Understanding metaphorical comparisons: Beyond similarity.

Abstract

Traditionally, metaphors such as "my job is a jail " have been treated as implicit similes (i.e., this metaphor would be treated as if it were a comparison statement, "my job is like a jail"). Tversky's account of similarity is applied to such nonliteral similarity expressions, and is shown to apply as readily to nonliteral comparisons as to literal comparisons. But treating metaphors as comparison statements fails to account for certain important phenomena, including metaphoricity itself (the judgment that a comparison statement is nonliteral). We argue that metaphors are exactly what they appear to be: class-inclusion assertions, in which the topic of the metaphor (e.g., "my job") is as-signed to a diagnostic category (e.g., entities that confine one against one's will, are unpleasant, are difficult to escape from). In such assertions, the metaphor vehicle (e.g., "jail") refers to that category, and at the same time is a prototypical exemplar of that category. This account of metaphor provides a basis for a theory of metaphor comprehension, and also clarifies why people use metaphors instead of similes. How do people understand nonliteral expressions such as my grandfather is a baby? Taken literally, this sentence seems false. A grandfather must be an adult, and an adult cannot be of an

Cites (2)

1. Logic and Conversation
   Grice, H. P. · 1975 · Speech Acts
2. Ad hoc categories
   Barsalou, Lawrence W. · 1983 · Memory & Cognition

Show all 2 references

Cited by (7)

1. The Roles of Similarity in Transfer: Separating Retrievability From Inferential Soundness
   Gentner, D., Rattermann, M.J., Forbus, K.D. · 1993 · Cognitive Psychology
2. Metaphor and Poetic Figures
   Shen, Yeshayahu · 2008 · The Cambridge Handbook of Metaphor and Thought
3. Only the tip of the iceberg: Who understands what about metaphor?
   Blasko, Dawn G. · 1999 · Journal of Pragmatics
4. Clinical and experimental perspectives on metaphorical talk
   McCurry, S · 1992 · Clinical Psychology Review
5. Abstract Concepts and the Embodied Mind: Rethinking Grounded Cognition
   Dove, Guy · 2022

See all 867