CoChat

A dendritic disinhibitory circuit mechanism for pathway-specific gating

Open access
Yang, Guangyu Robert, Murray, John D., Wang, Xiao-Jing · 2016 · Nature Communications

Published version of a preprint

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 73 of the 74 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Abstract

While reading a book in a noisy café, how does your brain ‘gate in’ visual information while filtering out auditory stimuli? Here we propose a mechanism for such flexible routing of information flow in a complex brain network (pathway-specific gating), tested using a network model of pyramidal neurons and three classes of interneurons with connection probabilities constrained by data. We find that if inputs from different pathways cluster on a pyramidal neuron dendrite, a pathway can be gated-on by a disinhibitory circuit motif. The branch-specific disinhibition can be achieved despite dense interneuronal connectivity, even with random connections. Moreover, clustering of input pathways on dendrites can naturally emerge through synaptic plasticity regulated by dendritic inhibition. This gating mechanism in a neural circuit is further demonstrated by performing a context-dependent decision-making task. The model suggests that cognitive flexibility engages top-down signalling of behavioural rule or context that targets specific classes of inhibitory neurons.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1038/ncomms12815

Cites

73 of 73 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

Figure 1 Dendritic disinhibitory circuit as a mechanism for pathway-specific gating. (a) Subcellular microcircuit motif for gating through dendritic disinhibition. Dendrites of pyramidal neurons are inhibited by SOM interneurons, which are themselves inhibited by VIP interneurons. A control input (representing a context or a task rule) targeting VIP interneurons (and potentially SOM neurons) can thereby disinhibit pyramidal neuron dendrites, opening the gate for excitatory inputs targeting these dendrites. (b) Circuit configuration for pathway-specific gating. Pyramidal neurons receive converging inputs from multiple pathways, for example, visual and auditory. Single neurons in these areas are selective to multiple stimulus features, indicated here by colour and frequency. The processing of each pathway is regulated by the control input. (c) Inputs from different pathways target distinct subsets of dendrites of these pyramidal neurons. A pathway can be gated-on by specifically disinhibiting the dendrites that it targets, corresponding to an alignment between excitation and disinhibition. Disinhibition is represented by dashed lines.
Figure 1 Dendritic disinhibitory circuit as a mechanism for pathway-specific gating. (a) Subcellular microcircuit motif for gating through dendritic disinhibition. Dendrites of pyramidal neurons are inhibited by SOM interneurons, which are themselves inhibited by VIP interneurons. A control input (representing a context or a task rule) targeting VIP interneurons (and potentially SOM neurons) can thereby disinhibit pyramidal neuron dendrites, opening the gate for excitatory inputs targeting these dendrites. (b) Circuit configuration for pathway-specific gating. Pyramidal neurons receive converging inputs from multiple pathways, for example, visual and auditory. Single neurons in these areas are selective to multiple stimulus features, indicated here by colour and frequency. The processing of each pathway is regulated by the control input. (c) Inputs from different pathways target distinct subsets of dendrites of these pyramidal neurons. A pathway can be gated-on by specifically disinhibiting the dendrites that it targets, corresponding to an alignment between excitation and disinhibition. Disinhibition is represented by dashed lines.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 2 Context-dependent gating of specific pathways. (a) A reduced compartmental neuron with a somatic compartment connected to multiple, otherwise independent, dendritic compartments (only three shown). (b) Excitatory inputs can generate a local, regenerative NMDA plateau potential in the dendrite. As number of activated synapses increased, there is a sharp nonlinear increase in the evoked dendritic membrane depolarization (VD). (c) Disinhibition of the targeted branch opens the gate for the excitatory input. (d) A pyramidal neuron receives converging inputs from multiple pathways carrying different stimulus features, giving it selectivity to a preferred stimulus for each feature dimension. Each input pathway targets separate dendrites, which are disinhibited correspondingly in each context by top-down control inputs (not modelled here). (e) Tuning curve for input pathway 1, when only this pathway is activated. The input pathway encodes a stimulus feature, for example, motion direction, with a bell-shaped tuning curve for the input. The preferred feature value corresponds to higher input firing rate. When gate 1 is open by disinhibiting the dendrites targeted by input pathway 1, the neuron exhibits strong tuning (light blue). When gate 2 is instead open, the neuron exhibits weak tuning for the feature (dark blue). The amount of inhibition reduced for a disinhibited dendrite, that is, the disinhibition level, is 30 Hz. (f,g) Two-dimensional tuning curves when both pathways are activated. (f) In the default context, no dendrites are disinhibited and both pathways are gated-off. The neuron exhibits weak responses regardless of the stimulus features. (g) When gate 1 is open by disinhibiting branches targeted by pathway 1, the response of this neuron is dominated by tuning to the pathway 1 stimulus, although pathway 2 has a residual impact.
Figure 2 Context-dependent gating of specific pathways. (a) A reduced compartmental neuron with a somatic compartment connected to multiple, otherwise independent, dendritic compartments (only three shown). (b) Excitatory inputs can generate a local, regenerative NMDA plateau potential in the dendrite. As number of activated synapses increased, there is a sharp nonlinear increase in the evoked dendritic membrane depolarization (VD). (c) Disinhibition of the targeted branch opens the gate for the excitatory input. (d) A pyramidal neuron receives converging inputs from multiple pathways carrying different stimulus features, giving it selectivity to a preferred stimulus for each feature dimension. Each input pathway targets separate dendrites, which are disinhibited correspondingly in each context by top-down control inputs (not modelled here). (e) Tuning curve for input pathway 1, when only this pathway is activated. The input pathway encodes a stimulus feature, for example, motion direction, with a bell-shaped tuning curve for the input. The preferred feature value corresponds to higher input firing rate. When gate 1 is open by disinhibiting the dendrites targeted by input pathway 1, the neuron exhibits strong tuning (light blue). When gate 2 is instead open, the neuron exhibits weak tuning for the feature (dark blue). The amount of inhibition reduced for a disinhibited dendrite, that is, the disinhibition level, is 30 Hz. (f,g) Two-dimensional tuning curves when both pathways are activated. (f) In the default context, no dendrites are disinhibited and both pathways are gated-off. The neuron exhibits weak responses regardless of the stimulus features. (g) When gate 1 is open by disinhibiting branches targeted by pathway 1, the response of this neuron is dominated by tuning to the pathway 1 stimulus, although pathway 2 has a residual impact.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 3 Characterization of gating selectivity in pyramidal neurons. (a) Schematic of gating, presenting pathway 1 input when gate 1 is opened (left) or gate 2 is opened (right). There are Ndend available dendrites in total. Each input pathway targets Ndisinh dendrites. To gate a pathway on, these exact Ndisinh dendrites are disinhibited, creating an aligned pattern of disinhibition. Each pathway selects dendrites randomly and independently from other pathways, which can result in overlap of the excitation–disinhibition patterns across pathways. When Ndisinh is large, projections from different pathways are more likely to overlap. The neuron's firing rate is ron and roff in response to the preferred stimulus of the gated-on (left) and gated-off (right) pathway, respectively. The gating selectivity is defined as (ron−roff)/(ron+roff), which is 1 for perfect gating and 0 for no gating. (b) Gating selectivity increases as excitation/disinhibition patterns become sparser, that is, with a smaller proportion of targeted and disinhibited dendrites for a pathway (Ndisinh/Ndend). Diamonds mark the case of non-overlapping excitatory projections, corresponding to the limit of maximal sparseness. (c) Gating selectivity is higher with stronger disinhibition, for all sparseness levels.
Figure 3 Characterization of gating selectivity in pyramidal neurons. (a) Schematic of gating, presenting pathway 1 input when gate 1 is opened (left) or gate 2 is opened (right). There are Ndend available dendrites in total. Each input pathway targets Ndisinh dendrites. To gate a pathway on, these exact Ndisinh dendrites are disinhibited, creating an aligned pattern of disinhibition. Each pathway selects dendrites randomly and independently from other pathways, which can result in overlap of the excitation–disinhibition patterns across pathways. When Ndisinh is large, projections from different pathways are more likely to overlap. The neuron's firing rate is ron and roff in response to the preferred stimulus of the gated-on (left) and gated-off (right) pathway, respectively. The gating selectivity is defined as (ron−roff)/(ron+roff), which is 1 for perfect gating and 0 for no gating. (b) Gating selectivity increases as excitation/disinhibition patterns become sparser, that is, with a smaller proportion of targeted and disinhibited dendrites for a pathway (Ndisinh/Ndend). Diamonds mark the case of non-overlapping excitatory projections, corresponding to the limit of maximal sparseness. (c) Gating selectivity is higher with stronger disinhibition, for all sparseness levels.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 4 Gating selectivity as functions of SOM–pyramidal circuit parameters. (a) A simplified model for a cortical column of SOM and pyramidal neurons. We only modelled the SOM-to-pyramidal connections. The model is subject to experimentally measured constraints of the following parameters: number of SOM neurons (NSOM), connection probability from SOM to pyramidal neurons (PSOM→pyr), and the number of dendrites on each pyramidal neuron (Ndend). We consider the ‘worst-case' scenario that the SOM-to-dendrite connections are random. Finally, we assume for now that control input for each pathway suppresses a random subset of SOM neurons. The different contrasts used are for illustration purpose only. (b) A critical parameter for the SOM-to-pyramidal circuit is the number of SOM neurons targeting each dendrite (NSOM→dend). This parameter can be calculated using other experimentally measured parameters under the assumption of random connectivity, . (c–e) Gating selectivity only weakly depends on Ndend (c), NSOM (d) and PSOM→pyr (e) if NSOM→dend is kept constant by co-varying another parameter. The plotted curve marks the mean and the shaded region marks the bottom 10% to top 10% of the neuronal population. (f) Gating selectivity is high when each dendrite is targeted by a few SOM neurons. Given experimental measurements of PSOM→pyr≈0.6, Ndend≈30 and NSOM≈160, we obtained NSOM→dend≈5, leading to relatively high gating selectivity ∼0.5. Total strength of inhibition onto each pyramidal dendrite is always kept constant when varying parameters.
Figure 4 Gating selectivity as functions of SOM–pyramidal circuit parameters. (a) A simplified model for a cortical column of SOM and pyramidal neurons. We only modelled the SOM-to-pyramidal connections. The model is subject to experimentally measured constraints of the following parameters: number of SOM neurons (NSOM), connection probability from SOM to pyramidal neurons (PSOM→pyr), and the number of dendrites on each pyramidal neuron (Ndend). We consider the ‘worst-case' scenario that the SOM-to-dendrite connections are random. Finally, we assume for now that control input for each pathway suppresses a random subset of SOM neurons. The different contrasts used are for illustration purpose only. (b) A critical parameter for the SOM-to-pyramidal circuit is the number of SOM neurons targeting each dendrite (NSOM→dend). This parameter can be calculated using other experimentally measured parameters under the assumption of random connectivity, . (c–e) Gating selectivity only weakly depends on Ndend (c), NSOM (d) and PSOM→pyr (e) if NSOM→dend is kept constant by co-varying another parameter. The plotted curve marks the mean and the shaded region marks the bottom 10% to top 10% of the neuronal population. (f) Gating selectivity is high when each dendrite is targeted by a few SOM neurons. Given experimental measurements of PSOM→pyr≈0.6, Ndend≈30 and NSOM≈160, we obtained NSOM→dend≈5, leading to relatively high gating selectivity ∼0.5. Total strength of inhibition onto each pyramidal dendrite is always kept constant when varying parameters.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 5 Two possible schemes of control for the interneuronal circuit. We built a simplified circuit model containing VIP, SOM and pyramidal neurons. (a–c) Control signals target only VIP neurons. (a) In this scheme, for each pathway, control inputs target a random subset of VIP neurons. And the connection probability from VIP to SOM neurons is PVIP→SOM. (b,c) Good gating selectivity is only achieved when a small subset of VIP neurons is targeted by control inputs (b), and when the VIP–SOM connections are sparse (c). (d–f) Control signals target both VIP and SOM neurons. (d) In this scheme, we assume that for each pathway control inputs target a random subset of VIP and SOM neurons. (e) Gating selectivity depends on the proportion of SOM (blue) but not VIP (green) neurons targeted by control input. (f) Gating selectivity does not depend on PVIP→SOM. Curves and shaded regions are as in Fig. 4.
Figure 5 Two possible schemes of control for the interneuronal circuit. We built a simplified circuit model containing VIP, SOM and pyramidal neurons. (a–c) Control signals target only VIP neurons. (a) In this scheme, for each pathway, control inputs target a random subset of VIP neurons. And the connection probability from VIP to SOM neurons is PVIP→SOM. (b,c) Good gating selectivity is only achieved when a small subset of VIP neurons is targeted by control inputs (b), and when the VIP–SOM connections are sparse (c). (d–f) Control signals target both VIP and SOM neurons. (d) In this scheme, we assume that for each pathway control inputs target a random subset of VIP and SOM neurons. (e) Gating selectivity depends on the proportion of SOM (blue) but not VIP (green) neurons targeted by control input. (f) Gating selectivity does not depend on PVIP→SOM. Curves and shaded regions are as in Fig. 4.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 6 Somatic inhibition improves gating selectivity. (a) PV neurons project to the somatic areas of pyramidal neurons, and are inhibited by SOM neurons and themselves. Suppression of SOM neurons causes disinhibition of PV neurons, therefore an increase in somatic inhibition onto pyramidal neurons. (b) A moderate increase in somatic inhibition always improves gating selectivity. We included PV neurons and their corresponding connections in the model of Fig. 5d. Gating selectivity increases as a function of the SOM-to-PV connection weights (wSOM→PV) in a wide range (see Supplementary Note 1 for a proof). However, when gating selectivity is low without PV neurons (light curve), the peak of this increase is lower and the slope is sharper. Gating selectivity starts to decrease when the SOM-to-PV connection, therefore the somatic inhibition, is too strong that the responses of many pyramidal neurons are completely suppressed.
Figure 6 Somatic inhibition improves gating selectivity. (a) PV neurons project to the somatic areas of pyramidal neurons, and are inhibited by SOM neurons and themselves. Suppression of SOM neurons causes disinhibition of PV neurons, therefore an increase in somatic inhibition onto pyramidal neurons. (b) A moderate increase in somatic inhibition always improves gating selectivity. We included PV neurons and their corresponding connections in the model of Fig. 5d. Gating selectivity increases as a function of the SOM-to-PV connection weights (wSOM→PV) in a wide range (see Supplementary Note 1 for a proof). However, when gating selectivity is low without PV neurons (light curve), the peak of this increase is lower and the slope is sharper. Gating selectivity starts to decrease when the SOM-to-PV connection, therefore the somatic inhibition, is too strong that the responses of many pyramidal neurons are completely suppressed.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 7 Learning to gate specific pathways. (a) Model schematic. Pre- and post-synaptic spikes both induce calcium influx. The overall synaptic weight change is determined by the amount of time the calcium level spends above thresholds for depression (θd) and potentiation (θp)36. The model is fitted to the experimental data, and is able to quantitatively predict results not used in the fitting. (b) Dendritic inhibition makes potentiation harder to induce. With background-level inhibition (light blue), synaptic weight change shows three regimes as a function of excitatory input rate: no change for low rate, depression for medium rate and potentiation for high rate. With a medium level of inhibition (dark blue), potentiation requires a higher excitatory input rate. With relatively strong inhibition (black), potentiation becomes impossible within a reasonable range of excitatory input rates. The post-synaptic rate is fixed at 10 Hz. (c) Learning paradigm. Left: excitatory synapses from each pathway are initialized uniformly across dendrites. When pathway 1 is activated, specific branches of the neuron are disinhibited (dashed line), that is, gate 1 is open. During learning, only one pathway is activated at a time. Right: after learning, activated excitatory synapses onto the disinhibited branches are strengthened, while activated synapses onto inhibited branches are weakened, resulting in an alignment of excitation and disinhibition patterns. Synaptic weights of non-activated synapses remain unchanged (not shown). (d) Response properties of the neuron before learning. Top: tuning curve of the neuron when only pathway 1 is presented. The neuron shows no preference to the gate opened prior to learning. Bottom: two-dimensional tuning curve of the neuron when both pathways are simultaneously presented and gate 1 is open. See Fig. 2 for the definition of the tuning curves. (e) Response properties of the neuron after learning. Top: the neuron shows strong tuning to pathway 1 input when gate 1 is open. Bottom: when both pathways are presented, the neuron's response is primarily driven by pathway 1 stimulus, although pathway 2 stimulus also affects the neuron's firing.
Figure 7 Learning to gate specific pathways. (a) Model schematic. Pre- and post-synaptic spikes both induce calcium influx. The overall synaptic weight change is determined by the amount of time the calcium level spends above thresholds for depression (θd) and potentiation (θp)36. The model is fitted to the experimental data, and is able to quantitatively predict results not used in the fitting. (b) Dendritic inhibition makes potentiation harder to induce. With background-level inhibition (light blue), synaptic weight change shows three regimes as a function of excitatory input rate: no change for low rate, depression for medium rate and potentiation for high rate. With a medium level of inhibition (dark blue), potentiation requires a higher excitatory input rate. With relatively strong inhibition (black), potentiation becomes impossible within a reasonable range of excitatory input rates. The post-synaptic rate is fixed at 10 Hz. (c) Learning paradigm. Left: excitatory synapses from each pathway are initialized uniformly across dendrites. When pathway 1 is activated, specific branches of the neuron are disinhibited (dashed line), that is, gate 1 is open. During learning, only one pathway is activated at a time. Right: after learning, activated excitatory synapses onto the disinhibited branches are strengthened, while activated synapses onto inhibited branches are weakened, resulting in an alignment of excitation and disinhibition patterns. Synaptic weights of non-activated synapses remain unchanged (not shown). (d) Response properties of the neuron before learning. Top: tuning curve of the neuron when only pathway 1 is presented. The neuron shows no preference to the gate opened prior to learning. Bottom: two-dimensional tuning curve of the neuron when both pathways are simultaneously presented and gate 1 is open. See Fig. 2 for the definition of the tuning curves. (e) Response properties of the neuron after learning. Top: the neuron shows strong tuning to pathway 1 input when gate 1 is open. Bottom: when both pathways are presented, the neuron's response is primarily driven by pathway 1 stimulus, although pathway 2 stimulus also affects the neuron's firing.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 8 Pathway-specific gating in an example context-dependent decision-making task. (a) A flexible decision-making task. Depending on the context, the subject's behavioural response should be based on either the colour or the motion direction of the stimulus. (b) The circuit model scheme. Motion and colour pathways target associative sensory neurons, which are subject to context-dependent disinhibitory control. Neurons preferring colour and motion evidence for the same target project to the corresponding neural pool in the decision-making circuit. (c) Associative sensory neurons receive converging inputs from both motion and colour pathways, and are controlled by the dendrite-targeting interneuronal circuit. (d–f) Fit and prediction of behavioural performance. Behavioural performance in the motion context as a function of motion coherence (d) and colour coherence (e) for a monkey (dots), and the model's fit (line). Experimental data are extracted from ref. 28. The model can capture the behavioural performance of a monkey. (f) In the model, the impact of the irrelevant pathway (colour) is strongest when the relevant pathway signal is weak (with low motion coherence).
Figure 8 Pathway-specific gating in an example context-dependent decision-making task. (a) A flexible decision-making task. Depending on the context, the subject's behavioural response should be based on either the colour or the motion direction of the stimulus. (b) The circuit model scheme. Motion and colour pathways target associative sensory neurons, which are subject to context-dependent disinhibitory control. Neurons preferring colour and motion evidence for the same target project to the corresponding neural pool in the decision-making circuit. (c) Associative sensory neurons receive converging inputs from both motion and colour pathways, and are controlled by the dendrite-targeting interneuronal circuit. (d–f) Fit and prediction of behavioural performance. Behavioural performance in the motion context as a function of motion coherence (d) and colour coherence (e) for a monkey (dots), and the model's fit (line). Experimental data are extracted from ref. 28. The model can capture the behavioural performance of a monkey. (f) In the model, the impact of the irrelevant pathway (colour) is strongest when the relevant pathway signal is weak (with low motion coherence).CC BY · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Show all 73 references

Cited by

Items 101–148 of 148

Metadata

Authors
Yang, G. R., Murray, J. D., & Wang, X.-J.
Affiliations
  • New York University (US)
  • Yale University (US)
  • New York University Shanghai (CN)
Corresponding author
Wang, Xiao-Jing
Venue
Nature Communications
Published
2016-09-20
Volume
7
Issue
1
Pages
12815-12815
ISSN
2041-1723 (ISSN-L)
OpenAlex
W2523714899
Cited by
148
References
74
Citations by year
2026: 7 · 2025: 24 · 2024: 14 · 2023: 16 · 2022: 20 · 2021: 16 · 2020: 14 · 2019: 9 · 2018: 12 · 2017: 15 · 2016: 1
FWCI
7.85
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Licence
Locations
  • Nature Communications (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory) (acceptedVersion, cc-by-nc-nd)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • RePEc: Research Papers in Economics (submittedVersion)
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion, cc-by-sa)
Funders
  • National Institutes of Health (UL1TR001863)
  • Office of Naval Research (N00014–13–1-0297, N00014)
  • National Institute of Mental Health (R01MH062349)
  • National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences
Topics
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Cognitive Neuroscience › Neural dynamics and brain function
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Cellular and Molecular Neuroscience › Neuroscience and Neuropharmacology Research
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Cognitive Neuroscience › Memory and Neural Mechanisms
Keywords
dendritic inhibition, pyramidal neurons, interneurons, synaptic plasticity, cognitive flexibility, context-dependent decision making, sensory filtering, neural network model
MeSH terms
Animals, Dendrites, Interneurons, Learning, Models, Neurological, Neural Pathways, Neuronal Plasticity, Parvalbumins, Somatostatin, Vasoactive Intestinal Peptide, Neural Networks, Computer, Pyramidal Cells, Sensory Gating

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.