Individual and group differences in adoption studies of IQ.

Abstract

In the last 5 years, the Colorado and Texas adoption projects have replicated and elaborated the findings of the classical adoption studies of this century: IQs of adoptees are more strongly related to the IQs of their biological parents than to measurable characteristics of their adoptive environment. At the same time, several studies from France have demonstrated substantial IQ gains in children adopted from impoverished biological parents to middle-class adoptive homes. The apparent contradiction between these two findings is emblematic of the nature-nurture controversy. A common model for resolving the paradox, the two-realms hypothesis, is conceptually inadequate and encourages separate analysis of individual and group differences. Subsuming the two kinds of findings in a single model shows that they are less divergent than they seem and highlights the need for further research into why some contradictions remain. Despite periodic declarations of peace (Clarke, 1984b; Plomin, 1983; Scarr & Weinberg, 1980; Wachs, 1983) or victory (Feldman & Lewontin, 1975; Urbach, 1974), the nature-nurture debate has not been resolved. There are many reasons for its continuation, some scientific and some ideological. Among the most important are the persistently opposite conclusions of two varieties of the adoption design. In one (the individual-difference design), IQs of adopted children are related to the IQs of their biological parents and some measure of the adoptive environment. Posi…

Cited by (7)

1. Intelligence: Knowns and unknowns.
   Neisser, Ulric, Boodoo, Gwyneth, Bouchard, Thomas J., Boykin, A. Wade, Brody, Nathan, Ceci, Stephen J., Halpern, Diane F., Loehlin, John C., Perloff, Robert, Sternberg, Robert J. et al. · 1996 · American Psychologist
2. Socioeconomic Status Modifies Heritability of IQ in Young Children
   Turkheimer, Eric, Haley, Andreana, Waldron, Mary, D'Onofrio, Brian, Gottesman, Irving I. · 2003 · Psychological Science
3. Heritability estimates versus large environmental effects: The IQ paradox resolved.
   Dickens, William T., Flynn, James R. · 2001 · Psychological Review
4. On the relationship between sources of within- and between-group differences and measurement invariance in the common factor model
   Lubke, G · 2003 · Intelligence
5. Investigating Spearman's Hypothesis by Means of Multi-Group Confirmatory Factor Analysis
   Dolan, Conor V. · 2000 · Multivariate Behavioral Research
6. Global Ancestry and Cognitive Ability
   Lasker, Jordan, Pesta, Bryan J., Fuerst, John G. R., Kirkegaard, Emil O. W. · 2019 · Psych
7. Heritability within groups is uninformative about differences among groups: Cases from behavioral, evolutionary, and statistical genetics
   Schraiber, Joshua G., Edge, Michael D. · 2024 · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences