CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 365 of the 365 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

The Role of Chemistry in Fracture Pattern Development and Opportunities to Advance Interpretations of Geological Materials

Open access

Abstract

Fracture pattern development has been a challenging area of research in the Earth sciences for more than 100 years. Much has been learned about the spatial and temporal complexity inherent to these systems, but severe challenges remain. Future advances will require new approaches. Chemical processes play a larger role in opening‐mode fracture pattern development than has hitherto been appreciated. This review examines relationships between mechanical and geochemical processes that influence the fracture patterns recorded in natural settings. For fractures formed in diagenetic settings (~50 to 200 °C), we review evidence of chemical reactions in fractures and show how a chemical perspective helps solve problems in fracture analysis. We also outline impediments to subsurface pattern measurement and interpretation, assess implications of discoveries in fracture history reconstruction for process‐based models, review models of fracture cementation and chemically assisted fracture growth, and discuss promising paths for future work. To accurately predict the mechanical and fluid flow properties of fracture systems, a processes‐based approach is needed. Progress is possible using observational, experimental, and modeling approaches that view fracture patterns and properties as the result of coupled mechanical and chemical processes. A critical area is reconstructing patterns through time. Such data sets are essential for developing and testing predictive models. Other topics that need work include models of crystal growth and dissolution rates under geological conditions, cement mechanical effects, and subcritical crack propagation. Advances in machine learning and 3‐D imaging present opportunities for a mechanistic understanding of fracture formation and development, enabling prediction of spatial and temporal complexity over geologic timescales. Geophysical research with a chemical perspective is needed to correctly identify and interpret fractures from geophysical measurements during site characterization and monitoring of subsurface engineering activities.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1029/2019rg000671

Cites

365 of 365 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

Figure 1 Types of fractures. (a) Block diagram illustrating fracture types in bedded rocks. Displacement is normal to the discontinuity for opening -mode fractures (Lc) and parallel or subparallel for faults (F). St, stratification; C L , cluster of opening -mode fractures (after Narr et al., 2006). (b) Opening -mode fractures are commonly called veins (V) if mineral filled (red, with medial line), and joints (J) if they lack mineral deposits; these terms are problematic for diagenetic settings in which fractures that formed at the same time can resemble veins or joints in terms of cement fill or fall into a hybrid category where fractures walls are lined with cement (blue) and may be locally bridged by pillar -shaped bridge cement deposits (Br). Large arrows show opening vectors. (c) Example of calcite (cc) - fi lled fracture in shale. Arrows show opening displacement. Note medial line. (d) Open, calcite -bridged fracture, Austin Chalk, Texas. Br, calcite bridge. (e) Core cut parallel to bedding, Cozzette Sandstone, Colorado. Br marks open, quartz -lined and locally quartz -bridged vertical fracture. (f) Joints, Precambrian sandstone -shale sequence, NW Scotland. Inset shows traces localized in sandstone beds, an example of stratigraphic control. (g) Cluster (CL), quartz -lined fractures, sandstone, NW Scotland (see Ellis et al., 2012). (h) Part of discrete fracture network realization for subsurface rock. A discrete fracture network model represents fractures realistically and discretely within a matrix grid. Model width dimension, 2 km. Although patterns affect flow, tests in wells, including pressure -transient tests, multiwell pulse tests, and tracer tests, commonly cannot distinguish among patterns, such as between long fractures and small but extensively interconnected fractures that may extend for long distances (kilometer scale).
Figure 1 Types of fractures. (a) Block diagram illustrating fracture types in bedded rocks. Displacement is normal to the discontinuity for opening -mode fractures (Lc) and parallel or subparallel for faults (F). St, stratification; C L , cluster of opening -mode fractures (after Narr et al., 2006). (b) Opening -mode fractures are commonly called veins (V) if mineral filled (red, with medial line), and joints (J) if they lack mineral deposits; these terms are problematic for diagenetic settings in which fractures that formed at the same time can resemble veins or joints in terms of cement fill or fall into a hybrid category where fractures walls are lined with cement (blue) and may be locally bridged by pillar -shaped bridge cement deposits (Br). Large arrows show opening vectors. (c) Example of calcite (cc) - fi lled fracture in shale. Arrows show opening displacement. Note medial line. (d) Open, calcite -bridged fracture, Austin Chalk, Texas. Br, calcite bridge. (e) Core cut parallel to bedding, Cozzette Sandstone, Colorado. Br marks open, quartz -lined and locally quartz -bridged vertical fracture. (f) Joints, Precambrian sandstone -shale sequence, NW Scotland. Inset shows traces localized in sandstone beds, an example of stratigraphic control. (g) Cluster (CL), quartz -lined fractures, sandstone, NW Scotland (see Ellis et al., 2012). (h) Part of discrete fracture network realization for subsurface rock. A discrete fracture network model represents fractures realistically and discretely within a matrix grid. Model width dimension, 2 km. Although patterns affect flow, tests in wells, including pressure -transient tests, multiwell pulse tests, and tracer tests, commonly cannot distinguish among patterns, such as between long fractures and small but extensively interconnected fractures that may extend for long distances (kilometer scale).CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 2
CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 3
CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 2 Sampling challenge. (a) Block diagram illustrating how subsurface fracture patterns are concealed by narrow dimensions of rock that can be sampled in wellbores. F, fracture trace; S o , bed surface with trace patterns; 1, 20 -cm -diameter wellbore that encountered fractures; 2, wellbore that missed fractures. Fractures in each layer are nearly uniformly distributed, yet due to random sampling of discontinuous features, Well 1 encounters fractures in most layers, whereas Well 2 intersects no fractures. (b) Core from Cretaceous Frontier Formation and an outcrop of the same formation (view of top of bed), Muddy Gap, Wyoming. Beds of this pavement dip toward viewer. F, fracture traces. Arrow marks 5 -mdistance between two fracture traces. Core, shown in inset, contains a Frontier Formation fracture; the core diameter is about 10 cm. Similar rock -volume sampling limits affect borehole -imaging petrophysical tools. Due to discontinuous wellbore -fracture intersections, measurement of variables such as fracture density typically do not provide information needed for modeling methods commonly used to populate properties in large -scale reservoir models that presume spatial continuity of measured data (e.g., semivariogram -based geostatistics). Where successfully sampled, as shown by the core inset, samples may be unrepresentative and provide little evidence of their pattern.
Figure 2 Sampling challenge. (a) Block diagram illustrating how subsurface fracture patterns are concealed by narrow dimensions of rock that can be sampled in wellbores. F, fracture trace; S o , bed surface with trace patterns; 1, 20 -cm -diameter wellbore that encountered fractures; 2, wellbore that missed fractures. Fractures in each layer are nearly uniformly distributed, yet due to random sampling of discontinuous features, Well 1 encounters fractures in most layers, whereas Well 2 intersects no fractures. (b) Core from Cretaceous Frontier Formation and an outcrop of the same formation (view of top of bed), Muddy Gap, Wyoming. Beds of this pavement dip toward viewer. F, fracture traces. Arrow marks 5 -mdistance between two fracture traces. Core, shown in inset, contains a Frontier Formation fracture; the core diameter is about 10 cm. Similar rock -volume sampling limits affect borehole -imaging petrophysical tools. Due to discontinuous wellbore -fracture intersections, measurement of variables such as fracture density typically do not provide information needed for modeling methods commonly used to populate properties in large -scale reservoir models that presume spatial continuity of measured data (e.g., semivariogram -based geostatistics). Where successfully sampled, as shown by the core inset, samples may be unrepresentative and provide little evidence of their pattern.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 3 Fracture patterns sensitive to sealing by cement by temperature regime. (a) At great depth, fracture opening rate is less than cementation rate. Fractures seal as quickly as they form. (b) At intermediate depth (diagenetic settings) fracture opening rates are broadly similar to cementation rates, but whether or not and at what rates fractures seal depends on mechanical processes (specific rates and timing of fracture opening, and chemical effects, chemical environment, host rock type, grain size, and other factors; spanning potential, Lander & Laubach, 2015). Open fractures may grow preferentially compared to partly sealed or sealed fractures, leading to a positive feedback loop that produces a wide range of fractures sizes and spacings. Heterogeneity in fracture patterns can arise in part owing to interplay of factors controlling spanning (including rock -type dependence). (c) At shallow depths, fracture opening rate greatly exceeds cementation rate. Fractures have narrow aperture size range, bed -bounded height pattern. F, opening -mode fracture; Br, cement deposits partly filling fractures. Blue, cement; black, fracture pore space. Conceptual diagram.
Figure 3 Fracture patterns sensitive to sealing by cement by temperature regime. (a) At great depth, fracture opening rate is less than cementation rate. Fractures seal as quickly as they form. (b) At intermediate depth (diagenetic settings) fracture opening rates are broadly similar to cementation rates, but whether or not and at what rates fractures seal depends on mechanical processes (specific rates and timing of fracture opening, and chemical effects, chemical environment, host rock type, grain size, and other factors; spanning potential, Lander & Laubach, 2015). Open fractures may grow preferentially compared to partly sealed or sealed fractures, leading to a positive feedback loop that produces a wide range of fractures sizes and spacings. Heterogeneity in fracture patterns can arise in part owing to interplay of factors controlling spanning (including rock -type dependence). (c) At shallow depths, fracture opening rate greatly exceeds cementation rate. Fractures have narrow aperture size range, bed -bounded height pattern. F, opening -mode fracture; Br, cement deposits partly filling fractures. Blue, cement; black, fracture pore space. Conceptual diagram.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 4 Conceptual fracture pattern topology. (a -d) After Laubach et al. (2018). Plan view fracture trace patterns on a bedding surface. (a) Interconnected, (b) not interconnected, (c) interconnected, clustered, and (d) ephemeral connections by second set. (e -g) After Sanderson and Nixon (2015). Network topology defined by arrangement of traces and nodes: (e) random array of traces as generated in stochastic models, (f) schematic representation of a network, and (g) network generated by random selection of branches on a square grid. Nodes and branches: I nodes (circles); Y nodes (triangles); and X nodes (diamonds). (h) Fracture trace patterns, Cambrian Flathead sandstone, Wyoming. Intersection pattern annotated for part of pattern. (i) Fracture network, Oman Mountains created by two phases of nonparallel horizontal extension with a rotation of ~20°. Rectangular grid markers spaced 2 m part. A parallel set of long, evenly spaced fractures formed during the first extension, reactivated in sinistral mixed mode. Second -phase fractures nucleate mostly close to tips of older fractures. Image is a modified part of a rectified high -resolution photograph created by Wüstefeld (2010). For the tectonic, geomechanical and pressure -temperature evolution of the area, see Grobe et al. (2019).
Figure 4 Conceptual fracture pattern topology. (a -d) After Laubach et al. (2018). Plan view fracture trace patterns on a bedding surface. (a) Interconnected, (b) not interconnected, (c) interconnected, clustered, and (d) ephemeral connections by second set. (e -g) After Sanderson and Nixon (2015). Network topology defined by arrangement of traces and nodes: (e) random array of traces as generated in stochastic models, (f) schematic representation of a network, and (g) network generated by random selection of branches on a square grid. Nodes and branches: I nodes (circles); Y nodes (triangles); and X nodes (diamonds). (h) Fracture trace patterns, Cambrian Flathead sandstone, Wyoming. Intersection pattern annotated for part of pattern. (i) Fracture network, Oman Mountains created by two phases of nonparallel horizontal extension with a rotation of ~20°. Rectangular grid markers spaced 2 m part. A parallel set of long, evenly spaced fractures formed during the first extension, reactivated in sinistral mixed mode. Second -phase fractures nucleate mostly close to tips of older fractures. Image is a modified part of a rectified high -resolution photograph created by Wüstefeld (2010). For the tectonic, geomechanical and pressure -temperature evolution of the area, see Grobe et al. (2019).CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 7
CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 5 Contrasting patterns in plan view generated by a geomechanical model like that described in Olson et al. (2009). (a) Parallel fracture traces, low interconnection. (b) Intersecting fractures. Flow simulations show that subtle differences in patterns -such as variation in length distribution or connectivity -can have marked effects on outcomes of engineering operations. For instance, effective permeability and strength estimation (e.g., Bear et al., 1993; Philip et al., 2005) and fluid extraction, storage, or disposal estimation (e.g., Middleton et al., 2015) require solving challenges of interpreting limited and usually ambiguous observations.
Figure 5 Contrasting patterns in plan view generated by a geomechanical model like that described in Olson et al. (2009). (a) Parallel fracture traces, low interconnection. (b) Intersecting fractures. Flow simulations show that subtle differences in patterns -such as variation in length distribution or connectivity -can have marked effects on outcomes of engineering operations. For instance, effective permeability and strength estimation (e.g., Bear et al., 1993; Philip et al., 2005) and fluid extraction, storage, or disposal estimation (e.g., Middleton et al., 2015) require solving challenges of interpreting limited and usually ambiguous observations.CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 9
CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 6 Cement bridges on fracture faces and in cross section. (a) Bridges, cross -section view, Mesozoic sandstone, NE Mexico, outcrop. P, porosity; Br, bridge (all images). Hooker et al. (2015). (b) Quartz bridges and quartz rinds, fracture face, Cretaceous sandstone, Colorado. Fall et al. (2012). (c) Quartz bridges (one example circled) and rinds, Paleozoic shale fracture face, core, West Texas. (d) Dolomite bridge with crack seal texture, Knox dolostone, core, after Gale et al. (2010). Crack seal texture developed across the whole bridge; bridge is composed of multiple crystals. (e) Cambrian sandstone, NW Scotland. Cathodoluminescence (CL) image; after Laubach and Diaz -Tushman (2009). (f) Microfracture, Paleozoic sandstone, Oklahoma. Sd, late siderite crystals. G, grain. Modified from Anders et al. (2014). (g) Cretaceous sandstone, core depth 6,200 m, Wyoming, after Laubach et al. (2016). (h -k) Quartz bridge with crack seal texture, East Texas core. Lq, lateral quartz. Gd, gap deposit quartz. FIA, fluid inclusion assemblage. (h) Transmitted light image. (i) Panchromatic CL image. Inset box shows detail in (j). (j) Panchromatic CL image, detail. (k) Map on CL image, showing location of gap and lateral deposits.
Figure 6 Cement bridges on fracture faces and in cross section. (a) Bridges, cross -section view, Mesozoic sandstone, NE Mexico, outcrop. P, porosity; Br, bridge (all images). Hooker et al. (2015). (b) Quartz bridges and quartz rinds, fracture face, Cretaceous sandstone, Colorado. Fall et al. (2012). (c) Quartz bridges (one example circled) and rinds, Paleozoic shale fracture face, core, West Texas. (d) Dolomite bridge with crack seal texture, Knox dolostone, core, after Gale et al. (2010). Crack seal texture developed across the whole bridge; bridge is composed of multiple crystals. (e) Cambrian sandstone, NW Scotland. Cathodoluminescence (CL) image; after Laubach and Diaz -Tushman (2009). (f) Microfracture, Paleozoic sandstone, Oklahoma. Sd, late siderite crystals. G, grain. Modified from Anders et al. (2014). (g) Cretaceous sandstone, core depth 6,200 m, Wyoming, after Laubach et al. (2016). (h -k) Quartz bridge with crack seal texture, East Texas core. Lq, lateral quartz. Gd, gap deposit quartz. FIA, fluid inclusion assemblage. (h) Transmitted light image. (i) Panchromatic CL image. Inset box shows detail in (j). (j) Panchromatic CL image, detail. (k) Map on CL image, showing location of gap and lateral deposits.CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 11
CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 7 Crosscutting relations of gap deposits are used to reconstruct historical sequence of fluid inclusion assemblages (FIAs). (a) Transmitted light image with partly transparent cathodoluminescence (CL) image and texture map of quartz bridge and surrounding calcite, 3,000 m, Cretaceous sandstone, East Texas. Transmitted light highlights locations of FIAs. Box shows location of images (c) and (d). (b) CL image of same bridge, with CL texture emphasized. CL image highlights textures in quartz and calcite. (c) Transmitted light detail showing FIA. (d) CL and mapped gap deposits showing crosscutting gap deposits and overlapping lateral deposits. Script letters/numbers and symbols show map notes recording crosscutting sequence. (e) Schematic of gap and lateral accumulation (after Hooker et al., 2011). P, porosity; Lq, lateral quartz; gd, gap deposit quartz; xc, crosscutting relation; MF, microfracture; ML, median line; Br, bridge; R, rind; FW, fracture walls; 1, total opening displacement (kinematic aperture); 2, aperture between rind deposits; 3, incremental opening amount (gap).
Figure 7 Crosscutting relations of gap deposits are used to reconstruct historical sequence of fluid inclusion assemblages (FIAs). (a) Transmitted light image with partly transparent cathodoluminescence (CL) image and texture map of quartz bridge and surrounding calcite, 3,000 m, Cretaceous sandstone, East Texas. Transmitted light highlights locations of FIAs. Box shows location of images (c) and (d). (b) CL image of same bridge, with CL texture emphasized. CL image highlights textures in quartz and calcite. (c) Transmitted light detail showing FIA. (d) CL and mapped gap deposits showing crosscutting gap deposits and overlapping lateral deposits. Script letters/numbers and symbols show map notes recording crosscutting sequence. (e) Schematic of gap and lateral accumulation (after Hooker et al., 2011). P, porosity; Lq, lateral quartz; gd, gap deposit quartz; xc, crosscutting relation; MF, microfracture; ML, median line; Br, bridge; R, rind; FW, fracture walls; 1, total opening displacement (kinematic aperture); 2, aperture between rind deposits; 3, incremental opening amount (gap).CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 8 Quartz bridge compared with modeled fracture quartz cement deposits. (a) Cathodoluminescence (CL) image bridge analyzed by Becker et al. (2010). Panchromatic cathodoluminescence (CL) and color CL partly transparent overlay image. Banding within bridge that parallels fracture walls are gap deposits similar to those shown at higher resolution in Laubach et al. (2016). A, ankerite; P, porosity; G, grain; Gd, gap quartz deposits; Lq, lateral quartz deposits; R, rind deposit. (b) Simplified map of quartz bridge deposit. Red, gap deposits, locus of rapid quartz accumulation, crack seal texture and fluid inclusion assemblages; blue, locus of slow quartz accumulation, lateral quartz deposits and quartz in host sandstone; CL textures in lateral deposits partly visible. I through V mark progressively younger groups of gap deposits sequenced by crosscutting relations. Note diminishing lateral quartz thickness toward younger gap deposits. (c) Modeled quartz accumulation color coded by accumulation rate. Red, fast; blue, slow. An open -access animation of modeled quartz accumulation for this bridge is accessible via Lander and Laubach (2015). Sample depth, 3,000 m.
Figure 8 Quartz bridge compared with modeled fracture quartz cement deposits. (a) Cathodoluminescence (CL) image bridge analyzed by Becker et al. (2010). Panchromatic cathodoluminescence (CL) and color CL partly transparent overlay image. Banding within bridge that parallels fracture walls are gap deposits similar to those shown at higher resolution in Laubach et al. (2016). A, ankerite; P, porosity; G, grain; Gd, gap quartz deposits; Lq, lateral quartz deposits; R, rind deposit. (b) Simplified map of quartz bridge deposit. Red, gap deposits, locus of rapid quartz accumulation, crack seal texture and fluid inclusion assemblages; blue, locus of slow quartz accumulation, lateral quartz deposits and quartz in host sandstone; CL textures in lateral deposits partly visible. I through V mark progressively younger groups of gap deposits sequenced by crosscutting relations. Note diminishing lateral quartz thickness toward younger gap deposits. (c) Modeled quartz accumulation color coded by accumulation rate. Red, fast; blue, slow. An open -access animation of modeled quartz accumulation for this bridge is accessible via Lander and Laubach (2015). Sample depth, 3,000 m.CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 14
CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 9 Durations of fracture propagation on burial history curves. (a) East Texas, Becker et al. (2010). (b) Northern Piceance Basin, after Fall et al. (2015); (c) Southern Piceance Basin; Fall et al. (2012); (d) Green River Basin, Laubach et al. (2016); (e) Mexico, Hooker et al. (2015). Curves show burial history of various units (primarily Mesozoic sandstones); gray and black bars on curves mark durations of fracture growth from reconstructed fluid inclusion assemblage trapping temperatures sequenced by crack seal texture reconstruction. Temperature is used as a proxy for time to place deposits on burial curves.
Figure 9 Durations of fracture propagation on burial history curves. (a) East Texas, Becker et al. (2010). (b) Northern Piceance Basin, after Fall et al. (2015); (c) Southern Piceance Basin; Fall et al. (2012); (d) Green River Basin, Laubach et al. (2016); (e) Mexico, Hooker et al. (2015). Curves show burial history of various units (primarily Mesozoic sandstones); gray and black bars on curves mark durations of fracture growth from reconstructed fluid inclusion assemblage trapping temperatures sequenced by crack seal texture reconstruction. Temperature is used as a proxy for time to place deposits on burial curves.CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 16
CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 10 Mechanical effects of cement on fracture patterns is suggested by contrasts between extreme cases: barren joints versus veins that were repeatedly fully cement filled during growth. (a) Joints, Lafonia Group, Falkland Islands. Note narrow aperture size range and regular spacing. (b) Veins, Antarctic Peninsula. Note wide aperture size range and irregular spacing. Insets show modelled nonspanning and spanning quartz cement respectively; modified from Lander and Laubach (2015). Inset key matches Figure 8; black, pore space; red, cement accumulation at fast rate; blue, green, cement accumulation at slow rate. Gray, dark gray, quartz and feldspar grains.
Figure 10 Mechanical effects of cement on fracture patterns is suggested by contrasts between extreme cases: barren joints versus veins that were repeatedly fully cement filled during growth. (a) Joints, Lafonia Group, Falkland Islands. Note narrow aperture size range and regular spacing. (b) Veins, Antarctic Peninsula. Note wide aperture size range and irregular spacing. Insets show modelled nonspanning and spanning quartz cement respectively; modified from Lander and Laubach (2015). Inset key matches Figure 8; black, pore space; red, cement accumulation at fast rate; blue, green, cement accumulation at slow rate. Gray, dark gray, quartz and feldspar grains.CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 18
CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 11 Evidence of mechanical impact of cement on spatial arrangement. Comparison of fractures in Cretaceous Frontier Formation sandstone sharing ENE strike but differing burial conditions and degrees of quartz cement spanning potential (after Li et al., 2018); clustering quantified using normalized correlation count method of Marrett et al. (2018). Insets contrast degree of cement spanning fractures at the localities. (a) Normalized fracture intensity variation and (b) normalized correlation count for spatial arrangements; values are within 95% confidence envelope; patterns are indistinguishable from random, outcrop, low spanning potential, western Green River Basin. (c) Normalized fracture intensity variation and (d) normalized correlation count. Patterns exceed 95% confidence envelope; patterns are regularly spaced fractal clusters, high spanning potential, eastern Green River Basin. Shaded areas of curves show statistically significant values. Compare Figure 3.
Figure 11 Evidence of mechanical impact of cement on spatial arrangement. Comparison of fractures in Cretaceous Frontier Formation sandstone sharing ENE strike but differing burial conditions and degrees of quartz cement spanning potential (after Li et al., 2018); clustering quantified using normalized correlation count method of Marrett et al. (2018). Insets contrast degree of cement spanning fractures at the localities. (a) Normalized fracture intensity variation and (b) normalized correlation count for spatial arrangements; values are within 95% confidence envelope; patterns are indistinguishable from random, outcrop, low spanning potential, western Green River Basin. (c) Normalized fracture intensity variation and (d) normalized correlation count. Patterns exceed 95% confidence envelope; patterns are regularly spaced fractal clusters, high spanning potential, eastern Green River Basin. Shaded areas of curves show statistically significant values. Compare Figure 3.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 12 Aspects of subcritical crack growth. (a) Schematic stress intensity factor/crack velocity diagram for subcritical tensile crack growth due to stress corrosion. K IC is critical stress intensity factor or fracture toughness, Ko is stress corrosion crack growth limit. Region 1 behavior is controlled by rate of stress corrosion reactions at crack tips. Region 2 behavior is controlled by rate of transport of reactive species to crack tips. Region 3 behavior is controlled by thermally activated bond rupture, which is largely independent of chemical environment (after Atkinson, 1984). Contrasts in behavior of fracture are based on observations of glass. (b) Schematic of silica system with crack. Oxygen atoms, red, and silicon atoms, yellow. Half plane where bonds are severed is denoted by dashed line. Boundary region, where motion of atoms is prescribed, is shaded gray. In internal region, atoms are free to relax to a minimum energy configuration. J -integral is evaluated on contours like that shown in black. (c) Crack tip stress fields calculated from individual atomic stresses averaged over 12 replica systems in amorphous silica at two loading levels (K I 2 ~ 0.05 and 0.25 MPa 2 ·m). Corresponding contours from linear elastic solution are shown in black. (b) and (c) are modified after Rimsza et al. (2018a).
Figure 12 Aspects of subcritical crack growth. (a) Schematic stress intensity factor/crack velocity diagram for subcritical tensile crack growth due to stress corrosion. K IC is critical stress intensity factor or fracture toughness, Ko is stress corrosion crack growth limit. Region 1 behavior is controlled by rate of stress corrosion reactions at crack tips. Region 2 behavior is controlled by rate of transport of reactive species to crack tips. Region 3 behavior is controlled by thermally activated bond rupture, which is largely independent of chemical environment (after Atkinson, 1984). Contrasts in behavior of fracture are based on observations of glass. (b) Schematic of silica system with crack. Oxygen atoms, red, and silicon atoms, yellow. Half plane where bonds are severed is denoted by dashed line. Boundary region, where motion of atoms is prescribed, is shaded gray. In internal region, atoms are free to relax to a minimum energy configuration. J -integral is evaluated on contours like that shown in black. (c) Crack tip stress fields calculated from individual atomic stresses averaged over 12 replica systems in amorphous silica at two loading levels (K I 2 ~ 0.05 and 0.25 MPa 2 ·m). Corresponding contours from linear elastic solution are shown in black. (b) and (c) are modified after Rimsza et al. (2018a).CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 21
CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 13 Fracture clustering from interactions at advancing tip (Olson, 2004). Sequence of aperture and stress intensity factor development, modified from his Figure 6 ( n = 80), near y = 8 m. Circle centered at (0,0) is scale for K I , showing diameter appropriate for value of 10 MPa·m 1/2 . Each segment modeled has an opening marked by an open circle with proportionate diameter. Fracture tip elements have a shaded circle marking magnitude of K I . Frames (a) -(h) show propagation of cluster across body, stress shadow effects on nearby fractures, and tapered opening shapes approaching tips of interacting fractures.
Figure 13 Fracture clustering from interactions at advancing tip (Olson, 2004). Sequence of aperture and stress intensity factor development, modified from his Figure 6 ( n = 80), near y = 8 m. Circle centered at (0,0) is scale for K I , showing diameter appropriate for value of 10 MPa·m 1/2 . Each segment modeled has an opening marked by an open circle with proportionate diameter. Fracture tip elements have a shaded circle marking magnitude of K I . Frames (a) -(h) show propagation of cluster across body, stress shadow effects on nearby fractures, and tapered opening shapes approaching tips of interacting fractures.CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 23
CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 14 Results of numerical experiment of simultaneous extension fracturing and cementation (modified from Hooker & Katz, 2015). Orange stripes mark locations of automatically detected fractures. f is a factor representing cement accumulation rate. K c is spring constant (stiffness) of cemented springs, relative to host rock spring constant (K r = 1). With increased cementation rate, fractures become narrower and more closely spaced. Red arrows mark apparent clustering. Decreasing Kc results in more refracturing of extant fractures. ' Joint -like ' little or no mechanical effect of cement; ' vein -like ' extensive mechanical effect of cement.
Figure 14 Results of numerical experiment of simultaneous extension fracturing and cementation (modified from Hooker & Katz, 2015). Orange stripes mark locations of automatically detected fractures. f is a factor representing cement accumulation rate. K c is spring constant (stiffness) of cemented springs, relative to host rock spring constant (K r = 1). With increased cementation rate, fractures become narrower and more closely spaced. Red arrows mark apparent clustering. Decreasing Kc results in more refracturing of extant fractures. ' Joint -like ' little or no mechanical effect of cement; ' vein -like ' extensive mechanical effect of cement.CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 25
CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 15 Simulated modulus evolution. Coupled diagenesis/rock physics simulation results for various rock properties for Williams Fork sandstones at MWX site, Piceance Basin, using temperature history and fracture time for ' Model 1 ' of Fall et al. (2012). Simulated evolution in Young's modulus, permeability, and quartz cement abundance in the matrix of a rock during fracture system development. Results show that onset of opening at ~40 Ma corresponds to initiation of rapid quartz cementation. Quartz (and later -stage carbonate cement, not modeled) cause substantial changes in predicted fluid flow and elastic properties for unfractured part of host rock. Young's modulus of the host rock increases by nearly 50% during active fracturing whereas permeability drops by more than an order of magnitude. Model simulation, R. H. Lander using compositional and textural characteristics derived from the Williams Fork sandstone data set of Ozkan et al. (2011).
Figure 15 Simulated modulus evolution. Coupled diagenesis/rock physics simulation results for various rock properties for Williams Fork sandstones at MWX site, Piceance Basin, using temperature history and fracture time for ' Model 1 ' of Fall et al. (2012). Simulated evolution in Young's modulus, permeability, and quartz cement abundance in the matrix of a rock during fracture system development. Results show that onset of opening at ~40 Ma corresponds to initiation of rapid quartz cementation. Quartz (and later -stage carbonate cement, not modeled) cause substantial changes in predicted fluid flow and elastic properties for unfractured part of host rock. Young's modulus of the host rock increases by nearly 50% during active fracturing whereas permeability drops by more than an order of magnitude. Model simulation, R. H. Lander using compositional and textural characteristics derived from the Williams Fork sandstone data set of Ozkan et al. (2011).CC-BY · From the PDF

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Show all 351 references

Research works printed but not linked: 27

  1. Aubertin M., 1996, Rock Mechanics Tools and Techniques
  2. Caputo R., 1995, Evolution of orthogonal sets of coeval joints, Terra Review, 7, 479
  3. Cartwright J., 2003, Subsurface Sediment Mobilization, 223
  4. 10.1130/0016-7606(1998)110<1242:LBCFIF>2.3.CO;2 · doi:10.1130/0016-7606(1998)110
  5. Collins A. G., 1975, Geochemistry of oilfield waters
  6. Cosgrove J. W., 1999, Forced folds and fractures, 7
  7. Keijzer M., 2007, Fractured Reservoirs, 227
  8. Dershowitz W. S., 1992, Rock Mechanics, 33rd US Symposium on Rock Mechanics (USRMS), 757
  9. English J. M., 2017, Geomechanics and Geology, 257
  10. Evans B., 2005, High‐strain zones: Structure and physical properties, 329
  11. Fossen H., 2018, Subseismic‐Scale Reservoir Deformation, 9
  12. Frape S. K., 1987, Saline water and gases in crystalline rocks, 19
  13. Garland J., 2012, Advances in carbonate exploration and reservoir analysis, 311
  14. Geloni C., 2018, Reservoir quality of clastic and carbonate rocks: Analysis, modelling and prediction, 419
  15. Götte T., 2018, Reservoir quality of clastic and carbonate rocks: Analysis, modelling and prediction, 373
  16. Gutmanis J., 2018, Subseismic‐scale reservoir deformation, 139
  17. Hooker J. N., 2012, Advances in carbonate exploration and reservoir analysis, 187
  18. Lander R. H., 1999, Porosity prediction through simulation of sandstone compaction and quartz cementation, AAPG Bulletin, 83, 433
  19. Milligan L. H., 1929, Festigkeit rissigen Glases (strength of glass containing cracks), Journal of the Society of Glass Technology, 13, 351
  20. Olson J. E., 2007, Fracture‐Like Damage and Localization, 123
  21. Olson J. E., 2007, Fractured Reservoirs, 97
  22. Seers T. D., 2014, Advances in the Study of Fractured Reservoirs, 51
  23. 10.1130/0016-7606(1984)95<454:FAGOEF>2.0.CO;2 · doi:10.1130/0016-7606(1984)95
  24. Shao S., 2015, Fundamental controls on fluid flow in carbonates: Current workflows to emerging technologies, 375
  25. Sonnenthal E. L., 2015, Proceedings of 40th Workshop on Geothermal Reservoir Engineering, 728
  26. Spence G. H., 2014, Advances in the study of fractured reservoirs, 1
  27. Welch M. J., 2015, Fundamental controls on fluid flow in carbonates: Current workflows to emerging technologies, 281

Cited by

See all 349

Metadata

Authors
Laubach, S. E., Lander, R. H., Criscenti, L. J., Anovitz, L. M., Urai, J. L., Pollyea, R. M., Hooker, J. N., Narr, W., Evans, M. A., Kerisit, S. N., Olson, J. E., Dewers, T., Fisher, D., Bodnar, R., Evans, B., Dove, P., Bonnell, L. M., Marder, M. P., & Pyrak‐Nolte, L.
Affiliations
  • Bureau of Economic Geology (US)
  • Geocosm LLC Durango CO USA
  • Sandia National Laboratories (US)
  • Oak Ridge National Laboratory (US)
  • RWTH Aachen University (DE)
  • Virginia Tech (US)
  • Pennsylvania State University (US)
  • Chevron Energy Technology Company Houston TX USA
  • Central Connecticut State University (US)
  • Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (US)
  • The University of Texas at Austin (US)
  • Massachusetts Institute of Technology (US)
  • Purdue University West Lafayette (US)
Corresponding author
Laubach, S. E.
Venue
Reviews of Geophysics
Published
2019-09
Volume
57
Issue
3
Pages
1065-1111
ISSN
  • 0096-1043 (ISSN-L)
  • 8755-1209
  • 1944-9208
OpenAlex
W2969274544
Cited by
349
References
351
Citations by year
2026: 62 · 2025: 49 · 2024: 47 · 2023: 59 · 2022: 51 · 2021: 45 · 2020: 31 · 2019: 5
FWCI
19.42
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • Reviews of Geophysics (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • OSTI OAI (U.S. Department of Energy Office of Scientific and Technical Information) (submittedVersion)
  • RWTH Publications (RWTH Aachen) (submittedVersion, other-oa)
  • VTechWorks (Virginia Tech) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • RWTH Publications (RWTH Aachen)
Funders
U.S. Department of Energy (DE‐FG02‐03ER15430, DE‐NA0003525)
Topics
  • Physical Sciences › Engineering › Mechanics of Materials › Rock Mechanics and Modeling
  • Physical Sciences › Energy › Fuel Technology › Hydraulic Fracturing and Reservoir Analysis
  • Physical Sciences › Environmental Science › Environmental Engineering › CO2 Sequestration and Geologic Interactions
Keywords
diagenesis, fracture cementation, subcritical crack growth, machine learning, 3D imaging, subsurface monitoring

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: The Role of Chemistry in Fracture Pattern Development and Opportunities to Advance Interpretations of Geological Materials. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1029/2019rg000671
The paper
Laubach, S. E., Lander, R. H., Criscenti, L. J., Anovitz, L. M., Urai, J. L., Pollyea, R. M., Hooker, J. N., Narr, W., Evans, M. A., Kerisit, S. N., Olson, J. E., Dewers, T., Fisher, D., Bodnar, R., Evans, B., Dove, P., Bonnell, L. M., Marder, M. P., & Pyrak‐Nolte, L. (2019). The Role of Chemistry in Fracture Pattern Development and Opportunities to Advance Interpretations of Geological Materials. Reviews of Geophysics. https://doi.org/10.1029/2019rg000671

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.