CoChat

A randomised controlled trial to measure the effects and costs of a dental caries prevention regime for young children attending primary care dental services: the Northern Ireland Caries Prevention In Practice (NIC-PIP) trial

Open access

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 61 of the 65 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Abstract

Background: Dental caries is the most common disease of childhood. The NHS guidelines promote preventative care in dental practices, particularly for young children. However, the cost-effectiveness of this policy has not been established. Objective: To measure the effects and costs of a composite fluoride intervention designed to prevent caries in young children attending dental services. Design: The study was a two-arm, parallel-group, randomised controlled trial, with an allocation ratio of 1 : 1. Randomisation was by clinical trials unit, using randomised permuted blocks. Children/families were not blinded; however, outcome assessment was blinded to group assessment. Setting: The study took place in 22 NHS dental practices in Northern Ireland, UK. Participants: The study participants were children aged 2–3 years, who were caries free at baseline. Interventions: The intervention was composite in nature, comprising a varnish containing 22,600 parts per million (p.p.m.) fluoride, a toothbrush and a 50-ml tube of toothpaste containing 1450 p.p.m. fluoride; plus standardised, evidence-based prevention advice provided at 6-monthly intervals over 3 years. The control group received the prevention advice alone. Main outcome measures: The primary outcome measure was conversion from caries-free to caries-active states. Secondary outcome measures were the number of decayed, missing or filled tooth surfaces in primary dentition (dmfs) in caries-active children, the number of episodes of pain, the number of extracted teeth and the costs of care. Adverse reactions (ARs) were recorded. Results: A total of 1248 children (624 randomised to each group) were recruited and 1096 (549 in the intervention group and 547 in the control group) were included in the final analyses. A total of 87% of the intervention children and 85% of control children attended every 6-month visit (p = 0.77). In total, 187 (34%) children in the intervention group converted to caries active, compared with 213 (39%) in the control group [odds ratio (OR) 0.81, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.64 to 1.04;p = 0.11]. The mean number of tooth surfaces affected by caries was 7.2 in the intervention group, compared with 9.6 in the control group (p = 0.007). There was no significant difference in the number of episodes of pain between groups (p = 0.81). However, 164 out of the total of 400 (41%) children who converted to caries active reported toothache, compared with 62 out of 696 (9%) caries-free children (OR 7.1 95% CI 5.1 to 9.9;p < 0.001). There was no statistically significant difference in the number of teeth extracted in caries-active children (p = 0.95). Ten children in the intervention group had ARs of a minor nature. The average direct dental care cost was £155.74 for the intervention group and £48.21 for the control group over 3 years (p < 0.05). The mean cost per carious surface avoided over the 3 years was estimated at £251.00. Limitations: The usual limitations of a trial such as generalisability and understanding the underlying reasons for the outcomes apply. There is no mean willingness-to-pay threshold available to enable assessment of value for money. Conclusions: A statistically significant effect could not be demonstrated for the primary outcome. Once caries develop, pain is likely. There was a statistically significant difference in dmfs in caries-active children in favour of the intervention. Although adequately powered, the effect size of the intervention was small and of questionable clinical and economic benefit. Future work: Future work should assess the caries prevention effects of interventions to reduce sugar consumption at the population and individual levels. Interventions designed to arrest the disease once it is established need to be developed and tested in practice. Trial registration: Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN36180119 and EudraCT 2009-010725-39. Funding: This project was funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme and will be published in full in Health Technology Assessment; Vol. 20, No. 71. See the NIHR Journals Library website for further project information.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.3310/hta20710

Cites

61 of 61 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

FIGURE 1 The number of primary teeth extracted under GA in Northern Ireland 2002 -13 (provided by Business Services Organisation of Northern Ireland, Business Services Organisation, Belfast, UK).
FIGURE 1 The number of primary teeth extracted under GA in Northern Ireland 2002 -13 (provided by Business Services Organisation of Northern Ireland, Business Services Organisation, Belfast, UK).CC-BY · From the PDF
FIGURE 2 Total number of children receiving a dental extraction GA in Northern Ireland 2002 -13 (provided by Business Services Organisation of Northern Ireland, Business Services Organisation, Belfast, UK).
FIGURE 2 Total number of children receiving a dental extraction GA in Northern Ireland 2002 -13 (provided by Business Services Organisation of Northern Ireland, Business Services Organisation, Belfast, UK).CC-BY · From the PDF
FIGURE 3 Location of the 22 general dental practices that participated in the Northern Ireland Caries Prevention In Practice trial. Reproduced from Land and Property Services data with the permission of the Controller of Her Majesty ' s Stationery Office, © Crown copyright and database rights. Departmental Memorandum of Understanding 2015.
FIGURE 3 Location of the 22 general dental practices that participated in the Northern Ireland Caries Prevention In Practice trial. Reproduced from Land and Property Services data with the permission of the Controller of Her Majesty ' s Stationery Office, © Crown copyright and database rights. Departmental Memorandum of Understanding 2015.CC-BY · From the PDF
FIGURE 4 The CONSORT flow chart. a, Not randomised ( n = 1207, 49.2%). CDS assessor refusal ( n = 36); parent withheld consent ( n = 138); did not attend ( n = 758); ineligible [ n = 158; caries ( n = 85), age ( n = 35), allergies ( n = 22), hospitalisation ( n = 10), adverse medical history ( n = 2), other trial ( n = 2), history of lactose intolerance ( n = 1) and not known ( n = 1)]; other reasons [ n = 117; patient would not co-operate ( n = 64), sibling recruited ( n = 16), appointment cancelled ( n = 15), parent absent ( n = 11), already on trial ( n = 3), language barrier ( n = 3), family migrating ( n = 2), patient sick ( n = 2) and family left owing to appointment ( n = 1)]. b, Timings and reasons for withdrawals given in Tables 8 and 9 . c, One child attended, but did not have caries examination.
FIGURE 4 The CONSORT flow chart. a, Not randomised ( n = 1207, 49.2%). CDS assessor refusal ( n = 36); parent withheld consent ( n = 138); did not attend ( n = 758); ineligible [ n = 158; caries ( n = 85), age ( n = 35), allergies ( n = 22), hospitalisation ( n = 10), adverse medical history ( n = 2), other trial ( n = 2), history of lactose intolerance ( n = 1) and not known ( n = 1)]; other reasons [ n = 117; patient would not co-operate ( n = 64), sibling recruited ( n = 16), appointment cancelled ( n = 15), parent absent ( n = 11), already on trial ( n = 3), language barrier ( n = 3), family migrating ( n = 2), patient sick ( n = 2) and family left owing to appointment ( n = 1)]. b, Timings and reasons for withdrawals given in Tables 8 and 9 . c, One child attended, but did not have caries examination.CC-BY · From the PDF
FIGURE 5 Recruitment of the trial participants over time.
FIGURE 5 Recruitment of the trial participants over time.CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 6
CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 7
CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 8
CC-BY · From the PDF
FIGURE 6 Cost-effectiveness plane difference in total health-care costs/difference in dmfs.
FIGURE 6 Cost-effectiveness plane difference in total health-care costs/difference in dmfs.CC-BY · From the PDF
FIGURE 7 Cost-effectiveness plane: difference in total health-care costs/difference in proportion caries free.
FIGURE 7 Cost-effectiveness plane: difference in total health-care costs/difference in proportion caries free.CC-BY · From the PDF
FIGURE 8 Cost-effectiveness plane: difference in total health-care costs/difference in episodes of pain.
FIGURE 8 Cost-effectiveness plane: difference in total health-care costs/difference in episodes of pain.CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 12
CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 13
CC-BY · From the PDF
FIGURE 11 Episodes of pain. The CEAC shows the probability of the intervention being deemed value for money at various hypothecated willingness-to-pay thresholds.
FIGURE 11 Episodes of pain. The CEAC shows the probability of the intervention being deemed value for money at various hypothecated willingness-to-pay thresholds.CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 15
CC-BY · From the PDF
Image 16
CC-BY · From the PDF

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Show all 61 references

Research works printed but not linked: 53

  1. World Health Organization, 2011, Oral Health Information Systems: Oral Health Surveillance
  2. Pitts, 2015, Children’s Dental Health Survey 2013. Report 2: Dental Disease and Damage in Children England, Wales and Northern Ireland
  3. Public Health England, 2014, Local Authorities Improving Oral Health: Commissioning Better Oral Health for Children and Young People. An Evidence-Informed Toolkit for Local Authorities
  4. Childsmile, Improving the Oral Health of Children in Scotland
  5. Appleby, 2015, Quarterly Monitoring Report
  6. Health & Social Care Information Centre, 2011, Dental Earnings and Expenses, England and Wales – 2009–10
  7. Lader, 2005, Children’s Dental Health in the UK National Survey 2003
  8. National Dental Epidemiology, 2013, Programme for England: Oral Health Survey of Five-Year-Old Children 2012. A report on the Prevalence and Severity of Dental Decay
  9. Dye, 2012, Oral Health Disparities as Determined by Selected Healthy People. 2020 Oral Health Objectives for the United States, 2009–10. National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, Data Brief Number 104
  10. Northern Ireland Statistics & Research Agency, 2010, Northern Ireland Multiple Deprivation Measure; 2010
  11. Ravaghi, 2015, Children’s Dental Health Survey 2013. Country Specific Report: Northern Ireland
  12. Faculty of Dental Surgery, 2015, The State of Children’s Oral Health in England
  13. NHS England, 2014, Improving Dental Care and Oral Health – A Call To Action
  14. Health & Social Care Information Centre, 2014, NHS Dental Statistics for England: 2014–15. First Quarterly Report
  15. Information Services Division Scotland, Dental Statistics – NHS Treatment and Fees Statistics up to Financial Year 2013/14
  16. Dean, 1945, Fluorine in Dental Public Health, 19
  17. Public Health England, 2014, Sugar Reduction: Responding to the Challenge
  18. Public Health England, 2015, The Relationship Between Dental Caries and Obesity in Children: An Evidence Summary
  19. Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN), 2014, SIGN 138 Dental Interventions to Prevent Caries in Children: A National Clinical Guideline
  20. Health & Social Care Information Centre, 2015, NHS Dental Statistics England 2014/15
  21. Tsakos, 2015, Children’s Dental Health Survey 2013 Report 1: Attitudes, Behaviours and Children’s Dental Health England, Wales and Northern Ireland, 2013
  22. Department of Health, Social Services and Public Safety, 2006, Primary Dental Care Strategy for Northern Ireland
  23. Department of Health, Social Services and Public Safety, 2007, An Oral Health Strategy for Northern Ireland
  24. Public Health Outcomes Framework, Healthy Lives, Healthy People: Improving Outcomes and Supporting Transparency
  25. NHS Scotland, 2013, Route Map to the 2020 Vision for Health and Social Care in Scotland
  26. NHS Scotland, 2015, HEAT Targets Due for Delivery in 2013/14: Summary of Performance
  27. Childsmile, Evaluation Reports
  28. Welsh Assembly Government, 2013, Together for Health: A National Oral Health Plan for Wales (2013–18)
  29. Welsh Assembly Government, 2008, Designed to Smile – A National Child Oral Health Improvement Programme
  30. Welsh Government, 2014, Designed to Smile Monitoring Report – December 2014
  31. World Health Organization (WHO), 2005, The Liverpool Declaration: Promoting Oral Health in the 21st Century
  32. House of Commons Health Select Committee, 2008, Dental Services Fifth Report of Session 2007–08
  33. Department of Health, 2014, NHS Dental Contract Pilots – Learning after First Two Years of Piloting. The Second Report from the Dental Contract Pilots Evidence and Learning Reference Group
  34. Department of Health, 2011, A Dental Quality and Outcomes Framework
  35. Department of Health, 2015, English Dental Prototypes Overview
  36. Welsh Government, 2015, Welsh Dental Pilot Programme
  37. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), 2014, Oral Health: Approaches for Local Authorities and their Partners to Improve the Oral Health of their Communities. NICE guidelines
  38. Northern Ireland Statistics & Research Agency, 2005, Northern Ireland Multiple Deprivation Measure, 2005
  39. Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA), 2014, Duraphat 50 mg/ml Dental Suspension
  40. Northern Ireland Health & Social Care Board, Statement of Dental Remuneration 2014/15, 2024
  41. National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE), 2007, Behaviour Change: the Principles for Effective Interventions. NICE guidelines
  42. NHS Business Services Authority, Vital Signs Report Year End 2014/15
  43. NHS England, 2013, Dental Policies and Procedures. Dental Assurance Framework (General) Tier 2 – Single Contract
  44. Information Service Division Scotland, 2015, Dental Statistics – HEAT Target H9: Fluoride Varnishing for 3 and 4 Year Olds. (Data as at 31 March 2014)
  45. Public Health England, 2014, National Diet and Nutrition Survey Results from Years 1, 2, 3 and 4 (Combined) of the Rolling Programme (2008/2009–2011/2012)
  46. Health and Social Care Information Centre, 2014, Dental Earnings and Expenses: 2012/2013 Initial Analysis
  47. Curtis, 2014, Unit Costs of Health and Social Care 2014
  48. Royal Mail, 2014, Our Prices: Your Handy Guide to Our UK and International Parcel and Letter Services Prices
  49. Department of Enterprise, Trade and Investment, Northern Ireland Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings November 2014
  50. HSC Business Services Organisation, 2014, Statement of Dental Remuneration 2014–2015
  51. Department of Health (DH), 2015, UK NHS Reference Costs 2013–14
  52. AA, AA Motoring Costs 2014
  53. British Dental Association, DCP Pay

Cited by

See all 52

Metadata

Authors
Tickle, M., O’Neill, C., Donaldson, M., Birch, S., Noble, S., Killough, S., Murphy, L., Greer, M., Brodison, J., Verghis, R., & Worthington, H. V.
Affiliations
  • University of Manchester (GB)
  • J.E. Cairnes School of Business and Economics, National University of Ireland, Galway, Ireland
  • Health and Social Care Board (GB)
  • Northern Health and Social Care Trust (GB)
  • British Dental Association (GB)
  • Belfast Health and Social Care Trust (GB)
Corresponding author
Tickle, Martin
Venue
Health Technology Assessment
Published
2016-09
Volume
20
Issue
71
Pages
1-96
ISSN
  • 1366-5278 (ISSN-L)
  • 2046-4924
OpenAlex
W2524393375
Cited by
48
References
65
Citations by year
2026: 1 · 2025: 3 · 2024: 4 · 2023: 4 · 2022: 7 · 2021: 2 · 2020: 7 · 2019: 7 · 2018: 5 · 2017: 7 · 2016: 1
FWCI
9.96
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • Health Technology Assessment (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • Research Explorer (The University of Manchester) (publishedVersion, other-oa)
  • ARAN (University of Galway Research Repository) (Ollscoil na Gaillimhe – University of Galway) (acceptedVersion, cc-by-nc-nd)
  • ARAN (University of Galway Research Repository) (Ollscoil na Gaillimhe – University of Galway) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc-nd)
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion, cc-by-sa)
  • Research Portal (Queen's University Belfast) (submittedVersion, other-oa)
  • ARAN (University of Galway Research Repository) (Ollscoil na Gaillimhe – University of Galway) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc)
  • Research Repository UCD (University College Dublin) (cc-by-nc)
Funders
Health Technology Assessment programme (08/14/19)
Topics
  • Health Sciences › Dentistry › General Dentistry › Dental Health and Care Utilization
  • Social Sciences › Economics, Econometrics and Finance › Economics and Econometrics › Health Systems, Economic Evaluations, Quality of Life
  • Health Sciences › Medicine › Pediatrics, Perinatology and Child Health › Pediatric health and respiratory diseases
Keywords
dental caries, dental caries prevention, young children, fluoride varnish, fluoride toothpaste, primary teeth, DMFS index, cost-effectiveness, adverse effects, NHS dentistry, Northern Ireland, children aged 2-3 years, tooth extraction, dental pain
MeSH terms
Child, Preschool, Cost-Benefit Analysis, Dental Care, Dental Caries, Female, Fluorides, Topical, Humans, Male, Northern Ireland, State Medicine, Toothbrushing, Toothpastes, Single-Blind Method

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: A randomised controlled trial to measure the effects and costs of a dental caries prevention regime for young children attending primary care dental services: the Northern Ireland Caries Prevention In Practice (NIC-PIP) trial. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.3310/hta20710
The paper
Tickle, M., O’Neill, C., Donaldson, M., Birch, S., Noble, S., Killough, S., Murphy, L., Greer, M., Brodison, J., Verghis, R., & Worthington, H. V. (2016). A randomised controlled trial to measure the effects and costs of a dental caries prevention regime for young children attending primary care dental services: the Northern Ireland Caries Prevention In Practice (NIC-PIP) trial. Health Technology Assessment. https://doi.org/10.3310/hta20710

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.