to a green fluorescence output (2,3-DAP) in the host/guest coacervate vesicles (P1/P2@CV, green circle). (b) LSCM image of a single P1/P2@CD showing co-located P1 and P2 guest protocells. Fluorescent labels: coacervate droplets (FITC-CSF, green); proteinosomes, P1 (Dylight 405, blue), P2, (RITC, red). Scale bars, 20 μm. (c, d) Time-dependent changes in pH ((c), membranization) and absorbance at 495 nm ((d), 2,3-DAP production, arbitrary units). Plots for P1/P2@CV after the addition of starch and oPD (black squares) show decrease in pH and increase in absorbance. Plots for P1@CV (red circles) show a similar decrease in pH (c) but a negligible change in absorbance (d). Plots for P2@CV (blue triangles) show negligible changes in pH and absorbance. (e) Time-sequence of fluorescence images of a single P1/P2@CV before (t0) and after (t0 = 0.5, 1, and 2 h) the addition of glucose. Production of 2,3-DAP via an inter-proteinosome GOx/HRP cascade reaction gives rise to green fluorescence in the unlabeled coacervate matrix. Blue and red labels as shown in (b). Scale bars, 20 μm. (f) Time-dependent changes in green fluorescence (2,3-DAP, gray value) recorded on individual coacervate vesicles containing captured GOx- and HRP-loaded proteinosomes after the addition of oPD and glucose in the presence of starch and starch hydrolases (red triangles), without starch but with starch hydrolases (green circles), or with starch but without starch hydrolases (blue triangles).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 4 Selective disintegration in co-trapped protocell populations. (a) Urease (red triangles)/GOx (gray dots)-containing proteinosomes with PEG-NHS cross-links (P1, blue rings) and dextran-(green pentagons)-containing proteinosomes with PEG-NHS-disulfide cross-links (P3, green rings) are co-captured within alginate/CSF coacervate droplets (P1/P3@CD, light orange circle) at pH 9 and reconfigured at pH 4 into P1/P3@CV, brown rings). Addition of TCEP results in the selective disassembly of P3, formation of P1@CV, and release of dextran into the lumen. Simultaneous addition of TCEP and glucose offsets disassembly of P3 by on-site production of hydrogen peroxide (thin black arrow); the defense mechanism is further enhanced by sequestration of HRP (pink triangles) in the coacervate scaffold. (b, c) LSCM images showing P1/P3@CV with co-captured P1 (blue, Dylight 405) and P3 (green, FITC-dextran) after the addition of TCEP showing partial (b, small green ring) and complete (c) disassembly of P3 and concomitant release of FITC-dextran into the lumen containing intact P1. The coacervate phase is labeled with RITC-CSF (red fluorescence). Scale bars, 20 μm. (d) LSCM images (top row) and corresponding line profiles (bottom row) of multi/single-chambered coacervate vesicles containing FITC-dextran (green) and captured disulfide-cross-linked proteinosomes containing RITC-gelatin (red) and GOx recorded 8 h after the addition of TCEP (10 mM) in the absence of glucose (left) or simultaneous addition of TCEP and glucose (10 mM (middle), 20 mM (right)). Without glucose, no proteinosomes are observed and the gelatin payload is observed throughout the host/guest protocell. Intact TCEP-sensitive proteinosomes are observed under GOx activity. Scale bars are 20 μm. Dashed white lines indicate the positions of the recorded line profiles (bottom row). (e) Bar chart showing percentage of captured GOx-containing proteinosomes undergoing complete disassembly in the presence of TCEP (5 mM) and various concentrations of glucose. Proteinosomes were captured in the presence (15 IU/mL, red) or absence (black) of HRP-containing alginate/CSF coacervate droplets (blue) or suspended in bulk solution (purple). Data recorded after 6 h.
Figure 4 Selective disintegration in co-trapped protocell populations. (a) Urease (red triangles)/GOx (gray dots)-containing proteinosomes with PEG-NHS cross-links (P1, blue rings) and dextran-(green pentagons)-containing proteinosomes with PEG-NHS-disulfide cross-links (P3, green rings) are co-captured within alginate/CSF coacervate droplets (P1/P3@CD, light orange circle) at pH 9 and reconfigured at pH 4 into P1/P3@CV, brown rings). Addition of TCEP results in the selective disassembly of P3, formation of P1@CV, and release of dextran into the lumen. Simultaneous addition of TCEP and glucose offsets disassembly of P3 by on-site production of hydrogen peroxide (thin black arrow); the defense mechanism is further enhanced by sequestration of HRP (pink triangles) in the coacervate scaffold. (b, c) LSCM images showing P1/P3@CV with co-captured P1 (blue, Dylight 405) and P3 (green, FITC-dextran) after the addition of TCEP showing partial (b, small green ring) and complete (c) disassembly of P3 and concomitant release of FITC-dextran into the lumen containing intact P1. The coacervate phase is labeled with RITC-CSF (red fluorescence). Scale bars, 20 μm. (d) LSCM images (top row) and corresponding line profiles (bottom row) of multi/single-chambered coacervate vesicles containing FITC-dextran (green) and captured disulfide-cross-linked proteinosomes containing RITC-gelatin (red) and GOx recorded 8 h after the addition of TCEP (10 mM) in the absence of glucose (left) or simultaneous addition of TCEP and glucose (10 mM (middle), 20 mM (right)). Without glucose, no proteinosomes are observed and the gelatin payload is observed throughout the host/guest protocell. Intact TCEP-sensitive proteinosomes are observed under GOx activity. Scale bars are 20 μm. Dashed white lines indicate the positions of the recorded line profiles (bottom row). (e) Bar chart showing percentage of captured GOx-containing proteinosomes undergoing complete disassembly in the presence of TCEP (5 mM) and various concentrations of glucose. Proteinosomes were captured in the presence (15 IU/mL, red) or absence (black) of HRP-containing alginate/CSF coacervate droplets (blue) or suspended in bulk solution (purple). Data recorded after 6 h.CC BY · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Show all 60 references

Cited by

Metadata

Authors
Yin, Z., Gao, N., Xu, C., Li, M., & Mann, S.
Affiliations
  • University of Bristol (GB)
  • Shanghai Jiao Tong University (CN)
Corresponding author
  • Li, Mei
  • Mann, Stephen
Venue
Journal of the American Chemical Society
Published
2023-06-27
Volume
145
Issue
27
Pages
14727-14736
ISSN
  • 0002-7863 (ISSN-L)
  • 1520-5126
OpenAlex
W4382318346
Cited by
25
References
60
Citations by year
2026: 11 · 2025: 7 · 2024: 7
FWCI
2.91
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • Journal of the American Chemical Society (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • Explore Bristol Research (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • Bristol Research (University of Bristol) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
Funders
  • China Scholarship Council
  • H2020 European Research Council (EC-2016-674 ADG 740235)
Topics
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Astronomy and Astrophysics › Origins and Evolution of Life
  • Physical Sciences › Materials Science › Biomaterials › Supramolecular Self-Assembly in Materials
  • Physical Sciences › Chemistry › Organic Chemistry › Supramolecular Chemistry and Complexes
Keywords
protocells, endosymbiosis, urease, glucose oxidase
MeSH terms
Urease, Artificial Cells

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.