CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 58 of the 58 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Questioning the regressivity of tobacco taxes: a distributional accounting impact model of increased tobacco taxation

Open access

Abstract

Background: Tobacco taxes, as with other ‘sin taxes’, are generally regarded as a highly cost-effective mechanism to reduce consumption but are often considered by policymakers to be regressive, undermining efforts to fully implement them at levels recommended by the WHO due to concerns of fairness. We aim to demonstrate whether there are circumstances in which the impacts of additional tobacco taxes are not regressive, using a standard income-share accounting definition of tax burden. Methods and findings: We apply mathematical modelling and explore the hypothetical distributions in the net change in tobacco taxes and cigarette expenditures by income group, following an increase in tobacco taxation. The hypothetical distribution per income group of additional taxes and cigarette expenditures borne by individuals following tobacco tax hikes was calculated with respect to a selection of parameters including: the change in the retail price of cigarettes, the price elasticity of demand for tobacco, smoking prevalence, cigarette consumption and individual income. We determine the range of hypothetical parameter values for which increased tobacco taxation should not be considered to penalise the poorest income groups when examining marginal cigarette consumption expenditures and using an accounting definition of tax burden. Conclusions: Our findings question the doctrine that tobacco taxes are uniformly regressive from a standard income-share accounting view and point to the importance of the specific features of tax policy to shape a progressive approach to tobacco taxation: tobacco tax increases are less likely to be regressive when accompanied by a broad framework of demand-side measures that enhance the capacity of low-income smokers to quit tobacco use.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2019-055315

Cites

58 of 58 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

Figure 1 Conceptual framework summarising the distributional accounting model of increased tobacco taxation impacting on the net change in tobacco taxes (denoted ΔT(y), varying with income) and the net change in cigarette expenditures (denoted ΔC(y), varying with income) borne by individuals with income y.
Figure 1 Conceptual framework summarising the distributional accounting model of increased tobacco taxation impacting on the net change in tobacco taxes (denoted ΔT(y), varying with income) and the net change in cigarette expenditures (denoted ΔC(y), varying with income) borne by individuals with income y.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 2 Neutrality frontier (blue, purple or red): relative price increase (r) as a function of price elasticity of demand for the poorest individuals (ε0)) for different values of the initial tax share within the retail price t1 (0=blue (top), 0.30=purple (middle), 0.60=red (bottom)) for which the ratio of net taxes with income is equal across all income groups. Note: the vertical black lines (at ε0=-1.00 and ε0=-0.20) delimit a plausible range of price elasticity estimates for the poorest individuals (see estimates from table 2). The bottom-right pink-shaded area indicates a (ε0;r) parameter space for which the net change in taxes will always be regressive (for an initial tax share within the retail price of t1=0.60). The purple points display three combinations of the (ε0; r) parameters ({−1.50; 0.37}, {−1.00; 0.70} and {−0.50; 1.70}) located on the neutrality frontier when the initial tax share within the retail price is t1=0.30 (purple curve).
Figure 2 Neutrality frontier (blue, purple or red): relative price increase (r) as a function of price elasticity of demand for the poorest individuals (ε0)) for different values of the initial tax share within the retail price t1 (0=blue (top), 0.30=purple (middle), 0.60=red (bottom)) for which the ratio of net taxes with income is equal across all income groups. Note: the vertical black lines (at ε0=-1.00 and ε0=-0.20) delimit a plausible range of price elasticity estimates for the poorest individuals (see estimates from table 2). The bottom-right pink-shaded area indicates a (ε0;r) parameter space for which the net change in taxes will always be regressive (for an initial tax share within the retail price of t1=0.60). The purple points display three combinations of the (ε0; r) parameters ({−1.50; 0.37}, {−1.00; 0.70} and {−0.50; 1.70}) located on the neutrality frontier when the initial tax share within the retail price is t1=0.30 (purple curve).CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 3 Value of the cut-off function yc²=s0(1+ε0(r+t1))/(εgsg(r+t1)).(A) Varying with income gradient in price elasticity εg (while ε0,r, t1, s0, sg are held constant).(B) Varying with income gradient in cigarette consumption sg (while ε0,r, t1, s0, εg are held constant). Full progressivity, where the ratio of net taxes with income increases with income across all income groups, is obtained when yc²=s0(1+ε0(r+t1))/(εgsg(r+t1))≥1. Partial progressivity, when yc<1; and where: the ratio of net taxes with income increases with income for incomes y within 0≤y≤yc§amp;lt;1; and the ratio of net taxes with income decreases with income for incomes y within yc≤y≤1.(C) Full progressivity frontier (blue (top), purple (middle), and red (bottom) curves, where yc²=s0(1+ε0(r+t1))/(εgsg(r+t1))=1): income gradient in price elasticity (εg) as a function of income gradient in cigarette consumption (sg) for which the ratio of net taxes with income increases with income across all income groups. Note: figure parts A and B use the following parameter values: initial tax share t1=0.50, price elasticity for the poorest ε0=-1.00, relative price increase r=0.60 and total cigarette consumption for the poorest s0=0.30*10 (ie, 30% smoking prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption). In figure part A, sg varies from −2.0 (blue (bottom), prevalence from 30% to 10% from poorest to richest), −1.5 (purple (middle), from 30% to 15%), to −1.0 (red (top), from 30% to 20%). In figure part B, εg varies from 1.00 (blue (bottom), elasticity span of −1.00 to 0.00, from poorest to richest), 0.80 (purple (middle), span of −1.00 to −0.20) to 0.60 (red (top), span of −1.00 to −0.40). When yc²§amp;gt;1 (horizontal black line), the net change in additional taxes will be fully progressive. Figure part C uses the following parameter values: t1=0.50, ε0=-1.00, r=0.60 and various values of s0 : 0.30*10 (blue (top), ie, 30% smoking prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption), 0.20*10 (purple (middle), ie, 20% prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption) and 0.10*10 (red (bottom), ie, 10% prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption). The top-left blue-shaded area indicates a (sg;εg) parameter space for which the net change in taxes will be partially progressive (for s0=0.30*10). The beam of curves (blue, purple and red) indicate the full progressivity frontier: below the beam of curves, the net change in taxes will be fully progressive; above, it will be partially progressive. The large coloured points (for εg={0.20;0.50}) display larger consumption gradients (sg={-1.00;-0.66;-0.33}) corresponding to 1.5 times greater consumption among the poorest versus richest; the small coloured points (εg={0.10;0.80}) display smaller consumption gradients (sg={-0.27;-0.18;-0.09}), that is, 1.1 times greater consumption among the poorest versus richest.
Figure 3 Value of the cut-off function yc²=s0(1+ε0(r+t1))/(εgsg(r+t1)).(A) Varying with income gradient in price elasticity εg (while ε0,r, t1, s0, sg are held constant).(B) Varying with income gradient in cigarette consumption sg (while ε0,r, t1, s0, εg are held constant). Full progressivity, where the ratio of net taxes with income increases with income across all income groups, is obtained when yc²=s0(1+ε0(r+t1))/(εgsg(r+t1))≥1. Partial progressivity, when yc<1; and where: the ratio of net taxes with income increases with income for incomes y within 0≤y≤yc§amp;lt;1; and the ratio of net taxes with income decreases with income for incomes y within yc≤y≤1.(C) Full progressivity frontier (blue (top), purple (middle), and red (bottom) curves, where yc²=s0(1+ε0(r+t1))/(εgsg(r+t1))=1): income gradient in price elasticity (εg) as a function of income gradient in cigarette consumption (sg) for which the ratio of net taxes with income increases with income across all income groups. Note: figure parts A and B use the following parameter values: initial tax share t1=0.50, price elasticity for the poorest ε0=-1.00, relative price increase r=0.60 and total cigarette consumption for the poorest s0=0.30*10 (ie, 30% smoking prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption). In figure part A, sg varies from −2.0 (blue (bottom), prevalence from 30% to 10% from poorest to richest), −1.5 (purple (middle), from 30% to 15%), to −1.0 (red (top), from 30% to 20%). In figure part B, εg varies from 1.00 (blue (bottom), elasticity span of −1.00 to 0.00, from poorest to richest), 0.80 (purple (middle), span of −1.00 to −0.20) to 0.60 (red (top), span of −1.00 to −0.40). When yc²§amp;gt;1 (horizontal black line), the net change in additional taxes will be fully progressive. Figure part C uses the following parameter values: t1=0.50, ε0=-1.00, r=0.60 and various values of s0 : 0.30*10 (blue (top), ie, 30% smoking prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption), 0.20*10 (purple (middle), ie, 20% prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption) and 0.10*10 (red (bottom), ie, 10% prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption). The top-left blue-shaded area indicates a (sg;εg) parameter space for which the net change in taxes will be partially progressive (for s0=0.30*10). The beam of curves (blue, purple and red) indicate the full progressivity frontier: below the beam of curves, the net change in taxes will be fully progressive; above, it will be partially progressive. The large coloured points (for εg={0.20;0.50}) display larger consumption gradients (sg={-1.00;-0.66;-0.33}) corresponding to 1.5 times greater consumption among the poorest versus richest; the small coloured points (εg={0.10;0.80}) display smaller consumption gradients (sg={-0.27;-0.18;-0.09}), that is, 1.1 times greater consumption among the poorest versus richest.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 4 Neutrality frontier (red curve including blue points): relative price increase (r) as a function of price elasticity of demand for the poorest (ε0)) for which the ratio of net cigarette expenditures with income is equal across all income groups. Note: the vertical black lines (at ε0=-1.00 and ε0=-0.20) delimit a plausible range of price elasticity estimates for the poorest (see estimates from table 2). The bottom-right pink-shaded area indicates a (ε0;r) parameter space for which the net change in cigarette expenditures will always be regressive. The horizontal purple points display four combinations of the (ε0; r) parameters (all for a relative price increase r=50%): {−0.90; 0.50}, {−0.70; 0.50}, {−0.50; 0.50} and {−0.30; 0.50}. For {−0.90; 0.50}, {−0.70; 0.50}, the net cigarette expenditures will be progressive (beyond pink-shaded area), while for {−0.50; 0.50} and {−0.30; 0.50}, the net cigarette expenditures will be regressive (within pink-shaded area).
Figure 4 Neutrality frontier (red curve including blue points): relative price increase (r) as a function of price elasticity of demand for the poorest (ε0)) for which the ratio of net cigarette expenditures with income is equal across all income groups. Note: the vertical black lines (at ε0=-1.00 and ε0=-0.20) delimit a plausible range of price elasticity estimates for the poorest (see estimates from table 2). The bottom-right pink-shaded area indicates a (ε0;r) parameter space for which the net change in cigarette expenditures will always be regressive. The horizontal purple points display four combinations of the (ε0; r) parameters (all for a relative price increase r=50%): {−0.90; 0.50}, {−0.70; 0.50}, {−0.50; 0.50} and {−0.30; 0.50}. For {−0.90; 0.50}, {−0.70; 0.50}, the net cigarette expenditures will be progressive (beyond pink-shaded area), while for {−0.50; 0.50} and {−0.30; 0.50}, the net cigarette expenditures will be regressive (within pink-shaded area).CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 5 Value of the cut-off function yc²=s0(1+ε0(r+1))/(εgsg(r+1)).(A) Varying with income gradient in price elasticity εg (while ε0,r, s0, sg are held constant).(B) Varying with income gradient in cigarette consumption sg (while ε0,r, s0, εg are held constant). Full progressivity, where the ratio of net cigarette expenditures with income increases with income across all income groups, is obtained when yc²=s0(1+ε0(r+1))/(εgsg(r+1))≥1. Partial progressivity, when yc§amp;lt;1 and where: the ratio of net expenditures with income increases with income for incomes y within 0≤y≤yc§amp;lt;1; and the ratio of net expenditures with income decreases with income for incomes y within yc≤y≤1.(C) Full progressivity frontier (blue (top), purple (middle) and red (bottom) curves, where yc²=s0(1+ε0(r+1))/(εgsg(r+1))=1): income gradient in price elasticity (εg) as a function of gradient in cigarette consumption (sg) for which the ratio of net cigarette expenditures with income increases with income across all income groups. Note: figure parts A and B use the following parameter values: price elasticity for the poorest ε0=-1.00, relative price increase r=0.60, and total cigarette consumption for the poorest s0=0.30*10 (ie, 30% smoking prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption). In figure part A, sg varies from −2.0 (blue (bottom), prevalence from 30% to 10% from poorest to richest), −1.5 (purple (middle), from 30% to 15%), to −1.0 (red (top), from 30% to 20%). In figure part B, εg varies from 1.00 (blue (bottom), elasticity span of −1.00 to 0.00, from poorest to richest), 0.80 (purple (middle), span of −1.00 to −0.20), to 0.60 (red (top), span of −1.00 to −0.40). When yc²§gt;1 (horizontal black line), the net change in cigarette expenditures will be fully progressive. Figure part C uses the following parameter values: ε0=-1.00, and various values of s0 : 0.30*10 (blue (top), ie, 30% smoking prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption), 0.20*10 (purple (middle), ie, 20% prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption) and 0.10*10 (red (bottom), ie, 10% prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption). The top-left blue-shaded area indicates a (sg;εg) parameter space for which the net change in cigarette expenditures will be partially progressive (when s0=0.30*10). The beam of curves (blue, purple and red) indicate the full progressivity frontier: below the beam of curves, the net change in expenditures will be fully progressive; above, it will be partially progressive. The large coloured points (for εg={0.20;0.50}) display larger consumption gradients (sg={-1.00;-0.66;-0.33}) corresponding to 1.5 times greater consumption among the poorest versus richest; the small coloured points (εg={0.10;0.80}) display smaller consumption gradients (sg={-0.27;-0.18;-0.09}), that is, 1.1 times greater consumption among the poorest versus richest.
Figure 5 Value of the cut-off function yc²=s0(1+ε0(r+1))/(εgsg(r+1)).(A) Varying with income gradient in price elasticity εg (while ε0,r, s0, sg are held constant).(B) Varying with income gradient in cigarette consumption sg (while ε0,r, s0, εg are held constant). Full progressivity, where the ratio of net cigarette expenditures with income increases with income across all income groups, is obtained when yc²=s0(1+ε0(r+1))/(εgsg(r+1))≥1. Partial progressivity, when yc§amp;lt;1 and where: the ratio of net expenditures with income increases with income for incomes y within 0≤y≤yc§amp;lt;1; and the ratio of net expenditures with income decreases with income for incomes y within yc≤y≤1.(C) Full progressivity frontier (blue (top), purple (middle) and red (bottom) curves, where yc²=s0(1+ε0(r+1))/(εgsg(r+1))=1): income gradient in price elasticity (εg) as a function of gradient in cigarette consumption (sg) for which the ratio of net cigarette expenditures with income increases with income across all income groups. Note: figure parts A and B use the following parameter values: price elasticity for the poorest ε0=-1.00, relative price increase r=0.60, and total cigarette consumption for the poorest s0=0.30*10 (ie, 30% smoking prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption). In figure part A, sg varies from −2.0 (blue (bottom), prevalence from 30% to 10% from poorest to richest), −1.5 (purple (middle), from 30% to 15%), to −1.0 (red (top), from 30% to 20%). In figure part B, εg varies from 1.00 (blue (bottom), elasticity span of −1.00 to 0.00, from poorest to richest), 0.80 (purple (middle), span of −1.00 to −0.20), to 0.60 (red (top), span of −1.00 to −0.40). When yc²§gt;1 (horizontal black line), the net change in cigarette expenditures will be fully progressive. Figure part C uses the following parameter values: ε0=-1.00, and various values of s0 : 0.30*10 (blue (top), ie, 30% smoking prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption), 0.20*10 (purple (middle), ie, 20% prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption) and 0.10*10 (red (bottom), ie, 10% prevalence and 10-cigarette daily consumption). The top-left blue-shaded area indicates a (sg;εg) parameter space for which the net change in cigarette expenditures will be partially progressive (when s0=0.30*10). The beam of curves (blue, purple and red) indicate the full progressivity frontier: below the beam of curves, the net change in expenditures will be fully progressive; above, it will be partially progressive. The large coloured points (for εg={0.20;0.50}) display larger consumption gradients (sg={-1.00;-0.66;-0.33}) corresponding to 1.5 times greater consumption among the poorest versus richest; the small coloured points (εg={0.10;0.80}) display smaller consumption gradients (sg={-0.27;-0.18;-0.09}), that is, 1.1 times greater consumption among the poorest versus richest.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Show all 58 references

Research works printed but not linked: 6

  1. International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), World Health Organization . Chapter 7: Tax, price and tobacco use among the poor.. In: IARC Handbook of cancer prevention, volume 14: effectiveness of Tax and price policies for tobacco control. Lyon, France: World Health organization, 2011. https://www.iarc.fr/en/publications/pdfs-online/prev/handbook14/handbook14.pdf
  2. Furman J . Six lessons from the U.S. experience with tobacco taxes. World Bank conference: “Winning the Tax Wars: Global Solutions for Developing Countries”, 2016. Available: https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/sites/default/files/page/files/20160524_cea_tobacco_tax_speech.pdf [Accessed 14 Jul 2018].
  3. Gruber, 2002, Smoking’s internalities, Regulation, 2003, 52
  4. International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), World Health Organization . IARC Handbook of cancer prevention, volume 14: effectiveness of tax and price policies for tobacco control, chapter 7: tax, price and tobacco use among the poor. Lyon: World Health Organization, 2011: pp.259–296.
  5. International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), World Health Organization . IARC Handbook of cancer prevention, volume 14: effectiveness of Tax and price policies for tobacco control, chapter 6: Tax, price and tobacco use among young people. Lyon: World Health Organization, 2011: pp.201–258.
  6. International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), World Health Organization . IARC Handbook of cancer prevention, volume 14: effectiveness of Tax and price policies for tobacco control, chapter 4: Tax, price and aggregate demand for tobacco products. Lyon: World Health Organization, 2011: 91–136.

Cited by

See all 35

Metadata

Authors
Verguet, S., Kearns, P. K. A., & Rees, V. W.
Affiliations
Harvard University (US)
Corresponding author
Verguet, Stéphane
Venue
Tobacco Control
Publisher
BMJ
Published
2020-06-23
Volume
30
Issue
3
Pages
245-257
ISSN
  • 0964-4563 (ISSN-L)
  • 1468-3318
OpenAlex
W3036183672
Cited by
33
References
58
Citations by year
2026: 4 · 2025: 4 · 2024: 8 · 2023: 4 · 2022: 9 · 2021: 2 · 2020: 2
FWCI
2.56
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • Tobacco Control (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • HRB National Drugs Library (Health Research Board) (submittedVersion)
  • Edinburgh Research Explorer (University of Edinburgh) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc)
Topics
  • Health Sciences › Medicine › Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health › Smoking Behavior and Cessation
  • Social Sciences › Economics, Econometrics and Finance › Economics and Econometrics › Economic and Fiscal Studies
  • Health Sciences › Medicine › Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health › Global Public Health Policies and Epidemiology
Keywords
tobacco taxation, regressive taxation, sin taxes, tax burden, cigarette consumption, cigarette prices, price elasticity, smoking prevalence, low-income smokers, tobacco control, demand-side interventions
MeSH terms
Smoking Prevention, Commerce, Humans, Taxes, Nicotiana, Tobacco Products, Tobacco Use

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Questioning the regressivity of tobacco taxes: a distributional accounting impact model of increased tobacco taxation. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2019-055315
The paper
Verguet, S., Kearns, P. K. A., & Rees, V. W. (2021). Questioning the regressivity of tobacco taxes: a distributional accounting impact model of increased tobacco taxation. Tobacco Control. https://doi.org/10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2019-055315

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.