Student or educator? Sign up with your school email and get 6 months of Pro free.
CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 458 of the 516 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 156 of the 422 sources its claims cite were checked for support.

The Fermi/eROSITA bubbles: a look into the nuclear outflow from the Milky Way

Open access
Sarkar, Kartick C. · 2024 · The Astronomy and Astrophysics Review

Abstract

Galactic outflows are ubiquitous in galaxies containing active star formation or supermassive black hole activity. The presence of a large-scale outflow from the center of our own Galaxy was confirmed after the discovery of two large (~ 8–10 kpc) γ\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\gamma $$\end{document}-ray bubbles using the Fermi-LAT telescope. These bubbles, known as the Fermi Bubbles, are highly symmetric about the Galactic disk as well as around the Galactic rotation axis and appear to emanate from the center of our Galaxy. The sharp edges of these bubbles suggest that they are related to the Galactic outflow. These bubbles are surrounded by two even bigger (~ 12–14 kpc) X-ray structures, known as the eROSITA bubbles. Together, they represent the characteristics of an outflow from the Galaxy into the circumgalactic medium. Multi-wavelength observations such as in radio, microwave, and UV toward the Fermi Bubbles have provided us with much information in the last decade. However, the origin and the nature of these bubbles remain elusive. In this review, I summarize the observations related to the Fermi/eROSITA Bubbles at different scales and wavelengths, and give a brief overview of our current understanding of them.

Overview

CoChat Summary

TL;DR

This review synthesizes multi-wavelength observations and theoretical models of the Fermi and eROSITA bubbles, the large-scale nuclear outflow from the Milky Way. It concludes that the γ-ray emission is likely leptonic, but the mechanical energy source and whether the two bubble systems share a single event remain unresolved.

Key findings

  • The Fermi Bubbles are γ-ray structures extending to ≈ ±20° in Galactic longitude and ≈ ±50° in latitude, covering almost 5% of the sky; each is ≈ 7 kpc wide and ≈ 10 kpc long, with a typical γ-ray flux of ≈ 4 × 10⁻⁷ GeV cm⁻² s⁻¹ sr⁻¹ in 1–100 GeV and luminosity ≈ 4 × 10³⁷ erg s⁻¹.
  • The eROSITA bubbles are larger X-ray shells at ≈ 12–14 kpc, with plasma temperature ≈ 0.3 keV, thermal energy ≈ 10⁵⁶ erg, dynamical time ≈ 20 Myr, and power ≈ 10⁴¹ erg s⁻¹; the North Polar Spur/eROSITA bubbles are now understood as Galactic Center activity, though distance estimates conflict with local ≈ 200 pc claims.
  • The γ-ray spectral origin is likely leptonic rather than hadronic: the hadronic channel cannot fully explain the microwave haze and simulations limit its contribution, while leptonic inverse-Compton emission plus in-situ cosmic-ray electron acceleration can explain both the γ-ray and microwave haze, requiring B ≈ 5–10 µG.
  • The mechanical energy source remains debated: star-formation-driven models require SFR ≈ 0.5 M⊙ yr⁻¹ over ≈ 27 Myr or enhanced SFR ≈ 0.2–0.8 M⊙ yr⁻¹ over the last ≈ 30 Myr, while AGN models require past SMBH power enhanced by factors of 10³–10⁷; the Fermi Bubble age is likely ≈ 6–30 Myr.

Methods

  • Review article; no new data are presented. It synthesizes multi-wavelength observations from Fermi-LAT γ-ray, eROSITA/ROSAT X-ray, WMAP/Planck radio/microwave, UV/optical absorption and emission, and H I/CO surveys.
  • It compares theoretical models for the bubbles, including SNe-driven winds, AGN jets/winds/bursts, TDEs, and hadronic versus leptonic γ-ray production, against the observational constraints.

Limitations

  • The paper states that no single theoretical model has reproduced all observational features simultaneously; open questions include the Fermi Bubble age, whether the Fermi and eROSITA bubbles originated from the same or separate events, and whether SNe or the central SMBH power them.
  • The paper notes unresolved issues: the NPS distance (Galactic ≈ 8 kpc versus local ≈ 200 pc), uncertain eROSITA bubble temperature (≈ 0.2, ≈ 0.3, or ≈ 0.7 keV depending on plasma assumptions), and discrepant CMZ star-formation-rate estimates (≈ 0.07–0.09 M⊙ yr⁻¹ versus ≈ 0.2–0.8 M⊙ yr⁻¹).
  • Evident from the text: many quoted ages, powers, and star-formation rates are model-dependent, and the review relies on heterogeneous literature rather than new observations.

Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1007/s00159-024-00152-1

Cites

458 of 459 references verified0 citation errors · 1 not checkable

Statistics

Nothing to recompute.

Figures

Fig. 1 Bubbles and winds in different systems. (a) galaxy M82, mass ∼ 5 × 10 10 M ⊙ , SFR ≈ 10 M ⊙ yr -1 . Credit: X-ray: NASA / CXC / JHU / D.Strickland; Optical: NASA / ESA / STScI / AURA / The Hubble Heritage Team; IR: NASA / JPL-Caltech / Univ. of AZ / C. Engelbracht. (b) galaxy NGC 3079, mass ∼ 10 12 M ⊙ , SFR ≈ 10 M ⊙ yr -1 , AGN power ∼ 7 × 10 42 erg s -1 . Credit NASA / CXC / SAO, and (c) galaxy cluster MS 0735, mass ∼ 10 15 M ⊙ , AGN power ∼ 2 × 10 46 erg s -1 . Credit: X-ray: NASA / CXC / Univ. Waterloo / B.McNamara; Optical: NASA / ESA / STScI / Univ. Waterloo / B.McNamara; Radio: NRAO / Ohio Univ. / L.Birzan et al. The physical extent of each image is noted at the top of the image.
Fig. 1 Bubbles and winds in different systems. (a) galaxy M82, mass ∼ 5 × 10 10 M ⊙ , SFR ≈ 10 M ⊙ yr -1 . Credit: X-ray: NASA / CXC / JHU / D.Strickland; Optical: NASA / ESA / STScI / AURA / The Hubble Heritage Team; IR: NASA / JPL-Caltech / Univ. of AZ / C. Engelbracht. (b) galaxy NGC 3079, mass ∼ 10 12 M ⊙ , SFR ≈ 10 M ⊙ yr -1 , AGN power ∼ 7 × 10 42 erg s -1 . Credit NASA / CXC / SAO, and (c) galaxy cluster MS 0735, mass ∼ 10 15 M ⊙ , AGN power ∼ 2 × 10 46 erg s -1 . Credit: X-ray: NASA / CXC / Univ. Waterloo / B.McNamara; Optical: NASA / ESA / STScI / Univ. Waterloo / B.McNamara; Radio: NRAO / Ohio Univ. / L.Birzan et al. The physical extent of each image is noted at the top of the image.From the PDF
Fig. 2 Fermi-LAT all-sky maps. Panel (a) : 12-yr view of the γ -ray sky ( E > 1 GeV), shown in Hammer projection. The bright central plane represents the Galactic disk where most of the γ -ray emission is due to the CR protons produced by supernovae shocks. Bright point sources outside the disk are external galaxies powered by AGNs. The most important structures for this review are marked as the Loop-I and the Fermi Bubbles. Credit:NASA / DOE / Fermi LAT Collaboration. Panel (b) and (c) : Significance map of the residual after modeling known γ -ray structures in a 50-month sky map. High 'sigma' in the residual map indicates un-modeled emission and shows the presence of new structures that are not correlated with the gaseous foreground map. The left and right panels show further breakdown into components that have soft (photon flux, dN / dE ∝ E -2 . 4 ) and hard (photon flux, dN / dE ∝ E -1 . 9 ) spectral indices, respectively. The image is reprinted from Ackermann et al. (2014), with authors' permission (copyright by AAS). For a reconstructed γ -ray sky map, see Scheel-Platz et al. (2023).
Fig. 2 Fermi-LAT all-sky maps. Panel (a) : 12-yr view of the γ -ray sky ( E > 1 GeV), shown in Hammer projection. The bright central plane represents the Galactic disk where most of the γ -ray emission is due to the CR protons produced by supernovae shocks. Bright point sources outside the disk are external galaxies powered by AGNs. The most important structures for this review are marked as the Loop-I and the Fermi Bubbles. Credit:NASA / DOE / Fermi LAT Collaboration. Panel (b) and (c) : Significance map of the residual after modeling known γ -ray structures in a 50-month sky map. High 'sigma' in the residual map indicates un-modeled emission and shows the presence of new structures that are not correlated with the gaseous foreground map. The left and right panels show further breakdown into components that have soft (photon flux, dN / dE ∝ E -2 . 4 ) and hard (photon flux, dN / dE ∝ E -1 . 9 ) spectral indices, respectively. The image is reprinted from Ackermann et al. (2014), with authors' permission (copyright by AAS). For a reconstructed γ -ray sky map, see Scheel-Platz et al. (2023).From the PDF
Fig. 3 Spectrum of the Fermi Bubbles for different exposure times. The data from the discovery paper (Su et al. 2010) is shown in green. The blue and red points show the spectrum after longer exposure times and are taken from Su & Finkbeiner (2012) and Ackermann et al. (2014), respectively. The apparent discrepancy between different papers is mostly due to uncertainties in modeling Galactic foregrounds and analysis strategy. The gray dotted lines represent the typical spectral slopes for IC (from CR electrons) and Hadronic (p-p) emission mechanisms for a given CR population. The black solid and dashed lines represent more accurate spectra for these processes (see section 4).
Fig. 3 Spectrum of the Fermi Bubbles for different exposure times. The data from the discovery paper (Su et al. 2010) is shown in green. The blue and red points show the spectrum after longer exposure times and are taken from Su & Finkbeiner (2012) and Ackermann et al. (2014), respectively. The apparent discrepancy between different papers is mostly due to uncertainties in modeling Galactic foregrounds and analysis strategy. The gray dotted lines represent the typical spectral slopes for IC (from CR electrons) and Hadronic (p-p) emission mechanisms for a given CR population. The black solid and dashed lines represent more accurate spectra for these processes (see section 4).From the PDF
Fig. 4 X-ray and radio sky maps. Panel (a) : soft X-ray (0 . 6 -1 keV) sky map from eROSITA telescope highlighting the existence of two X-ray shells ( eROSITA bubbles) symmetric across the Galactic plane and the Galactic axis. The typical brightness of the shells is ∼ 3 × 10 -3 cts s -1 arcmin -2 . . Image reprinted with permission from Predehl et al. (2020) (copyright by the authors). Panel (b) : ROSAT sky map of the central 50 ◦ of the Galaxy in the 0 . 73 -1 . 56 keV range (Snowden et al. 1997) showing the central x-shaped X-ray emission coinciding with the outer edges of the FBs (magenta circles, Su et al. 2010). The color scale is in units of cts s -1 arcmin -2 . The lower photon count in ROSAT is due to the ∼ 10 times smaller effective area compared to eROSITA . Panel (c) : Brightness temperature (in excess of the CMB) map at 28 . 4 GHz. The edges of the eROSITA bubbles and the FBs are shown using the magenta and cyan circles, respectively. The typical brightness inside the eROSITA bubbles region is ∼ 50 µ K. Image reprinted from Planck Collaboration et al. (2016) (copyright by ESO). Panel (d) : Central 50 ◦ view of the sky at 30 GHz (red) and 44 GHz (yellow) after removing the Loop-I and the Galactic disk-related emission. Image reprinted from (Planck Collaboration et al. 2013) with authors' permission (copyright by ESO). Typical brightness temperature is ∼ 20 µ K. The dark patches represent the regions excluded from the template analysis due to high contamination by the disk emission. Panel (e) : Polarization intensity map of WMAP at 23 GHz (Vidal et al. 2015). The small black lines represent the magnetic field orientation (perpendicular to the direction of the polarization vector). Overall alignment of the magnetic field can be seen along both the North Polar Spur (NPS) and South Polar Spur (SPS). Blue circles show the previously proposed full shape of Loop-I. Panel (f) : WMAP 1.4 GHz polarization map for the central 50 ◦ showing strong depolarization near the Galactic disk (Vidal et al. 2015). The gray region was not observed in the survey. Images for the panels (e) and (f) are reprinted with permission from Vidal et al. (2015) (copyright by the authors).
Fig. 4 X-ray and radio sky maps. Panel (a) : soft X-ray (0 . 6 -1 keV) sky map from eROSITA telescope highlighting the existence of two X-ray shells ( eROSITA bubbles) symmetric across the Galactic plane and the Galactic axis. The typical brightness of the shells is ∼ 3 × 10 -3 cts s -1 arcmin -2 . . Image reprinted with permission from Predehl et al. (2020) (copyright by the authors). Panel (b) : ROSAT sky map of the central 50 ◦ of the Galaxy in the 0 . 73 -1 . 56 keV range (Snowden et al. 1997) showing the central x-shaped X-ray emission coinciding with the outer edges of the FBs (magenta circles, Su et al. 2010). The color scale is in units of cts s -1 arcmin -2 . The lower photon count in ROSAT is due to the ∼ 10 times smaller effective area compared to eROSITA . Panel (c) : Brightness temperature (in excess of the CMB) map at 28 . 4 GHz. The edges of the eROSITA bubbles and the FBs are shown using the magenta and cyan circles, respectively. The typical brightness inside the eROSITA bubbles region is ∼ 50 µ K. Image reprinted from Planck Collaboration et al. (2016) (copyright by ESO). Panel (d) : Central 50 ◦ view of the sky at 30 GHz (red) and 44 GHz (yellow) after removing the Loop-I and the Galactic disk-related emission. Image reprinted from (Planck Collaboration et al. 2013) with authors' permission (copyright by ESO). Typical brightness temperature is ∼ 20 µ K. The dark patches represent the regions excluded from the template analysis due to high contamination by the disk emission. Panel (e) : Polarization intensity map of WMAP at 23 GHz (Vidal et al. 2015). The small black lines represent the magnetic field orientation (perpendicular to the direction of the polarization vector). Overall alignment of the magnetic field can be seen along both the North Polar Spur (NPS) and South Polar Spur (SPS). Blue circles show the previously proposed full shape of Loop-I. Panel (f) : WMAP 1.4 GHz polarization map for the central 50 ◦ showing strong depolarization near the Galactic disk (Vidal et al. 2015). The gray region was not observed in the survey. Images for the panels (e) and (f) are reprinted with permission from Vidal et al. (2015) (copyright by the authors).From the PDF
Fig. 5 Panel a : Spatial extinction map around the Sun obtained from a catalog of ≈ 35 Million stars. The direction to the NPS is shown using the blue arrow. Contour lines, starting from red to blue, represent iso-extinction levels of 10 -5 , 5 × 10 -5 , 10 -4 , 2 × 10 -4 , 5 × 10 -4 , 10 -3 , 2 × 10 -3 , 5 × 10 -3 , 10 -2 , and 2 × 10 -2 mag pc -1 . The image is reprinted with permission from Vergely et al. (2022) (copyright by the authors). Panel (b) : Hydrogen column density (obtained from extinction) at different latitudes toward the North-East base of the NPS (Green et al. 2015; Lallement et al. 2016). The right part of the figure shows the column density required to explain the absorption features of XMM-Newton spectra along those directions. Image reprinted from Lallement et al. (2016) with authors' permission (copyright by ESO). Panel (c) : H i emission map at the GC, showing the presence of a H i hole within the central 2 . 4 kpc. The yellow circles show the H α regions (i.e. star-forming), the red circles show the edge of the FBs, and the cyan circles show the outline of an X-ray arc, known as the northern arc (Su et al. 2010). Image reprinted from Lockman &McClure-Griffiths (2016) with the authors' permission (copyright by AAS). Panel (d) : Outflowing H i clouds (colored contours) in the GC. The Galactic disk contribution is shown by the gray scale. The dashed green line shows the approximate edge of the Fermi Bubbles (Miller & Bregman 2016). Image credit - Enrico Di Teodoro.
Fig. 5 Panel a : Spatial extinction map around the Sun obtained from a catalog of ≈ 35 Million stars. The direction to the NPS is shown using the blue arrow. Contour lines, starting from red to blue, represent iso-extinction levels of 10 -5 , 5 × 10 -5 , 10 -4 , 2 × 10 -4 , 5 × 10 -4 , 10 -3 , 2 × 10 -3 , 5 × 10 -3 , 10 -2 , and 2 × 10 -2 mag pc -1 . The image is reprinted with permission from Vergely et al. (2022) (copyright by the authors). Panel (b) : Hydrogen column density (obtained from extinction) at different latitudes toward the North-East base of the NPS (Green et al. 2015; Lallement et al. 2016). The right part of the figure shows the column density required to explain the absorption features of XMM-Newton spectra along those directions. Image reprinted from Lallement et al. (2016) with authors' permission (copyright by ESO). Panel (c) : H i emission map at the GC, showing the presence of a H i hole within the central 2 . 4 kpc. The yellow circles show the H α regions (i.e. star-forming), the red circles show the edge of the FBs, and the cyan circles show the outline of an X-ray arc, known as the northern arc (Su et al. 2010). Image reprinted from Lockman &McClure-Griffiths (2016) with the authors' permission (copyright by AAS). Panel (d) : Outflowing H i clouds (colored contours) in the GC. The Galactic disk contribution is shown by the gray scale. The dashed green line shows the approximate edge of the Fermi Bubbles (Miller & Bregman 2016). Image credit - Enrico Di Teodoro.From the PDF
Fig. 6 Warm / cold cloud velocities (in the Galactic Standard of Rest frame) toward the FBs (Ashley et al. 2020). The dashed black line shows the typical behavior of the clouds, indicating acceleration at | b | ≲ 7 ◦ and then flattening out at higher latitudes. The cyan and red points show the blue-shifted and the redshifted clouds. The red-hatched box is the region where the GSR velocity of the clouds should be zero since the radial velocity vector becomes perpendicular to the line-of-sight direction (if the clouds are within the FBs). Image reprinted from Ashley et al. (2020) with authors' permission (copyright by AAS).
Fig. 6 Warm / cold cloud velocities (in the Galactic Standard of Rest frame) toward the FBs (Ashley et al. 2020). The dashed black line shows the typical behavior of the clouds, indicating acceleration at | b | ≲ 7 ◦ and then flattening out at higher latitudes. The cyan and red points show the blue-shifted and the redshifted clouds. The red-hatched box is the region where the GSR velocity of the clouds should be zero since the radial velocity vector becomes perpendicular to the line-of-sight direction (if the clouds are within the FBs). Image reprinted from Ashley et al. (2020) with authors' permission (copyright by AAS).From the PDF
Fig. 7 Panel (a): MeerKAT 1 . 284 GHz map (1 ◦ ≈ 150 pc) showing radio bubbles and filaments at the GC (Ponti et al. 2021). Two vertical radio loops of total size ∼ 450 pc are clearly visible on the map. The image is reprinted from Ponti et al. (2021) with authors' permission (copyright by ESO). Panel (b): X-ray emission from ∼ 300 pc region of the GC and observed using XMM-Newton (Ponti et al. 2019). The red shows emission in the 1 . 5 -2 . 6 keV energy band, the green shows the S xv line emission (2 . 35 -2 . 56 keV), and the purple-blue shows the continuum emission in the 2 . 7 -2 . 97 keV. The blue circles show the outline of the 450 pc radio loop of the MeerKAT map. Image is reprinted from Ponti et al. (2019) with permission (copyright by the authors). Panel (c): Warm dust emission at 12 µ m and 22 µ m bands from Ponti et al. (2021) showing that the 12 µ m emission extends beyond the northern radio bubble. Each grid box is 0 . 5 ◦ . Panel (d): 13 CO emission map ( -3 . 5 < v < + 3 . 5 km s -1 ) showing a similar bubble / shell of molecular gas (Veena et al. 2023). The blue circles show the outer edge of the radio bubbles. The central blue dot shows the location of the Sgr A ∗ . Image is reprinted from Veena et al. (2023) with permission (copyright by the authors).
Fig. 7 Panel (a): MeerKAT 1 . 284 GHz map (1 ◦ ≈ 150 pc) showing radio bubbles and filaments at the GC (Ponti et al. 2021). Two vertical radio loops of total size ∼ 450 pc are clearly visible on the map. The image is reprinted from Ponti et al. (2021) with authors' permission (copyright by ESO). Panel (b): X-ray emission from ∼ 300 pc region of the GC and observed using XMM-Newton (Ponti et al. 2019). The red shows emission in the 1 . 5 -2 . 6 keV energy band, the green shows the S xv line emission (2 . 35 -2 . 56 keV), and the purple-blue shows the continuum emission in the 2 . 7 -2 . 97 keV. The blue circles show the outline of the 450 pc radio loop of the MeerKAT map. Image is reprinted from Ponti et al. (2019) with permission (copyright by the authors). Panel (c): Warm dust emission at 12 µ m and 22 µ m bands from Ponti et al. (2021) showing that the 12 µ m emission extends beyond the northern radio bubble. Each grid box is 0 . 5 ◦ . Panel (d): 13 CO emission map ( -3 . 5 < v < + 3 . 5 km s -1 ) showing a similar bubble / shell of molecular gas (Veena et al. 2023). The blue circles show the outer edge of the radio bubbles. The central blue dot shows the location of the Sgr A ∗ . Image is reprinted from Veena et al. (2023) with permission (copyright by the authors).From the PDF
Fig. 8 Galactic center at different scales. Panel (a) (1 ◦ ≈ 150 pc): multi-wavelength emission from the central molecular zone. The red shows NH3 emission and represents dense ( ≳ 10 3 cm -3 ) gas. The green and blue shows the 21 . 3 µ m and 8 . 28 µ m emission, respectively, and represent the PAH emission from cloud edges, young stellar objects, and evolved stars. The image is reprinted with permission from (Kruijssen et al. 2014) (copyright by the authors). Panel (b): Interstellar matter in the central few pc of Sgr A ∗ showing the circumnuclear disk (CND) in green and blue (HCN emission), and the ionized streams in red (6 cm radio continuum emission). The location of the Sgr A ∗ is marked with a ' + ' sign. Image is reprinted from Genzel et al. (2010) with authors' permission (copyright by the APS). Panel (c): Event Horizon Telescope observation of the accretion disk around the Sgr A ∗ at 1 . 3 mm (adapted from (EHT Collaboration et al. 2022b)). Here, θ g = GM bh / ( c 2 D ) is the gravitational radius of the central SMBH with mass M bh, and D is the distance from Earth. The white circle shows the beam size used for the image reconstruction. The image is reprinted with permission from (EHT Collaboration et al. 2022b) (copyright by the authors).
Fig. 8 Galactic center at different scales. Panel (a) (1 ◦ ≈ 150 pc): multi-wavelength emission from the central molecular zone. The red shows NH3 emission and represents dense ( ≳ 10 3 cm -3 ) gas. The green and blue shows the 21 . 3 µ m and 8 . 28 µ m emission, respectively, and represent the PAH emission from cloud edges, young stellar objects, and evolved stars. The image is reprinted with permission from (Kruijssen et al. 2014) (copyright by the authors). Panel (b): Interstellar matter in the central few pc of Sgr A ∗ showing the circumnuclear disk (CND) in green and blue (HCN emission), and the ionized streams in red (6 cm radio continuum emission). The location of the Sgr A ∗ is marked with a ' + ' sign. Image is reprinted from Genzel et al. (2010) with authors' permission (copyright by the APS). Panel (c): Event Horizon Telescope observation of the accretion disk around the Sgr A ∗ at 1 . 3 mm (adapted from (EHT Collaboration et al. 2022b)). Here, θ g = GM bh / ( c 2 D ) is the gravitational radius of the central SMBH with mass M bh, and D is the distance from Earth. The white circle shows the beam size used for the image reconstruction. The image is reprinted with permission from (EHT Collaboration et al. 2022b) (copyright by the authors).From the PDF
Fig. 9 Multi-Wavelength representation of the Fermi / eROSITA bubbles. The cyan shows the eROSITA bubbles (x-ray; Predehl et al. 2020), the light purple shows the γ -ray (Ackermann et al. 2014) and radio Loop-I / NPS (Planck Collaboration et al. 2016). The slightly different sizes in γ -ray / radio and x-ray bubbles are just to show the different colors. In practice, their edges almost exactly coincide with each other. The deep purple bubbles are the Fermi Bubbles (FBs; Su et al. 2010). The black hatched region represents the radio Haze emission (Planck Collaboration et al. 2013). Green clouds are warm clouds (WCs) detected in UV absorption lines (Fox et al. 2015; Bordoloi et al. 2017). Green clouds with arrows are non-radial clouds (nRCs; Ashley et al. 2020). The black outflowing clouds are atomic clouds (ACs) detected in H i emission (Di Teodoro et al. 2018). The white light cone shows the ∼ 3 Myr old ionization cone (Bland-Hawthorn et al. 2019). The ionization cone intersects the Magellanic Stream (MS) in the southern hemisphere. Note that the Magellanic Stream lies at l ≈ 90 ◦ / 270 ◦ plane and extends from ( l , b ) ≈ (270 ◦ , -30 ◦ ) to (90 ◦ , -30 ◦ ) (Putman et al. 2003), thus implying a shape that lies perpendicular to the image plane.
Fig. 9 Multi-Wavelength representation of the Fermi / eROSITA bubbles. The cyan shows the eROSITA bubbles (x-ray; Predehl et al. 2020), the light purple shows the γ -ray (Ackermann et al. 2014) and radio Loop-I / NPS (Planck Collaboration et al. 2016). The slightly different sizes in γ -ray / radio and x-ray bubbles are just to show the different colors. In practice, their edges almost exactly coincide with each other. The deep purple bubbles are the Fermi Bubbles (FBs; Su et al. 2010). The black hatched region represents the radio Haze emission (Planck Collaboration et al. 2013). Green clouds are warm clouds (WCs) detected in UV absorption lines (Fox et al. 2015; Bordoloi et al. 2017). Green clouds with arrows are non-radial clouds (nRCs; Ashley et al. 2020). The black outflowing clouds are atomic clouds (ACs) detected in H i emission (Di Teodoro et al. 2018). The white light cone shows the ∼ 3 Myr old ionization cone (Bland-Hawthorn et al. 2019). The ionization cone intersects the Magellanic Stream (MS) in the southern hemisphere. Note that the Magellanic Stream lies at l ≈ 90 ◦ / 270 ◦ plane and extends from ( l , b ) ≈ (270 ◦ , -30 ◦ ) to (90 ◦ , -30 ◦ ) (Putman et al. 2003), thus implying a shape that lies perpendicular to the image plane.From the PDF
Fig. 10 Analytically estimated propagation of shock waves for different energy injection methods. Left Panel : Forward shock from a ballistic jet with vj = 0 . 01 c and opening angle θ j = 4 ◦ (see Mondal et al. 2022, for details). The color of each line represents the shock temperature. Right Panel : Shock wave from an energetic explosion ( E = 10 56 erg) and a continuous wind injection ( L wind = 10 40 . 7 erg s -1 ) at the GC. The solution is based on the Kompaneets approximation (Kompaneets 1960) of shock propagation on a given density profile (shown in color; n ∝ z -1 . 5 ). Each curve represents the shock surface at a given dimensionless time. The real times for the (burst, wind) cases are noted in the legend in units of Myr.
Fig. 10 Analytically estimated propagation of shock waves for different energy injection methods. Left Panel : Forward shock from a ballistic jet with vj = 0 . 01 c and opening angle θ j = 4 ◦ (see Mondal et al. 2022, for details). The color of each line represents the shock temperature. Right Panel : Shock wave from an energetic explosion ( E = 10 56 erg) and a continuous wind injection ( L wind = 10 40 . 7 erg s -1 ) at the GC. The solution is based on the Kompaneets approximation (Kompaneets 1960) of shock propagation on a given density profile (shown in color; n ∝ z -1 . 5 ). Each curve represents the shock surface at a given dimensionless time. The real times for the (burst, wind) cases are noted in the legend in units of Myr.From the PDF
Fig. 11 Left: Different time scales in the FB-spectrum as a function of CRe or CRp energy. The IC cooling time, t IC , cool, due to the CMB is shown using the blue solid line. The Hadronic ( p -p ) cooling times, t pp , for nH = 0 . 01 and 0 . 1 cm -3 are shown using the red and green solid lines, respectively. The high t pp at E cr ≲ 2 GeV is because of ineffective inelastic collisions near the rest mass of the proton (0 . 938 GeV). Pion production below ∼ 2 GeV happens instead via resonant processes (Kafexhiu et al. 2014). The top x-axis shows the energy of γ -ray photons produced (from CMB) in the IC process corresponding to the CRe energy in the lower x-axis. The vertical labels indicate the typical CRp energy for producing γ -ray photons at 1 GeV and 100 GeV via π 0 decay. The horizontal black lines represent the dynamical time scales corresponding to a slowly expanding and a fast expanding FB.
Fig. 11 Left: Different time scales in the FB-spectrum as a function of CRe or CRp energy. The IC cooling time, t IC , cool, due to the CMB is shown using the blue solid line. The Hadronic ( p -p ) cooling times, t pp , for nH = 0 . 01 and 0 . 1 cm -3 are shown using the red and green solid lines, respectively. The high t pp at E cr ≲ 2 GeV is because of ineffective inelastic collisions near the rest mass of the proton (0 . 938 GeV). Pion production below ∼ 2 GeV happens instead via resonant processes (Kafexhiu et al. 2014). The top x-axis shows the energy of γ -ray photons produced (from CMB) in the IC process corresponding to the CRe energy in the lower x-axis. The vertical labels indicate the typical CRp energy for producing γ -ray photons at 1 GeV and 100 GeV via π 0 decay. The horizontal black lines represent the dynamical time scales corresponding to a slowly expanding and a fast expanding FB.From the PDF
Fig. 12 Acombined fit of the γ -ray and microwave emission for a given CRe population, N ∝ Γ -2 . 2 exp( -Γ / 2 . 5 × 10 6 ). Different colors show the synchrotron emission for different magnetic field values. Image is reprinted from Ackermann et al. (2014) with authors' permission (copyright by AAS).
Fig. 12 Acombined fit of the γ -ray and microwave emission for a given CRe population, N ∝ Γ -2 . 2 exp( -Γ / 2 . 5 × 10 6 ). Different colors show the synchrotron emission for different magnetic field values. Image is reprinted from Ackermann et al. (2014) with authors' permission (copyright by AAS).From the PDF
Fig. 13 Density (top row) and temperature (bottom row) color maps of hydrodynamical simulations of Fermi / eROSITA bubbles for different scenarios. First column: a star-formation-driven wind with SFR = 0 . 5 M ⊙ yr -1 ( L wind = 5 × 10 40 erg s -1 ) at t = 27 Myr (Sarkar et al. 2015a). Different regions of the wind are marked as - CGM: circumgalactic medium, FS: forward shock, CD: contact discontinuity, SW: shocked wind, RS: reverse shock, FW: free wind, CS: collimation shock, and WC: warm clouds. This scenario assumes that the FBs are represented by the contact discontinuity and the eROSITA bubbles (NPS) are represented by the shocked CGM (material between FS and CD). Second column: an AGN burst scenario where a total of 10 56 erg thermal energy is deposited within 40 pc during the first t inj = 0 . 01 Myr (Mondal et al. 2022). The snapshot is taken at 9 Myr. In this scenario, the eROSITA bubbles are represented by the shock, and the FBs are represented by the lower-density bubble inside the shock (Yang et al. 2022). Third column: an AGN jet scenario, where a jet with L jet = 2 × 10 43 erg s -1 is turned on for t inj = 0 . 04 Myr ( E tot = 2 . 5 × 10 55 erg) (Mondal et al. 2022). This scenario explains the FBs as the forward shock with M∼ 4 -5 and assumes that the eROSITA bubbles originated from a separate event unrelated to the FBs. Fourth Column: a misaligned AGN jet scenario where the jet with L jet = 2 × 10 41 erg s -1 is continuously injected at an angle of 45 ◦ from the Galactic rotation axis (Sarkar et al. 2023). The snapshot is taken at t = 3 . 6 Myr, i.e. E tot = 2 . 3 × 10 55 erg. The panel shows that misaligned jets do not naturally produce axisymmetric and hemispherical symmetric bubbles unless the jets are dissipated within the ISM. Such dissipation could occur either due to interactions with molecular clumps (Mukherjee et al. 2018) or via magnetic kink-instability (Tchekhovskoy & Bromberg 2016).
Fig. 13 Density (top row) and temperature (bottom row) color maps of hydrodynamical simulations of Fermi / eROSITA bubbles for different scenarios. First column: a star-formation-driven wind with SFR = 0 . 5 M ⊙ yr -1 ( L wind = 5 × 10 40 erg s -1 ) at t = 27 Myr (Sarkar et al. 2015a). Different regions of the wind are marked as - CGM: circumgalactic medium, FS: forward shock, CD: contact discontinuity, SW: shocked wind, RS: reverse shock, FW: free wind, CS: collimation shock, and WC: warm clouds. This scenario assumes that the FBs are represented by the contact discontinuity and the eROSITA bubbles (NPS) are represented by the shocked CGM (material between FS and CD). Second column: an AGN burst scenario where a total of 10 56 erg thermal energy is deposited within 40 pc during the first t inj = 0 . 01 Myr (Mondal et al. 2022). The snapshot is taken at 9 Myr. In this scenario, the eROSITA bubbles are represented by the shock, and the FBs are represented by the lower-density bubble inside the shock (Yang et al. 2022). Third column: an AGN jet scenario, where a jet with L jet = 2 × 10 43 erg s -1 is turned on for t inj = 0 . 04 Myr ( E tot = 2 . 5 × 10 55 erg) (Mondal et al. 2022). This scenario explains the FBs as the forward shock with M∼ 4 -5 and assumes that the eROSITA bubbles originated from a separate event unrelated to the FBs. Fourth Column: a misaligned AGN jet scenario where the jet with L jet = 2 × 10 41 erg s -1 is continuously injected at an angle of 45 ◦ from the Galactic rotation axis (Sarkar et al. 2023). The snapshot is taken at t = 3 . 6 Myr, i.e. E tot = 2 . 3 × 10 55 erg. The panel shows that misaligned jets do not naturally produce axisymmetric and hemispherical symmetric bubbles unless the jets are dissipated within the ISM. Such dissipation could occur either due to interactions with molecular clumps (Mukherjee et al. 2018) or via magnetic kink-instability (Tchekhovskoy & Bromberg 2016).From the PDF

Verification

Claims the paper makes

109 Valid · 10 Not valid · 150 Not checked · 207 Own results and interpretations

227 more claims · 46 with their cited sources checked

Create a free account to see all 476 claims and to verify the 150 references still open.

See all claims — free account
  • It may state two separate claims as one. 179
  • Probably not a substantial claim. 105
  • The quote only partly states this claim. 1

Create a free account to see these claims.

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

Each contradiction between two passages listed here was confirmed by an independent check.

3 of 3

Citations

Cites

Show all 516 references

Research works printed but not linked: 15

  1. Berkhuijsen EM, Haslam CGT, Salter CJ (1971) Are the galactic loops supernova remnants? A&A 14:252
  2. Braginskii SI (1965) Transport processes in a plasma. Rev Plasma Phys 1:205
  3. Goetz M, Downes D, Greve A et al (1990) Structure of the disk of M 82. A&A 240:52
  4. Haslam CGT, Wilson WE, Graham DA et al (1974) A further 408 MHz survey of the northern sky. A&AS 13:359
  5. Haslam CGT, Salter CJ, Stoffel H et al (1982) A 408-MHz all-sky continuum survey. II. The atlas of contour maps. A&AS 47:1
  6. Kompaneets DA (1960) A point explosion in an inhomogeneous atmosphere. Akad Nauk SSSR Dokl 130:1001
  7. Loose HH, Kruegel E, Tutukov A (1982) Bursts of star formation in the galactic centre. Astron Astrophys 105(2):342–350
  8. Nogueras-Lara F, Schödel R, Gallego-Calvente AT et al (2019) GALACTICNUCLEUS: a high-angular-resolution JHK$$_{s}$$ imaging survey of the Galactic Centre. II. First data release of the catalogue and the most detailed CMDs of the GC. A&A 631:A20. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201936263. arXiv:1908.10366 [astro-ph.GA] · DOI
  9. Salter CJ (1983) Loop-I the North Polar Spur—a major feature of the local interstellar environment. Bull Astron Soc India 11:1
  10. Sedov LI (1946) Propagation of strong shock waves. J Appl Math Mech 10:241–250
  11. Serabyn E, Guesten R, Walmsley JE et al (1986) CO 1–0 and CS 2–1 observations of the neutral disk around the Galactic Center. A&A 169:85–94
  12. Sofue Y (1977) Propagation of magnetohydrodynamic waves from the galactic center. Origin of the 3-kpc arm and the North Polar Spur. A&A 60(3):327–336
  13. Sofue Y, Reich W (1979) Radio continuum observations of the North Polar Spur at 1420 MHz. A&AS 38:251–263
  14. Spoelstra TAT (1971) A survey of linear polarization at 1415 MHz. II. Discussion of results for the North Polar Spur. A&A 13:237
  15. Spoelstra TAT (1972) A survey of linear polarization at 1415 MHz. IV. Discussion of the results for the galactic spurs. A&A 21:61

Cited by

See all 35

Metadata

Authors
Sarkar, K. C.
Affiliations
Tel Aviv University (IL)
Corresponding author
Sarkar, Kartick C.
Venue
The Astronomy and Astrophysics Review
Published
2024-03-30
Volume
32
Issue
1
ISSN
  • 0935-4956 (ISSN-L)
  • 1432-0754
OpenAlex
W4393345495
Cited by
34
References
516
Citations by year
2026: 6 · 2025: 17 · 2024: 11
FWCI
6.40
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Licence
Locations
  • The Astronomy and Astrophysics Review (publishedVersion)
  • arXiv (Cornell University) (submittedVersion)
  • arXiv (Cornell University)
Funders
German Science Foundation (STE/ 1869-2 GE/ 625 17-1)
Topics
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Astronomy and Astrophysics › Astrophysical Phenomena and Observations
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Nuclear and High Energy Physics › Astrophysics and Cosmic Phenomena
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Astronomy and Astrophysics › Galaxies: Formation, Evolution, Phenomena
Keywords
Fermi bubbles, galactic outflows, X-ray bubbles, circumgalactic medium, Fermi-LAT, multiwavelength observations, supermassive black hole feedback

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.

A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-10, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).

A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-10 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).

Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol).

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.