Student or educator? Sign up with your school email and get 6 months of Pro free.
CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 1,145 of the 1,256 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 96 of the 510 sources its claims cite were checked for support.

Testing general relativity in cosmology

Open access
Ishak, Mustapha · 2019 · Living Reviews in Relativity

Abstract

We review recent developments and results in testing general relativity (GR) at cosmological scales. The subject has witnessed rapid growth during the last two decades with the aim of addressing the question of cosmic acceleration and the dark energy associated with it. However, with the advent of precision cosmology, it has also become a well-motivated endeavor by itself to test gravitational physics at cosmic scales. We overview cosmological probes of gravity, formalisms and parameterizations for testing deviations from GR at cosmological scales, selected modified gravity (MG) theories, gravitational screening mechanisms, and computer codes developed for these tests. We then provide summaries of recent cosmological constraints on MG parameters and selected MG models. We supplement these cosmological constraints with a summary of implications from the recent binary neutron star merger event. Next, we summarize some results on MG parameter forecasts with and without astrophysical systematics that will dominate the uncertainties. The review aims at providing an overall picture of the subject and an entry point to students and researchers interested in joining the field. It can also serve as a quick reference to recent results and constraints on testing gravity at cosmological scales.

Overview

CoChat Summary

TL;DR

This review surveys how general relativity is tested at cosmological scales, emphasizing the split between background expansion/geometry probes and growth-of-structure probes, and how their combination constrains modified gravity. It also summarizes the status of major model classes, current data constraints, the impact of GW170817/GRB170817A, and the role of systematic effects and forecasting for future surveys.

Key findings

  • The review argues that cosmology offers two complementary probe classes: expansion/geometry and structure growth; for testing deviations from GR, the growth sector is described as “rather the most useful” because many MG models can mimic the same expansion history as CDM while differing in growth.
  • Current data generally remain consistent with GR, but often only at the level of relatively large uncertainties; the paper notes that constraints are tightening and that for upcoming surveys the dominant uncertainty will be systematic rather than statistical.
  • Specific examples summarized in the text include:
  • TeVeS was ruled out by Planck-based analyses, with one study reporting a best-fit Hubble constant that was “hard to reconcile” with other measurements and a goodness-of-fit worse than CDM.
  • The self-accelerating DGP branch is described as disfavored/inconsistent with observations, while the normal branch remains useful as a benchmark.
  • Galileon models are strongly constrained: cubic Galileons are ruled out by ISW data, and quartic/quintic Galileons are ruled out by GW170817/GRB170817A.
  • f(R) models are driven very close to CDM by cosmological and astrophysical constraints, and the paper states that combining stringent cosmological constraints, astrophysical bounds, and no-go theorems “practically rules out” f(R) as an explanation for cosmic acceleration.
  • The GW170817/GRB170817A event is presented as a major discriminator: it forces the GW speed to be practically equal to light speed and removes large parts of Horndeski/beyond-Horndeski and related model space, while leaving some viable subclasses (for example, generalized Brans–Dicke-like or certain no-slip scenarios) and several non-scalar-tensor classes.

Methods

  • Narrative review of the literature on testing GR in cosmology, organized around: GR basics, standard cosmology, probes of gravity, formalisms for modified gravity, model classes, screening mechanisms, current constraints, GW170817 implications, software tools, systematics, and forecasts.
  • Summarizes results from many published analyses and data sets, including Planck CMB, BAO, SN Ia, RSD, weak lensing, ISW, galaxy clustering, CMB lensing, and the GW170817/GRB170817A multimessenger event.
  • Reviews analysis frameworks such as phenomenological modified-growth parameters, EFT, PPF, growth-index approaches, and model-specific Boltzmann/Einstein codes like CAMB, CLASS, ISiTGR, MGCAMB, hi_class, and EFTCAMB.

Limitations

  • The paper explicitly states that it is not a comprehensive review of modified gravity models; it gives an overview of the current status of testing GR at cosmological scales and only outlines selected models as illustrative examples.
  • It also notes that many current MG constraints are still limited by the constraining power of available data, and that scale-dependent MG parameters are often not meaningfully constrained by current data.
  • Evident from the text: many quoted results are drawn from different papers using different parameterizations, data combinations, and modeling assumptions, so the review is synthesizing heterogeneous literature rather than presenting a single uniform analysis.

Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1007/s41114-018-0017-4

Cites

1145 of 1145 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Nothing to recompute.

Figures

Fig. 1 Growth rate of matter density fluctuations, f(z). Theory prediction curves are shown for: the ΛCDM model; the Dvali–Gabadadze–Porrati braneworld model (the self-accelerating branch, see Sect. 7.5.2) (Dvali et al. 2000); and the f(R) (see Sect. 7.4.1) modified gravity model (Hu and Sawicki 2007a) [model with c=3 from Linder (2009)]. Note that the growth in f(R) models is scale-dependent so the authors show predictions at two wavenumbers, k=0.02hMpc⁻¹ and k=0.1hMpc⁻¹. Also shown are the error bars projected from a future galaxy spectroscopic redshift survey designed with DESI survey specifications (Aghamousa et al. 2016) Image reproduced with permission from Huterer et al. (2015), copyright by Elsevier
Fig. 1 Growth rate of matter density fluctuations, f(z). Theory prediction curves are shown for: the ΛCDM model; the Dvali–Gabadadze–Porrati braneworld model (the self-accelerating branch, see Sect. 7.5.2) (Dvali et al. 2000); and the f(R) (see Sect. 7.4.1) modified gravity model (Hu and Sawicki 2007a) [model with c=3 from Linder (2009)]. Note that the growth in f(R) models is scale-dependent so the authors show predictions at two wavenumbers, k=0.02hMpc⁻¹ and k=0.1hMpc⁻¹. Also shown are the error bars projected from a future galaxy spectroscopic redshift survey designed with DESI survey specifications (Aghamousa et al. 2016) Image reproduced with permission from Huterer et al. (2015), copyright by ElsevierCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 2 Top panel: convergence power spectra for f(R) models (see Sect. 7.4.1), dynamical dark energy models and the ΛCDM standard model. Error bars are for the survey indicated on the figure—sky coverage of 20,000 square degrees with a galaxy density number of 10 per arcminutes squared. The dashed line corresponds to the shot noise term of auto power spectrum. Bottom panel: Ratio between ΛCDM model and f(R) models or wCDM models Image reproduced with permission from Shirasaki et al. (2016), copyright by the authors
Fig. 2 Top panel: convergence power spectra for f(R) models (see Sect. 7.4.1), dynamical dark energy models and the ΛCDM standard model. Error bars are for the survey indicated on the figure—sky coverage of 20,000 square degrees with a galaxy density number of 10 per arcminutes squared. The dashed line corresponds to the shot noise term of auto power spectrum. Bottom panel: Ratio between ΛCDM model and f(R) models or wCDM models Image reproduced with permission from Shirasaki et al. (2016), copyright by the authorsCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 3 Growth rate f(z)σ8(z) measurements for redshift range 0<z<1.55 and theoretical predictions from standard GR-ΛCDM model and MG models f(R) (see Sect.7.4.1), covariant Galileons (see Sect. 7.3.1), extended Galileons, DGP (see Sect. 7.5.2), and models with varying gravitational constant. The constraint obtained from Subaru FastSound sample at 1.19<z<1.55 (Okumura et al. 2016) is plotted as the big red point. The other results include the 6dFGS, 2dFGRS, SDSS main galaxies, SDSS LRG, BOSS LOWZ , WiggleZ, BOSS CMASS, VVDS, and VIPERS surveys at z<1. Predicted fσ8 from GR-ΛCDM with the amplitude determined by minimizing their χ² is shown as the red solid line. The data points used for the χ² minimization are denoted as the filled-symbol points. The other curves are predictions from MG models as indicated on the right Image reproduced with permission from Okumura et al. (2016), copyright by the authors
Fig. 3 Growth rate f(z)σ8(z) measurements for redshift range 0<z<1.55 and theoretical predictions from standard GR-ΛCDM model and MG models f(R) (see Sect.7.4.1), covariant Galileons (see Sect. 7.3.1), extended Galileons, DGP (see Sect. 7.5.2), and models with varying gravitational constant. The constraint obtained from Subaru FastSound sample at 1.19<z<1.55 (Okumura et al. 2016) is plotted as the big red point. The other results include the 6dFGS, 2dFGRS, SDSS main galaxies, SDSS LRG, BOSS LOWZ , WiggleZ, BOSS CMASS, VVDS, and VIPERS surveys at z<1. Predicted fσ8 from GR-ΛCDM with the amplitude determined by minimizing their χ² is shown as the red solid line. The data points used for the χ² minimization are denoted as the filled-symbol points. The other curves are predictions from MG models as indicated on the right Image reproduced with permission from Okumura et al. (2016), copyright by the authorsCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 4 These plots illustrate the differences between ΛCDM and Galileon models (see Sect. 7.3.1), with and without massive neutrinos. The Galileon models have background Friedmann equations that contain a scalar-field energy density contribution that generates late time cosmic acceleration and has an evolution consistent with observations and thus similar to that of a ΛCDM model. The Galileon scalar field here also affects linear perturbations and is not coupled to matter. The effect of the Galileon field considered here is focused on large-scale structure. The Top: CMB temperature power spectra showing the ISW effect at low multipoles. Middle: CMB lensing potential spectra. Bottom: linear matter power spectra. The models plotted in dashed lines indicate their best fit models to Ade et al. (2014c) temperature data, WMAP9 polarization data (Hinshaw et al. 2013), and Planck-2013 CMB lensing (Ade et al. 2014d). They note these as PL models. The solid lines indicate their best fits to CMB data (i.e., PL) plus BAO measurements from 6dF, SDSS DR7 and BOSS DR9. They note these as PLB models. The models correspond to best-fitting base Galileon modified gravity model (in blue), νGalileon (in red) and νΛCDM (in green). For the last two models, the authors added massive neutrino. In the upper and middle panels, the data points show the power spectrum measured by the Planck satellite (Ade et al. 2014c). In the lower panel, the data points show the SDSS-DR7 Luminous Red Galaxy power spectrum of Reid et al. (2010), but scaled down to match the amplitude of the best-fitting νGalileon (PLB) model (Barreira et al. 2014a). We refer to this figure from various parts of the text Image reproduced with permission from Barreira et al. (2014a), copyright by APS
Fig. 4 These plots illustrate the differences between ΛCDM and Galileon models (see Sect. 7.3.1), with and without massive neutrinos. The Galileon models have background Friedmann equations that contain a scalar-field energy density contribution that generates late time cosmic acceleration and has an evolution consistent with observations and thus similar to that of a ΛCDM model. The Galileon scalar field here also affects linear perturbations and is not coupled to matter. The effect of the Galileon field considered here is focused on large-scale structure. The Top: CMB temperature power spectra showing the ISW effect at low multipoles. Middle: CMB lensing potential spectra. Bottom: linear matter power spectra. The models plotted in dashed lines indicate their best fit models to Ade et al. (2014c) temperature data, WMAP9 polarization data (Hinshaw et al. 2013), and Planck-2013 CMB lensing (Ade et al. 2014d). They note these as PL models. The solid lines indicate their best fits to CMB data (i.e., PL) plus BAO measurements from 6dF, SDSS DR7 and BOSS DR9. They note these as PLB models. The models correspond to best-fitting base Galileon modified gravity model (in blue), νGalileon (in red) and νΛCDM (in green). For the last two models, the authors added massive neutrino. In the upper and middle panels, the data points show the power spectrum measured by the Planck satellite (Ade et al. 2014c). In the lower panel, the data points show the SDSS-DR7 Luminous Red Galaxy power spectrum of Reid et al. (2010), but scaled down to match the amplitude of the best-fitting νGalileon (PLB) model (Barreira et al. 2014a). We refer to this figure from various parts of the text Image reproduced with permission from Barreira et al. (2014a), copyright by APSCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 5 Contour plots for marginalized posterior distributions for 68% and 95% C.L for the two parameters {μ0-1,η0-1} at the present time with no scale dependence. On the left, time dependence is considered via the effective dark energy density parameter. On the right panel, time evolution is considered by direct inclusion of the scale factor. Results discussed in text of Sect. 6.1.1. The label Planck stands for PlanckTT+TEB Figure reproduced with permission from Ade et al. (2016b)
Fig. 5 Contour plots for marginalized posterior distributions for 68% and 95% C.L for the two parameters {μ0-1,η0-1} at the present time with no scale dependence. On the left, time dependence is considered via the effective dark energy density parameter. On the right panel, time evolution is considered by direct inclusion of the scale factor. Results discussed in text of Sect. 6.1.1. The label Planck stands for PlanckTT+TEB Figure reproduced with permission from Ade et al. (2016b)CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 6 Contour plots for marginalized posterior distributions for 68% and 95% C.L for the two parameters {μ0-1,η0-1} at the present time with no scale dependence. The time dependence is considered via the effective dark energy density parameter. Σ is obtained from Eq. (92). Results discussed in text of Sect. 6.1.1. In the labels, Planck stands for PlanckTT+TEB Figure reproduced with permission from Ade et al. (2016b)
Fig. 6 Contour plots for marginalized posterior distributions for 68% and 95% C.L for the two parameters {μ0-1,η0-1} at the present time with no scale dependence. The time dependence is considered via the effective dark energy density parameter. Σ is obtained from Eq. (92). Results discussed in text of Sect. 6.1.1. In the labels, Planck stands for PlanckTT+TEB Figure reproduced with permission from Ade et al. (2016b)CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 7 Left: Marginalized posterior contours (inner 68% CL, outer 95% CL) in the Q2-Σ2 space for KiDS with fiducial angular scales shown in green (labeled by ‘FS’), KiDS keeping only the largest angular scales shown in pink (labeled by ‘LS’), and combined with Planck in grey and blue, respectively. The indices represent the combination of MG bins, such that z<1 and k>0.05hMpc⁻¹. The intersection of the dashed lines give the GR prediction (i.e., Q=Σ=1). Reproduced with permission from Fig. 13 in Joudaki et al. (2017). Right: In addition to the cases described on th left, the constraints include galaxy–galaxy lensing correlation with cosmic shear in WL and RSD data as described in the text. ’Large-scale cuts’ mean that small scales have been excluded because of no adequate modeling for generic MG deviations in the nonlinear regime that can be utilized here. Again, the intersection of the horizontal and vertical lines is the GR prediction (i.e., Q=Σ=1)
Fig. 7 Left: Marginalized posterior contours (inner 68% CL, outer 95% CL) in the Q2-Σ2 space for KiDS with fiducial angular scales shown in green (labeled by ‘FS’), KiDS keeping only the largest angular scales shown in pink (labeled by ‘LS’), and combined with Planck in grey and blue, respectively. The indices represent the combination of MG bins, such that z<1 and k>0.05hMpc⁻¹. The intersection of the dashed lines give the GR prediction (i.e., Q=Σ=1). Reproduced with permission from Fig. 13 in Joudaki et al. (2017). Right: In addition to the cases described on th left, the constraints include galaxy–galaxy lensing correlation with cosmic shear in WL and RSD data as described in the text. ’Large-scale cuts’ mean that small scales have been excluded because of no adequate modeling for generic MG deviations in the nonlinear regime that can be utilized here. Again, the intersection of the horizontal and vertical lines is the GR prediction (i.e., Q=Σ=1)CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 8 Contour plots for 68% and 95% CL on MG parameters Σ and μ combining Planck CMB data (TT + lowP + CMB lensing), RSD data from BOSS DR12 and 6dFGS, and cosmic shear data from CFHTLenS in blue and DES-SV in red. The cross point represent the GR values (0,0) according to the authors’ definitions and show that GR is consistent with the data sets used. The combination for the contours in blue gives among the tightest current constraints on MG parameters as: Σ=-0.01-0.04^(+0.05) and μ=-0.06±0.18 (68 % confidence level) Figure reproduced with permission from Ferté et al. (2017)
Fig. 8 Contour plots for 68% and 95% CL on MG parameters Σ and μ combining Planck CMB data (TT + lowP + CMB lensing), RSD data from BOSS DR12 and 6dFGS, and cosmic shear data from CFHTLenS in blue and DES-SV in red. The cross point represent the GR values (0,0) according to the authors’ definitions and show that GR is consistent with the data sets used. The combination for the contours in blue gives among the tightest current constraints on MG parameters as: Σ=-0.01-0.04^(+0.05) and μ=-0.06±0.18 (68 % confidence level) Figure reproduced with permission from Ferté et al. (2017)CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 9 68% and 95% confidence contours on modification of the growth function in the ΛCDM cosmological model using the form fσ8→fσ8[Afσ8+Bfσ8(z-zp)] with a redshift pivot zp=0.51. The results are consistent with the predictions of general relativity: Afσ8=1, Bfσ8=0 (dashed grey lines). As explained in the text, the analysis used temperature and polarization data from Planck 2015, and a set of consensus values for BAO and RSD using full shape measurements (FS) from SDSS DR12 Figure reproduced with permission from Alam et al. (2017a)
Fig. 9 68% and 95% confidence contours on modification of the growth function in the ΛCDM cosmological model using the form fσ8→fσ8[Afσ8+Bfσ8(z-zp)] with a redshift pivot zp=0.51. The results are consistent with the predictions of general relativity: Afσ8=1, Bfσ8=0 (dashed grey lines). As explained in the text, the analysis used temperature and polarization data from Planck 2015, and a set of consensus values for BAO and RSD using full shape measurements (FS) from SDSS DR12 Figure reproduced with permission from Alam et al. (2017a)CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 10 EG parameter as function of scale in redshift range 0.5<z<0.7 (top panel) and 0.7<z<1.2 (bottom panel) as measured in de la Torre et al. (2016). In the two panels, the solid curves and shaded areas around them correspond to the prediction and the 68% uncertainty (thin grey) band for GR with a ΛCDM background set to the best fit model of TT + lowP + lensing Planck 2015 (Ade et al. 2016a). In the top panel, the horizontal (light brown) stripe shows the averaged E¯G over the range 3h⁻¹Mpc<rp<50h⁻¹Mpc from Blake et al. (2016b) at redshift 0.43<z<0.7 Figure reproduced with permission from de la Torre et al. (2016). As they comment there, this measurements of EG are slightly lower (1-2σ) than expected for the standard ΛCDM model of GR and one way to remedy to this is to lower the matter-density parameter. Figure reproduced with permission from Alam et al. (2017a)
Fig. 10 EG parameter as function of scale in redshift range 0.5<z<0.7 (top panel) and 0.7<z<1.2 (bottom panel) as measured in de la Torre et al. (2016). In the two panels, the solid curves and shaded areas around them correspond to the prediction and the 68% uncertainty (thin grey) band for GR with a ΛCDM background set to the best fit model of TT + lowP + lensing Planck 2015 (Ade et al. 2016a). In the top panel, the horizontal (light brown) stripe shows the averaged E¯G over the range 3h⁻¹Mpc<rp<50h⁻¹Mpc from Blake et al. (2016b) at redshift 0.43<z<0.7 Figure reproduced with permission from de la Torre et al. (2016). As they comment there, this measurements of EG are slightly lower (1-2σ) than expected for the standard ΛCDM model of GR and one way to remedy to this is to lower the matter-density parameter. Figure reproduced with permission from Alam et al. (2017a)CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 11 Various categories of modified gravity (MG) theories according to the principle or requirement they violate. It is worth noting that some models can belong to more than one category here like for example some higher dimensional models that have extra fields
Fig. 11 Various categories of modified gravity (MG) theories according to the principle or requirement they violate. It is worth noting that some models can belong to more than one category here like for example some higher dimensional models that have extra fieldsCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 12 Extra-fields modified gravity models. Purple color is for Horndeski models and orange is for models with torsion. This table follows the models as listed in Clifton et al. (2012)
Fig. 12 Extra-fields modified gravity models. Purple color is for Horndeski models and orange is for models with torsion. This table follows the models as listed in Clifton et al. (2012)CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 13 Higher-order-derivatives modified gravity models
Fig. 13 Higher-order-derivatives modified gravity modelsCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 14 Higher-dimension modified gravity models
Fig. 14 Higher-dimension modified gravity modelsCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 15 Thin shell profile of the scalar field for the chameleon screening mechanism. Only the mass of the thin shell contributes to the fifth force outside the shell while the force is suppressed inside the shell. See text and Khoury and Weltman (2004a) and Koyama (2016) for discussion
Fig. 15 Thin shell profile of the scalar field for the chameleon screening mechanism. Only the mass of the thin shell contributes to the fifth force outside the shell while the force is suppressed inside the shell. See text and Khoury and Weltman (2004a) and Koyama (2016) for discussionCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 16 Overall picture of the Vainshtein screening mechanism. There are three regions of interest: (r≫rv) far outside the Vainshtein radius and away from the source, the fifth force is not screened; (r≪rv) near the source and below rv, the fifth force is suppressed (this includes Λ⁻¹≪r≪rv). r=Λ⁻¹ represent the cut-off scale of the theory and is typically very large compared to the Schwarzschild radius
Fig. 16 Overall picture of the Vainshtein screening mechanism. There are three regions of interest: (r≫rv) far outside the Vainshtein radius and away from the source, the fifth force is not screened; (r≪rv) near the source and below rv, the fifth force is suppressed (this includes Λ⁻¹≪r≪rv). r=Λ⁻¹ represent the cut-off scale of the theory and is typically very large compared to the Schwarzschild radiusCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 17 Left: Forecasted 68% and 95% confidence contours on MG parameters Σ and μ for a future DES-Y5 survey in blue and for an LSST-like survey in green. No intrinsic alignment (IA) systematics are assumed here. While DES-Y5 promises to make tight constrains on Σ as expected from a weak lensing survey, LSST will provide an order magnitude further improvement on the two parameters. Right: A comparison between uncertainties for DES-Y5 survey when ignoring IA in green and taking them into account in blue. This means that ignoring IA leads to underestimating the uncertainties on the parameters. This also shows that these uncertainties will be systematic-error dominated. Figure reproduced with permission from Ferté et al. (2017)
Fig. 17 Left: Forecasted 68% and 95% confidence contours on MG parameters Σ and μ for a future DES-Y5 survey in blue and for an LSST-like survey in green. No intrinsic alignment (IA) systematics are assumed here. While DES-Y5 promises to make tight constrains on Σ as expected from a weak lensing survey, LSST will provide an order magnitude further improvement on the two parameters. Right: A comparison between uncertainties for DES-Y5 survey when ignoring IA in green and taking them into account in blue. This means that ignoring IA leads to underestimating the uncertainties on the parameters. This also shows that these uncertainties will be systematic-error dominated. Figure reproduced with permission from Ferté et al. (2017)CC BY · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

83 Valid · 9 Not valid · 289 Not checked · 144 Own results and interpretations

219 more claims · 33 with their cited sources checked

Create a free account to see all 525 claims and to verify the 291 references still open.

See all claims — free account
  • It may state two separate claims as one. 223
  • Probably not a substantial claim. 125
  • The quote only partly states this claim. 15

Create a free account to see these claims.

Citations

Cites

Show all 1,256 references

Research works printed but not linked: 10

  1. Cartan E (1922a) Sur les équations de la gravitation d’Einstein. J Math Pures Appl 1922(1):141–202
  2. Debever R (1964) Le rayonnement gravitationnel. le tenseur de Riemann en relativité générale. Cah Phys 168:303
  3. Eddington A (1924) The mathematical theory of general relativity. CUP, Cambridge
  4. Klein O (1926a) Quantentheorie und Fünfdimensionale Relativitätstheorie. Z Phys A 37:895?906
  5. Könnig F, Akrami Y, Amendola L, Motta M, Solomon A (2014) Stable and unstable cosmological models in bimetric massive gravity. Phys Rev D 90:124014. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.90.124014 . arXiv:1407.4331 · DOI · Paper page
  6. Lifshitz EM (1941) On the theory of second-order phase transitions I. Zh Eksp Teor Fiz 11:255
  7. Misner CW, Thorne KS, Wheeler JA (1973) Gravitation. Princeton University Press, Princeton
  8. Peacock JA (1999) Cosmological physics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
  9. Schwarzschild K (1916) Über das Gravitationsfeld eines Massenpunktes nach der Einsteinschen Theorie. Sitzungsber Koenigl Preuss Akad Wiss 7:189–196
  10. Segre C (1884) Sulla teoria e sulla classificazione delle omografie in uno spazio lineare ad uno numero qualunque di dimensioni. Mem R Accad Lincei, Ser 3 XIX:127–148

Cited by

See all 449

Metadata

Authors
Ishak, M.
Affiliations
The University of Texas at Dallas (US)
Corresponding author
Ishak, Mustapha
Venue
Living Reviews in Relativity
Published
2018-12-18
Volume
22
Issue
1
Pages
1-1
ISSN
  • 1433-8351 (ISSN-L)
  • 2367-3613
OpenAlex
W2809838409
Cited by
449
References
1,256
Citations by year
2026: 28 · 2025: 69 · 2024: 60 · 2023: 46 · 2022: 52 · 2021: 49 · 2020: 70 · 2019: 57 · 2018: 15
FWCI
4.35
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Licence
Locations
  • Living Reviews in Relativity (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • arXiv (Cornell University) (publishedVersion)
  • Europe PMC (PubMed Central) (publishedVersion, other-oa)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion, cc-by-sa)
  • OSTI OAI (U.S. Department of Energy Office of Scientific and Technical Information) (submittedVersion)
  • arXiv (Cornell University)
Funders
  • National Science Foundation (AST-1517768)
  • Office of Science (DE-SC0019206)
Topics
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Astronomy and Astrophysics › Cosmology and Gravitation Theories
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Nuclear and High Energy Physics › Noncommutative and Quantum Gravity Theories
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Astronomy and Astrophysics › Pulsars and Gravitational Waves Research
Keywords
tests of general relativity, modified gravity, cosmic acceleration, dark energy, gravitational screening, binary neutron star mergers, precision cosmology

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.

A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-10, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).

A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-10 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).

Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol and qwen3.8-omni-flash).

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Testing general relativity in cosmology. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1007/s41114-018-0017-4
The paper
Ishak, M. (2019). Testing general relativity in cosmology. Living Reviews in Relativity. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41114-018-0017-4

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.