Student or educator? Sign up with your school email and get 6 months of Pro free.
CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 77 of the 80 references it cites were found in a registry or an index, and 1 are not checked yet; none of the 24 sources its claims cite is checked for support yet.

Probing Protein-Protein Interactions Using Asymmetric Labeling and Carbonyl-Carbon Selective Heteronuclear NMR Spectroscopy

Open access

Abstract

Protein-protein interactions (PPIs) regulate a plethora of cellular processes and NMR spectroscopy has been a leading technique for characterizing them at the atomic resolution. Technically, however, PPIs characterization has been challenging due to multiple samples required to characterize the hot spots at the protein interface. In this paper, we review our recently developed methods that greatly simplify PPI studies, which minimize the number of samples required to fully characterize residues involved in the protein-protein binding interface. This original strategy combines asymmetric labeling of two binding partners and the carbonyl-carbon label selective (CCLS) pulse sequence element implemented into the heteronuclear single quantum correlation (1H-15N HSQC) spectra. The CCLS scheme removes signals of the J-coupled 15N–13C resonances and records simultaneously two individual amide fingerprints for each binding partner. We show the application to the measurements of chemical shift correlations, residual dipolar couplings (RDCs), and paramagnetic relaxation enhancements (PRE). These experiments open an avenue for further modifications of existing experiments facilitating the NMR analysis of PPIs.

Checked 2026-11-18 · 1 reference not checked yet

Overview

CoChat Summary

TL;DR

This review describes CCLS/DCLS NMR pulse-sequence strategies that combine asymmetric isotopic labeling with carbonyl-carbon-selective 1H-15N HSQC detection to characterize protein-protein interactions while minimizing sample number. It summarizes applications to chemical shift mapping, RDCs, PRE, and sensitivity-enhanced G5 pulses, including simultaneous detection of two or three binding partners in one sample.

Key findings

  • CCLS 1H-15N HSQC uses spin-echo filtering with a short 15N–13C′ magnetization-transfer period to detect 1H-15N correlations adjacent to NMR-inactive 12C′ carbonyls; reference and suppression spectra are acquired interleaved, and subtraction leaves U-15N,13C species observable, enabling simultaneous amide fingerprints for two binding partners.
  • In a 20-kDa U-13C,15N-ubiquitin sensitivity test at 10, 20, 30, and 40 °C (average T2 = 27, 33, 40, and 47 ms), the reference CCLS-HSQC was more sensitive than conventional HNCO at lower temperatures; the shorter TNC delay increases sensitivity for large proteins/complexes and compensates for S/N loss after suppression subtraction.
  • DCLS extends the approach to three labeled partners (U-15N; 15N,13C′; U-13C,15N) using three interleaved experiments and linear combination to yield individual sub-spectra; proof of concept used non-interacting MBP, Kemptide, and ubiquitin. RDC measurements with CCLS/DCLS and TROSY/anti-TROSY on a non-interacting ternary mixture (U-2H,15N MBP; 15N-Ser5,13C′-Ala4 Kemptide; U-13C,15N ubiquitin) agreed with back-calculated values from MBP and ubiquitin crystal structures.
  • The 1HN-Γ2-CCLS PRE experiment with asymmetric labeling (one partner U-15N, the other U-15N,13C) detected intra- and inter-molecular PREs simultaneously in one sample; applied to transient ubiquitin dimerization (U-15N,13C wild-type and U-15N spin-labeled K48C), with Γ2 rates identical to standard experiments. G5 pulses improved signal intensity from 6% to 23% versus regular CCLS on a Bruker 900 MHz AVIII at 298 K.

Methods

  • Design: review/methodological account of CCLS/DCLS pulse-sequence elements and their integration into NMR experiments for PPIs; includes previously published and some unpublished data (Figure 1C).
  • Samples/data: examples include U-13C,15N ubiquitin; 41 kDa PKA-C and PKIα; ternary mixtures of MBP, Kemptide, and ubiquitin; and ubiquitin dimerization (wild-type and K48C).
  • Main analysis: NMR spectroscopy using 1H-15N HSQC, CCLS/DCLS spin-echo filtering, interleaved reference/suppression spectra, linear subtraction, RDC/TROSY-anti-TROSY, PRE Γ2, and G5 triply compensated π pulses.

Limitations

  • Stated: PPI characterization has been technically challenging because multiple samples are typically required to characterize interface hot spots, and pulse sequences can limit sensitivity; CCLS/DCLS are presented as addressing these issues.
  • Stated: RDC measurements are susceptible to experimental condition variations that alter alignment tensors, making direct correlations across different samples difficult; the one-sample approach is argued to remove sample-inconsistency errors.
  • Evident: DCLS and RDC proof-of-concept applications used non-interacting protein mixtures rather than interacting complexes, and the CCLS/PKA-C–PKIα mutual interaction data are labeled unpublished; the methods require specific asymmetric/selective isotopic labeling schemes (e.g., 13C′ or 13Cα labeling), which may restrict general applicability. No dedicated limitations section is included.

Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.3390/molecules23081937

Cites

77 of 78 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Nothing to recompute.

Figures

Figure 1 CCLS pulse sequence. (A) Schematic of the CCLS-HSQC pulse sequence. It can be assumed, unless otherwise indicated, that all rectangular pulses are applied along the x-axis. 90° and 180° flip angles are represented by narrow bars and wide bars, respectively. The carrier frequency for 1H is set on resonance with water at 4.77 ppm. The carrier frequency for 15N is set in the center of the amide region at 121.8 ppm. The 13C offset is set to 174.8 for the C′ region. The reference spectrum is recorded with the shaped pulse for 13C′ (open rectangle) at the position while the suppression spectrum is recorded with this pulse in position b. A 3-9-19 Watergate pulse scheme is used in the reverse INEPT transfer. GARP1 decoupling with a field strength of 1 kHz is used during the acquisition of 15N. Delay durations: Δ = 2.4 ms, δ = 0.11 ms, TNC′ = 16.5 ms. Phase cycling: φ1 = x, −x, φ2 = x, x, −x, −x, φrec = x, −x. A second FID is acquired for each increment by changing the φ1 phase to y, −y in order to accomplish States quadrature detection for the 15N indirect dimension. The φ1 and φrec phases are also incremented by 180° every other 15N increment for States-TPPI acquisition. The gradients use the Wurst shaped z-axis gradients of 1 ms. Gradient strengths (G/cm): G1: 5, G2: 7, G3: 17. The CCLS-HSQC pulse sequence is based on the fast HSQC experiment [44] to preserve water magnetization. (B) Example spectra representing the reference spectrum, the suppression spectrum, and the resulting subtraction spectrum followed by insets from the PKA-C/PKIα complex displaying the separation of resonances from each species. The blue and red species are present in the reference CCLS-HSQC while the suppression spectrum contains only blue species. Subtraction of the suppression from the reference spectrum results in a third spectrum containing only the red species. (C) CCLS-HSQC experiment on the 50 kDa PKA-C/PKIα complex. The reference spectrum (left, purple) displays resonances from both U-15N labeled PKA-C as well as U-15N, 13C labeled PKIα (S/N = 40). The suppression spectrum (middle, blue) suppresses a signal from the 13C′ labeled PKIα, which shows only peaks from 12C′ labeled PKA-C (S/N = 50). Upon subtraction of the suppression spectrum from the reference spectrum, a sub-spectrum is obtained containing only peaks from the PKIα (right, red) (S/N = 15). (All figures were cited with permission of Springer Nature).
Figure 1 CCLS pulse sequence. (A) Schematic of the CCLS-HSQC pulse sequence. It can be assumed, unless otherwise indicated, that all rectangular pulses are applied along the x-axis. 90° and 180° flip angles are represented by narrow bars and wide bars, respectively. The carrier frequency for 1H is set on resonance with water at 4.77 ppm. The carrier frequency for 15N is set in the center of the amide region at 121.8 ppm. The 13C offset is set to 174.8 for the C′ region. The reference spectrum is recorded with the shaped pulse for 13C′ (open rectangle) at the position while the suppression spectrum is recorded with this pulse in position b. A 3-9-19 Watergate pulse scheme is used in the reverse INEPT transfer. GARP1 decoupling with a field strength of 1 kHz is used during the acquisition of 15N. Delay durations: Δ = 2.4 ms, δ = 0.11 ms, TNC′ = 16.5 ms. Phase cycling: φ1 = x, −x, φ2 = x, x, −x, −x, φrec = x, −x. A second FID is acquired for each increment by changing the φ1 phase to y, −y in order to accomplish States quadrature detection for the 15N indirect dimension. The φ1 and φrec phases are also incremented by 180° every other 15N increment for States-TPPI acquisition. The gradients use the Wurst shaped z-axis gradients of 1 ms. Gradient strengths (G/cm): G1: 5, G2: 7, G3: 17. The CCLS-HSQC pulse sequence is based on the fast HSQC experiment [44] to preserve water magnetization. (B) Example spectra representing the reference spectrum, the suppression spectrum, and the resulting subtraction spectrum followed by insets from the PKA-C/PKIα complex displaying the separation of resonances from each species. The blue and red species are present in the reference CCLS-HSQC while the suppression spectrum contains only blue species. Subtraction of the suppression from the reference spectrum results in a third spectrum containing only the red species. (C) CCLS-HSQC experiment on the 50 kDa PKA-C/PKIα complex. The reference spectrum (left, purple) displays resonances from both U-15N labeled PKA-C as well as U-15N, 13C labeled PKIα (S/N = 40). The suppression spectrum (middle, blue) suppresses a signal from the 13C′ labeled PKIα, which shows only peaks from 12C′ labeled PKA-C (S/N = 50). Upon subtraction of the suppression spectrum from the reference spectrum, a sub-spectrum is obtained containing only peaks from the PKIα (right, red) (S/N = 15). (All figures were cited with permission of Springer Nature).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 2 DCLS Pulsepulse sequence. (A) Schematic of the DCLS-HSQC pulse sequence. It can be assumed, unless otherwise indicated, that all pulses are applied along the x-axis. 90° and 180° flip angles are represented by narrow bars and wide bars, respectively. The reference spectrum is recorded with the shaped pulse for 13C (open rectangle) at position a while the 13C′ suppression spectrum is recorded with this pulse in position b and the 13Cα suppression spectrum is recorded with the 13Cα shaped pulse in position c. A 3-9-19 water-gate pulse scheme is used in the reverse INEPT transfer. GARP1 decoupling with a field strength of 1 kHz is used during the acquisition of 15N. The carrier frequency for 1H is set on the resonance with water at 4.7 ppm. The carrier frequency for 15N is set in the center of the amide region at 120 ppm and the 13C offset is set to 56 ppm. Selective 13C′ (13Cα) sine shaped pulses are centered at 174 (56 ppm) and a null 113 ppm away. Delay durations: Δ = 2.4 ms, δ = 0.11 ms, TNC′ = 16.4 ms, and TNCα = 24.5 ms. Phase cycling: φ1 = x, −x, φ2 = x, x, −x, −x, φrec = x, −x. A second FID is acquired for each increment by changing the φ1 phase to y, −y in order to accomplish states quadrature detection for the 15N indirect dimension. The φ1 and φrec phases are also incremented by 180° every other 15N increment for States-TPPI acquisition. The gradients use the Wurst shaped z-axis gradients of 1 ms. Gradient strengths (G/cm): G1: 5, G2: 7, G3: 17. (B) Example spectra representing the reference spectrum, the two suppression spectra, and the resulting subtraction spectra. The red, green, and blue species are present in the reference of DCLS-HSQC (a) while the first suppression spectrum (b) contains resonances from the blue species and the second suppression spectrum (c) contains resonances from the blue and green species. Subtracting spectrum c from a results in only resonances from the red species and subtracting spectrum c from b yields only resonances from the green species. This linear subtraction scheme results in spectra with each component in the mixture isolated. (All figures were cited with permission of American Chemical Society).
Figure 2 DCLS Pulsepulse sequence. (A) Schematic of the DCLS-HSQC pulse sequence. It can be assumed, unless otherwise indicated, that all pulses are applied along the x-axis. 90° and 180° flip angles are represented by narrow bars and wide bars, respectively. The reference spectrum is recorded with the shaped pulse for 13C (open rectangle) at position a while the 13C′ suppression spectrum is recorded with this pulse in position b and the 13Cα suppression spectrum is recorded with the 13Cα shaped pulse in position c. A 3-9-19 water-gate pulse scheme is used in the reverse INEPT transfer. GARP1 decoupling with a field strength of 1 kHz is used during the acquisition of 15N. The carrier frequency for 1H is set on the resonance with water at 4.7 ppm. The carrier frequency for 15N is set in the center of the amide region at 120 ppm and the 13C offset is set to 56 ppm. Selective 13C′ (13Cα) sine shaped pulses are centered at 174 (56 ppm) and a null 113 ppm away. Delay durations: Δ = 2.4 ms, δ = 0.11 ms, TNC′ = 16.4 ms, and TNCα = 24.5 ms. Phase cycling: φ1 = x, −x, φ2 = x, x, −x, −x, φrec = x, −x. A second FID is acquired for each increment by changing the φ1 phase to y, −y in order to accomplish states quadrature detection for the 15N indirect dimension. The φ1 and φrec phases are also incremented by 180° every other 15N increment for States-TPPI acquisition. The gradients use the Wurst shaped z-axis gradients of 1 ms. Gradient strengths (G/cm): G1: 5, G2: 7, G3: 17. (B) Example spectra representing the reference spectrum, the two suppression spectra, and the resulting subtraction spectra. The red, green, and blue species are present in the reference of DCLS-HSQC (a) while the first suppression spectrum (b) contains resonances from the blue species and the second suppression spectrum (c) contains resonances from the blue and green species. Subtracting spectrum c from a results in only resonances from the red species and subtracting spectrum c from b yields only resonances from the green species. This linear subtraction scheme results in spectra with each component in the mixture isolated. (All figures were cited with permission of American Chemical Society).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 3 CCLS/DCLS RDC. (A,B) Schematic of the gradient-selected TROSY-based pulse sequence for binary (A) or ternary (B) mixtures of proteins. It can be assumed, unless otherwise indicated, that all pulses are applied along the x-axis. 90° and 180° flip angles are represented by narrow bars and wide bars respectfully. The reference spectrum is recorded with the shaped pulse for 13C (open rectangle) at position a while the 13C′ suppression spectrum is recorded with this pulse in position b and the 13Cα suppression spectrum is recorded with the 13Cα shaped pulse in position c. The carrier frequency for 1H is set on resonance with water at 4.77 ppm, the carrier frequency for 15N is set in the center of the amide region at 121.8 ppm, and the 13C offset is set to 56 ppm. Selective 13C′ (13Cα) sine shaped pulses are centered at 174.8 ppm (56 ppm). Delay durations: Δ = 2.4 ms, δ1 = 1.5 s, TNC′ = 16.5 ms, and TNCα = 23.5 ms. Phase cycling: φ1 = x, −x, φ2 = −x, φ3 = −y, φrec = x, −x. Gradient strengths must be adjusted following the relationship G2 = G1·(γN/γH) where γN and γH are the gyromagnetic ratios of 15N and 1H, respectively. A second FID is collected for each increment by changing the φ2 and φ3 to x and y, respectively, and by inverting the sign of the G2 gradient in order to accomplish states quadrature detection for the 15N indirect dimension. The φ1 and φrec phases are also incremented by 180° with every other 15N increment for states-TPPI acquisition. The gradients use the Wurst shaped z-axis gradients of 1 ms. Gradient strengths (G/cm): G3: 3, G4: 13, G5: 4, G6: 5. To measure 1JHN coupling and NH RDC (in aligned media), which is a second spectrum, featuring the anti-TROSY component is acquired by changing the φ3 phase to y. (C) Example spectra representing the reference spectrum, the suppression spectrum, and the resulting subtraction spectrum. The blue and red species are present in the reference CCLS-HSQC while the suppression spectrum contains only blue species. Subtraction of the suppression from the reference spectrum results in a third spectrum containing only the red species. (D) Example spectra representing the reference spectrum, the two suppression spectra, and the resulting subtraction spectra. The red, green, and blue species are present in the reference DCLS-HSQC (a) while the first suppression spectrum (b) contains resonances from the blue species and the second suppression spectrum (c) contains resonances from the blue and green species. Subtracting spectrum c from results in only resonances from the red species and subtracting spectrum c from b yields only resonances from the green species. This linear subtraction scheme results in spectra with each component in the mixture isolated. (All figures were cited with permission of American Chemical Society).
Figure 3 CCLS/DCLS RDC. (A,B) Schematic of the gradient-selected TROSY-based pulse sequence for binary (A) or ternary (B) mixtures of proteins. It can be assumed, unless otherwise indicated, that all pulses are applied along the x-axis. 90° and 180° flip angles are represented by narrow bars and wide bars respectfully. The reference spectrum is recorded with the shaped pulse for 13C (open rectangle) at position a while the 13C′ suppression spectrum is recorded with this pulse in position b and the 13Cα suppression spectrum is recorded with the 13Cα shaped pulse in position c. The carrier frequency for 1H is set on resonance with water at 4.77 ppm, the carrier frequency for 15N is set in the center of the amide region at 121.8 ppm, and the 13C offset is set to 56 ppm. Selective 13C′ (13Cα) sine shaped pulses are centered at 174.8 ppm (56 ppm). Delay durations: Δ = 2.4 ms, δ1 = 1.5 s, TNC′ = 16.5 ms, and TNCα = 23.5 ms. Phase cycling: φ1 = x, −x, φ2 = −x, φ3 = −y, φrec = x, −x. Gradient strengths must be adjusted following the relationship G2 = G1·(γN/γH) where γN and γH are the gyromagnetic ratios of 15N and 1H, respectively. A second FID is collected for each increment by changing the φ2 and φ3 to x and y, respectively, and by inverting the sign of the G2 gradient in order to accomplish states quadrature detection for the 15N indirect dimension. The φ1 and φrec phases are also incremented by 180° with every other 15N increment for states-TPPI acquisition. The gradients use the Wurst shaped z-axis gradients of 1 ms. Gradient strengths (G/cm): G3: 3, G4: 13, G5: 4, G6: 5. To measure 1JHN coupling and NH RDC (in aligned media), which is a second spectrum, featuring the anti-TROSY component is acquired by changing the φ3 phase to y. (C) Example spectra representing the reference spectrum, the suppression spectrum, and the resulting subtraction spectrum. The blue and red species are present in the reference CCLS-HSQC while the suppression spectrum contains only blue species. Subtraction of the suppression from the reference spectrum results in a third spectrum containing only the red species. (D) Example spectra representing the reference spectrum, the two suppression spectra, and the resulting subtraction spectra. The red, green, and blue species are present in the reference DCLS-HSQC (a) while the first suppression spectrum (b) contains resonances from the blue species and the second suppression spectrum (c) contains resonances from the blue and green species. Subtracting spectrum c from results in only resonances from the red species and subtracting spectrum c from b yields only resonances from the green species. This linear subtraction scheme results in spectra with each component in the mixture isolated. (All figures were cited with permission of American Chemical Society).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 4 CCLS-PRE. (A) Schematic of the standard experiment for the detection of intra-molecular and inter-molecular PRE. In this case, four different samples are needed. The first sample for the intra-molecular PRE is prepared with an asymmetric labeling scheme using the first binding partner uniformly 15N labeled with a conjugated spin label (SL) and the second is NMR silent (unlabeled). A sample with a reversed labeling scheme is necessary to detect the intra-molecular PRE for the second binding partner (top panel A). For the inter-molecular PRE, two additional samples are required: one NMR silent with the conjugated SL and a second NMR active (e.g., 15N or 13C labeled) (lower panel A). Simultaneous detection of inter-molecular and intra-molecular PRE using 1HN-Γ2-CCLS experiment. One species is uniformly 15N labeled while the other is 13C and 15N labeled (b) allowing for the simultaneous detection of intra-molecular and inter-molecular PREs. As reported before, reverse positioning of the SL is required for obtaining a complete characterization of the complex. (B) The 1H-Γ2-CCLS pulse sequence for PRE Γ2 measurements. The narrow and wide bars represent 90° and 180° hard pulses, respectively. The three 13C 180° shaped pulses are 256 μs long Q3 pulse, the first two and the last one shaped pulses are applied to 13C′ and 13Cα, respectively. The 13C′ 180° shaped pulse may be at either position a or b. When it is at position a, the 1JNC′ is decoupled and reference spectra are acquired. When it is at position b, the 1JNC′ is present and 13C′-suppressed spectra are acquired. The flipping angles and phases of the pulses in 3919 are 20.8°x, 62.2°x, 131.6°x, 131.6°−x, 62.2°−x, and 20.8°−x, respectively, and the interval between pulses is 188 μs (=1/d, d is the distance in Hz between center and next null). T = 16.5 ms, Δ = 2.6 ms, G1 = (1 ms, 25.0 G/cm), G2 = (0.3 ms, 5.0 G/cm), G3 = (0.3 ms, 8.0 G/cm), G4 = (1 ms, 15.0 G/cm), and G5 = (1 ms, 10.0 G/cm). The phase cycling scheme is φ1 = (x, −x), φ2 = (x, x, −x, −x), φ3 = 4(x), 4(−x), φrec = (x, −x, x, −x, −x, x, −x, x). The quadrature detections in t1 dimension are acquired via States-TPPI of φ1. Constant time mode is used to measure Γ2, which is Γ2=Ln(S1/S2)/(τ2−τ1), where S1 and S2 are signal intensities of a peak measured with τ=τ1 and τ=τ2, respectively. 2 × 2 spectra are acquired in an interleave mode via changing relaxation delay τ (minimum 2 ms) and changing the 13C′ 180° shaped pulse from position a to b, respectively. (C) Intra-molecular and inter-molecular PRE measurements of 15N-UbiK48C obtained with the 1H-Γ2-CCLS experiment. The 1HN-Γ2 rate plot calculated for K48C mutant conjugate with MTSL in presence of UbiWT (upper panel C). The 1HN-Γ2 rate plot calculated for WT ubiquitin in the presence of UbiK48C-MTSL (lower panel C). (All figures were cited with permission of Springer Nature).
Figure 4 CCLS-PRE. (A) Schematic of the standard experiment for the detection of intra-molecular and inter-molecular PRE. In this case, four different samples are needed. The first sample for the intra-molecular PRE is prepared with an asymmetric labeling scheme using the first binding partner uniformly 15N labeled with a conjugated spin label (SL) and the second is NMR silent (unlabeled). A sample with a reversed labeling scheme is necessary to detect the intra-molecular PRE for the second binding partner (top panel A). For the inter-molecular PRE, two additional samples are required: one NMR silent with the conjugated SL and a second NMR active (e.g., 15N or 13C labeled) (lower panel A). Simultaneous detection of inter-molecular and intra-molecular PRE using 1HN-Γ2-CCLS experiment. One species is uniformly 15N labeled while the other is 13C and 15N labeled (b) allowing for the simultaneous detection of intra-molecular and inter-molecular PREs. As reported before, reverse positioning of the SL is required for obtaining a complete characterization of the complex. (B) The 1H-Γ2-CCLS pulse sequence for PRE Γ2 measurements. The narrow and wide bars represent 90° and 180° hard pulses, respectively. The three 13C 180° shaped pulses are 256 μs long Q3 pulse, the first two and the last one shaped pulses are applied to 13C′ and 13Cα, respectively. The 13C′ 180° shaped pulse may be at either position a or b. When it is at position a, the 1JNC′ is decoupled and reference spectra are acquired. When it is at position b, the 1JNC′ is present and 13C′-suppressed spectra are acquired. The flipping angles and phases of the pulses in 3919 are 20.8°x, 62.2°x, 131.6°x, 131.6°−x, 62.2°−x, and 20.8°−x, respectively, and the interval between pulses is 188 μs (=1/d, d is the distance in Hz between center and next null). T = 16.5 ms, Δ = 2.6 ms, G1 = (1 ms, 25.0 G/cm), G2 = (0.3 ms, 5.0 G/cm), G3 = (0.3 ms, 8.0 G/cm), G4 = (1 ms, 15.0 G/cm), and G5 = (1 ms, 10.0 G/cm). The phase cycling scheme is φ1 = (x, −x), φ2 = (x, x, −x, −x), φ3 = 4(x), 4(−x), φrec = (x, −x, x, −x, −x, x, −x, x). The quadrature detections in t1 dimension are acquired via States-TPPI of φ1. Constant time mode is used to measure Γ2, which is Γ2=Ln(S1/S2)/(τ2−τ1), where S1 and S2 are signal intensities of a peak measured with τ=τ1 and τ=τ2, respectively. 2 × 2 spectra are acquired in an interleave mode via changing relaxation delay τ (minimum 2 ms) and changing the 13C′ 180° shaped pulse from position a to b, respectively. (C) Intra-molecular and inter-molecular PRE measurements of 15N-UbiK48C obtained with the 1H-Γ2-CCLS experiment. The 1HN-Γ2 rate plot calculated for K48C mutant conjugate with MTSL in presence of UbiWT (upper panel C). The 1HN-Γ2 rate plot calculated for WT ubiquitin in the presence of UbiK48C-MTSL (lower panel C). (All figures were cited with permission of Springer Nature).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 5 CCLS G5 pulse implementation. (A) CCLS 1H–15N HSQC reference spectrum of 15N, 13C UbiWT, and U-15N UbiK48C mutant. (B) Overlay spectra of the UbiWT alanine 46 peak demonstrating a 23% signal intensity improvement with the G5 pulse. (C) Overlay spectra of the UbiK48C alanine 46 peak demonstrating an 18% signal intensity improvement with the G5 pulse. (D) Overlay spectra of the glycine 75 peak demonstrating a 6% improvement with the G5 pulse. (All figures were cited with permission of Springer Nature).
Figure 5 CCLS G5 pulse implementation. (A) CCLS 1H–15N HSQC reference spectrum of 15N, 13C UbiWT, and U-15N UbiK48C mutant. (B) Overlay spectra of the UbiWT alanine 46 peak demonstrating a 23% signal intensity improvement with the G5 pulse. (C) Overlay spectra of the UbiK48C alanine 46 peak demonstrating an 18% signal intensity improvement with the G5 pulse. (D) Overlay spectra of the glycine 75 peak demonstrating a 6% improvement with the G5 pulse. (All figures were cited with permission of Springer Nature).CC BY · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

0 Valid · 0 Not valid · 15 Not checked · 11 Own results and interpretations

14 more claims

Create a free account to see all 26 claims and to verify the 23 references still open.

See all claims — free account
  • It may state two separate claims as one. 5
  • The quote only partly states this claim. 1
  • Probably not a substantial claim. 1

Create a free account to see these claims.

Citations

Cites

Cited by

See all 13

Metadata

Authors
Larsen, E. K., Olivieri, C., Walker, C., V.S., M., Gao, J., Bernlohr, D. A., Tonelli, M., Markley, J. L., & Veglia, G.
Affiliations
  • University of Minnesota (US)
  • Department of Biochemistry, Molecular Biology, and Biophysics, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN 55455, USA
  • University of Wisconsin–Madison (US)
Corresponding author
Veglia, Gianluigi
Venue
Molecules
Publisher
MDPI AG
Published
2018-08-03
Volume
23
Issue
8
Pages
1937
ISSN
1420-3049 (ISSN-L)
OpenAlex
W2887185742
Cited by
13
References
80
Citations by year
2026: 1 · 2025: 2 · 2021: 2 · 2020: 6 · 2019: 1 · 2018: 1
FWCI
0.28
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • Molecules (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • Europe PMC (PubMed Central) (publishedVersion, other-oa)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • Archivio Istituzionale della Ricerca (Universita Degli Studi Di Milano) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion, cc-by-sa)
Funders
National Institutes of Health (GM 100310)
Topics
  • Physical Sciences › Chemistry › Spectroscopy › Advanced NMR Techniques and Applications
  • Life Sciences › Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology › Molecular Biology › Protein Structure and Dynamics
  • Physical Sciences › Chemistry › Spectroscopy › Molecular spectroscopy and chirality
Keywords
protein-protein interaction, 1H-15N HSQC, binding interface, chemical shift correlation, residual dipolar couplings, paramagnetic relaxation enhancement
MeSH terms
Carbon Isotopes, Isotope Labeling, Nitrogen Isotopes, Protein Binding, Protein Conformation, Proteins, Nuclear Magnetic Resonance, Biomolecular

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-11-18, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).

A second model labelled each claim on 2026-11-18 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.