A critical analysis of evaluation practice: the Kirkpatrick model and the principle of beneficence

Bates, Reid·2004·Evaluation and Program Planning
DOI 10.1016/j.evalprogplan.2004.04.011

Cited by (623)

Items 401–500 of 623

  1. Evaluation of the sustainability of groundwater irrigation development in Tejakula and Kubu Districts
    Ketut Budi Susrusa, Widhianthini Widhianthini, Putu Udayani Wijayanti, Ketut Ayu Yuliadhi · 2023 · International journal of business economics & management
  2. Evaluating Coaching Effectiveness to Improve Performance at Rumah Zakat
    Neng Riska Oktaviani, Donald Crestofel Lantu · 2024 · International Journal of Current Science Research and Review
  3. Linking ‘positive reactions’ to utility reactions and trainee satisfaction: a structural equation modeling approach
    Zahid Hussain Bhat, Riyaz Ahmad Rainayee · 2024 · International Journal of Training Research
  4. Obtaining Entrepreneurial Skills, While Preserving Motivation: Quasi-Experiment of Social Enterprise Training Effects
    Palina Prysmakova · 2024 · Journal of Social Entrepreneurship
  5. Capacity Building Berbasis Dukungan Perilaku Positif Komunitas bagi Pendamping Disabilitas Berat Jawa Timur
    Ni’matuzahroh Ni’matuzahroh, Atikah Permata Sari · 2024 · Jurnal Pengabdian Masyarakat Indonesia
  6. Teaching undergraduate medical students how to communicate with vaccine-hesitant patients: A scoping review
    Justin L. C. Bilszta, Edward Nguyen · 2023 · Focus on Health Professional Education A Multi-Professional Journal
  7. E‐learning in transfusion medicine: An exploratory qualitative assessment
    Arwa Z. Al‐Riyami, Kyle S. Jensen, Cynthia So‐Osman, Ben R. Saxon, Naomi Rahimi‐Levene, Soumya Das, Simon J. Stanworth, Yulia Lin · 2024 · Vox Sanguinis
  8. Discovering Improvement Opportunities and Challenges for Pharmaceutical Companies Adopting Digital Training Technologies: A Case Study
    Lasse Nielsen Langendorf, Md. Saifuddin Khalid · 2024 · Lecture notes in computer science
  9. Exploring Pre-service Teachers’ Preparedness for Inclusive Education Amidst COVID-19 Distance Learning in the UAE
    Muna Mohamed Alhammadi, Lawrence Meda, Efthymia Efthymiou, Cara Williams, Mohammad Ali Fteiha · 2024 · Springer eBooks
  10. Factors influencing attendance and success on the Institute of Environmental Management and Assessment Associate Membership Certificate course
    Fiona Draper, Crina Oltean‐Dumbrava, Chedly Tizaoui, Brian Newbury · 2011 · Journal of Further and Higher Education
  11. Participatory evaluation: an action research intervention to improve training effectiveness
    Gosim Martin Chukwu · 2016 · University of Liverpool
  12. Something of value Governance of Projects in the Project-Based Organisation
    Eva Riis · 2013 · University of Southern Denmark Research Portal (University of Southern Denmark)
  13. Security Practitioners’ Perspectives of the Alberta Basic Security Training Programme
    Glen Kitteringham · 2017
  14. A Taxonomy Guide for Surgical Simulation
    Aimee King Gardner, James N. Lau, Sara S. Kim · 2019 · Comprehensive healthcare simulation
  15. A Systematic Evaluation Process: Soliciting Client Participation and Working in a Cross-Cultural Context
    D'Jeane T. Peters, Lisa A. Giacumo · 2019 · Performance Improvement Journal
  16. Le modèle de simulation Simlife en médecine interventionnelle : validation pédagogique avant sa diffusion universitaire
    Jean-Pierre Richer, P. Delpech, Jérôme Danion, Benoı̂t Barrou, Cyril Brèque, Denis Oriot, Jean‐Pierre Faure · 2018 · Bulletin de l Académie Nationale de Médecine
  17. Evaluation of a research methods course for clinical residents
    Maryamalsadat Kazemi Shishavan, Mahasti Alizadeh · 2019 · Research and Development in Medical Education
  18. Selling Lottery Products To Minors: Factors Affecting Retailer Compliance
    Doris Malischnig, Mark Damian Griffiths, Gerhard Meyer · 2020 · International Journal of Mental Health and Addiction
  19. Lessons Learned From Introducing Staff to Quality Improvement Through Systematic Training at the Boston Public Health Commission
    Douglas K. Lau, Ann Henry, Osagie A. Ebekozien · 2020 · Journal of Public Health Management and Practice
  20. La technologie SimLife® dans la formation du chirurgien
    Jérôme Danion, Cyril Brèque, Denis Oriot, Jean‐Pierre Faure, J.-P. Richer · 2020 · Journal de Chirurgie Viscérale
  21. Keterlaksanaan Program Praktik Industri Program Keahlian Teknik Pemesinan Di SMK Muhammadiyah 1 Kepanjen Menggunakan Evaluasi Model Kirkpatrick
    Ahmad Iqbal Ismawanto · 2020 · Jurnal Teknik Mesin dan Pembelajaran
  22. Development and Evaluation of a Proficiency-based and Simulation-based Surgical Skills Training for Technical Medicine Students
    Frank Ruben Halfwerk, Erik Groot Jebbink, Marleen Groenier · 2020 · MedEdPublish
  23. L’effet de la motivation à se former sur l’efficacité de la formation e-learning
    Hanen Louati · 2020 · Recherches en Sciences de Gestion
  24. Evaluasi Pasca Pelatihan Teknis Jarak Jauh Probabilistic Seismic Hazard Analysis Tahun 2018 di Lingkungan Badan Meteorologi, Klimatologi dan Geofisika
    Madona · 2020 · Jurnal Widyaiswara Indonesia
  25. The benefit of business simulations for entrepreneurship education and research: Results and suggestions
    Francis Bidault, Alessio Castello, Karine Raïes · 2022 · Revue de l’Entrepreneuriat
  26. Qualité et efficacité de la formation : vers une réconciliation des paradigmes ?
    Nora Yennek, François Galinou · 2020 · Education permanente
  27. Management of formative research at the university
    Nancy del Carmen López García, Maricela Mariana Díaz-Soledispa, Segundo Mauricio Sani Buenaño, Ibsen Daniel Maldonado Ríos, María Margoth Bonilla Jiménez · 2022 · International Journal of Health Sciences
  28. A novel interventional pain simulation-based education curriculum: Implementation to enhance procedural training
    Danielle L. Sarno, Robert Jason Yong, Kara G. Fields, S. M. L. Lim, Christopher J. Gilligan, Lyba Khan, Ehren R. Nelson · 2022 · Interventional Pain Medicine
  29. EVALUASI IMPLEMENTASI KEBIJAKAN TATA KELOLA KEPESERTAAN PBI DAERAH JAMINAN KESEHATAN NASIONAL DI KABUPATEN KAYONG UTARA DAN KABUPATEN KETAPANG PROVINSI KALIMANTAN BARAT
    Dedet Triwahyudi, Firdaus Hafidz, Laksono Trisnantoro · 2021 · Jurnal Manajemen Pelayanan Kesehatan (The Indonesian Journal of Health Service Management)
  30. PERCEPTION OF EMPLOYEES IN THE AGE GROUP OF 21-29 YEARS TOWARDS THE TRAINING EFFECTIVENESS OF ONLINE TRAINING
    Ashish Singh · 2022 · Globus An International Journal of Management & IT
  31. An Investigation of Faculty Development Center Staff Evaluators Perceptions of Processes, Theory, and Models Used in Evaluating Faculty Development
    Thelma Woodard · 2013
  32. On-the-Job Training : The Case Study of Alfa Laval at the Ronneby Manufacturing Unit
    Yusaf Gohar and Rashid Ejaz · 2008 · KTH Publication Database DiVA (KTH Royal Institute of Technology)
  33. Modelo de Excelencia de Programas Formativos en Línea (MEPFL)
    Olga María Alegre de la Rosa, Luis Miguel Villar Angulo · 2007 · Revista Iberoamericana de Educación
  34. Aligning Human Resource Development with the Strategic Priorities of Healthcare Organizations: The CFO Perspective.
    Carla Breedlove Smith · 2013 · Digital Commons - University of South Florida (University of South Florida)
  35. Evaluating the Undergraduate English Language Teacher Education Program at Eastern Mediterranean University
    Şansel Zorba · 2015 · Eastern Mediterranean University Institutional Repository (Eastern Mediterranean University)
  36. Treinamento online sobre úlcera por pressão: aprendizagem, reação e o impacto no trabalho
    Juscilynne Barros da Costa Aroldi · 2017
  37. Factors that influence and predict undergraduate nursing and paramedic students' intention and use of evidence-based practice
    Mary‐Anne Ramis · 2017
  38. Employee Perception to Training and Development
    Mercy Ojotule Ibenu · 2016 · Eastern Mediterranean University Institutional Repository (Eastern Mediterranean University)
  39. An evaluation of the correctional training program delivered by the correctional service of Canada
    Shevaun Corey · 2012
  40. Training Evaluation
    Kurt Kraiger · 2016
  41. Using the Kirkpatrick model to evaluate the effect of a Primary Trauma Care course on healthcare workers knowledge, attitude, and practice (KAP) in two Vietnamese local hospitals. (Preprint)
    Ba Tuan Nguyen, Van Anh Thi Nguyen, Christopher Leigh Blizzard, Andrew John Palmer, Huu Tu Nguyen, Thang Cong Quyet, Viet Tran, Marcus Skinner, Haydn Perndt, Mark Raymond Nelson · 2023
  42. An evaluation of an intervention programme on Automotive Service Technicians using Kirkpatrick’s framework
    Vernon Candiotes · 2015
  43. Testing Kirkpatrick's Four-Level Hierarchy of Training Evaluation: Evidence from Thailand's Automotive Industry
    Tassanee Homklin, Yoshi Takahashi, Kriengkrai Techakanont · 2013 · Hiroshima University Acedemic Information Repository (Hiroshima University)
  44. Evaluer la qualité des dispositifs de formations : confrontation de différentes conceptions d'évaluation des formations
    Isabelle Gillet, Daniel Gilibert · 2009 · HAL
  45. Van cognitieve belastingstheorie naar onderwijspraktijk: het trainen van docenten
    Milou van Harsel · 2012 · Utrecht University Repository (Utrecht University)
  46. Measuring the Impact of the International Fellowships Program (IFP) in the Area of Education: Development of a Valid and Reliable Measurement Instrument
    Assane Kone · 2013
  47. O sistema de treinamento, desenvolvimento e educação (TD&E) voltado para sustentabilidade ambiental nas empresas: um estudo de casos múltiplos em uma indústria de defensivos agrícolas e uma empresa prestadora de serviços ambientais
    Isabela Grespan da Rocha Teixeira · 2013
  48. Developing Scientists Into Leaders: The Role of Shared Leadership Development and Engagement in an R&D Organization Undergoing Change
    Katie Irene Mary Zeier · 2014
  49. Exploratory study of mapping outcomes of executive coaching with specific focus on unplanned outcomes
    Peter Alan Williams · 2014
  50. The effectiveness of vehicles promoting eLearning professional development : a research thesis presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Management in Communication Management at Massey University, Manawatu
    Duncan O’Hara · 2010 · Massey Research Online (Massey University)
  51. Implementing an Integrated Care Pathway For General Foot Screening
    Bhaskaran, Vivek · 2014 · Lenus, The Irish Health Repository (Dr Steevens Hospital Library)
  52. Online Programme Of Excellence Model (Opem)
    Luis Miguel Villar, Olga María Alegre de la Rosa · 2007 · Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
  53. Implementation and Evaluation of Home Health Simulation to Improve Pre-Licensure Bachelor of Science Nursing Students' Learning: An Action Research Study
    Kathryn L. Kollowa · 2015 · 2015 APHA Annual Meeting & Expo (Oct. 31 - Nov. 4, 2015)
  54. Critical success elements for the design and implementation of organisational e-learning
    Kristal Teresa Reynolds · 2012 · QUT Business School
  55. Validation of the T-SAT-R-2: A Reaction to Training Scale for Use in Child Welfare and Human Service Trainings
    Susan E. Mason, Charles Auerbach, Wendy Zeitlin, Heidi Heft LaPorte · 2014 · Journal of Social Service Research
  56. Development and Preliminary Evaluation of a Continuing Education Curriculum in Problematic Sexual Behaviors
    William H. Swiggart, Marine V. Ghulyan, Charlene M. Dewey, Betsy White Williams, Charles P. Samenow · 2013 · Sexual Addiction & Compulsivity The Journal of Treatment and Prevention
  57. Participant perceptions of value: A qualitative framework for evaluating project management training
    Fraser Andrew Robertson · 2026 · Research Output (Edinburgh Napier University)
  58. Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Physical Training on Fire Department Rescue
    Shao-Hua Shang, Yu-Shiang Wu, Kuan‐Yung Chang, Shih-Feng Kao, Chi-Jan Huang · 2013 · Journal of Applied Fire Science
  59. A quantitative Kirkpatrick Level 1 and 2 study of equipment specialist apprentice operations training
    Dirk D. Hughes · 2012 · ProQuest Demo Repository
  60. Leaders’ perceptions after a coaching intervention as part of their development journey
    Armin F. Philipps · 2015
  61. Designing a Knowledge Environment for Teachers in the Context of Professional Development Programme DigiTiger
    Kersti Peenema · 2010
  62. TRANSLATION AND EFFECTIVENESS OF A STANDARDIZED TRAINING PROGRAM IN A MULTINATIONAL CORPORATION
    Stefan Raabe · 2015 · Gothenburg University Publications Electronic Archive (Gothenburg University)
  63. Patient Suicide - Designing a Supervisor's Guide for an Occupational Hazard
    Finbar McCarthy · 2015
  64. Medical Students Workload: Implication to the European Credit Transfer and Accumulation System in Integrated PBL Curriculum.
    Emad A Nosair · 2015 · Figshare
  65. Determining the effectiveness of the HERS-SA Academy using the Kirkpatrick framework of training evaluation
    Simone De Gersigny · 2005 · Open University of Cape Town (University of Cape Town)
  66. Book Review: 'ROI for Technology Projects: Measuring and Delivering Value' by D. Brian Roulstone and Jack J. Phillips
    Alexei Botchkarev, Peter Andru · 2012 · SSRN Electronic Journal
  67. An assessment of entrepreneurial orientation in corporate training divisions of selected South African banks
    Marié Deseré Botha · 2012 · Boloka Institutional Repository (North-west University)
  68. Despite the minimalist approach of Grameen Bank training program, similarities may be drawn between its practice and the models offered by Kirkpatrick and others
    Kazi Abdur Rouf · 2016 · International Journal of Research Studies in Education
  69. Measuring the Success of Executive Education: Comprehensively Depicting Holistic Finance Education
    Wolfgang Amann · 2016 · Springer eBooks
  70. Influence of Trainee Characteristics on Acquired Pharmacology Knowledge of Dental Professionals: A Pilot Study
    Aftab Ahmed Khan, Eraj Humayun Mirza · 2016 · Indian Journal of Pharmaceutical Education and Research
  71. Pre-training evaluation of civil servants : a first step to determine the transfer of competencies in the Belgian civil service
    Bruno Broucker, Annie Hondeghem · 2007 · Lirias
  72. An Evaluation of Performance as it Relates to the Adventist Community Services Nonprofit Leadership Certification Program in the United States
    Sung Kwon · 2013
  73. How Do We Know When Leadership Development Has Occurred? A Dialogue With Scholars and Practitioners
    Jennifer Moss Breen · 2016 · Journal of Leadership Studies
  74. Forming Judgments and the Influence of Grouping Items
    Lindsay Marie Valve · 2015 · TSpace (University of Toronto)
  75. The impact of postgraduate qualifications in medical education
    Ahsan Sethi · 2016 · Discovery Research Portal (University of Dundee)
  76. Developing and Implementing Supervisor Training for Clinical Psychologists in the United Kingdom
    Jan Hughes, Baxter Sarah, Frances Corrigall, Tom Isherwood · 2016 · International Journal of Practice-based Learning in Health and Social Care
  77. The Effects of Clinical Education Program for Nurses in Regional Public Hospital
    Yoonhee Shin, Kwanjun Park, Eun-Kyung Byun, Dongwon Lee, Woong Ju · 2016 · Health Policy and Management
  78. HRD practitioners’ recognition of the Kirkpatrick evaluation model: Focused on strengths, limits, and improvements
    정은정, 우성미, Sung Sesilia · 2016 · The Korean Journal of Human Resource Development Quarterly
  79. Melhoria do Processo Formativo numa Organização Não Governamental: O caso da Cruz Vermelha Portuguesa - Braga
    Professora Doutora, María Emilia, Emília Fernandes · 2016
  80. Driven by Customers or Driving Customers? What Really Matters in Executive Education
    Wolfgang Amann, Shiv Tripathi, Shiban Khan · 2016 · Palgrave Macmillan UK eBooks
  81. TRAINING UNIVERSITY STUDENTS FOR COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: LESSONS FROM A KNOWLEDGE, ATTITUDES AND BEHAVIOUR (KAB) STUDY
    Mike Weyers, Alida Glaudina Herbst · 2017 · SOUTHERN AFRICAN JOURNAL OF SOCIAL WORK AND SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT
  82. An evaluation of the effectiveness of the 'People Management Legal Framework Training' in facilitating managers to implement people management policies in the Irish Health Service Executive
    A. M. Barrett · 2016 · Lenus, The Irish Health Repository (Dr Steevens Hospital Library)
  83. Interkulturelle Kompetenzerweiterung im weltweiten Servicevertrieb
    Margarethe Überwimmer, Christine Ebner, Teresa Gangl · 2017 · Forschung und Praxis an der FHWien der WKW
  84. An Evaluation of the Scottish Multiprofessional Maternity Development Programme
    Elizabeth Howie, Jeanie Rankin, Jean Watson, Helene Marshall · 2011
  85. The Training of Newly Recruited Teachers in English Test Preparation Schools in China: A Case Study
    Ma Lan · 2018 · Scholarship at UWindsor (University of Windsor)
  86. The effectiveness of using learning factories to impart lean principles to develop business improvement skills in mining employees
    Ruramai Sarah Mabaisa Makumbe · 2017
  87. Professional development of police commanders: From classroom to work environment for adult learners
    Paulus van Eeden, Mpho Mildred Dichaba · 2018 · Cogent Social Sciences
  88. Application of fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model based on AHP in aircraft fire extinguishing assessment system
    Lanyong Zhang, Longnan Li, Lei Zhang · 2018 · Youth Academic Annual Conference of Chinese Association of Automation (YAC)
  89. Motivation à apprendre des cadres techniques des fédérations sportives tunisiennes. Approche par l’étude des représentations sociales
    Fériel Omrani · 2018 · Management & Avenir
  90. Simulation in Medical Education
    Yasser M El Miedany · 2018 · Springer eBooks
  91. The Implementation of Link & Match Program in Improving Competency Alignment with Business And Industrial World on Vocational Curriculum of Agriculture
    Iip Ichsanudin, Ishak Abdulhak, Rusman Hasan, Dadang Sukirman · 2019 · International Conference of Science and Technology for the Internet of Things (ICSTI)
  92. The Factors Affecting the Effectiveness of Training
    Monica Ahuja et al. Monica Ahuja et al., TJPRC · 2019 · International journal of human resource management and research
  93. Evaluation of Training Program Based on Comptencecy of Building Mechanical Works Building using Kirkpatrick
    Ambiyar Ambiyar, Suryadimal Suryadimal, Fahmi Rizal, Rusnadi Rahmad, Nizwardi Jalinus, Ganefri · 2019 · Journal of Physics Conference Series
  94. Outcomes from a Digital Literacy Project: the EIT experience
    Stephanie Day · 2014
  95. Immunization decision-making capacity building in low- and middle-income countries through teaching vaccine economics everywhere: a program evaluation
    Tania Banerjee, Shreena Malaviya, Yira Natalia Alfonso, Patrick T. Wedlock, George William Pariyo, Omrana Pasha, Dagna O. Constenla, Logan Brenzel, Ijeoma Edoka, Karen Joanne Hofman et al. · 2019 · Journal of Global Health Science
  96. Training Effectiveness in Times of Austerity
    Nur Ehsan Ibrahim, Wardah Azimah Sumardi · 2020 · International Journal of Asian Business and Information Management
  97. Final year pharmacy students' opinions on teamwork: A questionnaire-based study from a UK School of Pharmacy
    Lezley‐Anne Hanna, Meadhbh McReynolds, Maurice Hall, Alan J. Hanna · 2020 · Research Portal (Queen's University Belfast)
  98. Evaluation Systems for Biological Security Risk Mitigation Training and Education
    Giulio Maria Mancini, James Revill · 2020 · Springer eBooks
  99. Evaluation of continuing professional development programme for community development practitioners in the North West Province of South Africa
    Mokgadi Patience Molope · 2017 · Boloka Institutional Repository (North-west University)
  100. The Effect of Flipped Classroom Pedagogy on Continuing Professional Development of Academics in Higher Education
    Linda Yin King Lee · 2020 · Education innovation series